11 ms·
Alibaba to split into six separate groups
- sschueller 4y agohttps://archive.md/FXvGs https://archive.md/FXvGs
- roboben 4y agoWhat happens if someone bought BABA stock? Asking for a friend.
- bar94 4y ago> The listing status of Alibaba’s shares in New York and Hong Kong won’t be affected, people familiar with the matter said. Alibaba’s Nasdaq-listed American depositary receipts climbed more than 6% in premarket trading on Tuesday in New York.
- SomeBoolshit 4y agoTell him to read the article.
- roboben 4y agoThanks, just saw the archive.to link to actually be able to read it.
- smcl 4y agoI used to wait for the archive.ph (or similar) link to be posted too. But it's actually really easy, if you encounter a paywalled article copy the URL, go to https://archive.ph https://archive.ph, paste it into the second URL field and submit. Not sure why it took me so long to actually just go to the root URL and try it myself but at least now I know :D
- roboben 4y agoHow long will this thing survive?
- DANmode 4y agoArchive.org, archive.is etc have been around for eons. Don't worry.
- News-Dog 4y agoThe main site is https://archive.today/ https://archive.today/ Archive.today : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archive.today https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archive.today Archive.today wiki : https://wiki.archiveteam.org/index.php/Archive.today https://wiki.archiveteam.org/index.php/Archive.today https://archive.ph/ https://archive.ph/ https://archive.is/ https://archive.is/ https://archive.li/ https://archive.li/ https://archive.vn/ https://archive.vn/ https://archive.fo/ https://archive.fo/ https://archive.md/ https://archive.md/
- smcl 4y agoGood to see you again News-Dog :D I'm actually happy to see the .li, .vn, .fo and .md mirrors, I only knew about .ph and .is
- meh8881 4y agoAre these businesses really viable individually?
- A_D_E_P_T 4y agoAlibaba's six new groups are: - Cloud - Chinese e-commerce (taobao.com + others like 1688.com) - Global e-commerce (alibaba.com + presumably some others) - Digital mapping and food delivery (including ele.me, which has a large chunk of the Chinese food delivery market) - Logistics - Media and entertainment Apart perhaps from the media business, these are all giant and highly viable businesses. And, even if they're spun off and managed separately, doesn't mean they won't work together -- Alibaba's new "Logistics" spin-off will surely do well by providing delivery services to the "Chinese e-commerce" spin-off.
- Freak_NL 4y ago> Global e-commerce (alibaba.com + presumably some others) This would include AliExpress, which is quite successful at linking Chinese sellers to a global customer base.
- jrmg 4y agoAre e.g. AliExpress, Alibaba and TaoBao ‘different’ for sellers now? Like, do they need two or three separate accounts and the ability to process orders separately for each market, or will this complicate things for them?
- meh8881 4y agoI don’t think I would say the same of Amazon if we split it up into those things, minus the digital mapping and food delivery which honestly sounds like the worst of them anyway. > Alibaba's new "Logistics" spin-off will surely do well by providing delivery services to the "Chinese e-commerce" spin-off. Unless the Chinese e commerce spin-off realizes it was much better when they had in house logistics and just starts building that again?
- 4y ago
- PaulWaldman 4y agoHow can this be interpreted with Jack Ma's return?
- catchnear4321 4y agoPerhaps this was the cost of return?
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoJack Ma: Hey everyone I'm back after a totally normal time away from China... CCP (interrupting): Make sure to smile Jack Ma: sweat...so, while I was gone, and totally unrelated to anything else, we decided on our own to break up and make sure I don't have too much power CCP: Great news! We hoped you'd totally voluntarily come back and also wow what a great gesture ----- I kind of would have preferred they just be strong about it but they are following the west's lead here in pretending like the government and major business isn't just the same thing
- marginalia_nu 4y agoPony Ma: [grimace-emoji]
- eunos 4y agoTencent is less impactful in the world of atoms compared to Alibaba (ecommerce and logistics). Yet in the world of bits Tencent seems to be more scumbag than Ali. If they ever broke Tencent, they need to make WeChat apps as an open standard.
- graderjs 4y ago[flagged]
- tiny_ta 4y agoIt's good to see at least a few comments further down that wish that similar steps to break up TBTF companies were taken here in the west.
- tokinonagare 4y ago> Jack Ma: [...] we decided on our own to break up and make sure I don't have too much power Actually very good, would be nice if a few Western companies were splitted this way.
- Barrin92 4y ago
- hospitalJail 4y agoBetween the Uyghur Genocide and Jack Ma's disappearance(and drastic change after reappearance), China is scary. Not the kind of scary where you bend the knee, but the kind of scary you don't invite them to your birthday party. After I learned of the Uyghur genocide, I decided against having them manufacture my designed parts. Half of it was ethics, half of it was self preservation. Seeing what they did to Ma has convinced me it was the correct decision. Now I just need to find a source of cheap electronics to run my device.
