8 ms·
Chemicals released during wildfires in Australia damaged the ozone layer
- imdsm 4y agoSo basically, chlorine compounds (hydrochloric acid) in the atmosphere from CFCs (old aerosols, fridges) turn back into chlorine thanks to the smoke particles, which wouldn't otherwise happen, and the sun then causes the chlorine to break down in sunlight to chlorine ions which "eat the ozone". So it's a race against time between the ozone recovering through the decay of these CFC-related harmless chemicals, and smoke from wildfires making the ozone larger and not recovering. Not all wildfires send smoke high enough though. Interesting read!
- gonzo41 4y agoTake home lesson, start wearing sun hoodies.
- londons_explore 4y agoHydrochloric acid is a rather common chemical, produced by humans in the tens of millions of tonnes. I believe it is also quite common in nature - for example, your stomach acid is mostly hydrochloric acid.
- Groxx 4y agoI'm not really sure what you're trying to imply here. E.g. I don't usually vomit into the upper atmosphere.
- brink 4y agoIt sounds like a reason to do more controlled burns.
- leoedin 4y agoThey don't seem to answer the question of why the chlorine in the atmosphere comes mainly from CFCs. What about all the chlorine we use every day from e.g. bleach and swimming pools? Does that not wreck the ozone layer because it never gets high enough into the atmosphere?
- Uehreka 4y agoI guess that would be nice background, but you can also find the answer in like 5 minutes on Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chlorofluorocarbon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chlorofluorocarbon From the section on Regulation: > It turns out that one of CFCs' most attractive features—their low reactivity—is key to their most destructive effects. CFCs' lack of reactivity gives them a lifespan that can exceed 100 years, giving them time to diffuse into the upper stratosphere. Once in the stratosphere, the sun's ultraviolet radiation is strong enough to cause the homolytic cleavage of the C-Cl bond.
- chris_va 4y agoThey also eat methane, which is a potent greenhouse gas, so it's not all bad
- hummus_bae 4y ago[dead]
- mistrial9 4y agoIs it odd that a collection of non-USA researchers published something similar a year earlier? the USA-based Nature publication here is clearly paywalled so, hard to check the real differences, or publication references. https://acp.copernicus.org/preprints/acp-2022-247/acp-2022-247.pdf https://acp.copernicus.org/preprints/acp-2022-247/acp-2022-2...
- tokai 4y agoNo, not odd. Multiple of the authors of the paper you are linking are cited in the Nature paper. Your paper also cites prior research from Solomon - the first author of the Nature article. It is unsurprising that the two papers don't reference each other as they have been written and in review at the same time. They are all atmospheric researchers, so there is ofc a change that their research subjects overlap.
- stateofinquiry 4y agoNot sure why you are focused on "USA" or "non-USA", but FYI: Nature originated in the UK. Today, Springer-Nature is a major international publisher. Springer (formerly Springer-Verlag) originated in Germany, BTW.
- photochemsyn 4y agoCuriously enough, chlorine radicals and volatile organic compounds from coal and wood combustion have the opposite effect in the lower atmosphere, where the interaction increases ozone production (due to reaction with various nitrogen oxides). This also generates the lung irritant PAN which is a component of brown smog: https://www.nature.com/articles/srep36821 https://www.nature.com/articles/srep36821 > "The chlorine radical is a potent atmospheric oxidant, capable of perturbing tropospheric oxidative cycles normally controlled by the hydroxyl radical. Significantly faster reaction rates allow chlorine radicals to expedite oxidation of hydrocarbons, including methane, and in polluted environments, to enhance ozone production... Even when present at low levels, Cl radicals can have a profound impact on tropospheric oxidation and radical cycling. Cl chemistry can significantly impact levels of tropospheric ozone, a greenhouse gas that is also a precursor for the OH radical, destroying it in clean environments and enhancing its formation under polluted conditions." Incidentally, Australia's massive wildfires of 2019-2020 produced about 700 million tons of CO2, which is only about 1/3 of Australia's annual fossil CO2 generation from coal (counting total production of Australian coal, of which only about 1/5th is burned in Australia itself, the rest being exported). If you want to eliminate fossil fuel use, and aren't just posturing for political convenience, stopping production makes a lot more sense than stopping emissions at point-of-use.
- londons_explore 4y ago> If you want to eliminate fossil fuel use, and aren't just posturing for political convenience, stopping production makes a lot more sense than stopping emissions at point-of-use. This. And the fact I haven't heard of any country saying "we'll stop extracting coal/oil to help the environment" tells me nobody really cares about the environment - everyone just wants to look like they care to appease voters.
