4 ms·
"Company" = Salesforce, which is a name I'm sure people over here recognize, so we can swap it out in the title. There's also little value in pushing this clic
by paxys 4y ago
"Company" = Salesforce, which is a name I'm sure people over here recognize, so we can swap it out in the title.
There's also little value in pushing this clickbait style journalism to the front page.
First of all, it is objectively incorrect:
> Per the WSJ, the company will be letting go of 8,000 members from its massive workforce
The layoffs they are referring to happened in early January. They are not laying off another 8000 employees.
Beyond that, they paid an A-list actor $10M out of their marketing budget not to "sit around" but to do a set of commercials (one of which aired at the Superbowl). Considering they exceeded all analyst expectations for revenue and profits in the last quarter, it's safe to say that some of their effort is working. Enlightened engineers don't like to admit it, but advertising works, and is a critical part of running any business.
The fact that they also decided that 8K out of the 25K+ employees hired during the pandemic were redundant has nothing to do with Matthew McConaughey.
- eunoia 4y ago> Considering they exceeded all analyst expectations for revenue and profits in the last quarter, it's safe to say that some of their effort is working. > The fact that they also decided that 8K out of the 25K+ employees hired during the pandemic were redundant Kinda odd how you attribute them "beating the street" more to Mathew McConaughey's presence than the work output of 8 thousand employees. Can you elaborate on why this is so clear to you?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deltree7 4y agoThey have better metrics than random anti-corporate HNer who is typically clueless about accounting, marketing, lead-gen?
- mola 4y agoDon't you think that the ppl deciding to hire like crazies just to fire a year later should be accountable for that? They're clearly making bad decisions. It's just that someone else is expected to pay for them.
- giantg2 4y agoThose might be bad decisions for the employees, but those might be good decisions for the company. Basically, scoop up talent while you can, then cut the lowest performers. It's basically the last step in a thorough interview process.
- wootland 4y agoIf you've ever worked somewhere where there's been layoffs, you'll know that of the remaining employees, all of the best people immediately start looking for jobs elsewhere. If management is so incompetent that they overhired or underperformed bad enough to lay people off, the writing is on the wall to jump ship. It can take years to repair the motivational and cultural damage caused by a layoff. Especially when paired with "soft" layoff behavior like mandating RTO and "performance" management.
- deltree7 4y agoWhere is this magical "elsewhere" part where there would be no layoffs? It's mind-boggling that we have raised a generation of people who are absolutely clueless about "Cost-of-Capital". It is worse than people not understanding democracy
- wootland 4y ago> Where is this magical "elsewhere" part where there would be no layoffs? Any company with competent management. That includes not cargo culting layoffs while turning a blind eye to the damage they cause to a company. > It's mind-boggling that we have raised a generation of people who are absolutely clueless about "Cost-of-Capital". It is worse than people not understanding democracy What's mind-boggling is that people think the cost savings from a layoff happens in a vacuum. There are definitely repercussions in terms of loss of productivity, increased employee churn, brand damage, increased difficulty hiring in the future, loss of operational knowledge... Layoff are a sign of mismanagement. That has nothing to do with the "cost-of-capital".
- paxys 4y agoIs it very hard to believe that (1) some single digit % of employees (and even entire divisions) at a massive corporation – one that nearly doubled in size during the pandemic – aren't adding a lot of value and (2) a flashy marketing campaign can bring a company new customers?
- alpenbazi 4y ago8k of 25k is not some "single digit %" u sound like u get paid for salesforce-pr
- paxys 4y ago25k what? Salesforce had over 80k employees at the time of the layoffs.
- thwayunion 4y agoWell all the numbers I've ever seen have been just shy of 80, and 8/80 = 10%, which is 2 digits. So there are two possibilities. One possibility, I guess, is that both your and parent are using some sort of counting system we'll call "base b" where 25 base b = 80 base 10 and in which 8/80 base b < 10% base b. The other, more likely, possibility is that you're intentionally under-stating the scale of the layoffs and being oddly defensive. Enjoy your Salesforce stock grant, I guess ;-)
- dfmooreqqq 4y agoThe base b here would be base 37.5 :)
- Chris2048 4y ago8/25 is 32%, no?
- rco8786 4y ago25k is just what they hired during covid
- WalterBright 4y agoThe old joke is the marketing manager saying: "Half of all our marketing expenditures are wasted. The problem is we don't know which half." In my years in business, it's nearly impossible to draw an accurate cause and effect line between marketing and sales. Too many other factors at work.
- j0hnyl 4y agoOne thing I've noticed is that having competent and down to earth marketing folks also helps to boos overall morale at a company.
- kermatt 4y agoIt does seem odd that companies would pay for services from Salesforce because of a celebrity quip, instead of a determination that said services would improve the company's operations. Or perhaps these Marketing departments are just really good at internal marketing of budget usage?
