10 ms·
EU was set to ban internal combustion engine cars, then Germany changed its mind
- outime 4y agoPartially changed its mind. E-fuels (which is what Germany supports) are vastly inferior to e.g. EVs: >While e-fuels might help prolong the life of the combustion engine in a zero carbon world, they remain relatively inefficient compared to battery technology — and are also significantly more expensive [...] Vehicles run on e-fuels consume five times more energy than a battery-powered EV, and will be around eight times more expensive to run per kilometer in the future, according to a study commissioned by the German Energy Agency.
- credit_guy 4y agoSo what if they are vastly inferior? As long as they don't contribute to greenhouse gas emission, let the people decide. If some people want to part with their hard earned cash, why do you care? If anything, this will make rich people a little bit less rich.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Timon3 4y agoThe R&D investments mean that: - the type of vehicle available to most of the population will be inferior compared to a universe without this investment - companies have reasons to also use their fossil fuel investments longer - companies have more reasons to lobby for weakening the requirements for E-fuels It's not like this is happening in a vacuum - laws and investments have a big influence on which direction we go in. So far the capital class has managed to skirt many regulations regarding emissions (e.g. by "offsetting" emissions, or by lying about them). A lot of real harm has already been done, and this is an avenue that will inevitably continue this.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoAll of this may be true, but it will give (some) German car companies an excuse to keep their obsolete ICE production lines around a little longer than they would otherwise. And that will in turn slow down EV development and all the other natural tipping points that would wipe out the economic benefits of ICE cars in the first place. In the end German industry will pay for it. Companies like BMW slow-rolled their EV rollouts back in the second half of the 2010s and as of 2022 they were being substantially outsold by Tesla in the US (not just in terms of their anemic EV sales, but across all types of vehicle) and European sales are getting eaten away as well. This is before Chinese EV competitors catch up and really start to compete. If you’re a European manufacturer and you’re not pouring all your resources into EV production then you’re already dead. This is a place where Europe really needs to step in and save their manufacturers from themselves.
- photochemsyn 4y agoAs usual, those energy calculations are highly biased, and the way you can tell is that they don't have any error bars on those energy/expense ratios. They also don't include the costs relative to fossil fuel import and refining costs, another indication that it's not an honest analysis. E.g. long-distance transport in rural areas is probably going to be at least as cheap with hydrocarbon fuels as with EVs, while the opposite will be true in cities with robust electricity supplies, and so on. Additionally, synthetic fuel allows balancing of production and demand of electricity, a major issue when you're relying primarily on sunlight and wind, i.e. exceess PV in the summer months can be converted to hydrocarbon fuels for use in the winter months. See also: "Synthetic fuels in the German industry sector depending on climate protection level (2021)" https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666955221000423 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S266695522... Of course, if Germany builds such a project out at scale, it'll greatly reduce demand for both Russian Siberian pipeline gas and fracked US LNG tanker gas, which probably accounts for CNN's negative view and biased presentation, as their top shareholders have major holdings in Exxon, Chevron and so on. I doubt Putin is thrilled about the idea, either.
- patall 4y agoI personally believe that they only tell you that this about E-fuels, even though everyone knows that those will be too expensive. What they are really looking for are ethanol or vegetable oil derived fuels that are likely much cheaper, especially once the capacity of 5-10% in todays E10 gasoline is freed due to drop in demand. They cannot tell you that because food prizes are high right now. But I would not be surprised at all if in 2035 there was a biodiesel version of Porsche's 911.
- myshpa 4y agoClimate action is strongly influenced by lobying. More info: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35315102 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35315102
- willi59549879 4y agoThat's the first thing that came to my mind when I read the title. Some politician earned millions and now he/she changed their mind.
- WhereIsTheTruth 4y agoOil will be fully depleted this century (probably earlier), Germany is playing with fire, they must be one the most egoist politicians I have ever seen..
- cdot2 4y agoPeople have been saying we're within a decade of running out of oil for about sixty years now
- glogla 4y agoSame with Uranium! The reason is simple but bit insidious - when there is enough "known reserves" of something, it is not economical to look for more. Once the amount of known reserves shrinks, it beings to be worth it and people start looking again. So it might always look like we have between two to five decades of oil or uranium or lithium or whatever. Realistically, we will end humanity by burning oil a lot sooner than we will run out of oil.
