15 ms·
Apple and Foxconn win permission for 12-hour shifts for women in India
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zamadatix 4y agoIf I'm following the numbers correctly it seems to functionally come out at max of ~60h/week where ~12 of that would be at an overtime rate. Not sure what that compares to before but it sounds like an increase in both base and overtime limits. Interesting the night shift wasn't allowed for women before.
- glogla 4y agoPrevious was max shift of 9 hours and max overtime of 75 hours per three months. Now it is 12 hour shifts with 145 hours of overtime per three months. So yeah, this comes at 5x12 shifts.
- e12e 4y agoA point of comparison - in Norway employers need special dispensation to have workers work more than 100 hours overtime per year (with max 40 regular hours/week and five weeks paid vacation time).
- renewiltord 4y agoTrue, but Norway is an oil nation.
- qwytw 4y agoDenmark, Sweden and a bunch other countries in Europe that have similar rules (probably lower pay though...) are not.
- e12e 4y agoI believe that after a period of strong Norwegian krone - we're now back to normal, and pay is generally better in Sweden and Denmark.
- qwytw 4y agoyeah, interesting. Sweden is pretty close to Norway but Denmark is considerably ahead of Norway. Doesn't seem that a high GDP correlates than much with higher salaries in Norway's case (unlike in Switzerland)
- e12e 4y agoSo is Qatar. (apparently 48 hour week / 8 hour day - two weeks of vacation - overtime to be compensated 25% - unsure about limits?)
- jacooper 4y agoI mean worker rights in Scandinavian countries are rather the exception.
- heywhatupboys 4y agoScandinavia, especially Denmark, are known for having few labor laws. That's the point of the Danish model: few workers' rights
- vamega 4y ago> The legislation limits the maximum workweek to 48 hours, but also increases the number of overtime allowed to 145 over a three-month period from the previous 75 hours. A 5x12 shift would require 1/5 of the time to be classified as overtime. Indian labour laws seem to state that overtime must be paid at 2x regular wages. Almost seems like it would make sense to hire more people and have them work 4x12?
- sct202 4y agoIt depends on the benefits, taxes, training they pay for the incremental employees if it's worth it to plan for overtime or hire more people. Foxconn is a massive operation making a tiny profit margin thru contract manufacturing so if they're doing it this way, it probably makes sense for them.
- bell-cot 4y agoGut Reaction: In what ways is this different from woman nurses in American hospitals regularly working 12-hour (or longer) shifts?
- tpmx 4y agoDo they work 12 hours every day (mon-fri), every week?
- lm28469 4y agoNurses take care of people But yeah we also have 12 hours shift in the west in some industries, I don't feel like it's a goal to strive for though
- AlexandrB 4y agoPerhaps it's not worse, but why do we reflexively set the bar at the worst working conditions we can think of?
- bell-cot 4y agoIf tens (or hundreds?) of thousands of rather well-paid American professionals are also working in the conditions mentioned (12-hour shifts), then I assume that the headline is "anything that says 'Apple'" clickbait. Or a symptom of sheltered & pampered western office workers - who at times seem to view normal, physical work as a human rights violation.
- incone123 4y agoI used to do 12 hour shifts in EMS, where men and women are on the same shift system, so no issue with the hours. But factory work (which I've also done, 8 hour shifts) is constantly intense across the whole shift and I wouldn't want to do it for 12 hours.
- supriyo-biswas 4y agoNot trying to justify the 12 hour shift, but I imagine work at an electronics factory would be less stressful than your typical factory job.
- jmann99999 4y agoI have very little understanding of India. While reading the article, it sounds like the changes to Indian labor law would enable more hours to be worked. However, I don't understand whether this is a good or bad thing for the average worker (and/or woman) in India. Can someone provide more insight? Thanks.
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- vishnugupta 4y agoI don’t know the finer details, but if they are proportionately paid more this is definitely a big step in the right direction for women workers. In general, women participation in workforce is outright abysmal in India. Hopefully this will be on of the many small steps towards addressing that.
