8 ms·
Swiss Are on the Hook for $13,500 Each on Credit Suisse Bailout
- mpweiher 4y ago"Taxpayer exposure amounts to 109 billion Swiss francs " (Though that maximum is unlikely to be hit) In the meantime, top managers extracted 32 billion in bonuses over the last 10 years. Privatise profits, socialise losses. UPDATE: My mind still boggles at the scale of the looting. 32 billion in bonuses. If that's a thousand "top managers" that would still a jaw-dropping and life-changing 32 million per person. If it's a hundred "top managers", then it's a mind-numbing 320 million per person Let's go with the lower payout figure: 32 million would still be an insane amount even as the top payout for the singlemost important person, let's say the CEO, iff the company had been immensely profitable during that time and there had been significant personal risk. But the company wasn't profitable, there was no personal risk, and it wasn't a payout of that scale for the top one person, but for the top thousand or so (or whatever the number is, I don't know how many top managers there were...but if there were fewer top managers, the relative amount of the payout just gets larger). UPDATE 2: Source (German) "Denn was ist mit den verantwortlichen Top-Managern der Credit Suisse? Die, so hat es der "Tagesanzeiger" aus Zürich ausgerechnet, seit 2013 32 Milliarden Franken an Boni kassierten, während die Bank im gleichen Zeitraum 3,2 Milliarden Verlust machte." https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/weltwirtschaft/credit-suisse-ubs-kommentar-101.html https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/weltwirtschaft/credit-s...
- floucky 4y ago"Privatise profits, socialise losses" > Wow, this sentence is so eye-opening.
- _vbnz 4y agoIt reminds me of The Ragged Trousered Philanthropists where the capitalists conspire to make the local government purchase their failing electric company (written in 1910): 'Something will 'ave to be done, and that very soon,' Grinder was saying. 'We can't go on much longer as we're doing at present. For my part, I think the best thing to do is to chuck up the sponge at once; the company is practically bankrupt now, and the longer we waits the worser it will be.' [...] 'Sell out!' replied Grinder with a contemptuous laugh in which the others joined. 'Who's going to buy the shares of a concern that's practically bankrupt and never paid a dividend?' 'Who's to buy?' repeated Sweater, replying to Grinder. 'The municipality of course! The ratepayers. Why shouldn't Mugsborough go in for Socialism as well as other towns?' [...] 'Afterwards,' resumed Sweater, 'I'll arrange for a good report of the meeting to appear in the Weekly Ananias. I'll instruct the Editor to write it himself, and I'll tell him just what to say. I'll also get him to write a leading article about it, saying that electricity is sure to supersede gas for lighting purposes in the very near future. Then the article will go on to refer to the huge profits made by the Gas Coy and to say how much better it would have been if the town had bought the gasworks years ago, so that those profits might have been used to reduce the rates, the same as has been done in other towns. Finally, the article will declare that it's a great pity that the Electric Light Supply should be in the hands of a private company, and to suggest that an effort be made to acquire it for the town. [...] 'Come to think of it,' observed Rushton arrogantly, 'why should we trouble ourselves about the opinion of the ratepayers at all? Why should we trouble to fake the books, or declare a dividend or 'ave the harticles in the papers or anything else? We've got the game in our own 'ands; we've got a majority in the Council, and, as Mr Sweater ses, very few people even take the trouble to read the reports of the meetings.' [...] 'Well, 'ere's success to Socialism,' cried Grinder, raising his glass, and taking a big drink.
- msm_ 4y agoI thought that "socialism" has negative connotations for me, as an eastern European. But clearly it's nothing compared to how hated this word was in the US in 1910s. Interesting quote, anyway! Wikipedia says that the novel is semi-autobiographical by the author.
- _vbnz 4y agoThe book is from Britain and written by a socialist - this section is about how they try to twist it to their benefit, making the government take over their failing business and then blame the later failure on "socialism". But yeah, the first Red Scare in the US was during the First World War. Look at how they treated Eugene Debs - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_V._Debs#Sedition_conviction_and_appeal_to_U.S._Supreme_Court https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_V._Debs#Sedition_convic... Freedom of speech... as long as you don't actually try it.
- fiftyacorn 4y agoIts more than "Privatise profits, socialise losses" Its the intrinsic arrogance that the profits are somehow due to the business prowess of these charlatans, while any losses are due to "the market"
- abccbabc 4y agoWhere's the source for the bonus figure only being top managers, doesn't seem to be in article? At a bank, everyone gets a bonus - it's a standard part of annual comp. You can see actual details of CS bonus sizes here - unsurprisingly it's considerably less that $32m each! https://www.fnlondon.com/articles/credit-suisse-hikes-pay-for-key-employees-to-1-4m-as-bonus-pool-shrinks-50-20230314 https://www.fnlondon.com/articles/credit-suisse-hikes-pay-fo...
- ssss11 4y agoWhile I wholeheartedly agree with your sentiment, I wonder about the estimated figures. What’s the staff size of CS - could it be 10,000 top managers. Or 1,000 top managers but over ten years becomes ~5,000 if turnover averages at every 2nd year. Despite investment bank bonuses being very high compared with other industries, 32mil is just too insane to believe!
