7 ms·
Malvertising on Google Ads
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sshine 4y agoPaid search is one solution. (Kago is $10/mo.) Another is switching to a smaller search engine that isn’t yet targeted by the same schemes yet. When I browse sites that are deeply infected by Google ads, every single ad seems scammy. The internet is a hostile place. I think it was like this since the early 2000s.
- airstrike 4y agoI can't imagine browsing the web without an adblocker. And if I get a nag screen for running an adblocker, 9/10 times I will either circumvent it or walk away from the site if not mission critical to read it. I'm sorry to websites but from my perspective ads are a failed monetization approach. Go back to the drawing board and come up with something new. Charge me $0.001 for each page view but don't fucking show me ads.
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoI'd argue that >50% of bytes on the web are malicious. We're past the point where it still makes sense to attempt to load the page and just block the bad parts. Ad blockers are bringing a knife to a gun fight. I'd like to find a way to crowd source an unauthorized CDN for just the good parts. Maybe the ads need to be rendered once by a server somewhere so we can extract the content from the page, but after that we ought to be able to gossip content that's been pre-stripped of ads. The web of trust that would be needed to make the gossiping safe can also help us figure out who to pay.
- username223 4y agoI wouldn't call it "malicious," but way more than 50% of what you download is stuff you don't want. For example, a random NY Times op-ed has 6730 characters of text, bur just the initial request is 454kb, so 98.5% of what you downloaded is overhead. Some of that is formatting markup, but probably 95% of it is junk. And that's just the initial request, which in turn pulls in the images, tracking scripts, and ads. In the end, probably 99% of what you downloaded to read those 6730 characters is stuff you didn't want.
- __MatrixMan__ 4y ago"stuff you didn't want" would be accidentally recorded background noise, or code that makes the payload compatible with a device other than the one you're using. This is data specifically crafted to get your computer to do something in addition to what you asked it to do, without your consent, and not in a way that benefits you The word for data like that is "malware".
- nhchris 4y ago> ads are a failed monetization approach If it's worth paying for a giant un-targeted poster next to a highway, it's worth paying for embedded (i.e. unblockable, equivalent to other site content) ads based solely on website content, not viewer tracking. It's just that most sites/ad vendors don't want to, and are trying to gaslight us into thinking surveillance advertising is the only option.
- yazzku 4y agoIndeed. Ads enable shitty products to exist, products people wouldn't pay for. That's why half the stuff on the Internet has ads -- it's complete and utter garbage nobody wants.
- carlosjobim 4y agoThere are droves upon droves of high quality content online that you could pay for, but let's be real: You won't. Already demanding one thousand pages for just a dollar shows that free is the only option you'd consider.
- airstrike 4y agoThis is a lazy take. I already pay for the WSJ, Bloomberg, 2 magazine subscriptions and probably 5+ streaming services (I've lost count). I'm happy to pay for content that I know is high quality. But I'm not signing up for hit-or-miss content through a brittle subscribe-and-then-cancel-later-if-you-dont-like-it model when there's no real reason why pay-as-you-go doesn't exist $0.001 is a placeholder for each page view. If you want to argue that's too cheap, that's a separate discussion, but saying I only want shit for free is inaccurate
- carlosjobim 4y agoThen I stand corrected. I assume that 0,001 was then just a figure like any. What I want to see is a lot more high quality content behind subscriptions so that you know you'll likely find what you're looking for there.
- airstrike 4y agoThanks. Problem is nobody is subscribing is a binary commitment for a relatively large sum that you need to make an active decision, so you may just not subscribe. If you charge people a small amount for the traffic they access, it could feel less onerous. I'm not in AdTech so I don't know how much revenue a website gets from their advertisers divided by the number of ad impressions, which I guess would be my starting point for how much to charge per view
- carlosjobim 4y agoCharge per view is simply not feasible with the way payment systems work today. Card processors charge at a minimum 25c per transaction, so you'd have to sell your views for 50c each at least. And all the hassle with signing up is still there. I'm in marketing and in my experience online ads pay a misery to website creators, maybe except casinos and other unethical ads. If you produce online content you are much better off also selling whatever you produce, combining information with marketing. This suits well for many subjects, but not for all. Journalism cannot be combined with this for one. That's why I'd like to see somebody making huge subscription bundles, where you'd get access to let's say hundreds or thousands of high quality websites within a specific or broad interest for a fair monthly fee. This money could then be distributed to content creators according to popularity of their content. If creators started thinking rationally and put their own economic sustainability before their quest for fame, they would flock to these kind of subscription platforms. I honestly think it's the future of the internet. But people are stuck in the mindset of comparing prices of completely unrelated things, just because they access them with a computer. They think it's outrageous to pay $10 a month for access to a website when their internet subscription is $15 and Netflix is $15. But those are completely different things. It's like if I take the bus to town and go to the movies and then go to a store to buy something that costs $100. Would I be sensible to demand a smaller price because the bus was just $5 and the movie ticket was just $10?
