9 ms·
FBI chief says TikTok 'screams' of US national security concerns
- throwaway67743 4y agoI'll help translate: FBI chief says TikTok "screams" of not being surveillance that's accessible to the USA
- hammock 4y agoThe US government, specifically people who have high-level access to classified intelligence, has insinuated a lot about TikTok but has not revealed any specifics about what the concerns are. Would love to see a reveal of substance, or something, literally anything. Right now it just feels like agitprop
- ismokedoinks 4y agoNot that I have any deep subject matter knowledge but I agree, it feels like app store McCarthyism
- yamtaddle 4y agoALL of these sorts of social media programs are terrifyingly-capable spying platforms. It'd be weird if we didn't regard one controlled by a foreign adversary as a threat. I think the domestic ones are, too—but they feed info to US law enforcement and intelligence and are making lots of money, so we can't crack down on those, I guess.
- eatonphil 4y agoMcCarthyism was primarily a political thing by politicians. The FBI chief being discussed here, Wray, is a political appointment but not an elected politician so hopefully the appointment shields them from politics. Nevermind that the DoJ tries pretty hard to be independent of the President. But beyond that, this particular chief was appointed during the previous administration of a different party. And has served in both party's administrations. I have no position on TikTok, but Wray saying this is not really comparable to McCarthy.
- cwkoss 4y agoI feel like the FBI has politicized quite a bit since Comey.
- advisedwang 4y agoThe FBI chief is and has always been highly political. J Edgar Hoover was a extreme anti-communist and was investigating suspected communists, infiltrating CPUSA and creating blacklists at the exact same time that McCarthy was conducting his hearings. In fact the McCarthyism acticle on Wikipedia has a whole section about the FBI. The FBI was deeply involved in McCarthyism.
- lehi 4y agoSomething being political does not require it to be partisan. Joseph McCarthy worked hand in hand with then-FBI chief J. Edgar Hoover, and Wray was appointed by a president who also tried to ban TikTok.
- eatonphil 4y agoSure, but being kept on by an administration of the opposing party goes a bit to show that he is also not particularly partisan.
- rchaud 4y agoIt definitely sounds like that. But to me this feels more like 'testing the waters' to see if the argument sticks with the American people. I don't think it will, because they provided even a hint of a smoking gun. Eventually, I can see these hearings continue, but the line of argument will change to protecting American jobs, especially if Meta's ad revenues fall.
- favaq 4y agoIt's the Huawei story all over again.
- jpgvm 4y agoi.e we don't want to compete so lets just ban the foreign competitor we don't want to compete with.
- huhtenberg 4y agoA competitor under full control of Chinese government that owes its birth to a full copy of Cisco firmware deposited by Cisco with said government as a condition for entering Chinese market. That Huawei or is there another one?
- jpgvm 4y agoTechnology transfer isn't illegal, Cisco was happy with the commercial arrangement. More importantly Motorola before them which is who really kickstarted the Chinese electronics manufacturing sector. I wish it was more common actually. Imagine if we shared technology more freely in exchange for reciprocal benefits. For instance Australia (my home country) has a wealth of natural resources yet very little high-tech. We should leverage China's dependency on our raw resources to obtain technology transfer to enrich our country in a mutually beneficial way.
- falcolas 4y agoWe just usually call them tariffs and duties.
- kalleboo 4y agoThere's a pretty big difference between core infrastructure and a video entertainment app
- advisedwang 4y agoTikTok is a threat in many ways: * The extent to which TikTok tailors content, normalization of over-simplified content, ease of creating content and other factors make it great for radicalization. As well as extremist groups, this applies to more regular protest movements and generally an active citizenry, which is not in the interest of the feds. * It has encouraged regular crime and idiocy. For example it spread knowledge of the Kia/Hyundai ignition bypass, and is full of pseudomedical nonsence. It also serves as a useful scapegoat.
- dry_soup 4y agoYou might as well be describing YouTube or Twitter
- ourmandave 4y agoI have to think it's along the lines of the Strava fitness app data used to create a heat map of the positions of US military personnel. Only a lot, lot worse.
