8 ms·
UBS got Credit Suisse for almost nothing
- kristianp 4y ago"Banks are speculative investment funds grafted on top of critical infrastructure", no, they're not supposed to be. That's why there's rules about percentage of depositors money that is risked. Basel III rules.
- eftychis 4y agoAnd I am not convinced it is a good deal for UBS. Credit Suisse went from ~$4 billion minor problem in August to we need ~$54 billion to "Switzerland is offering UBS $100 billion "safety" loan and gives it to you for free and regardless if you want it you are getting it this weekend."
- vkou 4y agoNothing plus a mountain of potentially toxic liabilities. It's not exactly a slam dunk deal.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoLet's be real -- at this point we're pretty sure it's not "potential" liabilities. More of "how bad, and how urgent?".
- mojuba 4y agohttps://archive.is/lddBY https://archive.is/lddBY
- MichaelZuo 4y agoI'm surprised Matt Levine would write a somewhat clickbaity title. If the net equity value of Credit Suisse was very low or perhaps even negative, depending on the accounting, then UBS in fact paid quite a high price because of all the liabilities.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mey 4y agoConsidering Credit Suisse's litigation history, ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_Suisse#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_Suisse#Controversies ), I would be surprised if their liabilities are limited to just the balance sheet.
- _nalply 4y agoAnd that's why UBS not only paid not a lot but also got a guarantee from the Swiss National Bank for about, I don't know, perhaps 100 billion Swiss francs.
- eloff 4y agoIt was 9 billion. UBS is on the hook for the first five billion in losses, the Swiss National Bank for the next nine, and UBS anything else above that.
- _nalply 4y agoBut perhaps after some point, since UBS is too big to fail, the Swiss National Bank will again back UBS indefinitely. In other words: UBS 5 billion then Swiss National Bank 9 billion then UBS as long as they can and finally Swiss National Bank the rest.
- pg_1234 4y agoNo ... in the worst case scenario the Swiss protect deposits, possibly nationalize the infrastructure needed to service those deposits, then let the rest of the structure collapse into bankruptcy. You don't bankrupt your national economy to protect foreign speculators. You salvage the part that your citizens depend on (and were meant to be able to trust). Once you're talking 100 billion plus, global investor confidence will recover over time long before you recover from a financial hit like that. Basically the approach that Sweden took in 2008.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lordnacho 4y agoThe interesting part is the part about the AT1 "bonds". I put them in quotation marks because according to the article, they are more like a form of subordinate equity. In some ways. Weird and fascinating instrument, it's not often I come across a new one.
- kurthr 4y agoYes, they wiped out these CoCo (Contingent Convertable) bonds, which are floated to provide money to provide a "capital cushion" in the case of stress. As bonds they're definitely weird, because (in this case) they are effectively subordinate to equity. This wipeout may make it difficult to issue any more AT1s, which removes another barrier created in 2008 that was supposed to prevent public bailouts. I am a bit surprised they didn't just convert an payout at the fairly cheap stock price, which it sounds like other regulators are saying they will do? https://www.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/explainerwhy-markets-are-in-uproar-over-a-risky-bank-bond-known-as-at1-3034847 https://www.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/explainerwh...
- thechao 4y agoThe article actually discusses AT1's at length, and pre-addresses all of your arguments. I'm not sure I find Levine's argument 100% compelling — I mean, we're dealing with a sentiment based sale, not calculating engines — but I don't think he's as close to wrong as you seem to imply.
- kurthr 4y agoI don't have a strong opinion, and simply posted one of the many articles discussing it today. It's definitely water cooler talk, and I wouldn't say it's discussion is really 'at length' or base any significant legal or monetary decisions on it. edit: If you have Bloomberg Intelligence there's a nice graphic on Additional Tier 1 bonds with Triggers, Loss Absorption, and and Write Up by Issurer. It was known that both UBS and CS were non-recoverable.
- seanhunter 4y ago
- indigodaddy 4y agoSo many good sentences and one-liners just in the first paragraph of this article.
- loeg 4y agoLevine is a national treasure. Sign up for the newsletter! He's a phenomenal writer and they are consistently great.