- WhereIsTheTruth 4y agoYeah so screw future generations.. Earth population will double by 30 years, so oil consumption will more than double to accommodate with the need of even more energy than before Your perception of oil reserve is based on your needs today, rather than by projection Oil is not an infinite resource, you need to think tomorrow And that's without taking into account pollution, it'll more than double, earth size won't double, so what's gonna happen you think? We can do like germany with this example, or we focus on something future proof
- kayodelycaon 4y agoI think your experience with politicians is quite limited if Germany is the worst you’ve seen. Maybe you missed it but some country somewhere near Germany decided to start a war. ;)
- ihatepython 4y agoThe US? Proxy war would be more accurate
- brnewd 4y agoInstead of banning technical solutions like ICE, we should enforce limits on the total emission from production to end-of-life of a vehicle. Another huge factor should be the ecological impact of a solution. From mining, refining to disposal.
- irrelative 4y agoOr we could make a generalized solution, like a carbon tax, that will minimize the government picking winners.
- noslenwerdna 4y agoThe ecological crisis of our age is global warming. Clean mining is important, but it should not be the overriding factor. I agree that the total emissions from production to end of life are important, though
- 0xDEF 4y ago>The ecological crisis of our age is global warming. Clean mining is important, but it should not be the overriding factor. As a Danish I was surprised to see so many adult Americans and Germans blame climate change on dirty streets and rivers in India and not the GHG emissions from developed countries (and our Chinese factories). Or maybe it's willful ignorance to protect important GHG emission intensive industries in the US and Germany.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoNuance. The developed world is rapidly transitioning to clean energy and mobility while India and China are building GW of coal fired generation (but also deploying renewables at a quick pace). Everyone needs to move in the right direction, and all tools should be on the table to disincentivize carbon emissions (subsidies, tariffs, etc). I would like robust waste disposal systems adopted in the developing world so we stop filling the ocean with plastic (10 rivers in the world are responsible for the majority of ocean plastics), but I also understand that is not driving GHG emissions (which is the most pressing existential crisis for humanity imho). https://ourworldindata.org/renewable-energy https://ourworldindata.org/renewable-energy https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/per-capita-renewables https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/per-capita-renewables https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-change-renewables https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-change-renewables https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-percentage-change-renewables https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-percentage-change-... https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/stemming-the-plastic-tide-10-rivers-contribute-most-of-the-plastic-in-the-oceans/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/stemming-the-plas... (American)
- photochemsyn 4y agoOver the long term, well-designed ICE is not much of a problem. In this context, well-designed means that the only emissions are CO2 and water, which is achievable with proper engineering of the exhaust system (feeding incompletely combusted gases back into the engine, and eliminating NOx and ozone production). The real issue is the fossil fuel sourcing of the hydrocarbons that go into the cars, trucks, jets, rockets and ships, as well as into industrial production of ammonia, steel, and various materials. Ultimately all the hydrocarbon feedstocks will have to come from capture and reduction of atmospheric CO2 to methane, RP1 jet fuel, etc. It's really inevitable - even if climate wasn't a concern, eventually fossil fuel reserves will be depleted and even before then, the costs for new tech will be lower than for old tech (witness the end of the steam engine). However, for most transportation needs, electric vehicles will be the preferable option, with exceptions for international jet travel, long-distance bulk shipping, and rockets for space launches (due to the much higher energy density of chemical fuels relative to battery storage).
- midhhhthrow 4y agoThis will come a surprise to many but we’re a lot closer to peak oil than most people believe. Some of the latest research from scientists like Nate havens shows it’s happening within the next few years. Even she’ll has said their production peaked and will decrease 1 to 2 % per year
- sgc 4y agoThe fuel concerns in Ukraine right now and the precariousness of the EV in crisis situations has made me rethink an all-ev future. Fuel cells and hybrids using the type of hydrocarbons you mention, are starting to make much more long-term sense to me. Alternatively, we should basically force houses to be able to sustain themselves and charge at least the inhabitants' cars, while decoupled from the grid for indefinite periods.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoWhy do hybrids make more sense than pure EV's? Any polity with solar panels and EV's can be completely independent.
