4 ms·
A mirror that reverses how light travels in time
- greenhearth 4y agoThe phenomenon in the article still seems like a kind of reflection, but I wonder if a time crystal with quantum size facets would mess with light's actual space/time dynamics.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wheaties 4y agoThis is how the effects of Magnetorheological fluids work with sound and vibrational damping. Glad to see they have figured out a corrolary with EM waves.
- 1attice 4y agoUsage suggestion: can we please call this material a 'turnstile'? "All I have for you is a gesture, in combination with a word. Tenet. Use it carefully. It'll open the right doors, but some of the wrong ones, too."
- cwillu 4y agoThat movie lost me when I realized someone had to pour the concrete with the bullet and bullet hole and cracks already in it, but the same doesn't happen when the bullet comes out of human flesh. I'm imagining the horrifying disease a child must have been born with, that legitimately cured by putting a time-reversed gun to its body and pulling the trigger.
- 1attice 4y agoI quite enjoyed the film, but you're absolutely correct: it falls apart when you think about it too clearly. All the same, it got folks thinking enough about physics (and time!) to notice that it falls apart! That's powerful. Sort of like how ChatGPT's confident hallucinations make everyone read everything more carefully. It's not the intended outcome, but I value it.
- chrisshroba 4y agoThe analogy of "if it was a spoken word, it would sound as if it was getting played backwards" was helpful, but I'm still struggling to understand what's happening here. Thinking of the audio analogy, I could imagine implementing that as a buffer you record into, and after some amount of time, you play back the buffer in reverse. Is that what's going on here?
- Shared404 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35263734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35263734 helped explain it for me.
- timwis 4y agoSounds really interesting, but I'm struggling to imagine the implications of this. Can anyone expound on it?
- kiviuq 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gAy39ErqV34 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gAy39ErqV34
- karmakaze 4y agoI thought we already had phase-conjugate mirrors for EM? Is this not the case? "Real Genius" (1985) mentions a tracking system using one. Or rather how is this different than a phase-conjugate mirror?
- achr2 4y agoIt's hard to read between the aggrandized lines, but it appears that this is a discrete phenomenon based on precisely switched gates/reflectors. It's super interesting but not exactly science fiction. Imagine your signal looks like _A_B_C_ where each letter represents a discrete subpacket. The reflectors look like _1_2_3_. As long as those gates are timed to turn on precisely between the subpackets, the reflected signal would be the reverse order of packets.
- ouid 4y agoWe could already make light "slow", and then we can move our eyeballs faster than the light, hitting photons in the reverse of the order they were emitted in. It certainly isn't "time reversed light", it's a time reversed signal. I didn't RTFA though.
- tomxor 4y agoThe title is very click batey. It doesn't reverse how light travels in time, it just reverses light in terms of the order of photons, as in "Last in First out" instead of "First in First out". The concept is quite natural to grasp. The article makes it harder to understand than necessary by making it sound like science fiction. The "reflector" is actually a medium that encompass the entire signal being reversed... in the same way that you would need to buffer the entire segment of a signal in memory before reversing it (you can't send what you haven't yet received), you would also need the entire segment of light to be travelling through the medium at the same time in order to reverse it. This is why their experiment involves such long sections of material. It's an interesting and useful phenomenon, effectively being able to instantly change a material's properties to reverse the direction of photons currently passing through it, which probably has good application in signal processing performance (it would be comparable to hardware signal processing using electrical components). But "time" is not reversed; the direction of photon's currently traversing a medium is dynamically reversed, but unlike a reflective surface, a reflective medium could change the direction of multiple photons simultaneously instead of one at a time, which affects the order of that segment..
- nobodyandproud 4y agoSo photons would effectively be reflected back in a LIFO manner rather than FIFO? If so, thank you for the translation.
- tomxor 4y agoYes, exactly, I came to the same realisation that was an appropriate label and made an edit to describe it as such. In fact comparing it to FIFO as you have makes even more sense so I've edited it again. Surface reflections are FIFO, because there is no medium, no "storage"; This novel medium based reflection is LIFO, based upon whatever is traversing the medium at the time of the change to the medium. It's not magic, but it's an interesting way to achieve this in pure photonics, without first converting to something more manageable like electronics... it also doesn't require discrete memory like electronics, it's kind of analogue processing but with a buffer? but can only support analogue processing.
- mcdonje 4y ago>When a light wave enters the new time interface and the device changes its optical properties, the signal keeps moving forward in space. However, the signal gets reversed—if it was a spoken word, it would sound as if it was getting played backwards. In contrast, with a conventional reflection, a light or sound wave would travel back at its source but mostly look or sound the same as it did before So it's reflecting in a novel way. It's not sending information into the past. The headline gave me the wrong impression. Relativity lives. Time travel doesn't exist.
- IshKebab 4y agoIn fairness this technique is called time reversal because it is equivalent to playing back the waves but with the time axis reversed. (I assume that's it anyway - that's what you do in acoustics.) I agree the headline is misleading though. It doesn't affect how light travels in time.
- greenhearth 4y agoThis. I really thought light was literally going back in time, not getting rewound like a cassette tape.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nonrandomstring 4y agoI discovered this effect in mirrors in bright hotel bathrooms. They somehow distort time by inacurately making me look older. They need to fix that.
- cyclotron3k 4y agoDo you want to release the Shrike? Because this is how you release the Shrike.
- simple10 4y agoOh hell yes. About time someone references Hyperion.
- peter_d_sherman 4y agoDisclaimer: I don't know if anything said in the article is true -- or not... I do know that the article is interesting however... Here's the thing -- I notice that a lot of posters are using the words "forward" and "backward" with respect to time, with respect to waves... Here is my problem with those words, used in this context: If you are one of the posters who used the words "forward" or "backward" in your posts -- I ask you to first consider a simple Sine Wave (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sine_wave https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sine_wave). OK, now if you used the words "forward" and/or "backward" in your post -- please explain to me the following: Does a simple, periodic Sine Wave -- go "forwards" through time -- or "backwards"? ? Forwards or backwards? ? Note that I'm NOT asking about a complex information-carrying radio signal as might be emitted by a radio station or other source -- I'm asking about the simplest of simple Sine Waves -- as might be output by a frequency generator, pendulum, or other simple pure sine wave generating device... So, is that wave moving forwards or backwards? ? Or more specifically forwards or backwards -- in Time? ? Forwards or backwards? ?