4 ms·
The article starts off well, with a contrast between work environments where expansion is rewarded and those that end up fighting among themselves for control o
by pjc50 4y ago
The article starts off well, with a contrast between work environments where expansion is rewarded and those that end up fighting among themselves for control of an existing revenue stream. The latter phenomenon is common in petro-states, for example; arguably that is why Russia is so dysfunctional.
.. then the author takes a sharp right turn to blame it on "diversity", i.e. the idea that people who aren't white guys should be given a shot at the wealth, and it goes downhill from there. The rest of the blog is devoted to complaining about e.g. the existence of women's basketball or cosplaying aristocracy of the early 20th century.
(diversity discussion on HN is .. not likely to go well)
- fuckyc284 4y ago[flagged]
- bsenftner 4y agoI suspect you missed the point: not "diversity", that is not what the author is blaming. He blames the cultural shift from the revenue creation to revenue management with little to no attention outside the firm, as if the prior institutionalized revenue streams are forevermore assets. The author picks "diversity" has his "economic indicator" of this systematic transition.
- pjc50 4y ago> The author picks "diversity" has his "economic indicator" of this systematic transition. .. which is an instant red flag. They could have talked about e.g. Google's many chat apps or tendency to shut down products, or Facebook's abandoned "metaverse" project, as indicators that the company has switched from providing new ways to win revenue and serve users to new ways to spend revenue on conspicuous consumption. Instead they rant about "diversity". To expand on the author's metaphor, the problem with the Wild West is that some of the "building" was in fact theft, murder, and genocide; and the problem with Versailles was the incredible conspicuous consumption while failing to address the problems and starvation outside the magic castle walls, leading to an uprising of the public and middle-elites which got the entire aristocracy murdered. The unsympathetic reaction to the SVB crisis is a hint to SV that some of the proletariat might be massing outside the walls. Their approach to "diversity", "ESG", and other social issues is the beginning of a glimmer of recognition that they have a responsibility to broader society, but combined with a very poor ability to actually listen to people they consider not as smart.
- DeathArrow 4y ago>and the problem with Versailles was the incredible conspicuous consumption while failing to address the problems and starvation outside the magic castle walls, leading to an uprising of the public and middle-elites which got the entire aristocracy murdered. The author feels that big corps are not focused on the reason they exist but simply they are concerned to distractions outside of their objective.
- RandomLensman 4y agoBig corporations need to be seen to address certain things at certain times - so they are not in a vacuum. The c-suite doesn't have a free pass to ignore the world around them because their shareholders won't either.
- dash2 4y agoI think “red flag” is a bit of a red flag…. Whatever you think about diversity discourse, it’s surely a reasonable point that supporting diversity is not in fact how Google or FB got rich. Presumably now that times are tough, they are having to focus more on their core competencies.
- RandomLensman 4y agoTotally reasonable. But as a large established company their core competencies change a bit: Protecting existing revenue streams is a different skill set from creating new ones - and now they need both and the former might indeed have more of an "Versailles vibe" about it.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoSet aside your political bone to pick for a few seconds and think about it. The author isn't "blaming" anything on diversity. Diversity is just the "thing of the minute" in the context in which the author is writing about. In the 1950s he could write the same article and substitute in anticommunism. The "thing of the minute" will probably always be some broadly appealing subset of the culture and politics of the society and time in which the organization exits. It doesn't matter what the virtue everyone is professing is. What matters is that the virtue is at best ancillary to whatever the organization's goals are and resources directed at it are resources not directed at keeping the business running and prepared for the future.
- DeathArrow 4y agoIf you are an investor would you buy stock in a company whose output is wealth or in a company whose output is diversity?
- bryanrasmussen 4y agothat sure is pithy but as a general rule every company I've ever encountered says that their output is wealth, and some of them say that diversity is part of a strategy for achieving wealth. I would probably invest in a company whose overall strategy for achieving wealth sounds the most likely to succeed.
- 988747 4y ago[dead]
- pjc50 4y agoSometimes ESG is specifically asked for by investors, all the way up to BlackRock. It depends on your investment timeframes, as well. And a presumption of invincibility. Versailles was wealth-maximising until it was cancelled by the woke mob.
- throw1234651234 4y agoCalling people fighting for REAL issues "woke" is incorrect. Poverty is real and affected the majority of the population. Current woke issues do not affect the majority of the population, to say the least.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ookdatnog 4y agoAre you implying that issues that don't affect the majority of the population aren't real issues?
- daltont 4y agoStarted out interesting but devolved into a anti-"woke" soapbox. Can you prove that attention to diversity negatively impacted companies? The only evidence here seems to be more of a correlation-causation fallacy Sure one can overdo "diversity" to the point of hiring incompetent people for diversity's sake. But striving for diversity can also be a way of finding and developing untapped human potential in less represented groups.
- meany 4y agoI agree with your review. I enjoyed the Wild West vs Versailles take, but then the 100% focus on diversity took it sideways. The politics at these large companies is still driven by getting senior leadership to like you and see that you are moving their agenda forward. But even in that case, it’s not 100% politics, for the most part you need to be able to both deliver and play the game to advance. His whole focus on diversity was not well reasoned or an accurate portrayal of what goes on at these companies. Source: I have worked in big tech
- RestlessMind 4y ago> "diversity", i.e. the idea that people who aren't white guys should be given a shot at the wealth As a non-white guy, I find the "diversity" propaganda in SV over the last 5-6 years problematic. If that was truly about giving everyone a shot at wealth and increasing inclusion as you say, I would wholeheartedly support it. But after observing it closely for many years, I just saw empty virtue-signalling and no concrete action. Moreoever, there was no actual "diversity" of inputs and opinions - rather it was all groupthink.