7 ms·
The thing that's strange is FDIC took control and setup a receiving bank for liquidation. That's not normal; FDIC works quite hard to find a bank willing to ta
by bombcar 4y ago
The thing that's strange is FDIC took control and setup a receiving bank for liquidation.
That's not normal; FDIC works quite hard to find a bank willing to take over - usually they can work out what the "cost" is to take over, and FDIC pays the receiving bank that amount to "eat" the dying one.
If they don't announce they have a bank to assume SVP by Monday, it's quite abnormal.
- NordSteve 4y agoMost FDIC bank takeovers are slow moving crashes, allowing for a longer negotiation where buyers can evaluate the loan portfolio they are buying. This is a reaction to a classic run, so no time for that.
- czbond 4y agoChase has wanted this bank for years. Either they are taking advantage (takeover) or <conspiracy theory unfounded> helped accelerate it.
- gumby 4y agoMost of the good staff were poached by First Republic over the past few years. That caused me to bank my current startup at FR after more than 25 years of SVB. So I don’t think there was much for Chase to buy. SVB has been in decline for a while
- ashwagary 4y agoJust saw a First Republic stock chart in crash territory, contagion?
- everybodyknows 4y agoToday's price range: 45-95 https://www.cnbc.com/quotes/FRC?qsearchterm=first https://www.cnbc.com/quotes/FRC?qsearchterm=first
- gumby 4y agoS&P bank sector is down across the board, but presume it will regress to the mean fairly soon. Aren't many other banks with exposure similar to SVB's.
- alfalfasprout 4y agoFirst republic is in the same region and has a ton of tech clients. Collateral damage. So far it looks like they don't have the same exposure as SVB did though.
- VirusNewbie 4y agoInteresting you say this, their stock is up despite rest of my portfolio being red
- czbond 4y agoFlight to safety? Like when there was the Southwest Airlines December debacle - AAL skyrocketed for a bit.
- mikeyouse 4y agoSo what I think is happening here is that if you take over a bank the traditional way, you need to mark-to-market all of the bank's assets -- so all of the losses from the long-dated MBS that would be perfectly fine if held to maturity would have to be recognized immediately, just crushing the balance sheet of anyone who bought it. Probably trying to line someone up who can either absorb that loss, figure out a way to recapitalize without recognizing the loss, or get access to some other lending facility.
- t0mas88 4y agoBut from what I read it's common for FDIC to "sell" to the acquiring bank at a price that wouldn't make a loss. So if you marked to market all those long term bonds and then sold SVB to a bigger bank at the resulting (possibly negative) valuation. Why wouldn't a big bank take that deal?
- mixdup 4y agoExactly. The fact they didn't have a bank lined up points very heavily to the fact that they are not going to be made completely whole. In the past, the FDIC has found a buyer and as part of that process guarantees some amount of the losses. IE: Savior Bank buys Failed Bank for pennies on the dollar, or even for a negative amount. They get all deposits, insured or not, and all assets--meaning loans. Then, the FDIC guarantees they'll make Savior Bank whole some percentage of losses on assets that go bad. Sometimes 80% or more This arrangement usually results in all depositors being made whole, and the FDIC fund not taking any, or many, actually losses, because most of the loans will still pay back, at least partially They also do this before seizing the bank, so that it's all very orderly and calms any panics SVB was looking for a buyer on the open market and that failed--no surprise That the FDIC also could not find a buyer that they could subsidize and announce the same day as the seizure is very damning. I would be shocked if someone comes in later and tries to buy it Also, the fact the seizure happened in the middle of the business day, and not at the close of business yesterday points to a somewhat disorderly and rapidly deteriorating condition. I think maybe the run picked up a lot faster than they expected
- bombcar 4y agoThat's a really good point, FDIC usually swoops in Friday night; and this was closed on a Friday during business hours, that's actually insane; they couldn't hold on 8-10 more hours, the run must have been really bad. Even WAMU (a huge FDIC action) was done after banking hours closed on the west coast. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_Mutual https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_Mutual
- ashwagary 4y agoI just saw recent footage of 40-50 people standing in line outside an SVB branch waiting for service (withdrawals most likely). I would surmise that the news spread fast among the tech demographic the bank services and the run is really bad.
- toufka 4y agoAnd in this case, tech savy individuals are willing to send $XXM in 6 clicks, 3min after getting a slack message. That's a pretty quick kind of run relative to old-school 'stand in line for your personal life savings' kind of run.
- ecopoesis 4y agoWhen was the last US bank failure where depositors lost money?
- silisili 4y agoAppears to be 2020, from a cursory Google search. https://money.stackexchange.com/questions/129772/has-anyone-ever-lost-money-over-the-fdic-limit https://money.stackexchange.com/questions/129772/has-anyone-... The oft quoted 'nobody has lost money' is from the FDIC, and specifically says 'insured deposits.'
- everybodyknows 4y agoWhat is "SVP"?
- dredmorbius 4y agoI suspect a typo for SVB, "Silicon Valley Bank".
- kgwgk 4y agoThe size of this failed bank is quite abnormal. The business of this failed bank is quite abnormal. The surprising thing may be that the find anyone willing to take it out of their hands - let alone by Monday.