5 ms·
- $5 million in fines, for - 22 years of willful reporting violations - using 13 shell companies - to conceal ownership of a $32 billion portfolio I'm sure
by anigbrowl 4y ago
- $5 million in fines, for
- 22 years of willful reporting violations
- using 13 shell companies
- to conceal ownership of a $32 billion portfolio
I'm sure they're gutted by this ~0.016% fine.
- fnimick 4y agoFor context, 0.016% of 22 years is 1.25 days. They got fined effectively 1.25 days out of 22 years of profit.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThey did not make $32 billion in profit over 22 years.
- marcosdumay 4y agoWell, they almost certainly made more. The only number we have is how much they reinvested, after depreciation.
- ramesh31 4y agoThe SEC is, largely, a powerless bogeyman due to chronic underfunding and lack of staff. Another wonderful feature of corporate regulatory capture in the US.
- nsxwolf 4y agoSo you need more staff to write down a larger fine on a piece of paper?
- freejazz 4y agoYou need the staff to enforce it...
- garyfirestorm 4y agofine = scale of crime x (number of ppl working at SEC/1000000)
- flandish 4y ago…yes? Because with larger fines comes larger court cases - and larger numbers of support staff. Corporations have lobbied and purchased their way into these freedoms at the cost of our wallets and futures. Don’t play thick. I too wish these assholes got prison time for this behavior.
- FredPret 4y agoHow many bureaucrats does it take to type a zero on a fine? In all seriousness, I'm a dyed-in-the-wool capitalist and I love the SEC.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CosmicShadow 4y agoBut what kind of staff or funding does it take to say literally different words out of your mouth like, you are fined $5B instead of $5MM? I can do that for free, especially if they are already at the point where they are making the charge. Every fine should be devastating so that they either barely survive or die, and every other company shits themselves for life and we solve the problem.
- pwinnski 4y agoHence the phrase "regulatory capture" which describes a system in which unelected bureaucrats are not given life-and-death power over companies, but the people who set the rules are wholly captured by the regulated companies so the rules are made weak.
- CosmicShadow 4y agoThanks for the definition
- ramesh31 4y ago>But what kind of staff or funding does it take to say literally different words out of your mouth like, you are fined $5B instead of $5MM? Because we don't live in an autocracy, and government fines can (and are) successfully challenged in court. It takes an immensely greater effort, and immensely greater resources, to enforce a $5B fine vs a $5M fine.
- CosmicShadow 4y agoHow do you get away with defending tax fraud to the point where the fine is pointless? Does the SEC not get to keep the winnings to use for their future cases so they can hire a ton of lawyers? I guess the real problem is why are judges (presumably everywhere?) lettings companies and organizations get away with this or is there a specific set of judges that only handle SEC cases? Perhaps the first step to getting bigger fines is to just keep increasing fines across the board? Do they need to campaign to judges to remind them that financial crime is bad? How hard is it for anyone to understand that a fine is meaningless unless it hurts, no matter how big the number is? Do you really need more lawyers to prove that basic point? I guess you guys are stuck in a pretty crappy system, but then again I'm sure most places are :/
- hotpotamus 4y ago[flagged]
- yieldcrv 4y agoI feel worse for the whistleblower that probably reported that They thought they were going to get a much bigger payday by reporting the malfeasance of a 32 billion portfolio
- hef19898 4y agoYou can check on the SEC homepage if their is a corresponding whistleblower award. Could be as high as 1.5 million, which is not nothing but still less than one would have assumed.
- pseudosavant 4y agoI would guess that the whistleblower was employed by the church directly or via a subsidiary. Knowing many people who work for the Mormon church, it is likely the whistleblower lost their job and their pension. You will lose your job and pension if you stop regularly attending church services or giving 10% of your paycheck back to the church ('tithing'). I can't imagine they don't take a harder approach to this. To be clear, it is wrong to retaliate against whistleblowers, but large organizations get away with it a lot.
- lcall 4y agoI've been around the Church for a long time (and interacted a very little bit with senior leaders), and was a Church employee before health issues ended that. I very highly doubt that anyone "will lose your ... pension if you stop regularly attending church services or giving 10% of your paycheck back to the church". But job, yes. They want people who are devoted, if they are going to pay them to further the work. To me that makes perfect sense. (Thoughtful comments appreciated with downvotes; thanks.)
- mypalmike 4y agoThey "want people who are devoted" to helping skirt financial reporting laws?
- yieldcrv 4y ago
- tptacek 4y agoWhy would the fine be higher? Presumably it's proportionate to the harm caused, not by the size of the fund.
- shadowgovt 4y agoIt's actually a settlement, not a fine, which is probably pinned closer to the "This is the amount we think we'd have to pay lawyers to argue the case" value than the "This is how much we would owe if we were found guilty of breaking the law" value.
- tptacek 4y agoRight, either way, I'm looking for an intuition about how much an infraction like this should cost. Presumably, the settlement also includes the LDS church's consent to start filing reliable 13F's. I'm not saying I think 5MM is the right number; I'm just saying I have no intuition for what the number should be, and the rationale I see on the thread seems to be "they're big". If I get pulled over in a Bentley with an expired sticker, I pay the same price as someone in a Kia.
- tpush 4y ago> If I get pulled over in a Bentley with an expired sticker, I pay the same price as someone in a Kia. In the US, sure. The people advocating for a proportional fine in the LDS case presumably would argue for a proportional one in your example, too.
- nekasrbenda 4y agoNot in Sweden tho, traffic tickets are proportional to income.
- tptacek 4y agoIf you keep getting tickets in the US, you'll eventually get your license suspended.
- 4y ago