18 ms·
Speech is violence? Not if we want a liberal, intellectual society
- giantg2 4y ago"To be sure, that doesn’t mean that deliberately offending people for its own sake is morally acceptable, or that people should be entitled to use speech to incite violence, harass, or threaten." The difficulty is knowing what the intent was. Usually there are ways of "non-violent" communication. But it seems a lot of it is subjective. By far it seems the most restrictive places are primary and secondary schools.
- henrikschroder 4y ago> The difficulty is knowing what the intent was. It's not a coincidence that the postmodern thoughts that underpin a lot of this bullshit simply does away with intent, declaring it to be completely useless, and saying that the only thing that can be used to judge a message is how it affected the recipient. Combine that with "words are violence", and you can manufacture physical abuse out of thin air. It's really not the way forward for progressivism.
- __derek__ 4y agoI never associated Hilary Putnam with postmodernism, but I suppose he could have been affected by something in the air while writing The Meaning of 'Meaning'.[1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hilary_Putnam#Semantic_externalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hilary_Putnam#Semantic_externa...
- DubiousPusher 4y ago> It's not a coincidence that the postmodern thoughts that underpin a lot of this bullshit simply does away with intent Please make the connection between the disregard of intent and any rigorous definition of "post-moderism". Genuinely I don't see it. I think the degradation of intent is more at the hands of those who have used it as a shield than anyone else. We've seen entire regions of the world thrown into chaos without consequence. Why, because the responsible parties didn't intend the chaos. At a certain point it gets a little thin. What's imporant here is scale. Yeah, if you say something that rubs someone the wrong way, they should be able to have a conversation with you about your intentions and weigh those in their judgement. But what if it keeps happening. How long does someone else need to value your intent? 10 times? 100 times? Forever? And of course when we get to things that affect people's lives on a much more material basis, maybe its good that we stop counting intent for so much. Maybe what we need is for decision makers to get a little more cautios because they will actually feel some consequences if they really screw up a lot of people's lives.
- XorNot 4y agoThe guy who says things were "just a joke" when he see's the frown of disapproval...but he never apologizes. And he also doesn't stop doing it. It's "just a joke" every time.
- DubiousPusher 4y agoPerfect explanation of how "intentions" can come not to matter because we all know and hate this type of personal interaction. Well done.
- wwweston 4y agoPostmodernism absolutely does not deny intent. In fact, motivation behind texts/speech (as well as interpretation by readers/hearers) is such an important part of it that you can't really do postmodern analysis without accounting for motives. The closest thing I can imagine for any kind of defense of your statement is that postmodernism will not let the declared or conscious intent of the speaker absolutely constrain a text. The logical distinctions between "not absolutely constraining" and "declaring it to be completely useless" should be clear. And the idea that people don't always declare their intent accurately should also be uncontroversial. Really, postmodernism is essentially very big elaboration on the principles underlying Sinclair's observation "it is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it."
- freejazz 4y agoCompletely ignorant use of the word "Postmodern" for 1000, Alex
- hpen 4y agoMore like postmodernism throws away objectivity. Which In practice often leads to baseless assumptions about intent.
- CamperBob2 4y agoPeople who equate speech with violence have generally never known physical violence. I've always held that position firmly. The trouble is, people are turning out to be a lot more programmable than I thought they (we) were. You could almost say that we're becoming more like machines at the same time that machines are becoming more like us. To the extent that's true, the part of the old saying that goes "... but words will never hurt me" can be seen as less valid.
- fallingknife 4y agoPeople who equate speech with violence are usually looking for a way to respond to speech with violence.
- pessimizer 4y agoAgreed. It's an announcement that you've determined that some speech has to be crushed, but also preemptively framing it as self-defense. It's like when you first hear about Libertarians having a Non-Aggression Principle at their core, but then you start to hear how they redefine "aggression." In a very similar way, when Group A starts calling Group B "terrorist," it's really an announcement that Group A is going to be compromising their own professed ethics and processes to destroy Group B. It's an announcement of martial law, not a label that reliably describes any particular behavior by "terrorist" groups. Speech- and thought-violence rhetoric is just empty rationalization and crybully rhetoric from the powerless, but it's often a prelude to a brutal crackdown when it comes from the powerful.
- flippinburgers 4y agoYou bring up a very observable fact about how the extreme left is approaching the right via antifa. I don't see a reason for downvotes.
- fallingknife 4y agoMy comment is not directed towards any one political orientation.
- poszlem 4y agoAlthough violent speech may seem hard to swallow, the alternative of censorship has been shown throughout history to be far more detrimental. It seems that the younger generation has not fully understood this fact, but hopefully they will come to understand it through the lessons of others, rather than through their own experiences.
- eastbound 4y agoHas it? I see censorship as being extremely successful nowadays. It seems to keep the world together nowadays. Imagine we’d publish everything we know, many people would oppose.
- snerbles 4y agoHistory has shown us repeatedly - the next generation will only learn when the heel of the boot they cheer for is crushing their own throats.
- fsckboy 4y ago> Although violent speech is unacceptable speech inciting violence is unacceptable. Speech isn't by it's nature violent--although it might be called forceful--and I would refrain from ever calling speech violent. (and even speech inciting violence turns out to be acceptable to a majority of people in conditions where you say you want to kill (for example) a pedophile or a racist, or when you're writing a Declaration of Independence or a French National Anthem (La Marseillaise) because everybody agrees, the Tree of Liberty must periodically be watered by the blood of tyrants!) my comment is a little bit all over the place, but what I'm trying to say is, you should never agree to call speech violence but always put in the word "incite/ment"; and at the same time it's difficult to make any broad or universal statements about speech without discovering it's a complex subject. Humans are good at imagination or conceptualizing hypotheticals, and we have the capacity for violence, so it's very difficult to say what someone can and can't say, usually the listener understands implicitly but sometimes the person listening does not have your interstests at heart, has their own motives, or is plain nutso.
- luckylion 4y agoBut having a <ul> without display:block and adding custom oversized dots that aren't aligned to the line - we can all agree that is violence, can't we?
