13 ms·
Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public school teachers
- RickJWagner 4y agoI agree with Sanders that teachers are underpayed. I'd like to see a good plan to pay for it, though. (Where's that Golden Fleece list?)
- bushbaba 4y agoTeachers don’t work year round. So that 60k salary if adjusted to days worked + pension benefits is equivalent to six figures in the private sector.
- asddubs 4y agoteachers still have to exist in society all year round though
- PaulHoule 4y agoThen they get a summer job. I remember an elementary school teacher from when I was a kid who was a park ranger in the summer.
- sjm 4y agoDo you realize how dystopian that is?
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoPeople working year round is dystopian?
- russh 4y agoYes, I too work 12 months of the year.
- Loughla 4y agoYes, but you do the work of your main profession that you are an expert in, and are compensated appropriately. You don't do a side job bagging groceries or lifeguarding in the summers to be able to maintain living in a home you own. Legitimate question, do you not see the difference?
- PaulHoule 4y agoI'll say that elementary school teacher who worked as a park ranger in the summer got a good deal as he still had a government job and instead of paying for a gym membership he got paid to walk around in a beautiful place all summer. I'm sure most teachers don't have it so good but if one were trying to improve the current system you might try to create jobs that are complementary with teaching jobs. Teaching is one of those areas like software development where the social contradictions are intense because it is a labor intensive practice with very little capital spending (think how the final assembly people on a car have a huge "gun" that hangs from the ceiling and looks like something out of Doom that screws all 5 nuts for a wheel with perfect torque in one shot.) Schools are also funded out of property taxes which are rather regressive and limit the ability of schools to be funded by people who have a huge amount of money and instead pits teachers against people who don't make $60,000 a year and who don't get a few months off in the summer.
- patchorang 4y agoOne of the best teachers I ever had was our middle school chemistry teacher. He had to lifeguard during the summer to support his family. That seems pretty crazy to me.
- mrweasel 4y agoWouldn't summer be the perfect time to update their knowledge? University students are of on vacation, meaning that the professors are available to train the school teachers.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoMany teachers have CE requirements they must fulfill over the summer, and summer breaks in some places are as short as 6 weeks. Some teachers may do the minimum and find the role and their summers relaxing. Yet for the best outcomes and challenging districts it's far from a 'cushy' job.
- davidmichael 4y agoAttempting to get a seasonal job, year after year, for just 2-3 months a year would be difficult. My wife is a former school teacher and she spent a considerable amount of time planning and working on things for the next school year. If teachers are expected to all work over summer break to make ends meet then their performance will suffer. I'd argue that a better approach for teachers and education in general would be to move to more year-round schooling.
- throwaway5959 4y agoWhat does your wife do now?
- ethanbond 4y agoFrankly all this stuff boils down to “you get what you pay for.” And for a long time, the US has gotten a lot more than they paid for because there are people willing to take huge hits on QOL and pay to help kids. But really the folks who have always been antagonistic to teachers showed their cards through the pandemic when they staked out the position that teachers are public enemy #1 for not wanting to literally risk their lives for a public that treats them like a punching bag year in and year out. You know, stupid “Teachers’ Nights” at baseball games aside. If you want a gradual regression to abysmal education, sure, pay ‘em pennies and then we can instead pay for an uneducated populace via higher crime rates, lower civic participation, lower economic productivity, higher welfare burden, more homelessness, etc etc. Good trade!
- klyrs 4y agoMost of the teachers I know spend their summers on professional development. Taking classes, often paying out of pocket, to improve their knowledge base and teaching skills. If they were in the profession just for money, sure, they might just get a job and phone it in.
- sowuttho 4y agoA random teacher in any school across the US has done more for society in real terms than you have in a decade. You could be part of the open data movement and a researcher in your spare time not stocking grocery store shelves. Yes I’m suggesting your credentials are worthless. Why do we need full time university researcher role play when millions the world over are “researching” software engineering? There are far fewer teachers. Sounds like a pay rebalancing given market realities is in order. Coders are everywhere. Minimum wage for them!
- rhino369 4y agoThey shouldn't have their salary entirely prorated, but having a two month vacation during summer, one week spring break, and two week winter break is a huge benefit that should be considered when analyzing their compensation. Especially since they can make extra by teaching summer school, camps, taking other summer jobs.
- madsbuch 4y agoNot American, so a couple of questions: 1. Is it normal for teachers to have alternative income for the days they don't work? 2. Sounds like the term "six figures" has a special meaning other than just being in the range 100.000 - 999.999? It appears like there is a connotation that it is a special things to achieve in your life. 3. Taking inflation into account, shouldn't it soon be normal to earn that amount (when including pensions and benefits like health, which I know is expensive).
- mynameisvlad 4y agoAnswering #2, six figures refers to the number of digits in your paycheck, so 100k+ Lmao the downvotes are hilarious. I literally am explaining something the parent comment wanted to know. They didn't even have the bit about "100.000-999.999" when this comment was posted, as evidenced by another person quoting the original comment and the commenter saying they clarified the question.
- kube-system 4y agoAnd for the international audience, Americans cite salaries pre-tax. So a $100,000 salary means people earn somewhere around $80,000 after tax depending on their situation and where they live. And then further deduct benefits and retirement savings from that. About $60,000 might actually hit your bank account if you have a 100k salary.
- patchorang 4y ago1. Yes a lot of teacher have different summer jobs. 2. Means at least 100,000 3. Yes, it should be normal.
