14 ms·
Mysterious object is being dragged into the black hole at the Milky Way’s center
- chmod600 4y agoHow do things in space end up pulled into each other? If big object A pulls small object B with gravity, wouldn't B just speed up and then miss, ending up in some kind of orbit? Like, if you are in space and throw a rock at the Sun, it won't hit unless you perfectly counteract the relative speed, right?
- laserlight 4y agoThat's right, as explained in the following minutephysics video (3 minutes): Hitting the Sun is HARD. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHvR1fRTW8g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHvR1fRTW8g
- lisper 4y agoYou can tell that there must be something wrong with your reasoning by observing that meteorites regularly impact earth. You are correct that it is not easy to make things collide in space. But it's (obviously) not impossible. The trajectory doesn't have to be perfect, just close enough that the lowest point in the orbit is less than the radius of the object being orbited. In the case of a supermassive black hole, that's a pretty big target. The event horizon of Sgr A* is about 50 million kilometers in diameter, and that is surrounded by an accretion disk that acts kind of like an atmosphere, so anything that comes close gets slowed down through friction, and then it eventually falls in. (Also, near black holes, general relativity makes things kinda weird.) > if you are in space and throw a rock at the Sun, it won't hit unless you perfectly counteract the relative speed, right? If you are out in space in orbit around the sun this is true. But there are lots of ways to be "out in space" not in orbit around the sun. The reason that most of the stuff we see is in orbit around the sun is that the stuff that is not in orbit around the sun doesn't stick around very long. It either flies off into deep space, or it falls into the sun.
- darkerside 4y agoHmm, the meteorite never reaches the core of the Earth. It just happens to explode on contact with the massive crust that's constantly rotating around it. Similarly, that rock would be pulverized by the heat of the Sun before it ever came to a rest at its center. Assuming of course that you could "throw" that rock hard enough to counter our massive rotational velocity.
- dotnet00 4y agoIt'd speed up and miss, but say it passes through a cloud of gas which acts as drag and slows it down a little, now it misses the body slightly less, keep this going for a few thousand years and its lost enough energy relative to the first body that it can't keep 'missing' anymore and collides/falls in. They're essentially counteracting that relative speed over time by bleeding energy to all sorts of drag (one exotic example that comes to mind is with things like neutron stars and black holes bleeding out vast amounts of energy in gravitational waves - literal waves in space-time we can detect from billions of light years away - in the moments before they crash into each other).
- imglorp 4y agoClickbait headline, due to lack of mystery. Comment from an astronomer saying they have known for 20 years what this X7 cloud is. https://old.reddit.com/r/science/comments/11bk0u1/a_mysterious_object_is_being_dragged_into_the/j9yq00e/ https://old.reddit.com/r/science/comments/11bk0u1/a_mysterio...
- taylorius 4y agoA pallet piled high with unsold copies of Harry's blockbuster new book, "Spare"?
- antihero 4y ago[flagged]
- grishka 4y agoI'm getting a 403 both with and without a VPN.
- 00F_ 4y agocan someone flag this post for its stupid title? the object is not mysterious, they say what it probably is right at the start of the article. i see the mods change titles like this all the time. i dont think this should be an exception. this is really frustrating!
- nazgul17 4y agoDoes this mean that Sagittarius A* will become active once again (in the tone it takes for the orbit to decay)?
- sinuhe69 4y agoReminds me of the Void novels of Peter Hamilton. The black hole is in reality an artificial world, constructed by an ancient civilization to investigate the purpose of life. Enormous amount of energy is needed to run the world simulation inside, that why the “black hole” needs to expand to consume other star systems.
- darkerside 4y agoI wonder if our universe looks like a black hole to the universe contained in other black holes
- bluebluetimes 4y agoIs this a star that's collapsing into the massive black hole as it's 50x size of earth? What is unique about this object and why isn't there a better understanding of its origins given how advanced our understanding of black holes and life cycle of celestial objects like stars
- pixl97 4y agoI think of it as the difference between understanding a lot about water and knowing it's made of hydrogen and oxygen versus building a microscope that can actually see the molecules and atoms interact. You can predict a lot of the behaviors via understanding the macro effects of these objects, but when you can finally the (scale considered) micro effects you may observe some deviations from your theoretical expectations.
- Moral_ 4y agoIs it a balloon? /s “One possibility is that X7’s gas and dust were ejected at the moment when two stars merged,” Ciurlo said. “In this process, the merged star is hidden inside a shell of dust and gas, which might fit the description of the G objects. And the ejected gas perhaps produced X7-like objects.” This is pretty interesting, so much ejection due to a merger that the light is no longer visible. Space stories like this always melt my mind because this has all happened already , but we're observing it now.
- koheripbal 4y ago> this has all happened already , but we're observing it now. In a real sense, it only happens when the light from it reaches you. Reality propagates at the speed of light.
