11 ms·
Financial providers shouldn't be issuing moral judgements. It seems to be more common too. The other day I got a notification that was "FYI we sold your shares
by Havoc 4y ago
Financial providers shouldn't be issuing moral judgements. It seems to be more common too.
The other day I got a notification that was "FYI we sold your shares in company X (NASDAQ listed)". They've decided they're no longer keen on weed companies and have taken it upon themselves to fix my portfolio to remove such evilness. Left me slightly speechless...I'm paying you to hold shares not be moral police ffs.
edit: this was a self-managed portfolio hence my surprise at getting notified about successful trade
- bioemerl 4y agoWho did you get that notification from?
- devoutsalsa 4y agoIf you’re willing to share, what broker was that? I’ll avoid.
- Havoc 4y agoWasn't broker, but their upstream provider Euroclear
- devoutsalsa 4y agoInteresting. I looked it up and found some more information. https://thedalesreport.com/cannabis/euroclear-to-stop-supporting-cannabis-stocks-beginning-next-year/ https://thedalesreport.com/cannabis/euroclear-to-stop-suppor...
- hawk_ 4y agoIf they are custodians and not managing your portfolio, that might even be illegal.
- LtdJorge 4y agoBut will OP sue, tho?
- Havoc 4y agoI won't. A) not worth the hassle and B) I'm sure there will be some bullshit buried in the T&Cs on page 24 in font size 2 allowing this. I just thought it is very much left field for an own-managed share account
- Havoc 4y agoWasn't managed. Hence my surprise. My first thought was I had gotten hacked (yay lastpast) & someone is trading on my account
- xienze 4y ago> Financial providers shouldn't be issuing moral judgements. Have you considered that this may have been a decision based on “we might get sued for being party to human trafficking” reasons?
- silverpepsi 4y agoThat's a circular argument though, the label is also a moral judgement The public was becoming too liberal, didn't have a strong enough reaction to "prostitution" anymore. Hence they started relabeling most voluntary prostitution disingenuously and even changing laws to make clearly "nothing special" also be "sex trafficking" ... like a man traveling for a weekend getaway to another city with two half-sugar baby half-prostitites.
- xienze 4y ago> That's a circular argument though No it’s not. Whatever moral judgement the government assigns to a crime is irrelevant to a company who is staring down the barrel of a lawsuit for being party to said crime. In the end, all it would take is one case of a pimp accepting payment for his underaged prostitutes via this company for the payment processor to be sued into oblivion, so they made the rational decision to not open themselves to this risk any longer.
- Retric 4y agoHardly a realistic risk there. Payment processors are really hard to sue unless they are directly involved in fraud. Which is why person to person payment processors like Venmo can operate.
- xienze 4y ago> Hardly a realistic risk there. What? No it's not. Here's an example of a payment processor that got sued for being the payment processor used by a debt settlement firm that merely "overcharged consumers, took untimely fees, misrepresented the value of its services, and failed to make critical disclosures about consumer harms."[0] > Payment processors are really hard to sue unless they are directly involved in fraud. All of that is merely a question of the scale of the activity and how badly the government wants to stop it. Same reason cryptocurrency escaped taxing/reporting requirements for many years -- the scale and the ire of the government just wasn't there yet. Relevant to this discussion, the payment processor in question is associated with a company that makes no bones about providing services for people engaged in work that is illegal in many jurisdictions! If you don't think that would eventually land both companies in the government's crosshairs, I don't know what to tell you. Take "fair" out of the equation, if you're a business owner it's not about "fair", it's about saving your ass. It's not a moral judgement for a company to voluntarily disassociate themselves from another company engaged in illegal behavior. > Which is why person to person payment processors like Venmo can operate. Venmo's TOS has named restrictions on what customers can do (and "at our discretion" clauses), and they absolutely will ban users for violating them if it either Venmo can prove it or if they government starts threatening them over it. 0: https://www.mass.gov/news/ags-office-reaches-settlement-with-payment-processing-company-over-claims-of-unlawful-fee-practices https://www.mass.gov/news/ags-office-reaches-settlement-with...
