18 ms·
Saying goodbye to Stack Overflow
- andrewfromx 4y ago[flagged]
- JohnFen 4y agoI reached a similar place with SO a few years ago. These days, I rarely bother to go there, although I don't block it in my search results.
- mistermann 4y agoAs someone who listened to every single Stackoverflow podcast as it was being built, I would love to be a fly on the wall eavesdropping on Jeff and Joel's conversations (preferably with a bit of alcohol in them) about what Stackoverflow has become. Jeff especially was absolutely hardcore on perfection, I can't imagine he wouldn't be freaking out on some level with this nonsense.
- benjamoon 4y agoThis a GPT summary?
- andrewfromx 4y agoI can't lie, yes. BUT I used to write the same type summaries with my human brain all the time here too. Is it wrong to get all these points from an AI summary? I guess you could argue HN might as well just auto summarize every article now!
- majkinetor 4y agoNo its not. You used the tool in useful way, producing result that is helpful to others. Points deserved. Autosumarization would be cool too.
- grey-area 4y agoYes it is wrong.
- pixl97 4y agoYou mind explaining how?
- grey-area 4y agoIf you think it’s useful you’re stealing the work of GPT by posting without attribution, if you don’t you’re wasting our time.
- pixl97 4y agoThis is where I want to make an omniscient bot that follows you around and gives you a severe electric shock every time you use potentially copyrighting material snippets (I'll be nice and give you a 3 second window to declare fair use). I will be happy the day copyright is dead and buried under a mountain sized gravestone. As much as you think it protects the small guy, it enabled the rich to buy up portfolios and enslave them to constant payments and holding back the progression of society.
- grey-area 4y agoThe OP deliberately used another entities work as his own without attribution.
- JohnFen 4y ago> Is it wrong to get all these points from an AI summary? I don't think so, as long as you've vetted it for completeness and accuracy.
- nextaccountic 4y agoThat's exactly my point of view. Human-vetted AI content is just content that the human could write themselves, like a fancy autocomplete. Automatically posting AI content with a bot is a different matter
- ducktective 4y agoI think we need sort of an etiquette code to disclose when a piece of text is AI-generated. Like when we say "Full Disclosure" or "IANAL"
- andrewfromx 4y agoi can't help think of Data from star trek, longing to be more human like. At some point can the AI be allowed to post with the same equal rights as humans. Picard would fight for Data's rights to comment on hacker news articles.
- grey-area 4y agoPresumably he'd be annoyed if you stole Data's work and posted it in your own name though without attribution?
- dang 4y agoPlease don't. HN is a place for humans to write and converse with each other. Bots have never been allowed here and we've banned accounts for posting like this since long before GPT. (I don't want to ban you, obviously)
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- benjamoon 4y agoSorry, I was the person who asked, didn’t mean to get you told off by the attribution police! I think attributing GPT every time you use it is as stupid as attributing spell check when you use it. It’s a tool, not a person. Soon it’ll be a click away in the browser and it’ll be used everywhere exactly how you used it. In fact, pretty soon anyone saying you have to attribute text to GPT will probably be a GPT powered bot! :) For some reason though, your summary stuck out like a sore thumb. I work a lot with GPT3, I think you get accustomed to how it writes (obviously you can change that with some prompt work).
- uberman 4y agoI enjoy answering questions but like the poster, I kind of hold my breath any time I do. Toxic downvoting is not just a question thing. There are people who will downvote any and every answer even a correct one to a question they feel is unworthy of an answer.
- hnthrowaway0315 4y agoI think a big problem is voters are not shown and verified. If you upvote or downvote a post your id should show and you must provide a reason why the vote.
- mgkimsal 4y agoIt might likely need to be an additional thing and phased in. Current voting can carry on as is, but 'verified voting' would be a secondary mechanism, and... over time people could choose to ignore the non-verified votes, or the non-verified votes could be phased out altogether. I like the simple up/down vote mechanism, but it definitely seems to be abused, and I would prefer more weight be given to votes with a public reason. Votes without an explanation should end up weighting less.
- berkle4455 4y agocan you imagine if HN had the gumption to offer the same? would solve so many issues.
- mdmglr 4y agoPerhaps downvotes should not be allowed at all.
- bediger4000 4y agoSO has an additional problem the article's author doesn't get to: high-voted answers that at the time were relevant and correct, but are not relevant now due to time passing and Microsoft aligning Windows to fit their current direction. I reckon this problem exists for other technologies that change with time, too.
- syntheticnature 4y agoIndeed, I was recently looking for some information, and all the SO results I turned up were for the language in question as of 2011, and found to be inapplicable.
- bediger4000 4y agoI've had the same sort of experience. This leads me to believe SO could age off answers, or maybe even questions, and everyone except history buffs would benefit.
- hnthrowaway0315 4y agoreddit is a lot more frendlier so I'm using SO mostly read only.
- rurban 4y agoQuora is the better variant of SO. Not the toxic cesspool, that SO became. But same mailinglists are much worse.
- bobbob1921 4y agoI find Quora difficult to navigate when I’m searching for an answer to a question. That’s my main issue however, I also don’t like the constant pay wall restrictions I feel I come up against frequently on Quora.
- timdiggerm 4y agoI would love to see the author's posts
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mdaniel 4y agoTheir profile was linked in the reddit comments: https://stackoverflow.com/users/8075005/webstackdev https://stackoverflow.com/users/8075005/webstackdev although one must have "close privileges" in SO to view their allegedly closed questions
- CodeCompost 4y agoAnything you post on Stack Overflow gets automatically downvoted no matter what.
- egberts1 4y agoPerhaps your code is ... compost? headduck
- jrmg 4y agoMy pet Stack Overflow annoyance: the number of questions that have highly voted confidently incorrect answers or (perhaps worse?) answers that do work, but not for the reason in the confidently incorrect explanation that follows the ‘what to do’ part of the answer.
- yxwvut 4y agoI feel like this is particularly bad for python Q+A on SO. At least it's not as bad as Quora where the top answer is invariably a grandiose answer to a different question than was asked or an excuse for some bullshit 'heartwarming' anecdote that answers nothing.
