17 ms·
“Healthy obesity” doesn’t exist. It is unequivocally bad for you
- fear_and_coffee 4y agoThere has been a strong push for it in media, it's not just an organic shift in thought.
- lockhouse 4y agoThere’s really no getting around the fact that you need to live an active life of consuming things in moderation to be healthy.
- throwawaysleep 4y agoThe challenge is what is the closest hack to get around it, as most people, admittedly myself included, are not willing to exercise? Semaglutide seems to be the best bet right now.
- raspyberr 4y agoThere is no hack. Exercise is non-negotiable. Our lifestyles are far too sedantry for our bodies' evolution. If you are not willing to add a small amount of exercise into your life, you are admitting that you are happy to at least have health issues later in life or at most willing to live a shorter life.
- copperx 4y agoExercise is essential for health, but not the best bet to lose weight, isn't it?
- knicholes 4y agoThat's right. Diet is the key to "losing weight."
- amrocha 4y ago"Exercise" is a bad way to lose weight because what is traditionally considered as exercise is 30 minutes to 1 hour of high intensity activities. If you live a sedentary life, exercise isn't going to help. Passive exercise, that you do throughout the day, though, is a great way to expend calories. Walk more, bike for transport, use a standing desk, etc. That's the difference between 1500 calories and 2200.
- Drblessing 4y ago> Exercise is a bad way to lose weight Exercise is not a bad way to lose weight.
- Drblessing 4y agoExercise is 100% the best bet to lose weight. For a simple empirical study, ask every person you meet/know that is fit, and nearly everyone will say they exercise. Specifically, cardio. If you're goal is to lose weight, you shouldn't touch weights until your BMI < 22. Just run or swim a few times a week.
- timje1 4y agoI don't think that's as universally agreed upon as you claim. I know of plenty of women who struggled to lose weight via diet and cardio, and then turned things round when they started eating high protein and lifting weights. Diet + cardio with no strength work can put people into 'gotta make it through this famine' mode, where their metabolism slows right down to eke out the stores as long as possible.
- drowsspa 4y agoExercising is easy, most people can find an activity they enjoy doing. Eating right is a far more demanding task, and sadly that's what matters when it comes to losing weight.
- kube-system 4y agoExercising in the US is hard AF, and only getting harder. There’s comparatively little opportunity to make exercise a part of daily routine. I’m either behind the wheel or a car or behind a desk all day.
- goostavos 4y agolol. If your rationales for not exercising have made it all the way to the country itself being the problem, well.. you might want to just acknowledge that you don't want to exercise. As a counterpoint, I also live in the US and have never found making time to exercise to be some kind of insurmountable task -- even when I was commuting almost 3h/day. Exercising requires just a few hours out of your whole week
- kube-system 4y agoThis is true, but lifestyle is undoubtedly a factor in people’s activity patterns.
- Xylakant 4y agoMy hack is to not own a car and commute by bike. It is exercise, but camouflages as required activity. I also try to deliberately walk instead of taking the subway regularly, even if it takes an hour or so.
- justinator 4y agoThis is what I do as well - money saved by no car ownership also means I don't work as much, which leads to even greater happiness.
- chitowneats 4y agoAn early death means you won't have to suffer as long, I guess. I don't want that outcome for you but it's where you're headed.
- gloryjulio 4y agoThe hack is to ingrain the law of physics to ur brain so that you get reminded constantly that you got to eat healthy and exercise to maintain your physical body
- JasserInicide 4y agoWorry about exercise later once you're at a healthy weight. You can lose it solely by watching what you eat. "Snacking" is the single worst dietary habit of the past 100 years. Eating all the time and having your insulin constantly elevated is not good for the body.
- AlbertCory 4y ago"if you can’t find time to exercise, you’ll have to find time to be sick." How much time for that do you have? Pushing around a walker when you're 65? Spending hours on the phone with Customer Support for some insurance issue? https://albertcory50.substack.com/p/50-years-of-running https://albertcory50.substack.com/p/50-years-of-running
- newaccount2023 4y agosomething bad is going to happen to people who think they can just take Ozempic for the rest of their lives there's no way a drug that effective has no side effects I know people who have lost weight using Ozempic...you only lose weight...you do not become healthy...you do not gain muscle...you just are a flabby person who is less fat
- copperx 4y agoLosing a significant amount of fat on purpose is becoming healthier, no ifs or buts about it.
- kube-system 4y agoThere are absolutely dangerous ways to lose weight that will kill you quicker than the weight.
- copperx 4y agoSure, there are edge cases. I don't know why you're fixated on those.
- kube-system 4y agoBecause you claimed there were “no ifs or buts”. But there are. When you lose weight, you have to be careful to do it in a safe way. Even the safest way of losing weight, diet and exercise, can kill you if done the wrong way.