- dkarl 4y agoWorking most of the year as teachers means they can't make much at that summer job, though. I had a high school biology teacher who worked as lab tech in the summers, which she described as low-level work that she did just because she loved being in the lab. She was extremely sharp, but I don't think there was any way she could have trained for a more difficult position or taken on any higher responsibility when she couldn't stay on the job for more than a few months at a time. That was the only teacher I had who had any summer job that required education, except maybe for teachers who worked at a family business during the summer.
- sjm 4y agoTeachers do more work outside of their standard hours than most other professions. I dated a teacher for a long time and she worked much harder for her public school salary (waking up at 6am, prepping, lesson planning, grading, chasing up kids who aren't making it to school, dealing with social workers, etc.), than I do for my cushy six-figure tech job salary. Besides, why shouldn't teachers make six-figures? Why are teachers treated like this in the US?
- ethbr0 4y ago> Besides, why shouldn't teachers make six-figures? Exactly. Compared to what I do, educating 15-20 future citizens and adults seems on par. And to your broader point, indeed, the average US teacher at this point is 1/5 lesson planning, 3/5 instruction, 1/10 social worker, and 1/10 data entry/report filing.
- option 4y agoTeachers should make six figures, the best ones should make seven like couches do now. And it should be very easy to fire bad ones. Basically should be at will employment with school district.
- ethbr0 4y ago> at will employment with school district This is thorny, because it gets into the problems tenure was created to combat: school administration's goals aren't always student success. Especially now, they can be myopically assessment-focused or political. Subordinating teachers to the whim of administration wouldn't help this. Jury-of-their-peers is slightly better, but has its own issues.
- beeftime 4y agogood
- walthamstow 4y agoGood? If you want maths taught by actual maths grads, then you will need six figure salaries to attract them.
- macinjosh 4y agoNo one needs a math grad to teach 3rd grade math. That would be a huge waste of money and expertise.
- teucris 4y agoMore specifically, teaching is a different skill than knowing. Excellent math teachers are very different than math majors - in some ways it’s less complex (eg pushing the boundaries of the field of mathematics), and in others it is far more (understanding the human psyche and how to effectively communicate abstract concepts).
- pathartl 4y agoThat's the problem, they don't want kids to actually learn. They view teachers as glorified babysitters.
- badlucklottery 4y agoThis. A lot of districts are also trying to add some computer science curriculum but can't find anyone to teach it. 60k is extremely low for CS grads in any moderately-sized city but they might be willing to make that trade for two months off in the summer.
- rhino369 4y agoSchools wouldn't hire math grads even if they could pay them six figure salaries. You'll just end up paying the same type of people you have now six figures.
- SCdF 4y agoI am not american, but both my parents were teachers, and they absolutely worked all year round, and longer than 8hr days. There are such a things as lesson plans, and marking homework, and being asked to do extra work such as editing the school paper, or coaching basketball, or whatever. This idea that teachers work the same hours they are physically inside school and nothing else is laughable. Though regardless, entry level software developers in the united states get six figures out of the gate, so it seems remarkably reasonable.
- zwirbl 4y agoTeachers do create massive amounts of value for the society at large, so that would likely be very appropriate
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoGreat! They deserve it.
- akomtu 4y agoAsjusted to inflation, 100k today are worth about as much as 60k two years ago.
- callahad 4y agoAssuming Wolfram Alpha's CPI data is correct, I think you'd have to go back to 2002 for $100k now to be worth $60k then: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%2460%2C000+from+2002 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%2460%2C000+from+2002
- akomtu 4y agoI prefer the Coffee Purchasing Index, Costco Purchasing Index and Car Purchasing Index instead. Those don't lie.
- mempko 4y agoWhy shouldn't teachers make six figures? I mean after all, half the people here just put buttons on websites and get paid six figures.
- macinjosh 4y agoBecause teacher salaries, like the salaries of people here, should be determined by the market not by warm and fuzzy feelings.
- Loughla 4y agoOkay then. What is the market value of a well-educated society?
- paulryanrogers 4y agoMarket solves everything! Like that train derailment in Ohio! Certainly no need for a collective organization to step in to oversee clean up or preventative measures in the future.
- Zetice 4y agoThe market is too cruel to be left to take care of America's children.
- mempko 4y agoWhy? the market has huge flaws. For example, most money is held by a very small amount of people. Should the market solve for them or for the vast number of people? The market has externalities, which is a huge flaw in pricing things. This is a known studied problem with markets. Third, it's one of many optimization processes. If you understand machine learning, you understand that there are different models, different solution spaces, and optimizations (learning) on them requires different techniques. Why should we rely on a highly flawed optimization process like the market to decide these important things in society? Democratic and consensus building is another way to come to these complex decisions without relying on 'spot trade' and pricing restrictions that the market has. "The Market" is a technology. Thinking the market solves everything is like saying vacuum-tubes should be used in all electronics. Like, have you ever wondered why, at your work place, there aren't markets? Why don't most large successful companies have market dynamics internally if the market solves all organizational issues?
- sqlcommando 4y agoGood teachers are worth six figures easily.
- dividefuel 4y agoI don't understand these comparisons. Sure, the pay per hour worked might be the same as someone who works full time year around and earns $100k annually. But that doesn't mean teachers are paid $100k. They're still paid $60k. It's a $60k job with some large blocks of time off.
