6 ms·
America’s bad bet on expanding legal sports gambling
- agentwiggles 4y agoMeanwhile, states and cities are trying to illegalize vaping while leaving cigarettes on shelves, not to mention continuing the criminally stupid "war on drugs" in ways too myriad to count while retaining one's sanity. _sigh_
- jcranmer 4y agoIn all seriousness: where are e-cigarettes more restricted than cigarettes?
- vorpalhex 4y agoI'm going to give you the official reasons, because I do believe that is the "why" for most people who want to ban them: They are more attractive to kids. Tobacco is an acquired taste. I enjoy a yearly cigar but even it can be a bit strong for me. Vaping has flavors and is smooth and gentle. The problem here is not just that cigs are worse for you than vaping. Kids smoke because smoking is rebellious behavior. Making vaping illegal will only make it more rebellious. Also nicotine is a pretty solid fix for anxiety which kids are full of. There is a an alternative argument that vaping bans are due to tobacco industry insiders. Honestly though they would probably refer to capture profits than ban them. Vaping is relatively safe, esp compared to tobacco. My two pack a day mother who smoked since she was 14 moved entirely to vaping and got her nicotine habit very under control. This was a woman who got in trouble for smoking in a hospital bed pregnant yet was willing to forego her vape for four hours without even a complaint last time she had to fly.
- jcranmer 4y agoI didn't ask why people want to ban e-cigarettes; I asked where are they controlled more severely than cigarettes (and I don't consider flavor bans to be more severe than controls on cigarettes, since cigarettes themselves have rules on their composition which include flavor!)
- agentwiggles 4y agoThe city I live in recently passed a ban on "flavored tobacco," which includes (for some reason) vape products. While this ban has not taken effect yet, after it does, the net effect will be that full strength cigarettes like Marlboro Reds remain accessible at every gas station and corner store, while any vape product with a "flavor" is no longer legally saleable in the city limits. I guess if flavor bans don't count for you, this wouldn't bother you. For me, this is a major "throwing the baby out with the bathwater" move that will remove access to a class of product with great effectiveness for smoking cessation and harm reduction. The reasoning, to my eye, seem to be largely moral panic bullshit, largely caused by the popularity of vaping among teenagers. (Why not impose harsher penalties for stores selling to underage kids? Seems to work fairly well for liquor in my experience.) I'm also generally opposed to prohibition and think adults should be able to decide what goes into their bodies, so I'm opposed in principle.
- the_only_law 4y agoIt’s gotten so ridiculous I’ve started to see jobs… fully remote… that say will refuse to hire you if you use any nicotine products, explicitly including quitting aids like gums and patches.
- agentwiggles 4y agoThat raises my eyebrows... How do they plan to validate this? What's to stop one from just... lying?
- orangepurple 4y agoUrinalysis
- agentwiggles 4y agoA quick google suggests nicotine stays in your system for just a few days after quitting. I realize of course that it's hard to just quit nicotine on a whim for a few days, but I imagine most could do it for the sake of a job.
- bluSCALE4 4y agoGod, I can't stand vaping. I went to a concert and the guy next to me literally vaped for 3 hours straight. That's like 2 boxes in one sitting. I don't mind those that take small swigs here and there but just puffing it non-stop is like, dude, you're going to die.
- alanlammiman 4y agoBrazil. Sale of ecigs is not permitted, cigarettes have the usual restrictions (but not taxed as heavily as some other places). Still - I have to give it to them. I get the feeling it was the right call. No vaping ads and vape shops everywhere like I see in Europe
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoVaping in some EU countries is out of control. Due to the lack of government regulations compared to normal cigs, smokers found it as a good loophole for indoor smoking and switched to vaping everywhere, especially in public spaces like malls, pubs, clubs, shopping centers, etc. And whenever you tell them "please stop vaping here", unless you're a bouncer, they'll lash out saying "it's not illegal, show me which law forbids me vaping indoor; yeah smoking is forbidden indoor, but vaping is not smoking and this is just steam bro, not smoke, it's not dangerous for you". Some venues enforce a vape ban on their own, but most don't want to piss off their customers, so many venues ignore the people who vape inside.
- himinlomax 4y ago> I get the feeling it was the right call. No vaping ads and vape shops everywhere like I see in Europe Vapes cause at most 1/100 the harm cigarettes do. There is no combustion products, only nicotine, and not always. The only harm they do is as a possible gateway to actual smoked tobacco. As such, banning them while allowing tobacco is completely nonsensical. It should be the other way around.
