13 ms·
Wow - this is just wild. I've seen lots of arguments around "AI won't take everyone's job, it will just open up new areas for new jobs." Even if you take that w
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Wow - this is just wild. I've seen lots of arguments around "AI won't take everyone's job, it will just open up new areas for new jobs." Even if you take that with the benefit of the doubt (which I don't really think is warranted):
1. You don't need to take everyone's job. You just need to take a shitload of people's jobs. I think a lot of our current sociological problems, problems associated with wealth inequality, etc., are due to the fact that lots of people no longer have competitive enough skills because technology made them obsolete.
2. The state of AI progress makes it impossible for humans in many fields to keep up. Imagine if you spent your entire career working on NLP, and now find GPT-4 will run rings around whatever you've done. What do you do now?
I mean, does anyone think that things like human translators, medical transcriptionists, court reporters, etc. will exist as jobs at all in 10-20 years? Maybe 1-2 years? It's fine to say "great, that can free up people for other thing", but given our current economic systems, how are these people supposed to eat?
EDIT: I see a lot of responses along the lines of "Have you seen the bugs Google/Bing Translate has?" or "Imagine how frustrated you get with automated chat bots now!" Gang, the whole point is that GPT-4 blows these existing models out of the water. People who work in these fields are blown away by the huge advances in quality of output in just a short time. So I'm a bit baffled why folks are comparing the annoyances of ordering at a McDonald's automated kiosk to what state-of-the-art LLMs can do. And reminder that the first LLM was only created in 2018.
- mostlysimilar 4y agoThis is possibly a death spiral. GPT is only possible because it's been trained on the work humans have learned to do and then put out in the world. Now GPT is as good as them and will put them all out of work. How can it improve if the people who fed it are now jobless?
- jgust 4y agoPresumably this problem is solved with technology improvements or the need is recognized to hire experts capable of generating high quality training material. In either situation, there's going to be extreme discomfort.
- mostlysimilar 4y agoGPT is good because of collective knowledge, lots of data. What do you have in mind by "hire experts"? Isn't that what we have now? Many experts in many fields, hired to do their work. Cut this number down and you reduce training data.
- jgust 4y agoLet's assume that GPT eliminates an entire field of experts, runs out of training data, and whoever is at the helm of that GPT program decides that it's lucrative enough to obtain more/better data. One alternative is subsidizing these experts to do this type of work and plug it directly into the model. I don't expect the nature of the work to change, more likely it's the signature on the check and the availability of the datasets.
- pixl97 4y agoYou also may underestimate how quickly that AI could pass expert level. The experts out there still have many years of life left so they won't be disappearing soon. If we get self improving/self training AI sooner than later then, we'll humans won't be the experts.
- HybridCurve 4y agoIt's important to note however, that GPT does not itself have any knowledge, only information. Knowledge implies it has comprehension or understanding. It can just as easily produce bad information as good and it has little to no ability to self-assess the accuracy of information it provides.
- yoyohello13 4y agoThere is a problem, how will people become experts in the field. If all entry level positions are taken by AI, nobody will be able to become an expert.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoAlso what happens to the intuition and unwritten skills that humans learned and passed on over time? Sure, the model has probably internalized them implicitly from the training data. But what happens in a case where you need to have a human perform the task again (say after a devastating war)? The ones with the arcane knowledge are gone, and now humans are starting from scratch.
- mostlysimilar 4y agoIncredible that we've been writing speculative fiction about this for decades and still we sleepwalk right into it. I'd love to be wrong, but I think we're all still too divided and self-interested for this kind of technology to be successfully integrated. A lot of people are going to suffer.
- salad-tycoon 4y agoIt’s not just sci fi. It’s has already happened in past with construction. Things like pyramids and certain cathedrals and what not are no longer possible even with machines. At least this is what I’ve read and heard, I’m not actually an engineer or architect. Tangent, I’m looking for some sci fi about this topic. Any suggestions?
- veqq 4y agoNo. Things like Greek fire or Roman cement aren't possible - because we don't know the precise mixture or formulation involved. Many old descriptions mean we don't know how to do it, because they are very vague. But we can technically do much better waterproof concrete or whatever - however our incentives are also not aligned in the same ways. Here's a tangential link to monks building a Gothic cathedral with modern machines: https://carmelitegothic.com/ https://carmelitegothic.com/
- pixl97 4y agoActually we've recreated Roman concrete just recently. It appears a quicklime like substance in the concrete gives it a self healing property l
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoLiterally everything you do online is training data. This comment and discussion is future training data. Your browser history is logged somewhere and will be training data. Your OS probably spies on what you do...training data. It's training data all the way down. And they've hardly begun to take into account the physical world, video, music, etc. as training data.