- elforce002 4y agoAre vietnam, singapur, etc.., viable solutions? have you checked if you can get your supplies from LATAM?
- weregiraffe 4y ago>Between the Uyghur Genocide and Jack Ma's disappearance These two are not in the same category.
- glenstein 4y agoWhat's the category?
- Workaccount2 4y agoThe push back on banning (social media app) is befuddling to me. It's an egregious national security threat to have the youth of your nation addicted to an algorithm controlled by these same people. Censored because at least on reddit the bots will swoop in on any mention of it.
- bigbillheck 4y agoSurely this argument applies to every other country in the world and the allowing or otherwise of facebook, twitter, and so on?
- Workaccount2 4y ago
- eunos 4y agoSo Bell Lab break up with Chinese characteristics?
- AnotherGoodName 4y agoAlibaba group were the ones that disclosed the log4shell vulnerability which always surprised me. There they were sitting on the biggest security vulnerability ever and they tell the West about it!? I don't expect this to happen again.
- Shank 4y ago> Alibaba group were the ones that disclosed the log4shell vulnerability which always surprised me Really? My memory of the event was that the news broke in Minecraft servers [0] before it was expanded to all Java apps that used log4j. [0]: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2021/12/the-log4shell-zeroday-4-days-on-what-is-it-and-how-bad-is-it-really/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2021/12/the-l...
- shagie 4y agoIt started here https://github.com/apache/logging-log4j2/pull/608#issuecomment-989762094 https://github.com/apache/logging-log4j2/pull/608#issuecomme... and was rapidly recognized that this impacted almost everything. Minecraft servers were one of the most accessible places to use the exploit and at the same time, some of the ones that are least likely to patch updates rapidly.
- AnotherGoodName 4y agoAs others pointed out that comment was after the cve was created.
- shagie 4y agoThe comment is, but the start of the PR (by a person from the Apache Foundation org) matches matches the "we told Apache" date. The "all hell broke lose" starts with that comment. Note that the LDAP part wasn't sufficient to fully excise the security vulnerability.
- 4y ago
- lysecret 4y agoI mean, all the China scariness aside probably a good move, western regulators could take a look at.
- flakeoil 4y agoYes, Microsoft should be broken up. It's scary how they have their tentacles everywhere. Both Consumer and Business focused. OS, PCs, Browser, search engine, Ad network, professional social network, news outlet, cloud infra, cloud tools, dev tools, games, gaming platform, gaming hardware, server OS and DB, office tools locally installed, office tools in cloud, cloud storage, CRM, ERP, personal video calls and messenger, video conferencing tools and business messenger, owns github, owns npm, owns 50% of OpenAI. I have probably forgotten a few. Imagine all the cross selling and tricks they can pull off having all this inhouse.
- okasaki 4y agoSaves a bunch of time for the national security state too.
- AlchemistCamp 4y agoThe “tentacles everywhere” approach is a response to anti-trust concerns. Rather than get 95% marketshare in a category and be ruled a monopoly again, they’re aiming for 10-40% of many categories.
- pwinnski 4y agoWhich is amusing, given the history of anti-trust enforcement in the US. Most activity in the middle of the last century was aimed not at companies owning 95%+ of a market, but companies owning every step of a supply chain, smaller pieces of different markets. The focus was on encouraging competition, which has very much not been the focus for the last 40+ years.
- flakeoil 4y agoMaybe so, but 30-40% is often enough to be a market leader. And within the IT segment as a whole they for sure are dominant. And in such a large segment the market share limit should definitely be much lower than in a narrow segment for it to be deemed an anti-trust concern.
- fnord77 4y agowish the US govt took steps to keep corps from getting too powerful
- fancl20 4y agoI read the news again and the new structure still seems very similar to the company structure of Alphabet or Tencent. Is there anything I missed here?
- crop_rotation 4y agoThe structures have to be similar to give the companies a chance to survive. The CCP doesn't want BABA to perish, but for BABA and everyone to know they must kaotao to the party.
- avidphantasm 4y agoWould that the US would give our tech billionaires the same treatment.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- elforce002 4y agoAre we going to see something like that for microsoft, google, and facebook?
- crop_rotation 4y agoNo, the US government can't send them private messages to breakup by themselves. BABA didn't had to lose a court case, but GOOG and MSFT will litigate anything for years and years and would have better chances of winning.