- sebstefan 4y agoIIRC, last time something like this was discussed, the problem of fraudulent chargebacks was brought up as the main reason why these banking institutions keep targetting porn and sex work
- pydry 4y ago[flagged]
- gumby 4y agoThe B-1 was the original “put a piece in each congressional district” back in the Reagan era. The issue for gambling and sex payment processors is that they are easy targets for politicians looking for votes: someone who hates them will vote for such a candidate and few will bother to come out in support. Those politicians become the regulators, so in exchange for chilling on some issue or another the payment processors agree to “crack down”
- stametseater 4y agoI can't find a source for this (or the B-1 claim) right now so I might be wrong, but I believe the Space Shuttle was done in a similar matter, with subcontractors in each of the 50 states to make it politically bullet proof.
- gumby 4y agoIt was widely reported at the time (and Rockwell was proud of their approach) because it was a novel and cynical idea. Even though Reagan had been elected people back then were still shocked by a cynical approach like that. I was surprised by it. Literally every congressional district, not just every state. I thought the plane was cool, but even as a teen I could see that it was pointless.
- WorldMaker 4y agoI believe there's some disagreement if the Space Shuttle was intentionally built that way (though the eventual reality came close, but it may have been as much pragmatism and the usual procedures of government bid contracts), but it is definitely a common criticism of how Nasa's current Space Launch System (SLS) was planned and is being built. (It's a criticism also heavily negatively used when comparing, for instance, SpaceX projects over the same timeframes, especially by the sorts of people that think today's Nasa should be more in the business of buying and "leasing" commercialized rockets and capsules rather than building its own.)
- baidifnaoxi 4y agoThis is why I oppose ESG. It’s being pushed by the financial institutions under the guise of sustainability. But now you have many things unrelated to climate that have been show-horned in. It’s fine to create regulation that’s voted upon, it’s not okay to use financial firms to push moral or societal change in collusion with governments.
- throwayyy479087 4y ago[flagged]
- chpatrick 4y agoNestle is also at the top of most ESG indices.
- baidifnaoxi 4y agoWow. Yeah. It’s not just moral or societal, I guess. It’s also is influenced by $$$$
- notlukesky 4y agoWhy is this being downvoted if the fact is true? There are so many other high ESG scores like SVB and FTX and even countries like Sri Lanka (went bankrupt as well) that it has become an indicator like Jim Cramer. Every rating system will be gamed if there are incentives for it and be turned into a farce. Just like bombing countries to the stone ages for “human rights”, “liberation” and “democracy”. All code words for genocide and massacres. The British Empire, a “democracy”, used to invade countries for slave trading. Then when slavery was made illegal it then invaded countries under the guise of stopping slavery!
- Rexxar 4y agoBecause he can't make the difference between a consumer product company and a tobacco company ?
- itsdrewmiller 4y ago
- prepend 4y agoIs it a moral judgement? Or is it an extremely high number of chargebacks making it unprofitable? I don’t think payment processors care, but they have margins they want to maintain. Dipping their margins for particular companies or industries would be making a moral decision. For your mutual fund, I expect similar in that weed stocks aren’t performing as well as they once were and aren’t projected to perform as well so they no longer fit the targets of your fund. I’d read the prospectus before assuming some moral aversion to weed.
- Retric 4y ago[citation needed] on the chargebacks. Sex workers get a lot of repeat business and aren’t used for the kind of stolen credit card validation that hits many online businesses.
- HappySweeney 4y agoI have a buddy that used to own a brothel in Arizona. He said he got a lot of chargebacks, but he would dispute them with the physical signatures and generally won.
- stametseater 4y agoDo you mean Nevada? When was prostitution last legal in Arizona? 1918 as far as I can tell.
- HappySweeney 4y agoI mean Arizona. He was aware his business was not legal.
