11 ms·
Battery-free Game Boy (2020)
- kilgnad 4y agoThis will be worth billions of dollars in a post war apocalypse when electricity no longer exists.
- kube-system 4y agoI'll give you a half billion for a water wheel, roll of wire, and a magnet.
- elecush 4y agoOnce a GameBoy, now GameMan.
- aabhay 4y agoSomehow it doesn’t quite roll off the tongue when spoken aloud..
- the_third_wave 4y agoWhen I was a boy everything was just a game. Now I'm a man things are for real. Who would have thought that a GameBoy would lead to a RealMan?
- yftsui 4y agoIf electricity no longer exists, any electronic device will cease to function including this one. If you mean power grid is all down, the biggest winner would be those crank style devices or generator installers.
- nunobrito 4y agoIt's incredibly easy to produce/extract electricity. Can even take it directly from the ground with some water on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0zrDI_1q7o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0zrDI_1q7o
- rom-antics 4y agoWhen I was a kid I had a toy electronics kit and one of the circuits was an AM radio that worked without batteries. A normal radio station signal is strong enough to drive a pair of earbuds without any additional power. Since then I've always wondered if you could harvest that same radio energy to power other things without batteries, maybe even a Game Boy. There's electromagnetic radiation in the air all around us. And I'm sure you could build a Game Boy using today's tech that's much more power efficient than the ones from the 90s.
- knodi123 4y ago> I've always wondered if you could harvest that same radio energy to power other things without batteries That's how passive RFID tags work. The tag has a tiny little computer, and you hold it near a thing that emits an electric field that energizes it.
- pfannkuchen 4y agoI think the poster wants this to work without the “you hold it near a thing” part.
- mike256 4y agoBut it still works almost the same way. You hold it near a thing to get energy is mostly required because it works with very little power, let's say some milliwatts. Whereas old AM stations where sending in the range of megawatts.
- c12 4y agoThat broadcast power is required to provide range. Radio waves obey the inverse-square law: for every doubling of the distance from source you get four times less power. This is also why wireless power transmission at a distance isn't really viable.
- tootie 4y agoRFID can absolutely work at long range. Most applications don't by design because they don't want the data on the chip stolen. But there are applications that can read RFID from tens or hundreds of meters away.
- userbinator 4y agoI suspect actually reimplementing the original GameBoy SoC in a modern low-power process could provide a significant improvement over the inefficiency of an emulator.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoI was under the impression that doing things directly in custom silicon was always more efficient than emulation (all other things held fixed) both from a performance and power consumption perspective. The problem of course is that it costs orders of magnitude more money to implement, to say nothing of the difficulty in designing/testing the thing. It's basically the same progression we saw in bitcoin mining: Custom software on a general purpose CPUs, then on GPUs, then programmed on FPGAs, then actual ASICs that are straight up custom silicon to do nothing but check those hashes.
- byhemechi 4y agoI'm pretty sure @userbinator is talking about taking the exact same circuit but making it on something like TSMC's 4nm process, rather than an emulator running on a general purpose processor (i.e. CPU)
- deelowe 4y agoYou'd need to somehow address the SRAM potentially losing it's memory during power loss events.
- schappim 4y agoThis is definitely achievable! When I was a young, we'd take long road trips and my Gameboy (original) would run out of battery. I'd use a small solar panel (in place of one of the batteries) from a science kit to keep going, propped up against the back window. The wires and panel were held in place with chewing gum (yes, kids can be gross). I did have the "frequent power failures". Props to the team on fixing this :)
- 8note 4y agoI just had a wall plug in for my game boy colour. That worked quite well because the grid's always been pretty reliable
- boomboomsubban 4y agoCars usually lacked wall plugs. You could get ones that plugged into the cigarette lighter, but my parents at least were unwilling to string a cable through the gear selector to the back seat.
- IIAOPSW 4y agoThe trick is negotiation. Start by trying to bum a cigarette off mom. Then settle for using the cigy lighter for your gameboy
- vanderZwan 4y agoIt looks like we're talking about parents who did not realize on their own that keeping the Game Boy powered up helps keep the kid in the back of the car quiet, so I don't know if they would have been open to negotiation.
- schappim 4y agoThey purchased it for a flight from Sydney to Frankfurt in the mid-1990s... They so knew what they were doing, even when I didn't!