- halkony 4y agoAt first I thought it was noscript causing a formatting issue but when I turned it off it was still messed up lol. Agreed
- vannevar 4y agoI don't think that most of the people who equate hate speech with violence are literally requesting assualt charges be brought. They are calling for boycotts and de-platforming, both of which fall well within the bounds of the "marketplace of ideas." While there is indeed no right to not be offended, there is also no right to be listened to, and no right to artificially amplify your speech on someone else's dime. We live in a world where the mechanisms of mass communication are held in private hands---there is no digital public square, regardless of what techno-libertarians might have you believe. So there are speech winners and there are speech losers, chosen generally by capital. If you want to change that and have a public platform, you'll have to consider the digital equivalent of communism. Until then, you'll have to live with mass suppression of speech just as you live with mass amplification of it. They are two sides of the same coin.
- giantg2 4y agoThey may not be requesting assault charges, but they may be requesting pain and suffering compensation, or using "unkind" comments as leverage in a divorce. Edit: Why disagree?
- vannevar 4y agoI didn't downvote you, but I haven't heard of any kind of mass movement to get pain and suffering damages from Donald Trump's tweets, as painful as they were to endure. If you're talking about libel, that's a separate thing, and has been around since before the First Amendment. If you publish untrue things and they harm someone, of course you can (and should) be held liable for your words. Divorce is also a different situation, where someone's words may be fair game as evidence of actions and character, depending on the circumstances.
- giantg2 4y agoThings like harassment, or intentional infliction of emotional distress can be a basis for pain and suffering lawsuits. https://www.forbes.com/advisor/legal/personal-injury/suing-emotional-distress/ https://www.forbes.com/advisor/legal/personal-injury/suing-e... Things like insults, shaming, and verbal abuse are part of emotional abuse in divorce cases. These need not be evidence of actions or character. These can be used for an at fault divorce. What is consided to br an insult or shaming can vary greatly on perspective. Not to mention, the court may not stick ro just these examples and could include other things that makes the other person feel bad - "I hate this meal. Why do you always make this?" https://www.jerkinsfamilylaw.com/emotional-abuse-and-divorce--how-do-you-prove-it-and-what-will-it-mean https://www.jerkinsfamilylaw.com/emotional-abuse-and-divorce...
- fallingfrog 4y agoThe kinds of censorship that really bothers me is when people like Ron deSantis use the power of the state to force people like university professors to say specific things and muzzle them from saying other things. That's actual government censorship.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThose professors and teachers are employees of the government. Like it or not, that puts them under the same umbrella as police officers, fire fighters, and others. Government employees are very much restricted in what they can say and do when they are on the clock.
- ausbah 4y agono it doesn't, technically sure but universities are suppose to be free from controlled speech like this. see why tenure and academic freedom exist
- pclmulqdq 4y agoAcademic freedom is not a legal concept, and unfortunately the law trumps the ideals in this case. However, academic freedom isn't exactly unlimited: a tenured physics professor who doesn't teach a class on physics, publish a paper on physics, or advise a student for 10 years will likely be fired at most institutions (unless they have a nobel prize or something). Professors working at state schools have additional limits on their academic freedom. This is why you don't tend to see theology departments at state schools. Also, in practice, you could reasonably argue that there generally isn't much academic freedom in most fields, since most research is grant-funded, and that is controlled by (usually) governments.
- fallingfrog 4y agoAmazing how quickly people will pivot to "actually, it's ok to censor campus professors" as soon as the censored ideas are ones they don't like.
- jrm4 4y agoLawyer here, and this definitely strikes me as one of a surprising number topics in which, the law has for some time, already a very effective and useful way to get at this concept. Sure, speech can be harmful and hurtful, to the point that someone should get punished for it. But the law has generally done very good job of reminding us that this tends to be a VERY NARROW possibility, i.e. the harm has to be very specific and directed and measurable.
- csdvrx 4y ago> the law has generally done very good job of reminding us that this tends to be a VERY NARROW possibility, i.e. the harm has to be very specific and directed and measurable. Here in the US, yes. In the rest of the world (like, EU) they aren't very specific.
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoThe one good thing about America.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoThere are other good things, but it is certainly a deficiency in Europe. Some criminalize insults pretty heavily. While the thought behind that might be decent, I don't believe it to work in the future. For example in Germany the first amendment protects dignity. An ideal law nobody can really fully adhere to. It works because there is a societal consensus about its meaning. Nothing the law can really determine. I believe this consensus will not really survive the 21st century. Perspectives will be too different. Dignity in religious communities means something entirely different than in a secular society, and even in that values will diverge more and more. A lot of these laws are ancient and many were intended to protect monarchy from vulgar peasants, so I am a bit surprised "progressive" forces seem to have found their love for it. In the interest of civil liberties, these laws would need to be changed at some point. They basically allow authority to selectively punish anyone under almost any pretense.
- garbagecoder 4y ago
- Joeboy 4y ago> few liberal-minded commentators seemed eager to say Rushdie was entirely without fault This does not match my recollection. As I recall things, Rushdie was vigorously defended by the left, which at the time quite liked the idea of freedom of speech. At least in the UK, can't speak for anywhere else.
- DubiousPusher 4y agoI would say he was quite vigorously defended by liberals. Since the 1970s there pretty much hasn't been such a thing as the left, especially in Rushdie's hayday of the 80s-00s. If there was, I doubt it would've spent much time worrying about the fate of a bourgeoisie fantasist. Nothing against Rushdie btw. I loved the Satanic Verses. But institutional journalism (which provides the fundamental model most people use to understand Anglo politics) has conflated the terms left and liberal. And while I respect the drift of language as natural and intrinsic to culture, this misplacement has created a silly situation in which hypocracy, action and in-action are misattributed. Because these are two groups (overlapping in some cases) but distinct in a fundamental way. In fact, I would say articles such as this are entirely flawed in that they don't grasp this distinction because they take institutional journalism's political narrative way past its power to describe reality. Edit: BTW, this affects conservatives and "the Right" as well. Most of the people that rise to the top of the Rupblican and Tory parties are effectively "liberal". Most would not abolish civil liberties, equality before the law, etc. Just about everyone elected to government in both the UK and the US in all parties sit on a spectrum of liberalism. Mostly they just disagree about what year the government needed to stop doing things to create a "liberal" society.
- hbn 4y agoPerson A: "Speech causes violence!" Person B: "How so?" Person A: proceeds to beat Person B until he stops talking
- akomtu 4y agoIf A could beat B, he wouldn't resort to such rhetoric. Person A has a repressed desire to bully that manifests as this passive-aggressive fake politeness.