- sowuttho 4y agoHow dare we reap privilege on babysitters freeing devops engineers to copy-paste off stackoverflow
- blueblob 4y agoThat's a tiring argument that's reiterated every time teacher pay is involved. Most teachers also don't get the luxury of working 9-5, they have to do additional planning and grading outside of hours. Also, if you want to compare with the private sector, there are teachers in the private sector who make more.
- adamsmith143 4y agoAdjusted salary doesn't pay your mortgage.
- pokstad 4y agoInstead, allow for a voucher system where parents can apply the equivalent amount of money the public school spends and apply it towards private schools. Make it easy for teachers to start their own school or coop to compete for vouchers. Definitely a pipe dream but it might work.
- barbazoo 4y agoWhat a dystopian education system that would be.
- macinjosh 4y agoWhy? The idea that everyone is forced to go to the same place and be educated the same way is dystopian, IMHO. What ever happened to diversity?
- kennywinker 4y agoYou can have diversity without turning education into a for-profit hellscape.
- macinjosh 4y agoI went to a small private school in a low income area. No one in my school was wealthy. Tuition was low. The school was a non-profit. You are spreading FUD.
- kennywinker 4y agoYour anecdote doesn’t prove or disprove anything. Like a particularly snowy winter doesn’t disprove global warming.
- indymike 4y agoWho said schools have to be for profit? In my state we have vouchers, and most voucher money goes to schools operated by not-for-profits. We also have charter schools, and most of those are operated by for-profit companies. Either way, they offer a way to get kids into a better environment/institution than trying to fix a failing public school system.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JustSomeNobody 4y ago[flagged]
- Loughla 4y agoThey have pretty well given up on eliminating the DoE. Instead, they're just gutting education and getting the money through "school choice" like vouchers and public funding for religious/private schools. Why kill the beast when you can milk it?
- kennywinker 4y ago“The two parties are the same, it doesn’t matter who you vote for”
- kneebonian 4y agoRemind me who was it that closed polling stations in areas with large Sanders support during the primaries again? And why was it that Bloomberg was running for only like 3 weeks right around super Tuesday and then folded after that? Maybe they are the same they just pretend ti act differently in front of the camera?
- mattwad 4y agoThat's internal politics, not even close to related to destroying public services from our federal government. I'm pissed about what they and the media did to Sanders but I wish that Republicans had done the same to Trump.
- kneebonian 4y ago> but I wish that Republicans had done the same to Trump. This sounds like a dangerous line of thinking. Like we can argue about Trump till the cows come home but I think it'd be a tough sell to say he wasn't who the Republicans wanted as their nominee. It sounds like you are saying you wish the political parties would do what they feel is best irregardless of the will of their constituints. That is no longer representative democracy but rather tyrrany.
- kshahkshah 4y agoI'm in NJ where we value public education, for the most part. According to National Center for Education Statistics our average teacher pay was $77,489 in 2022. This is excluding benefits/pension. Well worth it.
- jvmfjvfjvf 4y agoIf you value education, why does your state have unions that force pay based on seniority and not outcome?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- aaronyarborough 4y agoHow is outcome measured?
- netfl0 4y agoRecidivism.
- hammock 4y agoSchool choice via vouchers, etc would allow parents to decide for themselves how outcome is measured Edit: why the downvotes? If you are uncertain of or unamenable to the way outcomes are measured, vouchers are a reasonable solution that puts the power in your hands
- kube-system 4y agoThere’s a significant race and religion component to school choice.
- hammock 4y agoWhat do you mean?
- Lucasoato 4y agoWhat a world would we live in if Bernie Sanders won those 2016 elections...
- dekken_ 4y ago[flagged]
- Der_Einzige 4y agoI'm still shocked to this day that Obama didn't get assassinated. I thought he'd make it less than a year.
- tristor 4y agoWhy? Why would you imagine that a globalist neoliberal who continued growth of funding to the military industrial complex would end up assassinated while POTUS?
- fullshark 4y agoOne where nothing much changed but the Democrats would be doing the populist posturing instead of the Republicans.
- shagie 4y agoThe executive branch has a lot less power than people think it does. Aside from the executive orders on "how" to implement laws that congress passes and the curtailments to power by the Supreme Court, they don't have much control over the purse strings. If congress doesn't like the "how" they either update the law or have the SCOTUS to make a ruling that says they don't have that power in the first place. A president can say to congress "I'd like you to pass a bill that..." and they can change some things for federal workers - but for states, they've got very little regulatory power outside of what has been granted to them through the various departments (e.g. Department of Education). 2016 had a 52/46/2 senate composition with a republican majority. The house was 241 to 194 with a republican majority. My crystal ball for a hypothetical president Sanders shows a president who would have been able to do very little except for some executive orders which would get overridden by congress. The house would have been very unlikely to give him the budget to fulfill his promises and ideals while blaming him and every executive branch agency for every failing and catastrophe that occurred in 2020.
- news_to_me 4y agoMy first “real” job after college (2013) I started at $60k. It was more than my mom, an elementary school teacher, ever made. It felt embarrassing. Teachers are at least as valuable as software developers (probably more), given their impact on society. Why do they make so little?
- mwint 4y agoSupply and demand, like always. The market cares not one bit about what someone “should” be paid, it cares about the price where no one is left willing to do the same job for less. If you want teachers to be paid more, increase the requirements to be a teacher. I’m a proponent of requiring at least n years experience in real world work, plus education in a hard science or trade.