- warner25 4y agoI believe this is the answer. I'm a career military officer, but without any inside knowledge, and the most troubling "red team" ideas that I've read involve an adversary targeting our troops and families in their ordinary lives at home, where we're soft targets. Troops accept the fact that they might be told to put themselves at-risk overseas, but they expect that their spouses and children will be safe in their own neighborhoods, that their utilities will keep working[1], that their identities and bank accounts won't be stolen, etc. We go after terrorists and insurgents the same way by learning their social networks and patterns of life. I'm sure that we wish we had stuff on our adversaries like the data from the OPM breach[2], the Strava fitness data, or the kind of data that TikTok can collect on their phones. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34474946 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34474946 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Personnel_Management_data_breach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Personnel_Management...
- david_allison 4y agoIt can get much worse: https://www.bellingcat.com/news/2021/05/28/us-soldiers-expose-nuclear-weapons-secrets-via-flashcard-apps/ https://www.bellingcat.com/news/2021/05/28/us-soldiers-expos...
- rchaud 4y agoMilitaries have extremely rigid rules about personal electronics for this reason. But this isn't about the military, this is about a national ban for everybody.
- HashThis 4y agoTheir big concern is NOT data stealing. That is a small thing. They are very worried about the US citizen population saying they are DONE with Lobbyists and congress selling out. US Citizens are done with the GDP being stolen via rigged industries (pharma, 2008 crisis, Medical, taxes, etc.) US Citizens starting to all agree together on TikTok, enables citizens to galvanize into a united front. The US Gov needs to control US citizens, by banning them. This is why US intel services have removed 100% of US citizens in militia community groups people from Facebook. 100% have their facebook accounts have been shut down. They can't shoot people over facebook. The gov's risk is that people see many other citizens galvanize that they find congress w/lobbyists effectively stealing GDP.
- TheBlight 4y agoAgree. I've never used the app but I'm curious about what these threat vectors are. But it's never discussed. It's just nebulously "bad."
- mrguyorama 4y agoOne concrete badness IMO is the black box algorithm of it. It's controlled semi-directly by the CCP, and they openly use a different algorithm and different filters in china vs the US, and not just for cultural reasons. Letting the CCP put it's fingers on the scale of what gets fed to millions of impressionable teens is just as stupid and dangerous as letting facebook continue to do so, with the only difference being Zuckerburg isn't a nation-state actor who is openly our rival. There is a lot of possible power for China to attempt to utilize in TikTok, do you really think they won't?
- rchaud 4y ago> Zuckerburg isn't a nation-state actor who is openly our rival. Zuckerberg has openly violated the privacy of millions of Americans, and been fined the largest amount in FTC history for doing so. He might not be in the Axis of Evil, but the fact that he continues to operate his division-by-doomscroll machine on American soil makes this TikTok talk sound pretty ridiculous.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThe one mentioned is that the Chinese could potentially use TikTok to control the narrative about a topic. Which is true, but it's the kind of thing everybody else does all of the time.
- belltaco 4y agoA live example https://www.theverge.com/2022/12/22/23522808/tiktok-journalists-data-accessed-bytedance-internal-audit https://www.theverge.com/2022/12/22/23522808/tiktok-journali...
- lm28469 4y agoTiktok in China seems to provibe much bethier content, especially to teens Science VS twerking how to be a good citizen VS tide pod challenge &c. It's not a military or political threat per say, just a slow brain rot over an entire generation https://www.deseret.com/2022/11/24/23467181/difference-between-tik-tok-in-china-and-the-us https://www.deseret.com/2022/11/24/23467181/difference-betwe...
- ashwagary 4y agoPart of the fear may be that any compelling case made against tiktok could strongly serve the purpose of getting US social apps banned from the rest of the world for the same reasons.
- legitster 4y agoThe actual national security concern is probably for state-sponsored psyops. We know Russia was able to pump a bunch of psyops campaigns into Western social media, most NATO governments now have dedicated branches that root out this kind of information. But Russia's programs were really obtuse and relatively easy to trace. On the other hand, TikTok is all about flooding people with niche content areas. And content is consumed so much faster that it propagates quicker. And keep in mind TikTok is still state-sponsored by China despite the algorithm being so addictive that it is banned domestically. My tinfoil hat is that US officials have reports that the Chinese state is having influence on the American news cycles, but doesn't want to admit that it's made its way already into news media and politics issues.
