26 ms·
Good summary, only thing I'd add is that the iPhone didn't drop support for flash, they never had it to begin with and made it clear they never would. Android v
by Gigachad 4y ago
Good summary, only thing I'd add is that the iPhone didn't drop support for flash, they never had it to begin with and made it clear they never would. Android vendors at the time used to use flash support as selling point until they too dropped it.
Being the first to call the death on something seems to be an ongoing trend with Apple.
- nntwozz 4y agoFlashback to Steve Jobs' famous "Thoughts on Flash" https://newslang.ch/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Thoughts-on-Flash.pdf https://newslang.ch/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Thoughts-on-F... It was not well received at the time. Oh how things have changed.
- gumby 4y agoWell it wasn't received well by Adobe, who had by then bought Macromedia, nor by people who had tied their wagon to Flash. But Flash was pretty horrible even on most laptops and even many desktops of the day, and was a security nightmare. The complainers were loud, but I think the majority of people who cared (99% of humanity didn't even notice, of course) were muttering "amen brother!"
- exsf0859 4y agoBesides animation and games, Flash was also used for streaming video and video conferencing. iPhone customers were so desirable that, over time, the video streaming sites had to support Apple's video streaming format. They would have also supported Apple's video conferencing app, but I think Apple was unable to open-source the protocols for the video conferencing format, due to patent issues.
- duskwuff 4y ago> had to support Apple's video streaming format It's a little weird to call an open standard (like H264) "Apple's format".
- Evidlo 4y agoH264 isn't open though, depending on your definition of open
- duskwuff 4y agoFine, pretend I said "industry standard" then. Either way it wasn't something Apple made.
- lultimouomo 4y agoH264 is not a streaming format. HLS is, and it is pretty much "Apple's format". It's pretty backwards, and everyone was forced to support it because it was the one streaming format you could use in iStuff.
- geocar 4y ago> It's pretty backwards I think it's pretty clever. There are a lot of usability issues with firewalls and proxies that make implementing other streaming protocols very difficult, and the HLS design basically causes the implementer to adopt a pattern that is resilient to those problems. Networks got a lot better after Covid had everyone work from home so IT had to sort the hot-path out for videoconferencing. Nowadays I think WebRTC would be fine, but in 2009 I think HLS was pretty smart.
- lultimouomo 4y agoI am comparing HLS with other HTTP-based streaming formats - DASH and SmoothStreaming. They definitely have their issues (DASH in particular is the epitome of the second system syndrome) but they fix the two most glaring issues with HLS: separate manifests and non-aligned segments. Source: I write an HTTP streaming client library for a living.
- geocar 4y agoHow can HLS be a move backwards if it came out before DASH and SS? Why do you think users care about “separate manifests and non-aligned segments” more than the video playing and not stalling and having to refresh?
- lmm 4y agoHave they? I would say the subsequent ~10 years of the web have vindicated Flash. HTML5 video hasn't made websites lighter or less annoying - quite the opposite (indeed video ads are a worse problem than Flash ads ever were). Meanwhile creativity and innovation on the web have taken a hit. 10+ years on there's still nothing that allows a lone auteur to produce a web experience as easily and effectively as you could with Flash (it seems to be possible to match Flash, a la the NYT's Snow Fall or the previous Madogatari intro, but not at a level that's accessible to an individual creator), and we're all worse off for it.
- rektide 4y agoThis keeps coming up, but it keeps seeming hogwash & backwards. There are dozens & dozens of really really good html/svg animation products that give Flash like capabilities. But there's vastly less interest in this stuff today. Fun/simple/quirky Flash-like stuff isn't nearly as unique or novel, now that we have much more upscale products & experiences. It was a magical time & Flash helped, but we've changed & these rose-colored glasses views on Flash never point out all the myriad of ways it was awful, choppy, poorly integrated, quirky to work with, & otherwise difficult. If you want higher there are hundreds of web-dev targeting game dev systems which can be put to use. Many of these actually do have popularity. In spite of their being good Flash-ish animation toolkits, it doesn't feel like there's a ton of demand or clear winners. It's hard to imagine what we'd want it for today.
