9 ms·
Early-life stress can disrupt maturation of brain’s reward circuits
- swayvil 4y ago[flagged]
- yamazakiwi 4y agoWhat if your present has no substance?
- 8bitsrule 4y ago>I call it indoctrination. But but swayv, without it, what would separate the savages from the civilized? (e.g. Who would sla^h^have their whole life for their retirement? How would barrages of ads increase their needs without limit?)
- nickdothutton 4y agoThe East Germans did some very interesting research into the impact of stress and trauma (the sort of stress you expense while being area-bombed during the latter stages of WW2) on expectant mothers and their unborn children. Unfortunately this doesn’t seem to have made its way online (I suspect a lot of it was unethical, so people are unwilling to cite it). Edited for typo.
- jlawson 4y agoThere are other studies done on people who gestated and were born through the lean years of WW2 in Europe. They still have trouble with weight 50 years later, statistically. It seems like that prenatal and early starvation permanently changed how their bodies interact with food. I think there may have been a stress response difference too but can't remember exactly. Source: Why Zebras Don't Get Ulcers by Sapolsky. This whole book is about stress.
- madaxe_again 4y agoThere was a study a few years back that looked at epigenetic shifts that persist for several generations in the instance of malnourishment of a pregnant mother - I think they were looking at Indian populations from around partition - the upshot was that the offspring was much more likely to be type 2 diabetic, which makes sense from an evolutionary perspective, as if you’re going to be born into a low calorie/famine environment, having elevated blood sugar is eugenic.
- taeric 4y agoI do find more amusement over the false understanding of ulcers from the title than I should. Some examples, it turns out, just don't age well. :D
- mclightning 4y agoYeah, it did make me think "are ulcers entirely caused by ulcers?" what's the answer here?
- taeric 4y agoUlcers are known to be viral today. People literally got a Nobel for it. Used to, they were thought to be caused by stress.
- crtified 4y agoIt may be gross oversimplification to say "if your formative years teach you that things suck, then you will expect things to suck (and will behave accordingly) forevermore...".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xattt 4y agoIf things suck now, waiting won’t matter later so do what’s in front of you now.
- conqrr 4y agoDepends on what particular "stress and adversity" from early life/ ELA from article. From what we have learnt from Spirituality and all of the wise philosophers, that sounds contradictory. Most of the teachings of philosophy point to adversity and stress as events from which we can learn from and become more stronger mentally. It's possible that always being in this state of stress can morph your worldview to always be broken, and perhaps that is what's being referenced and reflected here.
- nostrebored 4y agoLook at adversity in real life and tell me it makes mentally stronger people. Some people become very mentally tough, but this is a projection of physical resistance training onto your brain. Note that basically nobody does this. Very few people decide to put themselves into adverse circumstances and fewer still do it to benefit their brain.
- gary_0 4y ago> decide to put themselves into adverse circumstances If you've knowingly put yourself there, it's much less likely to be genuinely traumatic. It's only when someone finds themselves trapped in an unexpected and undesired negative situation that real trauma manifests. A roller-coaster ride and an auto wreck might have the same physical effect but very different psychological effects.
- conqrr 4y agoAnecdotal, also I admit I don't know what the exact range of adversity here is. But from all the immigrant friends I have living in the US and the ones who aren't here, a lot of them come from 'living on the street' environments from South Asia. Their attitude to life is to make it work no matter what and they are stoic. Their drive is something one would aspire to. Inability to take an action isn't an option or a natural state they can be at. I cannot help but compare them to Western born folks and see the stark difference in approaching everything to life.
- zmgsabst 4y agoThe US Marines literally sell themselves on “develop a fighting spirit”, overcoming obstacles, etc. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=x29Y38mfsxw https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=x29Y38mfsxw https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=O9gTAjbiQEM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=O9gTAjbiQEM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yotXRoLxFdY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yotXRoLxFdY
- SoftTalker 4y agoThis has been known for a long time. It's why poverty becomes generational and poor people tend to be unable to save money, even a little bit. They cannot comprehend a future in which they have money, so they spend what they get as soon as they get it.
- darkarmani 4y agoIt hasn't been known for a long time. Did you read the article? > “We know that early-life stress impacts the brain, but until now, we didn’t know how,” Baram said. “Our team focused on identifying potentially stress-sensitive brain pathways. We discovered a new pathway within the reward circuit that expresses a molecule called corticotropin-releasing hormone that controls our responses to stress. We found that adverse experiences cause this brain pathway to be overactive.”