- somenameforme 4y agoYour post can also be used as an argument for how disinformation claims are being weaponized. Hamilton 68 was a key figure in the Russian disinformation stuff. They claimed to have pinpointed hundreds of Russian bots and used this to create an interactive dashboard, headed by a former FBI counterintelligence official, enabling real time tracking of the latest "Russian disinformation." It was repeatedly referenced by both the media and high level politicians alike. This included Adam Schiff, The Washington Post, The New York Times, CNN, PBS, ABC, NBC, MSNBC, and many more. Mother Jones ran at least 14 articles on their "research" alone. The problem is that this was, itself, all complete disinformation. Their "Russian bots" were largely made of normal, and very real, conservative Americans. [1] Many were of substantial note, including authors, lawyers (one had published a book on the constitution), news editors/hosts, and more. So you ended up in this zone where anything conservative individuals were talking about was immediately claimed to be Russian disinformation, which was equated with fake news. But you'll never see anything about this in those same news sites that ran stories based on the disinformation. Nor is their any grand demand that we shut down Hamilton 68. In fact you can still find their dashboard on the "Securing Democracy" page. [2] So normal genuine conversation was being censored under the guise of 'securing democracy against state sponsored disinformation' while major examples of genuine disinformation, which did (and continue) completely distort democracy, remain completely ignored. Very little of it has anything to do with integrity, security, or safety. It's all petty politics. And supporting the government banning apps, with no proven misdeeds, is one heck of a nasty precedent. [1] - https://twitter.com/mtaibbi/status/1619029772977455105 https://twitter.com/mtaibbi/status/1619029772977455105 [2] - https://securingdemocracy.gmfus.org/hamilton-dashboard/ https://securingdemocracy.gmfus.org/hamilton-dashboard/
- lazyeye 4y agoConsidering nation-states send nuclear submarines to the bottom of the ocean to tap network cables, assuming they wont use a massive trove of tracking data (largest in human history) that just falls into their lap, is extraordinarily naive. Read any book on the history of espionage to see the efforts made to collect intelligence. Suggesting TikTok data wont be used in an intelligence context is simply ridiculous.
- epolanski 4y agoIt's like when they blame Russians for hacks and never give any evidence.
- tcmart14 4y agoSame here. I would not be surprised if they are telling the truth. After all, I am of the beliefs that no tactics are "off the board." The CIA used vaccine programs as a means to track islamic terrorists. So, I wouldnt be as socked pikachu faced at China using TikTok data. But it would be nice to get real hard data. I remember people making all sorts of claims about China bugging hardware and that is why we have to ban Huaweii, but all the third party analysis I've seen of their hardware pretty much concluded, "the hardware is not bugged. The most criminal thing about this is they advertise it as a latest gen i5 but its really a i5 from 2 gens ago and probably sloppy second bunk chips. You know, chips that can't get sold to like Lenovo because they failed QC."
- rr888 4y agoNow you know what it feels like to be the rest of the world relying on American tech companies.
- ouid 4y agoThe rest of the world, which for simplicity's sake we'll call the EU and china, have fairly powerful protections in place. EU law applies to companies operating in the EU, and China effectively bans all foreign apps. If Chinese businesses were not de facto arms of the Chinese state, and we had the diplomatic resources to investigate and prosecute chinese companies serving american citizens under american laws, then it might make sense to leaev well enough alone.
- jpgvm 4y agoChina does not ban foreign apps, that is pure misinformation. I think lack of success of foreign apps in China comes down to a much simpler dynamic. Foreign apps are simply not launched concurrently in China and optimised for the Chinese market from the outset. The exception to this are mobile games titles which are generally overly optimised for the Chinese market if anything and generally fail to succeed outside of it. This results in Chinese clones of said new foriegn app/service appearing very quickly and gaining dominance before said app can "expand" to China. By the time that happens, if it does, they have to compete with an established service that is language and culture native. Essentially if you aren't launching in China day one and have a great understanding of the -very- competitive Chinese Internet platform economy you are screwed before you even start.
- ouid 4y agoChina blocks all sorts of apps, what the fuck are you talking about?
- jpgvm 4y agoNo application is banned from operating in China if they are willing to follow the rules. Generally speaking companies like Google just don't like the rules so they don't operate there. The US has many laws that cause apps to be pulled from the App Store or forcibly be shutdown by hosting companies (even non-US entities!). Why is it different when the laws are from a different country?
