14 ms·
We need a new economics of water as a common good
- anotheraccount9 4y agoNext century: " We need a new economics of air as a common good".
- jlhawn 4y agoGeorgism?
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> Yet public ownership undervalues water, in that one person’s access does not limit another’s, even though water is a finite resource. This promotes excessive, unsustainable and inequitable use. And it discourages private investment. In 2015, private-sector investment in water globally accounted for less than 5% of the total funds allocated to telecommunications, energy, transport and other basic services (emphasis mine) And that is supposed to be a problem ?
- gryn 4y agono. basically they're shilling for nestle water scandal type of operations. edit: to those who down-voted me, can you provide a reason why having more private profit driven investments on water is a good thing that we should aim for? yes companies should not be allowed to hog a social good, and using an economics-style revalorisation will lead to the same dubious shenanigans done with carbon emission offsetting where companies will do some creative accounting to hide their value extraction.
- bradleyjg 4y agoI didn’t downvote you. The choice is often between private investment and no investment at all. It’s all well and good to say the world shouldn’t work that way but meanwhile people need water infrastructure while you are going about changing the world.
- goodpoint 4y ago> The choice is often between private investment and no investment at all. I No other option? Citation needed.
- slowmovintarget 4y agoThat's not how the interstates got built.
- eru 4y agoThat the interstates got built doesn't mean they were a good idea. There are always opportunity costs. The Soviet Union mostly managed to feed its citizens, but that doesn't mean we should copy the Soviet model.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoEr, chilling, or shilling?
- gryn 4y agoThanks, for catching that, fixed.
- rdevsrex 4y agoExactly, I would prefer it if we decommodified water use with and regulate use base on sustainability needs. It would have prevented all these water companies like Nestle from stealing the water from various regions.
- wyager 4y agoWhere is nestle "stealing the water from various regions"? I'm sure they've been involved in water rights disputes, as has any large water consumer, but I'm skeptical that "stealing" is the most objective description or that they're even a large consumer compared to ag.
- andsoitis 4y agoThere have a number of scandals involving Nestlé, such as: - https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2022-01-20/environmentalists-fight-to-shut-down-bottled-water-operation https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2022-01-20/environ... and https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/oct/29/the-fight-over-water-how-nestle-dries-up-us-creeks-to-sell-water-in-plastic-bottles https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/oct/29/the-figh... - https://www.mashed.com/717227/nestles-water-controversy-explained/ https://www.mashed.com/717227/nestles-water-controversy-expl... - https://www.bridgemi.com/michigan-environment-watch/michigan-may-restrict-withdrawals-bottled-water-nestle https://www.bridgemi.com/michigan-environment-watch/michigan...
- sologoub 4y agoSounds like the key issue is that local officials grossly underprice water they have. Strange given California just came out of yet another drought…
- andsoitis 4y agoNot just California. Here's an example from Canada - https://esemag.com/water/nestle-sells-canadian-bottled-water/ https://esemag.com/water/nestle-sells-canadian-bottled-water... We can assume that Nestlé executives are sitting in Switzerland dreaming up where in the world they extract the most water from, put in a bottle, and reselling to the communities (and further afield) that they took the water from.
- ip26 4y agoPrivate-sector investment would include such things as water treatment plants, desalination plants, and evaporation control…
- schiffern 4y agoLet's not forget the often-overlooked strategies of infiltration (recharging aquifers vs the typical drainage/hardscape paradigm) and the restoration and preservation of wetlands (which buffer and purify water).
- michaelscott 4y ago...for those that own it, certainly. What about everyone else?
- ip26 4y agoWhat’s the problem? With more investment, there is more clean fresh water, which is (directly or indirectly) good for all. The more water a golf course can recycle or reclaim, the less drinking water it siphons.
- jmcgeeney 4y agoNo no you don't understand, people won't drink water without a profit motive. We should do oxygen next.
- foota 4y agoThe suggestion is that water is very underpriced, meaning corporations have no incentive to try and retain more or reduce their usage (not that this isn't in large part due to corporate or farm interests lobbying). If water were gold, no one would let it run into the ocean.