- elforce002 4y agoInteresting. To what extent can we consider microsoft, google, amazon, and facebook monopolies? Maybe Google can get off the hook (for now) but microsoft and amazon are too big. No one can compete with those two. - Facebook: social media monopoly with whatsapp, instagram, and facebook. These should be independent companies. - Amazon: This is the biggest offender on this list: AWS, ecommerce, twitch, whole foods, logistics, etc... these should also be independent companies. - Microsoft: After Amazon, MS should be broken up decades ago. - Google: If it wasn't for Ads, google would have probably be in turmoil each year. Google cloud is good (we use them as our cloud provider), but reality is they are far away from AWS in terms of market-share. - Apple: This one is interesting since we know they are big but there's room to compete (to a certain extent). In short, at least MS and Amazon should be on the radar and be broken up within this decade.
- crop_rotation 4y agoSee this is all so subjective. I have a totally different Opinion and feel GOOG, MSFT should be the ones broken up. Facebook is not a monopoly on anything (and under threat from TikTok). If having multiple products was a criteria for breaking up companies, there would be too many eligble. Amazon: Neither retail or AWS nor whole foods nor logistics are a monopoly.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoMonopolies probably aren't the right angle to approach this from. A corporation can be "too large" without being a monopoly, though in the past that was their primary route to getting to that size. Perhaps it would be better to simply have a law that any company whose average market cap during a two year period exceeds 1% of the country's GDP is automatically broken up. Such a law might not even need to be used, as companies wanting to avoid a government lead break up would on their own either start spinning off parts of the company or paying dividends to shareholders to shed value from the company. Shareholders could then use those dividends to invest elsewhere or use it for spending in the economy. Buying up competitors or merging with them would also be tempered at the higher levels since it would risk creating an entity that gets broken up by the government. I'm sure the companies with the potential to be broken up by such a law would be very much against it and spend whatever it took to defeat the law. They might also try to convince the public that they have to be allowed to be gigantic in order to compete with similar entities from other countries that don't have a limit on size.
- markus_zhang 4y agoFinally they decided to break up the big players. Hopefully Tencent is next.
- jmclnx 4y agoI do not know why he did not get out years ago. Why these powerfully rich men is staying in China is beyond me. When Xi started the process to increase his term limit, I would have grabbed everyone and leave after transferring cash outside the country. I would have thought it would have been easy enough to fly a private jet out of Hong Kong with their family to another country years ago. Now I wonder if they are even allowed to fly on private jets these days.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoPerhaps he loves the Chinese nation even if he doesn't love the Chinese government. Making country, nation, and government into synonyms is a western cultural fallacy.
- nicolas_t 4y agoIt's also very typical of a lot of the chinese discourse of china. "What you criticise the CCP, you're not patriotic." is a typical sentiment expressed there. HKers that say they appreciate Chinese culture they come from but not the CCP doesn't engender very positive reactions in mainland China.
- RobotToaster 4y agoWorth noting that Jack Ma is a member of the CPC.
- localplume 4y ago[dead]
- crop_rotation 4y agoWould a high ranking CEO even have a choice in that matter?
- dathinab 4y agoexactly, they would not have a choice or more precise they would never have had a chance to reach where they did without becoming a party member through being a party member in the end isn't the same as being a politician of the party or working for them (just saying because some people seem to not be aware about this)
- seo-speedwagon 4y agoIt would be pretty funny if one of the groups’ business model was just drop shipping stuff from the other 5
- daevout 4y agoChina has done what's only being talked about in the west: successfully broken up a powerful tech conglomerate. One needn't resort to the kind of marxist leninist tactics that were at play here to achieve the same outcome, but all we'll get is more talk, or if things go really well, 5 mini googles just in time for openai, bing or someone else to become the next search monopoly.
- O__________O 4y agoWorth noting Tencent’s market cap is 10x more than Alibaba’s - so this clearly has to do with Jack Ma’s public conflict with the CCP and them making an example of him. Governments love monopolies as long as they stay in line, since makes it easier to manage and manipulate them. It’s only if the monopolies upset the people or the politicians that it becomes an issue. ___ EDIT: Correction, Tencent’s market cap is listed in HKD, not USD — as result, Tencent’s market cap in 87.7% more than Alibaba’s — NOT the 10x listed above. Link to sources here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35341846 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35341846
- paxys 4y agoIt's more that Tencent is primarily in areas like video games and entertainment while Alibaba was upending China's banking industry.
- O__________O 4y agoRight, but Tencent went along with CCP’s efforts to use and regulate it within and outside of China.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago> It’s only if the monopolies upset the people or the politicians that it becomes an issue. So, Democracy? Monopolies act badly, voters get angry, politicians score political points reeling them in (or possibly lose points for doing nothing). It's a good system and mostly works.
- dymk 4y agoCPP ain't a democracy that listens to The People
- O__________O 4y ago[flagged]
- quyleanh 4y agoSure this time Ma will watch his mouth before saying anything about government. Such a big price for lesson learned.