- jdthedisciple 4y agoCan you elaborate what precisely is the issue with low female participation in a country's workforce?
- asdajksah2123 4y agoThe fact that half your workforce doesn't have an opportunity to contribute to the country's growth? I mean, cut the US or Europe's output by 25-30% (to match India's low female participation) and you're basically talking about eliminating decades of growth. People would be so much poorer and worse off. And that's just at the national level. There are a whole lot of other issues at the individual level, and the fact that it indicates a lack of freedom and opportunity for nearly half the country's population.
- jdthedisciple 4y agoIs a nations prosperity only related to its nominal growth and GDP? Then why don't we send more children to work as well to increase "growth" a bit further? Are there no tradeoffs involved? Like what it does to a country's demographics and families? Are there other ways to increase GDP without forcing women into the workforce - with potentially better tradeoffs?
- chitowneats 4y agoI read TFA and didn't notice an answer to my question below. Do men already have this permission? If so, I don't see why women shouldn't.
- supriyo-biswas 4y agoThis article[1] has a bit more detail. It mentions: > The maximum work hours for workers in Karnataka industries will be 12 hours in a day but capped at the same 48-hour work week. This means workers can put in 4-day or 5-day work weeks while more flexibility is available for the management of daily production lines. > Finally, women will now be allowed to work night shifts – from 7pm to 6am. [1] https://www.india-briefing.com/news/karnataka-india-work-hours-extended-industries-after-lobbying-from-apple-foxconn-27367.html/ https://www.india-briefing.com/news/karnataka-india-work-hou...
- chitowneats 4y agoThank you. This is the type of info I was expecting in TFA.
- jdthedisciple 4y agoShouldn't be too hard with a good reason. Ever noticed how men and women aren't exactly the same?
- chitowneats 4y agoThey aren't exactly the same. They are very different. I am far from a copypasta liberal politics idiot. A quick look at my comment history would have indicated this quite clearly to you. Please explain to me why women shouldn't be allowed to work 12 hour days? I eagerly await your response.
- jedberg 4y agoSo from what I can tell, it sounds like this is a win for women in India. They were restricted from working as long as men (and still are?) so they couldn't make as much money as men. I mostly post this because my initial reaction was "oh they made it easier to abuse them!" but it sounds like that's not actually the case, which is a bit of a relief.
- advisedwang 4y agoOr maybe the men are already being abused? Perhaps if there were working hour rules for everyone, wages would have to come up? The US has working hour regulations, but I don't hear the workers complain that they are being stifled from working as much as the want.
- dcow 4y agoWhat's inherently abusive about a 12 hour work day? And you don't here complaints in the US because the US does not limit the amount of hours you can work in a day. It just says that companies must provide an unpaid break for more than 5 consecutive hours of work.
- AstixAndBelix 4y ago[flagged]
- dcow 4y agoThen don't work 12 hours a day. Simple.
- AstixAndBelix 4y ago[flagged]
- dcow 4y agoWhat hyperbolic nonsense! For your comment to even begin to be taken seriously the majority of employers in India would have to de-facto require 12 hour work days. That's just not even remotely close to being true.
- supriyo-biswas 4y agohttps://archive.ph/FOBB2 https://archive.ph/FOBB2, since the original link doesn't render the text for me for some odd reason.
- geuis 4y agoThere is no article, just a single line of text as a headline.
- globular-toast 4y agoWhat a sad world we live in where the ability to work for 12 hours straight is seen as a good thing.
- noturno_mind 4y agomeanwhile here we are discussing 4-days work week
- jdthedisciple 4y agoI know right? I find it strange how the bulk of the HN crowd seems to applaud this. 12 hour average job in India is not like your comfy WFH Silicon Valley BS Jira ticket work.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoI'm working a 12 hour shift right now
- jklinger410 4y agoMy mom works 12 hour shifts as a CNC machinist in the United States. Is there some point to this article or is it just neat to know?