- gbN025tt2Z1E2E4 4y agoSo the solution to the banking collapse is to create even MORE too-big-to-fail monopoly banks? The corruption has gotten so far out of control at this point it's laughable.
- yieldcrv 4y agoThe protest outside of Credit Suisse in Switzerland is about that Specifically the variety of undemocratic processes to reach this result in the past and now. Federal Council overriding parliament and the population, specifically to override the potential will of shareholders in the company.
- xadhominemx 4y agoYes, the solution for a distressed bad medium-sized bank is for a larger good bank to buy them before they unwind chaotically have bring down other banks / the economy. That’s been the correct/reasonable approach for centuries. No one is really getting bailed out here: CS shareholders will lose ~80% vs what they were worth a couple weeks ago, the AT1 shareholders got wiped out, and if you look at UBS’s share price, it’s not like people think they got an extraordinary gift from the regulators. UBS management at will have to suffer an enormous headache to integrate the operations.
- revel 4y agoWhere is the corruption in any of this? That is a strong accusation without any semblance of an argument. During a downturn the stronger companies often acquire distressed competitors and consolidate. Evidence of corruption would be CS being propped up and executives allowed to pay themselves big bonuses. I'm not seeing anything like that, are you?
- omgomgomgomg 4y agoWell, its was worth almost nothing, so there. There are a couple 1000 people who will be awaiting a salary this or next week, it is a bit a financial pandorras box, but with the properties of a bottomless pit. In all seriousness, I know a couple cs folks with rather expensive flats and habits, this will not end too good for some of them.
- simonswords82 4y agoIf they were on the inside did they not see this coming? I was reading about the incoming demise of CS about 3-4 months ago on WallStreetBets subreddit...
- skyyler 4y agoThat crowd has been screaming about CS since shortly after the GME fiasco went down... Kind of hard to take them seriously in recent times.
- bitL 4y agoNothing? More like overleveraged $1T that can explode anytime? UBS should have been paid instead to take the CS corpse.
- chaosbolt 4y ago1T$ will never explode and drag it down, it's "QE saved by the state" kind of money, so if UBS is overleveraged, it makes sense to buy Credit Suisse, this way if it all goes to shit they'll blame it on CS and if it doesn't then they got a bank for cheap.
- bitL 4y agoOK, if the part of the acquisition agreement with government is "QE if needed", then it makes sense to acquire CS to continue kicking the can forward.
- chaosbolt 4y ago>agreement There is no agreement in my opinion and there never is on QE, but what choice does any government have between "1 Trillion loss that can trigger more loss and potentially cause a revolution, a famine, a war, etc..." and "kick it down like those before me did and those after me will do", the can has already been kicked enough times, might as well continue until some genius comes up with a new financial system adapted to the 21st century. People always expect solutions, sometimes there aren't any that are satisfactory. The people who added so little value to the market and got so much out of it pulled that money from somewhere, someone built those houses etc... sure war and conquest has helped modern empires like the US, but it can only get you so far before you start risking nuclear armageddon, plus it's really, really, really, evil, kids getting bombed for oil is evil no matter how you put it... the alternative is well crafter financial systems that borrom from the future to spend today, aka QE, your grandkids will pay those interests on that loan the fed printed and lent the treasury, but you will have a more comfortable life.
- jacquesm 4y agoInteresting reading. The bit that really jumped out at me was this: "Saudi National Bank — the Swiss bank’s largest shareholder" -> so here we have part of the problem, with all of these banks owning all or some of each other it is no wonder that when one of them gets into trouble the others are immediately discounted on the stock market. Not only do they get indirectly affected because they likely engage in similar practices, they also are interlinked through various stock holdings. And the solution here? More such linkage! Why didn't the Swiss government or the Swiss national bank end up owning it? Instead it is now - again - part of another such complex. You have to wonder how long it will be before UBS will have to be rescued. Another random thought: If even the Swiss can't keep it together financially we're in real trouble.