- willy_k 4y agoYes Agent, this comment right here.
- tiny_ta 4y agoIf I were an economist/social scientist/political scientist, I would be grinning ear to ear right now. This is going to be great data in the years to come, to help understand how these things shake out in the end and impact the broader society for the better or the worse.
- crop_rotation 4y agoI doubt it will be a repeatable study. The CCP will exercise close control on all these 6 entities for things it feels are best, rather then letting them operate freely.
- FreeCodeFreak 4y agoThis can be very bad news even in the west, but in context of the Chinese totalitarian dictatorship (Btw. Also allied with Russia), this is just an expression of an authoritarian regime suppressing private freedom. It's nothing but another abuse to suppress their own society.
- bigbillheck 4y agoAs an American I would love for my government to break up a whole bunch of giant corporations.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- FreeCodeFreak 4y agoIn practice that would only weaken the US infrastructure. E.g. If companies like Apple and Microsoft were to be broken up, then that would actually severely confine technological innovation, and potentially place the US at a competitive disadvantage, and for what gain? More competition between smaller companies? More competition is not necessarily a good thing. However, you can regulate said companies, and limit their abilities to exploit people. E.g. Place limits on product pricing so it does not get to expensive - very important for life saving medication. You have to understand, there are some very motivated political ideologies that want us to believe that breaking up companies is going to protect consumers. It will not. And in fact, it can be quite devastating for technological innovation. So is regulation, but to an lesser extent, and I'd pick the lesser evil of the two any day. In practice, by breaking up a company, you are basically stealing from shareholders, forcefully taking their property and selling it at a huge discount. The owners (shareholders) may end up owning shares of both halves of a company that is being split, but it will not be the same company, and the new companies ability to make money may have been destroyed or significantly harmed in the process. Then government has to pay some sort of compensating dividend, and I do not see that realistically happen, because it is impossible to accurately determine the damage caused by splitting a company. In another ownership structure, companies could be broken up on paper, but still operated in a sort of partnership, hence the breaking up might not even make any sense in the first place.
- SentientAtom 4y agoIs Jack Ma alive? Thought they took him back im 2021
- est 4y agoJack was back to mainland today, he was reported visiting a middle school and talked about education and ChatGPT.
- brap 4y agoThe number of people in this thread living in the West and saying "let's blindly copy an authoritarian policy made by an authoritarian regime", without considering any 2nd or 3rd order effects this might have, is alarming.
- neural_thing 4y agoAlso, people here REALLY misunderstand why China is doing the things it's doing. Their FX reserves are running perilously low. They are looking for ANYTHING they can do to get foreign cash. I'm hearing rumors that they are the ones who tapped out the FIMA facility. Could get ugly. I know somebody is going to @ me with the 3T number, but the only data I trust is China's holding of Treasuries. That's been falling quickly.
- thriftwy 4y agoHow did China even managed to run out of foreign cash? This is huge news for me. They were always swimming in export profits / probably still are / travel limits since COVID means that obvious leak of travelling and spending abroad is plugged. How could they run out of cash?
- unity1001 4y agoThey didnt. He is just making it up. China has been dumping US treasuries recently. Maybe he is confusing that with China's foreign reserves drying up. ... In any case, Yuan is the new foreign currency. And China has, well, all of it...
- reaperman 4y agoFor clarity, China de-prioritizes T-bills in favor of US Federal agency bonds which are nearly the same risk but slightly higher returns/interest rates. They currently hold $1.2 trillion in federal USD Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac/SBA/FHA bonds. Higher reward, similar risk, still perfectly reasonable USD FX reserves.
- 4y ago
- arnaudsm 4y agoIf US regulators were reluctant to split FAANG because of chinese competition, this may be the signal that accelerates the effort.
- nerpderp82 4y agoRegardless of the motivation, it will only grow and gain marketshare due to this action.
- bacchusracine 4y agoDoes this change anything with regard to how average citizens can and cannot order from Alibaba? There are things available on that site that simply do not exist outside of it. Not on Aliexpress or elsewhere that I am aware of. I'd love to be able to order some of these, not for resale but personal use, but since I am not a corporation they are closed to me.
- dghlsakjg 4y agoI’ve had no problem getting quotes from alibaba vendors as a person. They don’t seem to care afaik
- Laaas 4y agoWhile I am not a fan of China, having a limit on the size of companies seems like a good idea. Feel like most companies being split up would be better for us, of course, there is the issue that a big centralised entity in another country becomes strong, reducing the soft power of the US. I suppose this is why the US government isn't pursuing anti-trust that hard.
- textread 4y agoAlibaba and Softbank shares have jumped by 15% and 6% respectively after this announcement.