- pjmlp 4y agoYes, most modern countries have between 35 and 40 hour work weeks.
- neither_color 4y agoI don't believe that "most modern countries" don't make exceptions for work that requires it or critical fields. In fact, those of us who've worked non-traditional shifts usually get some perk out of it. When I worked 12 hour shifts I'd work 3-5 days in a row, then get the same amount of days off. To this day 5 days on 5 days off is the best schedule I've ever had. I also had a friend working in mines up north in Canada. He'd work on-shift for weeks at a time and then get 3 weeks off with a flight paid anywhere he wants in the world. Is Canada not a modern country?
- ddren 4y agoIs there anything about sitting in a line manufacturing electronics that requires 12 hours shifts?
- fnordpiglet 4y agoProfit
- YeahNO 4y agoAnd it isn't for the peons doing all the work...
- fnordpiglet 4y agoWell……. The peons need to feed their kids and send them to school and shelter their families. So, yes, actually it is for them too. 12 hour shift jobs usually pay better and have longer contiguous time off. But, yes, these are all happy side effects. Profit doesn’t give a shit, and if it could find a way to get the same for less it would.
- dwighttk 4y ago12-hour shifts and also nightshifts for women
- eevilspock 4y agoAll the comments hinge on whether it is fundamentally wrong or abusive for people to have to work 12-hour shifts or significantly more than the current American 40-hour per week standard. It's not the absolute amount of work people have to do to survive that is fundamentally wrong. If everyone commenting here got ship wrecked on a desert island together and we worked 100 hour weeks and had children work too in order to survive, it is obviously not fundamentally wrong. What's fundamentally wrong is that we effectively have a world-wide caste system. People in the upper castes live in better environments with better laws, consume a far greater share of the planet's resources per-capita, don't have to work as much, get paid more and own more of the planet per-capita, and on top of all that they leverage an economic system that is able to provide them with even more wealth (super computers in their pockets, hand-picked strawberries) and the freedom to work less and play more (hire nannies, maids and janitors, have food delivered) for incredibly cheap by coercing a race to the bottom for those in the bottom castes, who have to work harder, longer and in jobs upper caste people would consider nightmares and would need expensive therapists to recover from. I hate Elon Musk and Twitter is a hellscape, but if you used it for one thing, it should be to follow United Farmworker's account for a daily reminder of what your upper caste life is built upon. https://twitter.com/UFWupdates https://twitter.com/UFWupdates
- soperj 4y agoThis makes sense, since in general India is known for it's lack of available work force, so having people being able to work more overtime is the most logical thing. /sarcasm
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ROTMetro 4y agoYes, let's take these high repetitive stress injury rate jobs and tack an extra four hours on. Of course the workers will do it, they don't have a choice. But their body's won't for long. But that's a sacrifice Apples willing to make for the convenience of less production line handoffs. As someone who has been at the bottom and had very unfavorable work conditions forced on me because companies could F! Apple, do better, be better.
- mungoman2 4y agoI don't get this. Why push your work force like this? It's clearly very bad for the workers. And also for the factory, surely having 3 shifts is more efficient because your workers are not as fatigued so will work faster with fewer mistakes?
- hoherd 4y agoFor 24x7 production operations, 12 hour shifts make a lot of sense. You work 12 hours, hand off your role to the next incoming shift, and 12 hours later they hand off back to you. You do this for 3 days one week, 4 days the next. 4 hours of OT every day. I did this for 2 years at an LSI fab in Colorado Springs and it was great.
- kennywinker 4y agoWhy would this make more sense than three 8 hour shifts per day, for anybody but the employer?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI don't think it is the rational to come into a situation and assume that everyone but you is wrong and incapable of judging what is best for them. in India there are hundreds of millions of workers that would love to work 12 hours shifts for more pay and a better quality of life. I'm sure there are advantages to the factory as well.