- xp84 4y agoPresumably it will improve the same way humans did -- once it's roughly on par with us it'll be just as capable of innovating and trying new things. The only difference is that for humans, trying a truly new approach to something isn't really done that often by most. "GPT-9" might regularly and automatically try recomputing all the "tricky problems" it remembers from the past with updated models, or with a few tweaked parameters and then analyze whether any of these experiments provided "better" solutions. And it might do this operation during all idle cycles continuously. Honestly as a human who grasps how the economy works, this doesn't sound like a good thing, but I don't see any path to trying the fundamental changes that would be required for really good general AI to not be an absolute Depression generator. The only thing I'm wondering is, will the wealthiest ones, who actually have any power to influence these fundamental thing, figure this out before it's too late? I really doubt your Musks and Bezoses would enjoy living out their lives on ring-fenced compounds or remote islands while the rest of the world devolves into the Hunger Games.
- oska 4y ago> once it's roughly on par with us it'll be just as capable of innovating and trying new things This is complete nonsense. An LLM has no ability to innovate or 'try new things'.
- pixl97 4y agoI keep seeing people post a line like this and it makes about zero sense to me... Just what the shit do you think Google/Microsoft/Amazon are pouring billions of dollars into machine learning/AI for? The first one that creates a self improving-self learning machine wins the game (or destroys the earth with a paperclip maximizer). You and your human intelligence are not magic. You're biological hardware and software that a lot of people are spending a lot of time and effort on reproducing in a digital format.
- oska 4y ago> You're biological hardware and software This is (materialistic) nihilism. Materialism is a philosophy and not a new one, but an exceedingly sterile one, in my view. If you want to take that philosophical position you can, but others are free to reject it (and most people do) because it is only a philosophical position, not a proved description of reality (how can it be?).
- WalterBright 4y agoImagine the devastation wrought by automatic looms, that put all the weavers out of a job! 97% of jobs used to be working on the farm. Now it's something like 2%.
- moffkalast 4y agoCan't wait for the economy that is 97% twitch streamers because that's all what humans are left qualified for. /s
- msm_ 4y agoYou joke, but an economy that is 97% artists (aka content creators) sounds... good? Isn't this the utopic end goal after we automate the scarcity out of our lifes?
- jordanbeiber 4y agoSure, with UBI. Otherwise not so much.
- moffkalast 4y agoIn theory it's great, in practice... who knows. The cynic in me would expect it to go worse than anyone could ever imagine. If everything is automated, why do you still need humans?
- pixl97 4y agoWe have more technology and more stuff than ever, yet it seems we've accomplished about zero in solving the human problems of greed and narcissism. Ted Faro is alive today. We just aren't sure which of the FRANK'S he's at.
- trafficante 4y agoHorizon: Zero Dawn was so compelling (to me) because of the outright horrifying plausibility of a gassed up tech CEO, convinced that software safeties were infallible, unleashes the consequences for their hubris upon the whole of humanity. Ted Faro was a horrible human being blinded by delusions of grandeur, but he wasn’t “evil” - he was even convinced he was saving humanity by ending the threat of both war and climate change. I don’t see GPT itself as representing a new Faro Plague, but I do see a lot of wannabe Ted Faros making the decisions at the top. If LLMs come even close to achieving their short-term potential, we’re unleashing a bigger destabilizing force on the world than the smartphone/social media combo - and the world of 202x seems blatantly incapable of absorbing that level of disruption.
- acuozzo 4y ago> GPT is only possible because it's been trained on the work humans have learned to do and then put out in the world. Which really makes you wonder if F/OSS was a good idea in the first place.
- csa 4y ago> I think a lot of our current sociological problems, problems associated with wealth inequality, etc., I see where you’re coming from, but is this really the main source of the inequality? Based on numbers relating to workers’ diminishing share of profits, it seems to be that the capital class has been able to take a bigger piece of the profit pie without sharing. In the past, companies have shared profits more widely due to benevolence (it happens), government edict (e.g., ww2 era), or social/political pressure (e.g., post-war boom). Fwiw, I think that the mid-20th century build up of the middle class was an anomaly (sadly), and perhaps we are just reverting to the norm in terms of capital class and worker class extremes. I see tons of super skilled folks still getting financially fucked by the capital class simply because there is no real option other than to try to attempt to become part of the capital class.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xp84 4y agoI think you and the one you're replying to are both very right. Yes, more of this money is going, instead of middle-class workers, straight to the capital class who own the "machines" that do the work people used to do. Except instead of it being a factory that makes industrial machines owned by some wealthy industrialist, the machines are things like Google and AWS and the owners are the small number of people with significant stock holdings. It's really striking though that a person graduating high school in say, 1970, could easily pick from a number of career choices even without doing college or even learning an in-demand trade, like plumbing, welding, etc. Factory work still existed and had a natural career progression that wasn't basically minimum wage, and the same went for retail. Sure, McDonalds burger flippers didn't expect then to own the restaurant in 10 years, but you could take lots of retail or clerical jobs, advance through hard work and support a family on those wages. Those are the days that are super gone and I totally agree with you both that something has changed for the worse for everyone who's not already wealthy.
