8 ms·
America’s property market suggests recession is on the way
- luckylion 4y agohttps://archive.is/0oGD9 https://archive.is/0oGD9
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe body of the article doesn't really support the headline; it's a lot more "might, might not, no one knows and the past few years have been weird".
- finikytou 4y agoif you say it often it might happen!!! what we are seeing however is that as people can't get loans anymore there are more renters which makes rent more expensive and ultimately owners richers which will then make people buy more houses even tho loans have higher rate,
- jmclnx 4y agoActually I heard somewhere rents are staring to fall. Not sure if I believed that article. But it also said there are a lot of new rental units about to hit the market in 2024 YMMV Another thing, I know some people in one of the "Tier 1 Cities" who's rent has not increased in a few years. But, these people never missed a rent payment and was never late, so it could be due to the landlord liking that.
- rcme 4y agoI thought it was the 2nd derivative that was falling. Rents were still going up, but not as fast as they were previously.
- Eumenes 4y agodoes this mean i may be able to scoop up a home cheaper? obv rates will be high, but if you have the credit and $$, should be a good opportunity for the financially patient/responsible.
- mistrial9 4y agoright - like the lengthy comment on this topic on an earlier day lamenting "you can only buy three" new houses.. A fellow and his two buddies would have a fun ritual of going to new home sales lots and buying with good credit as many houses as they could together on the first day. Then, they unwind the position to actual buyers for a profit.. good times! </s>
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI've been of a mind that the only way to "win" is to buy land instead and build on it. I see too many large, conglomorate home builders — perhaps two of which will divvy up entire subdivisions and rake in the profits for themselves. I'm no historian but it seems there's been a trend over the past century of entire markets becoming inaccessible to the average person. I'm not going to do the topic justice with my poorly worded rant but I'm thinking about how, for example, the "A&P's" made it impossible for mom and pop to open a grocery store (short of a niche kind of Indian Foods Market or whatever). Various big players have divided up each of the industries and mercantile opportunities leaving the rest of us with little more than food trucks, small restaurants, nail salons, etc. It's fascinating to me the rare opportunities of commerce that have briefly graced the middle class before being swallowed up — things like the book store, the record store, the drive-in movie theater, the personal computer, the video rental store....
- UncleEntity 4y agoI’ve been kind of halfassedly watching the properties in the town I bought my house and the last time I checked, probably a couple weeks ago, all the bargains were snapped up after being on the market for a while. Maybe something changed with the local economy that I don’t know about but it seems that people might be snapping up houses while they can still afford them. Obviously pure speculation on my part as I only pay attention to one smallish city. —edit— Turns out pure baseless speculation and probably a bug in Zillow because the bargain houses are still there.
- ChatGTP 4y ago[flagged]
- rythmshifter 4y agowhat... is this account
- ChatGTP 4y agoSkynet ?
- PopAlongKid 4y agoA mis-spelling of ChatGPT.
- oxfordmale 4y agoThis recession is going to play out differently than expected. Certain parts of the economy seem to be doing well, whereas others, such as the property market, show signs of recession. As a result, it does appear there will be a very shallow recession overall.
- baby-yoda 4y agoIMO we'll see sectors fall and start to recover at varying times and its going to be difficult to assess the economy in aggregate. Rates will continue to bleed out non-productive companies but large zombies might be able to survive. An additional rate hike in July is now close to consensus so I think behind closed doors the Fed and others are very concerned about large bankruptcies and contagion - using rates more aggressively to accelerate the burn might help to level things out.
- mcphage 4y ago> whereas others, such as the property market, show signs of recession I'm not even sure the article supports that much: > But recently, signs of an early and largely unexpected rebound have emerged, prompting concerns that higher rates are not having the desired effect. New-home sales jumped in January to a ten-month high. Surveys gauging the confidence of both homebuilders and homebuyers have improved. America’s property companies have reported more visitors to their show homes. “We have seen the momentum build week after week,” notes Sheryl Palmer, chief executive of Taylor Morrison, one of the country’s biggest homebuilders. It seems more like the property market is doing unexpectedly well.
- JCM9 4y agoSo in part folks playing financial wizardry with mortgages to get people to buy homes that they wouldn’t otherwise afford or be willing to buy. What could possibly go wrong?
- ceejayoz 4y agoIt's described as financial wizardry, but isn't it the same thing we've had for decades? Mortgage/discount points? Pay a little extra in exchange for a lower interest rate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discount_points https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discount_points
- mkmk 4y agoWorth noting, if you don’t follow this type of news closely, that The Economist publishes a piece saying a recession either is or isn’t happening every few weeks.
- themitigating 4y agoIsn't that true? At every point we are either heading towards a recession or not and it's a magazine dedicated to the economy and business.