- skybrian 4y agoYes, very true, but I think instead of "corporations" it would be better to think about three kinds of water users: agriculture, residential, and industrial. In the American West, water is underpriced for farming (80% of usage) due to senior water rights. Not sure about industry in general, but some users like semiconductor fabs do recycle water. It looks like they're going to recycle more. [1] Cities are starting to recycle too. These are water users who can pay for relatively expensive water. San Diego is doing more than most cities here. [1] https://spectrum.ieee.org/fabs-cut-back-water-use https://spectrum.ieee.org/fabs-cut-back-water-use
- kwere 4y agocorporations and people, US obsession with gigantic green lawns everywhere is an example
- refurb 4y agoI think you missed the point. It's overly wordly but it's basically saying "water is so cheap that the private market as no incentive to invest it in to improve the efficiency of its use" Same argument people make about fossil fuels - it's so cheap (often due to subsidies) that the private sector doesn't invest in alternative)
- ClumsyPilot 4y agowhere is the evidence that private investment is capable of solving the upcoming water crises? What happens in 50 years, when aquifiers under middle east and much of the midsest USA runs out? There is no private investment that can save them.
- refurb 4y agoDesalination technology? More efficient use of water for agriculture? New technology for water purification and waste water treatment? There are a ton of ways private investment can help make water use more efficient. But if water prices are artificially low, that investment will never happen. Israel has 10M people and gets 50% of its water from desalination - 75% of drinking water. It also reclaims 90% of agricultural waste water. It's absolutely possible for countries to solve many of their water issues with new technology.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoAll of those examples are marginal or irrelevant Shortage of water does not mean you have nothing to drink - drinking water is a tiny fraction of water use, only the poorest run out of drinking water. It's a solved problem in rich countries. What you don't get is that water shortage = famine. The problem is agriculture. Desalination is far too expensive to use for irrigation, irrigation requires insane quantities of water. Agriculture is so cost sensitive, and the amounts of water they need are so vast, that most crops are not irrigated even when water is free - the cost of fuel that you'd have to use to pump water from a nearby river to a field is too high. You know what would make a difference? Water infrastructure, like giant pipelines from north of Canada to dry areas of US, like we have for oil. Giant reservoirs to store flood water. You know who builds them? Governments.
- nonethewiser 4y agoWhy should the tax payers have to fund water investments instead of rich corporations?
- bioemerl 4y agoUnderinvestment in water is a really big deal, we need that stuff to live. I don't think privatization is the way to do it though.
- JamesBarney 4y agoPrivate investment is the cause of having many things we value in abundance like food.
- 1270018080 4y agoDoesn't that go against the entire ethos of the YC community? Is this post going to stay up?
- nomilk 4y agoFor anyone interested in water and economics, this Econtalk episode is unexpectedly fascinating. https://www.econtalk.org/david-zetland-on-water/ https://www.econtalk.org/david-zetland-on-water/ What blew my mind was how different water economics is from place to place. Availability of water (and the intersection of that with other unexpected factors, like crime) have a huge impact on day to day living. I was surprised by some of the vicious cycles (for example, water 'brown outs' - providing water for limited hours of the day - actually drives up consumption, since people get more than they need and store it for later use, often at great expense). Somewhat analogous to other 'runs' we see, e.g. banking. It's one of my favourite Econtalk episodes. Highly recommend.
- refurb 4y agoEcontalk is a podcast i keep coming back to. Russ Roberts does a great job bringing on a varied group of people. And his interview style is pretty refreshing. He asks questions like a novice would with “Wait, why is it like that?”. He had a pro-market view but lets his guests state their views before politely saying “i disagree for this reason”, then moving on. The 16+ years of archives are great to go back and listen to especially the interviews about the financial crisis of 2008. He talks to some heavy hitters in the finance industry and it’s fascinating to hear their different views.
- bannedbybros 4y ago[dead]
- akiselev 4y agoMy favorite extreme example of the ways in which water defines society is the Himba people [1] in northern Namibia. They live in one of the driest deserts in the world and water is so scarce that bathing with water is a social faux pas. Instead of bathing they cover their skin with otjize paste made of animal fat and red ochre which acts as a cleanser, protects them from the heat, and repels insects. When they hunt the men gather the liquid they need for the day by digging up tubers similar to cassava that contain a lot of fiber and moisture, while the women herd their livestock around watering holes until the dry season where they make a b-line for areas with high ground water to dig small wells. Among other adaptations, they hunt not by driving their pray to exhaustion or by using heavy weapons like spears, but by digging up beetle larva infected by parasitic Lebistina larva which produces a very concentrated toxin that they use with very thin bows and arrows to bring down pray (which they have to chase down anyway). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Himba_people https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Himba_people
- phkahler 4y agoThis is just a way to socialize water, take it from those who have it and give to those who dont.
