41 ms·
Silicon Valley, once the underdog, is now too big to fail
- cs702 4y ago> An industry built on risk-taking, which made mountains of money when those risks paid off, has just been reminded of what happens when they don’t. And the answer, once again, is: Someone else pays the price. Ouch. That's a bit painful to read, because... it rings true, based on conversations I've had over the past few days. My understanding is that a majority of venture-backed startups in the US as well as a majority of venture capital firms all their had their cash balance deposited at SVB. In other words, the federal government just saved the entire US venture capital ecosystem from failure.
- tarotuser 4y agoIt's the Silicon Valley corporate playbook: Privatize the gains, Socialize the losses. The corollary is: socialism for the rich, unabashed cutthroat capitalism for the rest of us.
- johndunne 4y agoI’m engraving this on a plaque and throwing it on the lawn of the super rich.
- luckylion 4y agoIf you can turn that into a service where I can engrave things on a plaque and have someone throw it into a garden of my choosing, I'm sure you can build a successful startup out of it. VaaS, Vandalism as a Service.
- dfxm12 4y agoIt should be noted, this isn't really unique to Silicon Valley. It's more like the "capitalist" playbook.
- notch898a 4y agoWhat is "capitalist" about requiring FDIC for a retail banking charter, then the same government creating the requirement (at gunpoint of licensing scheme) takes the money for that requirement, and creates a "insurance scheme." Only it turns out that "insurance" is a fraud, as it is misrepresented. The premiums are advertised as being for backstopping up to 250k in the account, but it turns out this was a fraud and actually it's whatever arbitrary amount they choose all the way up to the biggest holder in the bank. And when they're finished, they'll assess a "special assessment" which totally isn't a tax, nevermind the licensees have no choice but to pay it.
- dyno12345 4y agothe "gain" startups were getting was a deposit account that doesn't disappear over the weekend. these were not supposed to be high risk/reward investments.
- jonhohle 4y agoThe risk was not having insured themselves beyond what FDIC was providing. I can’t wait until my insurer covers hundreds of multiples above the coverage I have!
- dyno12345 4y agothe FDIC limit was a minimum. for decades the FDIC has covered the full amount in practice. if the current level of fees aren't enough to cover that, they will raise them. and that is exactly what is happening now.
- jonhohle 4y agoThat is not what is happening now. They are assessing additional fees under systemic risk protection rules. FDIC rates are changed on a regular, periodic basis with forewarning time for markets to adjust, not over a weekend. When has FDIC reimbursed more than the “up to” limit? Everything I’ve read regarding this suggests that this may be moral hazard, at least in the short term. The remaining amount should come from liquidation of the failed bank’s assets or by the acquiring bank, not the FDIC.
- rglover 4y agoAt the expense of anyone holding dollars worldwide.
- dyno12345 4y agoit's paid for by auctioning off SVB's assets and raising FDIC fees on other banks
- LanceH 4y agoI'm worried that "other banks" constitute a large enough body that they could just let SVB fail. Instead they're looking around nervously and acquiesce to a bailout because they might be just as vulnerable.
- dyno12345 4y agothe fees are not voluntary and other banks have no reason to want their customers to see examples of people getting wiped out by bank failures
- jonhohle 4y agoYour neighbor sets off fireworks in his living room and burns his house down. Everybody in your neighborhood with the same insurance policy immediately gets hit by a new fee that was not previously contracted, the neighbor walks away without a house, but also with his mortgage payed off. In what world do we live in that a government agency can demand a new mandatory fee over the course of a weekend. This whole thing is bonkers. “The ultimate result of shielding men from the effects of folly, is to fill the world with fools.”
- dyno12345 4y agopeople seeing a bank fail will worry that their own bank could fail, which could lead them to withdraw en masse which will cause their own banks to fail, and so forth. this scenario is bad for everyone.
- bsuvc 4y agoThe federal government caused the problem first though. The federal reserve denied inflation was real for so long, signaling to everyone that it was safe to buy US Treasuries, then suddenly and aggressively started raising rates. And wasn't it the federal government regulators who are responsible for ensuring that banks are not taking on excessive risk? Are they not to be trusted, and must every depositor perform a deep-dive due diligence on their bank and continuously do so in order to make sure their money is safe while deposited in a bank of all places? No, the Federal government is more like an arsonist who set fire to a building, then showed up to rescue the people inside, taking all the credit, and then shaming those who noticed the smoke and escaped on their own before they arrived.