- quotz 4y agoAm I the only one dying to learn more about this? How was he running a brothel in AZ?? Was it near the border?
- 4y ago
- jackmott42 4y agoWhy shouldn't they?
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoMany consider speech and unfiltered internet access basic rights. But we rarely hear people talk about the right to financial services. Having no way to make transactions and receive payments can bankrupt someone. And they don't just unbank people for moral reasons, there is a long list of individuals, activist groups and companies that have been shut out for political reasons too. In the current system banks as private businesses can refuse service to whoever they want. We don't own even our dollars in the bank, we're a creditors. If the bank fails anything that's uninsured may be lost, because the vast majority is not held in legal tender, it's book money which no other party will accept as payment. Your story seems extreme, that would not be legal in my country because stocks are your own property, the bank can't touch them. Either way, none of this should be allowed in the first place. The financial system is completely messed up and the only reason people think it's normal is because they don't know any other way. Money itself should be neutral, it should not be controlled by any single group and people should have free access to basic transactions. If only there were something like a public bank ledger that belongs to everyone...
- KronisLV 4y ago> If only there were something like a public bank ledger that belongs to everyone... Feels like proper legislation might also be a solution to the human problem, rather than just throwing technology at things. Maybe both? Of course, neither may actually be feasible in some places.
- RunSet 4y ago> Feels like proper legislation might also be a solution to the human problem, rather than just throwing technology at things. Maybe both? Possible compromise: We try the decentralized public ledger. Then, should that fail, we can still attempt to legislate morality for the... well, darn- I've lost count of the failed attempts but maybe it will work next time.
- cawest11 4y agoMotherfucker, the entire crypto industry is in the middle of a collapse. It lasted less than a decade at scale and that’s just the 10% that weren’t an out and out scam (I lean toward that number being closer to 0%, but I’ll throw you a bone since you sound like you’re caught up in it).
- newsclues 4y agoIt's not just a moral judgement. The illegal sex industry is a big one, and if you have a scalable and available online platform that illegal transactions can be hidden from the authorities that is a problem. It is a problem if your payment processor is taking payments for nonconsensual sex, rape and payments to have sex with children. Not just a moral panic issue. Edit: seems like I have some views that are unpopular with the cowards who downvote comments without engaging in discussion.
- throw_m239339 4y ago> Edit: seems like I have some views that are unpopular with the cowards who downvote comments without engaging in discussion. Downvotes are to be expected on that topic as soon as one says something mildly against the prostitution "business"... "Sex consumers" don't want to take responsibility for the damages they cause or the crimes they participate in, for them it's a "simple commercial transaction" between "consenting adults", forgetting all the coercive tactics pimps have been using for ages, the grooming, the drug addiction... Of course it's a legal risk for any payment processor involved in that kind of "business". Don't worry about the downvotes, your arguments are completely reasonable and nobody can silence you no matter how hard they try.
- newsclues 4y agoI'm not worried about downvotes, I just want the cowards to understands there is a difference between supporting the industry of people that agree to work in it, and people (sometimes children) who are manipulated, and forced with violence and drug addiction to do things they don't want to. There are sex slaves in America, and anyone that covers for that is worse than a coward.
- dpkirchner 4y agoSome of us just reflexively downvote when we see off-topic complaints about downvotes.
- itsoktocry 4y ago>Financial providers shouldn't be issuing moral judgements That ship has long sailed, my friend. We spent the past 7-10 years intentionally drawing corporate America into politics. I mean, Donald Trump was banned from Twitter. Apparently people want it this way, so here we are. This time it's a left-leaning cause that gets screwed.
- superzamp 4y agoI think these kind of shenanigans are byproducts of how regulation in financial services is delivered from the regulating bodies to builders in the space. As opposed to e.g. health where clear guidelines are often the norm, fintech is basically a shit show where regulators expect you to have internal processes to combat fraud, know your customers, do not finance terrorism, money laundering et al. — all without laying out actual precise guidelines of what they really expect want to see from an implementation standpoint, keeping you on your toes all the time. This leads to self-inflicted wounds from financial services providers, anticipating that regulators might not like e.g. stoner stocks and preemptive actions to minimize risk of being shut down.
