6 ms·
Nvidia predicts AI models 1,000,000X more powerful than ChatGPT within 10 years
- A_D_E_P_T 4y agoAs Scott Alexander at ACX recently said: "AGE OF MIRACLES AND WONDERS: We seem to be in the beginning of a slow takeoff. We should expect things to get very strange for however many years we have left before the singularity. So far the takeoff really is glacially slow (everyone talking about the blindingly fast pace of AI advances is anchored to different alternatives than I am) which just means more time to gawk at stuff. It’s going to be wild." Any model even just one or two orders of magnitude more powerful than ChatGPT is going to make for a wild future. 10^6x is hard to imagine. And the implications for the philosophy of mind are staggering.
- throwuwu 4y agoIt always seems slow until you’re on the right hand side of the elbow
- sdwr 4y agoThese are the days of miracle and wonder This is the long-distance call The way the camera follows us in slo-mo The way we look to us all
- r9295 4y agoGod, I love Paul Simon
- uejfiweun 4y agoGradually, then suddenly.
- nirav72 4y agoWhen I read words like singularity or AGI..is when I know we’re at peak hype and correction is coming. I just hope its not another AI winter. Because I’d still like to see this area continue to grow.
- nojvek 4y agoThe advances every week in papers in models, more TFLOPs per dollar per GPU, larger datasets, more VC billions being invested, more humans tinkering. It’s definitely going to be wild next decade. AI superiority is now a nation race like being first to moon, first nuclear bomb. Whoever cracks it gets many trillions added to their GDP.
- tim333 4y agoIt's hype for decades until it happens and then not so much. (https://waitbutwhy.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/Intelligence2.png https://waitbutwhy.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/Intelligen...)
- fidgewidge 4y agoIn this case "powerful" means faster chips. It's not clear that this translates into 1,000,000 smarter given that current AI might end up bottlenecked on availability of text and information to train it on. I guess if you could speed things up by a million-fold though, you could have way bigger context windows and you could potentially set a LLM talking to itself as it explores a problem through web search, writing and running programs, etc. Exciting times.
- pixl97 4y agoIf I had to make a guess, I would think that text based LLMs will run into that wall sooner than later. But the rapid increase in compute availability wouldn't limit us to text either. Also imagine the models working on image input, sound data, video, temperature, touch, and whatever other inputs you could encode and present to them. This brings it more in line with the human experience of inputs.
- CharlesW 4y agoThis is hyperbolic, of course. But it makes Kurzweil's 2045 prediction of the singularity not as outlandish as it first seemed. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/reaching-singularity-may-be-humanitys-greatest-and-last-accomplishment-180974528/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/reaching-s...
- oneoff786 4y agoStill outlandish. Not especially well defended either.
- meowface 4y agoWe're far enough away from 2045 that it seems hasty to completely discard it as outlandish. But, yes, unlikely.
- karmakaze 4y agoHe predicts 2029 as when machines will pass a "valid Turing test", one that goes for hours.
- abudabi123 4y agoCould Ai learn from 3D mapping daytime soap operas and trace character development along the narrative arc? Then it has to function in the real world.
- shsbdncudx 4y agoI imagine it could. Something for it to contend with though is that our published media, soap operas, reality tv, so and so, don’t really reflect what we humans are like in real life. They’re caricatures of us.
- machiaweliczny 4y agoBut instagram/tiktok has real data + you messages, people you know and talk to and listens to you 24/7. If they will be able to predict 1B of humans and social dynamics then I guess it’s enough of training data to basically simulate reality. EDIT: it gives insane “soft” power so pretty sure NSA etc. are working on this
- brokenmachine 4y agoImagine the power of 1,000,000 tiktok videos! That would really be simulated reality.
- weinzierl 4y agoNot saying it could no be true, but that's exactly what a company like Nvidia would say. Do we have any reasonably unbiased info on what the boundaries of the current approach are and when we will reach them?