- igortg 4y agoPeople should be allowed to make/buy sportscars with combustion engine. These alone don't move the needle of carbon emissions. Make trucks and average peoples car 100% electric and that's it.
- djaychela 4y agoWhy should sports cars be exempt? Ex-rally driver here, who competed at up to international level, for the record, so I'm no anti car person.
- sho_hn 4y agoThe argument I hear on occasion is that appropriate use of sports cars (i.e. actual sport use) can be regulated to use synthetic fuels as the amount of fuel required is relativity small, and sports car owners/operators are generally wealthy enough to pay for the more expensive fuel (and willing to do so to keep their hobby/passion intact). Koenigsegg with their hybrid powertrains makes that argument now and then and points out the parts of the perf spectrum/application space better served by the ICE due to the energy density of the fuel and what it does for weight. In this context an EV sports car could actually have the worse CO2 footprint due to the high upfront costs during battery manufacturing and the low number of miles driven/short lifetime of a vehicle like this. It may never hit the "break-even" vs. a synthetic fuel powered ICE sports car, unlike your standard commuter car which - given good cell chemistries, reasonable battery size, a production location with a good energy mix and proximity to the location of use to avoid shipping emissions, all of which seem to be improving - can hit this reasonably easily now within average vehicle lifetimes. I'm no expert on these arguments and it depends a lot on monitoring entire supply chains and monitoring use (e.g. the aviation industry does a lot of PR with SAFs and in reality they make hardly a dent there right now), but as an engineer I do find the "let's do the actual math and see what makes sense" mindset a good one.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xyzzyz 4y agoAverage person’s car alone doesn’t move the needle either.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoI’d really like having a small electric car I can drive around home but electric cars and infrastructure has a long way to go before I’m willing to give up my hybrid. A friend and I recently did a 2,000+ mile drive (round trip ~16 hours each). Stopping to charge would easily push the drive long enough we couldn’t safely do it, which means 4 days of travel instead of 2. If I wasn’t using a gas car, I’d never been able to do the trip. None of the available alternatives were feasible, given the amount of stuff we had with us.
- radicalbyte 4y agoThe infrastructure where I am (The Netherlands) is great as long as you can charge at home. Germany is just backwards which is odd - they're a car country and EVs are faster and more efficient than ICE so it's surprising they've not already gone all-in.
- martin8412 4y agoAnd where I'm at I'd have to pull an extension cord from my electric stove out the window from the fifth floor to wherever within some 100m I found a free parking spot on the street.
- namdnay 4y agoEverything is feasible if there’s a real incentive. There’s an unrealistic expectation that somehow we must be able to keep the same level of “transport easiness” in the post carbon era. That just won’t be the case. We won’t be going back to pre-industrial levels, but we definitely will be going back a bit
- kayodelycaon 4y agoIn a post-carbon world, travel will be more expensive and I will not have the additional income necessary to travel as much as I do now. That’s quite the opposite of feasible. Incentive doesn’t magically make more resources available to me. Incentive and resources don’t magically remove a person’s physical limitations.
- pibechorro 4y agoTop down economics like banning a whole industry never work. Solutions need to arise bottom up, its an emergent complex system requiering emergent solutions via voluntary desicions of all partys involved (end users,builders, etc). Let the market do its thing. I a generally against subcidies, but they would be a better carrot on a stick than an outright ban.
- ndsipa_pomu 4y ago>Top down economics like banning a whole industry never work. However, there have been many industries that have been modified by top-down bans. Asbestos, various pesticides and lead additives (fuel and paint) have been banned due to the harm that they caused and there's a strong case that ICE vehicles cause a lot of problems through their emissions.
- grey-area 4y agoThe EU banned incandescent bulbs. It worked and the world is a better place because of it.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoAlso forcing USB C and it’s going to work. People who don’t believe these nation station regs work are ignoring reality. It’s about systems thinking and pushing in the direction for desired outcomes. There will always be leaks or drag, but usually in de minimis amounts. Banning ICE in 2035 forces supply chain reconfiguration today, hopefully done in a way that locks in the changes (similar to turning down coal plants and demolishing them).
- favsq 4y agoOnly that LED bulbs are functionally equivalent while EVs are crappy crap compared to actual cars.