- mistrial9 4y agomoronic one-sided grudge content aside - isn't "market valuation" by private capital on assets they have an interest in, also a snake in the grass here?
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoIt kind of feels like the argument here is "why didn't someone stop us from making mistakes"? If it's the case that the federal reserve sent deliberately misleading messages that no one could have doubted why isn't there a giant line of banks currently going under?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kasey_junk 4y agoIt doesn’t take every depositor doing a deep dive, but if you hold half a billion dollars in cash at a bank, you bloody well better understand their balance sheet. I assure you that mainline company and governmental treasurers do this due diligence as a matter of course along with all the other counterparty risk mitigations that are SOP for well run companies. And if you are going to encourage (and sometimes insist) that your portfolio companies work with a bank, understanding concentration risk is the minimum professional standard you should be held to. Every other industry understands what fdic insurance is and is not. Competent CFO and corporate treasurers manage their counterparty risk as part of their job. It’s either immaturity, incompetence or entitlement that makes SV think this isn’t their problem.
- Frost1x 4y agoIt's worth noting that the concept of risk justifying disproportionate gains in most incarnations of capitalism isn't any sort of foundational principle. Instead, it was largely just a narrative people thought held true (and there's some truth still). These days it's largely the mantra that if you can't find a way to pass risk and costs off, you're incompetent at your role. We've learned to optimize risk away from the reward system and made it socially and culturally acceptable. Before, it was less accepted, hence the narrative. Anymore, people don't even paint the facade.
- breck 4y ago> My understanding is that a majority of venture-backed startups in the US as well as a majority of venture capital firms all their had their cash balance deposited at SVB Dataset needed.
- ryan93 4y agoI mean they would have recovered 80-90+ percent of their assets without government support. Plus many would have been back stopped by VC. People are really reading a lot into the whining coming from Jason calcanis types
- disruptivesloth 4y agoYeah they only would have realized 20-30B of loss tops, why are we even wasting our time discussing a non-issue ?
- ajross 4y ago> Plus many would have been back stopped by VC. I think that's very suspect given the behavior of the VC set. Altman said he was going to write a few loans ("six figure" ones, even! That's, like, more than a car loan!), but the "whiny Calacanis types" were absolutely the rule, not the exception. What has people so upset is exactly what the article is pointing out. The very set that claimed so loudly to be Brave Superheroes taking the risks that no one else could tolerate turned out to be outrageously risk-averse when faced with actually losing their own money. And I think that calls into question the whole venture capital business model. It's not what we thought it was. At the top, it was a cartel-run gravy train, squeezing investment dollars from downstream investors and turning that into income for the partners at the big players.
- ryan93 4y agomaybe i underestimated the number of calcanis types.
- treis 4y ago$100k is also like one pay cycle for a 10 person start up. The $10-20 billion in bailout sounds like a lot but it's not much compared to the market cap that banks are losing. Charles Schwab alone lost 30-40 billion in market cap because of SVB and bounced back up 10-15 on the bailout. The Fed action was to protect banks. A bunch of tech bros getting bailed out was a side effect of that.
- paddw 4y agoWhile Silicon Valley and the venture capital ecosystem don't come out of this looking sterling, it seems like this crisis was precipitated mostly be the financial mismanagement of a single entity, combined with exogenous factors in the U.S economy. There is clearly a lot of interest among some parties on trying to place blame on the tech ecosystem as a whole. Of course, SV is not blameless, but I think a lot of the characterization here is biased overall.
- game_the0ry 4y ago> Of course, SV is not blameless, but I think a lot of the characterization here is biased overall. I am sort of a silicon valley hater myself, but I agree that SV is not the only party to blame, not should it take the lion's share of the blame. SV did what SV does - take big risks. It did not help that the federal reserve help turbo charge risky investments via extraordinarily accommodative monetary policy. To blame SV alone is to ignore a bigger problem, which is the fed.
- wankle 4y agoI'd like to clarify, who is the fed? The federal government? If so, would that go as high as the sitting president?
- shkkmo 4y agoIn the USA: "The Fed" (singular) almost always, but especially in this context, means the Federal Reserve. "The Feds" (plural) usually refers to some or another branch of federal law enforcement, especially the FBI. It occasionally refers to a non-law enforcement federal agency.
- treis 4y agoThis is kind of ridiculous. The depositors at SVB were bailed out to save all the other regional banks. Obviously they were happy to get free money but life would have gone on if they didn't.