- unity1001 4y agoYeah, just like how keeping a military funded by taxes and governed by democratically made laws is taking the military power away from those who have it and giving it to those who dont...
- bitwize 4y agoSocialize all the things. Abolish private property.
- crooked-v 4y agoEat the... moist?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- latency-guy2 4y agoLets start with your personal belongings. I promise we'll get to the rest of everyone else eventually.
- bitwize 4y agoRead up on the difference between private and personal property before making such a foolish response. Private property is capital. Capital is the power to rule.
- marris 4y agoThe distinction is not as clear nor as useful as some make it sound. For example, is my pickup truck "personal" or "private"? Or is it personal as long as I drive myself and my stuff around, but as soon as I offer to sell moving services to others, it becomes private? Or is it still personal as long as I don't scale the business to more trucks? What if my brother and I want to pool two trucks? What if I contribute the truck and he contributes the driving skill, but we are both part owners in the business? What if he doesn't want to take the risk of capital ownership and instead wants a steady wage? At what point does the truck stop being personal property? My personal view of this is that Marxism doesn't really have much to say about organizations below a certain scale, and what it has to say about larger scale orgs is that they are icky/alienating. Everything else is more about trying to verbalize the ickyness than to explain anything substantial about the org mechanics.
- pcblues 4y agoSort of like air and food. Government-funded provision of necessities for health via taxes and protection via regulation should not be damned by calling it names.
- unity1001 4y agoIf they could privatize air, you can bet that they would have done it a long time ago. Its still public because they havent found a monetization mechanic yet.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agodo you notice how their grubby hands want to claim ownership of thongs they did not create?
- guerrilla 4y agoIt's not public, it's regulated commons.[1] 1. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/property/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/property/
- gruez 4y ago>Sort of like air and food. What are you trying to say? I'm not sure where you live but in most countries food is made and distributed privately, in stark contrast to how air is distributed.
- mjfl 4y agothis article is basically written under the assumption that water is going to become more scarce, while they even admit that global warming would increase global precipitation making water less scarce overall. They claim that some areas will experience more extreme droughts but I'm not sure that's how that works. They talk about the need for international regulatory bodies to manage international water disputes - but what will be the teeth of such international bodies? Invasion by the US or UN? I'm deeply skeptical of people who think like this. Please stay powerless.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoThe total amount of water on the planet stays constant because of that nifty water cycle. The amount of potable water is going to become more scarce as population increases and water transportation/sanitation infrastructure fails.
- mjfl 4y agoprecipitation naturally desalinates water, a normally very expensive process. isn't that a crucial detail? Global warming means more global freshwater.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoStill needs treatment, unless you drink rainwater straight. And you need to collect the rain, not just let it go to runoff. Flash floods are going to damage the infrastructure to collect and purify such water as well. I don't see how that's a good thing. Global warming means sea level rise which means more people crowded into less space which means more pressure on natural ecosystems and more conflict over less resources. Plus a hotter world means we're using more of that water keeping crops hydrated.
- mjfl 4y agoHave never heard of a groundwater well? The ground collects water! It's orders of magnitude cheaper than desalination!! https://media.istockphoto.com/photos/modern-water-well-diagram-picture-id531862237 https://media.istockphoto.com/photos/modern-water-well-diagr...
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y ago>>>Yet public ownership undervalues water, in that one person’s access does not limit another Chile's private water rights management does not undervalue water. In fact they value it so much that a new class of professional developed : water real estate brokers. Private leasing of public lands to the highest bidder is an interesting use case that does not get much attention
- eru 4y agoFor Chile's private water rights management to work, one person's access has to limit another person's access.
- andsoitis 4y agospeaking as an über capitalist, clean water is a human right that every single human on earth must have access to. there is no question about it, just about how to accomplish.
- gruez 4y agoIn other words, "suffering is bad and we should prevent it, but we don't know how"? What a brave and profound statement to make! /s
- andsoitis 4y ago> In other words, "suffering is bad and we should prevent it, but we don't know how"? What a brave and profound statement to make! /s That's not what I'm saying at all. What I am saying is that there probably isn't one solution that would work on every part of the planet and further more that in practical terms there isn't a single "we" on the hook to solve. There are probably many different strategies, from restricting private companies from extracting water at low cost and making huge profits, to building water infrastructure in places where there are none, to desalination, to eradicating cholera, etc. etc. But what I do believe is that ability to pay for water should not be a limiting factor to having access to clean water because it is a basic ingredient of life and so nobody should profit off of access.