- 55555 4y agoThailand. They're illegal. Cigarettes are not.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wartron 4y agoSan Francisco
- prh8 4y agoAs virtually most issues in America, unchecked capitalism is ruinous
- manual89 4y agoUnchecked capitalism is enabled by inadequate education.
- andrenotgiant 4y agoI know nothing about FanDuel and DraftKings, or sports betting in general. Do FanDuel and DraftKings only make money on fees, or are there also situations where , like in a Casino, you're playing against the house? Also, I bet there are SWE's from FanDuel and DraftKings on HN. No judgement I would love to hear how you see things from the inside.
- woooooo 4y agoEveryone's playing against the house, but the house sets lines and odds with a goal of getting 50% of bettors on either side of the bet for a guaranteed profit.
- edmundsauto 4y agoThis is a clean narrative and a reasonable starting assumption, but not necessarily accurate. House bookies are trying to maximize their earnings, not limit themselves to the rake. For example, certain teams have fans that bet on the team as a show of support rather than betting wisely. The house will identify these positions so they can take advantage, rather than letting the other side of the bet make most of the cash on bad bets.
- jamesfinlayson 4y agoYep big gambling companies have a lot of analysts on staff - all working on improving models to squeeze more money.
- iainmerrick 4y agoUntil sports betting was legalised in the US, FanDuel and DraftKings specialised in fantasy football, where you pay to enter competitions against other players. The winning players split the prize money, the company takes any money left over. For legal reasons the prize pot was fixed so if not enough people entered a contest the company would have to eat the loss. That was arguably not sports betting, therefore legal, because it was a game of skill against other players. The big difference with sports betting is that you’re now playing directly against the house. Their profit depends on how well they calculate their betting odds. Arguably it’s still a game of skill, but it’s obviously pretty stacked in the company’s favour.
- nickpeterson 4y agoThis one is going to hit really hard over time, because it normalizes betting on sports. Children will grow up in environments where it’s just what people do. How far are we from allowing people to bet money on high school sports? We’re going to start having big problems with degenerate gambling addictions in 10-15 years.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoI don't know where you grew up, but gambling on sports was already extremely normalized in my experience. Some sports more than others, but it's rare to go to a Superbowl party or the like without discussion of "making it interesting".
- Invictus0 4y agoBetting 20 bucks on the super bowl once a year with your friends is worlds away from "normalized gambling".
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoIn Australian the Melbourne / Adelaide cup days generally get a large amount of attention. I think they normalise and introduce gambling in a very problematic way - work ‘sweeps’ etc are very normal and mean that people are peer pressured into gambling.
- jarsin 4y agoVegas is about to legalize Esports betting. Canada already has, I believe. There will be ads in every video game in the not too distant future.
- KyeRussell 4y agoYep, as another commenter said, you don’t really need to make guesses here. Just look at Australia. “The odds” are so intrenched in talking about the game itself, that kids are naturally taught the lingo and that watching / betting on sports go hand in hand. We are in the process of trying to wind this shit back, but unfortunately at this point we’ve had enough time to build a powerful sports betting lobby, including the sporting clubs and leagues themselves. A politician has no powerful friends when they decide to fight this issue, and it makes them a lot of powerful enemies.
- denkmoon 4y agoLook at Australia for a cautionary tale on letting gaming companies do as they please. I've worked in the industry and I'm very much on the side of letting people gamble if they choose to do so, but _everywhere_ in our society is just plastered with ads for it. The volume of ads for gambling during a sports events can sometimes exceed the actual commentary on the event. I'd ban gambling ads, and I'd ban pokies (tangential to this discussion but pokies are pure evil). I'd expand our self exclusion legislation to a national system and crack down on online retailers allowing the self exclusion system to be subverted.
- fbdab103 4y agoFor anyone else who does not speak Aussie, a pokie is a video poker or slot machine.
- justinator 4y ago"Pokey" in old slang meant a jail cell. "Throw you into the pokey" a pokie is a video poker or slot machine Ah! You mean a, "fruit machine"?
- jamesfinlayson 4y agoI live in Australia too and I think the government letting pretty much any company that wants a wagering license have one is problematic. I'm sure there were problem gamblers 30 years ago when TAB was the only player but it feels like these days there's a new player entering the market every month, and they're getting increasingly desperate to make a profit in what is already a flooded market.
- benatkin 4y agoSome of it seems like gambling minus the fun. Especially when people bet on sports online anonymously against strangers. Still, just because it doesn't sound fun to me doesn't mean it isn't fun. Maybe they tell their stories to friends and still have social experiences, or it heightens the experience of following sports with friends.
