5 ms·
I usually hate dumping on Show HNs, but given the societal impacts of this, I feel the need to be blunt. Call me old fashioned, call me a luddite, whatever, but
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I usually hate dumping on Show HNs, but given the societal impacts of this, I feel the need to be blunt. Call me old fashioned, call me a luddite, whatever, but I hate this.
So now even our profile pictures aren't really us, but just some pseudo-reality version of who we think we are. And I know I know, people will argue that makeup/airbrushing/photoshop/facetune has been going on forever, but at some point I feel like we cross the line where it's no longer "reality with some touchups", but instead it's "complete fantasy made to mimic reality".
I just feel like AI is shooting us head first down this state where reality and fantasy are evermore difficult to differentiate, and I don't like the implications.
- insanitybit 4y agoSounds great tbh, reality fucking sucks and maybe fantasy won't be such a fundamentally broken shit show. Here's hoping.
- kube-system 4y agoThe idea that "reality sucks" implies a comparison to a fantasy world. If the fantasy world gets better, and reality stays the same, any relative perception that "reality sucks" will get worse. If you compare reality today to reality at any other time, reality is pretty great.
- insanitybit 4y agoIt does not imply that. Reality can suck irrespective of all other things.
- 000ooo000 4y agoAnother step closer to The Great Logging Off.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoAmen. I've been having a growing sense of an existential crisis over the past few months, and while a lot of it is due to the general fear of "will AI put me out of a job in the next 5 years", more of it has to do with fact that I'm just uneasy about where tech is headed. I spent my entire career diving head first into technology, and for the first half of it I was supremely optimistic about it. Things have obviously soured over the past decade as I've seen the negative impacts the internet has on our public discourse, mental health (including my own), etc. But now, seeing what AI has on the horizon, I'm honestly just like "I need to go for a fucking walk, upon which I will throw my phone into the river."
- 000ooo000 4y agoVery relatable. Also feeling the dread re. AI, but more so because I really enjoy programming and have no other marketable skills (and I have no interest in retraining). I think it's a decade or two away but I can see programming as a job changing so much as to be uninteresting to me. Hell, Agile has made it barely tolerable now. I'm also almost done with the web. I remember listening to the dialup modem with excitement, browsing the web, downloading things and just being generally enthralled with everything the web had to offer. Now it feels like a mall with 3 chain stores in it. Being mostly a web dev, I'm in a kind of weird spot mentally about what I do with 80%+ of my time (i.e. program for the web, browse the web).
- carapace 4y agoSame here. The kind of programming I love to do is now a hobby only. (It's a good thing, I think, because the machines will write bug-free code, but I'm wistful. And the money sure was nice!) I'm going to build toy computers for people like us who just like computers (something like Nand-to-Tetris, eh? Or Ben Eater's great kits.) but I'm not kidding myself that that's going to make a lot of money (not like programming used to.)
- tetris11 4y agoI dont mind my job being replaced due to AI, I mind that I won't be able to pay my bills because of the replacement. i.e. I'm not worried about AI, I'm worried about how capitalism will weild it against me.
- sdwr 4y agoIt turns into a "noob trap", where people (at first) see a bunch of perfect profiles and get discouraged, only finding the cracks in the facade if they stick around.
- peteralaoui 4y agoWhat if the cracks were imperceptible in the next iteration or two? Would you still say it's a noob trap? _Genuinely interested in your feedback_
- sdwr 4y agoThe authenticity cycle, as I understand it, goes: - honest signal (good-looking profile pics!) - the signal starts becoming cheaper to create (AI filters) - users of the signal look for subtler signs of authenticity (technical cues like blur around the edges, overly-softened features, lighting is wrong, or social cues like profile information doesn't match quality of image) - signal becomes effortless to fake, information content is wiped out entirely - retreat to authenticity / burn everything down and start over in a new game There's tons of value to be had in that middle area, where people assume the honest signal but it becomes possible to fake. That's what TV, for example, is all about. Take regular people, add white teeth, makeup, and flattering angles, and they become 10x as compelling as Joe from down the street (without having to be 10x as good!). And this is all armchair philosophy, parroting stuff from ACX and Ribbonfarm. The product concept itself is fantastic (if it works!), and I'm sure tons of people will pay for it. I think most users will want to slip under the radar, and have it not be obvious that they're using the service.
