11 ms·
White Castle collecting burger slingers' fingerprints looks like a $17B mistake
- synu 4y agoWhy is this article written like something from Idiocracy?
- gjsman-1000 4y agoA. The Register has been in decline for a long time. Take a look at their headlines and stories a decade ago, far more interesting and bombastic. B. The service that shall not be named is probably infiltrating more journalistic output than we think without us noticing. So attractive when you're overworked... (also notice the short paragraphs the article and the service share) C. As for the lawyers... they don't want "annihilative liability" and are doing everything they can to prevent such an outcome.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoI don't think ChatGPT would fill the article with puns.
- Operyl 4y ago> Absolutely! Here are some additional puns for an article title about White Castle's biometric issue: "White Castle's Fingerprint Fiasco: Slider Chain Gets a Wake-Up Call in Illinois" "Bun Intended: White Castle Gets Grilled Over Biometric Privacy Violation in Illinois" "Hold the Mayo, But Not the Biometrics: White Castle's Slippery Slope in Illinois" "From Crave Case to Court Case: White Castle's Fingerprint Foible in Illinois" "White Castle's Biometric Burglary: Slider Empire Slammed with Legal Woes in Illinois" It would if you asked, it seems.
- reaperducer 4y agoMayo? I guess ChatGPT has yet to scan a White Castle menu.
- zaroth 4y agoWell GPT said “Hold the Mayo” after all.
- crazygringo 4y agoOMG. I just had the horrible realization that a computer may be more creative than I am. At least when it comes to writing headlines. Wow.
- Operyl 4y agoHands down for me, here. I have zero writing creativity.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoBecause that's the humorous writing style The Register uses.
- justin66 4y agoHave you ever read a tech site where the articles were generally well-written and insightful? The authors who cannot get jobs with that site need somewhere to work too.
- Scubabear68 4y agoWhat’s interesting here is that the data was not collected secretly per se. White Castle used finger prints to unlock computers and access pay stubs, so employees had to know what was going on. The ruling is that they did not ask for and receive consent from those employees for years. The employee in question had been having her finger print scanned since 2004, and they only asked for consent in 2018. Which begs the question, if they asked and an employee said “no”, what happens? Are they fired? Banned from register work?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoThis - if it requires "consent" but not "informed and voluntary consent", the law is worthless and just increases the amount of paperwork. If an actual alternative has to be provided, that's a very sensible law. Biometrics can't be revoked, and every use puts them at risk, so making sure people aren't forced to let employers collect their biometrics is a good idea. Edit: If I read it right, the "consent" is required in the pure paperwork sense, unfortunately. That means for employees it only prevents biometrics from being used covertly. However, it still has value for non-employees, and the "written" aspect is particularly important here. A supermarket for example can't use biometrics to track people for advertising or theft protection purposes, because they'd first need to stop them at the entrance so they can sign a waiver. No cheating out of it with a small sticker "by entering these premises, you consent" in some corner.
- astura 4y agoAlmost certainly given a PIN code.
- nroets 4y agoSurely the system was designed to accommodate people who lack fingerprints.
- dehrmann 4y ago> Which begs the question, if they asked and an employee said “no”, what happens? Are they fired? This is like no-competes or binding arbitration agreements. If you decline to sign, your rights were honored, and you're free to find a job elsewhere.
- crazygringo 4y agoThis article makes it sound like White Castle was collecting "biometric data" to invade employees' privacy, as if it were using it to track their movement or connect them to potential crimes. The reality is "use of workers' fingerprints to access pay stubs and company computers". So it set up a fingerprint reader much like the one I use to unlock my MacBook, or sign in at my doctor's office, or open the turnstile at my gym. I understand that according to Illinois state law this is illegal without consent, and so legally they missed having employees sign a form. But morally/ethically is there really any problem with this? This is just how iPhones and MacBooks work, for example. Really seems like perhaps Illionis state law needs to be updated to reflect the widespread use of fingerprint readers for authentication on computers, tablets and phones.