- imtringued 4y agoHow does that explain the popularity of Tesla as a brand?
- the_mitsuhiko 4y agoFor as long as they don’t unfairly subsidize e-fuels and there is no cheating going on, i don’t care. The cost of it at present ids so high that i don’t expect them to play much of a role and if they come down in cost greatly it might actually be good for the environment.
- truthwhisperer 4y ago[dead]
- t-3 4y ago2035 is way too close to be practical. Electrical infrastructure, charging stations, public transport and rail all need to be beefed up to make a full EV transition realistic. The increased expense and shorter lifetime of EVs is bad enough (but could plausibly be improved to near parity in a decade), making it near impossible to own a car without living in a house is another thing altogether.
- thomasahle 4y agoIt's only the sale of them. People keep their cars for 10-15 years. If we don't even stop selling them in 2035 they'll still be on the roads past 2050.
- spankalee 4y agoI think I read that half of all cars that will be on the road in 2035 have already been sold.
- glogla 4y agoMoreover, there will be millions of new cars sold to holding companies in December 2034 and then sold as "used" in 2035-2040 with zero kilometers on them. Same things happened every time there was a new emissions regulation in EU. Given all the loopholes and the lifespan of modern cars, I would say 2035 is ridiculously late and it should have been 2025 or 2030 at most.
- marcosdumay 4y agoThe goal is to stop manufacturing, the ban achieves that.
- audunw 4y agoWho is going to want to buy "new" ICE cars in Europe after 2035? Gasoline sale is already plummeting by up to 30% a year some places in Norway. The people who drive the most are the first to convert to EVs since the economics make more sense for them, and newer cars get driven more than very old ones. So EVs will soon dominate the number of miles driven and thus the impact on fuel sale will be larger than you'd think. By 2025 I think you'll start to see gas stations closing down in Norway. By 2035 you'll see the same across Europe. You'll still have gas stations here and there. But it's not going to be as close and convenient as it is now. Even just a few gas stations closing down will get people to panic about whether they'll have a local gas station in the near future. Who will want to buy a new ICE vehicle in that situation? Sure, there will be some enthusiasts. But not enough that it's worth thinking about.
- glogla 4y agoSince I was a kid, my biggest complain with generic comic book villains was always that "some dude out to destroy the world" is just too unrealistic. Now as adult, I see that no, there are literally people who are trying to end humanity and destroy the world - not mad scientists or purple wizards from outer space, but climate deniers and pro-fossil fuel people.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoThe world isn’t ending. Watch less CNN.
- olddustytrail 4y agoYou don't have a clue what the world is doing. Learn more physics.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoI have a graduate degree in physics. Please educate me though.
- olddustytrail 4y agoClearly a waste of your time and money if you need me to educate you further. Why don't you already know about the problems upcoming?
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoProblems, yes. The end of the world, no.
- olddustytrail 4y agoSo you're just going to quibble over the amount of damage a civilization can take before collapse? What point are you trying to make here?
- tomas789 4y agoThis is such a great move! Let me explain. What you care about is not EVs. It is carbon neutrality. You actions should be geared towards that. Not EVs. They are just one way of getting there. Having commercially viable e-Fuels would have a few advantages. You can keep your old car and be net-zero, sport cars would be a thing, you can decarbonize other types of transport which are more complicated to decarbonize than personal vehicles. Like maritime, airplanes, long haul tracking and so on. Its like killing many many birds with one stone. At the momeny, the fact that ICE cars would be banned could be a red flag for new projects trying to push for e-Fuels as it limits their customer base. This is important because at the beginning they will be more expensive that crude-based products so you need to find a niche market where poeple are willing to pay premium for net-zero. I think that companies like Google, Apple and so on would be willing to pay maybe even 2x or 3x for the fuel if it guarantees true net zero (no offsets). As for the efficiency. It is true that the e-Fuel based chain would be less efficient than all-electric but there is a way around it. Efficiency is mostly important to keep the costs low. If you need 1kWh on the output and the efficiency is 20% instead of 90%, you will need 5 kWh instead of 1.11 kWh on the input. But what if the input is next to free? Two ways of getting that. One is by having a surplus electricity which we will have a lot as we inevitably have much more installed capacity in solar than peak load. The other one is to build renewables where they work very well (like Mauritania for solar), produce e-Fuels on-site and than ship them globally. Economy of scale will allow you to decrease cost of e-Fuels dramatically. It might seem like a long shot for you at the moment but I gave it a lot of thought and discussions and research and I think that this very realistic and very likely scenario. PS: If you want to start a business in this area, let me know. I'd be very interested!
