5 ms·
No dates, no sex, no weddings, no kids
- throwaway4aday 4y agoAt this rate, the North Koreans will be able to just waltz in in 2100 and take over.
- EugeneOZ 4y agoEvery country with machismo should have a movement like this.
- thriftwy 4y ago[flagged]
- Haga 4y ago[dead]
- postsantum 4y ago> South Korea > Machismo
- dorkwood 4y agoTo be fair, they use the same word in the article. Perhaps machismo is relative. “Many South Korean women are so fed up with machismo that, in recent years, they’ve taken up a radical stance: refusing to marry, date men, have sex and reproduce.”
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Onewildgamer 4y agoI don't know the situation of South Korea to comment on this topic. But, with the corporate industries talking too much about transparency it seems no one has come to identifying the cause of wage gap. Why not make the salary transparent across the board and the employee performance in public (internal to company) as well? People or Management say it is complicated, but is it really? This company Buffer appeared in HN for their transparency some while ago [https://buffer.com/salary-calculator/ https://buffer.com/salary-calculator/] We can surely determine if the wage gap is because of sexual discrimination or just a little relaxed performance.
- punnerud 4y agoWe do this in Norway, everyone’s salary was totally open (the last couple of years people can see if you have looked at their salary, so not totally open). A new government now, that want to make it totally open again. It’s the ‘Norwegian tax administration’ that give out the information. Media always have full access and can write articles based on it for individuals or groups of people, as long as they don’t publish the whole dataset.
- Onewildgamer 4y agoWow, that is impressive. Norway is surely advanced in humanities. So, why not publicise the performance metrics of the employees as well? Not public at least accessible like what you mentioned on salary. I'm not questioning why Norway isn't doing it but in general why not? Such access to performance can also serve as a driver in the employment industry. Along with the engineering blogs, one can display links to the portal with company attested achievements and stats, it will at least reduce false claims in LinkedIn.
- punnerud 4y agoWhat performance metrics? Never heard about something like that. More often than not, the sum of individual performance is not 2+2=4 but more like 2+2=3 or 1+1+1=4 Combining high performers (2) is often not better (1)
- 4y ago
- eatonphil 4y agoBefore reading this I assumed the biggest reason for Korean birthrate decline was that they don't allow enough immigrants, which is how some other developed countries handle it. I've heard only anecdotally from friends about the feminist movements and inequality faced, but the stats in this post sort of make clear the enormous problem of gender inequality in Korea. And furthermore it contrasts Korea with how other developed countries like Sweden and France handle this situation successfully. Very good article. Hopefully things improve.
- Silverback_VII 4y ago[flagged]
- unmole 4y agoSo, it's easier to rule Americans than Koreans?
- ipaddr 4y agoIt's easier to allow certain groups of people in and then cater to that group for lifelong votes. This is the strategy of the liberal party in Canada and has been used successfully. Next call people who opposite any immigration limit racist and create fears in the immigrant population. Use those fears to keep power.
- beardedwizard 4y agoWhich developed country is doing this? Please include sources.
- yucky 4y agohttps://media-cldnry.s-nbcnews.com/image/upload/t_nbcnews-ux-920-900,f_auto,q_auto:best/newscms/2014_16/322131/140414-infographic-pop-rev.jpg https://media-cldnry.s-nbcnews.com/image/upload/t_nbcnews-ux...
- 4y ago
- 29athrowaway 4y agoIf your criteria for selecting a mate is based on having low empathy, low agreeableness, and a preference for prevailing and competing... guess what will happen when you suggest a person with these personality traits to help with house chores, help with taking care of children, etc. What will happen is exactly what is expected to happen based on those personality traits: you will be playing "chicken" all the time with a person that always chooses to compete and you will always lose. "If you want those tasks done, do them yourself". If only there was a solution for that :) Hint: Don't get romantically involved with jerks
- fauxpause_ 4y ago[flagged]
- Onewildgamer 4y agoSuch people you define will either be a toxic manager working their way through middle management or some mean worker who's an absolute jackass to work with. Nobody wants to work with such people. Every company has them, but a respectable company will have low number of such people. This seems like a blanket assumption that all are always low on empathy, all the time non-agreeable and always competing. A workplace would in general give a person a good sense of self worth, high esteem, willingness to agree and disagree with whole heart. One or two bad people don't make the company and definitely need not use such a low bar to define the rest.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoI completely agree, but it seems we are not talking about the same thing. Did you read the article?
- Onewildgamer 4y agoI sure did, why you ask anyway? The article titled a clickbait but goes on about why South Korean women can't raise children and be competitive in workplace, which I assume is the situation in South Korea. Either have mutual respect and willingness to contribute to household work just like in a company with colleagues or be there to witness the fall of civilisation.