- anigbrowl 4y agoThis is false. Sometimes rhetoric is deployed to mask incapacity, sometimes it's just a delaying tactic - eg to get person B nervous or to allow time for person A's accomplices to close in.
- jojobas 4y agoBefore going violent you want to frighten as many opponents opponents into submission - violence has a cost even to the stronger party. Also group A has the power to subdue group B by other means than violence.
- PaulHoule 4y agoIn 2023 that ‘speech’ could well be spam generated by ChatGPT. ‘Free speech’ isn’t the right model to describe coordinated inauthentic communications, spam, agenda spamming, disinformation, etc. In case where capacity to receive messages is limited, communications can be vandalism if not violence.
- commandlinefan 4y agoEvery possible alternative you could suggest is worse.
- airhack 4y agoIt's interesting because in French, to speak literally translated would give something like "take the talk". (prendre la parole) So when somebody speaks, he takes something with, I guess, the hidden assumption that he/she's preventing others from taking it.
- fallingfrog 4y agoWhen a message board or user is kicked off a platform, it's never for "saying the wrong thing" or "political correctness". It's generally because they organized targeted campaigns of harassment, doxxing, swatting, and other kinds of behavior that violated the terms of service. Take this example: https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/internet/cloudflare-kiwi-farms-keffals-anti-trans-rcna44834 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/internet/cloudflare-kiwi-farms-... "At least three people have died by suicide after becoming targets of Kiwi Farms harassment campaigns, according to Vice. In 2016, the family of a trans person who died by suicide, Lizzy Waite, was harassed by Kiwi Farms trolls for weeks after her death. She had posted a suicide note on Facebook." "Sorrenti, known to fans of her streaming channel as “Keffals,” says that when her front door opened on Aug. 5 the first thing she saw was a police officer’s gun pointed at her face. It was just the beginning of a weekslong campaign of stalking, threats and violence against Sorrenti that ended up making her flee the country." When we talk about violent forms of speech, this is what we mean. Actual crimes. Note that this website was, in the end, taken down. But the users have moved on to other spaces where they organize harassment campaigns, such as Libs of Tiktok.
- ejb999 4y ago>>When a message board or user is kicked off a platform, it's never for "saying the wrong thing" or "political correctness". That is not what I have seen - what about all the MDs and scientists that warned about possible side-effects of the vaccine, but since their opinions were not approved by the government, were kicked off twitter/facebook etc? How about the NYPost being de-platformed for reporting on the hunter biden laptop story? a story which has now been admitted to being true?
- kneebonian 4y agoI was recently suspended from a platform for "hate speechd when I brought up the Pakistani rape gangs that were operating in the UK. It turns out hate speech means speech somebody hates.
- commandlinefan 4y ago> it's never for "saying the wrong thing" or "political correctness" My reddit account was permanently suspended for upvoting vaccine skepticism.
- rini17 4y agoNot so long ago, bodily punishments were considered fully acceptable, or even beneficial. So the distinction against physical violence which this article paints as clear, is in fact a recent development. Which may or may not continue further.
- kelseyfrog 4y ago> In contrast, physical violence is an uncomplicated, universal offender. A punch to the face hurts everyone. What a completely deranged take. It's easy to conceive of a thought experiment that absolutely destroys this perspective. Imagine that I've applied lidocaine to my face and you punch me. Then someone points out that because I didn't feel pain, that "It's ok to punch other people in the face." The author's argument makes about as much sense, ie: none.
- stonogo 4y agoIn this strawman argument, are you asserting that lidocaine prevents the punch from causing physical damage?
- kelseyfrog 4y agoIf the author was implying damage, he did an incredibly poor job at conveying that. He said "hurt" not "damage."
- stonogo 4y agoYou're going to have a frustrating time if you use that kind of pedantry to build a bad-faith interpretation of the proposed argument. "Joey got hurt in the boxing match" does not generally mean he was offended by the color of his opponent's shorts, and when someone talks about a punch in the face hurting someone they're using the broadest sense of the word 'hurt,' which is commonly accepted to encompass all of emotional pain, physical damage, and the deleterious effect of violence on any given community. Choosing the specific definition that makes the argument weakest isn't really productive unless you're just looking to get mad about something.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoLanguage is always evolving, and words do not always need to be tethered to their denotative meaning for us to understand what people mean.
- somesortofthing 4y agoI think this article makes a key mistake that I see almost all commentators make of visions of free speech less radical than, say, the first amendment: They consider only the direct effects of speech on those who hear it. If you accept this, it's very easy to(correctly) respond that it's not the state's job to police mere offense, no matter how grave it may be. Some people who try to make criticisms of a radical free speech regime(such as the NYT author this article mentions) also fall into this trap, but I think the much more compelling for limiting speech is less about harm done by speech to listeners and more about incitement of physical harm. It's very, very easy to communicate in ways that encourage and incite violence(be it direct physical violence or denial of the means to live a dignified life), especially against groups against whom such violence is already normalized. Not all speech that does incite violence is intended to, but this fact also lends plausible deniability to people who do explicitly want violence but know that it's socially unacceptable to call for it directly. There is the danger of being overzealous with what speech to limit, but at the same time, it's undeniable that a lot of money and attention is flowing to ever-bolder provocateurs whose only possible goal is to escalate existing tensions and iniquities to violence in service of their political aims. Taking such people at their word on their intentions is dangerous, and those who do so have no right to act surprised and claim innocence when actions and rhetoric escalate past the point they're comfortable with.
- kneebonian 4y ago> but at the same time, it's undeniable that a lot of money and attention is flowing to ever-bolder provocateurs whose only possible goal is to escalate existing tensions and iniquities to violence in service of their political aims. Then you should defeat them in the marketplace of ideas and be able to counter their facillous words. To suggest otherwise is to stand in a position where you claim that some people are incapable of intelligently reasoning about something and that another superior individual should be able to police what they hear. If someone says racist hateful things you're argument is that people should not be allowed to listen to it because it is a "bad thing" and other people who aren't as wise as you shoudlnt be allowed to hear it because they might act violently.