- Waterluvian 4y agoLooks like they used an existing emulator and this was mostly a hardware and memory integrity experiment. I’d love to see this approached from the perspective of “how clever can we get with the emulator itself to save power?” When I wrote mine, something I ran into was realizing that often the CPU and PPU are just doing the same thing over and over and over. If only I could cache all that work. For example, you don’t modify the previous frame. You have to draw the entire frame every time, writing sprites from OAM memory every time. Sometimes games do clever stuff here for effects, but a lot of the time you’re just drawing the same stuff. Like Tetris is almost completely a routine of drawing almost entirely the same graphics every time. Most of the cycles and OAM writes are just juggling sprites to draw the same layout every time. I documented the heck out of the PPU because it gave me the second most grief (sound being the worst by far) if you are curious: https://github.com/ablakey/gameboy/blob/master/src/guest/systems/ppu.rs https://github.com/ablakey/gameboy/blob/master/src/guest/sys... (goodness I’m proud of this project. Don’t tell my boss. He’ll want this level of documentation at work ;) )
- rapind 4y agoThat was a pleasure to read through. Made me think of literate code.
- IshKebab 4y agoAm I the only one that thinks this is a normal level of comments? Ok maybe slightly more than I would normally do... But if I was reading it my thought would be "thank god they wrote comments" not "they commented the heck out of this!"
- hackernewds 4y agoyou must also have really good commenting habits. I've rarely seen this at work, let alone for a passion project
- actionfromafar 4y agoIt sticks out to me. The regular mode for me when reading code is guessing. Even more rare are comprehensive comments which are actually up to date. Documenting something which never changes (like a gameboy) lends itself more to such. (Even though the code can still change, the device it emulates at least never does.)
- mhb 4y agoIs there a schematic? Did I miss it?
- MaanuAir 4y agoThere is a GitHub link near the end: https://github.com/tudssl/engage https://github.com/tudssl/engage
- KennyBlanken 4y agoI don't really understand why they wouldn't just use a supercapacitor instead of going to great lengths to work with a "small" capacitor? For the size/weight of the old batteries you could probably put 30-40 farad worth in, which I would think would be plenty. The energy harvesting buttons have to be incredibly annoying ergonomically - for gaming, you do NOT want buttons that are really hard to press.
- jandrese 4y agoI have to wonder just how much power they get out of those button presses. It seems like it must be such a tiny amount that it's hardly worth the effort.
- icoder 4y agoDepends on the game a bit but I too am a bit sceptical that this adds much, would be interesting to see a breakdown of solar vs buttons.
- vanderZwan 4y agoEven if it turns out to be useless, this was a research project. Testing if this is feasible in practice is part of the point. Although it is a bit odd that they don't show any stats on the main page. I looked it up in the paper[0], section 5.2 discusses power consumption/generation and pasted it below (I hope all symbols survived the clipboard). TL;DR: the buttons generate a very small difference in power generation relative to solar panels. HOWEVER, this still seems to be a significant difference in how quickly the battery drains. If solar panels generate 10.5 mW, and the buttons 0.5 mW, but the system requires 11.5 mW, then this doubles the up-time of the system. That would actually be quit a nice insight to share on the main project page IMO! > We have measured ENGAGE’s power consumption, looking into overall power consumption whilst first measuring the consumption of MCU together with the FRAM and display. The MCU and FRAM combined consume 11.15 mW and the screen consumes 344.31 μW during game execution taking a ten second average. During idle time the screen only consumes 3.90 μW, resulting in a combined system average power consumption of 11.50 mW. As a comparison, the original Nintendo Game Boy consumes 232.08 mW during game execution, varying slightly per game and cartridge architecture. While not necessarily a useful or meaningful number, we conclude that our platform is more than 20 times more power-efficient than the original Nintendo Game Boy (representing normal technology advancement, but noting that ENGAGE is an emulator). The measurements were conducted using a Fluke 87V [33] multimeter and the X-NUCLEO-LPM01A [123] programmable power supply source with power consumption measurement capability > Then, to give more insight in the energy harvesting on the ENGAGE platform we have measured the amount of energy the solar panels generate using a Fluke 87V [ 33 ] multimeter and compare this to the energy generated from the buttons. For the buttons we use the minimal energy generation figures from the specification of the harvester [ 153 , summary] as a worst case scenario3. Assuming that a single button press generates a minimum of 0.66 mJ and knowing the amount of button presses per game is specific to the game as per Table 1 , we can assume the buttons generate between 0.66 mJ for one press per second and 1.98 mJ for three presses per second. At 40 klx and 20 klx, the solar panels generated an average of 10.14 mW and 8.33 mW, respectively, i.e. less than the required system average power consumption of 11.50 mW. We can conclude that ENGAGE is mostly powered by solar panels and supplemented by the button presses although the button presses can significantly increase the on-time of the platform, as shown in Section 5.1 [0] https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3411839 https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3411839
- quink 4y ago(2020)
- giuliomagnifico 4y agoBeautiful, is a dream to have a device that you can forget about charge it and "range anxiety", I hope it will be implemented at least in smartwatch in the next years.