- seanhunter 4y agoAs others have said, there are 40000-ish employees almost all of whom will have some sort of bonus provision in their compensation. That doesn't mean every year they get one, it doesn't mean everyone gets a big one. There will be a handfull of big swingers who get or expect tens of millions, but the vast majority of folks in an investment bank would get a bonus in the thousands or tens of thousands. It's typically anywhere from 20% of base to a couple of times base depending on how well the firm did as a whole, how much your team/division contributed to that and how good your own appraisal/performance was.
- mamonster 4y agoIt really isn't only managers. Basically any trader/IB person expects a bonus if the had a good year and they don't particularly care about the whole company's profit situation as long as they know they made money. People still don't really seem to be aware of the fact that in a big bank you can have 5-6 people outside of management positions earning more than some of the C level employees. Example: You have a credit trading desk and an equity trading desk. Your equity trading desk makes 1 billion, your credit desk loses 2 billion. Sure, you lose 1 billion in total, but you still pay the equity desk the bonus on the 1 billion profit.
- fabian2k 4y agoAnd those bonuses have been criticized in the past as well, and might get even more scrutiny now again. I'm not particularly convinced by the arguments for the necessity of these bonuses (at least not at this magnitude). If you pay me to gamble in the casino with my employer's money, and I get a bonus when I win and only my base salary when I lose, that doesn't seem to make much sense.
- mamonster 4y agoWell, the catch is that most people who blow up will never again smell a high paying job in finance. It's not like 9/10 of the people who blow up just restart the casino at another firm, they simply never see the trading floor again except for what they do in their personal account.
- expertentipp 4y ago> they simply never see the trading floor again Who maintains this blacklist, is there a way to preview it?
- SvenL 4y agoI think the normal process is to check the cv and ask any previous employer about performance.
- phphphphp 4y agobonuses are to banks what stock is to tech startups. A bonus is a part of total compensation.
- blitzar 4y agoStripe is raising $3.5 billion to help pay the tax (tax rate 22%?) on (some of) the bonuses of its employees from the last 13 years. In no year has Stripe ever made a profit. For comparision in 2019 Stripe had 4,000 employees, Credit Suisse 50,000. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-06/stripe-details-3-5-billion-tax-bill-in-latest-fundraising-round https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-06/stripe-de... Prev: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35058846 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35058846
- zorked 4y ago> In no year has Stripe ever made a profit. This doesn't mean that a bonus structure isn't appropriate. Bonus are supposed to be an incentive. Achieve bold goals -> get bonus. If anything this is more important in growing companies than in stable, profitable companies, which have achieved a sustaining business model. Why pay a bonus to people just following the algorithm. No judgement on Stripe's specifics.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mirashii 4y ago> on the bonuses of its employees from the last 13 years. It feels like this is misrepresenting the situation quite a bit. This is not a tax bill on bonuses. This is a tax bill on equity, which is a part of the regular compensation package, and an awkward situation due to that equity being illiquid as Stripe has not gone public.
- mpweiher 4y agoStripe is not guaranteed by the taxpayer and not holding on to other people's (deposit) money. Banks are different. One of the greatest coups of lobbying was when the finance industry convinced politicians all over the world that banking ist just like any other industry and thus should not be regulated more than other industries.
- 4y ago
- kingstoned 4y agoPhilip Greenspun wrote about how looting public corporations in modern societies is the equivalent to kleptocracy in the 3rd world: https://philip.greenspun.com/politics/israel/ https://philip.greenspun.com/politics/israel/
- blitzar 4y agoWhere are the losses? What are the impaired investments? Why were they not there in the regulator approved, big 4 audited accounts from 3 months ago?
- misja111 4y agoCS complied with all regulations, even in the weeks before the bail out. The problem was that customers lost trust in CS and in particular its management and were withdrawing all their deposits.
- blitzar 4y agoThey didnt have hold-to-maturity losses like SVB - loss of deposits was just loss of (future) revenue.
- _0w8t 4y agoWhich pointed out that regulating the banks is mostly pointless. They always find loopholes. The only sensible regulation is to make sure that banks never gets too big to fail. This way a bankruptcy will be mostly inconsequential even if the government insures deposits.
- blitzar 4y agoI think this is my point - If Credit Suisse went bust, it is the biggest regulatory failure in banking. The regulations in switzerland are no different to any other bank in the world, likely they were more stringent requirements to hold larger quantities of capital and mark-to-market more instruments on their balance sheet. > make sure that banks never gets too big to fail Well the regulators just took two too-big-to-fail banks and merged them ...
- mpweiher 4y agoBanking used to be very heavily regulated. With good reason. During the early 80s (neoliberalism, Reagan, Thatcher, Kohl, etc.) regulations were relaxed and banking deregulated. The first big bank crisis + bailout (Savings and Loan crisis) followed a year later. Banking is not a regular industry, for a bunch of reasons.
