17 ms·
Signal says it'll shut down in UK if Online Safety Bill approved
- steponlego 4y agoDoes Signal still "need" your phone number?
- pas 4y agoyes. probably that's how they keep spam to a minimal.
- steponlego 4y agoHow's that make sense?
- leshenka 4y agoIt's harder and more expensive to mass-register with phone numbers. With one e-mail server you're essentially your own service provider with practically infinite amount of addresses for mere $5 a year.
- xboxnolifes 4y agoBarrier of entry.
- stiltzkin 4y agoThere has been other ways to fight spam.
- sjy 4y ago> The legislation contains what critics have called “a spy clause.” It requires companies to remove child sexual exploitation and abuse (CSEA) material or terrorist content from online platforms “whether communicated publicly or privately.” As applied to encrypted messaging, that means either encryption must be removed to allow content scanning or scanning must occur prior to encryption. This is not accurate. The “spy clause” (section 110) allows Ofcom to issue notices, if it is “necessary and proportionate” to do so, which could have that effect. In deciding what is “necessary and proportionate” Ofcom is specifically required to consider things like “the kind of service it is,” “the extent to which the use of the specified technology would or might result in interference with users' right to freedom of expression” and “whether the use of any less intrusive measures than the specified technology would be likely to achieve a significant reduction in the amount of relevant content” (section 112). This decision can be legally challenged. The difference is important. Every country has a system that allows police to legally break into your home and search it – if a legal authority decides that it is necessary and appropriate. Whether such powers are abused depends not only on the text of the law, which is often as vague and open to interpretation as the Fourth Amendment, but also on the prevailing culture of the government and its judicial and law enforcement bodies. That’s why Signal’s president acknowledges that they are responding to a hypothetical. While she won’t speculate on the probabilities, there are precedents which inform us about the probability that a democratic government would use these powers to break a popular secure messaging system over the reasoned objection of its users and developers. This law could achieve its goal of increasing public control over Big Tech’s content moderation policies without being used in that perverse way. Such perverse outcomes have not yet arisen under the controversial Australian laws which generated similar comments from Signal [1] and HN users [2] in 2018. [1]: https://signal.org/blog/setback-in-the-outback/ https://signal.org/blog/setback-in-the-outback/ [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18636076 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18636076
- brokenmachine 4y ago>Such perverse outcomes have not yet arisen under the controversial Australian laws which generated similar comments from Signal [1] and HN users [2] in 2018. How could you possibly know this? Everything is secret under risk of jail for disclosure.
- friend_and_foe 4y agoSo I've noticed recently, signal has quick responses in message notifications now, implying that the client reads your plaintext messages.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoSecure communications and government restrictions on content are *inherently* incompatible.
- digianarchist 4y agoIt could be worse. Labour could be in government [0]. [0] - https://labourlist.org/2023/02/for-the-online-safety-bill-to-be-effective-the-government-must-grow-a-backbone/ https://labourlist.org/2023/02/for-the-online-safety-bill-to...
- b3nji 4y agoBut how? Am I being daft, how can they remove themselves from the U.K.? What's going to stop people in the U.K. from using the service? If this is possible, why is this service a good thing in the first place? Surely, we need a decentralized system free from government bullshit that runs regardless? Free from corporate control too?
- stereoradonc 4y agoI'll shed a tear
- seba_dos1 4y agoStop giving them incentives!
- mananaysiempre 4y agoSignal reportedly has some popularity among UK politicians[1,2], if I understand correctly what you’re complaining about. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/dec/17/tories-switch-to-messaging-app-signal-to-curb-whatsapp-leaks https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/dec/17/tories-swit... or https://www.theregister.com/2019/12/20/uk_conservatives_brexit_from_whatsapp_to_signal/ https://www.theregister.com/2019/12/20/uk_conservatives_brex... (same story) [2] https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/boris-johnson-and-others-in-cabinet-are-using-the-encrypted-signal-app-c6nk6l0wf https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/boris-johnson-and-others-...
- tao_oat 4y agoAlso posted yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34923075 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34923075
- largepeepee 4y ago"If you get this wrong, you’ll end up criminalizing a lot of people whose only offense is using or selling a phone that is too abnormal for the Government’s official tastes," she writes. "Either you’re an obedient consumer who uses what Samsung, Google, Apple, and Meta have to offer, or you’re a criminal. Good luck developing your moribund tech industry with that attitude." Great that more people are speaking out against govt overreach.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoGet it wrong? That's the objective, not an error!
- skrebbel 4y agoTheres just as many politicians who fall for the “save the children” pitch as there is politicians who really truly want a surveillance state. It pays to keep repeating this. There’s no conspiracy.
- whitemary 4y agoSounds like capitalist "overreach" if anything.
- orangepanda 4y agoMany of those lawmakers want to regress back to the 18th century, replacing modern banking with cholera. Not having a tech industry isn’t a threat to them, it’s the goal
- pshirshov 4y agoCan you back your opinion?
- my_city 4y agoThe UK is an authoritarian, privacy-less, censorship-rife hellhole.
