8 ms·
More than 75 percent decline over 27 years in total flying insect biomass (2017)
- BMc2020 4y ago“There are decades when nothing happens; and there are weeks when decades happen.” --Lenin The crash will always seem years away right up until the moment it is here.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoLenin is responsible for the deaths of hundreds of millions of people. You're quoting someone who has a body count higher than that of Adolf Hitler.
- BMc2020 4y agoBut he did have some insight into the nature of revolutions, which is the context in this case.
- inductive_magic 4y agoCan someone here point me towards the most current literature/sources on this topic? I’ve seen Beneckes EU-parliament talk and found the numbers presented there (probably the same ones you can see in the paper) very concerning. What does figure 4 look like in 2023? Where can I subscribe to stay up to date? What can companies in the ML/analytics space do to help?
- debacle 4y ago> What can companies in the ML/analytics space do to help? ...nothing? Contrary to very wishful thinking, technology is not the tool to solve all problems, and it will never be a replacement for civic engagement.
- samstave 4y agoWell, one could hack Monsanto and find all the secret emails which talk about how bad glyphosate is for the actual environment-eco-system that used to be in balance with insects.
- mywacaday 4y agoWe don't have to hack, why not have and FDA like model where all information has to be made available or discoverable during an audit.
- FredPret 4y agoTechnology != Comp Sci. We are a technological species in that we evolved with fire and clothing, and after tool use. For any mess we find ourselves in, the solution - if there is one - will involve tech and engineering.
- jitlle 4y agoI think that comment was intended as a parody of what a absurdly stereotypical HN user might write.
- kuhewa 4y agoWe don't even yet have the data to describe temporal trends in insect diversity and abundance rigorously and at scale, let alone attribute drivers. There is definitely scope for ML to assist in producing/validating/collating data. Civic engagement is going to be more effective with science behind it, otherwise it is up against campaign donors and lobbyists who can accurately point out there isn't enough data to demonstrate insecticides have caused a crash in insect populations, and to act as if they have would be threatening rural economies and food security without cause.
- adrianN 4y agoML companies could help by developing cheap methods to reduce the use of pesticides.
- tokai 4y agoCheck out papers that cites this one. https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=13771116398962506989&as_sdt=5,39&sciodt=7,39&hl=en https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=1377111639896250698...
- lamontcg 4y ago> What can companies in the ML/analytics space do to help? plaster the internet with chatbots doing fake engagement in order to swing political bias the other direction. the other side of the argument is already doing it.
- frontierkodiak 4y agoWe don’t have the data to make much more than directional claims re: macro trends in insect biodiversity. Ecological monitoring is tedious and labor-intensive; insects are simply too minute, too diverse, and too numerous to be surveilled at scale. Scale is necessary to make multi-decadal claims across millions of taxa; this is probably why some of the most rigorous studies^1 have produced findings that complicate the idea of an insect armageddon. I’m working on a tool to make insect (focused esp. on pollinators) monitoring 10,000x cheaper. We do not currently understand the scale of insect declines, much less are we able to design targeted interventions. In the past decades, mammalian and avian declines were largely reversed, mostly thanks to ambitious multiyear monitoring efforts that enabled limited conservation resources to be allocated efficiently. We should replicate this model with insects. I plan to make this possible by radically reducing the cost of data. I’ve been toying with this idea for a few years, but I finally made the leap to building my startup^2 full-time a few months back (coming from entomology/ecology). Hoping for an alpha release & demo study this summer. I'm happy to chat with anyone interested. Especially interested to meet those working and funding in this space. 1. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-020-1269-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-020-1269-4 2. https://polli.ai https://polli.ai Note: This site is austere (I blame CUDA troubles for stealing my time this month). Expect something more representative by April.
- Xeoncross 4y agoThe way many cities, farms, processing plants, resorts, houses, etc... spray regularly, I think some people are targeting 100% decline in flying insect biomass. I hope they don't get their wish.
- mistrial9 4y agofrom past discussions here, it appears to be a) real, and b) due mainly to 24 hours lighting and destruction of common ground where reproduction happens I predict huge numbers, but of far fewer species in a hundred years..
- Laaas 4y agoFar fewer _current_ species, and some new species.
- CydeWeys 4y agoYou think it's mainly those factors and not simply greater use of insecticides?