- quonn 4y agoWell. That president was elected by the population. Half of which is female.
- vijaybritto 4y agoAnd?
- brhsagain 4y agoThe obvious implication is that this conservative machismo culture is to some degree what women want. Presumably you disagree with that, so why not just tell us why?
- vijaybritto 4y agoBecause culture is not determined by governments and election outcomes do not mean women want oppression to continue. The condition would be the same no matter if liberals or conservatives are in power.
- quonn 4y agoWow, just wow. Everything would be the same, whether you vote for equality or not? Says it all. The article even states that the current president is related to this protest. So you‘re disputing that?
- quonn 4y agoWhat, and? Do I need to spell it out? * He would never win were it not for the female vote. * Those doing the four Nos are not representative of the voting females which could otherwise achieve their goals at the ballot box. * Those who vote against their supposed interests at the election often also vote against their supposed interests when they pick a mate. My personal conclusion from this is that the biology runs deep in all human beings and many are not aware of it. Our brain is not just our conscious thoughts. We are a product of evolution and what we want is not always what we should want individually. Selfish gene, etc. etc.
- aiphex 4y agoSocial actions that lead to birth rate decline are a slippery slope that can be difficult to come back from without immigration. The economic conditions that have been forced on young people are bad enough for this. It will be a wait and see to witness if western nations are able to figure it out but so far many have thrown in the towel and are just relying on immigration now. Countries like Korea and Japan have so far resisted this in an attempt to keep their societies and cultures more homogenous, for which they have found many benefits.
- Tade0 4y ago> The repercussions of the so-called “birth strike” have been severe for the country. For three consecutive years, the country has had the lowest fertility rate in the world, with an average of 0.78 children per woman. How much of that can be attributed to the birth strike considering South Korea's fertility rate started its latest downward spiral in 2016 and two out of those three years had heavily-enforced lockdowns? Over here the government passed draconian anti-abortion laws, but that didn't have an immediate effect. Other things, like economic uncertainty were the main driver.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoBasically none.
- mfcl 4y agoYeah, I'm not convinced this is making a difference. No number or any kind of clue about the size of the movement was given.
- baidifnaoxi 4y agoAgree, this movement seems almost non-existent. Seems like SK is more suffering from an overwork culture that leaves little time for anything outside of work. Fastest way to destroy fertility rate is wage slavery.
- Tade0 4y agoI talked at length once with a person whose husband is a South Korean who moved to Europe. By her account he's happy here, because the work hours in South Korea are properly insane by European standards and he enjoys having so much free time now.
- implements 4y ago> Over here the government passed draconian anti-abortion laws, but that didn't have an immediate effect. Other things, like economic uncertainty were the main driver. Female people’s wombs don’t belong to the State. It shouldn’t be conscripting women into pregnancy to shore up the population, that’s pretty dehumanising (never mind sexist).
- stevespang 4y ago[dead]
- 55555 4y agoIn 2019, the 4B movement claimed to have 4,000 members! This is 0.016% of the women in South Korea! I'm going to assume (because I think it's very likely) that a large number of these were already not having much sex ("incels") nor planning on getting married. I'm also going to assume that many of these women who now claim they are remaining celibate are actually having sex anyway, as abstaining from sex is difficult to do (unless it comes naturally to you, in which case it's having sex that seems impossible!) In other words, this is a human interest story about basically nothing, that tries to normalize a fringe group and freak everyone out about it. Or, to be more charitable, it's an article about something that's happening within all genders in many countries (see MGTOW in America, for example), and is also about the fact that women still aren't treated equitably in South Korea. I don't see the point other than clicks. Beware articles about problems or trends that neglect to quantify anything.
- lapcat 4y ago> In 2019, the 4B movement claimed to have 4,000 members! "This movement—known as “the four no’s”—began in 2019. It has since spread..." > Beware articles about problems or trends that neglect to quantify anything. "Despite the solid academic credentials of women in South Korea, according to a study by Statista, the gender pay gap is scandalous: men earn 30% more than women. This makes the country, according to the Korean Herald, the most gender-unequal OECD nation." "According to a survey published by the Korean Institute of Criminology and Justice, eight out of 10 men admitted to having been violent towards their partner"
- baidifnaoxi 4y agoPay gap studies are notorious for being overly ignorant of confounding factors. There probably is a pay gap but it’s incredibly hard to quantify and many studies choose to look only at $$ versus benefits (schedule flexibility, maternity leave, part time, etc) US studies for example don’t always consider that women overindex in less technical careers (teaching, humanities, etc), often those that have lower salaries but significantly higher benefits and more flexibility. Women also overindex in part time positions.