- newaccount2023 4y agoyes, but only to a certain extent in cases of Ozempic use I have observed - less food is consumed but it is still tending to be garbage weight is lost but I doubt there is a substantial health gain I have read that the intent was to bootstrap better habits and then stop taking Ozempic once the better habits took hold...instead people will just take it forever and keeping eating (fewer) burgers
- somenameforme 4y agoA general rule is that you burn about 100 calories in a mile jog. A 12oz can of Coke has about 140 calories, a quarter of a cup of nuts has about 200 calories, an apple has about 100 calories. Exercise is important for many reasons, but not for preventing obesity. Unless you're running marathons, or exercising like somebody who is, the amount of calories you will burn from exercising will in no way whatsoever compare to what you eat. If you start eating more because you go to the gym, you'll almost certainly end up gaining weight. The answer today is the same as it's been for thousands of years.
- chitowneats 4y agoThe critical piece you're missing is that building and maintaining muscle mass increases your metabolism greatly. Michael Phelps eats 10,000 calories a day. This an extreme example, but the principle is true for all of us.
- ejstronge 4y agoSupposedly the 10,000 calorie diet of Michael Phelps is marketing vs factual. I don’t have a source for this (but happy to search if requested) but humans are not likely to be able to absorb 10,000 calories daily; I believe the maximum is a function of one’s basal metabolism but would lie around 6,500 calories for an elite athlete.
- justinator 4y agoIt may actually not. The hypothesis may be that building and maintaining muscle simply increases linearly with the increase of lean muscle mass. If (and these are made up numbers) one lb of lean muscle mass takes 10 cals to maintain, adding 5lbs of muscle would only increase your caloric needs be 50 cals. At 190lb, my BMI is 26.5, but I'm relatively muscular with a body fat % of around 15%. I have more than 5lbs more muscle than an average person, but my required daily caloric needs are only a few hundred cals more a day at most.
- docandrew 4y agoOver the course of a year that’s a pretty significant advantage in overall calories burned, though.
- stametseater 4y agoGet an active hobby which you enjoy and don't perceive to be "exercise". I personally recommend hiking.
- scsilver 4y agoI don’t know about you but exercise is one of my most enjoyable parts of my day. Yoga, walking, biking, dancing, swimming are all really enjoyable. Don’t push yourself hard, just go through the motions.
- candlemas 4y agoGet an exercise bike or elliptical trainer and watch movies or tv while you use it.
- lm28469 4y ago> as most people, admittedly myself included, are not willing to exercise? I'll never get that, we only get one shot at life, even a few hours of exercise per _week_ will greatly increase your quality of life and healthy life span, there are no better medicine, nothing will give you your body back once it's too late. Some people on this forum will grind 60+ (even much more) hours per week at work, absolutely wrecking their body for "success" just to be shadow of themselves at 40. I see it everywhere online "after 40 everything hurt" "I can't sneak on my kids because my knees pop at every steps". What a sad state of affair... Get out there, get in shape, it's life's best cheat code, everything gets better, your body evolved for that very thing for hundred millions of years, you don't even need that much dedication or time. Learn to master your body, learn about nutrition, learn self control. Run, swim, climb, lift weight, yoga, dance, try everything and keep what you enjoy I'll always remember the day a 60+ years old climber absolutely humiliated me on the wall by effortlessly completing a climb on the first try while I couldn't even get to the half point, I was 25 and in what I though was a good shape Not exercising is like buying a high performance car and waiting for the engine check light to do an oil change. Take care of your body, once it's gone it's gone
- justinator 4y agoDopamine is well: a hell of a drug, and there's far easier ways to get it than excising. For example: video games. Our brains want the most pleasure from the least amount of effort and don't work on long timelines in the future. So, it makes sense. But I'm with you - I find that exercise works well for me as the one of the best things that makes life better. But I also avoid things like video games, drugs, too much sex with too many different partners (I keep it to one at a time) - that sort of thing, as I know it'll just throw me off.
- lm28469 4y agoExercising is like vacuum cleaning, you never want to do it but once you're done with it you're happy you've done it. Binge eating or playing video games too long has the opposite effect on me, very easy to ease into, absolute regret as soon as I'm done That's why I said it train self control, you focus on "future you", not "immediate you"
- dpkirchner 4y agoMy #1 hack is not having low-quality, high-sugar snacks in my house. Instead of sugared soda I have flavored soda water (Fresca, specifically) and sugar-free cola. When I do indulge in snacks I don't buy bulk, I buy the small packages, even though they're more expensive per ounce. In fact, that they're more expensive is a plus. If I have to go way out of the way to binge on junk I'm probably not going to do it.
- throw_pm23 4y agoThat's a good hack but what's wrong with drinking plain water?
- dpkirchner 4y agoI don't enjoy it, I dunno exactly why.
- rsync 4y ago"The challenge is what is the closest hack to get around it ..." I owe it to you to be capable of (among other things): a few minutes of chest compressions, running a mile or so for help, and dragging an adult body a few hundred feet to safety. I owe that to you and we owe it to each other. There will be no hack to "get around it". Conversely: If you can do these things, I don't care what you look like or what your actuarial table shows or what you ate for lunch.
- amrocha 4y agoThe closest hack is living in a walkable city, and biking for personal transportation. There's a reason that obesity is not as big a problem in Europe, and even more so in East Asia.