- legitster 4y agoIt's kind of funny to me that almost everyone I talk kind of knows TikTok is bad, but in a way we really don't know what to do with. It kind of makes me appreciate that there were lots of times we banned things after they crossed an arbitrary line of danger. Alcohol was fine until hard liquor was invented. Child work was expected, until factories came along. In a way, I almost think of TikTok as a reverse Opium War. Opium was already a not uncommon vice in China until the British introduced much more potent strains. TikTok not being fundamentally different than the other tech that preceded it, just a more potent version.
- bigbillheck 4y ago> Alcohol was fine until hard liquor was invented If I catch your drift correctly you might want to read up on the history of distillation, and in particular the chronology thereof.
- coenhyde 4y agoI didn't interpret the OP's comment to suggest a specific order of invention, but an order of adoption / influence in a society.
- kevviiinn 4y agoAnd the order of adoption was hard liquor came after prohibition
- legitster 4y agoI know distilling goes back to antiquity but I was only thinking of the emergence of consumer drinks in the 1600-1700s. Specifically era of the London Gin laws. I think in particular it's fascinating because this was before people really measured or understood alcohol content and they really had trouble figuring out why some drinks needed no real restrictions and yet others could destroy lives.
- mrguyorama 4y ago
- thepasswordis 4y agoAbsolutely do not like the precedent this sets. If anything, apple should remove it from the App Store, and I will get mad at apple and think it’s an overreach. The government making noise that they should be able to ban apps from our phones is a step too far.
- ouid 4y agopreventing the mass exfiltration of american data seems like something that the government has absolute authority over. If Tiktok cannot prove that they are not doing that, then this is no different from the health department shutting down a restaurant.
- bitexploder 4y agoSeems like it would violate the first amendment. Government can’t really restrict my speech.
- monksy 4y agoThe US screams of lack of privacy protections of our own data and unchangable identities. Why they're pointing to just tiktok is a farce.
- bmarquez 4y agoYeah, it's like people have forgotten that Snowden revealed a direct link between NSA and big tech via PRISM.
- falcolas 4y agoIt's worse than that. State governments are actively using their quasi-legal (they haven't passed the judicial tests yet) powers to force social media to help prosecute their citizens... And they're hiding behind "the chinese government is worse". Yeah, they're terrible. Prosecuting women for seeking health services is also terrible.
- scotuswroteus 4y agoHa, for sixty, seventy, eighty years, most reasonable Americans have been saying all the three letter agencies "scream" power trip. For my money, I haven't seen an app that so easily allows normal people use copyrighted music -- you know, the stuff everyone hears and is blared at us until we like it -- to express themselves. If the data loss is such a terrible security threat, why is everyone using operating systems that enable it in the first place? Because the FBI only warns of threats that leverage the terribly insecure systems we all use to oppose the FBI's political projects. It's a problem, it's just not a problem the FBI has credibility to warn us all about.
- mlnhd 4y agoIs the US going to set up a Great Firewall to block tiktok.com? How is this going to work?
- pavlov 4y agoAlmost everybody has TikTok via either Apple's or Google's app stores. So it's very easy to block the distribution of the program.
- christkv 4y agoBanned in app stores and it will die.
- telotortium 4y agoDistribution in App Stores, running servers on US soil, and payment using the US dollar or involving US persons would presumably all be banned. That would be enough to effectively ban it.
- it_citizen 4y agoRaising a daughter I cannot help but wonder if a social media ban till 16, 18 or even 21 year old wouldn't be a net positive for society. I am more concerned about my daughter shaping her view of the world through social medias than doing other age-restricted activities like watching porn or drinking beers. It might be impossible to enforce completely but forbidding the platforms to host content made by teenagers would probably help reduce the interest for teenagers and some of its negative psychological impacts. It would probably also motive schools to implement policies to stay "social-media free".
- falcolas 4y agoWhy can't you (any parent, really), as her concerned parent, implement such a ban?
- tomjen3 4y agoIts a lot easier if they can still communicate with their friends. Sadly that happens a lot more on social media.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- it_citizen 4y agoWhen all of her friends communicate through social medias, she will feel excluded if she is the only one without it. It is the same problem as, when younger, all my friends had a phone and I hadn't. Except much worse because social media really became a big part of the social and cultural life of teenagers. I don't believe a ban would be effective unless it also applies to her social circle too. I know in some rare schools, parents organized themselves to all commit to not let their child use social medias. That might be another lead, but unlike a formal ban, it won't deter platforms to attempt to attract and retain the attention of our kids. I think in the meantime, the best approach is probably trying to limit her time using it, making her internalize the negative consequences, and try to limit the content she posts.