- pixl97 4y agoCausality is fun. The order in which things happen can be different for different observers. With light on earth humans don't generally experience this because of the small distances involved. But you can design an experiment with sound where 3 observers are placed in a large field and 3 loud noises are made, and each observer will tell you the noises occurred in a different order.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- prettyStandard 4y agoI think about this often. Is this reality's "update loop"[0]? [0] https://gameprogrammingpatterns.com/game-loop.html https://gameprogrammingpatterns.com/game-loop.html
- Eupraxias 4y agoMy head tilted at the title. I suppose "Mysterious object WAS dragged into the black hole a super long time ago..." doesn't have as much sizzle.
- hnthrowaway0315 4y agoWish I could see it as close as possible outside of the Schwarzschild radius.
- pixl97 4y agoEven on a 'quiet' black hole I feel the ergosphere is filled with enough high energy particles traveling near the speed of light that you would quickly turn from an observer into high energy x-rays.
- wincy 4y agoInteresting concept, how close could we get to Sagittarius A* without being melted even if we were in a spaceship that was 100 feet sphere thick sphere of lead? I feel like the distance would be way further than you’d expect.
- not2b 4y agoThere's no shielding against tidal force, which will rip apart anything that gets close enough. It's gravity. It's proportional to the inverse cube of the distance. Get twice as close, eight times as much tidal force trying to pull your head and your feet in opposite directions. Lead won't help.
- hnthrowaway0315 4y agoYeah I guess it doesn't have to be super close. Then sell tickets to zillionaires: a lifetime adventure - date with the black hole! Are you ready for the pull?
- peteradio 4y ago[flagged]
- ck2 4y ago26,000 light years is a freaking long way away. The fact we can determine -anything- is mind blowing.
- mati365 4y agoMaybe it is smaller blackhole with gas around itself
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- detrites 4y agoGiven the centre of the Milky Way is about 26000 light years away, shouldn't the title read "was" instead of "is being"? And if so, wouldn't adherence to HN's context policy require suffixing with a "(23977BC)"?
- baq 4y agoIt happened there then. We see it happen here now. We couldn’t have known about it in any other way, so for us it doesn’t really matter that it was there then.
- ericrallen 4y agoWhen will then be now?
- krapp 4y agoSoon.
- jjulius 4y agoWhen will soon be then?
- canadiantim 4y agoNow.
- geerlingguy 4y agoThis sounds like an excurb1a video.
- ricksunny 4y agoIt's a brilliant reference to Spaceballs https://youtu.be/5drjr9PmTMA https://youtu.be/5drjr9PmTMA
- stevespang 4y ago[dead]
- mountainriver 4y agoI’m going to say what everyone is too scared to: Starship
- Trombone12 4y agoI'd wait for Genzel to comment, some of us remember the disruption disappointment of G2 which they don't seem to comment on in the article: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/acb344 https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/acb344
- hownottowrite 4y agoIt’s literally just a cloud.
- jmbwell 4y agoAnd The Cloud is just Someone Else’s Stardust…
- photochemsyn 4y agoAs NASA notes: > "...the Sun - in fact, our whole solar system - orbits around the center of the Milky Way Galaxy. We are moving at an average velocity of 828,000 km/hr. But even at that high rate, it still takes us about 230 million years to make one complete orbit around the Milky Way!" It takes a vast amount of energy for a stable orbiting body to reach the center of mass of the object it is orbiting around, for example that's why the small Parker Solar Probe (launched 2018) required the massive Delta 4 heavy rocket to provide the boost energy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AlyuSwRSVHU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AlyuSwRSVHU So, 'dragged' isn't really the right way to think about it, is it? If two stars collided there must have been some massive energy input into the X7 object which accelerated it towards the black hole (it might instead have been accelerated away from the black hole, depending on the dynamics of the collision). Hence, 'it was shoved towards the black hole' is perhaps a more accurate view than 'it is being dragged by the black hole'.
- whatshisface 4y agoIt's not tugged towards the black hole in a straight line - the word "dragged" fits best if you interpret it like the drag on an airplane, something that's impeding the movement of the body and sucking energy away.
- photochemsyn 4y agoI suppose a lot depends on the frame of reference, but if this came about from two stars colliding, it seems safe to assume these two stars were in relatively stable orbits around the galactic center. Those orbits were stable because of the dragging effect of the black hole, much like Earth's orbit is stable because of the dragging effect of the Sun. If the Earth smacked dead-on into another Earth orbiting in the opposite direction around the sun, I imagine most of the combined mass would start falling into the sun due to net loss of momentum, although jets of material might get accelerated further out into the solar system, as well as inwards. In that case 'dragged' might make more sense. The case for two stars seems more complicated, they start orbiting each other before merging, which could be a very energetic event if they were large enough, i.e. a 'merger-triggered core collapse supernova'.