- gruez 4y ago>But what I do believe is that ability to pay for water should not be a limiting factor to having access to clean water because it is a basic ingredient of life and so nobody should profit off of access. Do you, as a "über capitalist" also believe the same to be true for food?
- andsoitis 4y agoyes. people will squabble about how much and what quality is minimally required, but I would love to see every society prioritize guaranteeing basic nourishment to not only survive, but to have a healthy mind and body.
- netbioserror 4y ago[flagged]
- tjbiddle 4y agoI understand this is talking about water as a commodity, but I'd like to share another side of it. Just finished a week motorbiking in Laos. It's currently incredibly hot and dry. They are at the end of dry season, but having lived in many climates with hot/dry - it still caught me off guard. Many of the farms were bone dry - dust everywhere. Doesn't help that the regularly do 'slash & burn agriculture' where they're burning the forest, clearing it, planting their crops, and repeating after they exhaust the soil. We were constantly coming across areas on fire. But no - that's not the issue. The government is corrupt there and is constantly selling the rights to build dams. There's no environmental survey before doing so - they're just cropping these things up all over the place; even where the return is very minimal. If there's a profit opportunity - it's there. This is of course causing downstream rivers to run low, preventing water access to farms and villages that rely on it. And the kicker: Laos doesn't even get the electricity generated - 90% of it is exported to neighboring countries like Thailand. Just incredible to see.
- lenova 4y agoHi there, I would love to hear more about your trip. I lived in Laos for a few months a decade ago, just outside of Vang Vieng. I think of the country often, and can only imagine just how much it has changed.
- esturk 4y agoHave you considered that Laos is the way it is because of its past history and geographical location? For one, it's the most heavily bombed nation in the world per capita (done by America during the Vietnam War)? [1] It isn't easy to develop a country that is so severely set back by war. Especially without outside help and/or investment. Laos also isn't getting the same attention as its neighbors like Thailand and Vietnam by the West almost as if it holds no strategic value to the West. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unexploded_ordnance#Laos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unexploded_ordnance#Laos
- fnordpiglet 4y agoThat’s one of their problems. But if you’ve visited the real problems are very apparent, and they start with their form of highly corrupt communism and hostility to the outside world. It’s not getting the attention from the west because the government is highly insular. Being the most efficient route to China and between Vietnam and Thailand makes it very strategically important, and China is probably more responsible for the state of Laos than anywhere else. It’s very much in their interest the west has no toe hold there, and that it stay effectively a vassal state dependent on their patronage.
- screwturner68 4y agoAm I supposed to feel bad for people who moved to the desert and have no water or worse subsidize a farmer to grow high water usage crops like alfalfa so they don't lose their antiquated water rights? Honestly, two of the fastest growing areas in the US is Las Vegas and Phoenix neither of which have their own water to me this is probably one of the dumbest moves I've ever seen. Are we as a country/society supposed to fix this or do we just say, wow that was a dumb fucking move I suggest you check out Des Moines?
- XorNot 4y agoLas Vegas is actually very efficient. The city's water infrastructure is well built, and sustainable. More over... It's simply not the problem either - cities never are. Cities need water for individuals - ablutions and drinking, some light industry. The amount they use pales in comparison to what farmers and livestock will go through, and the volume and type of effluent produced, as well as contamination risk.
- humaniania 4y agoAll of the food consumed in Vegas has to get shipped in. That is not efficiency. In what universe are golf courses in the desert efficient?