- jfengel 4y agoTFA is light on quotes, but it seems to come down to "China could feed misinformation to users". That's the most concrete claim I've seen. I'd buy that it could happen, but I'm still not sure it's worth "screaming" about. We get plenty of misinformation, and disinformation, via US-owned channels. One could imagine a sinister plot where they develop a detailed model of you and use it to concoct the perfect disinformation campaign targeted at you, engaging enough so you don't shut it off, subtle enough that it isn't obvious and annoying. It's not impossible; even mediocre targeting tools have led to some pretty impressive targeted propaganda campaigns. What could they do with the information that is currently useful enough to make it a near-addiction? And yet, it seems unlikely to me. The alternative is "they're making a ton of money", which seems a perfectly ordinary thing for them to do. That sinister plot seems to hinge on a lot of things going in their favor, like TikTok users not just moving on to the next shiny thing that catches their attention. Maybe the FBI has more reason to believe that this really is China's plan than they can let on. But it really looks to me just like they beat us at our own game, selling entertainment, and doing it on the cheap.
- cwkoss 4y agoI think it's plausible that the deep state feels threatened by Tiktok because it is out of reach of US misinformation campaigns: Tiktok has the power to counterprogram against falsehoods spread by US officials. We've seen how cozy Twitter is with the state. I wonder if any US propaganda falsehoods have been corrected by Tiktok already or if this a just a threat to national orwellian potential.
- kart23 4y agoi don’t understand how everyone was super worked up about russia influencing the election through facebook, but now that a foreign power literally CONTROLS the platform, people aren’t concerned about it. fwiw, I’m not that concerned about either platform. I just think people who claim one and not the other are being inconsistent.
- mrtksn 4y agoI'm very concerned that the US government will set a precedent for regulating what apps citizens are allowed to use. I definitely agree about the risks and banning it from the devices of the govt officials makes sense but banning access to an app screams "the Chinese/Russian/Turkish way of governing has won, freedoms are no more". I hope the US takes the EU approach and regulates what data is collected and transmitted where instead of walking the totalitarian route. In case you haven't notice, FB/Instagram/Twitter etc. are the same as TikTok from the perspective of Non-Americans(>%90 of the world) and TikTok just happen to be a first for Americans. I've been living in Turkey for some years now and I promise you, it's not fun. Do you know that it has been 2 weeks since Turkey banned country's most popular(and earliest, dating back to 1999) social media for no other reason that they suspect anti-government activity by the operators because they think it is not natural to have concentration of anti-govt views? That's where you are headed.
- walterbell 4y agoTiktok hired people associated with multiple governments, were they able to improve the situation? https://www.mintpressnews.com/nato-tiktok-pipeline-why-tiktok-employing-national-security-agents/280336/ https://www.mintpressnews.com/nato-tiktok-pipeline-why-tikto... > the threat to completely shut down its platform, subsided only after TikTok began appointing Western officials to important positions within its organization, thereby giving the state considerable influence over the content and direction of the app.
- kornhole 4y agoThis is what makes the ostensible claim that it needs to be banned for national security reasons harder to understand or accept. This leaves us just guessing about what the real reasons are, and people will call it conspiracy theory. Possible reasons could be: -They want to consolidate the number of outlets they need to manage -An interagency conflict between FBI and the ones managing Tiktok -Financial benefit for the competitors in which security state has financial stake -Some organizational or architectural issue that makes it difficult to control ????
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yehudalouis 4y agoI don't think the FBI cares about TikTok, to be honest. It seems like we're entering a period of posturing against the Chinese, using implicit 'sanctioning' methods: - Banning TikTok - Accusing them of the COVID lab leak theory - Posturing with Taiwan Seems were just building a substrate for... something. Not to sound too conspiratorial. ;)
- photochemsyn 4y agoTo be clear, the Wuhan Institute of Virology's research program involving betacoronaviruses and CRISPR gene editing technology was funded in part by the US government via a grant to Ecohealth Alliance from the NIH (at least $600,000 which is fairly significant) and the lead researcher at Wuhan developed that approach in collaboration with US scientists, so it's hardly just 'China's fault'. If a complete ban on this kind of research (CRISPR-editing wild-type viral sequences to make them more infectious in human cell lines, or in mice expressing human genes, etc.) had been implemented and enforced by NIH and NIAID, this scenario might have been avoided. Any (financial? criminal?) reckoning over who is at fault would result in at least some significant degree of shared liability between the USA and China.