- idlewords 4y agoReally more of a heckhole; let's be honest here.
- sschueller 4y agoTake a look what the EU wants to do with CSAM. Distopian nightmare to protect kids while at the same time make every single one of them a suspect.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoYeah, it's the reason da jour for getting rid of privacy. There's always a reason, it just keeps changing as people object to the old ones.
- leshenka 4y ago> Distopian nightmare to protect kids We know a little too well what "would somebody think of the childen" did to the internet in Russia.
- danjac 4y agoHaving grown up in, and subsequently emigrated from the UK, I would say that Britain is a weird place when looked at from a distance. The class system has led to a society where the middle classes consider themselves the moral guardians of the working class, while looking up at the upper classes with a mixture of contempt and envy. Middle-class right wing readers of the Daily Mail and left wing readers of the Guardian are more similar in that regard than either would like to admit. So (while coming from a different political place) both want to crack down on the evils of the internet to Protect the Children and, of course, to save the working classes from themselves (and protect their neighbourhoods: think of the property prices!). As both Conservatives and Labour need their votes, authoritarian cracking-down on issue du jour is always a good vote winner. Today it's the internet, back in the 80s it was MDMA and rave parties, back in the 1800s it was gin palaces and gambling. Same thing though: Britain's self-appointed moral guardians and their representatives in the media and parliament wagging their finger at everyone else.
- wunderland 4y agoHow would this work in practice? Would you need a proxy or non-UK VPN to access the Signal servers?
- PTcartelsLOL 4y agoI think you can use it from the UK, but it will not show up in the app stores in the UK
- wkat4242 4y agoProbably yeah. Unless they wish to block entire IP ranges from their servers. I wonder if this will finally make third-party app stores mainstream. On the other hand, signal isn't on F-droid either as it was moxie's pet peeve. But now that he's gone perhaps they'll reconsider in light of this.
- hkt 4y agoAh, politicians, consultancies, spooks, and civil servants all failing to understand cryptography. How novel. It really is a shame that we do this. It is symptomatic of an inordinate amount of ineptitude in our ruling class, and goes back centuries. It is strange to see that it is mostly the English speaking world that suffers from this, too. Why are we so different?
- idlewords 4y agoJust because people disagree with you doesn't mean they don't understand the technology.
- jesprenj 4y agoThey aren't banning cryptography. This only applies to private entities hosting conversations for other persons. This wouldn't apply to private individuals hosting their own conversation servers, let's say using encrypted XMPP.
- andai 4y agoWhile that is some comfort, it would eliminate the vast majority of encrypted communications as they exist today, no?
- teilo 4y agoAnd you think it will stay that way? It won't. This is just the start. Next, they will ban private servers and raid those who do not comply.
- gorbypark 4y agoAre you going to have a conversation with yourself? I suppose XMPP is federated, but would this ban a group of friends using the same XMPP server that's administered by one person? What about services that aren't federated? It would essentially criminalize running an instance of anything and sharing it with friends/family/others.
- hkt 4y agoThat's a huge number of people who can't access secure messaging anymore. Journalists can't run such services, and as soon as somebody does it for them they're a service provider who falls under the regulations.
- SSLy 4y agodupe https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34923075 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34923075 Signal would 'walk' from UK if Online Safety Bill undermined encryption (bbc.com)
- neverrroot 4y agoSad state of affairs. This is just one of so many things many are willing to accept in the face of “dangers”. It’s on us, and our desire to be protected from all possible things.
- antisocialist 4y agoOf course they will, because their security and privacy features would be misleading and rendered useless by this legislation. They have no choice. Resident crypto-haters can hate coin-based privacy networks all they want, but fully decentralized encrypted messaging will remain the only way to get E2EE private messaging and chat in free speech hellholes such as Iran, China, the UK, and the EU. Those organizations have no entity that does business anywhere (including the UK), and doesn't need anyone's permit to make its endpoints accessible to anyone.
- anonymousab 4y agoNothing about cryptocurrencies are needed for making a decentralized encrypted messager. That Signal has public, known contributors and servers is a choice by their developers, not something necessitated by the fact that they didn't host it on ethereum or whatever.
- tempodox 4y ago> …and doesn't need anyone's permit to make its endpoints accessible to anyone. Until exactly that is being made illegal.
- abigail95 4y agoAre they going to pull out of Iran too? Why hurt the people that you're trying to help. If this law passes they should do everything they can to increase availability of Signal in the UK.
- voxic11 4y agoYeah its weird to see this after reading https://signal.org/blog/help-iran-reconnect/ https://signal.org/blog/help-iran-reconnect/
- peterfirefly 4y agoIran doesn't have much reach outside of Iran. The UK does.
- abigail95 4y agoReach to do what? Signal is open source software. UK jurisdiction ends at its borders. If they don't like Signal they can ban their own citizens from using it. I don't understand what possible "reach" they could use to stop Signal exporting its products globally.
- peterfirefly 4y agoExtradition agreements exist. They can even be used with fictitious charges.