- mistrial9 4y agoyeah - all manner of agricultural and urban poisons .. without complicating it I went with the simple "destruction of common ground" Silent Spring is here
- davidkuennen 4y agoHaving lived in the countryside in Germany my whole life (34 years), I noticed a dramatic decline of insects. When I was a child, there were so many butterflies, bees and more in the summer. Today I barely see them anymore.
- everydayentropy 4y agoYup! I always thought it was me staying inside more as I got older, but I rarely see butterflies and bumble bees anymore. This terrifies me more than climate alarmism.
- smackeyacky 4y agoYou don't think it might be related?
- quacked 4y agoThey're related in that both are downstream of industrialization, but changing climates aren't lessening insect biodiversity as much as overuse of various chemicals are.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoWarmer climate should be better for insect populations. This is mostly about pesticide overuse.
- hermitcrab 4y agoAnd habitat loss? Crop monocultures are not great for most insects (or animals or birds).
- adammarples 4y agoInsects can be very sensitive to drought
- m463 4y agowhat got me is that over the past 10 or more years, I've continually seen dead bees on the ground. and I think... what a small creature to *notice* on the ground. How many dead bees escape my notice? there must be a LOT.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- samstave 4y agoThis is interesting to me ; I am a regular cyclist and I commented recently on the fact that when I was a kid, there were always 'clouds' of gnats in the evenings that typically swarmed around and you would bike through them... I havent encountered a swarm of little gnat in a very long time. However, I blame this on glyphosate which decimated the insect environments. The other thing, in the early 1980s in Lake Tahoe, there was a grove of trees near my elementary school where the Monarch Butterflies would congregate and an entire pine tree would be completely blanketed in them - havent seen that in decades. Milkweed is their only food and egg-laying spot (on the underside of the leaves) - but milkweed has been eradicated with glyphosate and thus no more Monarchs.
- logi2mus 4y agoWhen I was young the farmers made hay, no it is only Silage. So any moth which was attached to hay is now dead.
- melling 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons Climate change, plastics, antibiotic resistance, huge budget deficits, etc. We create all sorts of problems in society. We can’t seem to connect the dots… https://www.cbsnews.com/news/vinyl-chloride-ohio-train-derailment-thousands-pounds-released-annually-plastics/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/vinyl-chloride-ohio-train-derai... Our inflation problem was avoidable too but everyone wanted cheap money for way too long.
- DesiLurker 4y agoRight, As I often say, tragedy of commons will turn out to be our great filter. Not just at individual level but every level up including city, state & nations. It works great for when the problems faced are aligned with individual short term best interests not so well when collective action is needed.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoIt’s not just tragedy of the commons, it’s also a lack of collective will to not keep borrowing from the future and kicking the can. Debt, the biome, economic systems depending on never ending growth and an ever growing population pyramid. There is no incentive to think long term and preserve for tomorrow. This will catch up to us eventually, and ignorance will be plead.
- mistrial9 4y agoregulated and science-based Forestry seems to have destroyed thousands of years of forest growth in less than a hundred years of English command, here in California. Nothing about it was 'commons' .. Secondly, the largest polluter of the Pacific Ocean has been the US Navy, on shore and off.. also fully 'not commons' Let's ignore the politics and look with a science lense at what is really going on?
- DesiLurker 4y agobut Politics IS what is going on here. we can fix climate change with some effort. we can also fix biodiversity loss & most social issues with some restructuring. the problem is that those who stand to lose are the ones politicizing this to ensure that a consensus does not arise. Read 'Dark Money' by Jane Mayer if you have doubts. In light of so much manipulation I think its rather Naive to say that 'I dont wanna get political', No lets get political because the science is settled.
- jcq3 4y agoSo what? Old species die and new species born. Its just nature...
- fredoliveira 4y agoTell me you don't understand how ecosystems collapse without telling me you don't know how ecosystems collapse.
- csdvrx 4y agoIDK, if it turns out it's not due to insecticides, I think that's a valid point. The world is always changing. I may be philosophically wrong to want to lock it in its present state.
- stephc_int13 4y agoThere are sampling methodology issues with this type of studies. The main conclusion is that insecticide chemicals used for agriculture are pretty effective at killing insects (especially Neonicotinoid but probably also other classes). A more rigorous sampling methodology would produce a different picture, with huge differences depending on the distance from highly cultivated areas. This is not apocalypse, this is actionable, invertebrates species populations can rebound at a surprising speed in less poisonous ecosystem. Politics should act to ban some classes of insecticides.