- vijucat 4y agoI find it interesting that in parallel, I see a shockingly feminine Korean man in an ad every day here in Hong Kong. The Chinese government has banned effeminate men in media, and the mass self-emasculation of men chasing fashion trends is a legitimate national security concern! https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/tv/2021/09/02/china-bans-sissy-men-tv-encourages-more-masculinity/5694333001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/tv/2021/09/02/c...
- evilsetg 4y agoWhat is shocking to you about a man apperearing feminine? And where do you see a national security concern in effeminate men?
- hirundo 4y agoCould it be that one of the reasons that we have sexual inequality is that over generations the people most concerned about it reproduce less than the people least concerned about it -- who pass on those attitudes to their progeny? If love-of-justice tends to suppress fertility then the descendant populations will have a lower love-of-justice than otherwise.
- triggerwarn 4y agoDon't trust El Pais, they are an extremely biased publication by failed individuals. In Spain we are already well aware
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoWomen collectively (and righteously) started a Sex Strike [1][2] as we were entering the Great Depression with the founding of the American Birth Control League in 1921 [3]. This strike accelerated into second and now third wave feminism demanding (again, righteously) equal control of society. The post-war Baby Boom was an aberration to the trend in my opinion. Arguably this all started with universal suffrage in NZ in 1919 and I think this is just the most recent iteration. People used to have hope, but as we are seeing more and more concentration of wealth, and rent seeking everywhere, lack of economic mobility (unless you're a psychopath that will do anything to make money) is the likely path without a major counter-revolution. We need a voluntary, peaceful and measurably equitable society in order to create a world where people have hope for the future. All of the previous illusions of gods and governments as masters has failed. The only thing left is solidarity with other people qua people, vulnerability, sharing, caring etc... is the only option. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_strike [2]http://www.chrisknight.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2007/09/Sex-Strike.pdf http://www.chrisknight.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2007/09/Sex-... [2]https://sanger.hosting.nyu.edu/aboutms/organization_abcl/ https://sanger.hosting.nyu.edu/aboutms/organization_abcl/
- throwaway4aday 4y agoHow about we just cordon off an area and you can go do your thing there and let us know how it ends up?
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoThat sounds amazing, where?
- dauertewigkeit 4y agoI am really starting to hate this kind of journalism. There is a real story here, the gender inequality in South Korea. But it is dressed up into a ridiculous bunch of nonsense and portrayed as some kind of country wide "gender war", trying to evoke intense emotions in the reader. Why cannot one just be factual and informative instead?
- beardedwizard 4y agoIf I was paid 30% less I might want to start a war.
- ipaddr 4y agoManagement usually makes 30%+ more than reports all around the world. Do you suggest workers want war around the globe? Either you are happy with your pay or not. If my next door neighbour makes more it doesn't change my bills. If I make more than them it doesn't sudden make my bills easier to pay.
- hotpotamus 4y agoAh, seems like you are ignorant of the process of gentrification.
- ipaddr 4y agoIt's sunday, a great day to learn. Please share your insights.
- gsinclair 4y agoIf one neighbour earns more than you, it doesn’t change your bills. But if a large number of people in your area start earning more, and you don’t keep up, you are going to find it hard to continue living in that area because local prices will reflect the increased wealth. And if you rent you’ll likely be unable to afford the rent rises that are sparked by the increased desirability of the area. That’s my best guess at what GP meant.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shrubble 4y ago“Single mothers are stigmatized, doctors refuse to give IVF to women without a male partner—even though it’s not illegal—and out-of-wedlock births represent only 2% of the total, compared to the average of 41% for women in the OECD. Marriage and childbirth are closely intertwined; women are pressured to sacrifice their career once they have a child or get married." Is everything described, evil?
- zen_1 4y ago> out-of-wedlock births represent only 2% of the total, compared to the average of 41% for women in the OECD. And this is framed as a negative?
- lapcat 4y ago> And this is framed as a negative? Yes, because it means there's very little freedom of choice. Would you say that "shotgun weddings" are a positive?
- zen_1 4y agoWith Korea's birth rate I doubt there are too many of those happening. And if it's down to a choice between shotgun weddings where both parents commit (whether by choice or social pressure) to raising their child or single parenthood, I'd say the former is definitely a positive for the child in question and for society as a whole.
- Connor_Creegan1 4y ago[flagged]
- swagmoney1606 4y agoWeaponizing their fertility? I'm not sure you could describe this as "weaponizing" anything at all. This is just people choosing what life they want for themselves.
- Connor_Creegan1 4y ago[flagged]