- suzzer99 4y agoWay more often than not it seems like the first few answers are either wrong, overly complicated, or advanced RTFM posts with massive upvotes. Meanwhile the 3rd or 4th answer with modest upvotes is actually the succinct correct answer.
- jjgreen 4y agoI feel that pain. I recently posted question on SO about the best way to work around what is apparently a bug in Clang, providing a code listing, link to the (open-source) full listing, GDB traces ... 7-8 people asked that I provide a "minimal example", presumably so they could paste it into some online debugger. As I was preparing that, and within 24h of the original post, it was closed. Of course I deleted it. I'll take the issue up with the Clang people directly at some point.
- metabagel 4y agoYeah, typically there is always a better place to ask a question than SO. IRC, Discord, email list, etc. - wherever the experts and enthusiasts hang out who work all the time on whatever it is you are trying to wrap your brain around.
- __MatrixMan__ 4y ago...but then, once I get my answer on discord, I like to ask and answer your question on SO so that it's searchable. Somehow that lone upvote after five years of silence feels much more meaningful than the popular answers do. Like I'm glad if I can save 100 people 5 minutes, but even better is to save one person a week.
- Izkata 4y ago> As I was preparing that, and within 24h of the original post, it was closed. > Of course I deleted it. It was closed to prevent guesses from being posted as answers while you worked on the minimal example, if you'd just edited it in the question would've been put into the reopen queue.
- jjgreen 4y agoMaybe, maybe not. I'm not spending my time working on a closed question.
- Izkata 4y agoThey only gave two examples of their questions that have been closed, and the second one is obviously of a type[0] that hasn't been allowed for over a decade (long before they made their account). Nothing bad sticks out to me from their description of their first example, but the other indicates their understanding isn't as good as they think it is. [0] List questions have no single correct answer so don't work on a Q&A site where a single answer gets selected by the asker.
- reaperducer 4y agoThey only gave two examples of their questions How many examples would they have to post in order for you to be satisfied?
- Izkata 4y agoIt's not the amount, it's which example they gave. They insist they understand the rules, yet their evidence is something that's obviously against the rules?
- tsgagnon 4y agoDo you have a link to the rule about asking questions with only a "single correct answer"? Out of curiosity, I tried digging around and couldn't find references to that kind of rule.
- Izkata 4y ago> If your motivation for asking the question is “I would like to participate in a discussion about ______”, then you should not be asking here. https://meta.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask https://meta.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask "List question" is meta jargon on stackoverflow that longtime users will understand. It falls under these "open ended" questions, hence why OP's question was closed as "primarily opinion-based" - IIRC it used to have its own close reason but got rolled into that when others were needed. Here's a meta question specifically about list questions that says basically the same thing: https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/139618/are-list-questions-off-topic https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/139618/are-list-que...
- kstrauser 4y agoMy favorite is people downvoting and arguing about answers I posted over a decade ago. "Yeah, I know that's not how you'd solve a problem in Python today. It was a good answer in 2011 when I wrote it. How bored are you, exactly, that this is how you want to spend your days?"
- dietrichepp 4y agoI don’t care about the downvotes but I hate when people make misguided attempts to “improve” old answers. The most recent was someone who went in and removed use of the word “you” as an attempt to “depersonalize” the answer. There was some kind of recognizable idea behind the edits, but the user’s changes mostly just damaged the readability and made the answers more convoluted. The editor argued with me and linked to a meta post—which they wrote! This was a multi-page essay which explains, in depth, the rationale for these awful edits. The user argued that “you” is not used in good, professional documentation. This is, as far as I can tell, completely false and within seconds of pulling up various samples of good documentation I was able to find dozens of examples of “you”. Another user, years ago, would start fights and argue with anyone, saying that “standard C” only referred to the current C standard, and any previous editions of C were no longer “standard”. The user would insist upon removing the C tag from any question about C90, for example. The more you answer or ask questions, the more likely it is that you get into conflict with one of these horrible, horrible users.
- phpisthebest 4y ago[flagged]
- dietrichepp 4y agoUnlike Reddit mods, anyone with sufficient rep is granted the edit power on SO.
- dotancohen 4y agoJust wait until you see the Wikipedia mods.
- RomanPushkin 4y agoUsing StackOverflow for 13 years, 161 answers, 62 questions. ~1.9M people reached. I am confirming S.O. is toxic. Multiple times I asked questions that have been closed. I'm the founder of Ruby students community, there are ~2K folks. And I do not recommend them to ask questions on S.O., since the the atmosphere S.O. created is discouraging.
- avgDev 4y agoI had a professor who recommended that all students try to ask for help at least once on SO. 95% of students got their post deleted or got some snarky comments. Honestly, it seems like this reflects the programming environment fairly well. Most devs will be more than happy to answer questions and help. However, if you have done nothing you cannot be helped. I worked with a guy who gave up easily and was frustrated, but he refused TO READ. I would try to help him and would quickly realize our knowledge gap was so significant that I would need to provide reading materials for him, but he wouldn't read them. I have been building applications as solo dev for years at a midsize company and I have never encountered anything that wasn't already answered on SO or on reddit/github.
- bombcar 4y agoYou've struck at a the heart of the matter - in the glory days there were so many people involved that a few "TLDR" questions (or answers) wasn't a problem, but as the quality of the questions goes down, the discouragement for the answerers goes up, until you have a wasteland populated by "how do I make the cupholder come back out of the computer" questions and rabid answer zombies searching for another good question to chew on (and being perpetually disappointed).
- bena 4y ago14 years, 5 months, 71 answers, 7 questions, ~5.6m people reached. Top 10% reputation overall. The toxicity started before it was even out of beta. I was fairly vocal early on about how certain attitudes were not conducive to community. And here we are.
- rcfox 4y agoIt's disappointing that Reddit is now the go-to for answers. The language subreddits get flooded with questions akin to "where am I missing a semicolon?" and any interesting discussion or articles get drowned out.