- 4y ago
- tomlockwood 4y ago"In nations where millions of people hold diverse beliefs, who gets to decide exactly when speech becomes “harmful” and which people should be protected from offensive or critical speech?" I don't know, maybe we could all get together and collectively decide with some kind of voting mechanism??? Or, if voting every time is too onerous, we could elect a "representative" to stand in for our views? Just a thought!
- tempnow987 4y agoBut are we allowed to even discuss the topics - or will folks be burned / punched for even discussing the ideas?
- tomlockwood 4y agoWho isn't allowing us to discuss the topics?
- HonestOp001 4y agoThe news media, journalists, anti- whatever activists. Look at coronavirus and the lock step nature of journalism when people said the truth about distancing not being effective, keep the schools open, etc. people were banned from Twitter, YouTube pulled down videos and / or bd special pop ups to tell you to be wary about this person’s point of view.
- tomlockwood 4y agoAnd yet, I see this sentiment constantly and this point of view discussed.
- poszlem 4y agoYes, it's a great idea to let people decide what is and isn't true. We know that the more people decide something the better decision they make, that's why mobs of people are known for their cold and rational approach to issues. We could even go one step further and establish the dictatorship of the proletariat and they could decide what is and isn't true. We would have an office, let's call it General Directorate for the Protection of State Secrets in the Press. Главлит in short.
- gizmo 4y agoThis article is too long and says too little. The real debate about free speech is about finding the right balance between harms caused by speech and harms caused by censorship. It's about the distinction between highly protected forms of speech like journalism, ideas, and protests/strikes, and undesirable speech such as incitements to hatred, slander/harassment, spam, and predatory speech. As a society you have to figure out which kinds of speech is deserving of broad platforms (talks at universities, interviews on national TV), which kind of speech should be downranked but not banned, and which kind should result in outright de-platforming or even prosecution. The "speech is violence" rhetoric just means that speech has actual consequences and that we should look at these consequences instead of unthinkingly taking an absolutist free speech position. Free speech is never an absolute, and as anybody who has spent a lot of time online knows, there cannot be free speech without moderation (i.e. censorship).
- kneebonian 4y agoYes but the problem turns out that no matter how you define it whatever criteria you use to restrict speech will eventually become redefined to mean. "What those in power currently dislike." It's why the first amendment is their to recognize speech should not be limited because if it ever is, it will never stop being so.
- gizmo 4y agoThe first amendment doesn't protect literally all speech. Never has, never will. And your assertion that restrictions on speech (e.g. banning spammers) will inevitably lead to some kind of authoritarian dystopia is purely speculative.
- 99_00 4y ago"Speech is violence" doesn't exist as a principle in modern western societies. It's a slogan and call for a coordinated mass political attack against an identified target. It is applied by political partisans to attack their enemies and not applied to themselves or their allies. It's cynical, crass, mass political power put into action. Reluctant participants are dragged along under the implied threat that they will be targeted because "inaction is complicity" or some similar slogan.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- keerthiko 4y ago[flagged]
- luckylion 4y ago> For example, "cancel culture" doesn't seem like a problem to me. It's a pretty reasonable and sensible response by people who disagree with opinions shared by individuals with large platforms taking liberties to hurt people. Would you feel differently if it wasn't about canceling those who "hurt people" (where we again would need a definition of what is violent speech that hurts)? Like, if some group went out to cancel people because of their skin color, religion, sexual orientation, political persuasion, gender etc, would that also fall under "reasonable and sensible"? After all, these mobs would be just as offended by some person's reach/platform/existence as the ones who are doing the canceling now.
- devmor 4y ago"Would you feel differently if some imaginary scenario that isn't happening were instead happening?" What exactly is the point of asking this? The answer is obvious and it isn't what's happening.
- keerthiko 4y agoFor the sake of this discussion, I'll define "cancel" as in "cancel culture". It would be to "boycott their activity, discourage others patronizing them, and prominently proclaim you do not agree with them or want to support them financially or the growth of their platform, with the aim of aligning collective action to reduce their influence". > Like, if some group went out to cancel people because of their skin color Are you, by any chance, referring to racism? This flavor of "cancel culture" transcends my definition in a lot of ways (often involving physical violence, unjust law enforcement incarceration, employment discrimination and more). Also it is as old as modern global civilization, far predating the modern discourse about free speech, and yes, I dislike it. And so we as a society exert some amount of opposing force in response again, by "canceling" the racists in turn. This feedback loop continues for generations, and we slowly (hopefully) trend towards a less racist society. So how do I feel about it? I dislike racism, but it exists today as part of an ecosystem of forces that seems reasonable to me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Apreche 4y agoXKCD 1357 End thread. Please never open it again. https://xkcd.com/1357/ https://xkcd.com/1357/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vxNsr 4y agoOf all the asinine takes on free speech this one is the worst. Freedom of speech is a concept and idea, the government doesn’t have the right nor ability to police or grant anyone an intrinsic freedom they already have. All the government can do is lend some of its protections to help prevent others from trying to stop you from speaking freely. But as a society if we say that your right to free speech only exists in government buildings. Well… that’s not anything at all.
- Joeboy 4y agoAs well as just being an awful take in general, this is a staggeringly inappropriate take on the Rushdie situation.
- anigbrowl 4y agoWhile this comic does a good job of expressing a particular idea, it has become its own thought-terminating cliche.
- trieste92 4y agoI wonder how well this will age with the current legal climate and cloudiness around 230
- dadjoker 4y ago"What many people failed to understand, and therefore failed to defend, is an unpleasant fact of intellectual liberalism: When speech causes emotional or mental pain, the offended parties are morally entitled to nothing in the form of compensation from or punishment for the offender." A line that many people still can't handle.
- devmor 4y agoIt's entirely subjective. For instance, if you're a Christian, the Bible would have you beaten, stoned, amputated or killed for different types of speech deemed offensive to specific parties. The US legal system also provides many avenues for punishing people based on their speech. Most legal systems and most religions follow similar rules.
- Zetice 4y agoIt’s not that people expect compensation or punishment, it’s that as private citizens, we’re totally and completely free to judge the shit out of people for what they say and do. I don’t expect the government to step in when someone says something hateful, but I do pay attention to which groups allow that kind of behavior in their associations and which don’t. We all do have a right to leave the rooms hateful people are in, and the people in charge of those rooms (as long as its not the government) are free to control how their space gets used.