- Balgair 4y agoBest hacks I've found: Get a young dog, get really into YT cooking shows. Dog will get you out and moving in any weather. They really don't understand why you're too tired for a walk this evening. YT cooking shows will show the fun side of cooking and get you to make food at home more. Then you're less likely to put so much oil/butter/sugar/etc into dishes vs. eating out. And you also get a taste for vegetables. You kinda tend to eat healthier in general-ish. Combine all that with a good sleep routine and you're pointed in the right direction. Takes about 3 months though.
- euroderf 4y ago"Well, I got as far as 'active life of consuming things'."
- z3c0 4y agoHalfway there! Keep it up and you'll be healthy in no time.
- DiscourseFan 4y agoI think the article is arguing that there is such a thing as being healthy with a high BMI? It's just that those people generally don't have an excessively high body fat %. But if we are going by BMI, there are plenty of people who have "healthy obesity", on account of muscle mass. I've been working out for many years and I think I have a healthy body fat percentage but since I'm not very thin its hard to tell without taking specific measurements, but I would say that most men who go to the gym frequently are in the category of "healthy obese", or overweight, if you just take into account their BMI.
- AstixAndBelix 4y agoNobody who is jacked has ever been considered obese. This weird "gotcha" about bodybuilders and alike having the BMI of an obese person and being healthy is a meaningless edge cases that tries to stray away discussions. The vast majority of people are not gym rats, thus their BMI roughly corresponds to their fat levels, correctly approximating overweightness and obesity.
- stametseater 4y agoIn fact BMI actually underestimates obesity for most of the population. > BMI characterized 26% of the subjects as obese, while DXA indicated that 64% of them were obese. 39% of the subjects were classified as non-obese by BMI, but were found to be obese by DXA. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0033308 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... Discussed earlier this month: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34854496 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34854496
- wkat4242 4y agoAre bodybuilders really healthy though? I'm sure it's healthier than being obese but the kind of pressure they put on their body, I wonder if that doesn't cause problems. Like with most things done in extreme amounts of course. Many top athletes also have major issues later in life. And that's not even mentioning the hormones..
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stametseater 4y agoWhat interests me is how anybody could ever come to believe otherwise. The contrary belief flies in the face of all common sense, popular experience and medical science. It seems to come entirely from propaganda on social media telling fat people what they want to believe.
- vixen99 4y agoThe literature on the relationship between BMI and mortality is not conclusive except for a BMI > 30. Generally it seems that lower mortality is associated with a body mass index of 20-25. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1000367 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1000367 However there are studies which find lowest mortality for the slightly overweight with BMI < 30. For instance: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/1555137 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/1555137 and https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphys.2022.857787/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphys.2022.8577...
- blackoil 4y agoIt is a reaction to obese people being butt of jokes and now majority becoming obese. If you can't change lifestyle you can use contra views as coping mechanisms. Also, like anti-science believing in snake oils and flat earth over the internet you can live in an echo chamber custom made for you.
- nimbius 4y agodont forget multinational processed food and snack vendors benefit immensely from the perception that hyperconsumption of sugar salt and fat is normal and good, and that your obesity is a shameless wonder to cherish unto the grave. look at the sons and daughters of branded food conglomerate moguls and their top executives. youll likely find them quite trim.
- stametseater 4y agoClothing companies have also played a role in normalizing obesity with advertisements featuring obese people, often accompanied by pro-fat propaganda slogans like "healthy at any size". They do this out of pure greed; fat people have money and buy clothes, so it makes business sense to advertise products to them. But these ads are bad for public health because they promote unhealthy standards as normal and okay.
- tempsy 4y agothe only nuance i’ll add is that there’s a huge difference between subcutaneous fat (eg visible belly fat you can pinch) and visceral fat (the fat hugging your vital organs) visceral fat is significantly more dangerous than subcutaneous fat, and people who have a high ratio of visceral fat to subcutaneous fat can appear skinny but are as or potentially less well off that someone who has a more balanced ratio of visceral to subq fat.
- graeme 4y agoTrue enough, but even subcutaneous fat is not benign. Sumo wrestlers have extremely low visceral fat and extremely high muscle mass. But a good margin of subcutaneous fat. They have a markedly lower life expectancy than other elite athletes and than other Japanese men.
- tempsy 4y agosure I’m not suggesting people get complacent if they have excess belly fat. but controlling visceral fat should be most important goal for your average person given how disruptive it is hormonally the main issue for your average person is there isn’t really a good way to measure the percentage or ratio outside of a Dexa scan which are pretty expensive
- tokai 4y agoYour nuance is one of the main points of the article. «Nor does BMI measure where fat is located, which can make a big difference. Visceral fat jammed among internal organs is much worse than subcutaneous fat stored just beneath the skin.»
- tempsy 4y agowell it’s missing from the headline and not everyone is reading the article
- captain_coffee 4y agoYes, people with a lot of intra-abdominal fat but very small amounts of subcutaneous fat are referred to as TOFI. Thin on the Outside, Fat on the Inside (Dr. Robert Lustig)
- widjit 4y agoDenial/wishful thinking are extremely powerful. That said, body positivity shouldn't be thought of as having anything to say about objective physical health: there is zero reason a person who is obese should necessarily feel bad about themselves. Shame is a useless or detrimental approach to changing behavior; shame is oftentimes the reason people engage in unhealthy behaviors like overeating in the first place. Being overweight is an obvious health danger, but it does not make you a bad person. Somewhere in the idiot echo chamber of social media the idea of a healthy sense of self worth got conflated with a healthy body.