- zamnos 4y ago> Visa could be liable in suit over child sexual abuse material on Pornhub, other sites https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2022/08/01/visa-mindgeek-liable-payment-processors/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2022/08/01/visa-mind... You're totally right, in this case it's child porn. The lawsuit proves Visa's paranoia isn't entirely unjustified, either. That's the thing that pierces the corporate veil and puts executives in jail. Hence the cut off. I'm not sure how we improve the situation though
- philwelch 4y agoWhat makes you assume it’s a moral judgment and not a liability/risk-driven business decision? I’ve almost never observed large businesses, including banks, passing up a chance to make money because of their moral scruples. > The other day I got a notification that was "FYI we sold your shares in company X (NASDAQ listed)". They've decided they're no longer keen on weed companies and have taken it upon themselves to fix my portfolio to remove such evilness. You are aware that cannabis is still federally illegal, right?
- stametseater 4y ago> What makes you assume it’s a moral judgment and not a liability/risk-driven business decision? I’ve almost never observed large businesses, including banks, passing up a chance to make money because of their moral scruples. Amazon's firearm accessory rules seem to contain plausible examples of such. Permitted accessories include: Vise blocks designed to hold firearms, except for those intended for "assault weapons." Magazine loaders, except for those which can accommodate the following common rifle calibers: .223/5.56; 7.62x51; 308; 7.62x39; 5.45x39 Armorer's wrenches, except those specifically for assault weapons, particularly AR pattern rifles. Hand gun grips, but not "assault weapon grips". Implicitly permitted are jig kits except those for ARs specifically (no mention of other assault rifles/weapons. It bans "AR-specific jig kits") Source with many more examples, many of them sensible restrictions likely motivated by state laws, but many of them perplexingly specific: https://sellercentral.amazon.com/help/hub/reference/external/G200164950 https://sellercentral.amazon.com/help/hub/reference/external... Is there any state in this union in which restricts sale or possession of vise blocks designed to hold ARs? Not as far as I'm aware. They also restrict "Offensive and Controversial Materials", saying: > We maintain these policies to ensure a welcoming environment for our global customers and sellers to do business while offering the widest selection of items on earth. We promote trust and respect, as well as adherence to the law. > We exercise judgment in allowing or prohibiting listings and we keep our global community of customers and cultural differences and sensitivities in mind when reviewing and making a decision on products. One of the examples of products they ban is "Products that promote intolerance based on race, religion, and sexual orientation.", which interpreted in an impartial manner would obviously ban the Bible and many other religious texts, but in fact Amazon doesn't actually ban those. They're exercising a lot of judgement in the application of these rules and many apparent contradictions can be found. For instance they claim they won't sell products which promote or glorify terrorism, yet they sell the Unibomber's Manifesto and t-shirts of Che. https://sellercentral.amazon.com/help/hub/reference/external/G200164670 https://sellercentral.amazon.com/help/hub/reference/external...
- piokoch 4y agoThis ship has sailed when Gab creator was cut-off from all payment systems. People widely applauded Visa et. al move, as this Gab guy is a horrible person that ends each message with dreaded "Jesus is King" quotation. So "the people" was happy. Now people learn the hard lesson, one day your opinion, business, etc. might irritate the powers that be and you'll be crashed, as those who you helped to crash before. Let's this be the lesson for everyone.
- b1c1jones 4y ago[flagged]
- sowbug 4y agoIf you're not willing to defend the speech rights of those you personally find reprehensible, then you oppose free speech.
- ikiris 4y ago[flagged]
- snapcaster 4y agoI think a more generous interpretation of his comment would be that "speech protections are only relevant for unpopular speech". Nobody needs freedom of expression to discuss how it's kind of rainy today but hopefully sunny this weekend
- tetha 4y agoAlternative flippy way: I fight for your right to say your opinion, and for my right to call it stupid.