- SoftTalker 4y agoYes, I meant the behavior pattern has been known, not the bio-chemical cause. Read A Framework For Understanding Poverty by Ruby Payne. It explains this phenomenon and the book dates to the 1990s. Basically that the stress of growing up in poverty stunts your ability to plan for the future and you choose immediate gratification over longer-term strategic saving.
- zmgsabst 4y agoThis reeks of bias. I’m always leery of “the poors are dumb!” as if that’s self-evident, rather than in poverty the risk-reward trade off is different and they accordingly adapt to that — as a rational choice. Do you think escaping poverty is as simple as “just save money, dummy!”
- p1necone 4y agoYep, if you're earning something approaching fuckall no amount of saving is ever going to bring you out of poverty, so why would you not just spend spare income on stuff that's enjoyable now instead. The only way a lot of people can break the cycle is to earn more, not spend less - because spending less of fuckall still leaves you with fuckall.
- haswell 4y agoIt's exciting to read about new discoveries like this. It suddenly sheds light on my own lived experience, confirming what has always felt true, and I hope new treatments will come from this. I've been on a long term therapy journey for C-PTSD stemming from childhood trauma, and there's a part me that has always felt like I should be past all of that now that I'm some decades beyond that environment. There's part of your brain that tells you it's your problem, and won't accept that the mindset was deeply embedded before you even understood what was going on, or that other modes of existence are possible. The built-in pessimism has served me well in some professional capacities, but when this permeates all aspects of thinking, things do not go well in the long run. I'm on a much better path now, and meditation/yoga/some useful parts of Buddhist philosophy (and a really good therapist) are opening my eyes to new ways of thinking. But it has been a long and often painful journey.
- 300bps 4y agoSomeone on HN many years ago recommended the book, “Learned Optimism” and said it was life-changing for them. Read it, did the work. It was life changing. Seven years now with 0 anxiety after decades of having moderate to severe anxiety.
- hirvi74 4y agoI think I might purchase this book. I have seen it mentioned on here a few times before. If you do not mind, how did the book actually help you? Obviously, please do not feel obligated to answer if you are uncomfortable. I personally have found therapy to be nothing more than a substantial waste of time and money with perhaps a dash of cathartic release. Before anyone suggests that I need to "find the right one." I've seen around 14 different providers in about 12 years -- just doesn't work for me.
- Kye 4y agoOne advice I've heard is to learn about the different types of therapist and focus on finding one whose method (and there are a lot!) clicks with you. It's very possible all of those 14 providers used methods that didn't work for you.
- sublinear 4y agoYeah this can't be a hard rule on how brains develop. All I have is my own experience, but there are loads of happy and successful people that came from a rough start. From that very same experience I can also say that the trend for people to leave this world the way they came in seems stronger. I think personal values and culture play the strongest role.
- madaxe_again 4y agoOne can be successful and happy, as far as others are concerned, and still have a screwed up reward system. Actually, having a screwed up reward system can promote success, as one often goes to enormous lengths to prove to oneself that one isn’t a worthless piece of shit, which is often the upshot of anhedonia.
- malka 4y ago> one often goes to enormous lengths to prove to oneself that one isn’t a worthless piece of shit, which is often the upshot of anhedonia. Alas, it is an endless run. In the end, I'll always think that I am a worthless piece of shit.
- saycleearly 4y agoThe fate of every human being is the same, not to live any longer when the final comes through. But until that magical moment, we can see our lives through a more poetical and beautiful light.I feel there is greatness in the freedom of choosing to be just happy or to suffer a tragic life.
- blue039 4y agoI am generally happy and successful. However, my childhood was filled to the gills with trauma. So much so I visited a therapist and they immediately identified it. It emerges as rampant pessimism and distrust of anyone and everyone. It's highly beneficial in the corporate world but has irreparably damaged my ability to bond with people. Which leaves me at a impasse as to whether to solve it. Given my age it's not worth it as I am well beyond my years of socializing freely.
- beedeebeedee 4y ago> The study involved two groups of male and female mice. One was exposed to adversity early in life by living for a week in cages with limited bedding and nesting material, and the other was reared in typical cages. As adults, the early adversity-experiencing male mice had little interest in sweet foods or sex cues compared to typically reared mice. In contrast, adversity-experiencing females craved rich, sweet food. It seems like mice evolved so that males who were deprived or damaged took themselves out of competition with other males by not having interest in sex and sweet foods. I suppose as a species that might make sense by cutting the losses on a damaged individual, but it is a cold logic. It is uncanny that it maps to our religious practices, where "damaged" males drop out of sexual competition and became monks (but I suppose nowadays become "incels" instead).