- nfRfqX5n 4y agoWhat other requirements? Teachers require at least a 4 year degree. Specialists like speech therapists require a masters degree. Try paying off a masters degree with a teachers salary.
- monocasa 4y agoI mean, we already have massive teacher shortages. Class sizes keep going up, and many school systems are switching to four day schedules because of staffing issues. Not everything can be looked at from a macro econ 101 supply and demand take; the real world is much more complicated than that.
- jacobr1 4y agoSometimes it is more complicated, but in this case the analysis does apply. The problem isn't on the demand side, but on the supply. And one way to increase supply is to charge a higher price, or otherwise compensate (more time off, better work environment, prestige, etc ...) and a big part of the reason we have a teacher shortage is that there aren't enough compensatory incentives.
- hammock 4y agodeleted
- djent 4y agoNow imagine how much worse it is for those who make LESS than $60,000
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoEducation expenditures compares the public expenditure on education as a percent of GDP. https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/education-expenditures/country-comparison https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/education-expen... Education Expenditures by Country https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd Government expenditure on education, total (% of GDP) https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SE.XPD.TOTL.GD.ZS https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SE.XPD.TOTL.GD.ZS
- laverya 4y ago> Education expenditures compares the public expenditure on education as a percent of GDP. https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/education-expenditures/country-comparison https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/education-expen... I think this only counts federal spending - state and local spending total to ~3.5% of US GDP.
- kneebonian 4y agoI'll just throw out there that the elementary school bear where I live pays teachers around 20-25k. It is a LOC area for now, and it works out for the most part because most of the teachers there are doing it as a second job while their husband works (and yes the fact of the matter is where I live it is heavily cultural for the man to be the primary breadwinner in a home) but I worry about it shifting as we are seeing more and more people move in and it straining teaching resources more and more.
- mc32 4y agoCoL differs significantly within states and across the country. There should be a base plus CoL adjustment adjusted annually to account for inflation or deflation. A flat standard amount for anything does not make sense given the CoL disparities. 60,000 dollars is good for someone in Ukiah CA or Huntsville AL, but not for someone in NYC or Burbank, CA. Reminds me of lots of things kicking in at $10Gs. A figure that was set in the '70s and has not been revisited since.
- r00fus 4y agoThen maybe we can do the same for the Federal minimum wage? This is just a floor. States can take this and run with it to increase local teacher salaries beyond the floor. Sanders knows it won't pass in this corrupt senate, but possibly a future one may take this seed of an idea and make something workable.
- hammock 4y agoThe minimum starting salary for a teacher in Chicago is $60,000 (cost of living adjusted), the highest in the country. It hasn't solved Chicago Public Schools' problems. Source: https://wirepoints.org/chicago-teachers-are-paid-some-of-the-highest-salaries-of-any-big-district-in-the-nation-what-do-chicago-parents-get-in-return-wirepoints/ https://wirepoints.org/chicago-teachers-are-paid-some-of-the...
- megabless123 4y ago> It hasn't solved Chicago Public Schools' problems. sure but it probably has solved many financial problems for Chicago teachers, which is a good enough reason to implement a tool like this.
- HEmanZ 4y agoAt the cost of more financial problems for taxpayers? How do you balance those two?
- blamazon 4y agoThose teachers aren't burning the money. It goes back to the community around them as they spend it, generally.
- chitowneats 4y agoWe gave out a bunch of free money during the pandemic. What was the result of that?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- roughly 4y agoWe didn’t have a fucking depression. Also, there was some inflation.
- throwaway5959 4y agoSanders calls for a lot and never delivers. I wouldn’t hold your breath teachers.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoHe's one senator. There's not that much you can do as a single senator. The people of Vermont love him though.
- tomku 4y agoNobody in the Senate has figured out how to be something other than one Senator, but some of them can count to 50.
- r00fus 4y agoBetter him than those who actively attempt to harm the US populace to benefit their donors.
- bfrog 4y ago[flagged]
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoThere's a significant number that would rather do it themselves or simply be given vouchers to select an educational institution of their choice, because they believe government-provided educators don't teach things correctly or they want their children to be provided religious-focused instruction.
- mattbuilds 4y agoIf they want to do it themselves, then they can fund it themselves. I don't want tax dollars going to individual vouchers.
- cs702 4y agoI'd be OK with raising the minimum salary for public school teachers a LOT more, BUT ONLY for teachers who graduate in the top 10% of their high-school class and in the top 10% of their college class -- like in Finland, which has one of the world's best public school systems. It makes sense that if public schools hire teachers only from the most academically competent population in a country, and pay them well, those individuals will figure out how to improve the quality of public education. Some years ago I recall seeing a study by McKinsey which found that a majority of public school teachers in the US came from the bottom of their high-school class and the bottom of their college class.[a] Quite literally the opposite of Finland. -- [a] I found the study. Here it is: https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/mckinsey/industries/public%20and%20social%20sector/our%20insights/closing%20the%20teaching%20talent%20gap/closing-the-teaching-talent-gap.pdf https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/mckinsey/industries/public%...
- throwaway5959 4y agoYes we should all aspire to be more like the Fins. Which has a population slightly smaller than that of, checks notes, Missouri.
