7 ms·
Just in case it saves one person the effort to research this themselves ... for some reason I find the measurement of climate change in units of temperature a b
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
Just in case it saves one person the effort to research this themselves ... for some reason I find the measurement of climate change in units of temperature a bit problematic (though entirely rational). It tends to suggest the old bugbear of "global warming", which of course gets translated by deniers (& skeptics) into "well it's colder here so that's wrong".
I spent a while digging in to try to get some numbers on a different sense of what's happening. Global average temperature is changing because extra energy is being retained within the boundary of the planet's atmosphere [0]. So how much extra energy is being retained?
A best guess estimate from 2015 would appear to be that
> the earth is getting about 300 terawatt hours of energy per hour due to anthropogenic climate change, and humans use about 16 terawatt hours of energy per hour.
That is, the earth is gaining 18x more energy per hour than we use every hour, thanks to the changes in radiative forcing driven by climate change contributors.
[0] anyone familiar with complex physical systems will understand that when you add energy to such a system, the effects are often hard to predict. It is very likely that the temperature of the system will rise, but you may also see, for example, more movement as well (which is in some sense a related concept to "temperature" but not identical, and it adds uncertainty because it of the extra degrees of freedom).
- kuhewa 4y ago90% absorbed by the ocean thanks to a high specific heat it's an even more modest number in degrees
- nayuki 4y ago"16 terawatt-hours of energy per hour" is simply "16 terawatts of power (continuously)". I want to see writers move away from the unit kWh and instead use joules, which is way less confusing and harder to misuse. Also we as a society need to respect the distinct concepts of energy (J) versus power (J/s = W).
- evandijk70 4y agoIs that a problem of units or education? Children sometimes confuse the units of speed and distance, but not when they get older.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoIn this place I'm citing from, the writer originally used Joules, but was critiqued by some anonymous commenters and switched. They noted: > Note: Before anyone complains, I’ve deliberately conflated energy and power above, because the difference doesn’t really matter for my main point. Power is work per unit of time, and is measured in watts; Energy is better expressed in joules, calories, or kilowatt hours (kWh). To be technically correct, I should say that the earth is getting about 300 terawatt hours of energy per hour due to anthropogenic climate change, and humans use about 16 terawatt hours of energy per hour. The ratio is still approximately 18. Out of interest, you can also convert it to calories. 1kWh is about 0.8 million calories. So, we’re force-feeding the earth about 2 x 1017 (200,000,000,000,000,000) calories every hour. Yikes. https://www.easterbrook.ca/steve/2012/01/how-much-extra-energy-are-we-adding-to-the-earth-system/ https://www.easterbrook.ca/steve/2012/01/how-much-extra-ener...
- zackees 4y ago[dead]
- 8note 4y agoWhen we do hit whatever +1.5C or +2C, Q will be 0. The amount of energy input to the earth system isn't changing - that's defined by the temperature of the sun, it's the output that is decreasing. What your energy look describes is dT/dt, how quickly we will reach the new equilibrium. At the new equilibrium, the temperature is likely still to be the best descriptor of the new normal - we describe most processes and states in terms of temperatures they happen at, because it's and intensive property rather than an extensive one. You don't have to temper this 300 TW number by the mass or surface area of the earth to get a sense of what's happening when you use temperature What's the energy number at which a glacier will melt? What's the temperature? ∆T is one of the most important numbers in thermodynamics for good reason
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> What your energy look describes is dT/dt, how quickly we will reach the new equilibrium. The rate is important, but so is the final result. A system whose new equilibrium is +10C is as useless to humanity and life and earth whether we reach it in 25 years or 200. I agree with you that ∆T is more useful for thinking about actual effects (e.g as you noted glacial melt), but my interest in thinking about it in energy terms is (a) I think it highlights the cause more strongly (YMMV) (b) it better accomodates the possibility of the extra energy in the system having effects not so obviously correlated with ∆T
- klabb3 4y agoYeah, those are interesting numbers. Another one I’m curious about is: how much faster are we burning fossil fuels than they are replenished naturally? The only number I found was a low estimate of 750x, and I think that was for oil. I assume “natural” gas is faster?