- _vbnz 4y agoStuff like this will lead to the rise of socialism again tbh. It's like Tucker Carlson said - it's no wonder that the young people support socialism, when they can't afford a house and face massive economic uncertainty even in professional fields, etc. Everyone knows that the super-rich executives will benefit massively from this (or have already taken huge bonuses and dividends in prior years), and they basically run the government and will face no consequences. They get rewarded for failure, meanwhile normal working people face mass lay-offs, high interest rates and high inflation.
- dachryn 4y agothe execs definitely miss out on a lot of money because bonus programs are typically multi year. There are always -short term (how did we do this year, the classic everyone gets) -long term (bonus defined today, paid out over a few years if you meet the strategic goals, typically director and exec level, we are easily talking 100k+/year here in bonus money) bonusses. So, yeah, still a financial letdown for them. But they still got paid quite a lot of money of course. The average swiss person had no stakes or no culpability at all (except maybe choosing them, clients could have walkd away)
- cableshaft 4y agoBut they've already made out like bandits in the meantime, and can move on to the next company to raid (I mean, be an executive of). Like you can make $5 million a year now, but have things suddenly end on you at some point when things come crashing down, but probably not for several years, or you can make $1 million a year, but play it safe, and in five years get a $7 million long-term bonus. Might as well get as much out of the company now and trust the government will bail you out (or not, what do they care, they can just move on to the next thing, and even if not, they've already made a shit ton of money, they could just retire, no big deal).
- handsclean 4y agoIn my country it’s not illegal when you punch somebody in the face, but we have another deterrent that works very well. If you punch somebody in the face, then he pulls out his wallet and gives you $50, then presents his face for you to punch again if you’d like. Once you stop punching, he gives you $100. So you see, assailants quickly learn that face punching is an action of grave consequence and loss, and the fact that everybody here is punching each other in the face all the time is probably because of something else.
- expertentipp 4y agoWell it finally trickled down. Everyone gets minus $13,500.
- agilob 4y agohttps://archive.is/w0KGu https://archive.is/w0KGu
- clbrmbr 4y agoSwitzerland has a direct democracy. If 100k people sign a petition, an initiative (bill) goes to a popular vote. If this move turns out to be highly unpopular, it may be dismantled by the people.
- expertentipp 4y agoEvery democracy is toothless when people from the yachts join the game. Every.
- v4dok 4y agoYou would be surprized how well direct democracy works in Switzerland. Proper political culture and a fairly good standard of living is the trick. The same trick Athens used back then.
- expertentipp 4y agoYes of course, sir/madam.. but a penthouse overlooking the lake, and a German limousine - would that make you rethink this at least?
- dwattttt 4y agoYou're going to rapidly run out of limousines and lakeside penthouses if you need to persuade a majority of the Swiss
- expertentipp 4y agoOnce we run out of German maybe Austrian limousine, sir? We have enough for you and your entire family. I know the people will talk, but we're discreet and provide it with a driver - for life.
- v4dok 4y agoYou've clearly never been to Switzerland. If that worked (which it wouldn't), you would have better luck with bikes.
- petesergeant 4y ago> financial experts cautioned that there’s little chance the final price tag will reach the limits set by the government right, but had you led with that, nobody would click
- spaceman_2020 4y agoWhy have we collectively decided that Big Banks and Big Pharma can keep getting away with awful behavior?
- droopyEyelids 4y agoBig banks, big pharma, and others are -the powerful-, and the powerful can do whatever they want, unless someone else has the power to stop them.
- brigandish 4y agoWe haven't, if you have money you can put your own people or people you have influence over/with into positions of authority, or help get, shall we say friendly legislators elected who help set the regulatory frameworks. You could influence news media by advertising with them and threatening to pull your advertising if they criticise or investigate you. You can bully governments by threatening to move your offices and factories abroad. There's so much that giant companies can do. Ordinary folk only have their word of mouth, their wallets, and their votes. We saw how the rise of the internet gave these people power and things started to change, and so the word of mouth power was taken away through the actions of social media companies, which then affects how people use their wallets and their votes. Once again, freedom of speech turns out to be the most important freedom in a democracy.
- pjkundert 4y agoI guess they should have voted for the Vollgelt Initiative in 2018: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_Swiss_sovereign-money_initiative https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_Swiss_sovereign-money_i... But, Credit Suisse said it was a bad idea, and apparently the people believed them.
- exabrial 4y agoPlease don't do the same thing in America and this ridiculous invented student debt "Crisis"
- iudqnolq 4y agoForgiving student debt is a standard use of public funds to benefit a wide swath of society. That's clearly different from bailing out a bank.
- throwayyy479087 4y ago"Giving the upper middle class money" is the outcome of both. It's exactly the same, you just support one and not the other.
- iudqnolq 4y ago40% of student debtors never managed to graduate
- klyrs 4y agoStudent debt is a mini-bailout for millions of mostly lower and middle class people. The Swiss bailout here is for dozens of stupendously rich people.
- jones6ofMont 4y ago[flagged]
- come_at_me_bro 4y agocentral bank digital currencies are the biggest crypto scam ever
- dang 4y agoAbusing HN like this will get your main account banned as well, so please don't.
- come_at_me_bro 4y ago[dead]
- freddealmeida 4y agoI would burn the politicians at the stake but when looking at what I have to pay, I'm surprised I don't burn our politicians at the stake.