9 ms·
> Like many companies, our business has been impacted by the current macroeconomic environment, and user and revenue growth has not kept pace with our expectati
by ryandrake 4y ago
> Like many companies, our business has been impacted by the current macroeconomic environment, and user and revenue growth has not kept pace with our expectations. In order to run our business sustainably, we’ve made the very difficult decision to shrink the size of our workforce.
Let's just take a moment to admire this paragraph.
> "our business has been impacted by the current macroeconomic environment"
There's that passive, vague non-word again: "impacted". Such a milquetoast way to say "something happened" but without that pesky specificity.
> "user and revenue growth has not kept pace with our expectations"
So, they are growing, but not growing faster than some [arbitrary] goal?
> "In order to run our business sustainably"
Wait, I thought revenue was growing! How is that not sustainable? If you just leave costs where they are and let revenue grow, you are by definition sustaining/growing the bottom line.
> "we’ve made the very difficult decision to shrink the size of our workforce"
This is what I don't get about all of these layoff letters. It's always the same thing: We're growing, our revenue is growing, and [usually unsaid] our costs are growing. So why not just arrest the cost growth? Stop the bleeding, don't start amputating limbs. I can understand layoffs when your business is running at a loss, not when it's growing.
- arrty88 4y agoThey were staffed for 10x and only seeing 2x. Probably shutting down a lot of growth projects that aren’t showing promise.
- misssocrates 4y ago"Those who thought it was free money are now discovering that they have to pay for it retrospectively." -Nassim Taleb
- _alex_ 4y agoZero growth or negative growth (real or nominal) are both cases that not keep pace with expectations. What about that paragraph makes you think things are gangbusters but they have to lay people off?
- throw8383833jj 4y agoJack welsh school of management: you've got to reward the top 20% and layoff the bottom 10%, about once a year. this is very much possible when there's an oversupply of labor.
- calderknight 4y agoI think the companies have employees to try to make more money. When things are going really well in the economy it's easy for employees to create/capture lots of value, so the companies hire lots of employees to do that. But when the economy slows down a bit, suddenly it's a lot more difficult for employees to create value, so it doesn't make sense not to reduce the number of employees.
- onlypositive 4y agoYup, this is basically it. My team at work hasn't created any meaningful value in a year. We've shipped nonstop but the things were tasked to work on just don't work out or even if they are well received simply don't add up to our salaries.
- dehrmann 4y agoThis is going to get a lot of hate, but the common refrain about WFH is "my productivity is up." That might be true, but it doesn't mean you're producing the right things, and I've found that harder to do remotely.
- smohare 4y ago[dead]
- Supermancho 4y agoNo hate at all. The vast majority don't control what they are told to do. WFH has nothing to do with it.
- bart_spoon 4y agoWhat does this have to do with WFH? The point is that teams are tasked with meaningless projects, which they deliver on, but because the project was meaningless, they get axed for not producing value. They were doomed from the start, due to the strategic initiatives management mistakenly decided they should work on. This is occurs for both WFH and in person work.
- klysm 4y agoBecause we’ve set up the incentive structures to make growth the most important thing. Shares increase when you grow - the revenue barely matters to the people in control
- hronic379 4y ago[flagged]
- tyingq 4y ago>I applaud twitch for providing more cash flow to all of us, via capital gains and/or dividends. That's only the math if the layoffs have zero "impact" on the product.
- argiopetech 4y agoThe problem is, you can't tell a priori what the impact will be. It could be positive. It certainly could free funds for future positive changes.
- tyingq 4y agoYes, agree. Of course, it could alternatively create a poor customer support experience. Driving a harried reaction like hiring outside help costing more than you saved and distracting the whole org, creating more undesired side effects.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tidepod12 4y agoLots of false equivalence here. > What cash back do you get on your credit card? 2.625%? High yield savings account? Money market fund? 4.6%? None of these actions by me directly result in the loss of livelihood or uprooting of lives of other people. If you told me that by moving my money to a high yield savings account, it would result in my friends or family members losing their jobs, you bet your ass I wouldn't do it, "personal profit" be damned, and that isn't a hard decision to make in the slightest. Twitch's leader are making a conscious decision: profits over people.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- varunjain99 4y agoWell, a company doesn't exist to just be profitable. But to maximize profits (mostly). So it's certainly possible that cutting costs - even when profitable - can increase short-term and long-term profitability.