- kennywinker 4y agoThe reason it's wrong is that if you work for 12 hours per day, and sleep for 8 hours per day, that leaves you with only 4 hours per day for living your ONE AND ONLY life
- 4y ago
- throw93 4y agoThe HN headline is incorrect. It’s not “12 hour shift for women”. It’s “12 hour shifts AND night shifts for women”. Night shift were not allowed earlier most likely because of safety reasons considering India’s not so great women safety record. Not saying it’s justified but that was the reason most likely.
- lostlogin 4y agoThat’s just made it even darker. Holy crap.
- 29083011397778 4y agoAt the headline itself: only literally. For example, I (and many others in Canada) work graveyard. I only have to work 4 days a week (which is fantastic), and it's apparently echoed in this legislation as it "...limits the maximum workweek to 48 hours". Graveyard can limit ones health, but I think it gets a bad rap, and could wax poetic about other reasons I prefer it. Sent during day two of my long weekend :)
- dang 4y agoI believe you but I don't fully understand this. Can anyone suggest an accurate, neutral title, preferably using a representative phrase* from the article? If so, we can edit it. * https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=representative%20article%20by%3Adang&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- throw93 4y agoThe title of the referenced article itself should be good enough "Apple and Foxconn win permission for 12-hour shifts and night shifts for women at iPhone production in India". The original poster omitted the words "and night shifts" for some reason.
- thunderbong 4y ago
- timerol 4y agoIn addition to the 12 hour shift for all, and night shifts being allowed for women, there is still a 48 hour workweek, and maximum overtime of 145 hours in a 3 month period (an average of one extra 12 hour shift per week). Indian employers are required to pay double for overtime, so this seems mostly like the ability to move to 12x4 instead of 8x6. From an Indian minister: > “Now, the rule is that workers should work for 48 hours and the aim is to reduce work from six days a week to four or five and in a total week, the work still remains at 48 hours. In the case of those working for 10 hours a day, the workers will work for five days a week and those who work for eight hours a day will work for six days a week,” Ashwathnarayan said. From https://www.msn.com/en-in/news/other/karnataka-passes-bill-allowing-12-hour-work-days-in-industries-weekly-work-hours-to-remain-at-48-hours/ar-AA181nLg https://www.msn.com/en-in/news/other/karnataka-passes-bill-a...
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoThis reminds me of when people in China were expected to work on Saturdays back in 1999. Developing countries often require 48 hours a week as a way of catching up.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago1999? This was news in 2019. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system
- tough 4y agoJack Ma took some bad rap for promoting it if I remember correctly
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoYa, it is still common in some tech companies, but it was ubiquitous in 1999. By the time I started working in China (not for Alibaba) in 2007, it was not a mandatory practice anymore. China had changed a lot in just 8 years.
- 4y ago
- tsss 4y agoAnd why should men have to work longer than women?
- jdthedisciple 4y ago"Yayy women can finally be away from darned prison that we call home for 12 hours a day and even at night to do some bullshit job to help some idiot get a little richer yasss let's celebrate wohoo"
- chitowneats 4y agoI take back my other comment. I don't eagerly await any responses from you. Your comments are childish. Get off HN and go enjoy your 20s. If by chance you are older than that, grow up. No one is forcing anyone to work 12 hour days. It's about allowing it should a woman choose to accept the position. I get your angle now. Trad nonsense.
- bon-98 4y agoHopefully he isn't working in India on a 13 hour schedule lest he shall be able to enjoy his 20s. Just pay the worker a fair wage and they won't be pressured or expected to work these long shifts (which is what we all know is REALLY going on.) Putting pressure on The Corporation is asking too much, right?
- chitowneats 4y agoYes, corporations should pay a fair wage. This is about gender parity in government policy. I will entertain arguments that no one should be allowed to work 12 hours, or that both men and women can. If you look at the other comment he made, you'll see he's arguing for neither of those.