- mbgerring 4y agoYou can still do that with plumbing and welding
- JamesAdir 4y agoYou are a founder of a startup. A notable VC wants to invest millions of dollars but insists that the contract will be in their language which is Finnish. Would you trust GPT to translate the contract or reach out to a professional human translator? We've got Google translate from 2006, and there are still millions of translators at work all around the world. I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss those jobs.
- parker_mountain 4y agoI don't think it's so simple. A few counter-notes - Google translate and its ilk have already significantly cut down the number of translators required for multinational companies. Google translate in 2006 is also a bad example, it really only got excellent in the past few years. - I would trust GPT to write the first draft, and then hire a translator to check it. That goes from many billable hours to one, or two. That is a material loss of work for said translator. - High profile translations, as your example is, are a sharp minority of existing translator jobs.
- mr_toad 4y agoOr there will be a lot more translations produced, because they are so cheap, and human translators will have more work checking them all.
- q845712 4y agoI was just using bing translate last night, and it was literally making up english words that do not exist - I tried to google for them to see if it was just some archaic word, and it was complete fabrication. So I dunno how many years are left before we all trust machine translation unflinchingly, but I agree today's not the day.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoTry it on GPT-4, not Google or Bing Translate: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35180715 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35180715
- mxkopy 4y agoWhat should happen is a thorough investigation of our assumptions about economics and see if they hold true. 20-30 years ago saying "just get a robot to do it" would've been met with great cynicism, but now it's not that unthinkable. Especially once we apply what we learn to robotics - at that point doing things at scale is just playing an RTS
- pxc 4y ago> I mean, does anyone think that things like human translators, medical transcriptionists, court reporters, etc. will exist as jobs at all in 10-20 years? Maybe 1-2 years? It's fine to say "great, that can free up people for other thing", but given our current economic systems, how are these people supposed to eat? And it doesn't mean that the replacements will be much better, or even as good as the Humana they replace. They will probably suck in ways that will become familiar and predictable, and at the same time irritating and inescapable. Think of the outsourced, automated voice systems at your doctor's office, self-checkout at the grocery store, those touchscreen kiosks at McDonalds, etc. I already find myself wanting to scream > GIVE ME A FUCKING HUMAN BEING every now and then. That's only going to get worse.
- hd95489 4y agoA lot of those jobs exist for legal compliance reasons and are cost center. Every company in the world wants to make them as shitty and cheap as possible but remain compliant. Right now the floor is minimum wage but soon it will be gpt chat
- lezojeda 4y ago[dead]
- fsckboy 4y ago> how are these people supposed to eat? not only am I sure people will have no trouble eating, I'm willing to wager obesity goes up i'm not teasing, I don't think your worry is warranted
- chaostheory 4y ago> I mean, does anyone think that things like human translators, medical transcriptionists, court reporters, etc. will exist as jobs at all in 10-20 years? Before mechanical alarm clocks, there were people paid to tap on windows to wake them up.
- WalterBright 4y agoThink of people who have jobs like archaeology, digging up bones. The only way these jobs can exist is if technology has taken over much of the grunt work of production. As for human translators, the need for them far, far exceeds the number of them. Have you ever needed translation help? I sure have, but no human translator was available or was too expensive.
- layer8 4y ago> was too expensive. This is probably the real problem. Translators are payed shit nowadays for what is a really high-skill job. I have translators in the extended family who had to give up on that line of work because the pay wouldn’t sustain them anymore.
- adelie 4y agoyep, exactly. the issue isn't that there will no longer be a need for human translators - machine translation makes subtle mistakes that legal/technical fields will need a human to double-check. the issue is that many translation jobs will, and already are, being replaced with 'proofread machine translation output' jobs that simply don't pay enough. translation checking is careful, detailed work that often takes almost as much time as translating passages yourself, yet it pays a third or less of the rate because 'the machine is doing most of the work.'
- layer8 4y agoI don’t think it’s really because “the machine is doing most of the work”, but because there’s no good way for clients to assess the quality of the supplemental human work, and therefore the market gets flooded with subpar translators who do the task sloppily on the cheap, in a way that still passes as acceptable.