- cs702 4y agoI didn't say we should aspire to be more like the Finnish. What I did say is that I would be OK with teachers getting paid a lot more if they are drawn from the top of the distribution of academic performance in the country, which is what public schools in Finland do. It makes sense that if public schools hire teachers only from the most academically competent population in the country, and pay them well, they will improve the quality of public education. Please don't attack a straw man!
- fafafuf 4y agoI know this is crazy but: Recently I was thinking about opening a foundation that will create a universal multimedia "product" (combination of software, movies, games, maybe vr) that will teach kids around the world in schools subjects that all nations agree upon like mathematics, physics, chemistry, informatics etc. This is extremely challenging to convince governments to impose this in the schools but the gains are huge - naming only few: - We can release the workforce of millions teacher around the world that do repetitive job every day so that can focus on different aspects of education - We can hire the best of the best in the world teachers to prepare the product and all the kids around the world, no matter if big cities or small towns will have access to the same best possible education. - Education could be totally individual and adapted to every kid - Education can be fun so kids actually will like it What do you think?
- bick_nyers 4y agoI'm in the camp that believes individualized education is best solved using AI. Not ChatGPT, something better. Likely will need in-person teacher facilitation as well, setting up kids alone with a laptop and an AI feels very wrong and dystopian to me. Edit: Also getting all nations to agree will be impossible, if not then you will probably a curriculum that suffers death by committee.
- fafafuf 4y agoIt will need to be done step by step. When nations see how good and cheap this system is and how great are the education results they will be more willing to join. I also think that AI can play a huge role in this - but for sure it needs to be improved.
- maratc 4y agoSo, replace teachers with Linux servers and javascript?
- fafafuf 4y agoIn short "yes". Millions of teachers around the world every day do exactly the same work as other teachers - this is a huge waste of talented resources. If they don't need to do repetitive job, that can focus on individual learning for those who really need it or help society in other way.
- endisneigh 4y agoThe only way teachers would ever be able to make a lot of money is if some metrics apparatus was created by the United States and income outcomes were traced back to individual schools and teachers in said schools got some portion of that as part of their salary. Of course, the USA would have to bootstrap the first "cohort" of this. Otherwise, the point is simple - good teachers don't get paid more, because there's nothing you can point at to justify giving them more money, because the money that comes from the municipality (to fund the school and consequently the teacher) has nothing to do with the outcome. --- It's sad that the "privatize school", or "school voucher" discussion has become so corrupted by politics. Regardless of whether or not you agree with it, or not, it's worth critically thinking about and whether the implications of that kind of change are good or bad, and why.
- tsgagnon 4y agoI'm not sure how you reward outcomes of teaching without also actively discouraging teachers from taking positions at any school that could be seen as "struggling" from an academic perspective.
- endisneigh 4y agoThere are plenty of ways you could do it. The simplest is that you could normalize by the area.
- hammock 4y ago>The only way teachers would ever be able to make a lot of money Public school teachers already make more than private school teachers. Their salaries are propped up by governments and unions
- stefan_ 4y agoFunny, this doesn't seem to be in place for other government employees yet they make much more. Nor in the "meritocratic" "free economy".
- ethbr0 4y agoLater life success over median replacement value seems like a nice bonus structure for retirement. E.g. statistically normalize cohort (income, etc.), measure their median outcomes, and then see how the teacher's cohort does It'll be dirty, given the small sample size and number of variables, but it'd be a nice bonus +/- to retirement. I'd also hazard prior student reviews, sampled when they turn 30 & 40 would be very interesting.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI definitely agree that teachers in many areas are underpaid, but I think a single nationwide minimum wage for teachers is a bad idea. There is just way too much variability in cost of living between different locales for a single amount to make sense. Would much rather it be based on some localizable metric, e.g. X times the median apartment rent or some such (don't want to get caught up on the details, other than to say it should take some form of regional COLA into consideration).
- kneebonian 4y agoSee this is something I wish people would understand more when talking about economics things like a federal minimum wage in a place like NYC or Cali may not sound like much but in rural Missouri or Arkansas that could bankrupt most of the businesses overnight. If only we divided the country into geographical areas that could each be responsible for administering their own issues for the most part, so they would have a better understanding of the costs and tradeoffs, and be able to live they way they want without enforcing their way of life on people halfway across the country, and instead of the people in a few big cities and Washington DC ruling everyone from afar each regional area could be self governed. Oh well that sounds like nonsense anyway after all the same things that are good for NJ are obviously the way things should be run in Montana .
- spurgu 4y agoI don't see why this couldn't be done on a smaller (state or county) level instead. If someone starts offering an attractive starting salary and that leads to better educational outcomes you would expect others to follow (at least make it easy to campaign on it). Edit: And obviously adjust the salary to match local conditions as you point out.
- lukas099 4y agoThe federal government already uses locality pay tables when calculating civil servant salaries [1], so I guess they could use those. [1] https://www.federalpay.org/gs/locality https://www.federalpay.org/gs/locality
- IceHegel 4y agoThis Raj Chetty paper on teacher quality makes a strong case for doing whatever you can to get as many good teachers as possible (and as few bad ones). https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/aer.104.9.2633 https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/aer.104.9.2633 They claim replacing a bad teacher with an average teacher is worth like $250k in earnings per classroom. It's unclear what effect a blanket minimal salary would have on teacher quality. I'd be worried that it might make bad teachers stick around with good ones already making more than that.
- joxel 4y ago[dead]
- dewfaced 4y agoWould paying more get the results we are looking for? Or does additional funding just pad the pockets of administrators? Also why should we pay more for the poor education of the pandemic? We should be funding alternative strategies.