- kwere 4y agoWuhan had "pneumonia like" cases back in november. CCP is still at least responsible of keeping it quiet till it got too difficult to handle.
- tomjen3 4y agoAll social media is a national security concern, because it is known to cause (not just be associated with) decreased mental wellbeing.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoIt's hard to see a public Senate Intelligence Committee hearing on worldwide threats to U.S. security as anything except blatant propaganda, which makes this feel like propaganda warning us that the evil enemy may use propaganda to control our opinions.
- brutusurp 4y agoSo does Facebook, and Instagram, and Ring cameras, and iRobot vacuums, and voice assistant devices such as Alexa... Where's the government to protect us? Where's the FBI? Are they working inside these companies? Is there a clear conflict of interest? 2023: "We Found 28,000 Apps Sending TikTok Data. Banning the App Won't Help." - https://gizmodo.com/tiktok-ban-joe-biden-28000-apps-sdk-data-china-1850174019 https://gizmodo.com/tiktok-ban-joe-biden-28000-apps-sdk-data... - https://www.techuntold.com/dangers-of-instagram/ https://www.techuntold.com/dangers-of-instagram/ 2022: "Amazon likes to collect an enormous amount of data on you. Things like: records of your shopping habits, Alexa search requests, the TV shows you watch and when you watch them, the music you stream, the podcasts you listen to, when you turn your lights on and off, when you lock your doors, identifiers such as your name, address, phone numbers, or IP address, your age, gender, your location, audio and visual information like those Alexa-requests or photos you take, the names and numbers of people listed in your contacts. The list goes on and on and on." - https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/amazon-echo-dot/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/amazon-... - https://www.indy100.com/science-tech/amazon-alexa-device-dont-put-bedroom?amp;amp https://www.indy100.com/science-tech/amazon-alexa-device-don... - https://www.ventasdeseguridad.com/en/2022110822789/news/enterprises/security-risks-increase-in-instagram-accounts.html https://www.ventasdeseguridad.com/en/2022110822789/news/ente... "Ring has a history of not protecting users' privacy. At one point they reportedly stored customer data--including video recordings--unencrypted on an Amazon cloud server and employees could access any of this data. There have also been reported data leaks and concerns that the Ring Doorbell app is full of third-party trackers tracking a good amount of personal information that Amazon Ring doesn’t disclose." 'It was reported that in May, 2022 Amazon's patched Ring's app for Android due a "high-severity" security vulnerability that could have allowed hackers to access personal information, location, and camera recordings.' - https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/ring-video-doorbell/#:~:text=It%20was%20reported%20that%20in,%2C%20location%2C%20and%20camera%20recordings https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/ring-vi.... 2021: - https://news.ncsu.edu/2021/03/alexa-skill-vulnerabilities/ https://news.ncsu.edu/2021/03/alexa-skill-vulnerabilities/ - https://www.npr.org/2021/04/09/986005820/after-data-breach-exposes-530-million-facebook-says-it-will-not-notify-users https://www.npr.org/2021/04/09/986005820/after-data-breach-e... 2019: - https://gizmodo.com/dont-buy-anyone-a-ring-camera-1840070640 https://gizmodo.com/dont-buy-anyone-a-ring-camera-1840070640 - https://www.forbes.com/sites/tjmccue/2019/04/19/alexa-is-listening-all-the-time-heres-how-to-stop-it/?sh=52ade0465e2d https://www.forbes.com/sites/tjmccue/2019/04/19/alexa-is-lis... - https://www.techtarget.com/searchsecurity/news/252462588/A-recent-history-of-Facebook-security-and-privacy-issues https://www.techtarget.com/searchsecurity/news/252462588/A-r... 2018: - https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-security-breach-50-million-accounts/ https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-security-breach-50-mill...