- braingenious 4y agoI agree with all of this. Further… I think this is much more akin to those silly “make an anime avatar of yourself” apps than anything remotely resembling a headshot taken by a photographer. For example, there is an example of a woman with medium length brown hair and the example “headshots” are… not good. It looks like her eye color is different in every picture, the black and white example looks kind of rotoscoped, and the example in the rotation immediately after the black and white has incredibly messed up eyes. One of her irises is all wonky and non-human looking. It’s a great example of why it’s important for a human to supervise and correct SD generated things like faces.
- shtack 4y agoProfessional headshots have been both taken under unrealistic conditions and heavily edited for a long time. This is true for most selfies nowadays too. This doesn’t seem significantly different to me.
- peteralaoui 4y agoIt's not the first time that I hear that, thanks for your radical candor :) and to be frank too, I was also sharing that feeling of a fantasy made to mimic reality when I started this project. It all started when we started to argue with my family members on which avatars looked more like me. It made me realize that we were much more sensitive than I thought about our self-image. Me and my partner would pick different pictures in a set of 10 samples ^^ as if we had two slightly different perceptions of reality. Now, I changed my mind slightly and tend to see these models as an another type of compression of information. Almost like a new censor of data.
- xupybd 4y agoI'd love a version of this tool that alters my face enough to avoid it being useful for facial recognition. I don't really want to publish my face on linked in and other sites as I'm not keen on it getting indexed in some future facial recognition tool.
- peteralaoui 4y ago@xupybd, cool idea, it could maybe capture the essence of you while still injecting some perturbations into the final rendering to break facial recognition. If you want to experiment thatwith your photos I'm available on DM: twitter.com/_dulacp
- dr_kiszonka 4y agoI really like your point about compression. I have never thought about it this way. BTW, I am curious how much storage the "essence" of one's face take in relation to the ten images required by your service?
- flippinburgers 4y agoNo doubt there is that ... and, oh yeah, the money.
- kadoban 4y agoNothing is really us. We're wearing masks all day, every day. This stuff just lets us have more control and more fun with the masks we get for online use. Who cares if it's fantasy? We crossed that line _long_ ago with the examples you already brought up. The only difference is that this is new.
- jhanschoo 4y agoFor jobs for which your appearance has no bearing on your value, I don't think anyone should care.
- dwringer 4y agoI've been using an AI generated profile image which looks maybe 90% like me for quite a while in some places. I can't think of any obvious negative impacts. I've been totally upfront about it with my friends, but nobody's ever even mentioned it otherwise. People have made their profile pictures a "pseudo-reality version" of who they think they are since the dawn of profile pictures IMHO.
- grugagag 4y agoThe negative impact is the shock and horror on people’s faces when seeing the subject in person after having interacted with the avatar for some time. Some people may call that positive impact though
- unixfg 4y agoThat happens with any self-selected picture already. Angles, lighting, a good night’s sleep…
- xnorswap 4y agoThere's a negative externality of "punishing" anyone not engaging in this AI faux-reality and as with fashion magazines, altering the perception of what people should look like, leading to psychological damage when we don't live up to the expectation.
- salad-tycoon 4y agoAlternative view, the heavy handed photoshopping was more impactful because it was labor intensive, costs money and not too common for the majority of photos. Now that everyone can get the super model magazine cover photo treatment our minds will build a callus. No longer will photographs be evidence or aspirational but just a representation of a projected reality. After you see a magic trick a couple of times that awe and shock wears off quickly. Photo and video’s honeymoon is over.
- op00to 4y agoIf I am forced to use a picture, I use one from 20 years ago. :)
- hl00tb 4y agoWhat is even reality, and how do you even define real? We wear special clothes on special occasions, is that fake? because we don't wear those clothes normally. Why waste time and money on "real" professional head-shots when we can get them done for much cheaper price.
- jamesdhutton 4y agoI do understand the sentiment. I think it might be better if it was framed more as a touch-up service, like this: take a headshot of your own, against a neutral background. We will touch it up so that the lighting looks good, the background is good, etc. But it's just a touch up -- we won't fundamentally alter the shot.