- GlacierFox 4y agoIn the UK its a real problem. I've just watched a TV show on a national TV catchup streaming service (UKTV Play). I've just had to sit through 4 minutes of ads and every single one of them was for a different gambling company. It's plastered all over billboards too. Even major daytime TV shows are sponsored by gambling organisations to get those grannies in too (Foxy Bingo). It's sickening and I feel most people are blind to what is actually going on.
- humanrebar 4y ago> I've just had to sit through 4 minutes of ads and every single one of them was for a different gambling company. Crypto? Online card games? Mobile gacha games? Sports betting? A mix? It makes all the commercials for bad beer, fast food, and sugary drinks seem kind of quaint in retrospect. Like the old surveys of teachers from the mid 20th century claiming gum chewing as one of the biggest concerns for their classrooms.
- lumb63 4y agoLegalizing mobile gambling (sports is a common form of this) is a terrible idea. I used to be heavily in favor of legalized sports gambling; like the article says, I’m not harming anyone, and it’s my choice. Then one of my close friends with a gambling problem lost a substantial chunk of his life savings on gambling on his phone. He didn’t even have to leave his house to do it. After that, I had to reconsider my position. While I disapprove of governments babysitting their constituents rather than treating them as independent and responsible adults, I think addictive habits are a worthwhile exception. A person who is addicted to gambling is not in their right mind or acting rationally. It is the same as any other psychoactive drug or habit. Nobody should have their life outcome determined by something that hijacks their biology for exploitative purposes (and I do see it as exploitative inherently; the business model of gambling is such that on average the user must lose).
- bluSCALE4 4y agoI hate all forms of gambling outside of a casino. At least at a casino, it's isolated but when it's on your phone or in your neighborhood, it's just gross. At first I wanted to boycott any establishment that allowed machines in their businesses but it seems its too lucrative a draw as I see them everywhere in cities where they're allowed.
- api 4y agoI used to be very much the same and have started to reconsider too. I think I’m shocked at just how prevalent it becomes when it’s legal and advertising is permitted. It’s like gambling becomes a double digit percentage of the economy. In the future I think the ability to resist addiction is going to become a massive factor affecting life outcome, possibly even larger than intelligence or education or appearance.
- lumb63 4y agoSports gambling has just been legalized in my state and I’ve been getting bombarded by advertisements non-stop over the last few weeks. I joke now that every commercial is a sports gambling commercial. And the rub is, as the article says, the “please gamble responsibly” in the fine print. Those companies want us to gamble as responsibly as is required to keep them from being banned and not a hair more.
- Arrath 4y agoI've long looked askance at the rise of legal sports betting, back to the draft kings ads. It just feels so utterly insidious. The machine that is capital is running out of ways to extract money from us little folk, and wider spread gambling is the last gasp? I dunno, hard to express. It just gives me a bad feeling.
- arrosenberg 4y agoRunning out of capitalist* ways to milk to common folk. More rents are comin'.
- Barrin92 4y agoWhen I moved to Japan one of the sadder things for me in smaller towns was how many old people just spend their entire day playing pachinko. It seemed legitimately like the largest economic activity in some places.
- jknoepfler 4y agoOn the one hand, I agree. On the other hand, having played a lot of live poker, I'm fond of my local OMCs (old man coffees) who just want to chat and play cards, and are slightly losing over time (most to the house). That doesn't feel nearly as inequitable as the whale-hunting gaming ultimately depends upon (and which drove me away from it). Which isn't to suggest that pachinko doesn't have whales (or blackjack, or the state lottery, or slots), or that the picture you paint isn't depressing (I've seen it around the world in different forms, and it's always very depressing).
- winternett 4y agoThey do remind you to call a counselling number if you're addicted to gambling after the FanDuel commercial that tries to convince you to gamble though... So there's that... sigh
- lozenge 4y agoIn the UK the gambling companies funded a campaign "when the FUN stops, STOP" with a nice big FUN the size of a bus.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mistyvales 4y agoIn Minnesota, the taxpayers are paying for corporate welfare to the tune of billions of dollars via multiple Pro sports stadiums, the main one being the Vikings stadium. Back when Jesse Ventura was governor, he had a plan to run statewide legal sports betting to pay for those stadiums (since the multi-billion dollar NFL corp wasn't going to). Of course it was squashed immediately without any research or investigation into how it would be implemented, but it is one example of a positive outcome from sports betting. People are going to bet regardless of the system, but I'd rather people that actually care about sports pay into a massive stadium than that average person wondering why the taxes have gone up. Side note: If you get a drink downtown Mpls, you're not only paying tax for the Vikings stadium, you're also paying a penny or so tax for the Metrodome which was torn down nearly 10 years ago.
