8 ms·
Yikes. I borrow books constantly from the IA that are hard/impossible to find elsewhere because they've gone out of print. A lot of academic-ish non-fiction fro
by crazygringo 4y ago
Yikes. I borrow books constantly from the IA that are hard/impossible to find elsewhere because they've gone out of print. A lot of academic-ish non-fiction from the 1960s-1980s, stuff you can only otherwise get through inter-library loan that takes weeks rather than seconds.
Any idea if this means IA has to shut down lending by when? Tomorrow? Next month?
Any chances for appeal here? Or any chance they relocate the books division to another country or something?
It's just so sad if something so valuable is forced to go "poof". A real loss.
- Aeolun 4y agoFrom the article the publishers take issue with only 120 or so books. No idea what kind of effect that will have on the rest of it though.
- bdowling 4y ago> the publishers take issue with only 120 or so books Not quite. The plaintiffs have to name some specific works on which to base the case. The 120 is enough because the statutory damages for just those 120 works could be a staggering amount that would bankrupt IA. The complaint [0] also asks for an injunction enjoining IA from any further infringement of "any of the respective copyrights owned or exclusively controlled, in whole or in part, by Plaintiffs, whether now in existence or hereinafter created." [0] at 51. [0] https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.537900/gov.uscourts.nysd.537900.1.0_1.pdf https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.53...
- wahern 4y agoThere's a good chance IA will be exempted from statutory damages. See 17 USC § 504(c)(2), > The court shall remit statutory damages in any case where an infringer believed and had reasonable grounds for believing that his or her use of the copyrighted work was a fair use under section 107, if the infringer was: (i) an employee or agent of a nonprofit educational institution, library, or archives acting within the scope of his or her employment who, or such institution, library, or archives itself, which infringed by reproducing the work in copies or phonorecords The opinion (p46) defers this matter, > At this point, IA’s statutory remittance argument is premature. IA may renew the argument in connection with the formation of an appropriate judgment. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.537900/gov.uscourts.nysd.537900.188.0.pdf https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.53...
- Algemarin 4y ago> I borrow books constantly from the IA that are hard/impossible to find elsewhere because they've gone out of print. A lot of academic-ish non-fiction from the 1960s-1980s, stuff you can only otherwise get through inter-library loan that takes weeks rather than seconds. Try Library Genesis: https://libgen.is/ https://libgen.is/
- ZunarJ5 4y agoEven better: https://annas-archive.org/ https://annas-archive.org/
- xvector 4y agoThis is the one use case where the blockchain/web3 is useful. Give me a decentralized library on the blockchain, where no government can take it down by merely discovering the host's identity and location. Invulnerable to rubber-hose attacks and censorship (which IPFS is still vulnerable to.)
- pdar4123 4y agoWhy do u need a blockchain? Why not just torrents for sharing.
- MisterSandman 4y agoExactly, torrents are already decentralized.
- xvector 4y agoTorrents cannot be updated. Furthermore, torrents are subject to the sites that advertise them getting banned. You will constantly be on the hunt for new trackers. Blockchain is an obviously superior application here as new books and articles are constantly being released.
- 4y ago
- boomboomsubban 4y agoI assume this will be appealed, as what decision like this isn't appealed.
- bentley 4y ago“We will appeal.” https://twitter.com/internetarchive/status/1639424777264721923 https://twitter.com/internetarchive/status/16394247772647219...
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI said it before on this very forum. Wikipedia does not really need your donations these days. IA just might.
- TimTheTinker 4y agoIA and Signal are two nonprofits I donate to and recommend everyone donate to regardless of their political or religious convictions (or lack thereof). The Internet Archive very well may be the only way to know a lot of important things from the past -- things that libraries used to keep track of but can't in the internet age.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoI would add FSF and/or EFF. FSF is more uncompromising with respect to their original principles of defending digital freedom, whereas EFF sort of shifts with time (gradually giving up grounds).
- jefurii 4y agoLooks like EFF is providing the lawyers for this case. THEY need your dollars too.
- tenpies 4y agoUnfortunately IA lost all credibility in my eyes, when they decided that one journalist in particular gets to decide that none of their (awful) tweets should be archived[1]. I understand not allowing certain things to be archived, but the tweets of a public person, especially one who works as a news-maker, should certainly be in the allowed list. E: And just to be clear, this was before said writer set their tweets to private. --- [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20230000000000*/https://twitter.com/TaylorLorenz https://web.archive.org/web/20230000000000*/https://twitter....
- allturtles 4y agoYes, IA has followed a similar tragic arc as Google Books, another martyr to the dream of a truly 21st century library. What's most tragic about it to me is that that vast majority of works affected are "zombie" copyright works that have no actual commercial value. Someone, somewhere holds the copyright, but no one has sold a copy in years or decades. For the sake of protecting the tiny sliver of commercially valuable works, access to all of this other knowledge will be lost.
- crazygringo 4y agoSeriously. Has there been any kind of movement towards a law that would automatically put zombie works into the public domain? It really doesn't seem unreasonable that if a book, film, recording, or video game hasn't been generally available for sale over the past 5 or 10 years it becomes public domain. Use it or lose it, in other words. Although it might really only apply to past works. Because while physical books go out of print, e-books will probably be available forever, no?
- anticensor 4y agoBut then they would make such works paying public domain (the type of public domain that you have to pay royalties to the state) rather than FFA public domain.
- Mindwipe 4y agoNot in the public domain, no, but some countries such as the Nordics have mandatory schemes for orphan works where a collection society is able to authorise their use and has legal protection to do so, and will pay out said royalties should someone come forward to claim ownership at a later date. Most of Europe was going to do this at some point but the photographer's unions pushed back in very strong terms so they were often watered down.
- Mindwipe 4y agoNot in the public domain, no, but some countries such as the Nordics have mandatory schemes for orphan works where a collection society is able to authorise their use and has legal protection to do so, and will pay out said royalties should someone come forward to claim ownership at a later date. Most of Europe was going to do this at some point but the photographer's unions pushed back in very strong terms so they were often watered down.
- zmmmmm 4y agoseems to me that once something is out of print for a lengthy period of time, publishers shouldn't be able to make the fair use argument that electronic copies interfere with the commercial market for the book.
- lenkite 4y agoI guess they should move the site to Russia - better chance of staying alive.
- account42 4y agoBetter chance of staying alive and complete if they can remain in the US but additionally we build seperate archives in the EU, Russian and as many geographically and politically distant regions as we can.
- dredmorbius 4y agoIA have posted a response, though it doesn't address what will / may happen regards book lending: <https://blog.archive.org/2023/03/25/the-fight-continues/ https://blog.archive.org/2023/03/25/the-fight-continues/> Specifically: "We will be appealing the judgment and encourage everyone to come together as a community to support libraries against this attack by corporate publishers.... We will continue our work as a library. This case does not challenge many of the services we provide with digitized books including interlibrary loan, citation linking, access for the print-disabled, text and data mining, purchasing ebooks, and ongoing donation and preservation of books." Checking a listing for a specific book ... there's still the option to log in and borrow it as I write this.