- AlwaysRock 4y agoThis is one of those things that just makes sense and unfortunately will likely not happen. Teaching should be a profession that attracts the best instead of one that attracts those who can afford to do it.
- desireco42 4y agoUnless federal gov will fund this, it doesn't make sense to set it like that, it is more feel-good measure. Teachers and staff need to be paid well for sure but also a lot of funding need to be spent on schools and infrastructure and equipment for example. Federal Government could help with standardize maybe software and equipment for kids... that is if they were not corrupted like they are.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoI really wonder why those headlines still make the news. It's been centuries, and probably millenias, that politics have asked for things that they did not grant once they were in a position to do so. I demand a minimum salary of $1,000,000 for everyone, and immortality for all! Vote for me and make a news article I guess?
- lukas099 4y agoYeah, it's pretty easy to say that teachers should make that much.
- birdymcbird 4y agonot sure this really fix any problem. $60k good salary in arkansas maybe. if you in expensive city..not go very far. have kids in public america school system. government spending money in my opinion uncompetitive and wasteful. but public education must all support. it still good in america. national minimum salary ok but need states or cities to tune to living cost. $60k only work maybe in central us.. cheaper state or city.
- monocasa 4y agoI mean it's a national minimum. School systems would be allowed to continue to pay more. It'd help here in Colorado which is both a relatively HCOL area and a place that pays our teachers peanuts. I know teachers here that get less that $60k/yr as it is.
- HEmanZ 4y agoThis is loosely related, but every time I think of public school teacher salaries my mind goes to the public school teachers I know. As a group they are… exceptionally ungifted. As just one example, I lived with two middle school teachers in Texas for a few years. They probably couldn’t pass the grade they were teaching. I have never met two professionals with so many credentials (MS in Education) and so little sense. My memories of friends in college who became elementary school teachers fall into the same bucket. Do others have similar experiences with teachers or do I just have a bad selection? I think as a society, if increasing teacher pay gets us better teachers and therefore better educational outcomes then we should do it, hands down. But if that increase in pay gets us more of the same thing at higher cost to the public…? I’m not sure which of these outcomes is more likely. The optimist in me says more smart people see educating the youth as a viable career and we get more competent educators. The cynic in me says it never works like that in a system as bureaucratic as education. I don’t know what to think.
- tsgagnon 4y agoI know a few people who are teachers, or related fields like librarians, and I would say they all are smart, hard working and care quite a bit about their students. They are all underpaid and reaching the point of burnout of the entire system and they are only in their 30's. I'm honestly concerned that we'll see education in the US quite literally falling apart as people willing to work in education effectively evaporate.
- etrautmann 4y agoThis tracks my experience as well.
- HEmanZ 4y ago(Totally unrelated to topic at hand) Do you consider librarians in the same category as teachers? They seem like completely different things to me. Like, I don’t really care if my local librarian thinks the world is flat and wants to tell everyone about it. Just keep the library well run and organized. I do care very much if the 3rd grade science teacher is a hardcore flat-earther.
- tristor 4y agoAccording to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, in 2022, the median income in the US was $54,132/yr [1] and the US Census Bureau says median household income was $70,784/yr [2]. I'm not opposed to teachers making $60k/yr, but I think setting this as a floor at a federal level for what is one of the most common professions in the US [3] will have significant and serious unintended consequences. There is a massive amount of territory in the US, where people reside, and are entitled to a public education, that are not major cities with significant tax income. These places don't have the necessary population and tax base to pay this type of salary for a teacher. Let's take a look at one such state, Missouri, basically smack in the middle of the country. It has two major cities (Kansas City and St Louis) and a significant number of rural communities. The average salary for a teacher in Missouri is $51557/yr [4] but falls to around $40k/yr in rural areas like Marceline and Fredericktown, while being nearly $60k/yr in major cities like KC and STL. If you compare this to another common public profession, police officers, you see a similar story [5] with average pay around $58k/yr, but falling to less than 40k/yr starting for communities like Fredericktown [6] and Marceline [7]. How are small communities supposed to pay teachers $60k/yr? The reality is that politicians and pundits on the coasts never give a thought in their mind to "flyover country" or how rural and urban economics differ in the US. Instead, we try to manipulate the economy at the federal level, not giving any credence to the fact the United States is geographically massive with exceedingly varied local and regional economies and cultures. [1]: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/wkyeng.pdf https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/wkyeng.pdf [2]: https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2022/demo/p60-276.html https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2022/demo/p60-27... [3]: https://www.weareteachers.com/how-many-teachers-are-in-the-us/ https://www.weareteachers.com/how-many-teachers-are-in-the-u... [4]: https://missouri.teach.org/salary-benefits-missouri https://missouri.teach.org/salary-benefits-missouri [5]: https://www.salary.com/research/salary/alternate/police-officer-salary/mo https://www.salary.com/research/salary/alternate/police-offi... [6]: https://www.indeed.com/career/police-officer/salaries/Fredericktown--MO https://www.indeed.com/career/police-officer/salaries/Freder... [7]: http://marcelinemo.us/home/employment.html http://marcelinemo.us/home/employment.html
- bfeynman 4y agokeep in mind that teachers only work 9 months of the year as well. Not really that impressive to take a 2nd job when you have 3 months in the summer to do whatever you want.