- j5155 4y agoI know there are mechanical energy harvesting watches; I imagine making a similar smartwatch would be much harder with the higher energy requirement. And the issue with solar panels is the tendency for people to wear long sleeves, stay indoors, sleep, etc.
- chillbill 4y agoI appreciate the hackery aspect of this but I have very high levels of doubt that this path will amount to anything significant. Aside from that, it’s slightly annoying that they repeated a false premise (or at best half-truth) twice at the beginning and left a significant piece of how it works (it’ll turn on and off) till the middle. I think everyone knows that you can harvest solar power but the problem with it is its unpredictability. It doesn’t have to be the same experience as playing a game boy, but maybe start off with that: it’s not the same way as playing any console really, having to wait for a few seconds every ten is not only annoying, it won’t work for a significant amount of “computing”.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoIt'll be boring dystopia shit that will spy on you and phone home with dull data like when and where you opened a packet of chips for marketers to sell to marketers so they can sell ads that get shown to robots. But this time without needing to contrive a reason for you to keep it charged. Plastic packaging. Now with gallium arsenide!
- a1371 4y agoI recall there was a battery free cellphone project on the premise of harvesting power from electro magnetic cell tower waves. They couldn't pull it off but maybe that could help this?
- sbierwagen 4y agoOddly enough, the "energy harvesting switches" they used in this are commercial products! https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/zf-electronics/AFIG-0007/5250515 https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/zf-electronics/AF... https://switches-sensors.zf.com/us/product/energy-harvesting-generators/ https://switches-sensors.zf.com/us/product/energy-harvesting...
- testmasterflex 4y agoLove this kind of stuff. I made this slim PCB a few years ago with a super tiny NFC chip on it that can harvest energy from NFC: https://youtu.be/_BSfO9LAIqg https://youtu.be/_BSfO9LAIqg Made it into a business card as you can see.
- rexreed 4y agoI'd love to make that as well or find a source for it. Curious as to costs to manufacture and ease of reproducibility. Any tips / pointers / guides?
- testmasterflex 4y agoCan’t find the tutorial I used but here is one https://reddit.com/r/electronics/comments/efz9xf/my_nfc_powered_blinky_business_card/ https://reddit.com/r/electronics/comments/efz9xf/my_nfc_powe...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rexreed 4y agoI found this one: https://www.instructables.com/PCB-Business-Card-With-NFC/ https://www.instructables.com/PCB-Business-Card-With-NFC/ Looks closer to yours? Not sure how you did the 24k gold part tho ;)
- 4y ago
- sufficer 4y agoFunny I thought they'd harvest the button press energy before clicking and they did! An idea I had a while ago but laughed it off as impossible
- Aachen 4y agoI thought it would be a battery to wall charger adapter. I was wrong but the article did not disappoint.
- p4bl0 4y agoI upvoted but I really wanted to say thanks for sharing this link, it was very enjoyable to read!
- xialvjun 4y agoIt's not just a baterry free gameboy. It's electronic device with unstable energy.
- fredley 4y agoI have a playdate. This would be even easier when there's a crank for harvesting power!
- frosted-flakes 4y agoWell, not really. I have one too, and I can't imagine the crank being very usable if there was any resistance at all, beyond the tiny bit of friction present to stop it swinging on its own.
- ema_dev 4y ago[dead]
- diceduckmonk 4y ago> Can ENGAGE play all Gameboy games?... Yes! It is running a custom emulator which allows it to impersonate the Game Boy and play any Game Boy game (not the Color versions though). That said, just like with any emulator, not every title may work, and some bugs may prevent some games from loading some parts. This bit seems a little disingenuous.
