6 ms·
Dark energy from supermassive black holes? Physicists spar over radical idea
- misja111 4y ago> He also says the numbers don’t seem to add up: Dark energy is known to make up 70% of the mass-energy of the universe, whereas black holes are a mere fraction of the ordinary matter, which constitutes less than 5% of the universe So it seems both the missing dark energy and the missing dark matter could both be explained for, if there were far more black holes in our universe than we're currently aware of?
- contravariant 4y agoBlack holes are a known explanation for dark matter (until recently not for dark energy, as black holes were in the end still thought of as a bunch of dense matter). There are bounds on the size and quantity of such black holes, which get increasingly tight as more data on dark matter becomes available.
- mr_mitm 4y agoPrimordial black holes used to be a dark matter candidate but have been largely ruled out. This has been extensively studied already. They'd be anything but supermassive, though. The exact opposite, to be precise.
- shagie 4y agoThe "black holes as dark matter" were termed MACHOs (massive astrophysical compact halo object) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massive_compact_halo_object https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massive_compact_halo_object Most of that has been ruled out (see the graph on http://resonaances.blogspot.com/2016/06/black-hole-dark-matter.html http://resonaances.blogspot.com/2016/06/black-hole-dark-matt... ) and while some black holes may fall into the dark matter category, the observed "if there were that many black holes, micro lensing would be this common..." The result of those tests constrains black holes to less than 1% of the calculated dark matter... though there are some windows where there is very likely active research to try to detect black holes with those masses along with the cosmological models needed to have an early universe that produces black holes of that size in that quantity. From https://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.10722v3.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.10722v3.pdf > Primordial Black Holes, in particular asteroid mass ones, remain a viable dark matter candidate. Further improve- ments in the theoretical calculations of the production and evolution of PBHs are required to reliably predict the abundance and properties of PBHs from a given model. Even so, it seems clear that a cosmologically interesting num- ber of PBHs can only be produced in specific models of the early Universe, and often fine-tuning is required. However, whether or not PBHs are a significant component of the DM is a question that has to be answered observationally. Novel ideas are needed here to either detect or rule out the remaining open parameter space. Note that we're dealing with really small ones that haven't evaporated yet. The chart on page 16 - with M PBH [g] and the X axis of 10^15 to 10^36 - that's grams. Also fun - https://github.com/bradkav/PBHbounds https://github.com/bradkav/PBHbounds which has them in solar masses
- vecter 4y agoThe remaining ~25-27% is suspected to be dark matter.
- borissk 4y agoInteresting, but quite wild hypothesis. No mechanism was proposed on how black holes store dark energy. In the end it may turn out that black holes are the source of both dark energy and dark matter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thunderrabbit 4y agoFraser Cain interviewed co-author Chris Pearson regarding the topic https://youtu.be/-8CIUzPkigQ https://youtu.be/-8CIUzPkigQ
- icare_1er 4y ago[flagged]
- badcppdev 4y agoNonsense. Inside the global warming field there are loads of different models and predictions and intense debate about different ideas. There are some outlier models that are ignored by other scientists because of their bad faith assumptions and methodology but that's true of many fields of science like quantum physics and cosmology.
- icare_1er 4y agoWrong. Scientists trying to get funding for projects exploring things like the impact of sun radiations on earth climate, have a very hard time because of the political rules that are enforced in terms of what's allowed to be looked at and what's not.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoScientists also have a hard time trying to get funding for proving that things don't fall down when you drop them.
- lanstin 4y agoScientists are also tired of arguing about the reality of evolution, perpetual motion mechanisms, flat earth, a non-plate techtonic earth and maybe other settled matters. Try to get a research fellowship for flat earth or perpetual motion and see just how ruthlessly science cuts down dead ideas. Or maybe now in Florida you can get a flat earth fellowship, the Republicans certainly seem eager to remove the benefits of our scientific learnings as fast as they can.
- badcppdev 4y agoScientists choose to argue about things like did Eukarya evolving from Archaea?Imagine having interesting debates about that [0] and then having some numpty tell you that evolution doesn't exist at all. 0 - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0960982220300105 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096098222...