- DelightOne 4y agoThose can be answered by ChatGPT. Only question is where to integrate it into peoples' workflows. Maybe into the post-creation interface? Maybe into the SO question-creation dialog.
- stuff4ben 4y agoInteresting... I wonder if this is where knowledge sites gravitate to? Of course if the AI isn't smart enough to answer the question without it's training not having covered it, I'm not sure it would work...
- svachalek 4y agoWhat would be really cool is an AI interview. "So this looks like the same problem, do the answers here help?" "Oh, why not?" "I see, so what else have you tried?" "I see we still haven't resolved the issue, so I'm going to rewrite this discussion in our standard format and post it for our expert community to solve."
- DelightOne 4y agoSomething like that. Especially when the Chatbot then corrects the small usual mistakes it already knows by itself (as ChatGPT can).
- digianarchist 4y agoReddit has it's own moderation problems. I've been banned from more sub-reddits in the last 6 months than the proceeding 14 years I've used the website. The internet is fast becoming a collection of digital-fiefdoms.
- t-eckert 4y agoI never ask questions on Stack Overflow. I usually just chat with the people I know and trust in a Discord or Slack, which kind of sucks because the answers are not preserved for everyone else. I think with the toxicity of SO not getting solved, the future will be more distributed with people posting on their own blogs.
- jjordan 4y agoIt's been hostile for years. Lately I find that I'm getting actual answers from there less and less. Not sure what can be done apart from a decisive change in community engagement from the top down.
- stillsleepy 4y ago[flagged]
- permo-w 4y agomy most recent attempt wasn’t downvoted or closed, instead I got an ‘typo edit suggestion’ - or something to that effect - where someone had gone through and edited in about 5 false corrections to imagined typos. I did have the option to decline the edit, but it’s another example of the weird moderation culture does anyone have insight into the moderator process that’s encouraging these behaviours?
- zabzonk 4y agopost a link that proves what you say
- ryathal 4y agoEdits provide reputation when accepted and on SO specifically are about the only reliable way for new users to get reputation. Answering new questions that don't get closed is difficult, anything "easy" is mobbed by people and a single answer gets reputation and the other largely ignored or even deleted. Asking is also difficult for the reasons commonly cited elsewhere in comments. Edits are also further gamified to be accepted through review queues that give badges for stamping enough things. Technically, trivial edits are discouraged, but there's nothing enforcing that publicly.
- skilled 4y agoI think SO has very distinct culture and it is a notoriously hard-moderated platform. It attracts a lot of like-minded people for the various exchanges and you can get a kick out of it if you're also extremely passionate on certain topics. But outside of that, I treat SO mostly as a dictionary/reference. The whole points and reputation system isn't for me, but in this case that's how SO works and without this system it would be yet another lame Q&A platform that's riddled with spam and bullshit information. I can see leaving the platform or not using it at all, but I wouldn't block it from Search.
- fishtoaster 4y agoI think a common misunderstanding about Stack Overflow is that it's a place to get your questions answered. It's not - that's only a secondary use case. The primary purpose of S.O. is to produce a searchable corpus of answers with few duplicates and pretty high-quality answers. They're optimizing for being the first google result for "how to do X in Y language." They're not optimizing for being the best place for an individual to ask "hot to do X in Y language." When you consider S.O. through that lens, I think a lot of how the site works (aggressive close-as-duplicate-ing, for example) makes more sense.
- eulers_secret 4y agoI rarely respond to super recent comments, but you're 100% right. What SO didn't expect was that their real purpose was as feedstock for LLMs that will consume them and surpass them entirely.
- stonemetal12 4y agoI look forward to the day that the LLM responds to a question like the users of SO do, duplicate, didn't do enough research before asking, etc.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoYou’re just repeating what SO owners say, or aspire to. Why do you agree?
- nextaccountic 4y agoHow can you not agree that the SO goal is to achieve whatever the owners of SO want it to achieve?
- wahnfrieden 4y agoI didn’t disagree with the goal. I question the owner’s stated goal vs the actual behaviors and utility to its audience. So is the goal descriptive or aspirational. If latter then describing the site that way reads more like an ad. Like taking musk‘s statements on what Twitter is “for” at face value
- EamonnMR 4y agoIn my experience then preferred place is now Discord which is awful because it's not indexed by search engines. But at least there's a chance that your question gets answered, or you get pointed in the right direction.
- drewda 4y ago> I've finally decided to cancel my SO account, to add it to my hosts block list, and to block SO results from Google using an extension. I won't say that Twitter and StackOverflow are exactly alike, but to quit a website I also find that I have go "cold turkey" by making it hard to enter the hostname on autopilot or click a search result. That's why I added "||twitter.com^" to uBlock Origin on both my desktop and mobile web browsers.
- teddyh 4y agoDon’t forget all the Nitter proxy sites: https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/wiki/Instances https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/wiki/Instances
- someuser54541 4y agoIsn't Discord the new platform? I used IRC quite extensively for asking development related questions, but after the freenode fiasco it seemed Discord became the best place to get development questions answered for a large variety of languages and frameworks.
- thrownaway561 4y agoI use it as my own personal knowledge base. I only post things that I have figured out and haven't been asked before, basically answering my own questions.
- fabian2k 4y agoI'd really, really like to see links to specific questions that were closed for allegedly bad reasons. These posts complaining about SO almost never contain them, so we're only getting half the story. Stack Overflow can be a rather harsh experience if you're unfamiliar with it and have wrong assumptions about how it works. The "wrong assumptions" part is not intended to blame the asker, it's just a fact that SO has some rules that are not obvious if you're used to more forum-like sites. I still find SO very useful, and I have no issue at all with getting questions closed. I may have received a downvote or two that I found unwarranted, but not more. And you don't always get an answer, but that is not that surprising for more specialized questions. It's still the most useful general purpose site for programming questions for me.