- oblio 4y agoTrue, but in economics (I guess in life, too?), timing is everything. It's "boy cried wolf", otherwise.
- Jensson 4y agoIt's "boy found wolf tracks, but no wolf came that night, so people called the boy a liar".
- Spivak 4y agoIt’s “boy found wolf tracks in the woods where everyone knows there’s wolves already but is sure this time the tracks mean they’ll attack.”
- r3trohack3r 4y agoThere are two lessons in the boy who cried wolf. Every day the boy would cry wolf and eventually the towns people stopped believing him. Then a wolf came and the boy had already lost his credibility so nobody believed him. Then the wolf ate all the sheep. The first lesson is the boy’s, don’t burn trust by crying wolf. The second lesson is the town’s. They let the boy desensitize them to wolves and now all their sheep are dead.
- oblio 4y ago
- jmclnx 4y agoWell as long as people are spending and the US unemployment rate is low, this article means nothing. I guess they never heard of Interest Rates or Working from Home or real wages increasing (though slowly) :) Anyway, I am starting to believe these "recession is on the way" articles as the top 1% trying to cause one so they can prevent the slow movement from slave wages to almost livable wages.
- _8j50 4y agoWho stands to benefit the most from a recession? I am curious because this talk has consistently been rubbish.
- kingkawn 4y agoEveryone who wants in on the ground floor of of the next boom
- newaccount2021 4y ago[dead]
- sokoloff 4y agoI think there’s a more likely explanation that the longer an expansion cycle goes, the more time people spend wondering when it will stop/reverse. The more people who wonder about it, the more market there is for articles talking about the inevitability.
- JPKab 4y agoThe primary reason the unemployment has remained low is due to so many people primarily baby boomers, leaving the work force. High inflation means that interest rates on all loans have to be higher for banks to earn back their principal. I'm not even counting the Federal reserve needing to race their core interest rate which they will. When capital becomes more expensive businesses are more likely to fail and less likely to be started. Inflation leads to higher interest rates and lower lending. Reduced lending leads to economic contraction. Wage gains in real terms are primarily due to a supply and demand curve for labor. Most industries are having any wage gains erased by inflation. This isn't a new phenomenon with the exception of the first contraction in the labor force participation rate in decades. Inflation of this nature is only halted by reduced economic activity. Without it, it continues until real wage growth is sharply negative. By the way, if you're a reader of HN, you are almost certainly in the "1 percent" globally.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoI thought we were already in a recession, does this mean a recession in the property market or overall?
- sokoloff 4y agoThe US has had consecutive quarters of GDP decline in 2022, historically a very strong correlate with a declared recession. The National Bureau of Economic Research has not declared that the U.S. economy is in a recession, so officially/definitionally the US is not determined to be in a recession.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoThat raises the question if it's a political action. If Q1 2023 is a third consecutive quarter in GDP decline, that would seem to strongly signal a recession. Is there a formula that is followed to officially/definitionally determine is the US is in the recession? I'm not even sure how to search for the answer to this next question but I presume somewhere there has been a process used by the government in the past, so we can at least tell if current government is charting their own process.
- reducesuffering 4y agoThe negative GDP growth quarters were Q1 and Q2 2022. We already had a reversal and positive GDP growth for Q3 and Q4 2022. That would seem to portray that everyone who wanted to call a recession after Q2 2022 were premature. https://www.bea.gov/data/gdp/gross-domestic-product https://www.bea.gov/data/gdp/gross-domestic-product White House description of how NBER determine's recessions https://www.whitehouse.gov/cea/written-materials/2022/07/21/how-do-economists-determine-whether-the-economy-is-in-a-recession/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/cea/written-materials/2022/07/21/...
- coffeebeqn 4y agoBy what definition? GDP growth was around 3% for Q3 and Q4
- anonyfox 4y agoFor me it seems that some people really want to have that recession happening, even though there is no actual reason it must happen organically. Like, some media and investors really want to talk everyone into having a recession, that might actually occur if just enough people believe it and behave accordingly. And I have no idea why people might want that. I mean, we do have some smaller growth for various reasons right now, but there is no _shhrinking_ going on, which would be the important thing to call something a recession, right?
- xpl 4y ago> And I have no idea why people might want that If you can anticipate the market movements, you can profit from that (and vice versa). So maybe those investors have placed big bets on a recession but it isn't happening — and they just desperately want it to happen anyway.