- omegabravo 4y agoDepriving people of energy can be just as catastrophic. While not digging it up would be effective, I'm not sure some people in developing* country would necessarily agree. It's a complex topic, and Australia (where I live) has little excuse to still be using coal fired energy so much. Politics gets in the way of the obvious solutions. I don't particularly like attributing CO2 to the source. Unless we're going to stop counting CO2 emission internally, because the oil has been extracted elsewhere. edit: updated to developing, didn't realise the other was offensive. My apologies
- fwlr 4y agoThis article missed the chance to be much more interesting. While the 2019-2020 Australian fires were undoubtedly catastrophic, there have been other much worse fires in recent times. This one killed 34 people; a decade prior, the bushfire season killed 5 times as many people, with 174 deaths. Four decades prior to that, the bushfire season burned 5 times as much land area as the 2019-2020 season, with over 15% of Australia’s total land area suffering fire damage. It was the particularly intense burning, causing smoke to travel much further than usual, that caused this season to loom so large in people’s minds. There are astounding figures, like that 80% of the populace experienced days or weeks of heavily smoke-filled air, or that it arguably killed as many as 450 people indirectly through smoke inhalation interacting with existing respiratory issues. That intense burning was due mostly to the extremely high fuel density of the particular areas that were on fire - forests rather than grasslands. And the intense burning caused some incredible phenomena: flames at ground level that would reach the 20th floor of a skyscraper, radiant heat so extreme that you could be standing on the other side of an 8-lane highway and it would still give you 2nd degree degree burns in seconds and kill you in minutes, fire fronts that travel for days at an average of 6-8 miles an hour (even an ultra-marathon runner with a head start could not stay ahead of the fire) and reach peak speeds over 80mph (overtaking you in your car)… and all throughout, the roar of a thousand jet engines as vegetation literally exploded at the fire’s approach - gaseous decomposition from the ambient heat. These fires were so intense that they launched smoke far higher into the atmosphere than fires usually do, and so we got to see some very unusual chemistry happen in the atmosphere. I criticize the article for not being as interesting as it could be because it exhibits the same malady as so much of the other reporting on that bushfire season - the unique physics ignored in favour of using the tragedy for political purposes.
- magicalist 4y ago> the unique physics ignored in favour of using the tragedy for political purposes. A new study attempting to explain a previously noticed phenomenon in the ozone layer is "for political purposes", seriously?
- fwlr 4y agoPerhaps I am being a little unfair, there is a lot of discussion of the physics and chemistry in the article. It may seem like a wild leap to start talking about politics because of a few paragraphs at the end of the article, to which I offer the defense that the Australian media landscape during that season was extremely, aggravatingly politicized. I did try to make sure most of my comment was focused on the interesting physics of extreme wildfires, leaving my criticism as a one-line post-script at the end.
- CE02 4y agoI think this is illustrative of a broader theme which is how enduring and baked in a lot of our climate degradation is. As much as the chlorine compounds will decay, but not exactly anytime soon. To think we won’t have an issue with this again before they’re decayed would be ridiculous. It’s the same thing with the broader topic of global warming. Absolutely we should seek to minimize greenhouse gas emissions, that’s a no brainer. But at our current stage in developement, especially with some countries not exactly being team players in this fight, a lot of the increase and future increase in temperature is baked in (pardon the pun). As much as I’m all for mitigation, much like the wildfires themselves, we will already have plenty of consequences to come. That’s why I’m so excited to see focus shifting more towards mitigation and resilience. We need to be prepared for the inevitable we’ve caused.
- Uehreka 4y agoPersonally, I wouldn’t use the term “excited”. The focus could just as easily shift towards nationalist movements trying to hoard resources and prevent refugees from warmer areas from crossing borders. There’s no guarantee that “resilience” is going to come in the form of technical innovation or human cooperation.
- CE02 4y agoAs much as I see the concerns, the issues that could arise from resilience are issues that can arise anywhere where human self-interest is present which is just about everything. I am excited for firms to start focusing on greener office buildings, even if their are some using it to greenwash for optics. Though as I mentioned, I completely see your point. I guess I should rephrase to “I am excited that there is the potential for positive action in this space.
- voytec 4y agoI highly recommend The Juice Media YT channel and their caricatured series called "Honest Government Ads" [1]. They are covering climate change and, among others, Australian government incompetency in quite funny, provocative and slightly NSFW way. [1] The Fires: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6BmbvTvFQ3g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6BmbvTvFQ3g [1] We're Fine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cOmdkN6MOwU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cOmdkN6MOwU [1] the Safeguard Mechanism: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YrkE_VaMD4k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YrkE_VaMD4k
- samstave 4y agoLove things like this! "Brought to you by the Department of Thoughts and Prayers"
- King-Aaron 4y ago"Everything is Cool and Normal (TM)"
- voytec 4y agoI've learned the wonderful word "shitfuckery" from them.
- swarnie 4y agoI thought that named looked familiar and oh my, they are the RAP NEWS guys. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L6O6sM2Shok https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L6O6sM2Shok I'm going to lose an hour of my life reminiscing about how Youtube used to be and what it would have been.
- sterlind 4y agoRap News was wasted on the early 2010s. Such a stable, boring time compared to Brexit, Trump, Covid, the war in Ukraine, ChatGPT, UAP disclosure. Why couldn't Robert Foster have been born a few years later?
- anoncow 4y agoI read recently that wildfires should be allowed to burn down forests as smaller wildfires when prevented will result in larger wildfires in the future (because of availability of more dry organic fuel). This combined with the current article makes me question the approach Australia currently uses for wildfires. Do we let small wildfires burn themselves out? If yes, why are larger fires happening? Should we actively trim forests periodically? If no, why not?
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoProbably no one wants to take the risk or responsibility for letting a small one burn in the event that they lose control. No one gets in trouble for failing at trying to put it out. But taking the decision to stand back? You'll get raked over coals if it was the wrong decision.
- krimpenrik 4y agoThey definitely do controlled burning to remove organic fuel. 4 years ago i was working at a farm in Western Australia near Albany and the sterling range mountain range they did a controlled burn which got out of hand and we had to evacuate. Spend the next week's putting out fires that reignite. Farmers also burn down crop fields to make seeding easier and is a risk to jump in other fields or neighboring woodlands. My girlfriend there worked as a parc ranger / firefighter. It's a big topic, farmers in the outback have their own firetrucks and teams
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- steve_mcdougall 4y agoHow could Dan Andrews do this? /s