5 ms·
I remember reading about the Wirecard scandal when it happened, and the key learning wasn't that it was some very complex financial scam that no one could have
by paxys 4y ago
I remember reading about the Wirecard scandal when it happened, and the key learning wasn't that it was some very complex financial scam that no one could have seen coming (quite the opposite in fact), but rather that the entire state machinery – politicians, regulators, intelligence agencies, banks – was complicit in the fraud because they wanted to take credit for a German company making its name among the silicon valley elites.
A passage from the article:
> On February 18, 2019, Germany’s financial regulator, known as BaFin, issued a ban on creating new short bets against Wirecard, citing the company’s “importance for the economy.”
> The same day, prosecutors in Munich confirmed to a German newspaper that they had opened a criminal investigation. But they weren’t going after Wirecard—they were going after the F.T.
- andix 4y agoThey were probably not complicit in the fraud. They just looked the other way, because a scam in that scale was unthinkable for them. As far as I know there are no cases of bad faith or corruption known. They „just“ didn’t do their job carefully enough.
- whatshisface 4y agoIf that's the public attitude it's going to keep happening.
- andix 4y agoSure, but technically you need to know about the fraud, or at least that you are doing something wrong, to be complicit in it. I think they genuinely though they were doing the right thing.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>I think they genuinely though they were doing the right thing Your job as a government regulator/agency isn't "to believe", it's to be impartial, do your due diligence and apply the law indiscriminately. Selectively looking the other way is blatant corruption. Ask any accountant at any company. They double check everything. If you miss something and fuck up you can't just tell your boss "well, I didn't check it because I believed there couldn't be anything wrong here". It doesn't matter what you believe, your job is to check.
- andix 4y agoTo commit fraud you need an intent. That’s how fraud is defined. You can’t commit fraud if you don’t intend to. Same goes for being complicit in a crime. Just by doing some things in good faith, you can’t be complicit. For example: if you help somebody carrying stolen goods, you are not a complicit, if you don’t know (and don’t have to suspect) that it’s stolen. See Wikipedia: In law, fraud is intentional deception to secure unfair or unlawful gain, … https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraud
- throwawaysleep 4y ago> If you miss something and fuck up you can't just tell your boss "well, I didn't check it because I believed there couldn't be anything wrong here". It doesn't matter what you believe, your job is to check. Fraud and conspiracy require intent. So yes, if you are accused of fraud, “I didn’t check as I didn’t suspect anything was wrong” is a defence.
- imtringued 4y agoIf you genuinely think you are doing the right thing then don't do insane things like suing the whistle blowers.
- Mizza 4y agoSelectively prohibiting certain types of bets in an allegedly "free market" system is complicity regardless of knowledge. Rules for thee but not for me!
- usrusr 4y agoJust like parent wrote: complicit for wanting to take credit, not (necessarily) complicit for participation in a material sense. They wanted to believe, wanted to believe very hard.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>They „just“ didn’t do their job carefully enough. How is selectively not doing your job carefully enough a.k.a. looking the other way, different than corruption? That's literally corruption. You bribe people or pull strings for authorities to look the other way when you comit your illegal activities.
- lqet 4y agoA similar thing happened with FlowTex [0]. FlowTex was founded in 1994 by Manfred "Big Manni" Schmider [1, second on the right] and Klaus Kleiser as a business for selling horizontal drilling machines. After a few years, they claimed to have sold over 3000 machines, each for 1.5 million marks. In reality, they had only sold around 270. They sold non-existing machines to leasing companies and immediately leased them back, without ever delivering the machines. This made it look like there was actually demand for these machines, which encouraged banks to give FlowTex more loans to buy (non-existing) machines. When the banks wanted to see the machines, they showed them a few in one hall and then served dinner. During dinner, they replaced the serial numbers on the machines, drove them to the next hall, showed them again to the bank representatives, created another disruption, replaced the serial numbers again, and so on. This went on for years. When the scam collapsed in 2000, "Big Manni" was living in a palatial mansion on 15 acres of land [2], had houses in Cannes, Miami, Ibiza and St. Moritz, and owned a 55 meter yacht that previously belonged to the prince of Brunei. He had 2 private jets and a helicopter to fly him 10 km to work every day. In total, FlowTex had received over 4 billion DM (over 2 billion euros) of loans for buying fake machines. It quickly became clear that people in the ministry of finance and the tax office knew about the scam for years and did nothing to stop it. FlowTex paid taxes on the money "earned" from selling the fake machines to the leasing companies, politicians were proud to have such a successful company in their home state, and he was a large donor to the governing parties. I recall seeing a documentary once where it was hinted that even people inside the banks at least suspected it, but profited from provisions for giving out the loans and did not raise any alarms. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FlowTex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FlowTex [1] https://www.bbheute.de/fileadmin/news/56352147.jpeg https://www.bbheute.de/fileadmin/news/56352147.jpeg [2] https://www.durlach.org/data/media/35/flowtex2.jpg https://www.durlach.org/data/media/35/flowtex2.jpg
- sva_ 4y ago> the entire state machinery – politicians, regulators, intelligence agencies, banks – was complicit in the fraud because they wanted to take credit for a German company making its name among the silicon valley elites. I like how we all seem to accept this as a fact, like Germany couldn't actually have a great financial company, and seem to completely ignore the possibility of good old real corruption. But yeah, corruption luckily doesn't exist in this country.