- tylerpachal 4y agoNot specific to fossil fuels, but there is Earth Overshoot Day[0] > Earth Overshoot Day marks the date when humanity has used all the biological resources that Earth regenerates during the entire year. [0]: https://www.overshootday.org/ https://www.overshootday.org/
- carlmr 4y agoBasically a few minutes into January 1st it's earth overshoot on oil and gas replenishment.
- WorldMaker 4y agoGiven many fossil fuel deposits took millions of years to settle/decompose/compress, I don't think you get a proper X multiplier without an exponent greater than 6.
- klabb3 4y agoYeah the time is interesting but it doesn’t directly imply anything about the flow. I’m curious about that. Ie how much new oil/gas etc is being produced by nature each year. Found this[1] now, which gives a ballpark of 20-80k barrels/y which can vary quite a bit depending on the guesstimates of undiscovered reserves. Since we produce 80-100M barrels/y, we’re drinking from the basin about 1000x the rate that it replenishes. Or slightly worse, because we’re slurping up the yummy and easily accessible parts, whereas formation occurs everywhere. Still, the 1e6 estimate seems orders of magnitude too high (to my surprise as well). Again, this is only for crude oil, and there are certainly more factors at play. 1: https://earthscience.stackexchange.com/questions/571/how-much-oil-is-created-each-year https://earthscience.stackexchange.com/questions/571/how-muc...
- dkjaudyeqooe 4y ago> anyone familiar with complex physical systems will understand that when you add energy to such a system, the effects are often hard to predict This is something that is very underappreciated. It's entirely possible that the climate becomes chaotic (in a mathematical sense) and there are sudden, drastic changes that cause economic and social devastation. It seems inevitable that people will be complacent until it's too late.
- csomar 4y agoOn the other hand, this energy can also get converted into complexity. It's not like this hasn't happened before (organisms, trees, animals, cities, etc...). So it's possible with this fast increase in energy, we get the SciFi city we have all been dreaming of. Of course, it's easier for this energy to dissipate as heat and kill us all.
- rkuykendall-com 4y agoIt seems inevitable that [conservatives] will be complacent until it's too late. Let's not white-wash the problem.
- c1sc0 4y agoThe problem looks pretty “white” to me already.
- cambaceres 4y agoWhat does that mean?
- revelio 4y agoFlipping that around, it seems inevitable that [leftists] will insist on mass collective action based on the predictions of unreliable academics, until the moment they realize those predictions were wrong. Again. Example: the idea that global warming doesn't cause warming is new. 20 years ago climatologists were telling British people with absolute confidence that by now there'd be no more snow. In the 1960s they were telling people there was a new ice age on the way. Both predictions were dead wrong and have now been white-washed out of existence. Why is it only conservatives who require that if people claim their understanding of the climate is good enough to predict it decades into the future, they actually be able to do that? Why is it only conservatives who recognize that academia's reputation should suffer if they constantly make aggressive predictions, get it wrong and then pretend it never happened?
- georgeglue1 4y agoDo you have a sense of what the % increase in total energy is? As in what is the denominator for the +300 terawatt hour figure?
- djleni 4y agoYeah this stat is a bit confusing to me. Does this imply in preindustrial times the net energy was 0, or is this total energy and there’s some number not mentioned of loss?
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoMy understanding (I'm not a climate scientist) is that yes, net energy was zero over the "right" period of time (i.e. incoming energy from the sun balanced energy lost by radiating to space). The key technical term (IIUC) is "radiative forcing" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiative_forcing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiative_forcing
- suby 4y agoThe analogy I've seen which I like is to that of a boiling pot of water on a stove. As you increase the heat (energy) in the system, the water level fluctuates throughout. You have points where there's a higher water level, but you also have points where there's a lower water level.