- aidenn0 4y agoThis privileges the government as one of many organizations with outsized power. Should we also restrict private, yet powerful, organizations from similar actions? Clearly the article was considering various non-governmental institutions as places where liberal intellectualism are traditionally important and whether or not they should continue to have those values.
- bjt2n3904 4y agoI've been told that not only is my speech violence, but so is my silence.
- devmor 4y agoAnother thinkpiece positing that facing consequences for saying fucked up shit is somehow a bad thing. How many of these must we suffer through? Why do none of these people grasp the concept that when you speak to other people, they do not have to passively absorb your words? This author, like many others, could use the sage advice my father gave me in 5th grade when I taunted and made fun of another student and got beat up for it: "Don't let your mouth write checks your ass can't cash."
- Swenrekcah 4y agoThere are two distinct things people often confuse on either side of this issue. Say a stupid/offending/violent thing and you’ll face consequences from 1) other people listening in the form of shunning/shouting/lost opportunities/laughing. 2) the government in form of fines or even imprisonment. People on both sides get all hot and bothered when they receive 1) and complain that they have freedom of speech or that their opponents are bigots. This should mostly be ignored, like you said: "Don't let your mouth write checks your ass can't cash." Some people however want their opponents to face 2) and that is very dangerous. That is literally fascism and this sentiment exists on both sides as well. It’s 2) we need to defend against and pretending that we’re only talking about 1) is a fatal misunderstanding.
- devmor 4y agoThe problem is that people keep getting upset at 1) and use 2) as a justification for why it's "morally wrong" for 1) to be happening to them. I have genuinely never seen anyone calling for 2) outside of nations run by theocracies and dictators, with the exception of the UK.
- Swenrekcah 4y agoI see numerous calls for hate speech laws to be used against all sorts of people every year in many democratic countries.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kneebonian 4y agoDid you guys know it is illegal to say "I want to kill the President of the United States of America". It is illegal it is a federal offence, it's one of the only sentences that your not allowed to say. Now it was okay for me to say because I was telling you it was illegal to say "I want to kill the President of the United States of America", because I wasn't saying it, I was telling you it was illegal to say it, like a public service. But it is not illegal to say "with a mortar launcher", because that's it's own sentence. It's an incomplete sentence but it may have nothing to do with the sentence before that. So that's perfectly fine, perfectly legal. It's incredibly illegal, extremely illegal to go on the internet and say something like "The best place to fire a mortar launcher at the White House would be from the roof of the Rockerfeller Hewitt building, because of minimal security and you'd have a clear line of sight to the President's bedroom." That's insanely illegal, ridiculously illegal, recklessly illegal, horribly illegal, extremely felonious, super illegal because they will come to your house in the middle of the night and they will lock you up. Extremely against the law One thing that is technically legal to say is "We have a group that meets Friday's at midnight under the Brooklyn bridge and the password is sic semper tyranus"
- Bytewave81 4y agoA true classic. RIP Trevor Moore. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eg3_kUaYFJA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eg3_kUaYFJA
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoOn the other hand, you can't have your liberal, intellectual society if you allow people to go around making credible threats of violence, which are "just speech" if you subscribe to the speech-is-speech, violence-is-violence approach. If you have to wait until the threat is realized, then any group capable of having members take the punishment for individual acts of violence can grant credibility to making threats to others. To avoid their society devolving into "rule by overt threat of violence", people typically agree that someone who says "I will shoot John Doe between the 3rd and 4th ribs with the FAL I have in my attic using this .308 round at 2:13 pm tomorrow as he walks his kids to school like he does every day except Tuesday, unless he pays me $500" should be able to be stopped, violently if necessary, before they have a chance to actualize their speech. Arguing whether that speech is, in-of-itself, violence comes down to the messy semantics of trying to define violence. The fact that it is unacceptable is relatively unanimously agreed upon. So the question isn't "Can speech be unacceptable?" it's "What kind of speech is unacceptable?". The example I gave was a specific, actionable, and credible threat against an individual, by the individual that intended to carry out the threatened violence. I'll assume most readers would mark that as "acceptably provoking punishment". Where it gets messy is when you start shaving off qualifiers. For example, someone stating "I'm going to kill all the programmers, and here's how" is potentially making a credible and actionable threat, but against a non-specific group of people. Is that worthy of punishment? What about someone with a large audience saying "It is our moral obligation to eliminate the programmers by any means necessary", maybe wink-winking and nudge-nudging at a guillotine in the background. It's not specific, and they're not saying THEY are going to be the ones to commit the violence, but it's still a little hinky. In my opinion, that last one is probably the source of most discourse around "is speech violence". Most everyone is okay with suppressing more overt threats than that. It's when you get to that line that people break down into the camps of "people using their influence to benefit by threatening violence in a plausibly deniable way" warranting (self)defense or not. So saying "but my free speech" or "it's just speech" isn't really a compelling point. We all agree that some kinds of violent speech should be suppressed. The question is simply where the line gets drawn.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> The question is simply where the line gets drawn. Not that simple. First you have to decide who gets to draw it.
- Zetice 4y agoSigh, every single time this comes up, people gloss over the part of freedom of speech that involves free association. I’m free to say, “i hate <thing>”, and you’re free to refuse to associate with me as a result of that. It’s so simple. The government can’t, but you can. As long as we all agree with that, then yeah freedom of speech is great, you just don’t get to stop applying it when you feel satisfied.
- rajin444 4y agoThis argument always comes up too and you end up with certain people trying to force others to bake cakes a certain way. The whole idea of “protected classes” spits in the face of free speech. I think free speech is a noble goal but can only really exist when we don’t live in a zero sum world. Until then: > "When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean. Neither more or less." Alice responded to Humpty Dumpty, "The question is, whether you can make words mean so many different things?" Humpty Dumpty retorted: "The question is, which is to be master? That's all."
- flangola7 4y agoThe cake thing isn't about speech but public accomodations.