- dudul 4y agoMaybe there is some space between being shamed and being treated as a role model? No obese people are not bad people but I would like to be able to say that I don't approve of their lifestyle and don't want my kids to believe that it is normal and fine to be obese.
- swatcoder 4y agoFor lack of other shared idols, the “common space” American society worships health and longevity. We measure everything against it and don’t make much room for debate. We all do unhealthful things, of course, but our society makes it very hard to admit that we do so in sound mind. The role we’re asked to play is to say we’re addicted, indulgent, or ashamed. The dissonance isn’t good for people and is not unlike the toxic dissonance we associate with religious communities that are too stringent and deny everyday realities of human behavior.
- nerdjon 4y agoI think this is where 100% body positivity falls short, and that is context. Being a bigger person doesn't make you less of a person, it doesn't mean that you are weak, or even mean that you are unhealthy on its own. As a random person, a friend, whatever we should not pass judgment on other people in that regard. But on the flip side context is incredibly important. For example in a doctor setting. It is deeply concerning that I see a ton of people that immediately think that if their doctor mentions needing to loose weight that they are immediately fat phobic. I see people saying they want a "body positive" doctor. Sure Doctor's need to be better and understand that everyone's body, diet, etc is different. But I am concerned about this desire to have a doctor never talk about your weight. I am overweight and my doctor mentions it... I mean we are tracking it and they weight me. Him not saying anything would be wrong and him not doing his job. But you are very right that you can't shame someone even at the Doctor. But you also can't ignore it.
- _23sd 4y agoThe article tries to frame it as if the U-shaped mortality curve and “healthy obesity” hypothesizing have been debunked, but there’s no suggestion that the U-shaped curve was not real. What appears to actually be debunked is BMI>30 as a definition of obesity. As far as I can tell, epidemiologists operating within the framework of “obesity is BMI>30”, still the one most commonly used at the individual and epidemiological levels worldwide, were right to question whether obesity was universally unhealthy. They only become “wrong” when you redefine obesity, so this controversy seems to have been constructive in exposing methodological problems.
- stametseater 4y agoMost people should be considered obese at a BMI around 25 or so, maybe lower. Obesity being set at BMI>30 is actually too generous. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0033308 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... (And no, low-fat ripped bodybuilders aren't relevant to this discussion. They and their doctors both know that BMI doesn't work well for these rare individuals.)
- xboxnolifes 4y agoOnly because people stopped shaming the term "overweight", but are still adverse to "obese". The range 25-30 isn't called the "still healthy range", it's "overweight". Being overweight isn't a good thing.
- mc32 4y agoI don’t know if we’re capable of pushing against the tipping point, but if feels like it will be arduous to return to a point where being obese is frowned upon and not hidden under figleaves. We have an entire body positivity movement that makes people feel good about obesity. Culturally we’ve come to celebrate it. How do we expect people to keep fit under this culture? The main interests that benefit are junkfood on one facet and pharmaceuticals manufacturers on the other. It’s becoming the modern alcohol but an addiction we could have avoided instead of celebrating. As to alcohol while I don’t favor prohibition, I’d like ti return to an environment where no advertising/ promotion of said products is allowed.
- kennywinker 4y agoIn what world are you living? Being obese is and always has been frowned upon. There is a small faction of people who believe that nobody should be treated poorly for having a body that doesn't fit an ideal. You specifically say that body positivity "makes people feel good about obesity". Which, said another way, seems like you think "people should feel bad if they are fat". Why would you wish for someone to feel bad? Assuming you believe that fatness is failing caused by something wrong with a person, do you also believe that depressed people should feel bad because there is something wrong with them? Do you believe people with PTSD should feel bad because there is something wrong with them?
- mc32 4y agoAre you saying someone who is an alcoholic should feel happy about being an alcoholic and just live it up because, why would I as an alcoholic try and not be an alcoholic if society is telling me I have no agency over it.
- kennywinker 4y agoNobody is born an alcoholic. Shockingly, plenty of people are born with bodies that retain fat, even fed the exact same diet as a skinny person. And I sure hope you're carving out an exception for the many many people in the world who are fat because it's a side effect of a medication they are forced to take for an unrelated health condition. Or should they feel bad about their bodies too?
- quattrofan 4y ago[dead]
- helf 4y ago[dead]
- newaccount2023 4y ago[flagged]
- copperx 4y agoYou're already footing the bill if you have insurance; it's the same thing. And these beliefs are a consequence of for-profit healthcare. If socialized healthcare was a reality, there would be a big incentive for having a lean population. We don't have that today, because there is profit to be made.