- achr2 4y agoWhich is exactly what this new breed of AI does - create a facsimile that is good enough to devalue the human equivalent.
- dogcomplex 4y agoIt is very obvious there is a mass unemployment wave coming - or at least a mass "retraining" wave, though the new jobs "teaching AIs" or whatever remain to be seen. I hope everyone currently just questioning whether this will happen now is prepared to state it with conviction in the coming months and fight for some sort of social protection program for all these displaced people, because the profits from this new world aren't getting distributed without a fight.
- psychphysic 4y agoIf not unemployment and retraining then a lot of people are going to need to miraculously become better at their jobs. I somehow imagine it'll be the worst of both worlds but I'm a glass half empty kind of guy.
- moffkalast 4y agoWell it won't be miraculously, it'll be by using the AI tools to augment their work if anything. But probably unemployment.
- JohnFen 4y agoRetraining only works if there are jobs available.
- KevinGlass 4y agoAI doesn't have to better, or even 90% as good. It just has to be cheaper.
- carlosjobim 4y agoThere should be no tax payer money to these people. AI can never perform physical labour, so there is still a market for physical labour open for those replaced by AI. There will still be people working physical jobs as there are today, and you demand that they support those who are too lazy to work a physical job? No, they have to work as well. Everybody who doesn't have to do physical labour - including me - should be happy and grateful for that privilege - not try to rob even more from physical labourers, who in the end, create everything.
- jll29 4y ago> Imagine if you spent your entire career working on NLP, and now find GPT-4 will run rings around whatever you've done. What do you do now? I have been doing NLP since 1993. Before ca. 1996, there were mostly rule-based systems that were just toys. They lacked robustness. Then statistical systems came up and things like spell-checking (considering context when doing it), part of speech tagging and eventually even parsing started to work. Back then, people could still only analyze sentences with fewer than 40 words - the rest was often cut off. Then came more and more advanced machine learning models (decision trees, HMMs, CRFs), first a whole zoo, and then support vector regressors (SVM/SVR) ate everything else for breakfast. Then in machine learning a revival of neural networks happened, because better training algorithms were discovered, more data became available and cheap GPUs were suddenly available because kids needed them for computer games. This led to what some call the ¨deep learning revolution¨. Tasks like speech recognition where people for decades tried to squeeze out another half percent drop in error rate suddenly made huge jumps, improving quality by 35% - so jaws dropped. (But today's models like BERT still only can process 512 words of text.) So it is understandable that people worry at several ends. To lose jobs, to render ¨NLP redundant¨. I think that is not merited. Deep neural models have their own set of problems, which need to be solved. In particular, lack of transparency and presence of different types of bias, but also the size and energy consumption. Another issue is that for many tasks, no much data is actually available. The big corps like Google/Meta etc. push the big ¨foundational¨ models because in the consumer space there is ample data available. But there are very important segments (notably in the professional space - applications for accountants, lawyers, journalists, pharmacologists - all of which I have conducted projects in/for), where training data can be constructed for a lot of money, but it will never reach the size of the set of today`s FB likes. There will always be a need for people who build bespoke systems or customize systems for particular use cases or languages, so my bet is things will stay fun and exciting. Also note that "NLP" is a vast field that includes much more than just word based language models. The field of propositional (logical) semantics, which is currently disconnected from the so-called foundational models, is much more fascinating than, say, chatGPT if you ask me. The people there, linguist-logicians like Johan Bos identify laws that restrict what a sentence can mean, given its structure, and rules how to map from sentences like "The man gave the girl a rose" to their functor-argument structure - something like "give(man_0, rose_1)¨ - which models the "who did what to whom?". When such symbolic approaches are integrated with neural foundational models, there will be a much bigger breakthrough than what we are seeing today (mark my words!). Because these tools, for instance Lambda Discourse Representation Theory and friends, permit you to represent how the meaning of "man bites dog" is different from "dog bites man". So whereas today`s models SEEM a bit intelligent, but are actually only sophisticated statistical parrots, the future will bring something more principled. Then the ¨ "hallucinations" of models will stop. I am glad I am in the field of NLP - it has been getting more exciting every year since 1993, and the best time still lies ahead!
- yyyk 4y agoThere are three 'markets' for translators: * Verbal translation, where accuracy is usually important enough to want to also have a human onboard since humans still have an easier time with certain social clues. * High-culture translation, where there's a lot to personal choice and explaining it. GPT can give out many versions but can't yet sufficiently explain its reasoning, nor would its tastes necessarily match that of humans. * Technical translations for manuals and such. This market will be under severe threat from GPTs, though for high-accuracy cases one would still want a human editor just in case. All in all, GPT will contract the market, but many human translators will be fine. There's still areas where you'd still want a human, and deskilling isn't a bug threat - a human can decide to immerse and get experience directly, and many will still do so by necessity.