- germinalphrase 4y agoI’ve actually known some monks, and I’m pretty sure they would look askance at your suggestion that they became monks because they are “damaged males”.
- beedeebeedee 4y agoI agree, and in fact, I think early struggle can be a gift if it can be worked through. It can open up a whole new world of the mind that monks are able to cultivate that you cannot approach if you are preoccupied with interests in sex and food (and other hedonistic things).
- hirvi74 4y ago> I think early struggle can be a gift if it can be worked through That is a gigantic "if." I think not having to repair one's self and, instead, using said time and resources to better one's self or to work towards one's goals would be a better gift.
- spoiler 4y agoAs someone who's often contemplated whether I've made it where I am in life despite or thanks to my fucked up childhood, this really hits home. It's really difficult to look at it as a gift. It feels more like a curse that has a bunch workaround protocols in place.
- anonuser123456 4y agoI don’t like the phrase “normal reward behaviors” in this article. We don’t live in “normal” conditions relative to our evolutionary history. Maybe these responses are adaptive and provide a fitness advantage under historically normal conditions even if they appear maladaptive in the current environment.
- thomastjeffery 4y ago[flagged]
- isityouyesitsme 4y agoI think you've managed to miss the OP point entirely.
- thomastjeffery 4y agoHow so?
- hirvi74 4y ago> Maybe these responses are adaptive and provide a fitness advantage under historically normal conditions even if they appear maladaptive in the current environment. It's equally possible that the responses are maladaptive and provide a fitness disadvantage under historically normal and current conditions too. Evolution is not always well optimized, and sometimes "bugs" make it through. One just needs to be fit enough to reproduce -- nothing else matters after that.
- unixhero 4y agoSee Dr Gabor Mate about this. https://open.spotify.com/episode/2XCJAb43d6b4cNLdKS9jSw?si=vsgrwPVYRuu_evZ-iW_w7g https://open.spotify.com/episode/2XCJAb43d6b4cNLdKS9jSw?si=v... + his recent books, can be bought from Amazon
- gregwebs 4y agoI highly recommend Hungry Ghosts for anyone that wants to understand addiction (it’s an escape from pain that probably started in childhood ). You could also go straight to The Myth of Normal which has some of this information from his other works. The Joe Rogan interview was one of Rogans worst jobs interviewing- there’s a lot more depth that Mate has to give and some of it comes out in other interviews he has given. There’s a few on YouTube https://youtu.be/H9B5mYfBPlY https://youtu.be/H9B5mYfBPlY
- unixhero 4y agoI didnt find it worst at all. It was able to convey his ideas and as a result of liking the ideas so much; I bought and read all of Mate's books. The worst ones are the ones where he onlyntalks about himself. I would nominate the interview with Louis Theroux, number 835 [0]. This was an extremely wasted opportunity to talk with the best and one of our most prolific documentaries of our time. For what it's worth, these are the best ever: * 908 Leah Remini * 1609 Elon Musk * 1518 David Choe [0], https://open.spotify.com/episode/0IGHoKiXvNiWJU9S9xPpei?si=SoyHHysdTda7sZfCyM59Eg https://open.spotify.com/episode/0IGHoKiXvNiWJU9S9xPpei?si=S...
- ews 4y agoStumbling upon Gabor Mate and his book 'Scattered Minds' by literal chance made me realize not only that I had (severe) ADHD, but it that it could be traced back to interactions and stresses from my early childhood that mirrors information I had about my parents' emotional situation during that period. Since then, it has been a long journey until finding the right therapist and meds. If there is a book that has radically changed my life for the better, it is this one. I wish I knew about my condition and family history 20 or 30 years ago.
- dmclamb 4y agoThis resonates with my experience of learned helplessness, especially when instilled within the first two years of life. The analogy that comes to mind is how a baby elephant, tied to a stake, can't escape the rope and eventually accepts he is stuck where the rope lets him wander. As the elephant grows large enough to overpower the rope and walk away, he has already stopped trying, so he remains stuck. I'm not sure if this is a true story, but it stays with me. It seems reasonable to conclude there is a physical impact on brain development.
- devwastaken 4y agoIn God of war Ragnarok there is a similiar story with a whale. It is chained to a lake so long that after its bonds are removed, it will not leave.