- 300bps 4y agoPolitics should act to ban some classes of insecticides. And people need to be educated so they don’t hire pesticide companies to bomb their entire yard every year with insecticide because they want fewer mosquitos and other bugs outside.
- huuhee3 4y agoThis. I can't understand people who want their plot of land to be without natural life. Might as well sell the house and move to a flat instead.
- zamadatix 4y agoIf that were the only difference between a house and a flat then there would be reason to be confused. Few chose a flat vs a house mainly based on how much they love nature itself.
- ninkendo 4y agoI don’t think anyone wants their plot of land to be without natural life. Maybe without mosquitos though.
- mikrotikker 4y agoYea but like, there's topical applications instead of bombing the backyard. Or plant lots of citrus in the yard. Rip a small branch off and scrunch up the leaves and keep it near. The citrus fumes from the leaves can keep them at bay.
- 1attice 4y agoHear me out: sure, we denuded the planet of life, but we're ushering new life into being with GPT-N /s If there are future generations, the priorities of this era will be inscrutable
- zabzonk 4y agoannecdata: my very nice cleaning lady saw a bumble bee on her allotment yesterday, and told me about it. 10 years ago it would not be worth mentioning - they all come out in early spring. this is in lincoln, uk
- schnebbau 4y agoAt some point in the future the consequences of our actions are going to start emerging, and shit is going to get real for society. Where in the world would be a good place to be living when this happens? Probably a relatively small, relatively undeveloped island in the pacific right? (if it isn't underwater by that point)
- huuhee3 4y agoSomewhere with lots of natural resources, not too hot and few people. Alaska perhaps? Siberia would work if the local government wasn't so crazy.
- potsandpans 4y agomy escapist fantasy exists deep in the sticks of northern vermont / maine. not too many people, necessary cold seasons, relatively decent hardiness zones.
- pixelfarmer 4y agoSome point in the future? We are in the midst of a massive species extinction event already. The problem with all that: The dependencies in the biosphere are complex graphs and we humans are eradicating part of that, unraveling everything connected to that. Guess who is part of that big graph? Humans. For beings which declare themselves as being "intelligent" this can only be described as exceptionally stupid.
- darth_avocado 4y agoIt’s fertilizers but it’s also declining biodiversity. We’re razing down natural habitats and covering it up with other things. When you dig up the prairies and build McMansions with decorative grass at best, turf or concrete at worst, all the native insects go to die, and so does the rest of the food chain.
- laen 4y agoI can remember a decade ago having to clean my car’s windshield each time I filled up at the gas station. Now-a-days in both the US and Germany I find it a rarity - my wipers can generally get the one or two splats. You’ll notice a bit more on the country roads vs interstate/autobahn but such an alarming difference overall.
- rqtwteye 4y agoThat’s very true.
- joss82 4y agoIs it the same car, though? For efficiency, newer cars have become more profiled and glide through the air where older cars were more boxy.
- mikestew 4y agoAs you’ll see in a moment, the question/assertion has come up before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31947758 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31947758
- hermitcrab 4y agoI had a chuckle a few days ago in my local bookshop when I saw next to each other books on: -the insect apocalypse -how to eat insects
- b3nji 4y agoNow what are the elites going to get is to eat?!
- hermitcrab 4y agoAside: I fairly recently got into photographing bugs with a macro lens and flash. It opens up a whole new world that you can't normally see with the naked eye. Also you can do it in your garden or local park, no need to fly to the Serengeti. Insects (and arachnids) are amazing.
- pleb_nz 4y agoFlying somewhere is only adding to the environmental issues anyway....
- dustymcp 4y agoAnecdote time, i drove home last summer to my parents they live in the middle of nowhere with farmland all around and i remember distinctly when i was a kid how many bugs that would be squashed, coming around now there is very little compared.. I dont know much about pesticides but that seems like a slippery slope.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoPerhaps loss of insects is an indicator we got absorbed into a simulation. Just kidding.
- pvaldes 4y agoTo start, In Germany Alternative universe title: After several decades German Insects learned not to keep falling on Malaise traps, or local birds learned how to ravage the traps and take profit of it Another alternative universe title title: After taxonomists vanished insect biomass is flying under the radar and being severely underestimated
- kornhole 4y agoWe have chemical warfare treaties between humans. Why not extend it to other species?
- phendrenad2 4y agoAm I allowed to say that the number of bugs I see in 2023 is roughly the same as I saw when I was young, or will I get downvoted for disagreeing with the bug hive?