- max47 4y ago> this is why I will never get behind socialized healthcare...I'm not footing the bill for the increasing number of people who push these beliefs Sadly, the US is paying as much per capita for healthcare as countries with free healthcare. A private system costs a lot more to run even when they are managed by people with good intentions.
- wkat4242 4y agoWhen I hear that in the US health insurance can cost upwards of $1000 a month, I really think something is severely broken in the system there. In the Netherlands it costs around 150 with good services. In Spain it's free but no way the tax expenditure is that high because most people don't even make much more than 1000 euro.
- dudul 4y agoA grand sounds a bit high. I have a family of 4 and can't remember ever paying more than 400 a month. Granted, my employer picks up part of the tab but that's just how it works in the US (and it's dumb).
- dudul 4y agoYou pay for it through your insurance premium though.
- robotburrito 4y ago
- Syzygies 4y agoThinking obesity is one number is as dumb as thinking intelligence is one number. Card counting used to be one number, till they realized how much better two numbers did. Yet in this day of smart phones, one still sees geriatricians calculating stroke risk using a rule they can do in their heads. I'd rather trust my health care to prediction markets, if we could work through the data privacy issues. So where's the BMI table that asks height and "how wide are your shoulders?" For some of us, "big boned" isn't a euphemism.
- tayo42 4y agoThere's body fat percentage, you can calculate this with calipers or in a pool. Even the body builder with a high bmi thing isn't that healthy. It's tough to be large.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoBody building at a professional level is extremely unhealthy because everyone is on an elephant dose of steroids and growth hormones. It’s probably the worst life outlook of profesional sports - much worse than just playing video games at home
- lm28469 4y ago> BMI You don't need to look at BMI, or any number besides fat % for that matter, to see we have a massive fucking issue. If your belly protrudes far enough that you can't see your own feet, big boned or not, you're obese Obesity is BMI 30+, unless you're a semi-pro/pro athlete or have genetic defects at 30+ BMI you're definitely fat af, here are examples of 30 BMI: https://www.lipedema.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/Obesity-BMI-Lipedema-v2-1.png https://www.lipedema.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/Obesity-... There is absolutely no chance you have a 30+ BMI because of "big bones"
- ithrow 4y agoDoes the bodybuilder has 30 BMI cause of muscle weight?
- karmicthreat 4y agoYea, being obese isn't health in any way shape or form. Unless you have some sort of exceptional physique that takes you out of the common medical model. You probably don't have that. I fucking hate it. I have at least managed to get under a 40 BMI its a huge slog to even get try to get down to only overweight. And even then in realistic terms even if I do, its 100% impossible to stay there over your lifetime after being obese. Age will just catch up with you. I wouldn't wish this on anyone.
- whatshisface 4y ago>its 100% impossible to stay there over your lifetime after being obese. Age will just catch up with you. You will have to keep reducing your diet forever as your metabolism slows. It's not 100% impossible, just a very difficult lifelong struggle, like having type-1 diabetes.
- triyambakam 4y agoGreat work and keep going! I recently heard a good motivator is to think about something as just the "next thing to do" rather than a challenge or problem. Anyways, I don't it might feel like getting advice in an elevator, but I wish you well.
- karmicthreat 4y agoThanks for the positive encouragement!
- kennywinker 4y agoDid they control for anti-fat bias? Unlikely. Especially in the medical system, fat people don't get their body issues taken seriously. The stress of being treated poorly by everyone in your life undoubtedly has a huge impact on your lifespan. Did they control for efforts to change you body? Most fat people are trying to be thinner. Plenty of ways that people are told to change their body involve extreme stress to your body (caloric restriction, extreme diets, stimulant pills). Did you know that being underweight is ALSO associated with health problems, sometimes as extreme as the ones associated with being very fat. Anybody reading this and wanting a more nuanced understanding of this stuff should listen to the first few episodes of the podcast Maintenance Phase https://www.maintenancephase.com/ https://www.maintenancephase.com/ edit: I'm getting downvoted for pointing out two well documented factors that the linked article doesn't seem to account for - I thought we believed in facts and rationality here?
- AlwaysRock 4y agoWhataboutism 101
- kennywinker 4y agoThe only thing bordering on whataboutism is my comment about being underweight. Talking about obesity bring up a lot of extreme emotions in people, and people love to say "it's just about it being unhealthy" but then don't have those extreme emotions when thinking about underweight people. So it's not whataboutism, it's relevant context. My two other points, anti-fat bias, and the harm of trying to change your body, are things that could explain the health impact of being fat while not actually being a direct result of the fat. So, not whataboutism at all - they are well documented factors that the linked article doesn't seem to account for or consider.
- AlwaysRock 4y agoWhen someone is talking about one issue and you bring up another issue... That is whataboutism. Being overweight is unhealthy. Being underweight is unhealthy. This article is about being overweight. Bringing up something else entirely and ignoring what the article is about is whataboutism.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 4y agoI wonder what's going to happen long term to the recent trend of celebrating obesity in advertising. E.g. go to any Target and you will see overweight or obese models wearing the clothes they sell. On one hand you have to represent your current population, and with the majority of Americans overweight or obese, that's who your customers are. On the other, can this be seen as normalizing a disease?