- zitterbewegung 4y agoWhen you unlock your MacBook you are opting in to unlock the MacBook and you don't need to use it. Also, it is protected by a Secure Enclave and the actual fingerprint isn't stored. Reading the bill it even points this out. Biometrics are unlike other unique identifiers that are used to access finances or other sensitive information. For example, social security numbers, when compromised, can be changed. Biometrics, however, are biologically unique to the individual; therefore, once compromised, the individual has no recourse, is at heightened risk for identity theft, and is likely to withdraw from biometric-facilitated transactions.
- crazygringo 4y agoPresumably whatever fingerprint reader White Castle used for logins also stored a hash, similar to MacBooks. I don't know of any general-purpose fingerprint readers for authentication that store the original image. Also I don't see how compromising that hash is a problem in practice, if that ever happened. If it's salted it's worthless, but even if not, I don't know how you'd reasonably physically use it to hack into another fingerprint reader anyways.
- fragmede 4y agoThat is a huge presumption and, as GP pointed out, the problem is if your fingerprint gets leaked, it's rather difficult to change it. Apple did a great job with TouchID but security experts went all over it trying to poke holes. Most other fingerprint systems don't get anywhere near the same amount of scrutiny. So in an unfortunate turn of fate, Apple's awesome implementation of fingerprint authentication on the iPhone resulted inthe general public being comfortable with fingerprint auth in other places, when they really shouldn't be.
- batch12 4y agoSounds like they were using biometric MFA as a security control. A breach would have been cheaper.
- gjsman-1000 4y ago> A breach would have been cheaper. Especially considering we are talking about a sandwich shop, not Google or AWS.
- Turing_Machine 4y agoWhile it's certainly not Google, White Castle had 2019 revenue of $720 million, and has around 10,000 employees. A little more than just a "sandwich shop".
- Zigurd 4y agoNo, really, it is just a sandwich shop. All those shops could be sold off to pay a fine for this violation. We need to stop thinking a corporate entity and/or brand image deserve to be protected from the consequences of lawbreaking. This is the misperception that makes white collar crime, which is often several orders of magnitude more damaging in monetary value than street crime, published far less than the size of the crime would suggest.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoWith a revenue of $720M in the restaurant business, there is no way you’re going to make $17B from a sale. Subway has revenue of around $10B and is selling itself for $10B.
- bannedbybros 4y ago[dead]
- sandworm101 4y agoThis isnt about fingerprints. This is about a large corporation not reading a law. This is about recklessly adopting a new business practice without first consulting basic legal advice. The big numbers will get knocked down eventually but they are going to be rightfully on the hook for millions.
- kderbyma 4y agoThey should. Big business means you front the costs to do proper business. if you make billions and cannot do your legals....too bad. that money will be theirs soon
- crazygringo 4y agoWhite Castle doesn't make "billions". It's annual profit is in the very low millions. It doesn't even take a billion in revenue a year. White Castle isn't Google or Facebook. It's a relatively minor burger chain.
- crazygringo 4y agoHonestly it's pretty easy to see this fall through the cracks. Because it's one of 50 sets of state law, and it's entirely non-obvious that there would be a law around fingerprint readers in the workplace at all. The IT person who decided to adopt it would have needed it to occur to them to check with legal. And I can imagine that for most people it wouldn't occur to them. Any more than you'd think to check with legal about whether a password should require at least one punctuation character. I'm not defending White Castle here but neither do I think it's anywhere close to "reckless". I think it was just a normal day to day IT decision that nobody thought anything of. In other words, there was probably no criminal intent here nor recklessness. Just ignorance of a relatively unknown statute, that sure you should pay a reasonable fine for. Not a big deal.
- sandworm101 4y agoWell, if it met the legal definition for recklessness then the leadership would be sued by the shareholders. That isn't this. This is reckless as in not-smart rather than per se. They will have to pay a price so that lawyers for a thousand other companies can walk into the next board meeting to say "See, I told you and I was right about that fingerprint thing last year!" They will be punished, but the courts will not allow this to destroy the company.
- lordnacho 4y agoHow could you buy 23B burgers with $17B? Seems too good to be true.
- bell-cot 4y agoWhite Castle's reputation is not for large burgers. Nor for premium-quality ones.
