4 ms·
Literally anything google values will be abused and ruin the internet. If they valued shortness then everything would be trimmed to bullet points removing usefu
by Gigachad 4y ago
Literally anything google values will be abused and ruin the internet. If they valued shortness then everything would be trimmed to bullet points removing useful info.
The problem is really not that google is doing a bad job, it’s that the incentives to get views on pages ruins the internet.
- inductive_magic 4y agoThat sounds like it makes sense - but if human readers know what's a good search result and what isn't, why would Google not be able to optimize their algo accordingly? If the results for a query don't match the "nature of the query", it's a bad result. If the algo can be gamed, it isn't aiming for the actual goal, i.e. it fundamentally fails at information retrieval.
- Gigachad 4y agoBecause anything google can detect, the spammers can generate to match. We will soon enter an era of GPT generated spam which not even humans can tell if it's real info or just garbage that looks real.
- thr717272 4y agoLuckily on Kagi I can just block sites the moment I realize it is nonsense. Or boost or even pin sites that I feel are extra valuable. Back in the old days I had a txt-file on my desktop containing domains with a minus in front, llke -example.com -example.org for all the worst offenders, so that I could post them on the end of every contested search. After a while I think Google found a way to ignore those as well as every other filter I had - at least I gave it up.
- trinsic2 4y agoI have never used anything but google, duckduckgo and startpage. I always end up coming back to google because the results are not as good. Well startpage has the same results as google, but i stopped using it for reasons I forgot. What made you chose Kagi?
- thr717272 4y agoTested it and found it realized doublequotes something none of the big ones that I can access (bing, ddg, google) does. That was it. And the first time I saw a reported bug in the search results getting serious attention and a fix I was sold.
- onion2k 4y agoif human readers know what's a good search result and what isn't That assumes there's a single, canonical idea of what a "good result" looks like. I imagine that's dependent on a lot of factors, from the context of why the user is searching, their demographic, and their biases. When I search for "chocolate chip cookie recipe" I want straight facts - ingredients and bullet point steps and nothing else. My mother would want some background about the recipe, where it's from, and what makes it different. You can't get that from the search term alone. You need a lot more context. It's exactly what the promise of 'personalized search' based on tracking everyone around the internet told us it would give us but it doesn't seem to work very well.
- Nextgrid 4y ago> That assumes there's a single, canonical idea of what a "good result" looks like Maybe we can't agree on what people want, but what I'm sure we can agree on is what people don't want. I don't recall anyone ever saying "I wish there were more ads in the content I'm consuming". So we could at least start with that.
- bootsmann 4y agoYes, and now turn that sentiment into a metric that can be measured as input to the model. At first it was click-through rate, but that turned SEO into sites into clickbait to get high click scores. Then they switched to time spent on the site, and as a consequence we get recipes that are filled with 2h of prose above them just so people stay longer on the site.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoRecipes are a pain in general, even without google, doubly so for baking. Baking is a science, not art... so recipes calling for a cup of flour and two teaspoons of butter are useless to me, while recipes with ingredients in grams are useless to many american grandmas. On the other hand, a pinterest page with a photo and a large overlay asking me to register is useless to both of us.
- 4y ago
- owisd 4y agoI disagree that whatever ranking system google uses will just be gamed to the same extent. If google downgraded the rank of pages with lots of ads and trackers it would substantially reduce the incentive to game the system, the reason it won’t is because most of those pages are running Adsense so there’s every incentive for google to keep the status quo.
- frankzander 4y agoThat is exactly the point!
- yunohn 4y agoIf you provide less monetisation for content creators, you end up with less content too. This is not as simple as you think…
- piaste 4y agoYou could reward the type of monetization that is correlated to high-quality content and penalize the type that is associated with spam. Site offers extra paid content or services, or takes donations? Rank up. Ads? Neutral or rank down based on type of ads. Affiliate links? Rank way down.
- tazard 4y agoLess content is fine when the issue is too much junk content. Content would then be created by enthusiasts instead of businesses
- carlosjobim 4y ago> enthusiasts instead of businesses Those are more and more the same person - especially when it comes to online ventures.
- Loic 4y agoYou end up with less trash/monetization content and more content from passionate people writing about what they love/like/do for the joy of sharing. But this does not sustain the chocolate factory.
- ekianjo 4y agobullet points would be an improvement over bullshit useless prose
- thegginthesky 4y agoThe real problem is that Google holds an effective monopoly in search, so any digital marketer worth a salt will optimize the crap out of their blogs and pages to get higher and higher rank within Google alone. This will, in turn, lead to what we see today: a race to the bottom in terms of quality to get the best SEO results. I've found that a mix of search engines give me the best results, I'm trying my best to incentivize competition. If I want super local results anywhere outside the US, I'll use Google+uBlock because that's what it works, but everything else I use Kagi or DDG.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoWhy do people even care about views? Because of advertising. It is the root cause of all problems on the web today. All Google has to do to fix the web is put itself out of business by delisting pages with ads including its own. Search and the web at large would be fixed in days.
- gniv 4y ago> Literally anything google values will be abused and ruin the internet. That is true to the extent that the "anything" is only a proxy for quality. Keywords, reputation, etc are all proxies. But now with these AI models Google should be able to assess the true value of a page. Does it provide useful information? In what area? Etc. Then invert that in order to answer queries. I really hope this is where page ranking is headed.
- JohnFen 4y ago> But now with these AI models Google should be able to assess the true value of a page That'd be nice, but I am skeptical for a number of reasons. Not the least of which is that where Google has already applied AI, it has seemed to make things worse, not better.