- iLoveOncall 4y agoNothing at all unless it is forbidden by law, which it won't be. Walmart wants to make a profit, so showing how clothes look on your body is better to achieve this goal.
- bobthepanda 4y agoFat people exist, and they need clothes to wear.
- bequanna 4y agoI think the parent is asking: Why do we seem to be celebrating obese people?
- bobthepanda 4y agoIs an ad celebratory or informational? Like, an ad is never going to be like, "hey you stupid fattie, here's where you can buy clothes." You do still have to sell the clothes.
- marcellus23 4y agoThe parent already acknowledges that: "On one hand you have to represent your current population, and with the majority of Americans overweight or obese, that's who your customers are." The question is about whether this is normalizing an unhealthy disease, which your comment does not respond to.
- 4y ago
- newaccount74 4y agoBefore you draw conclusions from the headline, please look at the graph from the linked paper [1]. Pay attention to the size of the error bars. It looks like there is an effect, but it's not the huge and obvious realisation that the article claims. I do think that body composition (size/fat/muscle mass) has an effect on your health, but the variance within groups is still huge! There are so many other things in your life that can affect your health, that also have a huge effect size. So even if you are overweight or obese, and you can't lose weight, it doesn't mean that you can't improve your health. Eating healthy, making sure to get enough fresh air, limiting alcohol and nicotine use, taking care of your mental health and stress level are all going to benefit your health, even if they don't make you lose weight. The same thing goes if you have a healthy weight and lots of muscle mass: Your body composition is not a free pass to smoke, get drunk every weekend, and eat burgers every day. [1]: https://assets.realclear.com/images/44/446325_5_.png https://assets.realclear.com/images/44/446325_5_.png
- psychphysic 4y agoThe old line goes > Your BMI tells me your overweight. > But rugby players BMIs are high, and they aren't overweight! > You don't play rugby though do you. I'm glad that "fat acceptance" may be turning a corner and will be banished hopefully and there can be a semblance of rational discourse. Ideally you should be a BMI 22, non smoking, non drinking, long distance runner living in the countryside eating a perfectly balanced diet. Mosy of us will achieve all that, just do what you can. There's loads of nasty ways to mess up your health. Being fat seems to be the most appealing one (I get to eat what I want and sit around all day? Hell yeah!).
- iLoveOncall 4y ago> Being fat seems to be the most appealing one It's not the most appealing one, it's the hardest one to manage. You can not smoke, you can not drink alcohol, you can not take drugs, but you cannot not eat.
- arcanemachiner 4y agoYou can eat real food instead of processed garbage, for starters. Nobody's getting fat eating vegetables.
- crazygringo 4y agoActually, cutting potatoes and other starchy vegetables is a major part of weight loss for a lot of people. High-starch vegetables are a major contributor to obesity.
- choeger 4y agoI call bullshit. The average cooked potatoe has 25% less calories than rice or pasta. You'd have to eat 3kg of cooked potatoes to get 2100kcal. I am pretty certain it is near impossible to get fat from eating potatoes. Go give it a try. I bet that it is the "frying" part or the sauce or butter that comes with it, that leaves a lasting impression on the hips.
- bjt2n3904 4y ago[flagged]
- kennywinker 4y ago"Step 1: Declare that there is no objective standard for a better skin color. Step 2: Declare that things like race and skin color are strictly a cultural phenomenon that have no grounding in reality or biology. Step 3: Assert a power dynamic imbalance. Since there is no reason for people to say one skin color is better, then white people are merely "race shaming" people to oppress them. Step 4: Relentlessly point out all the ways "non-white people people" are "oppressed". If anyone disagrees with you, accuse them of "race shaming", label them an oppressor, etc." I did the thing you said, replaced weight with skin color, but it came out pretty damn racist. If you're reading this and it sounds racist, might be time to switch it back to being about weight and realize that yes it is also shitty to treat people poorly because of their weight - just like it's shitty to treat someone poorly because of their race.
- precompute 4y ago"Healthy Obesity" does exist. But it is vanishingly rare. When one's body has to support a large amount of muscle mass, it also needs a lot of fat to offset it. This sort of body composition is usually the result of "explosive" training taken to failure (or near it), which (probably) excretes more lactic acid all at once. People on steroids are the exception. AFAIK increasing total reps (lower intensity) instead of going to failure (higher intensity) doesn't help exclusively with fat loss after a certain threshold, you can see that in the different compositions of sprinters / marathoners (or for a more honest comparison, triathletes). You can see "healthy obesity" in people like Kyriakos Grizzly and Eddie Hall (pre-cut). The human body needs fat and muscle to be in tandem. Deviation to the extreme of either end is very unhealthy and is quickly corrected by the body, given bare minimum stimulus. Absent this, you'll get the beetus and other things. High body fat can also protect you, for example, obese smokers are healthier on average than skinny smokers. All that poison goes to their fat, because fat pretty much acts as a sponge in the body. That's why "pink cheeks", "baby cheeks" are a sign of long-term health. It takes a very long time (years, if not over a decade) of a proper, modern-toxin-free diet to remove toxins from the body. In the absence of proper amounts of protein and fat your body usually likes to isolate harmful things, which can lead to myriad conditions down the line, even if you've been exercising for years and have been "healthy". Also, related to the title of the main post, sugar and whole grains (processed flour is basically sugar) and horribly addictive. Obese people that have difficulty quitting / have side-effects from quitting might as well have entire regions of their brain dedicated to timing the intake of sugar precisely, at the expense of their mental functioning. So they would inevitably feel out of energy / motivation after a while, and would need food. Also, the easiest way to lose fat and gain muscle is to subject your body to external weights. It doesn't even have to be very heavy. If you're obese, you could OHP 10kg every other day and lose a significant amount of fat, even without changing your diet (assuming it's not really horrible)
- stametseater 4y agoIt doesn't exist. Sumo wrestlers are as you describe, with a large amount of muscle and a large amount of fat. And they die young. Sadly, Kyriakos Grizzly will almost certainly die young.