- swift532 4y agoYou get to call it stupid, you don't get to cut someone's water or electricity off because you think they have a stupid opinion. Same should go for having the ability to pay for stuff and receive money from people who want to give it to you, as long as what you are doing is not illegal.
- throw_m239339 4y ago> Financial providers shouldn't be issuing moral judgements. It seems to be more common too. Nothing to do with "morals", everything to do with the risks associated with prostitution. Same thing with Cannabis businesses, which payment processors tend to not do business with. These companies have very little morals, but their executives don't want to be thrown in jail for being digital pimps.
- sowbug 4y agoIt's a circular argument. Businesses don't do business with Business X, so it's too risky for us to do business with Business X. Yet we have figured out how to let 16-year old kids drive 5,000-pound blocks of metal in public. The distinguishing element of the two cases is morality. (Substitute porn for prostitution to sidestep the question of legality; the result is the same.) I don't want the government to legislate morality. Everyone in a free society should have the choice to be moral or immoral; otherwise there is no morality. But if the U.S. government wants to effectively eliminate cash through post-9/11 KYC/AML laws, structuring laws, increasingly strict service-industry cash-transaction reporting requirements, and so on, then either the government needs to establish a genuinely amoral and private electronic-payment system that allows disgusting, vile, reprehensible, but legal transactions. Or the government must actively affirm the obligation of private payment processors like Visa and Mastercard to support transactions that conflict with their moral preferences. Our freedoms of speech and association are being swept aside as the government shunts nearly all financial activity through private enterprises. What good is the Bill of Rights if you can't do anything without a debit card?
- throw_m239339 4y ago> It's a circular argument. Businesses don't do business with Business X, so it's too risky for us to do business with Business X. It isn't a circular argument, running a business is all about risks management, choosing not to do business with people that could be link to sex trafficking mafia is very much effective risk management, that platform can go take their business elsewhere. This isn't even a partisan issue, prostitution is frowned upon by most payement processors for very objective reasons. It's a non story.
- goldfeld 4y agoSocieties should not gain leverage over lower classes and then buy their morally broken bodies when they have little else. Of course society should indeed profess the meagerest moral rights and humanity for all and protect that.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoI remember when visa rejected my attempt to give money to wikileak, which is legal in my country. So I donated BTC, and this is when I realized why we need crypto despite all the scams.
- ChickenNugger 4y agoPretty much all the payment processors cut off Wikileaks without even the government asking them to. And all they did is publish evidence of war crimes.
- throw101010 4y agoI know it is not a popular topic here, but this kind of lack of control over (allegedly) your assets is one of the premises for the existence of Bitcoin. Self-sovereignty and self-custody prevent third-parties from making decisions for you like this, and the removal of intermediaries (like payment processors) also prevent anyone from restricting you ability to transact with your desired counterparties. The kind of freedom this enables also has disadvantages of course, but I strongly believe the few real "bad" transactions that gets blocked by the current system are a drop in the ocean compared to the billions of people deprived of access to the system and the millions of others who are included but seriously limited in what they are "allowed" to do on it.
- umeshunni 4y agoYou realize this article is about crypto payment processor SpankPay, right?
- throw101010 4y agoWhich is not a third-party *required* to do this kind of transactions. It is just a convenient way to convert the crypto to fiat that these processor handle for their customers. There are ways to handle this step without a third party (P2P exchanges are one). Less convenient for sure, but ultimately if you care about your economical freedom you will adopt them... or you will live in a walled garden, at least as long as your activity fits the current agenda/policies of these intermediaries (and your government). As soon as you don't, you get kicked out/cut from the system, even if your activity is not illegal.