- rhtgrg 4y ago"More powerful" here just means larger (another commenter says faster chips, but you don't even need that if you spend the next ten years training a model, although that could be a more accurate representation of what Nvidia is trying to say, since the alternative is a no-brainer). AI isn't really "smart," and it seems unlikely we're going to get there anytime soon (in other words, the "singularity" is still firmly out of our grasp). What we're seeing today is the fruit of training models with large swaths of data, and the limits of this approach are predictably based on the availability of such data and the resources required to convert them into these gigantic models. Framed in those terms, the "limit" we should be considering ought to be more about utility than how many resources we can afford to throw at models that might ultimately have no use. Discussions around these topics tend to get dramatized, though. In my opinion we haven't made a lick of qualitative progress in recent years in the "IQ" of AI, but we do get better at utilizing what we have, and making quantitative progress in building ever larger models.
- pixl97 4y agoPlease lay out your definition of smart? For the task they are given, take textual tokens as input and make coherent output, the models seem 'smart enough' for me. The problem here is all the text in the world is still one dimension of information. The emergence of human intelligence, at least I believe, isn't from one dimensional information, but from being able to get feedback and prune the bits of information that are inconsistent with reality. There is no continuous feedback loop in our current LLMs to prune/down weight bad information in that fashion that the mind works in. There is also the "the LLM universe is what humans tell it", if we feed it bad data that's incorrectly weighted, then we'll get bad output. There is currently no scientific method model internal for the AI to test its predictions on reality. I believe all the above issues are solvable, but no idea on the time and resources necessary to accomplish them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- epups 4y agoThere is not enough written text to scale a model like ChatGPT at even 10x its current parameters, so improvements will have to come from optimizations and/or longer training (at diminishing returns).
- motoxpro 4y agoEnough data wont really be a problem. https://us.sganalytics.com/blog/2-5-quintillion-bytes-of-data-generated-everyday-top-data-science-trends-2020/ https://us.sganalytics.com/blog/2-5-quintillion-bytes-of-dat... I wouldn't be surprised if we create more data in one year than is in the entire internet from the start
- KeplerBoy 4y agoquintillion bytes of social media probably have very limited value.
- junglistguy 4y agook
- Alifatisk 4y agoWell said
- Temporary_31337 4y agoTranslation: nVidia is talking up the hype that can increase its stock price (now that the cryptocurrency hype is over)
- simooooo 4y agoYou could apply that to any announcement by any company
- ncr100 4y agoSounds like a business plan to me. /s
- olivermuty 4y agoSausage company predicts the world to have sausage for dinner five times a week in 2030! Hah
- signatoremo 4y agoDo you think it’s all hype and no substance? Any opinion of how much is hype, and how much is real?
- brhsagain 4y agoI have a probably really stupid question but I'm going to ask it because I really don't know the answer. What's stopping someone from starting a distributed effort to train an open source ChatGPT model, like Folding@home but for AI? Is it a technical limitation with how models are trained, difficulty of coordination, something else?
- code-is-code 4y agoTraining in parallel on more then one GPU is pretty hard. Distributing the training over many random computers and adding at least some kind of validation, seems to kill the performance. So it would always be easier to rend cloud GPUs.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoBut would it be cheaper?
- zamadatix 4y agoThe models are extremely large to ship around, sync, and load on consumer hardware over the internet. Maybe there are better ways to build and train a model for a distributed use case though.
- zirgs 4y agoThe model that's used by Stable Diffusion is only around ~4 GB in size.
- nassimsoftware 4y agoIs there a point where those AI models could plateau and adding more parameters or data will not improve them anymore?
- ghostk 4y agoWithout changing the architecture in a significant manner/using more training data, there does come a point where adding more parameters will result in no gain (and sometimes even worse results). There's also a consequence of performance by adding more params. The inference time will be longer and even just training the model will take longer and won't be able to run as many epochs in an efficient manner.
- deterministic 4y agoIt currently looks as if all AI’s trained on internet texts basically become really good simulators of toxic people on the internet. Full of gas lighting, lies, extremisms etc. So perhaps maybe the goal should be to make better AI’s rather than “more powerful” toxic people-on-the-internet simulators?
- Lockal 4y ago1,000,000X more posts about ChatGPT successors on HN main page? Who would have thought! (great time to use https://lobste.rs/ https://lobste.rs/)
- d4rkp4ttern 4y agoOk I’ll be the one to ask — 1,000,000x means what, exactly?
- brokenmachine 4y agoWell it's certainly a lot more than 1,000x that's for sure!
- jarbus 4y agoI'm wondering how this is going to be different than self-driving, where we can get 90% of the way there, but the last 10% is notoriously difficult with not nearly enough edge cases represented in the data