- TylerE 4y agoI believe it short term. I’m not sure I’ve seen a large convincing example of it NOT causing a PR/customer/staff retention issue long term.
- ryandrake 4y agoSo why didn't they do it a year ago? Or two years ago, or three? It would have increased profitability at that time, too. How did dozens of already-profitable companies all suddenly decide together to cut costs within 6 months of each other? I wish they would be more specific than the "macroeconomic environment" excuse. I swear these CEOs are like soccer players running around the pitch, just waiting for Mister Macroeconomic Environment to run near them so they can dive, clutching their calves, crying "impacted! impacted!"
- sberens 4y ago> It would have increased profitability at that time, too. Not necessarily. The profit(headcount) function generally varies over time.
- wombatpm 4y agoAnd you can’t fire all of the engineers and replace them HR drones and expect to maintain the revenues and profits. Under you theory, companies should start laying off at the top and work down until the proper $/person metric is obtained
- kneebonian 4y agoThat is preposterous the big tech companies would never do anything like cullouding with one another to depress salaries and reduce expenses, that is absolutely insane and conspiracy minded, I mean they super swore pinky promised they wouldn't do it after that one time Google and Apple did.
- gotoeleven 4y agoYou would also be angry if they wrote "we fired our 400 worst employees because we decided they're not worth their salaries" which also happens to be exactly true. Up there with anti-whiteboard-interview screeds, the critique-the-tone-of-a-layoff-post comment is a mainstay of the hacker news comment thread: as tiresome as it is uninteresting.
- TylerE 4y agoSo what does that make a meta post twice over?
- gotoeleven 4y ago"Be the change you want to see in the world" -- Barack J. Obama
- lanza 4y ago> Wait, I thought revenue was growing! How is that not sustainable? If you just leave costs where they are and let revenue grow, you are by definition sustaining/growing the bottom line. Come on man, if you don't understand how a business can be showing signs of unhealthiness while still increasing revenue then don't post. That's such a trivial superficial analysis of reality. I'm not going to pretend to know or understand enough about Twitch's business to agree or disagree with whether they need layoffs. But a shallow comment of "revenue go up" is lowbrow nonsense.
- ilyt 4y agoOr, the investors want their returns. If you don't understand how perfectly healthy business can be gutted just because investors want better number on next year's sheets and don't care about long term then don't post.
- throwawayinvi 4y ago[flagged]
- dantheman 4y agoIf you look around most companies especially with the way hiring has been the last few years, layoffs != gutting.
- camhart 4y agoI just want to say, investors getting returns should be a goal of every for profit company (whos taken investor $$). Thats why investors risk their capital. That capital is responsible for the growth of most major tech companies. Its responsible for most jobs at tech companies. Not saying this is an excuse to treat employees poorly. They're just as vital as the capital (employee hours is often quite literally whats bought with the capital). But I get tired of hearing only poo poo being thrown on investors.
- yunohn 4y agoHaving money should not be worth more than doing the work. Same goes for landlords.
- misssocrates 4y agoWhy don't they just say what happened? "We got drunk on cheap money"
- sokoloff 4y agoOr "while the Fed had the punch bowl out, we drank heartily like everyone else; when they took it away, we grabbed out coat and headed home to sleep it off a while..."
- listenallyall 4y agoLeave costs where they are? Inflation likely causing many of their inputs to increase. Employees tend to want raises, bonuses and stock options. Health insurance basically always goes up. Customers demanding more features/quality (i.e. faster streams, 4k) while bandwidth/server costs rising. Marketing visibility often set via competitive bidding or auctions. They already reduced what they pay to their content creators late 2022. > I can understand layoffs when your business is running at a loss How do you know Twitch isn't? > This is what I don't get No, there's more.
- lakomen 4y ago> How do you know Twitch isn't? They wrote that they're profiting, in the initial post, just not as much as they'd like to. Profit isn't loss.
- listenallyall 4y ago> They wrote that they're profiting, in the initial post no, they didn't
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chatmasta 4y agoHere's a better version: > Everyone else is firing people. So it seemed like a good time to fire some people. > We found 400 people to fire, which sounded like a good number because it's not as big as 500. None of them seemed to be doing anything useful, so we fired them. > The product will not be affected and as a user you will notice no difference whatsoever. > Signed, some anonymous guy who took over after our CEO stepped down this week so you can't blame him for firing people.
- bottlepalm 4y ago> there’s a looot of employees here we don’t like. Instead of going through the whole PIP/HR dance we’ve decided to give every manager a blank check to fire a few of you. The whole ‘economy’ situation is a perfect cover to do this now. Adios.