- sebzim4500 4y agoAll the risks that SV takes, and the one that nearly bit them was putting their money into a bank that bought US government bonds. Reality is stranger than fiction.
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoWell, putting a huge fraction of your money, individually and collectively as an industry, into the same banking institution is by itself a risk. SVB's problem wasn't just buying government bonds. The other problem SVB had was a homogenous customer base that had highly correlated behaviours. In particular, during the COVID boom, their customers collectively raised a ton of money and created a huge pool of deposits for SVB. And then when that money dried up, that turned into net outflows. And these behaviours were correlated, both as a group, but also critically with... you guessed it... interest rates. Which means as bond values were dropping, they were simultaneously seeing a major change in their cashflow profile, and the combination of the two is what led to a liquidity crunch. That just isn't happening at other, more diversified banking institutions.
- steponlego 4y agoFDIC blew their whole wad on SVB, that’s not lawful. Another couple banks have problems like this and they’ll be telling us that we need to turn on the munny printer to save them. Maybe the precious metals people were right.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> FDIC blew their whole wad on SVB, that’s not lawful. Even if it was true that they had blown their whole wad, it would be lawful. The systemic risk exception would allow that. > Another couple banks have problems like this and they’ll be telling us that we need to turn on the munny printer to save them. No, the funding mechanism is well-defined and does not involve monetary policy. (Its even fiscally neutral, so it doesn’t even involve the monetary effects of non-neutral fiscal policy.)
- taylodl 4y agoYou really need to educate yourself into how modern money works. Money isn't printed into existence, it's debted into existence. That's a concept the goldbugs either didn't understand or refused to acknowledge.
- notch898a 4y agoEconomics is an imperfect science but the equation of exchange suggests printing money could just change the nominal value of debts/goods and redistribute them rather than the total real value of debt/goods. That is you needn't create new real debt when printing money, you could just say be reducing the real value debt owed to current currency holders and distributing it to the backstopped depositors. I'm not saying we should be going to a commodity money, but if we were using a physical commodity as money (as in the commodity is physically in the coin, not notes representing the commodity) that were hard to mine more of, I'm not sure this kind of redistribution would be so practical.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoLet's be real here. No other bank in the world would've collapsed in similar situation. Did SVB lose money and made bad bets? Yes. Could they have raised back money by selling shares and return to solid ground? Also probably yes. What made this completely fatal is their client base. Client base which are supposed to be the biggest risk takers in the economy. Fled away at record speed. The burners of billions of dollars, fled away from quite moderate risk bank (moderate relative to their own risk profiles). That has been there for 40 years. It's not people who are unfamiliar with raising money. It's not your common people who somehow started a bank run. It's a small and connected group, that could communicate exaggerated risk to everyone and flee at record speed. Which is why I don't buy their innocent claims at all. It's actually hilarious that people who were selling sham crypto for billions of dollars got spooked by a bank. As depositors. It's like they projected their own insecurities and grift and fled like they saw their own scam and found themselves in it.
- HDThoreaun 4y ago> Client base which are supposed to be the biggest risk takers in the economy. A huge part of being a successful risk taker is knowing when to get out. Make no mistake, SVB was going to collapse eventually. Too much of their deposits were startup slush funds that will be withdrawn in the next few years as they struggle to raise money.
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoSee, that's what I started thinking as well. Except banks aren't startups. Banks actually make more money during high interest environment, and they don't need to have increasing deposits to stay alive (that's wrong projection from crypto grifters). If they had cash injection, they could still plan for reduced client deposits. They don't need their deposit base to grow to stay alive. That's startups projections.
- HDThoreaun 4y ago> Banks actually make more money during high interest environment SVB was not in a position to capitalize on raising rates. All their money was stuck in those low rate bonds and mbs's. If they want to get in on those higher rates they would need their deposits to increase, but they have been and will continue to decrease. They tried to raise money, no one gave them any because their book was underwater.
- swatcoder 4y agoMy impression of the FDIC action was more that Silicon Valley was lucky for being the first domino that nobody wanted to fall. It could have been any industry or sector facing challenges, but the FDIC was primarily concerned with restoring systemic confidence so that they could avoid a more widespread crisis. That's more (this bank is) "too triggering to fail" than (this industry is) "too big to fail". If SVB was a later failure in an ongoing crisis, it doesn't seem like the FDIC would have been prioritizing it because of some Silicon Valley connections.