- barrell 4y agoI get the concern here, and emotionally I share it. Half of my contacts now have very strange AI avatars as their profile pictures and I still recoil a little every time I see them (the avatars). I think it's a slippery slope and I don't like where it seems to be going. However, rationally, it's not like humanity has had picture perfect representations of themselves for very long. For most of our evolution, we relied on paintings & sculptures, which it was up to the artist (or the commissioner) to decide on how 'real' they were, and they were almost always "complete fantasy made to mimic reality". From this lens, the use of unedited real photos of you was the strange period of time, not this AI age we seem to be headed into. Maybe that helps put your mind a little at ease, maybe it just confuses you more (definitely the latter for me)
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoMy primary point is that I think it's fine to use an obviously generated "cartoon image" as an avatar, but what I think is dangerous is when reality and fantasy blur so much that people (including, especially, the subjects themselves!) get lost with respect to which is which. It's a similar concern to the updated TikTok "makeup filter" that made the rounds recently, which basically is extremely difficult to detect as a filter. I thought especially poignant was a photographer who was saying she gets these beautiful women in to do portraits, and then when they look behind the camera to view their untouched portraits, they're aghast at how "ugly" they are, because the "filtered" version of themselves has started competing with the real version in their own head. This shit just fucks with everyone's brain long term, in an unhelpful way, in my opinion.
- HTTP418 4y agoYou realize what you described isn't a new phenomena. Paintings that were done followed a similar principle but often even more extreme. Men would make themselves look taller, hide physical deformities, etc... They would imagine themselves being greater than they actually are.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
- tekbog 4y agoI have similar thoughts, and wrote an article called "death of reality"[0] (a bit dramatic I know). More and more of our identity is on the cyber space however all the tools allow more and more fakeness so we just make our own "digital persona", I don't think people are talking about this or noticing it enough. The last straw was with Samsung, unbelievable. [0]https://bogdannovykov.substack.com/p/death-of-reality https://bogdannovykov.substack.com/p/death-of-reality
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoMy counterpoint is that people who make judgements about the professionalism of candidates based on their Linked In headshot deserve to be duped.
- nativespecies 4y agoIs it really that different from an avatar if we reach a point where we all recognize them as avatars? Seems like the danger is in not knowing where the line is between "real" and "tuned" - the more tuned, the easier that line is to see. I don't think this is really that different than people Photoshopping their photos - it's been a plague for dating apps for like, what, two decades?
- seydor 4y agoRelax, it will blow over. It started from twitter, soon these AI pics will look cringe (they already are imho) and people will be shunned for them
- barking_biscuit 4y agoMeh. You just run a genetic algorithm which adjusts the hyperparameters used to train the model, so that it's constantly being updated to pass as real.
- tippytippytango 4y agoAs long as someone seeing only my AI headshot can still recognize me for a first time coffee meeting, then the photo passes the reality test for me.
- dolmen 4y agoThat's not more wrong than people who keep a 10 years old picture as their profile picture.
- cyrialize 4y agoI feel this. I'm lucky I got a free professional headshot at a conference I went to a while back. I like it much more than the AI generated look.
- Nadya 4y agoMy profile picture has never once been me. When I see other people's profile pictures - the time it is them it is often a heavily edited photograph - either professional or through the use of app filters or digital editing software. The pictures that people present of themselves so rarely are representative of what they look like in normal situations and day-to-day life. I am completely unphased by this. Then again, my profile picture for the longest time was a picture of three pairs of thigh high socks. So maybe I don't give the same weight to someone's profile picture or chosen avatar as other people seem to do.
- op00to 4y agoI use a drawing of myself as my “head shot”. Doesn’t get more fantasy than that. It’s not really me, it’s a drawing. The Wall Street Journal has used “not-them” drawings as profile pictures forever.
- solarkraft 4y agoPhotos are just some pseudo-reality version of who we think we are, even without filters. You choose the angle, the lighting, whatever, all with a specific goal in representing yourself. Oh, you also add choosing the clothes, the hair style and your posture/facial expression to the mix. It (the genre of image we're talking about)'s all unnatural and meant to portray people in a light somebody wants to portray them in. In fact that's most of "photography" is.
- tomjen3 4y agoJust so that we all understand what photoshop can do: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-lblzHvKhRc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-lblzHvKhRc It does look a little plastique, but it is also (deliberately an extreme case).