- raydev 4y ago> we’ve decided to give every manager a blank check to fire a few of you This hasn't been common in a lot of recent layoffs. Low level managers aren't getting input, the decision comes from the top and it's random.
- vineyardmike 4y ago> the decision comes from the top and it's random As someone laid off from a FAANG, it's not random. They don't lay-off the top performer. They don't lay off the woman who keeps winning peer bonuses, or the one who plays golf with the VP, or the one doing cross-team knowledge sharing sessions. They're not laying off the guy that got an out-of-band pay increase because they're so valuable to the company. They may not use it as a PIP alternative, but it's not random. If you're an IC, you want your manager to be sharing documents with your name on it to the VP/Director. You want to be getting CC'ed in emergency product discussions. You want the senior leadership to know your name for a good thing. If your manager doesn't include you in meetings, and doesn't talk about your work, and doesn't make your presence known then your in trouble... when layoffs start and a director gets an excel spreadsheet with everyones name on, you want them to recognize your name. They're not axing the people they recognize first.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- justapassenger 4y ago> I can understand layoffs when your business is running at a loss, not when it's growing. Do you revisit your personal budget only once you run out of money, or once your income changes?
- machinawhite 4y agoDo you also employ people and managers and use your personal budget solely to make profit instead of buying food? Stop the weird analogies
- edanm 4y agoIt's not a weird analogy, it's a great analogy. Companies don't use their budget only for profit and not to "buy food", that's a ridiculous assertion. Companies get income, the use it to pay for all the operations that went into making that income, usually mostly salaries. Only what's left over is profit. And if a company sees that next year, when it expected income of 100m, it instead will only get 80m, that difference has got to affect it somehow.
- machinawhite 4y agoNope. Try again.
- ryandrake 4y agoI think we are confusing derivatives here. No, when my income is growing from year to year, but just growing a little slower, I don't revisit my personal budget. I think these company leaders are seeing the second (or third) derivative starting to go down, and are panicking without actually losing money (base measurement) or revenue (first derivative).
- shapefrog 4y agoYou gotta spend money to make money.
- bart_spoon 4y ago
- TeeMassive 4y agoThey're culling the less performant employees and use the current economic crisis as a PR excuse.
- dusted 4y agoI'm impressed that they even needed 400 people to run it in the first place ?
- jefozabuss 4y agoThere is a lot going on the back-end of these big streaming sites and also they have "support over 25 languages, in order to provide 24/7/365" so I'd guess it's in the thousand+ range.
- thenerdhead 4y agoEveryone is going through two things. Correcting irresponsible hiring over the last couple years, and a strategic inflection point. While the former has mostly happened, the latter is going to continue to happen until new business models are found. It is very common to see new CEOs at this time to “make things more contemporary” and with that is the redundancy of roles and even people who may not adapt to the new culture. Much of the business speak here is trying to say “we’re reducing our workforce to make room for new roles and new people who will match our new strategic direction”. Every company is confused internally and need strong leadership to get through it. Literally all ordinary rules of business go out the window and people are firing from the hip right now. Pun intended.
- PurpleRamen 4y ago> There's that passive, vague non-word again: "impacted". Such a milquetoast way to say "something happened" but without that pesky specificity. Well, everyone ion the business knows what's going on with twitch and the streaming-market at the moment. So no reason really to explain further I guess? > So, they are growing, but not growing faster than some [arbitrary] goal? Actually, in the last months they were shrinking. Partly because viewership around this time of the year is always shrinking for reasons, but this time even more, because pandemia inflated the market, and now as it's ending, the inflation also disappears. Overall, there is still growth compared to the time before the pandemia, but nobody really knows how it will hold until the end of the year. Additionally, the gaming-markted is being a wild mix at the moment, and most attempts of twitch to diversify their content have failed. So they are a bit clueless at the moment I guess how the ship will move and grow.
- Tsiklon 4y ago>> "user and revenue growth has not kept pace with our expectations" > So, they are growing, but not growing faster than some [arbitrary] goal? Actually the absence of a direction in this sentence is specifically vague language that allows the implication of, but not statement of “negative growth”.
- Vaslo 4y agoSetting targets for your business is not arbitrary. No business with investors just dials in an easy forecast. All investors demand growth with profit, otherwise they would put their money elsewhere. Goals are not set to make employee lives easy.