- Zigurd 4y agoThis raises the question of whether corporate "death penalty" verdicts should be enforced. Corporations are just a collection of assets, as their management will remind you when they are bought and sold (even though they are portrayed as "persons" when "speaking" with money). This is outlier example, but why should any corporation that created an environmental disaster not pay what a complete liquidation of assets would yield, if that is less than the cost of remediation? Asking for a friend in the railroad business.
- jehb 4y agoI totally love this idea, and would love to be able to think up a way to make it viable. My concern under current law in most countries is that it's just going to lead to the proliferation of the complicated ownership structures like we see today, where the entity operating the assets is completely separate (legally) from the entity owning the assets. Imagine a world where every train and every track is owned by a separate LLC, with complicated usage agreements shared between them, but somehow still all owned by a handful of "blameless" holding companies.
- Zigurd 4y agoTax authorities, and the accountants who file returns, seem to navigate that space pretty well.
- scott00 4y agoTo have a debate about this we really need to add some precision to some of your terms. When you talk about "complete liquidation of assets" there's sort of two things that come to mind, and I'm not 100% sure what you mean. Option one is what I would call a reorganization: the rights of equity holders are terminated, and creditors (which would include beneficiaries of civil judgements) get some fraction of what they are owed, through a combination of keeping some portion of their existing claims, receiving cash received from selling new stock, and receiving some amount of new stock. Crucially, the business keeps operating when this happens, it's really just reorganizing the capital structure, not doing much to actual business operations. Option two is a true liquidation: the business stops operating, all of its assets are sold, and the proceeds distributed to creditors and then the corporate entity simply ceases to exist. The original debate about the "corporate death penalty" arose from how Arthur Anderson was treated in the wake of the Enron scandal. In that case, AA was criminally indicted. A criminal conviction is a huge problem for a public accounting firm, because convicted felons can't be CPAs or audit public companies. Indeed, it was ultimately convicted and barred by the SEC from auditing public companies. But it actually collapsed far before that, basically immediately after the indictment, as all of its clients saw the writing on the wall and dropped them. This was an option 2 liquidation. Personally, I would only consider an option 2 liquidation the "corporate death penalty". In the case of your friend in the railroad business, it's probably not the socially optimal outcome because you would actually get more money for the victims through an option 1 reorganization than option 2 liquidation. In general that's why option 2 should be sparingly applied: it reduces the resources available to compensate victims, and inflicts collateral damage on employees, vendors, and customers who mostly didn't do anything wrong. In addition to option 1 and option 2, some people also consider simply indicting a corporation as the "corporate death penalty" because of how in the case of Arthur Anderson, the criminal indictment did pretty much immediately cause option 2. I think that that position is not really consistent with the facts, however. There are at least 54 publicly traded companies that received criminal convictions between 2001 and 2010; 37 of them were still around in 2013, only 5 failed, and of the 5 it doesn't really seem like the conviction had much to do with their demise[0]. [0] https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1440&context=jbl https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?articl...
- donatj 4y agoThis is a weird one to me. To not consent to having your fingerprint scanned yet continuously doing so seems questionable. To do something for years without issue and then sue long after the fact doesn’t feel like justice. It feels to me that providing your print to begin with without coercion fulfills consent. I understand that the need to keep one’s job can be seen as coercion but I am confident the percentage of employees that actually objected at the time was negligible.
- tantalor 4y ago> involves the use of workers' fingerprints to access pay stubs and company computers Maybe: requiring fingerprint to access your pay is effectively coercion.
- donatj 4y agoPay stub, not pay. Very different things
- wpietri 4y agoGiven the rampant level of wage theft in this country, not so different at all.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoIf these employees are receiving any sort of public benefit, or become involved in some legal claim, or basically just need to prove their income to someone, they will absolutely require pay stubs. If they're not able to come up with proof of income, they could be denied Medicaid, Social Security, Section 8 housing assistance, SNAP "food stamps", WIC, TANF, or all sorts of other benefits that they would be entitled to, if only they could prove that they're earning a legitimate income from their employer who is required to provide pay stubs in an accessible fashion (they used to be simply attached to the paper check, or mailed via postal service; how complicated was that?)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- superkuh 4y agoWhite Castle's complaint against "annihilative liability" is more corporate/institutional exceptionalism. Human persons are often completely financially destroyed by civil suits. I don't see any reason why just because it's a corporate person they should be protected from this outcome. If anything it should be more likely against a corporate person who has no real criminal liability.
