4 ms·
> most startups in the US bank with them Is this true? And if so, how was this not a major red flag for investors earlier? From what I gather as an outsider,
by lolinder 4y ago
> most startups in the US bank with them
Is this true? And if so, how was this not a major red flag for investors earlier?
From what I gather as an outsider, it sounds like SVB has most of its assets in the form of loans to tech startups and most of its liabilities in the form of deposits from tech startups. This seems like an obvious recipe for disaster in the event of a tech downturn, no?
EDIT: People have clarified that the bonds are the big problem on the assets side, not the loans. They had a bunch of low interest rate bonds that now have to be sold at a loss because interest rates are much higher.
- tommoor 4y agoVC's are generally the ones that actively promoted SVB to their investments. There's literally a branch on Sandhill road.
- lolinder 4y agoBy investors I'm not talking about venture capitalists, I'm talking about the stock market. I'm just surprised that people are just now realizing how bad it is to have the lion's share of Silicon Valley's financial resources centralized in one institution that doesn't have much in the way of other business.
- dahdum 4y agoTheir success is due to their tight focus though isn’t it? They’ve been around for 40 years and deeply entrenched in the VC ecosystem. I am very curious whether their poor risk management is new, or if they’ve been playing fast and loose for much longer and only blowing up now.
- blitzar 4y agoSince 1980 interest rates have only really ever gone down. Buying long dated bonds at X% and having to sell them a year later at X-1% actually makes you a capital gain. Old habits die hard.
- kasey_junk 4y agoSVB has an extremely low loan to deposit ratio (~.45). Most of their assets are in the form of treasuries, bonds, etc. Depositor concentration is definitely high but that’s not particularly uncommon in banks (though for one of this size it is). But that concentration is what fueled their growth as well.
- lolinder 4y ago> Most of their assets are in the form of treasuries, bonds, etc. I believe you know what you're talking about, but if that's the case why are they struggling to raise capital to pay depositors? (I'm asking as an ignorant outsider to banking in general and SVB in particular.)
- lokar 4y agoInterest rates went up. That would be fine if they could hold the bonds until maturity, but to honor withdrawals now they are forced to sell at a loss.
- lolinder 4y agoRight! Okay, that makes sense. So the failure on the assets end of the balance sheet was relying on bonds that were purchased at times of historically low interest.
- lokar 4y agoAlso, in more normal time they could have put more deposits into shorter term debt that would not have had this problem. But rates were so low that would have been very unattractive.
- lordnacho 4y agoWhat doesn't seem to be so explicitly stated is that due to rates going up, the bonds are worth less than they were when rates were high. So they wouldn't have enough money if they turned the bonds into money. Guy lends you 100 at 3%, you buy 100 of bonds than pay you 5%. Guy asks for his money back, your bonds are worth only 80, big problem.
- gizmo 4y agoIt was a major red flag! You're right about their liabilities, but their assets are mostly longish duration bonds. When interest rates go up their main customer base (startups) will have a harder time raising money (bad for them) and the value of their bonds will go down (because new bonds offer more interest). And now they're forced to sell these bonds at a loss to cover the money outflow (customers leaving). They're deep in the hole with no way out. Basically SVB failed basic risk management, and they deserve to go down. You can't promise your customers they can take their money out at any time and then turn around and invest that money in longer duration assets you can't liquidate. Just irresponsible. Execs selling millions worth of shares in the past weeks is also classy.
- Aperocky 4y agoSo a slow version of Terra Luna. Resilient system design doesn't just apply to engineers.
- phpnode 4y agoit's a totally different situation to Terra/Luna
- Aperocky 4y agoThe Terra/Luna system would work very well when Luna's cap >> Terra. The SVB system would work very well if the interest rates stay low, when they could liquidate their 10 year bonds for same value (and their start up would be more likely to turn profits as well). These are all systems designed with assumption that turned out to be false.
- karpierz 4y agoThe issue is not that SVB has loaned too much to companies that can't pay it back. The issue is that SVB took in a lot of deposits in 2021-2022, and locked them into 10 year bonds at 2.5% interest. Now in 2023, a lot of their customers are burning money (withdrawing funds) and aren't raising money (depositing funds), and so they need to start liquidating the 10 year bonds. The issue is that the 2021 bonds are discounted because interest rates have grown since, and they're out some money unless they can hold the bonds to maturity. So they're raising money to bridge the deficit to allow themselves to hold more of the bonds.
- lolinder 4y agoRight, I get the loans don't feature right now, but the reason why depositor behavior is so concentrated is because they're mostly in the same industry affected by the same market forces. To have large numbers of loans out to that same industry at the same time is additional risk, whether or not that particular risk caused problems this time. EDIT: Elsewhere in the comment thread people have clarified that the bonds are the big problem on the assets side. They had a bunch of low interest rate bonds that now have to be sold at a loss because interest rates are much higher.
- abarringer 4y agoRight, Talking to some people in the banking industry and the fear is no one know which other banks are in similar situation.
- blitzar 4y agohint: every bank Most banks dont have the same cash flow in/out profile that SVB are facing thus wont have the same issues.
- chasely 4y agoWhy would they buy 10-year bonds when their depositors are startups, many of whom won't exist in 10 years? Seems like shorter-term T-bills would have been more appropriate, but I know next to nothing about finance.
- adamsmith143 4y agoWhat could possibly go wrong running a bank by working with the most volatile companies on Earth with failure rates above 90% lol.
- mbreese 4y agoThey aren't loaning money to the startups (well, mostly). They handled the banking. This current problem has nothing to do with their clientele, it has to do with long term bonds. They sell banking services to startups... all companies need some way to manage payroll (for example). Regardless of the balance sheets of their clients, they should have been able to manage assets such that they could fulfill day to day banking needs. It's that failure to manage assets on the bank side that we're talking about. Startups/clients failing should be a normal event at SVB, given their focus.
- frellus 4y agoAs far as I understood it, the 10% which paid off made SVB into the type of bank it is today. They obviously made a bad move in 2020-21 in thinking the public market was going to crash and what would happen to bond yields, but so did lots of people. If you think SVB is the only bank which is making high risk decisions to get payoffs, I would suggest you level up and look at what ALL these banks are doing. Faith in the system and long-term risk assessment isn't built into the mentality of banks which have so much invested in equity trading vs. boring deposits.
- paulddraper 4y agoThe financial stability of the depositors had ~0 to do with this situation.
- adamsmith143 4y agoThis is completely wrong. This was a classic bank run caused by the startups banking with SVB switching from net depositors to net withdrawers as they aren't able to raise in the current environment and obviously none of them actually make money. The withdrawals start, there was a liquidity and then a panic and boom bank dead.
- riseagainst22 4y agoThis is true. most startups are trying to bank with the company I work at now and switch from SVB to us, it is a fucking panic and some of these companies are trying to send us 100's of mill cash in hand
- paulddraper 4y ago> Is this true? And if so, how was this not a major red flag for investors earlier? The red flag being......? There is nothing per se that makes this situation unique to startups. This would happen to any bank that (1) made bad investments (2) caught the public eye.