- comte7092 4y agoExactly, no one is barging into private homes and forcing people to bake cakes for strangers. It’s about what you’re required to do if you’re open for business to the public.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- imgabe 4y agoNo it wasn’t. The issue was a custom made cake. The court ruled that the cake constituted an artistic expression (i.e. speech) on the part of the baker and they couldn’t be compelled to produce speech they disagreed with. If they just wanted a premade cake there would have been no issue. Suppose at some point gay marriage is overturned, and some conservative group goes to a gay baker and commissions a cake saying "Hooray no more gay marriage! God is good!". Should they be compelled to bake that cake since they can't discriminate on the basis of religion? You might disagree with that logic, but the ruling had to do with free speech, not public accommodations. Commissioning a custom work is not a public accommodation.
- jzb 4y agoIf we want a "liberal, intellectual society" we absolutely have to consider some speech "violence." To use one current example: The people pushing the idea of trans people as "groomers" is violence. It is not an intellectual debate, it's not necessary to entertain in order to preserve free thought, etc. The goal of that speech is to other trans people and it endangers them. Tolerance of that kind of speech ensures that trans people cannot participate equally in society when there's no consequences for trying to stoke hate and encourage stochastic terrorism. At some point, if we cannot agree that things like that are unacceptable I don't see how we ever move forward.
- TheFreim 4y ago[flagged]
- teolandon 4y agoDid you misread something in the parent comment? They were talking about pushing the idea of trans people as groomers, in general. Trans people existing doesn't mean they're performing any type of child abuse.
- anigbrowl 4y agoThe idea that it's "violence" to oppose child abuse proves that the point, speech being "violence" is absurd. Hold up; you're saying that the act of appearing or speaking in public while dressed/presenting in ways that are stereotypical of the opposite sex is abuse. This seems like the exact opposite of the point you are trying to make.
- michaelanders 4y ago[dead]
- gazpachotron 4y ago[dead]
- kneebonian 4y agoYes some people employ terms to other people based on religious belief or skin color, should it be acceptable to "other" people by calling them Christofacist? Or suggesting that we should #killallmen? Why should prefixing a proposal with the phrase "trans" suddenly allow one to invalidate other people's rights? And before you say that is extreme, hypothetical or doesn't count because it comes from a position of power my own ancestors were driven out of their homes in 4 states and had an extermination order issued against them by the state of Missouri based on people abusing free speech against them.
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoThe very first example given, of Rushdie having a fatwa against him, is framed as an example of trying to answer "Why should we defend his writing?" And the general conclusion is that we owe nothing to the "injured" party (in this case, Muslim clerics). But the Muslim clerics issued their own violent speech. Their speech could have led to the assassination of a human being. Does that speech owe anything to the injured (read: dead) party? Should we allow speech to incite people to kill, "because intellectual liberalism?" The answer, enshrined into law in most nations, is: no. We don't let you get away with killing people by incitement of violence. Your speech has consequences, and in many cases, you will be held accountable; if not by the law, then by vigilante justice. (This isn't an argument, it's a fact proved by the opposing argument) You can choose to make the distinction that if you don't see physical harm, that that's not real harm, and thus, doesn't matter. But certain speech can in fact cause physical harm. The consequences of certain speech, by certain people, in certain contexts, can be debilitating, physically painful, nauseating, and drive people insane, even to suicide. In many cases it simply isn't a choice; your body just reacts to stimuli. The simplest example is kids who kill themselves from incessant traumatic bullying. Even if you think those kids should "toughen up" and "just deal with it", that's not how the brain works. Some people in society are more vulnerable to suggestion and more likely to self-harm than others, and a non-stop barrage of hate and intimidation puts them in a traumatic state. The feeling of anguish is so much they commit suicide to stop the pain. Speech does do real harm, both directly and indirectly. So, where does that leave us? Arguing over to what degree "verbal harm" counts as "real harm"? Waiting for someone to die, then deciding who, if anyone, gets the blame? This is a pointless morass, because the whole problem can be avoided by just not fucking with people intentionally. Just like with other crimes, sometimes people do harm by accident, and we deal with that in many ways. But when people do harm intentionally, that's a much more serious matter. Thus we don't need this pointless philosophical diatribe to justify our ability to cause harm at will. If you're going to be a dick, then be a dick. But don't pretend you're doing it to defend some high-minded ideal. You're doing it because you're a dick, and there is no defense for that.
- disembiggen 4y agoI am not a liberal. Many people are not. The paradox of tolerance is the easy counterarguement to this. If you choose to never do anything in response to the things people say that's your perogative, I on the other hand can listen just fine to other people and my response to the things they say might be to tell them to stop saying it. "I don't believe you should be allowed to say this without consequence" is also a thing one can say.
- kneebonian 4y agoAh yes the paradox of tolerance. The "our enemies will stop us so we must stop them first" argument. Never found it convincing for some reason.
- Swenrekcah 4y agoWell it actually is something that people have to be aware of. There’s a reason for the “ah you see, the cops have to follow the rules taps forehead” trope. It’s genuinely hard to maintain a truly tolerant liberal democracy in the face of determined adversaries that can skillfully use the system against itself. Now, that is no reason to take sloppy shortcuts like saying this or that opinion should be banned, but it is absolutely worth keeping in mind.
- flangola7 4y agoWhen you see someone walking towards you with a knife and he says "I am going to stab you", you don't wait for him for to make physical contact before you decide to draw your gun. The Nazi party was in power for over a decade before the first gas chamber was built. If they had been stopped at the broadcasting hate propaganda stage millions of lives would have been saved, and a war requiring the collective military capacity of the rest of the hemisphere wouldn't have been necessary. Perhaps the most important lesson of the 20th century is that the broadcasting of the right words for long enough and to enough people can cause destruction and death orders of magnitude greater than any single weapon of war.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- breadbreadbread 4y agoI think this article comes very close to saying "don't let words affect you", which is fundamentally impossible to ask anyone to do and taken to it's logical conclusion I should also not absorb anything in the article. I also think this article also ignores the fact that hateful people often use the language of free speech to justify their own behavior and to punish their critics. Everyday on the internet I see trans people threatened, disrespected, or legislated out of existence... then the ensuing backlash in which people try to reassert the rights of trans people... and then the backlash to the backlash is always "these woke libs trying to cancel us are the real n@zis". It's exhausting. Infuriating. Some speech suppresses the speech of others. And some people don't want to be taught that they are hateful. If you make declarative statements that villainize minority groups, you make others fear for their safety and it silences voices. That is a form of "violent speech", though that term sucks. Free speech isn't just about saying anything you want, it's also about maximizing the number of voices at the table, and to do that you can't just let people get away with saying vile shit.