- beebeepka 4y agoNot sure about this elephant story but this is precisely how people have been training dogs and even bears for a long time. Imagine a 500kg bear dancing for someone's amusement when the music starts. I haven't seen this in 30 years but even as a kid it seemed really wrong in many ways
- scruple 4y agoWe have twins that are approaching 4. For a long time we had a latch on the refrigerator because, shortly before they turned 2, they would get into the fridge and make a mess, leave the doors open, etc. We recently bought a new fridge and haven't put a latch on it. They don't understand that they can open it on their own yet and we haven't told them. Observing this reminded me of the elephant story and it's made me wonder if this is something that could affect them later in life.
- moremetadata 4y ago> made me wonder if this is something that could affect them later in life. There are plenty of study's that carried out experiments into learned helplessness[1,2] whats interesting now is how its being associated with things like depression [3] later on in life. I'd go so far to say people who have suicided themselves or attempted could be because of their childhood abusers and certainly in the past, there was no evidence back then and very little surveillance, so clever well connected individuals could get away with alot. I know here in the UK the Police and NHS do not investigate attempted suicides, even when they have been told. In fact, I do know a GP could tell you how to suicide yourself with off the shelf ingredients, which might seem to be against the hippocratic oath, but who is that GP prioritising, the patient they have just told to suicide themselves or their other patients? Words can be so vague especially in the legal system. I can remember my time as a toddler in Terry's nappy's with rubber pants, that chaffed the groin area, and with todays improved food standards and food diversity, access to multi vitamins, I think the younger generation will find it easier to remember their childhood. In the case of childhood abuse, some just regress or some come out fighting, the legal system is very skewed here because it only wants to punish the individual, it doesnt want to take responsibility for allowing the abuse to occur by not teaching kids law in order to avoid abuse. Even the state doesnt hold primary school teachers to account, but then the state also carries out secret experiments on kids on all ages, some of them pre-emptive in order to control individuals later on in life based on the existing theories of the day. Things might be better in the US by virtue of having private healthcare, but state healthcare like the UK's NHS enables the state to carry out more experimentation in secret. The NHS is not all that its cracked up to be, far from it, but then most users dont know nothing about healthcare which is why they are using it in the first place. All parts of the UK state data share whilst denying it until they have to come up with something called parallel construction to use a US legal term. Bottom line is, with kids every action has a reaction and some things, your beliefs they might choose to disagree with later on in life. Factors like are they kept busy with their own adult life or do they have plenty of time on their hands to reflect, will also determine how much their agree with from their childhood. Above all else, make sure you have a relationship with them so that they can talk to you. I didnt have a relationship with any adult where I could talk to them about stuff, and its only later on in life, that you come to realise especially when aware of law that criminals acts were carried out on you and other elements of your childhood were stolen. I think this is why law is not taught to kids, it keeps those pontificating lawyers and judges in employment, but it doesnt tackle the causes of crime, it just enables it by keeping kids innocent and in the dark. Taking away that cotton wool you want to wrap kids in, is a very delicate matter, too much cotton wool, will set them up for exploitation later on in life, take it away too quickly and that could be traumatic if not a path that some choose to walk. Its a tightrope to walk. I'd also be wary about moving them around to different schools and different parts of the country. Its a legal form of isolation when considering how the new kid is bullied at school often overseen by teachers and can be used to isolate people later on in life. Its probably why the Police and Military move people around, breaking down friends networks, forcing new friends networks on people. Its that divide and conqueror mentality which has existed since before Roman times. I think a good approach is to not be dictatorial, which can be simple instructions of dont do this, dont do that, be quiet without the explainantions in a concept understandable format. Thats hard when kids are young, but explain why something can or cant be done. That was harder in the past because there was no internet, but with the internet today, its easier to find out things. Example, putting things in mouths, explaining the concept of germs and how some of them like bacteria can go dormant in the body (biofilms) desite antibiotics and some viruses never leave the body (herpes), and some viruses get into parts of the body where the adaptive immune system cant go and importantly, clinicians cant test for their existence except at the time of autopsy. I know the medical profession like to portray themselves as experts, but if you look at how medical theories are being rewritten all they time especially now when new tech becomes available or cheaper to use to allow more testing and data acquisition occurs, that's when you realise even dominant personalities can skew the interpretation of data. [1] 1975 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1150935/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1150935/ [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=Learned+helplessness https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=Learned+helplessness [3] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11522522/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11522522/
- runsWphotons 4y agointeresting but also in mice
- gigatexal 4y agoSeems more and more that a parent's sole role is to protect their child from any sexual/physical/mental abuse or trauma. Speaking from experience one spends the rest of their life in therapy or otherwise dealing with it.
- iamnotsure 4y agoHumans have no reward circuits.