5 ms·
Highways fatalities up 22%. Our smartphone addiction is a big reason why
- pascoej 4y agoTexting and driving ought to be treated similarly to a felony DUI.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoTexting and driving used to be a lot safer. It was easy to write texts without looking at my Razr. Probably every other T9 phone too.
- notch898a 4y ago[flagged]
- mc32 4y agoCan’t mobOSes disable all functionality on movement above X/mph —perhaps allow it only if another device is in proximity (such as passenger presence, in public transit, etc), except for hands-free voice calls?
- q845712 4y agoimo there's already a bunch of inconsistent nanny-state stuff when trying to use a smartphone as a passenger/navigator. There's things I'm not allowed to do without unplugging the phone briefly, and there's also things I'm allowed to do that absolutely require looking down at a zero-haptic-feedback touchscreen. It seems like there's always corner cases that aren't considered (in your proposal above, what if the navigator doesn't have a phone because they're a child, or because their phone ran out of batteries? What happens when the sensors/algorithms are wrong about how fast we're going? What happens when the sensors are wrong about whether or not there's another device? What if that second device keeps disappearing and re-apparing while somebody tries to do a multiple step operation?) ... Trying to build some water-tight mechanism to keep us out of trouble but also with access to full functionality "when we can use it responsibly" is an endless rabbit hole. IMO it feels like a systemic problem asking for a systemic solution. Whether we think that solution is self-driving cars, rail travel, walkable cities, or taxis probably says as much about our politics as anything else though.
- mc32 4y agoI think the failsafe is to not allow anything beside voice calls if it detects movement. Phones while on motion are a convenience, not a need. Before the 90s very few people had mobile phones and they got places fine.
- Gigachad 4y agoYou think all train and bus passengers should have their phones locked because of moronic drivers? Better option is to roll out the phone detection cameras and hand out 10 year license suspensions.
- Noumenon72 4y agoThat is absolutely false. I didn't even own a car in the 2000s because going anywhere meant a bunch of printed maps, bad GPS, and getting lost. Google Maps liberated me to a whole world of restaurants, side trips, urgent plan changes, and last-minute tourism. Plus podcasts, voice memos, and time sensitive texts. It kills me that safetyism is throwing out all those babies with the bathwater.
- perilunar 4y ago> printed maps, bad GPS, and getting lost That’s on you. Like almost everyone over the age of 50, I learnt to drive before mobile phones and GPS, and it was fine. Paper maps and street directories worked well enough. Getting lost was uncommon, and no big deal.
- triceratops 4y ago> inconsistent nanny-state stuff Your phone isn't the state.
- q845712 4y agolol fair enough.
- scoofy 4y agoSo, with kid gloves? Look state by state at DUI laws. Many if not most won’t end leave you with a suspended license, much less jailed.
- nerdchum 4y agoThere's no breathalyzer for smartphones though. They need some way to prove it.
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://bgr.com/lifestyle/phone-detecting-cameras-trial/ https://bgr.com/lifestyle/phone-detecting-cameras-trial/
- bobmaxup 4y agoSeems like it passed the trial: https://roadsafety.transport.nsw.gov.au/stayingsafe/mobilephones/technology.html#:~:text=Since%20commencing%20enforcement%20on%201%20March%202020%2C%20the%20MPDC%20program%20has,offences%20(during%20the%20period%201%20March%202020%20to%2031%20December%202022) https://roadsafety.transport.nsw.gov.au/stayingsafe/mobileph....
- Gigachad 4y agoThese are being rolled out across Australia. I believe they use computer vision to filter down the data and then pass it on to a human for manual verification. The proof is then a photo of you with a phone in hand.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoI don't believe for a second that after the initial rollout the system won't be tuned for an "acceptable" false positive rate. Once a penal colony always a penal colony... (Not to say that a large majority of Western European and large minority of US jurisdictions won't try to do the same damn thing.)