- jll29 4y agoA Chinese washing machine manufacturer may not hesitate to use MT (Google Translate, chatGPT or otherwise) to translate the instruction manual to English. In some cases, the quality may not go down or even go up (we've probably all seen some pretty bad human translations). "AI" is not the only automation that threatens translation jobs: translation memories (plain ol' databases that remember past translations) have killed a lot of business for human translators, namely re-translating new versions of products, where not a lot has changed. Nowadays, they only get paid for the sentences that were modified compared to the previous version ("the diff"). SDL Trados is an example of this simple approach that is extremely effective, and used heavily e.g. by the European Commission's translation service.
- bloppe 4y agoTechnology never affects the economy in isolation. It acts in concert with policy. Broadly speaking, inequality rises when capital is significantly more valuable than labor. The value of either depends on taxes, the education system, technology, and many other factors. We're never going to stop technology. We just have to adjust the other knobs and levers to make its impact positive.
- malermeister 4y ago> given our current economic systems, how are these people supposed to eat? I've said it before and I'll say it again. This right here is the crux of the issue. The only way people get to eat is if we change the economic systems. Capitalism supercharged by AI will lead to misery for almost everyone, with a few Musks, Bezoses and Thiels being our neofeudal overlords. The only hope is a complete break in economic systems, towards a techno-utopian socialism. AI could free us from having to do work to survive and usher in a Star Trek-like vision of the future where people are free to pursue their passions for their own sake. We're at a fork in the road. We need to make sure we take the right path.
- mostlysimilar 4y agoIt will take massive cooperation. Given how rough it was to make it through the pandemic... how can we hope to come together on something this daunting?
- malermeister 4y agoI hope I'm wrong, but I worry that the change will come the same way it came to Tsarist Russia or to the Ancien Régime. Things will get worse and worse until they boil over.
- jMyles 4y ago> given our current economic systems What can possibly be the benefit of requiring this constraint? Remove the idea that this is necessary and watch how much relaxation comes to the deliberation on this topic. "Current economic systems" will simply have to yield. Along with states. This has been obvious for decades now. Deep breaths, everybody. :-)
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> What can possibly be the benefit of requiring this constraint? It's not "requiring this constraint". If you have some plausible pathway to get from our current system to some "Star Trek-like nirvana", I'm all ears. Hand-wavy-ness doesn't cut it. > "Current economic systems" will simply have to yield. Why? For most of human history there were a few overloads and everyone else was starving half the time. Even look at now. I'm guessing you probably live a decent existence in a decent country, but meanwhile billions of people around the world (who can't compete skills-wise with upper income countries) barely eke out an existence. For the world that just lived through the pandemic, do you honestly see systems changing when worldwide cooperation and benevolence is a prerequisite?
- eternalban 4y ago> how are these people supposed to eat? My gut feeling is that AI is the 'social historic change' that will make UBI politically viable and a reality.
- timoth3y 4y agoThe problem is not that automation will eliminate our jobs. The problem is that we have created an economy where that is a bad thing.
- elwell 4y agoThe problem is that humans are often selfish.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoI don't think it's the economy, it's the policy. Automating a shit-ton of jobs is great for the economy. The economy is just fine if 90% of people are starving because big corps are saving shit-tons of money. The government of a wealthy country should ensure that its citizens are able to eat, and have a sheltered place to sleep, without them needing to work. Because the way things are going, there won't be enough work to go around. Even now, with the supposed "labour shortage" there are record numbers of homeless people, and people living paycheck-to-paycheck. Housing is more unaffordable than ever. Minimum wage is not keeping up with the economic realities. Governments need to step in; they need to change policy so big corps are paying more taxes, and that tax goes to a basic income that can cover the cost of housing and the cost of food. Maybe not right away, maybe it starts at $100/month. But eventually the goal should be to get everyone on a basic income that can cover the necessities, then if they want to be able to enjoy luxuries (concerts, gourmet food, hobbies, streaming services, etc.) they can choose to work.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoLooking around here in Amsterdam, there is a lot of work to be done. And all the places that aren’t as nice, there is a LOT of work to be done. Computational irreducibility combined with human insatiability combined with ethics entails: a lot of work to be done. Everyone needs to get to work, we aren’t done yet. If robots could do all the work… well, god bless. There is SO much work to do. That makes me think the issue is not “robots taking jobs” but the focus and intention of the collective. Any new hire is WAY more valuable now that they can use chatGPT. So why aren’t we hiring more people? Well, one small issue: notice how you get taxed for hiring people a lot more than buying tech? That’s probably something to be fixed.