- throwaway6734 4y agoThis is a terrible idea. Teaching difficulty is directly linked to the quality of students and their parents. I'm all for the federal govt given bonuses to teachers teaching in poor and high crime areas because students in those areas tend to have significantly more behavioral issues.
- BaculumMeumEst 4y agoI’m in favor of pushing all kids to excel and rewarding excellence and achievement regardless of race or social status. If that is included in a minimum salary of $60,000, I would support it. If it isn’t, I would not, and would support private schooling instead.
- mistercheph 4y agoSchools need to attract more competitive applicants. Raising the salaries of already-veteran teachers, although a kind gratitude for their service, will not have a significant impact on educational outcomes for students.
- flerchin 4y agoI see no reason this should not be the case. That is the starting wage in my Dallas area school district.
- rayiner 4y agoNationwide minimum salaries don’t make sense. In nearby Carroll county, MD, the median individual salary is $45,000 and about 45% of the population over 25 has a bachelors degree. Minimum teacher’s salary is about $48,000, which puts them above the median for all workers, in a county that’s pretty highly educated, but also fairly cheap and rural. By contrast, $60,000 in NYC is quite out of line with what other college educated workers earn in that city.
- tptacek 4y ago$60k is below the starting salary for an NYC public school teacher.
- thorawayz 4y agoTeach your own kids.
- adenozine 4y agoHard agree! Time to strip some of the administrators and get some talent in the classrooms. I heard Florida was letting people in classrooms after just a few hours of supervision. If the education crisis isn’t addressed, this country will be absolutely decimated in another thirty years. A level of brain drain hitherto unwitnessed in modern times. If I was raising a young child now (mine are in their late twenties) I’d be strongly weighing the pros and cons of suggesting they go abroad for higher education, and I’d certainly be hiring a tutor rather than trusting the K12 system. Not everybody can afford all of that, despite the money being taxed already. We could lower the military budget by a percentage point and fix all this tomorrow, if we really wanted to…
- baron816 4y agoIt’s really hard to make moral judgments on what someone should get paid. How much does a bricklayer deserve to get paid? How much does an insurance broker deserve to pay? How much does a blackjack dealer deserve to get paid? It’s easy to say teachers or X deserve to get paid more, but by how much? And if you just say everyone deserves more pay, that just means no one deserves more pay.
- blockwriter 4y agoI’m trying to get a real grip on the financial hellscape of my home state, Illinois, for a novel I’m working on. The Illinois constitution ensures the benefits of public sector employees, and these benefits, once enacted, cannot be diminished. Basically, it made short term political sense to increase benefits, and so politicians did, whereas in the long term this spelled doom. In order to fund the pension, the state cuts services and puts assets from the school system into hock. Teachers, cops, firefighters, municipal workers, et. al. consume the state’s finances, and every plan that has been proposed to reduce the pension problems, even if endorsed by the union, has been challenged by individual members and been ruled unconstitutional by the state’s Supreme Court. It seems like teachers in Illinois are on a defined benefit plan where the contributions are a percentage of the salary. Increasing the salary of starting teachers statewide to $60,000.00 would have staggering consequences in Illinois. It’s pretty interesting, if bleak. https://www.illinoispolicy.org/reports/pensions-101-understanding-illinois-massive-government-worker-pension-crisis/ https://www.illinoispolicy.org/reports/pensions-101-understa...
- zephrx1111 4y agoA simple rule of thumb is that if you pay more salary than they deserve, it is a harm for them, and for society as well in this case.
- Justsignedup 4y agoTeachers are such a fucked up system that its hard to visualize just how bad it is. Having worked in teacher support orgs in the past, I can tell you... its bad. - There are definitely bad teachers out there. The older the get the worse they get. But what's really counter-intuitive is that the teacher filter is absolutely backwards. The teachers who are smart, tallented, and trully exceptional... they end up leaving and getting better professions. Anyone who is tallented with mathematics has a real chance at getting a job in IT/Programming. And I've seen trully caring teachers just leave because a 3x pay increase OVERNIGHT is much more of a quality of life improvement than any sort of feel good from teaching. The worst with no other opportunities stay. And the best lave. And sometimes the best stay, but it is an exception, not the rule. - Teachers are overworked, underpaid, and often pay from their own pocket. They burn out. Worse, they often can't afford to live where the work is. And to make things even worse, the more educated they are, the harder it is to find work. I know a PHD who wants to teach highschool because he loves it... he has to basically find a school so despearte for teachers that they can't pass on him, because any other school thinks that the small pay the union demands to increase him by is just not worth it. - Teachers in cities get paid so little they can't afford rent. Seriously, 50k salaries in NYC. Even at 60k its basically poverty pay, and you need a Masters!!! - 1 in 3 teachers burn out within a couple of years. This has been a very consistent statistic. 60k is far too low. I don't think teachers should be paid below 100k fresh out of school. The work is hard, and we need people fighting to get these positions by showing excellence. This is our future, we should not give it to the shittiest educators who can't afford not to be a teacher. Every time I talk to a teacher who's smart, all I can think of is "literally you can find work in the tech sector, even doing just customer service, for double your pay" My sister is working on her masters (lots of cost) and is a NYC teacher (not DOE, she gets paid a bit better working for a charter school). She cannot afford to move out of our parent's house because her quality of life would go down drastically because most of her money will go to survival. The fact that she gets to save 24k a year on rent (pretty much the minimum rent I could find that's not dilapidated) allows her to live even a bit. Not to mention that she has to still pay the 6-7 years of college tuition out of pocket. OH and she's specialized (special education).