- filoleg 4y agoAt least for this specific case, you hit the nail on the head. Here is a comment[0] from the reddit thread that found the actual questions (that the OP asked on SO) and explained in very clear terms why they were closed. Not really happy with how trigger-happy SO is with closing questions based on wrong assumptions in general. But in this specific case, it feels very justified. 0. https://www.reddit.com/r/webdev/comments/116vvpp/saying_goodbye_to_stack_overflow/ https://www.reddit.com/r/webdev/comments/116vvpp/saying_good...
- Aperocky 4y agoI wonder if the amount of reputation had an outsized effect. I do the same thing for questions I ask, but did not receive any similar treatment. I did accumulate quite a number of reputation from answering spree 5 years ago (slightly over 5K). I do not mod or police ever, but I just reopened a few questions that I think is worthy for the effort - I probably should do more of that to offset the overzealous folks if I find time...
- silversmith 4y agoCounter-ancedote: my 13 year old, 9K rep account gets the same treatment as original poster. I've given up on participating (after latest and particularly upsetting episode of "question not good enough"), and use the site only through google. Shame, it used to be easy access to expertise.
- Aperocky 4y agoInteresting, can you reopen your own questions? I'm quite OK with duplicate close if the reference actually solved my issue. But I've never had a question outright closed on me, I'd be fuming.
- nickstinemates 4y agoI said goodbye to StackOverflow more than 8 years ago[1]. I was an avid fan, listened to every podcast episode as Jeff and Joel were building it and was excited for its launch. The early days were so much better because the toxicity had not set in. However, my account clearly has first mover advantage. I sit at Top 0.5% without having contributed in a very long time. Both on the Question and Answer side, I have benefitted from providing answers to basic questions and asking basic questions. 1: https://stackoverflow.com/users/4960/nick-stinemates https://stackoverflow.com/users/4960/nick-stinemates
- thatwasunusual 4y agoThis is slightly off topic, but still related to SO, Reddit, or whatever community out there that is being used for getting any kind of help: Most people doesn't know what they are trying to solve or achieve. And/or they don't know how to phrase themselves correctly. Look at /r/Unity3D, which I frequently visit, and you can see _tons_ of duplicate questions, with different wording, because the OP doesn't know what to search for to find the solution to the problem at hand. I see the same thing in SO as well, which is why I have also disregarded that for problem-solving information. I'm back to finding out stuff the hard way; reading the documentation and use my 30-year old programming knowledge to sort it out. Sometimes I share my knowledge on f.ex. /r/Unity3D, but often gets downvoted because it's illegal to use _anything_ that GCs in a simple ping pong game. So you need to use difficult to use data structures instead.
- synergy20 4y agosoon maybe the same will be said to reddit?
- moate 4y agoUnlikely. Reddit has subreddit built right into the ecosystem, so if r/developersneedanswerstotoughcodingquestions gets taken over by an SO style mod mob, you can just go start r/fucktheolddeveloperreddit and the cycle will start new. Reddit has a lot of flaws, but stagnation isn't exactly one of them
- chrisan 4y agoSomeone did the work of getting to the bottom of this and OP eventually shared his questions that were deleted https://old.reddit.com/r/webdev/comments/116vvpp/saying_goodbye_to_stack_overflow/j9bjepo/ https://old.reddit.com/r/webdev/comments/116vvpp/saying_good... > The first question is a request for ideas. That's offtopic for SO. > The second question was a good question, but since it ended up being a bug in your setup, and not actually part of the language, it wasn't as useful of a general question. This one I'd argue could be trimmed down further to a SCCEE for the bug and rephrased, but it doesn't matter now since the bug is auto-patched. > The third question has a great question set-up (formatted and straight to the point with SCCEEs) but the answer is the same as the linked duplicate so it should be closed. > The fourth question is another straight up duplicate asking for the meaning of certain Regex characters.
- marcus_holmes 4y agoI get that technically this is correct (the best kind of correct). But the UX of the site is basically "post a question, get modded to shit" now. I don't think the original author is complaining about the functionality, or even the community (though debatable). I think they're complaining about the UX. And that's not something we can argue with - they think they're posting valid questions, and their experience is that their questions are always rejected. This is true, and it remains true even if technically their questions should be rejected for valid reasons.
- HeavyStorm 4y agoThat's a GREAT discussion to be had... SO purpose is to be a kind of encyclopedia, so it makes sense to try to categorize duplicates (eventually fading them into obscurity). But is that the best experience for the user? Is it supposed to serve only readers, or those who are actually asking questions?
- chrisan 4y ago> But the UX of the site is basically "post a question, get modded to shit" now. You are 100% correct. SO clearly has an issue as this comes up time and time again. I wonder if a ChatGPT like front for it would serve everyone better?
- stillsleepy 4y ago[flagged]
- moate 4y agoWhat does this have to do with Stack Overflow? Did you wander in from reddit? This isn't how we do things here. Do better.
- anderspitman 4y agoI think it's highly dependent on the individuals in the various programming language communities on SO. I've found answers to my Rust questions to be very helpful and welcoming, while I'm not sure I've ever managed to avoid a Golang question being downvoted (disclaimer: I write far more Go than Rust). Most languages are somewhere in the middle in my experience, with the default being not getting an answer at all. That said, as a search resource for common problems SO is invaluable.
- labrador 4y agoI recently silently rage quit a subreddit because it got a new moderator who is not very bright and deletes my posts as being off topic when I'm clearly on topic to anyone with a greater than room temperature IQ. I quit after several months of getting my posts deleted. I remind myself they do it for free, which was why I was silent in my quitting. The article isn't about AI writing code instead of using SO, but a follow up will probably be forthcoming. Moderators: Can't live with them, can't live without them. Edit: Note to moderators: If a post has garnered several thousands of up votes overnight don't come along a say it's not a good post in the morning when you wake up. You don't know more than thousands of people who have invested a lot of time in knowing their subject.
- stuff4ben 4y agoThat's gotta be frustrating. I'm sure you tried reaching out to other moderators. It's almost like Reddit needs a mod committee for mods so that users can petition their cases.