- rossdavidh 4y agoI'm no expert in the field, but my understanding is that CS was, in fact, rather too big for the nation of Switzerland to bail out. Their two biggest banks (CS and UBS) do an awful lot of non-Swiss business, so that is possible for them in a way that it would not be for a nation like the U.S.A. So, they made UBS take it (all accounts are that UBS was not interested until the Swiss government told them that yes they were interested). Also, UBS has more skill at running a bank than the Swiss government, although arguably the Swiss government might have had more skill at running a bank than Credit Suisse.
- cm2187 4y ago"all these banks owning each others": Which other banks? This is fairly unusual as the capital treatment of equity ownership is very punitive. Banks shareholders typically aren't banks.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat quote isn't what I wrote. And the relevant bank is mentioned just prior to the bit you quoted. And now they have a new shareholder: UBS. Which is also a bank.
- paganel 4y ago> If even the Swiss can't keep it together financially we're in real trouble. Eventually all financialized systems go the way of the dodo bird. The Republic of Genoa is the classic example for this, as they had made their fortunes via trade (including slave trade) starting with the 1200s, but by the 1500s almost all of their wealth-creation had started to rely on providing "financial" services. And then they crashed. I'm also of the opinion that the UK's problems are caused by the same phenomenon, that's why they have never quite recovered from the 2008-2010 global financial crisis. Afaik Switzerland is not yet a fully financialized economic system but it's certainly up there. The future will be interesting for them.
- revel 4y agoThere was a question last week about mark-to-mark accounting for banks in the wake of the SVB failure. The question was (to paraphrase): why aren't banks forced to mark every asset for every financial statement. This article pretty comprehensively describes why such a thing is not really possible, let alone desirable. In regards to this article, I have to laugh at the asset managers holding cocos who thought that they were trading pseudo-warrants. I respect the shamelessness of these guys to try and blame other people for their own mistakes -- a lot of portfolio managers were successfully able to convince investors that their losses during the GFC were due to the ratings or govt agencies -- but they're not going to convince the central banks to eat the losses on this one. There is absolutely no incentive to make Swiss taxpayers eat tens of billions of losses because some fund manager didn't read the literal name of the instrument he was buying.
- morninglight 4y agoThat's what my mother in law said about our baby. HA!
- sschueller 4y agoThe Swiss are extremely pissed. They spent a lot of capital and time to put up the to big to fail laws which this bank met yet it still failed. CS paid over 32 Billion in bonuses since 2013![1] Meanwhile people aren't getting paid more to balance the inflation. I also see a lot of US blaming going around specifically because of the capital regulations that the EU and Switzerland put in place since 2008 and supposedly the US did not. Also supposedly profited over them because they did not need to meet as strict of capital requirements. I don't hear much about SVB however. The news has also reported that the Swiss government wanted to let the US branch of CS fail but there was enormous pressure from the US to prevent this. There are a lot of details of this deal that aren't clear yet but I do have the feeling everyone here more or less agrees this was the only option. The focus seems to be on why it came to this situation in the first place. There is also a push from some parties for a government investigation. I also expect the next pension law adjustment coming up to have a very hard time after all this. [1] https://www.blick.ch/politik/trotz-hilfe-vom-staat-darum-sollen-bei-der-cs-weiterhin-boni-fliessen-id18414836.html https://www.blick.ch/politik/trotz-hilfe-vom-staat-darum-sol... Edit: Spelling
- gruez 4y ago>CS paid over 32 Billion in bonuses since 2013![1] Meanwhile people aren't getting paid more to balance the inflation. It's worth noting that in certain industries, bonuses make up a fair chunk of total comp and are expected. They should therefore be thought of as being closer to employee compensation than some sort of extraordinary reward.
- rcme 4y agoYes, but in banking, government bailouts have also come to be expected. Clearly the public should consider bailouts and fat profits and bonuses as fundamentally incompatible.
- gruez 4y ago>bailouts and fat profits and bonuses as fundamentally incompatible. I noticed you specifically called out "bonuses" but not salaries or wages, implying that bonuses are bad but salaries and wages are not. However, as I pointed out, the bonuses should effectively be counted as wages because they're expected.