- 5350-uiop-1130 4y agohttps://nypost.com/2020/12/15/riots-at-apple-plant-in-india-cause-7-million-in-damage/ https://nypost.com/2020/12/15/riots-at-apple-plant-in-india-... this is what apple does. they use their clout, then they turn their back and play ignorant whilst placing unrealistic demands on the subcontractors who then place those demand on the labour. from: https://www.macrumors.com/2023/02/14/only-half-of-indian-iphone-casings-meet-standards/ https://www.macrumors.com/2023/02/14/only-half-of-indian-iph... > 'Apple engineers told that Chinese iPhone suppliers and government officials have a "whatever it takes" approach to win iPhone orders, work was often completed weeks ahead of schedule at "inexplicable speed". In India, [we] are not running at this pace. "There just isn't a sense of urgency," one Apple engineer remarked.'
- fnordpiglet 4y agoI like when people use words like inexplicable for things for which they know exactly how it’s achieved, but want to pretend they don’t because the answer is disturbing.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoiPhones are not worth that answer. Nor is any other electronic. I wish this was escapable somehow, but my employer literally requires and pays for this equipment. To abstain from employment would be crazy – it wouldn't send a message to Apple. What the hell can someone do?
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoI think a general strike is desperately needed. Seeing Biden do a complete about face on unions to enrich the robber barons that run domestic rail was the last sign I needed. Unfortunately the people who would benefit the most from striking are those who either drink the propaganda from conservative outlets or are otherwise marginalized. Felons, people on probation, green card workers, the poorly educated, chronically overworked, etc.
- fnordpiglet 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- geodel 4y agoWell, Apple/Foxconn gonna do Apple/Foxconn. But India really needs to look at growing unemployment problem for its massive population. Working hours need to be set like 30-40h a week. It helps nation (not necessarily companies) in two ways: 1) Employees to not get overworked as a rule. 2) Companies can hire more employees and run more shifts if they need 24/7 work. Right now there are huge number of young people sitting at home for years unable to find any employment and other few are being overworked.
- dirtyid 4y agoIf Foxconn is going to follow the campus model, which is likely because Apple manufacturing cities draws labour from across country, that means building infra to house 2x-3x more workers, especially during surge production for new launches. Reality is it's a low margin business and Taiwanese companies have decades learning to squeeze blood from stone, hence their reputation of being slave drivers across Asia for a reason. Of course your system is good for India, but these companies are only in India because it's good for them.
- geodel 4y agoAgree on all points. I feel in larger picture it is not just that China is geopolitical risk out of nowhere. The demographics of China is changing and they themselves do not want 12 hour slave labor type of jobs as much as they would in last few decades. With India's still growing population and unimaginative political class the only model to follow is Chinese model of past. And these Foxconn factories are example of that.
- throwawaaarrgh 4y agoVote with your dollars, people. Don't buy Apple and Foxconn products if you care about the wellbeing of workers.
- spiderice 4y agoWait what? Because of 12 hour shifts? Should I not use hospitals either? Or are you referring to other working conditions unrelated to 12 hour shifts?
- ROTMetro 4y agoIs someone doing the same task 60 times a minute in the hospital that entire shift minus a lunch break? Do assembly line workers for Apple get treated the same as hospital workers? Not eve close! Do hospital workers have to ask permission to go to the bathroom? Do hospitals have suicide nets to prevent their workers from trying to kill themselves because they have lost all hope? You are talking two very different things.
- cute_boi 4y agoHow about we also address the issue of hospital working conditions? Nurses shouldn't be forced to work more than an 8-hour shift. While there may be some issues with knowledge transfer during shift changes, there are solutions available that may increase costs but are necessary to prioritize the well-being of healthcare workers. In the case of Apple, it appears they are being driven by greed, and the transfer of knowledge to work in their factories is generally unnecessary. I require people to not support greedy corporation.