- nerdchum 4y agoMaybe in Australia where they had Covid camps, something like that could fly but I don't see that flying in America. they can't make it illegal to check GPS or look at a map or change the radio station and they can't prove you were doing anything more than that.
- vba616 4y agoWhat does texting and driving actually mean? I simply can't read messages and type with my fingers if I wanted to, while moving. Do people really do that without immediately crashing? Or is using Google Maps with Android Auto and tapping to view incoming texts what should be a felony? If looking away from the road is the problem, then we should prohibit any controls in the center console for climate control or radios, and...passengers?
- dghlsakjg 4y agoThere are plenty of people that absolutely do exactly that. When I was younger and dumber I used to do literally that. Get a text message, read it, and respond to it, while driving. With a stick shift, too. I can't believe I never hurt anyone doing this. In BC, Canada, where I now live, this is prosecuted rather aggressively as 'distracted driving'. First ticket is in the neighborhood of $400 + required increase in premiums, and the threshold is touching your phone or having it within reach and not in a cradle. A second offense within a year can lead to a suspended license. It certainly shows. When I go down to the states, it is noticeable how many people I can see interacting with their phones compared to BC.
- Noumenon72 4y agoI can easily believe you never hurt anyone doing this, as conditions that lead to an accident are rare and often predictable. For example, you probably never answered a text while going through a roundabout, but restricted it to straight sections of road with a clear view ahead and no nearby cars. This increased you risk, but from an extremely small base.
- climb_stealth 4y agoThere are people driving on the road that are periodically looking down at their phone to text. For x seconds at a time. It boggles my mind whenever I see it. Kind of makes me want to chuck something at them. I'm sure everyone has been in a situation where they are not paying attention. But I think the danger with texting is that it happens more often. It is unlikely to be just one message. Which makes it more likely to result in an accident.
- Clubber 4y ago>Texting and driving ought to be treated similarly to a felony DUI. And that's how we have a police state. Honestly, emotions and laws really don't mix, that's how we have more people incarcerated both per capita and in total numbers than any other country in the world. "Super-predators," gets votes, but the repercussions were pretty horrible. Something much less horrible would be to make gasoline super expensive like in Europe, or lower the speed limit to a speed that is much less likely to cause fatalities, or do an old fashioned marketing / awareness push. The More You Know. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_More_You_Know https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_More_You_Know Also, the article seems to be speculating on the cause: >How many of those deaths involved distracted driving? >“It’s much bigger than the data show,” said Bruce Landsberg, vice chairman of the National Transportation Safety Board. Data collection methods are so riddled with problems, he said, that reliable estimates are difficult if not impossible. So it's bigger than the data shows, but reliable estimates are difficult or impossible, so it seems he's talking out his ass. Maybe it's because many more people were working at home in 2021-2022.
- lisasays 4y agoAnd that's how we have a police state. No, that's how we have a slippery-slope argument. Studies have shown that texting while driving is about a high a risk factor as drinking alcohol. If not classed as a felony (and intrinsically more difficult to control) - the state should at least do something to seriously discourage people from doing it.
- Clubber 4y ago[flagged]
- lisasays 4y ago[flagged]
- Clubber 4y agoI think making texting and driving a felony is an absurd emotional overreaction and would cause more harm than good. I think we have many laws on the books that are absurd emotional overreactions that put a lot of non-criminals in the system, and frankly, it disgusts me. I think people who are proponents of that either aren't very thoughtful, or are just outright cruel, or perhaps both. Does that clear it up for you Lisa?
- codevark 4y ago[dead]
- riffic 4y agorail is a safe investment to make for our future. a good counterargument here to a thread such as this one from yesterday griping about the ballooning costs of CA HSR https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35157023 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35157023
- ecshafer 4y agoRail is a great investment. The US, and California especially, does a lot of self inflicted wounds between strict zoning requirements, unnecessary environmental assessments, priority to vehicles, endless nimby local meetings, etc.