- labrador 4y agoI think the problem is there is a lot of turnover. I appreciate the work of most moderators to keep the quality up, but like open source, the work-for-free model comes with it's problems
- philipwhiuk 4y agoIt's more accurate to think of subreddits as a bunch of kingdoms with an order of succession than parliaments or such like. Top Mod can remove bottom mod. Not vice versa.
- labrador 4y ago> bunch of kingdoms Funny that many of the sidebar rules read like decrees from a King
- shanebellone 4y ago"Stack Overflow is a toxic cesspool that is utterly useless outside of historical answers. That begs the question, what fills the void? It seems like Reddit, mostly." The irony is too much. Reddit is wildly toxic. Though, there are a few good communities. With that being said, SO isn't super useful when languages like Python have awesome documentation.
- mellosouls 4y agoUnfortunately this doesn't really have much to do with StackOverflow, beyond it having the success that gives it a) A large community. b) Unpaid moderators who include people and cliques who feel self-worth in gatekeeping and other forms of "power". It's always been this way in most fora; the more success, the larger the community, with a corresponding increase in inappropriate moderation. See also, Wikipedia, Reddit, everywhere else of this ilk. HN's acclaimed moderation - apart from being in a much smaller community, doesn't fit that model at all; perhaps it's not scalable though.
- metabagel 4y agoYeah, there's probably a limit to how much dang can be scaled. https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=dang https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=dang
- nmilo 4y agoDo I live in a different world than everyone here? Stack Overflow is awesome and I don't think I've ever had a bad experience with it (seriously). The response time is like 10 minutes or less since everyone there is so hungry for karma. The complaints about "closing questions" never really hit me because, when a question is closed, they usually point you towards an answer that helps anyways. They've always answered my stupid questions from years ago like "why does my program crash when I put a 1MB object on the stack" and "please make this CMake setup work for me," and if they didn't, they point me to a duplicate question that does. Just set aside your ego, fuck karma, and you'll be fine. I really don't see how people can find this site toxic.
- bombcar 4y agoIt really REALLY depends on how you use SO and what "sub overflows?" you're using. Some of them are quite active and fun to work with, others are brutal. And it also depends on how much effort you put into your questions, also. But any complaining that goes beyond "googling my question doesn't get me my complete answer anymore" should include examples of when it failed, because often people complain who just wanted SO to do their legwork for them.
- commandlinefan 4y agoI kind of wondered about that, too - I've asked a few questions on SO and never had one removed. Not all of them ever got answers, but I don't think any were ever removed or even downvoted.
- playingalong 4y agoMe neither. But I think to ask a good question (on SO or to a more senior colleague at work) is a skill itself. Most people don't have it. Even most developers don't have it, which is somewhat surprising. Also this skill is not taught actively, or at least not widely. So people end up asking these poorly worded or poorly aimed questions. And they receive hardly any help to get it right. Neither before (in their education), nor during/after (when using SO).
- mdaniel 4y ago
- at-fates-hands 4y agoI haven't used SO for about 4-5 years now. In the past, it was the first place I'd go. The last few questions I asked were downvoted and closed or told to reference answers from another question that didn't have anything to do with what I was asking for. I just gave up on it being a useful resource when I got stumped as a developer based on the last few questions I asked. The last few years I've gotten better answers from Reddit, Discord and various forums I visit from time to time. I've even started using ChatGPT to get answers which has worked surprisingly well. I don't want to say its outlived its usefulness, but even the small dev circles I run in, none of those people have used it in a while either.
- marcus_holmes 4y agoIt used to be cool. A good place to ask questions (and answer them when bored). Now it's read-only. One of many sources of answers (mostly for Linux config rabbit holes these days). Never post anything on there because it gets modded to shit within minutes.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoI have pretty much the same stats as the OP, with 28 questions over 8 years. I haven't had many questions closed, but there hasn't been one time where it was not legitimate, and the linked question didn't answer my problem. The OP linked a few questions that got closed, and while we cannot see the content, we can see from the URL that it's pretty obvious they are very searchable questions that are obvious duplicates or do not fit SO: - "meaning-of-dollar-sign-after-digit-and-dash-in-a-regex" - "any-reason-to-use-grid-for-mobile-andn-desktop-views" - "regex-matching-behavior-between-char-class-and-eol" - etc. Not only that, but those questions were not just closed, but were actually deleted, which indicates not only a problem with the content, but also big problems with the format. StackOverflow ain't the problem here.
- cwoolfe 4y agoI had a lot of angst against stackoverflow for years. Eventually I had to come to terms with the fact that while I hated how I was treated there, they did somehow manage to create an incredibly powerful tool that helped me in my career. I had to come to terms with the fact the policies I hated somehow also helped make top-quality answers instantly accessible.
- JohnFen 4y ago> helped make top-quality answers instantly accessible. I wonder if it depends on what questions you need answering? I stopped using SO because I couldn't find good quality answers to my questions (to be clear -- I'm talking about in their database, I wouldn't dare to actually post a question on SO). But the questions I have tend to be obscure or difficult ones, because I don't need much help with the easier ones. It's also a bit irritating when I find someone else has asked the same question, but they were either left unanswered or the answer was incorrect.
- dpkirchner 4y agoMy favorite feature of SO is their ephemeral chat system that returns 404 pages instead of useful information. It's a good alternative to forums that have been deleted and turned into SEO link farms.
- cableshaft 4y agoI haven't used SO for anything other than a read-only reference for probably over a decade at this point. It's always seemed incredibly hostile to me. But it's also about the only place you can find the answers to esoteric programming questions, especially specific error messages, so I keep clicking the links if they come up in a google search. But if I could do my job without using it, I would.
- egberts1 4y agoMeanwhile, Old Reddit was recently shutdown. Do not care for the New Reddit. Goodbye, Reddit. source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34885234 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34885234
- wesleyyue 4y agoI just contribute questions and answers on the respective communities of the libraries and languages my question is about, which often have way more helpful and normal people. The moderation power of SO attract the horrible people and the abusive snark you get on the platform is just not worth it.