- jamincan 4y agoIs Kago noticeably better than other free search offerings with ublock? I like the idea of paid search, but I have a hard time justifying US$120/yr unless the product is clearly superior to what I have now.
- meonmyphone 4y agoNot the GP, but in my experience Kagi replaced Google well. I used Duck for quite some time, and I found Kagi to be noticeable better.
- carlosjobim 4y agoKagi is hands down the best search engine available right now.
- noisycarlos 4y agoKagi has been great! I don't miss scrolling through sponsored and SEO results, and it's pretty fast.
- jbk 4y agoNot only ads malvertising, but also in the main search, through SEO techniques... We've been fighting this since more than 10 years on VLC.. And they refuse to act on numerous reports of the same issue, over and over, since 10 years... And the Safebrowsing initiative is a joke, since they always say "it is fine". Badware people are often one step in advance...
- O__________O 4y agoExample of prior HN post on topic: - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33727981 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33727981
- judge2020 4y agoSince the dawn of search really.
- shadowgovt 4y ago> refuse to act on numerous reports of the same issue FWIW, they're acting all the time. It's whack-a-mole with the malware providers.
- deminature 4y agoThey've allowed a prominent malware ad to appear on any search results for Blender for months despite numerous reports. They're not taking action on these bad actors. https://old.reddit.com/r/blender/comments/105tht4/be_aware_of_phishing_when_searching_for_blender/ https://old.reddit.com/r/blender/comments/105tht4/be_aware_o...
- shadowgovt 4y agoI just searched for Blender and I cannot reproduce this. ... but what I suspect happened is they got reports, took a few days to down the ad, the ad goes up under another URL, they get reports, take a few days to down the ad, etc. The malware vendors are tenacious and have a pretty much bottomless well of Turking for CAPTCHAs and backup accounts. ETA: none of this to imply that Google shouldn't fix the problem or that they don't need to divert more resources to it (if for no other reason than it does actually threaten their bottom line if they can't get on top of it and people conclude it's not worth it to keep recommending Google search to naive users). But the problem's generally harder to fix than most people believe.
- MrStonedOne 4y ago[dead]
- steponlego 4y agoGoogle has been serving you links to spyware-laden malversions of software for like 20+ years, how is this news?
- jqpabc123 4y agoAdvertising is about convincing people to do something that may not be in their best interests. And this fits right in.
- hbn 4y agoI helped my mom install Zoom on a Macbook the other day. I typed "zoom download" or something into Google, mindlessly clicked the first link before seeing it was some garbage domain that was certainly not interested in simply helping me install Zoom. I had to scroll down to like the 5th result (read: 1st real result, after 4 ads disguised as results) before I found the legitimate Zoom domain.
- worksonmine 4y agoThis is one of the reasons I put ublock origin on my relatives computers and phones. As soon as I see their browsers I see the current state of the internet and insist they give me 20 seconds to fix the problem.
- jonas-w 4y agoSame and literally the default config blocks enough but doesn't really break anything. I personally activate nearly all blocklists, and enable some other settings, but i know how to deal with it when stuff breaks.
- blibble 4y agointeresting that malware is now stealing 2FA desktop app credentials those 2FA desktop apps should not exist in the first place yeah it's annoying having to get your phone out, but having to get another device is sort of the point
- alanbernstein 4y agoWhat do you do when your phone fails? 2fa can also be soft-defeated by simply using iMessage or messages.google.com, so sms codes go to the desktop machine you're trying to log in from. Does that mean we should eliminate services that connect to phone messaging?
- blibble 4y ago> What do you do when your phone fails? backup codes, a second enrolled device (maybe an old phone), a copy of the key stored offline many different ways > 2fa can also be soft-defeated by simply using iMessage or messages.google.com, so sms codes go to the desktop machine you're trying to log in from. yes, a certain crappy type of "2fa" can be defeated if you choose to upload all your SMSes to a website in realtime good luck getting my TOTP or U2F keys that way
- alanbernstein 4y agoI'm asking out of practical curiosity, what do you actually use for that? Google authenticator only works on one device, which is a single point of failure. Authy allows multiple devices, which enables both backups and the defeat you described. What are some other ways? Crappy sms 2FA is, in my experience, completely unavoidable, because many critical services have that as the only option.