- neogodless 4y agoIf they were selling you an emulator, I'd agree. But they're not advertising the capabilities of the emulator so much as telling you what to expect if you take this project on. In theory, all games should work, but emulators can be imperfect, so know what to expect.
- initramfs 4y agoYeah, they are educators, not commercial developers. They encourage others to fork it. I began organizing a theoretical framework for a solar powered laptop 2 years ago: https://hackaday.io/project/177716-the-libre-autarkic-laptop https://hackaday.io/project/177716-the-libre-autarkic-laptop
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- petodo 4y agoI guess Solar powered Game Boy would make for less attractive title.
- Aachen 4y agoBecause that's not all it is. They didn't just take a console and slap a solar panel on top and wired that into the battery compartment. They took a new CPU, buttons, etc. and run an inefficient emulator (goes to show how big the energy budget is) with auto save state before turning off from lack of light/button energy. Arguably, the former is way more useful in the short run, as you could actually use it for more than ten seconds at a time and retrofit any device easily. But as a research project, the latter is way more useful because it might pave the path to this being viable in the future and having an entirely new class of devices.
- petodo 4y agoit pretty much is, they removed battery and replaced it with direct power supply from solar panels, they mention some additional energy from buttons but I really doubt that would have any meaningful gains, after all how can you generate energy and store it between keypresses unless you will be constantly pressing button in which case you need third hand
- Aachen 4y agoThe state saving for when solar power drops, not needing any battery at all, isn't in any way cool or seem principally useful to you?
- logicallee 4y agoThis is an incredibly important project under the new reality that Russia can cause war and havoc at any time and in any state. If they can do it in a Europe that has basically been at peace for 70 years, and facing massive worldwide opposition and direct opposition from the United States in the form of aid, weapons, and people, then they can do it anywhere, even in the continental United States. No place is safe under such conditions. In Ukraine as a war crime, Russia targeted energy infrastructure including power plants, bringing energy grids offline. This is something that could deprive people of basic communications and information access. The mitigation of this seems difficult. Solar panels on the outside of houses can be destroyed by bombing easily, and gasoline powered generators on the inside are loud, expensive, and require ventilation for safety. How can a people stay connected and continue to communicate under active Russian attacks on their energy grid? With these thoughts in mind, when I saw this project I smiled, because it approaches the issue from an alternative angle. Who needs a loud and potentially noxious gasoline generator if it is possible to reduce the display draw to an amount that can be successfully powered from incident light? Such a solution can solve pressing issues in our time and going forward. Quiet, compact, and mobile. A good solution for the worst possible world.
- initramfs 4y agoI wrote about that idea a few months ago, and covered the solar gameboy too: https://iotmote.substack.com/p/remaking-the-nokia-6110-and-psion https://iotmote.substack.com/p/remaking-the-nokia-6110-and-p... In 2011, Intel demonstrated a solar powered Pentium chip- they remade the 1994 Pentium it on 32nm. But it was a demo only. The reason it's been so "demo" for over 10 years is because no one thinks solar is possible to run anything portable, but no one questions why so much investment is focused on the latest graphics cards and AI chips like the A100. If there was more consumer demand, you'd see it released yesterday. The solar calculator in 1978 was far more advanced for its time, but now you have most people laughing at such an idea for a few hundred thousand more transistors. Sad.
- javier_cardona 4y agoGetting the electronics to work on such a tight energy budget is a big challenge, very impressive! I've worked on a similar concept using a bistable display and a supercap for energy storage to recharge very quickly when sun is available. This is for more zen-like use cases, like chess puzzles: https://lightnote.cardonabits.com/products/lightnote-chess-edition https://lightnote.cardonabits.com/products/lightnote-chess-e...
- yftsui 4y agoI thought it was just a “crank radio” style device with a large capacitor, this seems an interesting way of mimicing that.