- uoaei 4y agoThis article is only about the US. I would be interested to see comparisons in app usage statistics between countries compared to similar highway fatality statistics for those countries. For many people in many countries that aren't the US, trading [Whatsapp] voice memos is one of the only ways people interact with each other through their phones. I would imagine that chatting with your friends becomes a lot easier and probably safer if you're doing it that way while driving.
- 1-6 4y agoVoice assistants and LLM's will probably be the next horizon for handsfree driving. Contextual predictions will make word input and browser automation vastly more useful.
- jcpsimmons 4y agoThe less-comfortable reason is that concern for others’ wellbeing is at an all time low. I regularly see outright aggressive driving, ESPECIALLY when I’m in California. People are stressed and they are taking it out on strangers.
- lisasays 4y agoThe less-comfortable reason is that concern for others’ wellbeing is at an all time low. Driven in turn by a lack of empathy, and a sense of feeling interconnected with others. As fueled, in turn, by smartphones.
- btbuildem 4y agoThis is absolutely it. We've become desocialized, and the kind of callous assholery that usually goes on online has leaked into the real world. I routinely witness people brazenly running red lights, and my instinct is to throw bricks at them -- so how am I not part of the problem? I don't really know how we back away from this.
- alphabettsy 4y agoWe’ve begun electing the people who used to be trolls to leads our communities. Road rage and aggressive driving aren’t new though. Neither is antisocial behavior on the roads or otherwise. Is there actually more of it?
- joshcsimmons 4y agoGetting angry when people flagrantly ignore the rules that keep us safe is NOT part of the problem.
- prirun 4y agoMost people think handsfree is okay, but it's bullshit. The problem with phones is that drivers' brains are distracted from driving, not that their hands aren't on the wheel (although that too is problematic). I had a friend call me while driving on a 35 MPH road with not much traffic. While talking to me, he came to a 4-way stop, ran it because he was distracted, and could have easily caused a wreck. I tell people "don't call me while you're driving!" but they do it anyway. After running the 4-way stop (with other cars at the intersection), he pulled over, told me what happened, and swore off using the phone while driving. A couple of years ago while stopped at an intersection, some dumb woman slammed into me (and the next 2 cars ahead of me) and her car ended up in the oncoming traffic lane facing the other direction. So not a "she bumped my fender" kind of wreck. My car was totaled, I had $46K in medical bills, multiple CT scans, X-rays, surgery to fixed a smashed nose, a 2nd surgery to fixup the 1st surgery, 25 Dr appointments during the height of Covid, and there was a person with Covid right next to me in the ER the day of the wreck. Was it really worth it for that person to be able to text while driving? To top it off, the fine in KY for texting while driving is $25. Big deterrent, right?
- ecshafer 4y agoThe fines for driving in the US are absurdly low in general. Through our laws incentivizing driving cars at every stage we have created a car centric society. Part of this is our laws with low fines and punishments. Realistically, someone texting and driving should have their license revoked, and probably a 4 or 5 figure fine. And many other driving offenses should as well.
- nickthegreek 4y agoFines unfairly affect the poor. The punishment should be community service, say highway trash pickup.
- triceratops 4y agoNot sure how that's better. Poor people are more likely to have jobs with inflexible hours.
- btbuildem 4y agoSmartphones have been around for long enough now -- I don't know whether I agree with the titular claim. I think the phone/distraction addiction is more of a symptom of something else. I've seen somewhere on twitter a thread positing that Covid changed people's brains (long covid especially), but let's take that with a grain of sand maybe. Right neighbourhood anyway, it seems the rise in these behaviours coincides with the rise of the pandemic.
- nunez 4y agoThe penalties for getting caught speeding or with your smartphone are too lenient. That's why people text and drive. "It won't happen to me" mentality is too pervasive. Get caught using your phone? Lose your license. Excessive speeding? $MEGAHUGE ticket on first offense; lose your license on second attempt.