- blibble 4y ago> I like how we all seem to accept this as a fact, like Germany couldn't actually have a great financial company what, Deutsche Bank doesn't count?
- Kalium 4y agoWhen you're looking for a national champion fintech company, a 150-year-old stodgy bank doesn't quite fit the bill
- WeylandYutani 4y agoIn the Netherlands stodgy banks are responsible for 80% plastic card use, SEPA instant money transfers and internet banking.
- jgalt212 4y agoI think you should probably poll some current and former DB employees on this one.
- blibble 4y agoI guess obvious sarcasm isn't so obvious
- throwaway2037 4y agoThe commercial side of DB is rock solid. They are considered a powerhouse corporate lender, deeply embedded within the German economy. On the whole (compared to other highly advanced economies), Germany companies prefer to borrow money from corporate banks directly, instead of issue bonds. (The aversion to capital markets in Germany is bizarre to me.) And corporate borrowers prefer a national champion, rather than a foreign competitor. (Massive lending [infra, etc.] that requires syndicates of commercial banks are another story.) On the other hand, the investment bank side of DB... Sigh, that is another story. Wildly incompetent management. (See also: Credit Suisse) I cannot believe that the regulator or Bundestag (Parliment) did not force them to spin out the IB. If the corporate bank sinks with the IB, it would cause serious economic damage in Germany.
- steveBK123 4y agoRegulatory capture & open transparent fraud are not necessarily a new or new or unique combination.
- dmix 4y agoThe golden child is often given the benefit-of-the-doubt in human culture. Especially when people bet their horse on them being the golden child. And especially in tech (humans inherently love their popular stories and stereotypes). It makes it easy for the golden-child to skate off their early reputation for years, before it comes time to really ask whether they became the golden-adult everyone expected them to become.
- steveBK123 4y agoYes. WeWork, Theranos, FTX, RE bubble era banks, Dotcom tech, etc. Really just go back and read a "30 under 30" or "40 under 40" list 5 years later and I'm sure you'll find a handful on the list, every time.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoThe difference is that other than Theranos, none of those had politicians backing them up and protecting them from regulatory investigations like Wirecard had.
- paxys 4y agoTheranos didn't either. There were a few influential people on the board, but they were more for providing prestige and legitimacy in front of investors and customers than pulling any strings in the government. The FDA and other agencies more or less did their job (which wasn't enough, but that's how regulation works in general in the USA).
- red-iron-pine 4y agoTell me again about all of that money that FTX donated, and then tell me there weren't politicians backing them up
- dmix 4y ago> but rather that the entire state machinery – politicians, regulators, intelligence agencies, banks – was complicit in the fraud because they wanted to take credit for a German company It's interesting how The New Yorker still made the "links to Russian intelligence" the lead in their headline. Foreign boogiemen are always more palatable than blaming regular old politicians/businessmen domestically. Or at least the more juicy tidbit for clickbait.
- jjoonathan 4y ago> It's interesting how The New Yorker still made the "links to Russian intelligence" the lead in their headline. Foreign boogiemen are always more palatable than blaming regular old politicians/businessmen domestically. Or at least the more juicy tidbit for clickbait. I don't see Russia anywhere in the headline, only a passing mention in the subheadline after mentioning the German elite and a facade of innovation. The subheadline correctly prioritizes the two according to how they appear in the story, in the exact manner which you suggest it does not. Lol. You, on the other hand, were very quick to "Russia Hoax!" post. Agenda much?
- dmix 4y agohttps://i.imgur.com/uXJRq74.png https://i.imgur.com/uXJRq74.png It's relevant you think anyone questioning this well established instinct by national papers is pro-Russian though. Pretty standard these days. I don't feel the need to defend my support of Ukraine or being anti-Russia or w/e, I've done that enough elsewhere. I tend to give HN enough credit where I don't feel the need to make that sort of thing apparent (similar to using /s for the subset who always miss the obvious). But I guess nuance is potentially lost among Twitter-brained social media users which risks derailing threads.
- jjoonathan 4y agoYour post was a knee-jerk repeat of a very common conservative talking point. It had no nuance to lose.
- Paradigma11 4y ago