5 ms·
Standardized tests are much easier to prep for than GPA and extracurriculars. I don’t get where the statement “rich kids don’t test well” actually comes from, a
by seanmcdirmid 4y ago
Standardized tests are much easier to prep for than GPA and extracurriculars. I don’t get where the statement “rich kids don’t test well” actually comes from, and it wasn’t just made up to argue a point. Perhaps if you had state sponsored test prep like in China (you spend the last two years of high school just prepping for the test), but high school isn’t compulsory and many poor kids don’t even attend.
- Clubber 4y ago>I don’t get where the statement “rich kids don’t test well” actually comes from, and it wasn’t just made up to argue a point. When I read what you said and thought the same thing. I then looked up what the author wrote: Rich kids who “don’t test well.” He's just saying if you have a kid that doesn't test well (I am one of those) and happen to be wealthy, the rich have options that poor kids don't. He isn't saying rich kids don't tend to test well. I'm not sure that premise is 100% accurate either. My parents were teachers and we didn't have extravagant lives, but my parents knew the value of an education and forced me to do test prep 6 days a week the summer after my Junior year. I ended up improving my scores and getting into a good state university and subsequently have a good career 25+ years and still going strong. I think edge case success (students that don't test well) boils down more to parents giving a shit than anything else. It's not easy, that's for sure, even if you are moderately wealthy.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoGPA and extracurriculars are so much easier to game than standardized tests, it's not even close. Moreover, this is what all the research on the topic suggests.
- Jensson 4y ago> Standardized tests are much easier to prep for than GPA and extracurriculars And that makes them perfect for poor kids who don't have much time or money, they can easily get similar levels of test prep as rich kid with little effort. GPA or extracurriculars however, no chance, those are much more dependent on home environment and wealth.
- lordnacho 4y agoWhy would home environment be more influential for GPA, which is a bunch of tests, versus the SAT, which is also just a test? Extracurriculars I agree with, rich people are more likely to have connections to get the nice internships.
- Jensson 4y agoYou don't see why studying 20 hours for 1 test that you can easily repeat is easier to scrape together than 2000 hours to score well on all tests throughout high school?
- lordnacho 4y agoIf you can't find the time to do your normal tests for GPA, you won't find time to study for the SAT either. Whether that's because you live in an unsupportive home or you just can't find the discipline, it's only theoretical that someone who isn't used to a studying environment can somehow have the foresight to invest their few hours on this particular exam.
- Jensson 4y ago> If you can't find the time to do your normal tests for GPA, you won't find time to study for the SAT either. That is just nonsense. Lets say that you have 20 hours to study per year, like a couple of weekends that are calmer etc, you can spend those on SAT and you got basically the full benefits of studying for that test since studying more isn't very beneficial. But 20 hours to study per year wont budge your GPA much at all. Close to every kid can find 20 hours to study per year, I'm pretty sure. Or do you think that people can either study all the time, or study none of the time, no in-between at all? Edit: > it's only theoretical that someone who isn't used to a studying environment can somehow have the foresight to invest their few hours on this particular exam. Not at all, I never studied for anything in high school and got shit grades. But I spent a weekend to study for a SAT once, got good on that, and got into college that way. This isn't theoretical at all, it happens all the time. It is very different to do something for a very short time, or keeping that up for 4 years straight.
- LewisVerstappen 4y ago> Standardized tests are much easier to prep for than GPA and extracurriculars All the data shows the exact opposite. Also, it's pretty obvious this is false if you spend 10 seconds thinking about it. You're forced to give the test yourself. Whereas you can easily hire a tutor to read over and "check" (i.e. rewrite) your school essays/homework. Rich kids can also easily get internships/research experience while in HS due to family connections.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoCram schools exist for a reason. You can get lots of help on the ACT/SATs, heck, they even offer it in China. Grades and extra circular can be gamed as well, but you have to do a lot more planning ahead of time...like you can't just start 6 months before a test date and maybe try again 6 months after that. You have to start form late elementary school and be consistent up until 12th grade.
- ouid 4y agoWhat? I think you have the wrong kind of standardized test in mind. Bad standardized tests written by politicians are easy to prepare for. Often by design, since they are supposed to measure "what you have learned", rather than how smart you are. The SAT is an IQ test.
- adrr 4y agoYou just need money to game extracurriculars activities and GPA(pay a tutor to do your kids work every day or go to a private a school). https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/818679/An_Unequal_Playing_Field_report.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
- ilamont 4y agoWhat happens when the student takes a test in class if the tutor has been doing all the work?
- megmogandog 4y agoPresumably that's where the rich students who "don't test well" come from
- Glyptodon 4y agoUsually things are designed so that these kids can still get A's if their tests are all B's, B's if tests are all C's, and so forth. Often with some special extra credit offered just to makes sure they can always get at least a B.
- lcuff 4y ago> Standardized tests are much easier to prep for than GPA and extracurriculars. Based on comments so far, I'm curious what you mean by this. My own take is that you are correct because standardized tests are 'easier to prep for' because, in many ways, they are IQ tests that you can't prep for, or rather that Bang for the Buck of prepping is low. So, poor, smart kids with no prep can take the test hung over and do well, as the author says. Rich folks can get tutors to spend tens or hundreds of hours prepping, and have only a modest impact on their score.
- tptacek 4y agoSAT prep tests do have some impact, but much more significantly, re-takes and disability accommodations are highly impactful and heavily SES-correlated.
- Glyptodon 4y agoThere's a lot of evidence that it's difficult to drastically change someone's test scores in a year or two, and it's compounded by the degree of internal motivation of the test taker. And there's an element of reversion to the mean with children of some high achievers. Meanwhile, GPA and extracurriculars are significantly reflections of socialization and parents rather than anyone's inherent or learned abilities.