- alexhjones 4y agoWhat’s the next best alternative?
- fnordpiglet 4y agoTrue. We wouldn’t want women to be able to earn as much as men in India. It’s important to take a principled stand against gender parity and punish these guys with your wallet.
- newmanah223 4y agoI try not to judge these jobs by first world standards. What I don't understand is why a company can use $2 an hour labor and then sell a product for $1K. If I ran the US, I would put heavy tariffs on goods that companies try to outsource for cheap labor. This would encourage them to use technology and robotics to produce domestically.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoTariffs would increase the cost of these outrageously profitable products decreasing their market reducing sales. All things capitalists hate. Lofty goals like safe working conditions will always be fought against by capitalists who, by design of their own, are completely disconnected from the reality their greed creates.
- angelgonzales 4y agoThere are no alternative economic systems without questionable environmental and safety records. Any production system will be designed to maximize outputs at the quality the customer requires while minimizing process inputs. Whatever psychological and social framework is used organize companies, governments and individuals, the individual workers will still be performing the same assembly processes on the factory floor.
- andrepd 4y agoThat's a nonsensical statement. Slavery, feudalism, and neoliberal states all attempt to produce as efficiently as possible, but they're obviously quite different...
- angelgonzales 4y agoThe internal mechanisms are quite different, yes, however, the inputs and outputs are for the sake of this discussion, identical. The people, regardless of the system, would probably be performing the same types of operations. I’m not sure you read my original point as I intended it to be understood. A worker making tires under authoritarian communism is still going to be making tires under democratic capitalism - the differences in this worker’s experience may not be the result of these political and economic systems but rather policy at the corporate, departmental or state level which are not unique or exclusive to a particular government or economy. Any system will self propagate at the expense of other systems and individuals like workers.
- throw93 4y agoIt’s always race to the bottom for workers when multiple states are fighting for iPhone factory. They drop the labor protections, drop minimum wages($2-3 per day), increase working hours. It’s just a win for Apple and nobody else(maybe politicians). All this for a bigger screen to watch TikTok on. What a sad time we live in.
- JanisErdmanis 4y ago> The law makes Karnataka one of the most flexible places to work in India This is quite a take. The flexibility seems here is meant to be in favour of employers, not employees who are in a situation to work 12-hour shifts. In that case, the word exploitable would be more appropriate. > be very efficient in terms of increasing productivity If the increasing length of a shift is seen as productivity improvement, I wonder what the next step is going to be for them. Stagnating wages in an inflationary environment seems like a good candidate.
- gabrieledarrigo 4y agoFuck you Capitalism. I hate you.
- skc 4y agoSomehow, Apple will have a moving video about their human centered values at their next product launch and there won't be a dry eye in the room. It's sickening how effective it is.
- lazyeye 4y agoYes these are the kinds of people in Silicon Valley that like to lecture everybody else on how to think and behave.
- mns 4y agoThey make it up with those watch armbands and some women presenters, it’s fine!
- throw_m239339 4y ago"we are diverse and inclusive". That's all it takes for western consumers to forget about the unethical and immoral way these corporations make money and feel good about themselves. 20 years ago it was "we're green", in 20 years it will be something else.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoTo be fair, this does seem like a step forward wrt gender equality.
- diyseguy 4y agoI once had a typing job working 3 days at 12 hours each with 4 days off. Though by the third day it was kinda rough, it was still the greatest arrangement I've ever had.
- erenyeager 4y agoEncouraging women to work, and go work more hours has to be one of the biggest swindles in modern society. It leads to less time to focus on children, puts more pressure on families, and gives more influence to outside factors like government, media, and businesses on children, instead of parents. Frankly I’m waiting for when UBI can be more disbursed and people can work for useful things as they please without the millstone at their necks.
- not_me_ever 4y agoFor comparison: That is 4-6h less per day than at the shop which produced the jeans you are wearing.