- gigibec 4y ago[dead]
- trieste92 4y ago> Some speech suppresses the speech of others Isn't this exactly what you're trying to do here? > Free speech isn't just about saying anything you want, it's also about maximizing the number of voices at the table Free speech is "about" whatever is in the first amendment > it's also about maximizing the number of voices at the table Ahh yes, because the people who try to redefine "free speech" like what you're doing are definitely well known for promoting this /s
- banannaise 4y ago> Free speech is "about" whatever is in the first amendment It is very odd to assert that the morality of speech is completely, correctly, and undeniably established in a document written 250 years ago that defines the laws of only one country.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- banannaise 4y agoAs noted (and then, weirdly, disagreed with) in the article, you have to make a clear delineation between speech that is offensive and speech that is abusive. And that is not always an easy distinction to make! Repeatedly using slurs is abusive, but what if the majority of people don't see it as a slur? If your answer is "then it's not a slur", then what do you think of the frequent use of the N-word in the first half of the 20th century? Is it abusive to repeatedly and baselessly accuse an entire group of child abuse ("grooming")? If you repeatedly attend community gatherings to repeat speech that is deliberately offensive to that community, does that rise to the level of abuse? These are reasonable questions that we tend to just skip over when we talk about "cancel culture" and those who are characterized, fairly or unfairly, as victims of it.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoabusive speech isnt illegal either
- gallopingcomp 4y agoWhich is not to the parent comment’s point anyway.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThen maybe I missed the point of the comparison. Why would we care if speech is considered abusive of not? From the perspective of the article, hurtful speech (abuse), is and always will be subject to the interpretation of the listener. As such it will always change with time and context. Anything can be interpreted as abusive speech at any time. It is not a consensus definition.
- danans 4y ago> Consider these statements: > Jesus is not the son of God. All nonbelievers are evil and going to hell. Pornography is morally acceptable. Women should be forced to wear hijabs. American veterans who fought in Iraq are war criminals. The detainees at Guantánamo Bay deserved to be tortured. Capitalism is inherently exploitative, and all wealthy people are morally compromised. Communism is an evil, totalitarian ideology that killed millions of people. The biggest problem with this analysis is that it treats the speech as separate from the power and reach of the person saying them, downplaying the utterances as just information detached from the real world context in which they are used. On any given day, you can probably find a mentally ill person on the streets shouting a number of those things, but people aren't listening. When someone with significant influence, as Yiannapolis was, starts spurting bigotries and abusive speech, the scrutiny on their speech should be greater.
- baron816 4y agoThe thing is, people on the far left and the far right DON’T want a liberal society. They want authoritarianism. They want control to suppress their adversaries.
- realjhol 4y agoThe idea that we can have value-free laws instituted by impartial institutions is a fantasy. By its very nature politics is about rewarding friends and punishing enemies. If the state - any state - regards you as deplorable, then it is totally irrelevant that some piece of paper somewhere might claim you are entitled to some rights. In practice this won't matter. The state will crush you, and the mob will cheer.
- nbardy 4y agoThere is no true scotsman. Doesn't mean we can't have truth
- realjhol 4y agoThat's irrelevant. The fact is that we don't have neutral institutions. Even theoretically it would be extremely unlikely, and in practice it won't happen, chiefly because it would involve people in the in-group making comittiments to deplorable people in the out-group. This might be approximately possible in a united cohesive high-trust society... but that bond of kinship simply doesn't exist anywhere in the West today
- raxxorraxor 4y agoJournalists thought the same while feeling decently smart. They were neither smart nor produced articles worth reading in the end. Anyone can strive to objectivity. Even if you can never reach it, the quality between someone who tries and someone who gives up is tremendous.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoIn the context of the US, everything I’ve seen suggests the right seeks authoritarianism more than the left does, doing things like getting books they don’t agree with banned, working to eliminate the votes of those not aligned with them, and weakening the barrier between church and state.
- pugets 4y agoBeing liberal in the 90’s meant defending controversial or disruptive speech on the premises of the mantra, “I may not agree with what you say, but I’ll defend your right to say it.” This principle operated as a liberal self-preservation tactic. The Church had more influence in society than it does today, and if anyone was going to challenge the status quo, it had to be liberals. Hip hop music, feminist art, raunchy daytime television, and that nasty George Carlin all played a role in challenging the modesty that the Church wanted to preserve. Decades passed. The church lost most of its mainstream power. Raytheon began marketing itself as a diverse workplace. Goldman Sachs marched in parades with rainbow flags. The question of gay marriage was settled. As society liberalized, liberals found themselves usurping the role of cultural hall monitor. It became disadvantageous for liberals to defend controversial speech, so new rationales had to be created to prevent the spread of anti-liberal ideas.
- Joeboy 4y agoMaybe there's something to that, but I think the main thing that happened was that we developed incredible new technology that allowed all of humanity to communicate openly in real time on an equal footing without gatekeepers or censorship. Then we looked at it and decided we didn't like it.
- XorNot 4y agoYou're posting this on a heavily moderated forum with multiple censoring methods.
- Joeboy 4y agoWhich you're telling me because....?
- pugets 4y agoYes, but HN “works” because it is a small-ish community with principled moderators and generally well-educated people. The community guidelines request that commenters assume the best intentions in others. I’ve been in enough heavily-censored forums, groups, and websites to say that too much moderation can be worse than too little.