- adam_d 4y ago>Dark energy is known to make up 70% of the mass-energy of the universe, whereas black holes are a mere fraction of the ordinary matter, which constitutes less than 5% of the universe. Is there some cosmological constraint that says dark energy compressed into a small volume would exhibit gravitational pull and therefore contribute to our measurements of black hole masses? If not then it feels like this is a weak counterargument that makes a pretty big assumption that dark energy must have the same mass-energy equivalence behaviour as regular energy from a general relativity perspective. If black holes somehow are the origin of dark energy, then surely this is driven by physics at energies far beyond our understanding from either particle physics or cosmology. In that case aren't basically all bets off in terms of what you'd expect to observe in terms of apparent black hole masses?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cowl 4y agoWell the whole idea is to "make it work" under the constrains of our current understanding (General Relativity). After all , all that Dark Energy is by definition is something that is Contrasting the Gravity as described by general Relativity. If we remove that fact than it doesn't need to be reconciled with anything really. Saying that it is a type of energy that doesn't behave according to general Relativity, you need to solve a much bigger problem, find the Substitute of General Relativity that would work for all cases and in that scenario maybe even Gravity is different and you don't even need Dark Energy.
- jdmichal 4y agoAre there MOND theories that attempt to account for dark energy too? Or only dark matter?
- mr_mitm 4y agoNot that I'm aware, but there are modified GR theories. In classical GR, the equations can be derived by applying the principle of least action with the Ricci scalar R being the Langrangian. People are studying what happens if you assume the Lagrangian is a function of R, like R^n or so. It doesn't have the same stigma as MoND, but it's also not that popular. It's also very hard to test for. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F(R)_gravity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F(R)_gravity
- lake_vincent 4y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong (please), but don't we still lack any kind of fundamental definition of what dark energy/matter is other than..."the cause of the difference between what is calculated, and what is observed"? To the point that we aren't even really sure that there is such a "thing" as dark matter (in that it exists in any conventional sense)? From Wikipedia: "Dark matter is a hypothetical form of matter thought to account for approximately 85% of the matter in the universe...The primary evidence for dark matter comes from calculations showing that many galaxies would behave quite differently if they did not contain a large amount of unseen matter. Some galaxies would not have formed at all and others would not move as they currently do." 85% is kind of a lot of "stuff" to be missing... I find it kind of funny that humans are so confident that our models of reality are correct that we truly think it's more likely there's just hidden "stuff" than there's just something hugely wrong with our idea of what the universe really is, and how it works. Our physics works great in a lot of circumstances, but to be missing 85% of the damn universe might imply we are wildly off base when it comes down to the true nature of things. Obviously, I don't have an explanation myself, and I understand that we can only work with the evidence we have, but I think it's a sign we need to radically rework our basic assumptions about reality, and not just look for our missing keys... Perhaps black holes are the right place to look, but not as a cubby hole for our missing stuff - rather, as a path to transforming our assumptions about reality.
- Vvector 4y ago"...humans are so confident that our models of reality are correct..." Dark Matter is just a hypotheses to explain our current observations. Future discoveries may back up dark matter, or point towards something different. This is how Science works.
- credit_guy 4y agoFrom what I understand, this has nothing to do with dark matter. It's only about dark energy, which is an unrelated concept.
- codethief 4y ago+1 In particular, dark energy is not > "the cause of the difference between what is calculated, and what is observed" Dark energy / the cosmological constant Λ is a completely natural parameter to the field equations, not a corrective term (even though it might feel that way if you follow the history of cosmology). It's not that we calculated Λ to be zero but observations forced us to set it to something non-zero. We had no clue what it's value should be and simply deduced from observations that it happens to be non-zero. End of story. Now, particle physicists / field theorists have been looking for a particle physics-based explanation for Λ and preliminarily called it "dark energy". But there's no guarantee there is one. Maybe Λ is indeed just a boring parameter.
- yipbub 4y agoIt's interesting to see the epistemological differences at the frontiers of knowledge.
