5 ms·
Pretty cool no doubt, but it seems that people are mostly discovering the power of Wolfram Alpha for the first time. It has been able to do stuff like this for
by paxys 4y ago
Pretty cool no doubt, but it seems that people are mostly discovering the power of Wolfram Alpha for the first time. It has been able to do stuff like this for over a decade now, just without a conversational chat interface.
- nico 4y agoThe chat interface + context is the magic. GPT had been out for a while, but it only really exploded in use with ChatGPT. Essentially, a conversational agent + tools = magic.
- broast 4y agoPersonally I find completions as equally useful as the chat interface and I'm waiting for OpenAI to prioritize economizing and adding plug-ins for gpt3/4 for completions like they have for chat and gpt-3.5-turbo. Being able to rely on Wolfram for accurate completions (through the API) rather than just through chat/chat api would be very cool
- andai 4y agoI've seen a paper (I forget which, might respond below later) about GPT-4 and tool use i.e. it reliably knows when it's hit the limit of what it can do on its own, and can successfully emit commands for external APIs to handle those aspects for it (calculator, character manipulation, etc). My hunch is if you read that, you could get "raw GPT-4" to defer to WolframAlpha via a similar mechanism (with a couple dozen lines of glue code).
- jeron 4y agoWolfram had ability to infer context for a while but never felt magical because you often hit limitations where it did not understand, unlike chatGPT
- htss2013 4y agoYes but let's acknowledge the less magical reality - a big part of the magic of chatgpt is its willingness, not ability, to make stuff up and deliver it with confidence. If chatgpt gave errors or some other bad experience instead of smoothly fabricating fake answers, a lot of the magic would wear off. For savvy users this doesn't matter. The utility is off the charts and you can mitigate the risk of being lied to. But let's not pretend this is cost free. There is a huge externality in the form of shadow scrambling reality for millions of people who don't realize it's happening.
- danielrpa 4y ago"Fake it until you make it" - very human behavior indeed. It's unfair to hold the AI to a bar we don't apply to ourselves.
- brianpan 4y agoI expect a calculator to multiply 2 numbers for me very quickly and correctly. Every time. I don't hold any human to that bar and that's perfectly ok.
- Spivak 4y agoYeah, and you can have GPT do that quickly and accurately. You just have to give it access to a calculator just like you would for a human. Tell it not to compute anything and explain how to format the output that can be ingested by a calculator or interpreter. People have crazy unrealistic expectations of what the raw model can do but undersell what it’s possible to build with a machine that grasps language better than basically every human.
- withinboredom 4y agoI don’t need a calculator to tell me 50 * 12 is 600. But you’re saying an AI does?
- 4y ago
- ren_engineer 4y agothe magic was that it was free, only OpenAI can afford to do it after selling out to Microsoft for near unlimited compute resources. Google was too afraid of negative PR to do it themselves at first, they should have spun their chat bot out into a startup that wouldn't hurt their core brand. Google had an internal ChatGPT equivalent for over a year
- nico 4y agoTried Bard yesterday, it sucks in comparison with ChatGPT. Doesn’t even translate. I was expecting a lot more from the company that made Google Translate.
- zvonimirs 4y agoYea, couldn't have finished college without it!
- Balgair 4y agoSecond! Those nasty integrals in E&M became a breeze with WA. Our TAs learned to accept the application of a 'WolframAlpha' operator to solve them, since everyone knew they were just busy-work integrals once you got to upper-division classes.
- 77pt77 4y agoQuite frankly if you have homework where WA can solve the integrals instead of you having to somehow "massage" them for it to even be able to "digest" it, your upper-division classes are not very upper at all.
- Balgair 4y agoIt was the top astrophysics program in the world when I was there. Maybe they should have stepped it up though and gone for top in the universe.
- kickaha 4y agoTen years ago you could say to your iPhone, “Hey, Siri. What’s the ratio of the distance to the sun to the distance to the moon?” And it would tell you the answer and give a pop up with the parameters and calculations from Wolfram Alpha. Solidly reliable. This was such a fun game in the car with little kids who didn’t know any better that (1) it’s magic I couldn’t have imagined ten years before and (2) it was nerdy as hell. Today it will, at best, give you the “Here’s what I found on the web” uselessness. So frustrating.
- rednerrus 4y agoHook up the chatgpt shortcut to siri and boom problem solved.
- kridsdale1 4y agoLink?
- Robotbeat 4y agoThere are a billion GPT-3 Apple Shortcuts if you search for them on the Shortcuts app on your iPhone/iPad/iWatch, but I preferred to just make the shortcut myself so I could easily modify it and be sure I wasn’t leaking my API key to a 3rd party. I just followed this simple guide: https://www.innoq.com/en/blog/openai-gpt-3-on-macos-ios-apple-shortcuts/ https://www.innoq.com/en/blog/openai-gpt-3-on-macos-ios-appl...
- 93po 4y agoCan it still do stuff like set timers on my phone for me?
- andai 4y agoSiri had a WolframAlpha integration and removed it?
- 4y ago
- mrtksn 4y agoI agree, ChatGPT appears to be the ultimate UI and as a result great services are exposed. It’s very powerful UI because it solves the discoverability completely and replaces the original UI with uniform conversational UI.
- antegamisou 4y agoExactly, I'd even go out on a limb and say I find its capabilities much more impressive than ChatGPT's. The way it generates output is probably more interesting from an scientific/academic point of view than the black-box essence of LLM but that's just a personal observation.