- lmm 4y agoI think the demand is there, but you underestimate how much difference the tiny inconveniences make. Like, maybe there's stuff out there that can do the same thing, but the people who are just starting out don't know where it is (hell, I'm an experienced programmer and I don't know where it is) or what to pick up. A lot of those great Flash works were made by literal schoolkids, or more often by young adults who'd got their start as schoolkids and gradually refined their craft, because you could just pick up Flash and start doing things, and kids did. From what I hear maybe Roblox is filling the same niche now, but that's only happened in the last few years, and for all that Flash was notionally proprietary and poorly-integrated with the open web, having it right there in your browser was still a win.
- Groxx 4y agoIt was divisive, but I wouldn't say "not well received". The "Flash deserves death" camp was very large and very, very happy that someone with power was finally calling them out on their horrific security record. Losing the high-quality authoring environment, without anyone producing something competitive, was a pretty big blow. But for the rest, I'm quite glad to see invasive browser plugins disappear.
- wlesieutre 4y agoMaybe not well received from Windows users? It had some fun games but on the Mac side it was always an unstable dumpster fire. Having the iPhone browser start to push people away from making entire Flash-based websites so they could play music and crash my browser was a godsend.
- dutzi 4y agoThere was also the Adobe Loves Apple campaign https://www.fastcompany.com/1646594/adobe-launches-hearts-and-minds-pr-campaign-bite-apple https://www.fastcompany.com/1646594/adobe-launches-hearts-an...
- twelvedogs 4y agoIt was incredibly well received by web devs
- kristopolous 4y agoThey're often the ones holding the gun. Example: if they didn't remove the 3.5mm headphone jack, almost nobody else would have.
- gopalv 4y ago> They're often the ones holding the gun. Apple customers historically are often the most accepting of new things, even if that means change that involves spending more money, because Apple will cover the other end of change well (& expand a little that way). The 3.5mm jack loss is tolerated because of airpods. I'm old enough to remember the furor caused by Apple taking the 3.5 floppy drive when every publisher used Apple hardware for QuarkExpress & everything Adobe, replaced with this new-fangled usb thing. The crucial thing over there was that Apple didn't bring in their own USB drive thing, but instead let IOMega try to deliver it & it went poorly for Apple customers who had big data swaps between them & others (DTP shops, magazine layouts, Photoshop artwork etc).
- KerrAvon 4y agoYou have to remember that this was pre-iPod — Apple did not have infinite money at that time; it had been not quite two years since it was nearly bankrupt. They really had to be careful with resources. Having third parties provide all of the interesting external peripherals might have been a simple necessity.
- kristopolous 4y agoNah, Steve was smarter than that. First, removing the floppy bought Apple millions of dollars worth of publicity - it seemed scandalous and people still remember it 25 years later just like he somehow got away with using public domain images of Ghandi and Martin Luther King to hawk consumer electronics. It was as if Albert Einstein personally thought you should really buy an iPod. Second, as with all of Apple products, aesthetics concerns were more important than functionality. If you've ever dealt with that original iMac, it's a tight fit. The design ratios would be off with a floppy so it had to go. Now I wish it didn't also have a bios battery that would freaking explode at about the 10 year mark, splattering battery acid everywhere and destroying the hardware but that's part of the long tradition of Apple's occasional exploding devices.
- tetris11 4y agoAnecdotally, it was the reason why I went for Nokia N900 as my first smartphone, because I didn't want to give up my beloved Newgrounds. Flash turned out to not run super well on the device, but by then it was too late and I'd already deep-doved into the Linux and on-device programming rabbit hole.
- bick_nyers 4y agoAnecdote #2: As a kid/preteen I never cared much about the iPhone or iPod Touch because I couldn't play Age of War and other games on either AddictingGames or Kongregate. Fruit Ninja etc. was cool but didn't feel complete enough of a game for me. I still had dial-up for a few years after the first iPhone released, so I would often save the webpage for a flash game, and then I could play it whenever (but not wherever).
- mejutoco 4y agoI think they were more part of the reason Flash died, than predicted it. Also interesting that at the time Jobs did not want native apps on the iPhone, only web apps.
- londons_explore 4y agoFlash probably wouldn't have died had it not been for Apple's refusal to support it. One could totally imagine a rewritten and modernized version of flash that became the dominant web experience (perhaps replacing HTML and javascript, which in many ways are inferior).
- macintux 4y agoThat’s like saying one could imagine a modern U.S. rail infrastructure that allows pleasant passenger rail travel everywhere you want to go. Of course it’s possible with enough time and money, but from all accounts Adobe could not have achieved it.
- stuaxo 4y agoI'm pretty sure Adobe did build a version even if it wasn't released.