- Mizza 4y agoI'm a layman, but I like this idea intuitively. It's not mentioned in the article, but this theory also necessitates that black holes aren't singularities, which gets rid of what always seemed to me like the biggest hack in physics.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoNature hides singularities :)
- syllablehq 4y agoI've always wondered if the "horizon" metaphor in event horizon was more apt than we expected - just like when you approach the earth's horizon, you don't get flattened or fall off, you just reveal more geography - I've always wondered if it were possible that as you approach an event horizon you don't get "squashed into spaghetti" but just reveal more space which is just as "normal" as the space before you approached the horizon. But caveat - i have no real reason to actually believe this is true - I'll assume for now it's just poetic.
- jerf 4y agoThe "squashed into spaghetti" occurs in "normal space" before you get to the black hole, for most black holes. It is not an effect of anything special about black holes, it's just plain ol' normal tidal effects, turned up to eleven, then turned up until the knob breaks, then turned up some more. Neutron stars will give you a bad day with tidal effects too long before you reach their surface. Very large black holes turn out not to have this, though it's going to be a long time cosmologically before there are any large black holes also quiet enough for you to get anywhere near.
- syllablehq 4y agoTo an outside observer it would look like you were torn apart by tidal forces, but would it feel that way to you? Or would you feel normal? If it's just space being curved, would you feel nothing just like you feel nothing in freefall? I'm sure this question is wrong...
- graderjs 4y agoCould the cosmic web explain dark matter/energy? Could gravity not being homogenous across universe explain dark matter/energy? What if law of gravity has other terms that only reduce to the versions we think of as true in the scenarios we've tested...but the other terms are affecting things of supermassive scale? What if there is some other "force" between things cosmically that we have never seen on the scales we've done stuff...but that we can observe (but misinterpret as dark stuff) on galactic/cosmic scales? What if quantum correlation produces a "force" among particles that's only apparent on super massive scales? If all particles used to be close together in the big bang, couldn't they have some lingering correlations? Or became correlated with movement of electricity through cosmic web?
- josu 4y ago>Could gravity not being homogenous across universe explain dark matter/energy? [chatGPT]> While it is true that gravity is not perfectly homogeneous across the universe, this alone does not explain dark matter or dark energy. Dark matter is believed to exist because of the observed gravitational effects on galaxies and galaxy clusters that cannot be accounted for by the visible matter alone. These observations suggest that there is additional matter that we cannot see, which we call dark matter. While gravity may vary in strength in different regions of the universe, this alone cannot explain the observed gravitational effects that we attribute to dark matter. Similarly, dark energy is believed to exist because of the observed accelerating expansion of the universe. While variations in gravity across the universe could play a role in this phenomenon, they cannot explain the magnitude of the effect that we observe. In summary, while variations in gravity across the universe are a real phenomenon, they cannot fully explain the observed effects attributed to dark matter and dark energy. These mysteries continue to be the subject of active research in the field of astrophysics and cosmology.
- kgwxd 4y ago“spar over radical idea”. What a fancy way to say “do science”.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ac130kz 4y agoI'm still convinced that there's a huge gap in general relativity since it seems that "dark matter/energy" with no material evidence whatsoever is exactly that final correction term.
- canjobear 4y agoDark energy is just the cosmological constant. It fits into general relativity with no problem at all.
- pseudolus 4y agoPrevious related thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34813141 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34813141
- rolenthedeep 4y agoHere's a question I'm not even remotely qualified to ask: could it be that supermassive black holes cause a contraction of local spacetime in a way that gives the impression that local space is static while distant space expands? I think this mechanism would be largely indistinguishable from classic hubble expansion, at least on local scales.