- BowBun 4y agoA dutch lawmaker in the article said that e-fuels still release carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. If the EU were to accept Germany's loophole, then there would be a known avenue for vehicle fuel pollutants to continue to damage our environment. Given companies will always prioritize profits, if that loophole exists and they can re-use their infrastructure, naturally they will heavily invest in this area and continue polluting the world. What's the point to all these changes if we just shift from one mode of pollution to another? Maybe the loophole should be to allow fuels that generate 0 carbon emissions (+ other rules) when combusted.
- spankalee 4y agoThe recent IPCC reports are scary, and we're not doing nearly enough to stay within 1.5C warming. Banning ICEs would be great, but will obviously get a lot of push-back from industry and people who don't have great alternatives. EVs have their own problems and can't scale fast enough - we need more options. So countries considering ICE bans should invest as much as possible into public transit, denser urban development, and making bikes and ebikes more viable for more of the population. They should consider those critical, Manhattan-Project-style, investments and pour hundreds of billions into it if necessary.
- heisig 4y agoGuy from Germany here: No, we didn't change our mind on combustion engines. They are getting less popular every month, and even the German car companies have roadmaps that phase out the combustion engine well before 2035. Here is my take on the situation: The problem is that the current government consists of three very different parties (which was the only viable option for forming a government without the conservative climate disaster that is the CDU/CSU). One of these three parties, the FDP, is currently losing popularity because they essentially promised that fancy technology will solve all our problems (take note HN!), but that bluff got called now that they are part of the government. The FDP is quickly losing voter support, and entered panic mode. Unfortunately, the only voter base they can quickly tap into are petrolheads and people that don't like when things get "verboten". The FDP runs the ministry of transport, and used that influence to stall legislation for the entire EU. The other parties cannot really object, or our government would fall apart. I can only personally apologize to all other EU nations. A party with about 5% popularity is holding our government hostage. The only positive thing is that these people cannot really decide about the law in 2035, only about the law today. I hope the climate movement will grow stronger, and those people and their policies will be history much sooner.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- myspy 4y agoThe population is divided too. I see it in a couple forums that green energy is said to be too costly and the people in our country can‘t afford new cars and that more trust in new tech (decarbonization and fusion) is needed. Change is needed but no one wants it. USA and China take no action and Germans are pissed they have to solve the problem. That‘s what people here are thinking.
- thatwasunusual 4y ago> people in our country can‘t afford new cars This is about _new_ cars, so you don't have to replace your old car with a new car once this goes into effect. Also, this is 12 years from now. Do you remember how the EV industry was in 2011?
- pojzon 4y agoOil and car industries are not going down without a fight. Just tells me its ok to buy a new disel coz it will be supported at least fir the next 50 years or so. Cheaper and higher comfort.
- DFHippie 4y agoCool! And it's ok for me to go into my neighbors' house and take their television because they're not home. Cheaper and higher comfort. [I'm just pointing out that your sense of the word "ok" does not mean harmless, but without foreseen inconvenience to yourself.]
- carlosjobim 4y agoYou're not pointing out anything, just exposing how you are as a person and how you'd act if there were no consequences.
- karlzt 4y agoPrevious thread 24 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34985662 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34985662
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- heywhatupboys 4y ago> All that was needed was a rubber stamp from the bloc’s political leaders. ummmm, that is NOT how the EU works.
- gregors 4y agohttps://www.factorywarrantylist.com/car-sales-by-country.html https://www.factorywarrantylist.com/car-sales-by-country.htm... No idea if this data is accurate, but according to this VW sells just about as many cars to China as total cars sold in Germany. Curious, what affect would these laws have on EU car manufacturers that generate the majority of their profits outside the EU? I believe GM sells more cars in China than the US now as well.
- frankreyes 4y agoAmong other things it prevents hydrogen engines, or green gas produced from Sabatier process. It's silly