- jimt1234 4y agoI still don't understand the "national security concerns" from TikTok. It seems there's two: 1. The CCP has access to video-view and location data 2. The CCP can manipulate video streams to push a narrative For #1, isn't TikTok mostly just a bunch of teenagers dancing? Who cares if the CCP access this data? Also, couldn't the CCP just purchase this same/similar data from a thousand other data brokers? For #2, pushing a narrative pretty much defines social media apps these days, for better and for worse. So, why is it so bad on TikTok or when the CCP does it? Heck, Fox News is constantly parroting Russian propaganda, yet no one is talking about banning the channel. What makes TikTok/CCP so much worse that the app needs to be banned? I honestly don't understand what makes TikTok so much more threatening than what's already going on. What am I missing?
- legitster 4y ago> Also, couldn't the CCP just purchase this same/similar data from a thousand other data brokers? Contrary to popular belief, data-broker data is generic and not very good. Knowing that you are a 30s male who likes beer is not as useful as, say, finding out you are a high ranking military official and what remote locations you visit in the US. > #1, isn't TikTok mostly just a bunch of teenagers dancing? How quickly TikTok understands your preferences and feeds you content you like is scary. And it's designed to send you down niche rabbit holes. You may start watching construction videos, but within an hour you may be watching a nurse tell you pharmaceutical companies are trying to kill us but set to a fun dance.
- kornhole 4y agoThese claims about Tiktok have been used for years, and the data collection is not much different from other corp/state social media apps. I assumed the motivation was around information control, but as researched here, https://www.mintpressnews.com/nato-tiktok-pipeline-why-tiktok-employing-national-security-agents/280336/ https://www.mintpressnews.com/nato-tiktok-pipeline-why-tikto..., the company is well influenced by NATO intelligence now. The cognitive warfare landscape is evolving. I am really not sure what the justification is at this point. Perhaps they want fewer platforms to control, the architecture is not conducive to the level of control they desire, the FBI is not aligned with agencies controlling Tiktok?
- dcl 4y agoWhat's wrong with a simple reciprocal policy, if they don't allow foreign owned/controlled social media in their state, we don't allow theirs here.
- timcavel 4y ago[dead]
- lazyeye 4y agoWhat does it matter whether TikTok is a security threat (although it clearly is). In what other trade context would it be acceptable for one country to block all access to its own market (e.g Facebook, Twitter etc) whilst still enjoying full access to everybody elses? How is it remotely unreasonable to treat China in the same way it treats everybody else?
- cainxinth 4y agoAny chance the people in this thread can stop with the whataboutism (“The U.S. does it too!”) and focus on the topic at hand: is TikTok a national security threat or not?
- alxmng 4y agoThe FBI is a national security concern.
- hedora 4y ago> Wray told a Senate Intelligence Committee hearing on worldwide threats to U.S. security that the Chinese government could also use TikTok to control software on millions of devices and drive narratives to divide Americans over Taiwan or other issues. Good point. Now can we have our laws banning foreign control of news outlets and consolidation of media ownership back?
- zakki 4y agoWhich one do you like? Chinese government (and the likes) that clearly says/acts that their monitor their citizens movement. Or USA government (and the likes) that is not open in acknowledging they monitor their citizens.
- throwasd 4y agoBut USA shamelessly goes through other countries email and what not
- euroderf 4y agoWhy do I get the feeling that the NSA decompiled the app (and reconstructed its source) and freaked out and shoved their evidence in front of decisionmakers ?
- grapesurgeon 4y ago[dead]
- DuckFeathers 4y agoThis is just FBI acting as a PR arm of Meta. It must be embarrassing to Americans in-the-know.
- rchaud 4y agoEvery single phone in America capable of accessing TikTok is controlled by either Google or Apple. Instead of banning TT, where are the calls to the homegrown OS makers to not allow app vendors to access privacy-breaching information? This still seems like saber-rattling (cyber-rattling?) against China than anything constituting a real and present danger.
- orcajerk 4y ago[flagged]
- modshatereality 4y agoSo attempt to prosecute them under your non-existing legal theory. Are they a criminal enterprise or not? If yes how is facebook/google/microsoft any different? Perhaps you should invest some effort in mandating better protections of user privacy, and securing the horrifyingly bad mobile permissions/capabilities schemes that allow such actors to exfiltrate sensitive information instead of allowing this to continue?? HMMM? Also we need laws prohibiting ISP's from blocking user ports so PEOPLE can actually compete with these trillion dollar conglomerates.