- xwdv 4y agoEven in a world of perfect AI, there will be plenty of jobs. Anything involving movement and manipulation of matter will still require humans for the time being. We’re not at a point yet where an intelligent an AI could simply build you a house without human labor involved. Many of these jobs are cheap and easy to understand and quick to train in. These aren’t the kind of jobs people probably wanted, but they’ll be there.
- yoyohello13 4y agoNow 90% of humanity can toil for 12 hours a day in the fields to support the 10% who own all the machines. Super awesome!
- xwdv 4y agoWhen 90% of people are toiling in fields, there won’t be as many complaints I’d think because there would be a lot more equality among the 90%, vs the 50/50 split that we have today.
- eggsmediumrare 4y agoYou're describing feudalism
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoAs other comment said, you're describing feudalism. So why are you making this sound like it's desireable?
- xwolfi 4y agoCome on, we could do it when we abandonned the horses, we can do it again.
- mitthrowaway2 4y agoDo you mean "the glue factory is always hiring"?
- UncleEntity 4y agoUnless you’re the horse.
- screye 4y ago> human translators, medical transcriptionists, court reporters Yes, they will be all called 'ai data labellers'. For a long time, "People don't just want jobs, they want good jobs" was the slogan of industries that automated the boring stuff. Now AI is suddenly good at all the jobs people actually want and the only thing it can't do is self-improve. In an AI future, mediocre anything will not exist anymore. Either you are brilliant enough to be sampling from 'out of distribution', or you're in the other 99 percent normies that follow the standard : "learn -> imitate -> internalize -> practice" cycle. That other 99% is now and eternally inferior to an AI.
- UmYeahNo 4y ago>In an AI future, mediocre anything will not exist anymore. Right! Aren't we all mediocre before we're excellent? Isn't every entry level job some version of trying to get past being mediocre? i.e. Isn't a jr developer "mediocre" compared to a senior dev? If AI replaces the jr dev, how will anyone become a senior dev if they never got the chance to gain experience to become less mediocre?
- pyuser583 4y agoThe problem starts long before AI takes the jobs. I used to do a job that was eventually automated. We did the one and only thing the computer couldn’t do - again and again in a very mechanical fashion. It was a shit job. You might get promoted to supervisor - but that was like being a supervisor at McDonalds. Why not treat the job seriously? Why didn’t the company use it as a way to recruit talent? Why didn’t the workers unionize? Because we all knew it would be automated anyway. We were treated like robots, and we treated the org like it was run by robots. There’s a huge shadow over the economy that treats most new jobs like shit jobs.
- Tiktaalik 4y ago> does anyone think that things like human translators, medical transcriptionists, court reporters, etc. will exist as jobs at all in 10-20 years? Maybe 1-2 years? Maybe the very, very basic transcription/translation stuff might go away, but arguably this race to the bottom market was already being killed by google translate as bad as it is anyway. In areas where quality is required (eg. localizing video games from japanese to english and vis versa) people would be (justifiably) fussy about poor localization quality even when the translation was being done by humans, so I have to imagine that people will continue to be fussy and there will still be significant demand for quality job done by people who aren't just straight translating text, but localizing text for a different audience from another culture.
- qiqitori 4y agoYou have no chance to survive make your time.
- anileated 4y ago> The state of AI progress makes it impossible for humans in many fields to keep up The way it works, someone would have to produce more original training data in the first place. In long term, it is AI that has to keep up, not the other way around. > wealth inequality Microsoft, OpenAI run closed for-profit LLMs that are inherently only possible thanks to creative work of all the people that might stand to lose jobs now. Not only it should be clear where the driving force for rising wealth inequality is going to be going forward—these companies’ effectively scraping original works of living humans and repackaging them for profit should be in violation of intellectual property law, if it isn’t already. Perhaps more people should start adding two and two together.
- pixl97 4y agoIf you think the IP law that is already making the rich even richer is what's going to save us you're highly confused. And if you think that AI is going to stay at LLMs and not eventually evolve into self learning/self modifying systems you are shortsighted.