- jiggyjace 4y agoAll of the food consumed anywhere has to get shipped in because of globalization... Because that's the most efficient thing. And golf courses only use 4 acre feet of water for each acre of golf course. In the grand scheme of half a million acre feet of water that Vegas takes from Lake Mead, it sure is efficient given how worried it makes people who don't even live there.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoIf you are interested in better understanding water issues, I highly recommend the books Salt Dreams, which is about the Colorado River, Salton Sea and water history in Southern California, and Water for a thirsty land, which is the history of water development in Fresno County, California where a lot of water rights issues were hashed out historically in court and a lot of equipment was invented and patented, etc. Fresno has a very interesting water history and has done a good job of learning to recharge its aquifer, among other things. It probably has better water security than most of California and anyone interested in improving water security for their region would do well to learn a little something about Fresno. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27566605 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27566605
- jillesvangurp 4y agoIt's not so much that there's a water shortage in a lot of places but merely that the natural sources of drinking water that people use are drying up forcing them to switch to more expensive sources of water. My home country the Netherlands actually has a water shortage. But much of it is below sea-level and we pump a lot of non salty water into the sea (at great expense) to keep the land dry. So, this is a notion that needs a little explaining. How come there is a shortage in a country like that? Very simple: farmers don't like it when their fields are a swamp, so ground water levels are kept very low. This is done by draining, pumping, etc. Most of that water ends up in the sea. This in turn is governed by local policy on which farmers have a lot of influence. Additionally, they use groundwater for irrigating the land. Because dry land doesn't produce a lot of crops. So, ground water levels are at a historic low in a lot of places. To the point where nature is struggling and water companies that also rely on ground water for supplying drinking water have to remind people to limit their water usage. In a country that is basically a swamp below sea level. The solution to all this: change policies and stop using ground water at an unsustainable rate. There's plenty of other water. But using that is more expensive. Ground water tends to be very clean as it has been filtered through sediment layers. Surface water from rivers, lakes, etc. needs more treatment. Collecting rain water seems very uncommon. But there is plenty of that as well. Most of it is pumped and drained straight to the sea. There is an abundance of water. So much that it is actually a problem. If my country stops pumping and draining water out to sea, it won't take long for a lot of it to be reclaimed by it. And in a pinch, we can actually take ocean water and desalinate it. This would of course be ridiculous in the Netherlands considering that two of the largest rivers in Europe flow through it to the North Sea and given that it rains a lot here (less than it used to, but still). Other places in the world have a lot less water. But this planet is far from running out of water. Most of it is still covered by water and we have plenty of ways to produce drinking water from that. All we need to do is transport it around to where it is needed. In some places, desalination is cheaper than doing that.
- skybrian 4y agoI know nothing about it, but it sounds sort of like it would be good for the groundwater level to be low, but fresh water to be stored somewhere else rather than pumped into the sea? Like a reservoir?
- Nifty3929 4y agoNestle uses appx zero water. 58M gallons, according to this article, which is equivalent to about 181 acre feet. Agriculture measures their water in Millions of acre feet! (MAF) They use dozens of MAF per year. Nestles use is not so much as a rounding error. And the water they bottle is used for it’s highest imaginable purpose - drinking. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/apr/27/california-nestle-water-san-bernardino-forest-drought https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/apr/27/california-n...
- turndown 4y agoGood thing one of those is required for civilization, ye, life itself to function, and the other is wrapping water in a plastic container. Certainly agriculture must use water more efficiently, but let’s not compare apples to oranges.
- hackernewds 4y agoYes, let's not compare drinking water directly per droplet needed. To wasting billions of gallons of water to grow some almonds in dry California for economic reasons
- turndown 4y agoYou have made a strawman where I said growing almonds was a great idea or something - it isn’t and should be stopped, but let’s not sit here and act like Nestle is anything but a dreg scraping parasite. Farming practices in the US should change, and all water bottling should be banned permanently.
- ethanbond 4y agoIt’s not a straw man at all. It is the definition of distraction to even be discussing an edge case of water consumption. You can completely eliminate all bottled water and it will not make a dent whatsoever in any problem that matters.
- acd 4y agoWe need to pay for all common reources such as fish, groundwater, polluting air quality. However banks and investment companies should not be allowed to invest otherwise the market will become skewed. Earths resources are not endless. We share earth with future generations. Thus we should try and live in harmony with eco systems.
- Bloating 4y agoTaxes! We need more taxes! But, tax that other guy
- EngManagerIsMe 4y agoTax me, tbh. I make $700k a year. If my taxes go towards resource conservation and regulating the commons towards sustainability, I'm all for paying more in taxes. So yeah, tax the other guy who is like me and tax me. (And before you respond with, "Well, you can voluntarily pay more in taxes" you should know that I've put aside hundreds of thousands a year towards environmental conservation, and two, I believe that even if I donated 100% of my own income it wouldn't be enough. I believe in taxes as a mechanism, and I believe that taxes on income at or above what I make are eminently reasonable.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]