- metabagel 4y agoThis is the way
- jotaen 4y agoWhat I find off-putting about StackOverflow is their crowd-sourced moderation system (which I got access to at some point due to karma threshold). It’s based on pre-categorised moderation queues with flagged submissions that you can (have to) go through, and it’s designed in a way that you mostly choose from a set of pre-fabricated standard responses to “resolve” the issue. The eventual moderation decision is “democratic”, so when 2 or 3 moderators happen to come to the same result independently, then that’s what it is. To me, that “moderation process” mostly felt like a robotic assembly line which isn’t designed to genuinely help people, but it’s primarily optimised for throughput. The frustration expressed by end-users is a direct consequence of this design that’s not really surprising. What’s most bizarre is that the system intersperses phony test submissions every once in a while, just to verify whether you as moderator are “doing it right” (or, are still alive, for that matter).
- boltzmann-brain 4y agoUnderrated reply. Do you have screenshots of what that looks like?
- jotaen 4y agoSure: - All moderation queues: https://files.jotaen.net/!nmezmQKFdH https://files.jotaen.net/!nmezmQKFdH - View for reviewing something: https://files.jotaen.net/!KwekXrbj36 https://files.jotaen.net/!KwekXrbj36 - Popover when selecting “Share Feedback”: https://files.jotaen.net/!FgRNhhfAT8 https://files.jotaen.net/!FgRNhhfAT8 - Resulting comment after selecting one of the canned responses: https://files.jotaen.net/!JUtTBMxApL https://files.jotaen.net/!JUtTBMxApL Last time I used this system was multiple years ago. As I just took the screenshots, it appears some things have changed compared to how I remember it from the past. Specifically: (take with a grain of salt, though!) - the option whether to share feedback “as yourself”, I think that used to be the default back then, and the “Community Bot” seems new. - the “custom comment” option didn’t used to be available in all queue categories. By the way, there was no onboarding to this moderation system whatsoever, so when I reached the required karma threshold (2000 or so?), I just got access to it à la “there you go, please help yourself”. Also, there is no way to communicate with other moderators on an issue, but everyone is just doing their own thing in isolation until there appears to be some “statistical consensus”.
- weinzierl 4y ago> "SO was incredible when it came out." Amen to that. > "That begs the question, what fills the void?" ChatGPT or another language model. StackOverflow started with the vision of not being what made Experts Exchange so terrible - that was a brilliant plan at the time and SO did many things very right. Now, many years have passed and not only have we seen SO grow into the whole plethora of QA sites that are Stack Exchange but also a couple of other QA sites. None of them are great, none of them are nearly as useful as the original SO was. I think it is save to say, that this approach simply does not scale. I might be wrong and maybe, some day, someone comes around and nails QA at scale. My bet is that with ChatGPT the humanly curated QA site is as dead in the water as the humanly curated web directories were when Google came around.
- thedonkeycometh 4y ago[dead]
- sattoshi 4y agoThese types of posts annoy me. I constantly see people talking about SO being "toxic", or closing perfectly good questions. And yet these people never link to specific examples. Why is that?
- aendruk 4y agoPart of it may be that there’s nothing to link to. I received a toxic welcome in Stack Exchange comments just this morning and checking it now the whole thread is gone as if it never happened.
- mdaniel 4y agoI was curious if these are captured in the Stack Exchange Data Dumps <https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/19579/where-are-the-stack-exchange-data-dumps https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/19579/where-are-the...> but while researching that, I found https://data.stackexchange.com/stackoverflow https://data.stackexchange.com/stackoverflow and at least according to my "select * from comments where userid=$my_user_id" the answer is no, they're straight-up deleted
- twobitshifter 4y agoYou know sometimes it's better to find a project's slack/ discord / mailing list / forum and ask your question there. The responses will be from the most knowledgeable people online and you'll get humane treatment.
- jmartrican 4y agoIn the beginning, I've had questions downvoted. But after a while, I learned how to ask questions. I can say that this is not something I struggle with. One issue I did have recently was with having one of my questions deemed a duplicate. And it was a duplicate if you only consider the fix or root cause. But the original question did not have the error message that i was getting, and hence never came across the original. Hence I did not think it was a duplicate. In time I was able to get the duplicate label removed, and the question opened back up. I love SO. And I'm saddened by the OP's experience. I can imagine how frustrating they must feel. Hopefully, posts like this can lead to positive change.
- matsemann 4y agoIf the other question solved your problem, it's considered a duplicate. However, a duplicate isn't necessarily bad, and getting your question closed for it shouldn't be taken as a slight. It's just another angle (as you had a different error) to get to the same answer.
- jmartrican 4y agoBut the original did not have the error message in it. So one would not come to that answer if they are searching for the error message. That's why I wanted it opened back up. Not because I thought it was a slight. The fact that after a short period of time my question got 10k views and a gold badge shows that people were coming to my question which had the error people were searching for. So why does this matter? Well SO runs on points. If its ok to remove points from SO and still have a functioning site, then yeah I agree leave it a duplicate. But if SO's point system does matter, then leave it open and allow it to generate points for the person who asked the question that is helping many people stuck at the same place.
- NetOpWibby 4y agoAnecdotally, I've had an interesting experience on SO for a few months after I was fired from a small web shop in Boston. Literally every question I asked across the SE ecosystem was serially downvoted and/or had "request for closure." That's when I stopped looking at SO as a place to get help. When ChatGPT came out, I loved asking it SO-esque questions and not dealing with elitist/asshole humans.
- autokad 4y ago[flagged]
- jasonlotito 4y ago"You either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villain." I remember SO coming onto the scene, to combat Experts Exchange. Now, it's the modern EE. I've never seen a duplicate question. I have numerous times seen a question I've had closed as a duplicate, but the linked to "answer" was definitely "NOT" the answer.