- anileated 4y ago> If you think the IP law that is already making the rich even richer On the contrary, the confusion is all yours. This is literally the reason plenty of photographers, illustrators were able to make money, as just one example. Without this any major publication could just grab whatever photo or artwork they saw fit, but they didn’t precisely because there’s such thing as IP law. Before you argue for some form of communism without any intellectual property, ask yourself why people produced creative work in the first place (you know, all those works thanks to which an LLM can do its thing). Could it be because the fruit of their work was considered their intellectual property? As in, they were paid for it and were in control of it? Now as soon as LLMs are trained on that work and can suddenly can produce derivatives cheaper, techbros are suddenly all like “let’s pretend IP law is some unfair thing that only benefitted the rich”. Those publishers now pay OpenAI/Microsoft for those very photographs and illustrations, that were taken for free, while the very people who created them would be losing jobs and gigs. Similar to book authors and other creative industries. Do you really think this works in favor of decreasing the wealth gap? Not having to pay original creators for their work and instead paying a fraction of a penny to Microsoft while those creators starve? Aren’t you living in perpetual cognitive dissonance from these mental gymnastics? No surprise non-tech people and especially creatives hate tech people more and more.
- awb 4y agoAnd there’s the fact that many tasks don’t need to be perfect. AI is ideal for doing 90% of the legwork in those use cases. Or you could still have a human in the loop, for example a CTO reviewing their AI developer’s code. But now you can pay one person instead of 10. That said, these tools still need some domain knowledge. It’s not at the point yet where anyone off the street can use it to accomplish an unfamiliar task. There’s an old story about someone charging $1,000 to fix a machine. They did it in 10 seconds and the client complained. The consultant said “I get paid for knowing how to fix it”. The same might be true for knowing how to prompt AI.
- Blackthorn 4y ago> It's fine to say "great, that can free up people for other thing", but given our current economic systems, how are these people supposed to eat? Yeah, exactly this. The funny thing about economic upheavals and industrial revolutions is that while people might get reallocated eventually (say, 30 years), that doesn't provide any comfort to the people who are getting upheaved now.
- evo_9 4y agoYeah – first off, I agree with everything you are saying. I would just add that this is a larger problem just starting to come into focus, which is this: over a long enough period of time virtually ALL jobs will be eliminated. There was a time when man thought – let's make our lives easier by inventing 'tools' and eventually, we will have 'tools' so advance we'll sit around and discuss philosophy like we're all Greek aristocrats. Or something like that. Somewhere toward that goal we became overly fixated with money/wealth and the pursuit of endless profits. Meanwhile, companies continue to post record profits while downsizing - gee, I wonder why. The reality is, we need to start to figure out and move toward a new way to run the world. I always semi-land in a kind of Star Trek: TNG 'creation socialism', or whatever it is they have as a means of structuring a society, where you have a replicator that can create almost anything for you. They also have 'intellect machines' that are often used to build things from just describing what you want, or in other situation to dig into engineering problems, etc. Things that we are now starting to do with our new GPT tech. Putting all this another way – how are all these corporations going to continue to exist when there are no customers to buy their products, because there are no jobs left. Basically, money as we know it is going to go away, we won't be a society of limited resources anymore. And again as a reminder, this isn't something I'm saying is 2-5 or even 50 years away (maybe?). What I'm saying is that set the timeline however you want, it is going to happen, and we need to start to plan for it now. Based on what's happening already, we're likely at the start of a 20 – 50 year transition towards a new form of society entirely.
- nmeagent 4y ago> Basically, money as we know it is going to go away, we won't be a society of limited resources anymore. I doubt it. There will probably always be some scarcity. Even if we remove (or effectively remove) scarcity of physical resources or energy, there is still only a limited amount of time. You could base an entire economy on time and you'd still need some kind of a medium of exchange. Even in Star Trek TNG, every schmo on Earth doesn't have access to Federation supercomputing clusters or their own starship.
- Mizoguchi 4y agoI think the panic about AI suddenly taking people's jobs is a bit exaggerated, and even if it does it is impossible to tell what the consequences will be in the long term. Most likely society will reorganize around it and new professions that don't exist today will be created. And we haven't even considered the positive impact of AI. It could for example accelerate the process of drug manufacturing and genetic therapies that will considerably increase human's lifespan, triggering another form of social reorganization. So it is really impossible to tell with certainty how the world will look like in 50 or 100 years from now. I am optimistic and would like to think it will be a much better place, not necessarily perfect and just in every aspect, inequality and armed conflicts will probably continue to exist, but overall it will be better than it is today. There was a lot of fear during the industrial revolution, prompting many intellectuals to have a very grim outlook of the future, particularly when it comes to social issues (yes you, Marx). But ultimately, if you look at the data compiled decades later, such as GDP and life expectancy around the world, it is undeniable that social and economic changes resulting from the industrial revolution made the world a much better place. Not a perfect one, but certainly much better than it was (at least for humans).