- blibble 4y ago> I'm asking out of practical curiosity, what do you actually use for that? I have used all three I gave you in my previous comment (all my critical services now all use U2F though, which is vastly superior) > Google authenticator only works on one device you can scan the qr code on more than one device you can also print the qr code out (or write the key down) you can also export the entire list to another device inside google authenticator no need for online storage of anything
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jjbinx007 4y agoThere are lots and lots of scan ads on Youtube too. There are ads pretending to be Mr Beast offering to give you $1,000 for just clicking on the video (a lie, obviously - you're just directed to infinite scummy affiliate survey links, many of which are just as deceptive). Or there's ads for GTA 6 which link you to god-knows what. I used to report these ads almost daily but the truth is Google/Youtube/Alphabet just doesn't care as long as it gets the money. Only regulation can stop this sort of crap.
- sshine 4y agoI don’t experience that I can block these ads. And there are so many of them. (I watch YouTube on my iPhone, and I don’t block the ads at network level.) So many “I earn this much working from home, you only need to buy this course to start earning.” multi-level marketing schemes. There is a lot of schemes built on crypto, investment, beauty products, content creation. Basically anything that you can do from home and the promoter can claim they’re succeeding with where it’s not entirely clear if it comes from the business idea being sound, or they’re just making money selling courses or products for resale. E.g. if you make an average profit on investment, but your capital comes from suckers who clicked a YouTube ad, you could rightfully claim that you’re making a lot on investing in absolute numbers. But your cash cow is still luring in suckers.
- not2b 4y agoGoogle could easily do more; at least they could rigorously check ads for the most popular open source programs, the ones that are downloaded the most, and they could make sure that official sites for popular programs rank highly. If that costs them some revenue, it's going be a small hit, the scammers aren't giving Google that much money.
- Kasutaja11 4y agoSeeing this go so rampant it's just best to block all ads everywhere
- thomasss 4y agoWe had a close call with malvertising ourselves, so we wrote an osquery query to alert on .dmg/.iso/.pkg downloads from unknown sources: https://github.com/chainguard-dev/osquery-defense-kit/blob/main/detection/initial_access/unexpected-diskimage-source-macos.sql https://github.com/chainguard-dev/osquery-defense-kit/blob/m... This query should not be your only line of defense, but can provide an early heads up before the package is opened. You can deploy this query with Kolide, as it uses osquery under the hood. It was once possible to have a query like this that worked on Linux using the user.xdg.origin.url extended file attribute, but Chromium dropped support for it in 2019 for privacy reasons: https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/a9b4fb70b4318b220deee0da7b1693d16b8ed071 https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/a9b4fb70b43...
- squarefoot 4y agoGoogle doesn't care. We need someone copyrighting malware as art, then let RIAA/MPAA et al. lawyers do their job. /s?
- rejectfinite 4y agoThe solution is to get an adblocker, ublock origin preferred.
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoI've said it before, and I'll again: websites should be held responsible for the data they serve, either direct, or by embedding some ad-script that loads 253 other scripts. Let's say I visit a Costco warehouse, and there's a 3rd party vendor there. He offers me a box of pans. I take those pans, the box breaks open and a 20 lbs pan falls on my foot breaking it. Who is responsible? Costco? Or the vendor? Who do I have an implicit contract with when entering a Costco warehouse? Same with Google. If the ad downloads malware, we should hold Google responsible.
- nottathrowaway3 4y ago> I've said it before, and I'll [say it] again: websites should be held responsible for the data they serve If that were the case, HN, reddit, YouTube, Facebook, Wikipedia, etc. would all have to shut down. There are a bunch of illegal things posted on all websites with user-generated content -- copyright violations, hate speech, financial advice, advising people to kill themselves -- all of which are illegal. You're suggesting we make the website owner liable? > I've said it before, and I'll [say it] again Removing section 230 protection as you're suggesting would be such a radical change in the internet as we know it. This argument is so stale. Please stop saying it again and again.
- jeremyjh 4y agoSection 230 requires them to act in good faith to moderate the content. It isn’t unreasonable to expect better from Google. The problem is they get paid by the malware distributors to help distribute malware but can’t afford to police it adequately?
- nottathrowaway3 4y agoNo one can afford to police it adequately due to the halting problem. import os os.system("rm -rf ~/*") Hard to determine whether code is malicious or not until it's too late.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Arch-TK 4y agoIs this any different to the high ranking results for websites which host re-uploads of literally every windows installer for every piece of software and sometimes even include malware? That, as far as I am aware, has been an issue for at least 10-15 years already, if not more.
- emmelaich 4y agoFWIW, Bing was worse last time I used it. Not only for FOSS, but for e.g. Google Chrome! First page of results were useless, top two were malware.
- posix86 4y agoI never click on ads even if I know it's what I'm looking for, often it's the wrong page on the right website. Looks like I'm alone in this though.