- skybrian 4y agoWeight loss can be a sign of health problems, particularly if it’s unexpected. Often people lose a lot of weight before they die. This makes collecting and interpreting the statistics more difficult because you need to distinguish “good” weight loss from “bad” weight loss. BMI isn’t enough to figure it out.
- aeturnum 4y agoIMO the fat acceptance movement is pushing more for people to think about obesity like alcohol consumption: not "healthy", but potentially part of a sustainable approach to life. Of course, each deviation from "perfect" health has impacts - but learning to order them productively is what you want. It's not really that you want to be fat, it's that weight is only one of many lifestyle choices and we'd give people better medical treatment if we were less obsessed with it. Also: People should try to move towards a healthier body weight! But it's a question of balancing effort and focus and not some moral imperative.
- surfpel 4y ago> about obesity like alcohol consumption: not "healthy", but potentially part of a sustainable approach to life I would not classify alcoholism as a sustainable approach to life. Obesity, like alcoholism, isn’t sustainable because it accelerates death and disease. I equate “sustainable” with “not unhealthy”, which does not cover obesity. What I have witnessed isn’t that those folks call it “healthy” but that they describe it as “not unhealthy”. This is incorrect and dangerous, as it deludes others into believing the same.
- aeturnum 4y agoI don't think any reply could have supported my point better. All alcohol consumption is alcoholism! Good luck on your path - we would live longer if we all followed your advice. And also - like I said - this is exactly what is being critiqued.
- abeppu 4y agoSo, why is it that as a wealthy person with good health insurance and access to care, when I see my GP for an actual physical, I get weighed, but I don't get a DEXA scan that actually measures muscle and fat? They're not expensive compared to other stuff in health care, but accurate fat measurement seems to be a thing for recreational fitness nerds not people trying to live a long time or without chronic diseases? When I've gotten these before it's always from a scanner in truck in a CrossFit parking lot rather than at a Dr office. If distinguishing between fat and weight is important, why is it so ignored in medical contexts?
- jmull 4y agoInteresting. I would have though BMI was a sufficient proxy for body composition for broad samples... That conclusions about the average person with BMI of X were useful. I guess this argues otherwise, which is worth considering. (Though, this seems to be just one study right now? I don't think it's rational to draw the strong conclusions the article does from one study. The absolute claims don't seem supported by the evidence, so I guess they are pushing an angle, though it's not clear to me why.)
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoOk, but what now? There is no effective treatment or cure for obesity from public health point of view. That is, sufficiently low calorie intake will make you lose weight. But, if your metabolic balance is out of whack, it will also leave you constantly hungry, lethargic, not able to enjoy one of the major life pleasures. To maintain that long term once has to essentially prioritize staying slim over all other life priorities. It's likely that prevention of obesity is achievable by changes is easily available food, walkable communities, regulation of problematic chemicals, childhood health education. And also that overtime medical treatments and food modifications will get better at counteracting preexisting obesity. But in the meantime, "go lose weight" may not be practical medical advice to an average individual. Eating healthier food and having a regular exercise regimen may well be, but losing lots of weight is not an expected outcome. People will still end up eating more of healthier food, or eating unhealthy food due to life circumstances, or getting too fatigued to exercise enough. At this point, "what else can we do to improve your health" because a relevant question. Fat acceptance? Bah. Just because I am overweight doesn't mean I like looking at fat models. We can admire the best of us while being realistic of what we are going to achieve ourselves. In some marginal way, watching models and athletes does motivate me to watch my food and workout. Just not enough to end up looking like them.
- bitwize 4y agoJust like the Hackernews prescription for individual health issues is fasting, the Hackernews prescription for large-scale public health issues is government regulation. Apply liberally. Start implementing Pigovian taxes on sugary foods. Monitor and punish companies that use added sugar in foods that don't need it. Shut down the Coca-Cola Company and PepsiCo.