- soerxpso 4y agoHe's making a point about actual cryptocurrency and smart contracts, and you're trying to refute it by pointing out that the good qualities of crypto do not apply to a random private firm that happened to slap the word "crypto" on its elevator pitch. Many such cases! Someone explains that it's healthy to eat vegetables sometimes, and you respond, "Actually, yesterday I ate a pound of deep-fried broccoli covered in pure corn syrup, and I got diarrhea afterward."
- 4y ago
- SilasX 4y agoI thought it was the law[1] that put them on the hook for any sex trafficking that's facilitated by said payment processing, not moral judgments? [1] FOSTA/SESTA https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=FOSTA-SESTA&useskin=vector https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=FOSTA-SESTA&usesk...
- stuckinhell 4y agoI don't like this trend of financial providers issuing moral judgement, de-banking people, and more either. I'm pro-BLM but learning Silicon Valley Bank gave BLM millions of dollars before it collapsed rubs me the wrong way. I need my banks and financial institutions to do their primary job first and foremost. I'm getting to the point where DIE marketing is become a signal of poor upper management trying to hide failures.
- yokem55 4y agoThere is an interesting investigation into that claim written up on Talking Points Memo - https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/a-quick-look-at-the-lying-trumpist-liars-behind-that-database-on-corprate-giving-to-blm https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/a-quick-look-at-the-lyi... Basically the Claremont Institute tallied up announcements of corporate charity that went to anything related to racial minorities, and called that "giving to BLM and supporting riots."
- stuckinhell 4y agoThe core point still stands, why are they giving ANY money to charity at all ?
- yokem55 4y agoWhy does anyone give money to charity? Usually because they want to support the cause.
- stuckinhell 4y agoGiving money to charity while your business fails doesn't make sense
- zhte415 4y agohttps://www.marketwatch.com/story/no-silicon-valley-bank-did-not-donate-more-than-73-million-to-black-lives-matter-95e08b3 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/no-silicon-valley-bank-did...
- cvalka 4y agoWhat broker was that?
- bitwize 4y ago> Financial providers shouldn't be issuing moral judgements. This isn't a moral judgement so much as it is an attempt to avoid association with high fraud risk transactions, which lead to more chargebacks, potential implication of the bank in criminal activity (e.g., money laundering), and greater government scrutiny under initiatives like Obama's Operation Choke Point.
- flangola7 4y agohttps://i.redd.it/wrm9icqvgzja1.jpg https://i.redd.it/wrm9icqvgzja1.jpg A large segment of the population unfortunately have extremely distorted moral compasses, and a disproportionate number of them likely work in conservative industries such as finance. Americans on average consider pornographic actors to be more immoral than lobbyists, spies, and lawyers, and second only to politicians. I'm not surprised at this chart but it really depresses my spirits.
- closeparen 4y agoYou’ll have a hard time establishing a right to financial plumbing for illegal activity. Denial of financial services is a pretty good crime-fighting tool, in that it both scales better and avoids the violence of policing/incarceration.
- mrguyorama 4y agoAlternate take: Companies should have every right to not do business with people they find morally repugnant, but only in industries where there is a "service of last resort". I wouldn't care about visa kicking out perfectly legitimate sex work if they could sign up on, say, the post office's website for a bank account and some basic payment system.
- cykros 4y agoThey sold them without your consent? In a cash account? Or margin (and not fully paid)? If the former, I'd be personally looking into recourse, or at least reading any agreements you have on file, because nothing about that sounds remotely above board (though brokerages are known for staying pretty on top of regulations with pretty sizeable legal teams). Asking that you transfer it off the platform is one thing; selling something you custody with them without your permission, on the other hand, exposes you to market risk and ultimately sounds like it's in violation of at least a few rules, given they've not been given discretionary authority in the account. Some industries get to get away with making a lot of their own decisions there and just shooting themselves in the foot if they feel like it, but with the thick regulations in the capital markets, this sounds like an overreach. They can kick YOU off the platform, but even when doing that, they typically need to leave your securities alone in an account that you still get to choose when to sell.