- notShabu 4y agoThe reason the bank is worth nothing is because it's all liabilities (responsibility to provide customer deposits) and no profit. However it's similar to when people fight over the most important projects and tickets in a company. They fight over something with "negative" value (more work, risky initiatives) because it increases how "critical" or important they are to the company which can be leveraged into far more value later on.
- davidw 4y agoIs someone going to make a ChatGPT synthesis of Matt Levine's writings? Imagine you have, like, a writer who is really knowledgeable about a subject, and you have readers who would like to learn about this subject, but also have limited time. And, I mean, the writer is really prolific and sometimes feels almost a bit too verbose. In these kinds of markets, sometimes there is no deal to be struck, and...that's fine? But imagine if there were an intermediary who could summarize the writing in a way more accessible to people who are casually interested.
- lxgr 4y ago> And, I mean, the writer is really prolific and sometimes feels almost a bit too verbose. I've honestly never felt this way about Matt Levine's newsletter. He provides a lot of educational context that news articles generally don't, and that to me (other than the excellent writing) is its value – if you get rid of that, what's left? And just like in any written medium, you are always free to skip sections. How should an LLM make the decision for you whether a given section is relevant or even interesting to you?
- davidw 4y agoI realize it's an unpopular opinion, but something about his writing style can feel a bit circuitous at times. This particular one was a bit more direct, but sometimes I find them a bit of a slog. If they weren't really interesting, I simply wouldn't read them. They are, though. That's the dilemma.
- lxgr 4y agoIt definitely does, but that is exactly the didactic value, I'd argue. Examining the same situation through different lenses in a somewhat verbose way can make things click in a way that a dry and concise statement of facts sometimes can't. I'm not saying that there are no original ideas in his writing that could be extracted as bullet points, but on average, I think that's not the main reason why people read the column: If you're a finance pro, you probably come for the ideas and the clever writing; if you're an interested novice, you come for the writing and/or the didactic value. Remove the writing and the didactics, and you're probably left with a very small audience.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoEarlier this week I started reading both The Panama Papers and Moneyland. The hope is that they'll help make sense of such insensible things.
- pc_edwin 4y agoI find this stage of the economic/business cycle to be truly fascinating. A lot of things happen in such a short amount of time that we typically only read about or see in movies UBS's main calculus is risk, which is why the offer can double in a matter of hours. If the crisis is not stabilised, UBS could potentially be liable for tens of billions and face potential downfall. This is why UBS needed a guarantee from the Swiss National Bank and a MAC clause to proceed with the deal.
- chii 4y agoaka, they won't do it, unless there's some "free" profit they can get from doing the deal. Which means somebody gets a win out of this crisis after it's over, but the swiss taxpayer gets to take a loss if somehow it ends tits up.
- pc_edwin 4y agoI respectfully suggest that there may be a slight misunderstanding regarding the situation at hand. It is important to note that the Swiss National Bank (SNB) is the protagonist here, not UBS. Credit Suisse (CS) is hated by everyone, which has made it difficult to provide them with a direct bailout. However, allowing the bank to fail will lead to a crisis that surpasses the GFC. Therefore, the SNB sidestepped CS and its shareholders to craft a deal in such a way that it is too good for UBS to refuse. I would like to reiterate that neither CS nor UBS wants this, its being forced upon them by the SNB through the carrot (sweet deal) or the stick (coercion). I'm not absolving any of the individual parties from responsibility but I have to state the obvious here. The current state of affairs is a direct result of a chain of events that has led us to this point. The government implemented a set of measures including a lockdown and a dangerous stimulus and liquidity program. However, just as we were on the brink of hyperinflation, they began rapidly draining liquidity from the system. It is essential to acknowledge that it is not a mere possibility but rather an absolute certainty that something will break. Upon delving deeper into how the banking system operates, this becomes abundantly clear. The entire economy is built around deposit stability, without this stability, banks are unable to hold long-term assets on their balance sheets. These long-term assets include mortgages, business loans, corporate bonds, municipal loans, government bonds, and others. This is what is meant when people refer to the economy as a credit-based system.
- rafaelturk 4y agoNohting... Plus all the skeletons in the closet (a.k.a bad debt)