- news_now 4y ago[dead]
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoOr just have a battery that recharges so that you never have to swap it and make it incredibly power efficient
- guskel 4y agohttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BYxUC1X180o https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BYxUC1X180o
- hbn 4y agoIt's a neat proof-of-concept, but the video gets a little optimistic and hand-wavey about how practical this could actually ever be. "Right now we have interruptions, but[...] that interruption amount is going to continually decrease as we make these systems better and more energy-efficient." Is that really the case? The limiting factor here is not just the efficiency of harvesting energy. The energy being harvested from the sun and from the button presses has a hard cap at some point, and while I don't know enough about the topic to do the math, I'd have to assume it's not particularly high. Even if you were able to harvest 100% of the sunlight hitting a smartphone (quick Google search says solar panels harvest ~15%), and 100% of the energy from the taps of a user's finger, would that be anywhere close to enough power to run the thing? This seems like more of a conceptual limit than a technological one.
- colechristensen 4y agoWith magic solar panels and full sun an iphone shaped solar cell could charge my iphone fully in under an hour and a half. Good commercial solar cells can get a little more than 20% efficiency so really with good sun and a bit of restricted usage an iphone with a solar cell for a back that got a lot of sunshine could power itself enough to be practically useful. With the ability to scale down the power usage with processors that do a whole lot less it’s certainly practical to get much more out of usable processors. You can do a lot with, say, 10 watt hours per day and that much is certainly achievable on a hand held device.
- jetbooster 4y agoWithout concentrating the sunlight, the max efficiency of a solar panel is about 68% conversion. With 1kW/m², and a solar panel the size of a 0.01m² phone (6.1 inch, 16:9) that's 6.8W to play with, at the theoretical maximum. A quick check states a Raspberry Pi 4B at 100% CPU draws 6.4W, so in perfect conditions with a perfect panel, it's just about approaching feasible to run a chip on a phone sized panel. However a Gameboy is much simpler than a Pi. It seems the Gameboy draws about 70-80mA@1.5V, or 0.1W, which is very impressive. I would say that would 100% be physically feasible to power with a gameboy sized solar panel in our lifetime.
- 4y ago
- Vrondi 4y agoThis makes me look at my Tandy m100 and wonder if anyone ever tried to run it off solar panels...
- psychphysic 4y ago> Can ENGAGE play all Gameboy games? > Yes! It is running a custom emulator which allows it to impersonate the Game Boy and play any Game Boy game (not the Color versions though). That said, just like with any emulator, not every title may work Yes! Proceeds to explain no.
- initramfs 4y agoIt completely works. The choice of implementing an intermittent design for 2020, was reasonable. For 2022, it's questionable: https://protean.systems/ https://protean.systems/ There are lithium ion capacitors that can run a game continouously for hours since they are battery-like https://www.tindie.com/products/jaspersikken/solar-harvesting-into-lithium-ion-capacitor/ https://www.tindie.com/products/jaspersikken/solar-harvestin... and don't require complicated power management systems. If this were for simple SMS and phone texting, it could run for enough time to not need to shut off every 10 seconds. But the very short capacitor design requires using very exotic FRAM. I think if enough optimizations are made, one run a tiny linux with a conventional filesystem: https://tiny.slitaz.org/ https://tiny.slitaz.org/
- oceanplexian 4y agoI was a little let down that the solution to not having batteries was just a few solar cells. If you're looking for something along the same theme, it's not a "Game Boy" but a Youtuber built a handheld powered by radioactive tritium. https://hackaday.com/2021/07/14/tetris-handheld-powered-by-tritium-cell-eventually/ https://hackaday.com/2021/07/14/tetris-handheld-powered-by-t...
- calebegg 4y ago(to be fair, it also gets power from the buttons)
- hwc 4y agoGreat! Now do an e-ink book reader!
- LtdJorge 4y ago> This site uses cookies from Google to deliver its services and to analyze traffic. Information about your use of this site is shared with Google. By using this site, you agree to its use of cookies Is that really how GDPR works (I'm in Europe)?
- terrycody 4y agoMost amazing game boy mod seen over these years, very interesting and excellent work!
- bArray 4y agoI remember years ago the Pocket Pikachu game [1]. Would be cool to have something similar but using energy harvesting to keep your digital pet active. Given improvements in AI and processing power, with some form of decentralised trading, this would be super cool for kids. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pok%C3%A9mon_Pikachu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pok%C3%A9mon_Pikachu
- e12e 4y agoWould love to see this as a "workboy" https://www.inverse.com/input/gaming/meet-the-workboy-nintendos-long-lost-gameboy-productivity-device https://www.inverse.com/input/gaming/meet-the-workboy-ninten...