- weard_beard 4y agoThere's been huge amounts of inflationary money printing. The macro market indicators are all showing that the amount of leverage, borrowing, debt, all factors point to an imminent crash. What's keeping major players from collapsing is more borrowing, creative accounting, innovative means of hiding debt, and an artificial stay on margin requirements and bills due. In, "home economic" terms, the mortgage is long overdue, behind on car payments, cell phone bills, and we're eating on credit cards. We're using our student loans to make minimum payments to keep the bill collectors happy for now, we're working on a debt consolidation loan with the bank at a reasonable rate, but it might not come soon enough. We're clearly on a knife's edge, and we don't know if things will work out. What's very clear is that this is not sustainable.
- knapcio 4y agoJust posting this as I think it may be useful to gain some perspective for this type of articles. An article from 2000 indicating soft landing: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB969020894934426807 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB969020894934426807
- UncleEntity 4y agoBecause they papered over the landing with newly created dollars — which isn’t really happening this time because they beat that horse to near death. Plus you have a lot more going on this time around which isn’t really helping with an orderly landing.
- knapcio 4y agoI do not know what may or may not happen as if I knew, I’d become very rich. My point here is that the article from 2000 indicates soft landing when the landing definitely was not soft at that time. Just wanted to show the value of such articles.
- hammock 4y agoOutside of tech it was relatively soft
- dragonwriter 4y agoThere's mixed perspectives on this because in aggregate top line terms it was relatively soft but in distributional terms both the 2001 recession and the subsequent expansion up to the Great Recession were abysmal for all but a very narrow slice at the top (which—on a higher level than the particular housing-related financial shell games that get the most focus, whuch really were just one of the ways the underlying dysfunction was papered over with debt—is pretty much the main cause of the Great Recession.)
- hammock 4y ago
- credit_guy 4y agoChatGPT changes everything. Normally with the high rates and the continued inflation we'd head to recession. But ChatGPT is our get-out-of-jail-free card. In the next few years there will be a burst of economic activity driven by new GPT bots. We have already started seeing it. But this stuff is exponential, like Covid. By the end of this year we'll see GPT applied to countless things. By next year we'll see lots of companies establishing GPT departments. We are not heading to a recession, we are heading to 4% growth. Sustained over a few years.
- newaccount2021 4y ago[dead]
- rjbwork 4y agoI definitely admire your optimism, I gotta say. It is very cool and is certainly able to produce some mind blowing artifacts, but it feels like it's going to absolutely obliterate some jobs and not really create too much new stuff. It will increase productivity in a handful of fields though. My predictions: Obliterate: Copywriters Increase Productivity: Programmers, Lawyers Create: ???
- credit_guy 4y agoYour predictions are in line with my predictions. When you say "increase productivity", what do you think "productivity" means? It means dollars. Increased productivity is increased GDP. Also, when you say "programmers". That's not just a tiny corner of the economy. It's quite a huge one. And I can see cases where the increase in productivity can be of a factor of 10 or more. I don't know about you, but I've been involved in many (too many) migration projects in my life. That's something a good GPT bot should be able to handle. How many migration projects don't take months or years? With a good GPT assistants one could envision weeks instead of months. Or how about adding unit tests to a large codebase? Or pointing at security vulnerabilities? Or commenting on the code architecture and giving improvement suggestions? Or even maybe carrying out the improvements themselves. All these things are dreams right now, but ChatGPT is just a baby. Literally 3 months old. You mentioned lawyers. But how about CAD designers. I have some friends who design interior furniture. What if they could get a first draft in a few seconds instead of hours? What if the subsequent drafts could also take seconds instead of hours? What about advertising? Here, I just asked ChatGPT to come up with ideas for a hypothetical home brew low carb beer, it gave me 10 answers in a matter of seconds. Here's a few: "Drink up, buttercup - this low-carb brew won't give you a beer belly!" "Because who needs carbs when you have beer?" "Who says you can't have your beer and drink it too? Try our low-carb option today!" As for create? Wow, sky is the limit there. I wrote a fairy tale for my 5 year old daughter a few days ago. Something with unicorns and pixies and an owl and some friendly talking trees. Of course, it was all ChatGPT. I won't bother you with some more quotes, but you can try an exercise like this on yourself, and then maybe you'll reconsider your question marks in the category "Create".
- almost_usual 4y agoThe risk is commercial real estate and corporate debt. I believe this was mentioned during the last Fed minutes.
- everybodyknows 4y agoSo does inversion of the 2-10 year yield curve. Currently -0.88%, an extremity last reached in 1981. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=10DLP https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=10DLP
- htag 4y ago> Second, buydowns fly in the face of what the Fed has been trying to do: tamping down on property purchases to bring demand and supply into better balance. This is an editorial, so the rigor is unclear. Is it actually the Fed's intention to reduce the demand for housing by raising interest rates? If so, it is short sighted to reduce short term demand for housing in a way that reduces the long term supply of housing.
- gmays 4y agohttps://archive.is/yiBV1 https://archive.is/yiBV1