- kmeisthax 4y ago>In 1989, the novelist Salman Rushdie went into hiding. The supreme leader of Iran, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, had issued a fatwā calling on “all valiant Muslims wherever they may be in the world” to kill the writer without delay, for which the assassin would receive a bounty of $1 million. It's not a good look to start your article on how speech is not violence with a concrete example of someone using speech as violence. Or to then keep referring back to it, but only to chastise liberals and leftists for being mildly critical of Rushdie, rather than the actual god damned supreme leader of Iran who called for his death. Fatwas are exactly the sort of thing I'd point at if I wanted to say that speech is violence. And there are plenty of examples of fatwas in the western world now. Hell, we coined the word "stochastic terrorism" to refer to them, because apparently you're not allowed to call a fatwa a fatwa unless it comes from the Champagne region of France. Otherwise it's just sparkling murder. To be perfectly clear: we can't have a liberal intellectual society in the Arab world[0] for as long as people like the Ayatollahs have power and a platform. Likewise, speech-shaped violence in the Western[1] world harms liberal values way more than left-wingers saying offensive speech is violence. In fact, the reason why left-wingers are up in arms about offensive equals violent is specifically because a lot of that offensive speech comes with implicit fatwas built-in. Bonus inaccuracy nit: >The Roman Catholic Church considered the idea of heliocentricity to be harmful in the 16th century No, they considered insulting the pope to be harmful. The academic establishment wanted heliocentricity dead, because Galileo was a mathematician - the lowest rung of the academic hierarchy at the time. They silenced Galileo by convincing the Catholics that they had been insulted by a book he published on the topic of heliocentricity. [0] Iran is majority Shia Muslim but this isn't specific to one sect. [1] As in, "countries with liberal constitutions and rule of law". Western countries are not literally the westmost parts of the planet.
- brandonmenc 4y ago> It's not a good look to start your article on how speech is not violence with a concrete example of someone using speech as violence. > The supreme leader of Iran, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, had issued a fatwā calling on “all valiant Muslims wherever they may be in the world” to kill the writer without delay, for which the assassin would receive a bounty of $1 million. This is called "putting a hit out" on someone.
- Barrin92 4y agoLiberalism in the broad sense and its attitude to speech suffer from a sort of dualism that's hinted at in the second part of the article. To maintain traditionally liberal views on speech you have to somehow convince yourself that speech and actions are different things. But in reality there is no such distinction and I think in our information age that's become quite obvious. There's nothing privileged about speech, it need not even be human in origin any more. Speech acts are just a means to effect change in the world, it's information in a network directed towards certain ends akin to Klausewitz pointing out that war is just politics by other means. Violence and speech but more generally action and speech are materially the same thing, one is kinetic and the other isn't, but the goal is identical. I think the same is true in regards to money. Speech has entirely been commoditized and it's produced the same conflict under liberal frameworks that violence has. If speech is reach then it is just power and doesn't live in some lofty magical mental space. So the title is right, in liberal societies speech cannot be violence but this is just an instrumental claim to make liberalism work. In the same sense how John Locke had to adopt a Tabula Rasa/Blank Slate view of individuals to justify Natural Rights, which scientifically turns out to be just wrong.
- tootie 4y agoWho exactly is this article speaking to? Who right now is trying to put legal limitations on speech? Maybe Ron DeSantis? Most of the agitation against hate speech is not demanding formal punishment from a court. It's asking for platforms to choose not to amplify their messages. Or for the speakers to rethink their lives and choose to be different. The entire article is arguing against a point of view that doesn't really exist.
- aidenn0 4y agoMy interpretation is it's speaking to former bastions of "intellectual liberalism" (e.g. universities).
- tootie 4y agoAbout what? Universities are supposed to educate. Hosting people with objectively wrong viewpoints isn't edifying. A history department isn't going to host a speaker who denied the Holocaust because they want a diversity of opinions. They are by their very nature going to be very selective about who speaks.
- aidenn0 4y agoBut should they expel students who are Holocaust deniers?
- musictubes 4y agoI remember the Idea Channel on YouTube had a video about violence. He started by quoting an artist saying something to the effect that putting paint to canvas was a violent act. The host went on to define violence as the taking away of agency. The rest of the video was mostly him arguing that physical violence is as easy to define as you might think and that ideas and speech can in fact be violent. My reaction was that even if at the margin physical violence isn’t as easy to pin down as you imagine, I don’t understand making the term violence so broad that it loses its meaning. If everything is violent then nothing is.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoAmazing how trendy redefining words has become.
- ParetoOptimal 4y agoDefinitions are constantly in flux. It's the reason the dictionary has to be updated. See the evolving definition of "literal" for instance or how "gay" has changed over time.
- hpen 4y agoMy solution for banning any speech is that the rules have to be nearly unanimously voted in, and voted in for multiple (maybe 3?) presidential administrations. Things like banning the shoutout of “fire” in a theater. Some laws need to be low pass filtered.
- Clubber 4y ago>Things like banning the shoutout of “fire” in a theater. Some laws need to be low pass filtered. That was mostly overturned in 1969, though the history of it is interesting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_theater https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_the...
- hpen 4y agoInteresting info. I think people still get the point I’m making but thanks for the clarification
- Clubber 4y agoYou're welcome. The most interesting part is the "fire in a theater" was at a time when the government was throwing people in jail for protesting WWI under the Wilson administration. When the SCOTUS affirmed the Debs conviction and 10 year sentence and permanent disenfranchisement, they referenced the case of "fire in a theater," as justification. It was a pretty dark time in our history. I'm glad it was overturned. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_V._Debs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_V._Debs
- hpen 4y agoI will say that you will never find me fighting for speech being banned. Peers of mine bring up the "fire in a theater" as a counter for us already having free speech limitations. I thought that was still the case and so I was looking for a way to make common sense stuff illegal given the precedence that there are active limitations today. I'm really uncomfortable with the way twitter mobs dictate what is and isn't free speech and I was looking for a more democratic, test of time driven solution.
- more_corn 4y agoCalling for violence is speech and sure as shit leads to violence. In fact if we want to be intellectually honest speech should be recognized as a legitimate form of violence. If you ever decide to do violence you’re going to be a lot more effective if you have a mob at your back. To be clear I’m not calling for mob violence. I’m Just being intellectually honest. Speech is an effective tool in the execution of violence. Whatever else your politics we can all agree that “Go to the capital and fight like hell” led to a mob attacking, entering and committing violence at the capital. It was certainly more effective than the speaker showing up personally with his fists up. Was the speech itself violence? No. Did it directly encourage violence and then that violence happened? Yes. In that sense was it an effective orchestration of violence? Yep.
- lamontcg 4y agoThe biggest problem with liberals talking this way is that I fear that right wing Christians are likely to actually implement it someday.
- petodo 4y agoJudging by Reddit it definitely is, I am always shocked to see Reddit hivemind approving violent attacks on some racist spouting slurs, as if violence was appriopriate response to words. I don't expect anyhing better from HN crowd, they are not that different after all despite HN thinking they are on high horse.
- rurban 4y agoLooking is now also violence. The next step to wrongthink might be hearing.