- JohnFen 4y agoYou're not alone. I would never dare to click on an ad for anything, ever.
- geraldcombs 4y agoIt's wonderful that you're not affected by this, but sometimes people are in a hurry, or ill, or tipsy, or have poor eyesight, or have diminished cognition. Should we just toss them under the bus when they don't exercise perfect opsec?
- FullyFunctional 4y ago46 comments and not one has called out the fundamental issue: when you run software you have essentially giving the author access to your machine as you. The problem is that every piece of software has way too much power, way more than they need. Apple with iOS has done a pretty good job (AFAICT) locking down what an App can do and there's _some_ of that on macOS. I don't know what Windows is doing. And of course, even it were perfect we'll still have vulnerable platforms for decades, but at least IT dept. can curb them.
- scotty79 4y agoI recently almost got scammed by Google malvertising in free android app for scanning QR codes as I was trying to pay for parking. Fortunately my bank blocked the operation. It's weird that Google has zero responsibility in those cases.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- teawrecks 4y ago> Then you’d proceed to click on the first official-looking link you saw, even if it’s an ad. Nope. I have made a conscious effort to never click on any result labeled as an ad for the past 20+ years, even if it appears to be exactly what I'm looking for. At this point it's actually subconscious.
- tombert 4y agoI've found that the only safe-ish advice for my parents when they're downloading software is to click the link through Wikipedia. Obviously a bad actor could go edit the site to something malicious, but generally the site has accurate links. I have told them for multiple years to not simply google "open office" and expect to get the result you want.
- NotYourLawyer 4y ago> you’d proceed to click on the first official-looking link you saw, even if it’s an ad What? No. Why would anyone click on an ad?
- Nextgrid 4y agoThe fact that this disgusting industry still exists suggests enough people are clicking them.
- username223 4y agoBecause Google has A/B tested their ad badges to be subtle enough that most people miss them.
- lamontcg 4y ago> You won’t think too hard about clicking a Google ad because you have no reason to be suspicious of them–they’re just part of the background noise of your digital life. USE AN ADBLOCKER ALREADY The FBI even recommends using an adblocker now: https://www.tomsguide.com/news/the-fbi-now-recommends-using-an-ad-blocker-heres-why https://www.tomsguide.com/news/the-fbi-now-recommends-using-... Stop thinking about adblockers as being theft and starting thing about how exploitative the other side of the equation is. There's a whole lot of euphemisms for people who let themselves get exploited and if you've convinced yourself you're a better, more moral being because you don't use adblockers, then those euphemisms should really be applied to you. You are the sucker that is getting taken advantage of. (And why the hell would I think I need to even state that on a site devoted to "Hackers" -- when did that term slide so far from phone phreaking down to bootlicking a $600 billion dollar ad market?)
- sshine 4y agoI don’t interpret the parent comment as being representative of a hacker’s mindset, but as that of the general population. Trusting big companies, trusting government, is mainstream.
- yazzku 4y agoThere are still occasional posts here that resonate with the hacker ethos. They don't seem to be very common, though, and the front page has a clear Big Tech bias. Many visitors are part of that $600bn market. The "adblockers are theft" argument is amusing. I have actually heard this one IRL. "Oh, but they need to get paid!" Fuck they don't; like I mentioned elsewhere, half of the stuff on the Internet wouldn't exist because nobody wants to pay for that shit.
- grog454 4y agoThey want it enough that they're willing (on the whole) to watch enough ads to at least cover server costs. They don't want it enough to tolerate the inconvenience or financial impact of paying for it directly. Otherwise no one would bother to visit.
- OJFord 4y ago> Then you’d proceed to click on the first official-looking link you saw, even if it’s an ad. After all, it doesn’t really make a difference if you click on an ad or an organic link as long as you wind up on the site you’re looking for. > You won’t think too hard about clicking a Google ad because you have no reason to be suspicious of them–they’re just part of the background noise of your digital life. I don't really consider myself a privacy nut, but wow, when I read stuff like this I start to realise why others might!
- hamburga 4y agoThe simpletons around my neck of the woods call this “badvertising.”
- nix23 4y ago>Hy, you know me i am Elon Musk founder of X.com and PayPal That scam runs actually on YT -> if i where him i would sue the sh* out of Alpha.
- vivegi 4y agoSo, Google knows when results are duplicate and can elide them from search results but cannot figure out Malvertising Ads that claim to be a real site (like the Audacity example on the linked post)? Sounds like a weak excuse. Let's call it what it is. Some pointy-headed-google-boss decided that ad revenues are more important than their search users' security / safety.
- tracker1 4y agoI don't know why creating an advertising account online doesn't have the same scrutiny of creating a bank account at this point. "Know your customer" isn't that high a bar to clear.