- ticviking 4y agoOr perhaps we could try asking schools to do less. Based on my experience in education burnout in "Bad schools" comes from a handful of terror students, and in "good schools" from a handful of overly demanding parents. Students who cannot behave in an appropriate manner shouldn't be the schools problem, they should be the parents problem. Ultimately they are the communities problem, but schools aren't the appropriate place to solve it. Demanding parents is a different problem but is much easier to manage if you are treated as a professional(on par with a Lawyer, or Accountant) and have the ability to make professional decisions that require formal steps to challenge.
- juancampa 4y agoHow about we align incentives instead? Here's an idea: when a student graduates, they allocate 1% of their yearly salary to their favorite 5-10 teachers for the next 5 years. I call it the "thankfulness tax". Incentives aligned: the most impactful teachers make the most money.
- shagie 4y agoIn the "give this a read" category... The Unincorporated Man. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unincorporated_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unincorporated_Man // https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/4025200-the-unincorporated-man https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/4025200-the-unincorporat... It has some intriguing ideas that... bear thinking about. I'll note that this is a social / political / economic paper with a story more than a good story with interesting ideas. From one of the Goodreads reviews which spells out the basics of society: > This novel offers a really interesting and innovative SF concept: in the future, every person is incorporated upon birth. Twenty percent of the shares go to the parents, five percent goes to the government, the rest can be sold by the owner for education, possessions and so on. You can buy and sell someone's shares as an investment, for charity, even as a hostile act. Reaching "self-majority" - owning the majority of your own shares - is similar to becoming independently wealthy in today's world. The entire future society is based on this basic economic concept. I thought it was a fantastic idea and was really excited about the novel. > Unfortunately the brothers Kollin ruined this inventive idea with some really poor writing and plotting. It's a classic example of great concept, poor execution. --- The "sold by the owner for education" - gets into a "you want to go to college? Sell 5% of your shares to the college." I'm not going to claim it's a good idea, just an interesting point for discussion to think about and bring up when political discourse is acceptable late at night at a party or other social event.
- juancampa 4y agoWhat an interesting concept. Thanks for sharing this!
- jdmtheNth 4y agoMy experience of teachers is in Canada, and spans my children's (15 and 25) current and completed school careers and my wife's employment at the local university's BEd program. While I've met a couple of exceptional and outstanding teachers in the last two decades, they are vanishingly rare. By far, the majority of teachers I have met call themselves teachers, but are, in reality, dispensers of goverment-directed and union-approved knowledge. They use the internet to produce generic fill-in-the-blank exercises, send home atrociously spelled and grammatically incorrect instructions that don't make sense (when there's anything sent home at all), and only hold the kids to the lowest standards, so that everyone can pass. Their unions fight for maximal pay, but demand increasingly minimal interaction with the children. Teachers can't volunteer their time anymore, staying to help kids that need it, or running clubs. In many cases, they don't even supervise the children during lunch hours, instead relying on community volunteers, or, more commonly have the grade 6 kids watch the younger kids. Of course, this is the same province that famously allows a shop class teacher to wear impossibly huge prosthetic breasts because presumably it helps him deal with teenage boys or something. I would love to see teachers being paid according to their worth, but with the standards they are set for the kids and themselves model, a lot of them are already. TLDR: Teachers deserve better, mechanical, unionized, education dispensers really don't.
- r00fus 4y agoAnecdotally, I spent a two separate days leading a single hour of my mom's class (about a single topic each time) as a guest instructor. Both times it exhausted the hell out of me. At the time I was incredibly fit (ran 4x a week for 3mi+) but the attention requirements of teaching 1st and 3rd graders was INTENSE. I was amazed at how my mom could do this day in and day out. Plus she dug into her own pocket to supplement the classroom supplies. Teachers should be paid well north of $60K.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoSadly, he can call for world peace and an end to fossil fuel extraction, but this is only a dream.
- beej71 4y agoIt barely makes any economic sense to train to be a teacher. It's unlikely you'll make enough money to pay off your debt unless you get PSLF... but who knows if that's going to even exist in 10 years--that program's in the crosshairs of at least one of the major parties. You're risking being in debt for life.
- deeg 4y agoTangential to the main topic: I live in Boston which has a reputation for having lousy public schools. Is there any major city (for whatever definition of major you want) that is considered to have a good public school system? If so, what do they do right?
- Ancapistani 4y agoThe idea of a single minimum salary nation-wide is absurd IMO. In my state, the average starting salary for a degreed and certified public school teacher is ~$35k. That's one of the lowest in the nation, for sure, but my point is that New York's starting salary is ~$63k. Making a $60k base salary law would cripple my state's ability to staff its schools, while having no impact on states like NY, as they higher cost of living there means that they're already well in excess of this proposed minimum.
- sershe 4y agoI think the rule should be, the combined salaries of the teachers and anyone else spending most of the time with kids, like special education assistants, counselors, etc. have to be some multiple of the salaries of everyone else in the district. Ideally, a multiple should be such that the districts are initially out of compliance by 2-3x, and they either have to come up with lot more money, or get rid/cut salaries of a bunch of non-teaching parasites they now employ. Then in future when they want to hire a diversity coordinator or spike an administrator's salary before retirement so that they could get a $300k pension, they have to raise teacher salaries automatically.