- codethief 4y agoThat's a good question and is not exactly easy to answer. The Einstein field equations of General Relativity are highly non-linear which makes it difficult to talk about superpositions of solutions to the equations and to compare local physics (at the level of black holes) to cosmological effects (e.g. the expansion of the universe) and transfer results and insights between them. Let me explain. When we talk about cosmology in general and the (accelerated) expansion of the universe in particular, we zoom out to very large scales and consider a homogenous model of the universe (a so-called FLRW spacetime[0]). Here, homogeneity means that mass density, hubble rate and so on are the same across the universe and only depend on time. We then deduce that at this scale and under these assumptions we need to incorporate an additional parameter Λ, called cosmological constant aka dark energy, into our field equations / cosmological solution in order to match observations.[1] Homogeneity was a simplifying assumption, though! Our universe is clearly not homogeneous! Next to your head, there is air, and inside your head evidently not :), and so the mass density is clearly not constant across space! The same thing holds for black holes: Outside a black hole there's vacuum, inside a black hole there is… Well, we don't really know but the mass from which it formed has gotta be somewhere, right? So the mass density in black hole spacetimes is presumably not constant, either. Interestingly, we know that spacetime near other celestial bodies (galaxies, stars, planets, moons, …) can be approximately described by one of the black hole spacetimes, too. (This is because outer region of black hole spacetimes describes not just black holes but any spherically or axially symmetric static/stationary spacetime.) So it's turtl—… uhh outer black hole spacetimes all the way down! Anyway, in those cases of stars/planets/moons we have some massive object in the center of the spacetime region and vacuum outside – once more, the mass density is clearly non-zero! So how do we square this with the homogeneity assumption of our cosmolical model (ΛCDM)? We can't but that's perfectly fine from a logical point of view. The reason is that we cannot simply take all those local spacetimes (of all stars, planets and black holes) and simply add them up to obtain the spacetime of the entire universe, because the field equations are not linear. Adding up two solutions does in general not yield a third solution! Conversely, we cannot simply zoom in on the FLRW spacetime and then compare a local, perfectly homogeneous "snippet" of FLRW with a black hole spacetime – this comparison does not make sense a priori. Unfortunately, the reality is we simply don't know how to zoom in / zoom out between different spacetimes at different scales. So while we have a cosmological constant at large scales (when assuming homogeneity), there is no guarantee such a constant makes sense at smaller scales, i.e. that there is expansion at smaller scales. This is because there are two possible ways to interpret the cosmological constant: One way is to interpret it as a fixed parameter in the field equations (i.e. it influences every solution), another way is to interpret it as a term in the specific large-scale spacetime solution of our universe (i.e. ΛCDM) and shove it into that solution's energy-momentum tensor. Now, I think most physicists adhere to the first interpretation and assume that the constant is the same across all scales and possibly even homogeneous. Thus it should impact all spacetime solutions in the same way and at all scales, including black hole solutions. For this reason people have introduced modified black hole solutions that, like our cosmological model, take into account a positive cosmological constant (= "de Sitter"), for instance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Sitter%E2%80%93Schwarzschild_metric https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Sitter%E2%80%93Schwarzschil... As you suspected, in these solutions you generally have both effects that counteract each other: The gravitational pull of the black hole (leading to an event horizon) and the expansion of the universe ("anti-gravitational pull") due to the cosmological constant, leading to a cosmological horizon in the region far away from the black hole. Nevertheless, whether you believe in/consider a cosmological constant at small scales is a bit up to you. Most people I know seem assume that space at the level of atoms, planets, solar systems or even galaxies is not expanding and only very far away from gravitational systems you'll end up with expansion. This is supported by the fact that the cosmological constant is so tiny and, thus, in the aforementioned De Sitter black hole solutions, the cosmological horizon is far, far away from the center – so far indeed (111 (M/Msolar)1/3 parsecs[2]) that we know this outside region of the spacetime can no longer be valid/applicable. To see the latter, remember that black hole solutions assume a perfect vacuum away from the central body (black hole/star/planet/…) but in reality no massive body is alone in the universe. This means that, before you reach a distance of 111 (M/Msolar)1/3 parsecs from a given body, you'll long have encountered another couple massive bodies which will modify your spacetime and cause additional gravitational pull. (Once again, how exactly they modify spacetime we don't know (short of maybe some numerical approximations), since we can't easily superpose spacetimes!) Long story short: Only in very few situations it's worth considering a cosmological constant at small scales. Its effects are easily cancelled out / hidden by local gravity. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedmann%E2%80%93Lema%C3%AEtre%E2%80%93Robertson%E2%80%93Walker_metric https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedmann%E2%80%93Lema%C3%AEtr... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lambda-CDM_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lambda-CDM_model [2]: https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2020AAS...23537904F/abstract https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2020AAS...23537904F/abstra...