- aeturnum 4y agoI haven't exactly had "bad" experiences on SO - but I do feel like it's generally a waste of time to ask questions on it. Basically - SO is very good at general knowledge questions (kinda ChatGPT territory) but bad at corner cases. A good example was this fiddly CSS / font question I had that had some constraints from a static site generator where you could inject custom CSS[1]. People really wanted me to accept answers that would not work for my constraint set, and I think the implicit answer is that the combination of formatting tools does not support what I want to do, but the whole thing was frustrating. I mostly think that, once you get to a certain level of proficiency, you're going to lose time on SO rather than gain it. You will spend a lot of time crafting a detailed and clear question that does have an answer - but on balance if you just read the docs / source / whatever you'll get the answer you need faster. [1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/66619732/can-i-write-css-rules-so-that-emojis-get-different-weight-than-other-text https://stackoverflow.com/questions/66619732/can-i-write-css...
- ranting-moth 4y agoRant: I stopped flagging content on SO when my flags were moderated "unhelpful". They were not, and the content would later be removed or fixed (presumable after others had flagged it). I do get it that moderating a site like SO is a massive effort. But there needs to be a check on rouge moderators.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- revskill 4y agoSeriously i can't register new account on Stackoverflow. There're similar sites. The bug is simple: You previously registered using gmail. Now you register new account with same email but with password. Instead of merging my account as before, they said account exist.
- m463 4y ago> It's been three years since a question I posted to SO wasn't closed within the first ten minutes of posting it and downvoted for good measure sigh. How can these kinds of jarring experiences be eliminated? This was my experience years and years ago. I think the quote was: "This question is not a good fit to our Q&A format. We expect answers to generally involve facts, references, or specific expertise; this question will likely solicit opinion, debate, arguments, polling, or extended discussion" This just made the site about as interesting as hanging out at the DMV. (actually, the DMV might be more interesting, because it's full of people)
- philipwhiuk 4y agoIt's a Q&A site, not a meet-and-greet.
- m463 4y agoYeah, I don't need a social network, but the question asked was a really good question, and the answers were USEFUL.
- politician 4y ago(Programming) SO is done, and should be dismantled. Its historical answers have been indexed into GPT, and the recent content circa 10 years ago and since has been this constant fight against moderators. I’ve had the same experience as the author, but haven’t blocked it from my hosts file. I think that I will.
- ranting-moth 4y agoMy pet annoyance is also the prohibition of opinion based answers. I've found many great answers, usually the top result on Google. But sadly the question is locked. Sometime the top answer (before the question was locked) was pretty much the right thing to do 5 years ago, but no one can add another answer. I do understand that opinion based questions are a moderation tar pit. But sometimes there aren't that many options. You get 5 different opinions and you pick the best one for yourself. I've sometimes thought there would be a place for a "Stack overflow overflow" site - banned on SO but allowed on SOO.
- shagie 4y agoThe difficulty is that questions that solicit opinion based answers often become unnaturally popular and difficult to moderate. Consider https://stackoverflow.com/questions/84556/whats-your-favorite-programmer-cartoon https://stackoverflow.com/questions/84556/whats-your-favorit... and the "is another answer going to be useful?" Or https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1711/what-is-the-single-most-influential-book-every-programmer-should-read https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1711/what-is-the-single-... The "no opinion based questions" is a clear line that can be drawn (rather than other squiggly lines that are more difficult) that reduces the overall moderation workload. You'll note that https://mathoverflow.net https://mathoverflow.net allows such questions - but they have many fewer questions per day and a much higher percent of the userbase performs moderation actions. This means that you can allow for that additional workload (which is a few questions rather than hundreds or thousands) to be spread across a larger part of the site's users. If you want Stack Overflow to allow such questions, then get 1% of the user base to close questions that should be closed every day so that the moderation tasks on them don't get too heavy on too small a group of people who would eventually say "we're not carefully moderating this anymore and instead not allowing those questions at all."
- Izkata 4y agoThat (plus "culture"-style questions as in the sibling reply) was pretty much the original purpose of programmers.stackexchange.com but it got taken over by people who didn't like these open-ended questions. After some years with them banned, it was renamed to softwareengineering.stackexchange.com
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI posted this comment, a couple of weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34722910 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34722910 It was part of a larger discussion on SO. In it, I mention an exercise: Here's an exercise: Go to Meta, and suggest that people applying for positions of authority have at least a 10% question-to-answer ratio. If anyone were to do that, they would be attacked and downvoted. Possibly banned.
- rbanffy 4y agoMy only advice: Karma is for burning.
- Cupertino95014 4y agoIn the long 40+ year history of "social networking" (with that term construed broadly to mean "anything where people contribute") the most stale, boring, pedantic debates have always been "does this message belong on this forum?" Besides SO have gotten that way, it's why almost no one wants to contribute to Wikipedia. You could almost graph the decline of a forum as directly proportional to the percentage of content that debates that question.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Euphorbium 4y agoI mostly use other stackexchange sites, not stackoverflow, and my experience is completely opposite. I get good answers and my questions are usually upvoted. What I am missing is the ability to have a discussion.
- SeanLuke 4y agoWhat has struck me was how many times the top answer to a question on S.O. has been utterly, pitifully wrong. That alone has gotten me thinking about whether S.O. is actually a force for good.
- nl 4y agoThis is such a foreign experience to me. I've been a member of SO for 13 years, and I've asked 24 questions. I've had one question downvoted[1] which I'm a bit annoyed about (I misunderstood the documentation terminology - but I don't think that is an uncommon problem). My only other bad experience was when I had a buggy version of a library and an error in my question[2]. Someone solved the error in my question after I had already edited it to fix that and wanted their answer accepted even though that didn't solve the problem I was having. [1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/43889952/what-shape-input-and-outputs-are-expected-for-sklearn-pairwise-distance-function https://stackoverflow.com/questions/43889952/what-shape-inpu... [2] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/63256952/pil-image-from-numpy-array-indexing https://stackoverflow.com/questions/63256952/pil-image-from-...
- exabrial 4y agoWhat ticks me off on StackOverflow is changing my posts and attributing it to me. For instance, I ended a post with "Thank you for any help, I appreciate your time". A overzealous moderator on a mission edited that and removed it. I added it back and told him that I'm polite in person and on the internet, and it's my desire to reflect that. That feedback was of course discarded and they locked the post. So yeah, despite being top 5% in the world, I stopped answering questions on the stupid site.
