11 ms·
Please don't use large language models as a therapist.
by xena 4y ago
Please don't use large language models as a therapist.
- andai 4y agoThey work better than seven human ones I tried. Might just be my luck!
- proper_elb 4y agoI don't doubt that experience, and I also have the comparison between humans and GPT and see where you are coming from. However, the advice still stands, in my eyes. If we recommend to check even simple python for correctness, how much more should we tell people to not trust LLMs when it comes to much more complex and influential things like therapy? Also, you and some others might be able to understand the limitations of LLMs. It is the general public that I am worried about.
- andai 4y agoYes, it is extremely limited, albeit in different ways than humans are. My point was just that as a profession, they aren't currently setting a very high bar. There are always exceptional individuals, but sadly exceptional individuals can't scale to meet the needs of a society. (There's a serious shortage of therapists, teachers, etc., even counting all the lousy ones!)
- proper_elb 4y ago> My point was just that as a profession, they aren't currently setting a very high bar. I think I know where you are going, but I will be going offline for today soon, so I will be just leaving some thoughts regarding the matter. My background: Masters in CS, with a minor in Psychology. I have a psychology-ish circle of friends, some doing research, some doing therapy. I also have my fair share of negative experience with therapists due to some... uncommon combination of phenomena that require attention. - One common mistake is confusing psychology (along with the more or less recent reproducibility crisis) with therapy (which is a profession that aims to help people, with some methods being grounded in psychology, some partially so, some other not at all). - It would be weird for me to not acknowledge that there are some bad apples amongst therapists and how much it can suck being treated by one. Then again, I do not thing that the field of software development is any less diverse in the quality of output we deliver. Identifying software engineer that fulfils ones need is almost an art, maybe quite similar to finding a suitable therapist. - "Finding a suitable therapist should not be an art!" Yes, would it not be nicer if everyone instantly found a suitable therapist? It would, but that is not the reality we live in. If even finding someone who can code a decent program that meets your relatively well-defined business needs, how much harder is it to find someone who treats multiple humans, with their unique problems, biographies and current lives? - I am totally with you about the scaling issue! I am not against E-therapy and the usage of AI in it, but I think it has to be done with caution - not out of despair.
- alfor 4y agoI am building a coaching journal, could be a therapist if you change the prompting. The AI doesn’t have something else in their mind, a limited amount of time/energy for you. Like radiologists and doctors the AI will be better than most of them really quick if not already.
- sebzim4500 4y agoWould be very interesting to see whether they do better or worse than the average human therapist. My own experience suggests it might be a closer than you suspect.
- yndoendo 4y agoReligion and cults are next in the ML rabbit hole of content creation.
- hef19898 4y agoTime to re-watch the Terminator franchise and Matrix before reading up on the Butlerian Jihad, I guess. As the saying goes: Proper Planning Prevents Piss Poor Performance...
- noduerme 4y agothe people who create LLMs are just as psychotic as the ones who start cults, they just lack the je ne sais quoi to hypnotize people in person.
- celdon25 4y agoYour comment will probably get flagged but I have to admit I’m legitimately curious to find out if this holds any water.
- noduerme 4y agosnarky + opinionated !== flagged. it's okay to have a dark sense of humor; the mods aren't AIs. Yet.
- zafka 4y agoI like your "about" - So what got you hell banned for 8 years?
- noduerme 4y agoheh. yeah, I didn't realize it because sometimes I'd still get responses from one or two people who could still see my posts. Definitely slowed me down after a few years of shouting into the void. Paul Graham did me a favor, really. [edit] sorry, slightly dyslexic. so what got you was the question? Insulting Paul Graham.
- 4y ago
- hprotagonist 4y agoreturn to tradition, use emacs -nw -Q —-eval “(doctor)” as your ancestors did!
- number6 4y agoTIL: Eliza lives in Emacs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ELIZA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ELIZA
- hprotagonist 4y ago* Changes in Emacs 17 ** Frustrated? Try M-x doctor. ** Bored? Try M-x hanoi. ** Brain-damaged? Try M-x yow. ** Sun3, Tahoe, Apollo, HP9000s300, Celerity, NCR Tower 32, Sequent, Stride, Encore, Plexus and AT&T 7300 machines supported. The Tahoe, Sun3, Sequent and Celerity use 4.2. In regard to the Apollo, see the file APOLLO in this directory. NCR Tower32, HP9000s300, Stride and Nu run forms of System V. System V rel 2 also works on Vaxes now. See etc/MACHINES. and has done since ~1985!
- WithinReason 4y agowhy
- bezier-curve 4y agoReplika used GPT-3 in 2020 and it was marketed under the health section of the Google Play store.
- throwawaaarrgh 4y agoNow I want to use a language model as a therapist.
- totetsu 4y agoIf you already have some idea of what you're looking for / in need of (as in talked to a therapist in the past), these language models can be a very good workbook, sounding board, self discussion tool.
- lm28469 4y ago> self discussion tool. Self discussion as in "discussion between you and god knows who will get the data in the end" ?
- totetsu 4y agoWell yeah obviously read the TOS part about not sharing sensitive information.. in that sense it's not appropriate for therapy. But I've found it useful just keeping things general and not specific to details of my own life.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoHuggingface started as an attempt to use this stuff for therapy work. Hence their name. It's telling that they pivoted away from this verticle very quickly though!
- CamperBob2 4y agoHuh. I thought it was an 'Alien' reference.
- dokem 4y agoReally delusional to think you need to protect people from themselves. I don't get why HN puts therapy on such a pedistal.
- Levitz 4y agoGiven the difference in cost, I can't picture a future in which this doesn't happen.