- axilmar 4y agoCould it be that there is no gravity, and what we perceive as gravity is the pressure from the expanding universe?
- apple-sauce 4y agoIsn't that gravity is just a result of clock tick rate is slower if you are closer to some matter?
- axilmar 4y agoI believe that is backwards...time changes due to gravity and not vice versa. It's a misunderstanding propagated in the last few years through misconceptions.
- Maursault 4y ago> Could it be that there is no gravity It makes so much more sense that there's no Dark Matter.
- gtech1 4y agoaround the turn of the century many ideas were floating around in order to explain unexplainable phenomena. It took Einstein and Quantum physics to radically change the worldview and make sense, while make-shift ideas were discarded. I suspect the same will happen with Dark Matter
- gtech1 4y agoSo how would that explain the fact that spacetime is curved in a very predictable manner in a clear relation to the mass of an object in spacetime ?
- axilmar 4y agoPerhaps spacetime curvature is nothing more than the gradual stopping of the universe expanding when mass is present.
- andrei_says_ 4y agoWhat is going on with titles? Do physicists really put on boxing gloves hoping that physical violence will resolve a scientific argument? Is this a new widely accepted approach? I find this level of editorializing ridiculous to the point of insulting. I don’t need the imagery of violence to boost my curiosity about a new discovery.
- PavleMiha 4y agoI get criticising science journalism, but this isn’t even a metaphor, it’s one of the meanings of “spar” as per most dictionaries: to argue.
- pleb_nz 4y agoSpar can also be used to simply mean 'to argue'. Sail boats can also have a spar. It's not soley a boxing term. I think the title of fine.
- andrei_says_ 4y agoThank you. Had Never seen it in context outside of physical fighting.
- riley_dog 4y agoIf you find this title insulting, I can't imagine how you get through the rest of your day. Some synonyms of spar are argue and quarrel. This isn't ridiculous editorializing.
- jdmichal 4y agoIf sparring incites images of violence for you, I suspect you don't really understand what sparring is. It's specifically practice without the violence -- extra rules are put into place to ideally eliminate injury, though of course accidents do happen.
- inspector-g 4y agoThis reminds me of a question I’ve had for a while, and have not been able to formulate it well enough to do any searching for an answer on my own (total layman here). Do we have any hypotheses of what the matter inside a black hole might be like? I mean “hypotheses” in a strict sense; I do not mean “a good/definitive answer” To oversimplify a bit: white dwarves are supported by electron degeneracy pressure, and if such pressure is exceeded by gravity then e.g. a neutron star can form. Neutron stars are supported by neutron degeneracy pressure, and if such pressure is exceeded by gravity then a black hole can form. For each of those “steps” we have an idea of what the matter within must be like to support/exceed such pressures. Are there any hypotheses for what the matter might be like after such known pressures are exceeded and a black hole is formed?
- wcoenen 4y agoDegeneracy pressure comes from the Pauli exclusion principle. There is no limit to how high this pressure can go, as there are always higher energy states to occupy. (Except that for electrons at a high enough energy state, they will disappear by fusing with protons.) For neutrons, there is no such disappearing effect, so the degeneracy pressure can keep on increasing. So how can this pressure ever be "overcome by gravity"? Apparently at some point the degeneracy pressure itself starts to contribute significantly to spacetime curvature. This increases gravitational pressure, which compresses the neutrons, which increases the degeneracy pressure, which increases curvature, etc. No balance is possible anymore and collapse happens. Presumably this process of ever increasing neutron degeneracy pressure continues within the black hole until unknown physics come into play.