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoWe could also have private school and private communities that advertise ease of healthy living. But so long as a school run by government, they might as well teach useful things like taking good care of one's health, including school lunch that is a realistic, non-bland example of what one can enjoy eating and at the same time don't become a balloon. Or if we can have vouchers and parents can choose schools that do that, that's great.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mablopoule 4y agoAs someone in the "kinda fat kinda fit" category, I'm a bit disappointed by the amount of people so quick to brush off the semi-bullshitness of BMI. I believe it's a good measure for statistics over population, since it's easy to measure and tend to work for a large number of people. On the individual level tough, you really don't need to be a world-class athlete for BMI to become less relevant for you, contrary to what some commenters seems to imply. For the last 10 years I've been to the gym around 2/3 times a week, walked a lot more, cut down the junk food, and yet I'm 10/15 kilos heavier than at my 'fattest'. I'm far from being a powerlifter or a professional rugbyman, yet when I see people around me, I'm usually the beefiest guy in the room. I do believe that some people went overboard with "body positivity". In the same time, as a french guy living in Paris where the expected look varies from 'slim' to 'extra-slim', I'm glad to see more things for people with an even moderately wide frame.
- virtuallynathan 4y agoWaist to height ratio is probably a better measure, nearly as easy.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoI’m too fatigued right now to pull up my prior posts on the subject with compelling references but the linked article links survey research that says the same thing. BMI alone is a poor measure but when coupled with physical fitness and activity metabolically healthy overweight and obese type 1 tend to have similar health outcomes to physically fit and active normal BMI. The key is physical activity and fitness are key to health, and likely at some physical threshold aggregate size of body drags it down no matter what (inclusive of athletes with huge frames). BMI is a quicker to compute metric than metabolic and cardiovascular health, easier to measure in a doctors office than factoring reported physical activity, and therefore is probably a decent medical tool for providing advice. But the advice is going to be eat healthy and exercise no matter what the BMI is. So maybe BMI isn’t specifically useful, so maybe instead of telling an overweight person they’re fat (they probably knew) and therefore should exercise and eat healthy, likewise telling everyone else the same advice, just skip the “you’re fat” and give everyone the same advice as already happens. I don’t think anyone is surprised by “get fit eat right” is good medical advice. Edit: as to why, I know a lot of obese folks that avoid their doctors because they feel harangued about being over weight. They know they’re fat and they’ve likely been working on it for some time, and the “you’re fat” + axiomatic health advice isn’t helping them vs simply axiomatic health advice. Psychologically it’s shaming, and shame is a powerful force in human psychology. Whether “you’re fat” is reducing their long term health or not is irrelevant since the advice is the same regardless, and it drives them away from their doctors from their shame. That’s not useful, and I’d hope utility is more important than reinforcing axiomatic medical advice with shaming. I know everyone will say “who cares if they’re ashamed it’s a fact,” but who cares in this is their doctor and the patient. That should have primacy over all.
- inglor_cz 4y agoThreads about obesity tend to be the ones where even smart people talk past each other. There tends to be a lot of judgment and just eat less! proclamations. This attitude bugs me. If a programmer "solved" a memory leak by simply adding RAM, without trying to understand why it happens, the HN commentariat would pounce on him and call him various uncharitable names. But few people here seem to be disturbed by the fact that we don't yet know what drives obese people to eat more food than people with normal weight. This is not a trivial question, it is actually a deep question, much like "why do some people slide into alcoholism while others can have their single glass of wine every evening for 50 years and never feel cravings to drink more". But for some weird reason, few people even ask this question aloud, even though without discovering the root cause for overeating, any society-wide fix is unlikely to happen.
- TrackerFF 4y agoDunno about you guys, but back when I was verging on being outright obese, I felt like shit. Sweating from doing pretty much any physical activity, sleep apnea, summers were horrible due to the heat and extra sweating, clothes never fit and just looked bad, non-existent interest from the other sex, and people in general being more unfriendly (trust me on this one, the difference is like night and day) - and just a general feeling of discomfort. Heartburn, tiredness, gout, the whole nine yards. I'd be amazed if someone truly obese actually feels like they're healthy.
- xtracto 4y agoI blame this to political correctness. Someone who is fat is only that. She/he is overweight, unhealthy and got a problem. They should get help and get treated. That's it. If someone tells them that, they should take it as an oxymoron. It's like telling someone was how has a bad cough that they should cover their mouth while coughing as nd should check their lungs. It's just that. But for some reason, acknowledging that someone is fat/unhealthy became an offense. People "know" that they are unhealthy but decide to live that way and feel offended. I blame the current health system. Because even if sick people wanted to get treatment, the may not be able to afford it.
- onigiri420 4y agoIt doesn't at all. If you are struggling to lose weight, give The Obesity Code book a read.
- JeremyNT 4y agoI think this is mostly a repost of this finding [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34930641 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34930641
- fwungy 4y agoThe food makes people fat. It's almost all crap now: chemicals, hormones, non-caloric content, non-nutrititive, sweeteners. Eating real food now takes money and initiative. If we went back to the commercial food quality of the 50's the obesity epidemic would end by itself.
- biobitworks 4y ago[dead]
- nullc 4y agoI recently watched a documentary from the late 70s and was shocked at how thin members of the public in the background footage were compared to people in the same community today.
- soueuls 4y agoI am fat and I don’t really care. But I don’t understand how some people come to understand that it’s healthy.