- wendyshu 4y agoThat sentence is redundant noise on the page. Show your appreciation by upvoting answers instead.
- eYrKEC2 4y agoBeing polite is "noise" in the real world too. It just so happens that the noise serves to lubricate the interactions of humans by adding the frills of niceness and respect.
- exabrial 4y agoNo it's not. Being polite is human. It exists in every culture in some form or another. And besides, who are you to judge anyway?
- wendyshu 4y agoI don't see the rationale for closing questions. If they're bad questions, downvote. If it's a duplicate, put an answer linking to an answer to the other question. Closing cuts off the possibility that someone might actually provide a useful answer.
- wendyshu 4y agoOn the math stack exchange site someone will harass you if your question might possibly be a homework question. Infuriating.
- datavirtue 4y ago"My last question (just now) asked about potential maintainability issues involved with a certain approach to CSS layout. I gave an example of a concrete maintainability issue..." Don't you dare question or besmirch the viability of raw CSS!! I made that mistake on HN a few days ago. This came as a surprise to me as I thought the tech community was well aware of what a quagmire CSS is.
- Buttons840 4y agoA few weeks ago SO closed my 10 year old question as a duplicate of a 7 year old question. I'll take help from any site, but I have no enthusiasm for SO and will not participate on the site (although I do have a lot of karma from old answers of mine).
- everyone 4y agoWhen is someone gonna make a new similar site without the crippling modern SO problems? I know similar sites exist, but they seem to have a tiny fraction of the users and not much activity. SO badly needs a successor everyone currently on SO can move over to.
- everyone 4y agoI have had the same experience with programming SO. Anything you ask no matter how specific, novel, and well researched and written just gets insta-downvoted. And there are people who dont seem to know anything about your question's topic just spamming useless answers all day. I posted a question on physics SO recently though.. and it wasnt a good question. It was a complete noob question, but the thread it spawned was amazing, and my question was answered incredibly satisfactorily in multiple ways.. I even gained karma by asking the question. The difference is shocking.
- _xivi 4y agoThe "problem" with moderation is that it's open for debate and not hard science The main closing reasons are ambiguous (generic), designed to cover many cases, but it became such that almost anything can arguably fall under one of them
- tastysandwich 4y agoIs this just a recent thing? I've had an SO account for years. Have only asked a handful of questions but they've never been closed. What I found annoying was that a lot of the time I never got a helpful answer, and ended up solving it myself a few days later. I then went back and answered my own question (which ended up being helpful for a bunch of people and it got a lot of points). What about the rest of Stack Exchange? I once asked for help identifying an insect and got pretty helpful answers there (bit of a segue - I ended up breeding a colony of those insects and still have them to this day).
- antifa 4y agoMost of my questions on SO have wrong answers, didnt-read-the-question answers, no answers, my self answer, or "hey did you ever figure it out?"
- sieabahlpark 4y ago[dead]
- yieldcrv 4y agoThe javascript and CSS community on Stack Overflow has always been toxic, interesting to see that its overflowed to being useless now. Other programming languages on the main Stack Overflow are much more collaborative. But if you ever get into a new niche, you never know what will happen.
- movetheworld 4y agoExactly my experience: 1. ask a question isolating and narrowing down my issue as good as I can 2. marked as a duplicate providing a link with an issue, which is loosely related, but does not solve my problem 3. start explaining / defending in comments why question is not a dupe 4. stays marked as dupe 5. give up and feel disappointed for the time and effort investment
- redbell 4y agoIn unrelated topic, I’m wondering how others can resubmit the same post without being flagged as “duplicate”. I had many original submissions that were resubmitted and having more attention. For instance, this post was sent about two days ago here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34873768 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34873768
- bilekas 4y agoI do understand the frustrations of SO. All laid out with good examples by OP. But the point : > I've finally decided to cancel my SO account, to add it to my hosts block list, and to block SO results from Google using an extension. This feels like the OP is just being spiteful. Love it or hate it, SO is a significant aid for developers and engineers of all levels. Simply blocking it because of some bad experiences trying to contribute seems really petty.
- BrandoElFollito 4y agoI am on SO for 14 years and collaterally accumulated some 200k of rep. I am an amateur dev and SO helped me tremendously to overcome problems that are obvious after some time. But at the time they were blocking. Some questions I asked were brilliant :) and some were nightmarish. SO usually got it right. Except some of the tags that are toxic to the point I do not even try to ask a question there because of the immediate down votes and patronizing. I am looking at you Golang (Go). It would be better, I think, if the rep of the asker was more prominent. Voting down a question that *I* think is useless when asked by someone with 20x my rep is an indication that maybe I am wrong. Also I never understood what the downvote is for because the description tells about quality and usefulness, but it is often actually used to say that you do not agree. Requiring a reason for the downvote may help.
- garfieldnate 4y agoMy experience on SO has been overwhelmingly positive, but I can say that I observe a large difference in the behavior of other users depending on the subject of my question. The C/C++ community is the most pedantic I've experienced, with tons of people jumping in to get those answer points, but also some fussing over question edits, tags, comments, etc. But I don't mind pedantic; they're also the most active, and I don't remember the last time I had a question that was left unanswered. I've improved my ability to ask focused, clear questions over the years, and that has led to a higher likelihood of getting answers. When I was a student still learning how to code, a lot of my questions would be left hanging, but looking back I think a lot of that was asking unclear questions, or not using the right keywords, or not even understanding what it was I wanted to ask (some was due to asking questions about arcane stuff used only in academia). Overall, I'd say that learning to use SO well has been largely a matter of improving my technical communication skills. Just wanted to give a word of support for SO. I love that site, I've used it for over 10 years now, and I look forward to having a place to go for technical help for the foreseeable future. It's gold for googling issues, but I can always count on a community there to help me craft another piece of "internet documentation" to help me and the next person.