- crazygringo 4y agoThe question is, does the punishment fit the crime. You don't impose the death penalty for stealing an orange. With corporations the point of a penalty is to deter, not destroy. If White Castle goes out of business and thousands of people lose their jobs, how is that good for society? Justice requires proportionality.
- wpietri 4y agoJustice does require proportionality. But if only the especially rich get proportionality, then it's not really justice, is it? I agree it wouldn't be fair to White Castle if they were destroyed over this. But I'm not so sure it's particularly unfair when counted on the "workers vs corporations" scoreboard, or the one for "privacy vs exploitation".
- yathaid 4y ago"With corporations the point of a penalty is to deter, not destroy." I don't know if this actually the point like you suggest, but why do you believe this should be the point?
- count 4y agoA death penalty for the company shouldn't involve all those people losing their jobs, it should involve the wiping out of the existing shareholders and the sale of assets at auction to another buyer, who, presumably, would continue to operate the business in a law abiding manner.
- forgotusername6 4y ago
- raisin_churn 4y agoI don't have enough information to form strong opinions about this specific case, but > what White Castle's lawyers described as "annihilative liability" sounds like something that should very much be on the table more frequently when large companies have repeated egregious violations of law as is alleged here.
- vineyardmike 4y agoThis is a common tactic in law suits. Go for the biggest flashiest number, to set the tone. It also helps shareholders be more willing to see a large settlement. In this case, they’re alleging every finger scan violates consent while White Castle says they should settle with the initial scan violated consent -once per employee. If the initial suit was for a more modest sum and a more modest allegation, White Castle may never have even considered admitting fault. I agree though, that we need laws with teeth so big companies can’t consider it a cost of doing business. The 17B number could wipe out many businesses entirely. Maybe they should. Chapter 11 protects the economy and jobs by ensuring the organization could still run, just with shareholders losing out.
- more_corn 4y agoThis is silly. They’re being penalized for not adding a legal form to their onboarding. There’s no real option to say no. Biometric auth is a condition of employment. If you can’t say no it’s not consent. The punitive judgement would in no way protect citizens from future abuses. It’d just make every company spend more on lawyers. I don’t disagree with protecting people from having their biometric data collected without consent, I just don’t think another page of incomprehensible legal bullshit in your hiring packet does anything to protect anyone. Again it’s not consent if you can’t say no. If it’s a condition of employment many vulnerable people cannot say no.
- anonymousiam 4y agoSo they implemented the fingerprint system in 2004, but the biometric law was enacted in 2008. Yeah, suddenly they were breaking the new law, but whose job was it to continuously monitor all the state/local laws and ensure compliance? Not every business gets this right and they should not be severely punished when behavior that had been legal for years suddenly became illegal. Obviously White Castle did not intentionally violate the 2008 law when they implemented the system in 2004.
- jahewson 4y ago> whose job was it to continuously monitor all the state/local laws and ensure compliance For a company over 100 years old with 10,000 employees? I suspect the answer is their compliance department.
- wonderwonder 4y agoWaiting for the inevitable follow up story where the company has been sharing the data with law enforcement.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoAnd selling to Experian along with the pay stubs.
- Cody_C 4y agoCan you imagine the founder of White Castle being shown this in some quick burst of future vision? He would have to have his mind blown beyond belief. He was born in 1880. https://www.whitecastle.com/about-us/our-history https://www.whitecastle.com/about-us/our-history Gotta say those are some good burgers, regardless of the biometrics case.
- giardini 4y ago24 Hour Fitness gyms asks for a fingerprint/thumbprint on each visit. Is this not legal? It doesn't work well for me: I always must make multiple login attempts and inevitably an employee must intervene and approve. I miss their previous system which used a simple bar code.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoAre you in Illinois? I’d still refuse it.