- tekknik 4y agoExtradition agreements also exist with Iran, they are a member of interpol
- NoImmatureAdHom 4y agoI don't imagine Signal is much concerned with complying with Iranian law. If you don't employ Iranians in Iran or operate infrastructure there, why would you care?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sbaiddn 4y agoFrom the spooks POV thats not a problem, that's a solution! (Assuming Signal isnt compromised, then its a wash)
- squarefoot 4y agoHurry! Let's approve this liberticide bill using the old "for children safety" argument before AI allows pedophiles to create their own real looking virtual child porn at home, and we run out of excuses to justify it.
- hnarn 4y agohttp://archive.today/xMtaI http://archive.today/xMtaI
- 1659447091 4y agoI wonder how much leverage Signal has here, if any. I have a friend whose partner worked at a high level in the UK Gov in the foreign affairs area. Still don't have any idea of what they did exactly, other than vague but incredibly interesting stories. They mentioned it was the app they were told to use for communication with official contacts. This was a number of years ago though.
- wyager 4y agoI wish American companies would simply start ignoring silly foreign directives and force those countries to implement internet-blocking themselves. That way, the cards are on the table, and it's clear to everyone who's actually responsible.
- kypro 4y ago[flagged]
- screamingninja 4y ago[flagged]
- btbuildem 4y agoKnowing nothing about the bill, the title of it tells me it's something that will compromise online safety -- and indeed, seems like it. The one tasty morsel here is the (unprecedented?) threat of holding corporate executives criminally liable for harms. Of course it's over something so nebulous as "would someone think of the children!?" -- I would love to see this become more of a trend over the massive harms corporations are routinely causing and getting away with.
- srj 4y agoThis is the case in some other countries already (e.g. India, Russia).
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoOf course the only time CEOs could be held responsible is over the stupidest law imaginable.
- whitemary 4y agoCorporate executives literally control the UK government.
- andsoitis 4y agoBold claim. Can you name a few corporate executives who control the UK government and in what specific ways they do?
- pleb_nz 4y agoIt wouldn't be corporate executives that control the UK government, these people come and go and without belittling the power and publicity they have, It would be the groups that own the corporations if it were anyone with true influence and power.
- legrande 4y agoWe still have choice of jurisdiction for cryptography projects. Look at Liberland[0]. So the UK is fast becoming a mini-china. Just don't do crypto projects there then. [0] https://www.vice.com/en/article/xgdj9k/inside-liberland-a-crypto-libertarian-micronation-in-eastern-europe https://www.vice.com/en/article/xgdj9k/inside-liberland-a-cr...
- xbar 4y agoCheers, UK.
- amelius 4y agoNobody actually cares about these things except HN and perhaps a few other people.
- lrvick 4y agoIf Signal was not centralized, it could not be forced to comply with anything, and also could not be withdrawn from any country. Centralization remains incompatible with privacy and censorship resistance.
- idlewords 4y agoThat's ridiculous. If Signal weren't centralized, it would long ago have split into four thousand mutually incompatible OpenSignal apps, all of which would be just as easy to ban in the UK app store.
- sschueller 4y agoLike IRC /s Only because something is decentralized doesn't mean it will scatter into an incompatible mess.
- t09i209ba893 4y agoMatrix hasn't split into thousands of mutually incompatible apps. I speculate that having a complete, "flagship" client helps prevent this.
- tptacek 4y agoThe story of the Matrix project is about the closest thing you could find to a total vindication of Moxie's original take about federation. Federation delayed the convergence of Matrix to E2E-by-default by (as I recall?†) years, and will drastically complicate their response to the Nebuchadnezzar results, which were themselves in part a complication of decentralization and loose coupling. You can coherently argue that decentralization is an important, or even necessary, goal for private communications. I won't agree, but I can productively hear that argument out. But I don't think you can cite Matrix as the counter to Moxie's point; with respect to Matrix, the more appropriate assessment of Moxie's federation argument might be "prophetic". I will never sound like it, but I'm in Matrix's corner. I see clearly where they fit into the ecosystem. The world where Matrix replaces Discourse, Slack, IRC, and Telegram is a better world. I do not see Matrix replacing Signal, or whatever post-Signal project is carrying forward their ideals 20 years from now. † A Matrix project person will be sure to correct me on this, and I call it out in part to be candid that I'm not certain about the specific duration.
- devmunchies 4y ago> Signal says it'll shut down in UK > At least Northern Ireland and Scotland will be spared. The Home Office legislative proposals, if adopted, will apply only to England and Wales So… will signal shut down in the UK or just England/Wales?
- twodave 4y agoCorporations and governments are not responsible for keeping children safe online. Parents are. It is far past the time we should have learned that letting kids interact with strangers online is no different than it is at the park or the gas station.
- CharlesW 4y agoSafety, like security, is best when layered. This bill appears to be absolute garbage, but as a parent doing my best to balance my kids' online autonomy and safety, I want the online analogue of reasonably safe roads and cars for them.