- bgroat 4y agoSomething curious that I've noticed is that the people who I see that are MOST excited are in tech. When I show ChatGPT to a lay person they don't really care. When I show it to a professional copywriter they say that if they submitted this content to a client they would lose the client. I'm reminded of when my son was learning to talk and everything he said seemed brilliant and coherent to me. To any stranger it sounded like gibberish. I think GPT is like my son, and all tech people are like excited parents. Maybe the kid will learn to speak like an adult, but it can't yet
- satvikpendem 4y agoPerhaps those in tech can simply see further out. It reminds me of the advent of the internet, the lay person also didn't care, until websites and web apps were made that catered to their needs. But the people who made those sites and apps were precisely the tech people who could see beyond the lay person's idea of what the internet was. So too with AI.
- pedrosorio 4y agoSo too with NFTs and web3 /s
- jsutton 4y agoWithout the sarcasm, yes :)
- satvikpendem 4y agoAI actually does something useful, Web3 doesn't.
- foobiekr 4y agoPerhaps they have Gell-Mann amnesia and a case of engineer’s disease.
- bgroat 4y agoThis is the sort of stock line, and we're inclined to believe it because we're all in tech. But go back on HN a decade and be really honest. Are we any better than average at forecasting? I'm starting to think that being on the bleeding edge and seeing so many possible alternate futures actually makes us worse
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ilyt 4y ago> 1. You don't need to take everyone's job. You just need to take a shitload of people's jobs. I think a lot of our current sociological problems, problems associated with wealth inequality, etc., are due to the fact that lots of people no longer have competitive enough skills because technology made them obsolete. I think the problem is that money saved from making those jobs redundant is not going back to the society but few heads on top. That's the fundamental problem, company moves money from payroll to tech that replaces the people and any savings are entirely company's profits. And then they go ahead on tax avoiding spree so increased profits don't even flow back to the society
- jliptzin 4y agoIsn't this just a specific case of the general risk of devoting your career to pushing the envelope (science/research/business, etc)? You can work 30 years on a problem, finally come out with a solution only to find you're a week late and someone already published/patented exactly what you independently came up with. Then the only thing you have to show for your 30 years of work is everyone calling you a copycat. Weren't there other physicists like a week behind Einstein with relativity? And probably tons of other examples.
- hnxx 4y agoFor the translator job, that is already the reality. I saw Chinese students major in English and translation post comments in social media that company are already asking the employees to first ask ChatGPT and then review the response. It's true that there are few top students can do better in translating than ChatGPT, but it was told that only students are outstanding in both English and Chinese can do it. There are hundreds of thousands of people making their living on translating, and now most of them need to find something else to survive now.
- mistrial9 4y agothis is partly true but not accurate in important ways.. The result of ChatGPT depends on the domain of the language. Technical reasoning based on many parts of input, is what the machine was designed for.. human language A to human language B depends on specific models built over the last ten years or so.. But if you subtract those two.. language structure and technical structure, you are left with giant holes in the way humans talk, interact and create. Overall I would say that people who translate formal documents are in trouble yes.. people who translate to no-loyalty cost-sensitive markets like corporate ads for products or travel recreation things.. are in trouble. But there are many other kinds of communication, and therefore translation.
- karmasimida 4y agoAI is Pandora’s box, once it is out it is out. We are into a new reality and no need to lament the old one, because it is gone anyway
- winternett 4y agoI see the real story at the end of the day as "Ai will take a sht load of jobs from everyone until it screws up royally, and then companies will need to rehire at a higher rate... We keep committing seppuku by emerging technology to where hubris becomes a large scale financial or even a physical crash, and the smartest ones of us avoid the knee jerk reaction to quick over-adoption of new and unpredictable tech. The main problem is that there are so many forces pushing us towards adoption of whatever is packaged and marketed most heavily, and we need to incorporate better rollbacks and ways of gradually adopting new tech. Testing is also a quickly dying art, as seen with Twitter... This will be our downfall if not properly reigned in. The people (self proclaimed tech leaders) who we exalt have already shown us that they are impulsive, and driven by greed, vanity, and ego. If we continue to let them act as "golden children", and continue to make them more and more wealthy, there will be no going back to fairness in our world. Tax them fairly, hold them accountable, stop letting them influence politics, stop electing rich people and people with conflicts of interest, and let everyone have a voice and equal opportunity to climb into responsibility based on their incremental successes... We're not doing any of that at all right now -- it greatly worries me.
- qazpot 4y ago> won't take everyone's job, it will just open up new areas for new jobs. This was true for Industrial Automation when machines automated physical work and humans could do knowledge work. Now machines are on the verge of automating knowledge there would be no work left for humans.
- adastra22 4y ago> I mean, does anyone think that things like human translators, medical transcriptionists, court reporters, etc. Bad examples. Those are instances where you need human beings to provide interpretation of the context surrounding the translation/transcription, and where strict regulatory regimes are in place. Those are likely the last to be automated.