- ep103 4y agoThe thing that blew my mind was that they always report this in degrees Celsius. I'm in America, even despite an engineering degree, I think in Fahrenheit. 1.5C sounds like a small number, until you remember that Fahrenheit is ~2x 1C. So 1.5 degrees C is ~3 degrees F. Which, to me, just emotionally feels like a bigger number despite being the same empiraclly. Similarly, it means when the IPCC is saying there might be a 7C change in 100 years, they mean a 15F change. 15F is emotionally terrifying to me. Its the difference between 85 degrees and 100. 7C is an abstract concept to me.
- mulmen 4y agoUK tabloids apparently choose to use Fahrenheit to sensationalize heat waves.
- saulpw 4y agoThe US is basically the only country in the world that uses the Fahrenheit scale.
- mulmen 4y agoThis is false. Fahrenheit is commonly used in Canada to this day. Awareness of the scale still exists in the UK as well. Any commonwealth country is likely to have awareness because metrication happened so late in those countries.
- andrew_gs 4y agoThat's certainly not true for Australia and New Zealand, numbers in Fahrenheit are basically meaningless for me.
- mulmen 4y agoAustralia and NZ had much more successful conversions to the metric system than Canada but there are people alive today who would have used the Fahrenheit scale early in their lives. Contrast this with non commonwealth countries who converted to the metric system 100 years earlier than the commonwealth. UK Metrication: 1978 (partial) Canadian Metrication: 1976 (partial) Australian Metrication: 1988 NZ Metrication: 1976 French Metrication: 1858 German Metrication: 1872 Mexican Metrication: 1857
- andrei_says_ 4y agoI wish warnings came with clear outlines of mass extinctions, of changes in resources, and most importantly, of cost to property owners in impacted areas. That last one could finally cause some action because the current economy largely ignored anything else.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoBut if any of those outlines don't happen when expected or in a different way then people call it all bunk - same reason people discount it now because of previous dire warnings. The boy who cried wolf is the great fable for this, because ultimately there was a wolf.
- alfor 4y agoComplex systems usually tend to equilibrium otherwise they would be in constant oscillation (positive feedback theory). As we look back in ice cores, there is variation, but not constant oscillations witch confirm a self stabilizing system. A few negative feedback we don’t often hear: increase of co2 have a huge effect on plant grow especially in hash deserted conditions. Increase in temperature increase humidity: clouds that have a huge effect on reflecting radiation (much greater than co2) increase precipitation, increase plant growth in deserts. Not to say that we should continue this experiment, but maybe not panic either and see this as the only problem: war, famine, poverty are much more important and real immediate problems instead of projected possible problems.
- wcoenen 4y ago> Increase in temperature increase humidity Water vapor amplifies the effect of other greenhouse gases. https://climate.nasa.gov/ask-nasa-climate/3143/steamy-relationships-how-atmospheric-water-vapor-amplifies-earths-greenhouse-effect/ https://climate.nasa.gov/ask-nasa-climate/3143/steamy-relati...
- alfor 4y agoYes, but also with clouds that prevent radiation from reaching the ground.
- kuhewa 4y ago> increase of co2 have a huge effect on plant grow especially in hash deserted conditions. Which might sound good for crops but of itself can destabilise ecosystems, African savannahs are already becoming scrubbier with brush and shrubs due to more CO2 enrichment for at least ~1 million and possibly several million years. That will definitely have implications for populations of animals adapted for grassland
- brnt 4y agoIm sure the IPCC authors didn't forget their climate science 101 material. Moreover, we can tackle multiple problems concurrently, no need to make it appear we can only ever do one thing. And as it so happens, climate change tends to correlate extremely well with war and famine. It certainly appears a climate solution is going to help many other big problems along as well.