- paulpauper 4y agoNot just welfare for the stadium, but sports betting means more literal welfare for people who can afford it least. Sports betting takes money from the least successful and funnels it off in the worst, least productive way possible.
- mistyvales 4y agoFair point, and totally agree, but it won't stop people from betting or gambling. I wonder what it would take to ban Powerball or other lotteries? Worth the discussion for sure.
- alexb_ 4y agoPretty much all complaints about this stuff comes down to "the ads are EVERYWHERE" - what's stopping us from just banning advertisements like we did with cigarettes? Feels like a fine compromise.
- paulpauper 4y agoIsn't this what crypto is? It's the same sort of thing. At least sport's betting does not seem to have the same level or magnitude of scamming or fraud compared to crypto.
- jackstraw14 4y agoIt's sad but a big chunk of what people spend their time on nowadays whittles down to a bet. Sure crypto is one example, but you can easily find yourself in similarly scammy territory in more regulated markets. Where you live, how you live, even where you work is a bet on how much you think you're worth vs how much the market values your work. Where you stick your retirement funds is a bet hoping for a prosperous post-work life. A normal sequence of life is looking more like a series of bets, to me anyway. Maybe it was always like this, but people just didn't look at it that way quite as much?
- wirthjason 4y agoWhat about “gambling” in the financial markets? Want that $1.50 call on GameStop earnings? Bets come in all shapes and sizes, including Wall Street bets.
- chmorgan 4y agoWait until Vox finds out about alcohol and marijuana... Seriously though, too much of anything is an issue and gambling is no exception. Even eating can have terrible health effects. And lack of sufficient exercise is quite bad for you too. Could it be a problem for some people? Yes, of course. Is it their choice? Yes, it is. Putting it in perspective, it's yet another personal choice that can have a dramatic impact on your quality of life, and if you have a family to support, theirs as well.
- theowawaysed 4y agoWhen I watched a documentary explaing how universities welcomed gambling companies to their campus made realise that USA already lost the battle to China. Just an outsider opinion
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- htag 4y agoI am surprised fairness in sport isn't a more central theme in this discussion. As more money is spent in sports betting there is more incentive to "fix" games. I view sports betting as a threat to fair competition. Maybe we've spent so long with limited sports gambling that we have forgotten the impact these scandals have.
- bitcurious 4y agoGambling in general is expanding across the board. Loot boxes for kids, then cryptocurrency pump & dump, sports gambling, casinos being built. It’s a kind of decay I saw elsewhere first.
- david2ndaccount 4y agoThe US historically has oscillated between allowing gambling and restricting gambling. We might be at the high mark of this current swing. When most people know someone whose life was ruined by gambling we will see widespread bans and likely go back to just Nevada having legal gambling (as it is allowed in their state constitution).
- listenallyall 4y agoZero chance. Casinos generate taxes and jobs. Online gambling & sports betting generates more taxes and a few more jobs. Lotteries and horse racing too. States simply can't afford to give it up now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- newmanah223 4y agoGambling creates no wealth for society as a whole. A gambling island like Vegas may benefit because they suck wealth from surrounding areas. Any jobs or government revenue created from gambling come at the expense of productive activities, while simultaneously creating social problems from addiction and crime. I hate the term gambling. It isn't a gamble for the state lotto that sets mathematical payouts that ensure a certain percent profit, nor is it a gamble for the casino owner with his slot machines.
- unmole 4y ago> Gambling creates no wealth for society as a whole. How is it different from any other form of entertainment?
- theaussiestew 4y agoI was about to post a retort but you got me there. Maybe one could say that most entertainment is more nourishing?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jstarfish 4y agoMost other forms of entertainment do not negatively affect the lives of the consumer and everyone around them. Porn, prostitution and shopping/hoarding are the three main exceptions that come to mind.
- sokoloff 4y agoDrinking and smoking would be on my list.
- agtech_andy 4y agoAn example of a gambling dystopia is Serbia. There are gambling places everywhere, even in small towns or next to otherwise scenic places. It is terribly depressing to be constantly reminded of this massive suck on productive society. And these places are a visual assault, the front of the buildings are a mix bright, flashing lights and blackened windows on otherwise lively streets. I really wish I was exaggerating. The Google Street View of Belgrade hasn't been updated since 2014, but if you look up "Belgrade Casino", you can see just how many of these have spread in the last decade.