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoSo are you saying, then, that you find it odd that marketing and advertising works? Nothing wrong if you do, I just wanted to be clear on that point.
- bsg75 4y agoNo, I find it odd to spend that much cash on a celebrity endorsement when the target consumer audience (businesses) know that the celebrity is not a Sales Force customer: "What the heck to Matthew McConaughey use SalesForce for ?" or more importantly: "Why is SalesForce paying that kind of money when they could be investing instead in their abysmal support?" - as a SF/Tableau customer this is my perspective.
- ztrww 4y agohow do you know it worked in this specific case though? maybe Salesforce would have done just as well financially and also saved 20 million or something like that without that ad campaign
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoAnd maybe it wouldn't have. But since I don't work for SalesForce's marketing dept, there's no way to tell.
- proser 4y agoThat's not what marketing does. It doesn't influence the decision. Marketing makes sure your company is top of mind when the customer decides to make a decision.
- bombcar 4y agoAnd whilst $10m sounds like a lot (and it is!) that's only about ~50 (Bay Area) employees.
- paxys 4y agoProbably fewer than that. Cost of an employee to the company is on average 2x their salary. Plus such mass layoffs don't just target entry level employees but an entire vertical slice including senior ICs, managers and executives. A lot of them at companies like Salesforce, Google, Meta get $1M+/yr in comp.
- wootland 4y ago> The layoffs they are referring to happened in early January. They are not laying off another 8000 employees. That's not true. They announced 8,000 layoffs in January but they haven't executed all of that yet. As per the quoted WSJ article: > In January, the company said 8,000 workers had to go. “It’s an unfortunate part that you have to say goodbye to folks who, in many cases, are your friends and you have relationships with,” Mr. Benioff said in an interview. “But, ultimately, the success of the business has to be paramount.” > After an executive retreat in February, he proposed in a draft of a year-ahead strategy plan that the company rank employees based on metrics, including how much money salespeople bring in. Those in the bottom 5% would be routinely dismissed, according to a draft of the policy posted on the company’s Slack channel and described to The Wall Street Journal.
- paxys 4y agoThe two aren't connected. They announced 10% layoffs in January and executed it. Then they announced that they would be rolling out stack ranking and PIP quotas for managers, but both of those decisions were later reversed (https://www.businessinsider.com/salesforce-plans-ranking-employees-return-to-office-layoffs-2023-2 https://www.businessinsider.com/salesforce-plans-ranking-emp...).
- wootland 4y agoIt's actually unclear as to whether or not they have done all of the layoffs. From your article: > The company has been reducing its workforce since November, when it cut hundreds of salespeople. In January, the company announced restructuring plans to lay off 10% of staff — roughly 7,000 people — and shed some of its office real estate. > Since then, thousands of workers from that planned 10% cut have been notified of their terminations. Insider has also reported that remaining employees are feeling increased performance pressure, and some are being pressured to quit with severance offers that are not as big as those being laid off. > Salesforce has not confirmed whether it has notified all 10% of workers included in the official restructuring plan yet. Insider previously reported that at least one person familiar with the matter said the company was evaluating last month whether it needs to cut an additional 10%.
- airstrike 4y ago> The fact that they also decided that 8K out of the 25K+ employees hired during the pandemic were redundant has nothing to do with Matthew McConaughey. Like everyone else in Tech, they over-hired because they were objectively in a different state of the world in 2021, which was possibly everyone's best year in 1-2 decades. Then 2022 rolled in, shit hit the fan on inflation, Ukraine war and a seemingly overnight massive hike in rates after being in negative yield territory for a while... guess what? Companies went back to the drawing board, stared at lower revenue expectations, higher costs, worse margins given operating leverage and decided they could do without X% employees to favor profitability over growth, since there's nowhere near the same growth to be had in 2022-23 as there was in 2020-21 Conceptually, I dislike layoffs as much as the next person... but keeping the same cost structure against deteriorating topline growth is just Bad Business, and that's how CEOs get fired and companies go under. Ask the owner of the pizza joint nearest to you and they're likely to agree. All in all, unemployment is still at record lows so I'm incline to believe that laid-off workers are finding employment elsewhere, which is the good side of Capitalism. It could have been worse, John... a lot worse
- bink 4y ago> Considering they exceeded all analyst expectations for revenue and profits in the last quarter, it's safe to say that some of their effort is working. Didn't the layoffs happen in January (the end of their fiscal quarter) and wouldn't they have taken the costs of those layoffs and subsequent severance in that quarter? So they recorded record revenue and profits _despite_ laying off people, not because they laid them off.
- chank 4y ago> marketing budget Do people who would be in a place to make the decision about their companies choice of CRMP really need to be marketed to in order to know about Salesforce? Seems like a wasted budget IMO.