11 ms·
Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure group says
- SturgeonsLaw 4y agoThis is great. I'm all for the convenience of paying with a card, and use it for 99% of my transactions, but cash has a place in a free society. Without it, the state and the banks have the means to shut off a person's participation in society. That's too much power going to unaccountable people. To say nothing of the surveillance a cashless society affords as well. A cashless society is incompatible with a free society.
- robertlagrant 4y agoI am not a blockchain person, but I think this was one of the better philosophical reason to like the blockchain. It seems to allow digital money that's not easily revocable by an authority. Of course in practice it probably is, but I appreciate the theory.
- eru 4y agoMost blockchain money is pseudonymous and very easy to track. Eg bitcoin has a globally readable track of each transaction ever. You can use enough cryptography to make blockchain transactions anonymous. But I think you can use the same cryptography to make non-blockchain electronic money anonymous, too.
- reidjs 4y agoEasy to track but not easy for a government to prevent transactions
- unicornmama 4y agoIt’s hell of easy to prevent transaction. You publish a wallet blacklist and prohibit all exchange services from processing tainted bitcoins.
- Quindecillion 4y agoThat's not transacting on the Bitcoin blockchain though. Once you have access to Bitcoin on-chain and have other people willing to transact directly through Bitcoin, with no fiat intermediaries like exchanges... yeah, there's literally nothing anyone can do to stop the transaction from going through (eventually). The end goal with Bitcoin is to bypass all the permissioned fiat rails eventually.
- oblio 4y ago> with no fiat intermediaries like exchanges What's the volume of Bitcoin traded outside of exchanges? 0.0001%?
- oblio 4y agoJust because you don't like it, doesn't make it wrong :-)
- ashwagary 4y ago>What's the volume of Bitcoin traded outside of exchanges How could you ever know? A group of people could trade paper wallets with 1000s of Bitcoin trillions of times and no record of it would show up on chain.
- eru 4y agoWell, that's off-chain and requires trust. So it's arguably not bitcoin. (It requires trust, because how do you prevent double spending attacks? Someone can just print out the same paper wallet twice. You need to move the funds to an address you control to be sure.)
- ashwagary 4y ago>So it's arguably not bitcoin. It's always Bitcoin in any scenario we can think of since value never ever leaves the chain, only the person with control of the on-chain value changes. >Someone can just print out the same paper wallet twice. I used "paper wallet" as a simple place holder, many tamper resistant one time use solutions exist, like Opendime.
- koonsolo 4y agoInstead of giving an example that doesn't work, maybe give an example that does work: Monero.
- Dma54rhs 4y agoI agree with the premise but in practice something like Bitcoin would be perfect for a police state. Easily trackable, just have to block the endpoints to repress people, forever history.
- Quindecillion 4y agoThere are several ways to obfuscate transaction history on origins, such as coinjoins or simply opening a few private Lightning Network channels and pushing sats a couple of hops through them to unidentified end addresses.
- livre 4y agoNobody here has addressed the actual issue of Blockchain in a cashless society. You need internet for using crypto, your internet company accepts only legal currency (card, cash, etc) and since there's no chash and you have been cut off from using cards you can't pay for your internet bill and that means it'll eventually get cut and you won't be able to use crypto. Crypto needs cash to work, because people need cash or card for utilities, those companies won't accept your make believe money like the little shop in the corner does.
- davidguetta 4y agoYes. Its crazy how much people dont realize that thing can change fast, an authoritarian gov comes and take your rights in the name of "security". Just look at russia, iran, china, or even also kanye west / andrew tate who had their account frozen.
- tchvil 4y agoNo need to name only exotic or unfriendly places, Canada applied the same technique against its 'Freedom Convoy' truckers.
- moremetadata 4y agoIf the cash machine knows the serial numbers of your banknotes that its issued, and you then go and spend some of that money with someone, when those bank notes come back into the banks hands, they can use this to build up a map or pattern of behaviour. Are you comfortable with your bank knowing who you hand cash to? In another situation, most on here will be familiar with FIFO and LIFO for buffers, and whilst most cash registers take a serialised bank note and hand it back out in a LIFO manner, sometimes the register operator will take bank notes and put them at the bottom of the pile. This creates a new state, LILO as its gone to the bottom of the pile of bank notes. In addition why did the shop or business engage in that activity with some people and not others? Is there something shady taking place or are they displaying knowledge to others? How does that mess around with the banking systems ability to build payment networks what central banks would call the velocity of money? A cashless society would make some crimes less possible like muggings, but could it also escalate the extremity of muggings? For example if fingerprints are required with a card or smartphone, would muggings evolve becoming more extreme with events like cutting off peoples fingers? It also highlights the fact that's society is not configured/setup properly because such events like muggings are taking place. I think coinage should be dropped (ie non serialised money) and banks should start displaying the serial numbers of bank notes much like the blockchain, so that people can track and trace where all the money is going. For example, celebrities helping out less fortunate people with autographed products including things like NFT's could evolve, because a celebrity could hand out cash to someone which has its immediate utilitarian value as currency, but just like collectors demonstrate, that bank note could actually be worth more to a collector willing to pay x times more for that celebrity bank note which the less fortunate currently has in their possession. Ergo could poverty be reduced with this method or would human behaviour change and less celebrity worshipping occur? And would less celebrity worshipping be a bad thing or not?
- mejutoco 4y ago> when those bank notes come back into the banks hands, they can use this to build up a map or pattern of behaviour. Are you comfortable with your bank knowing who you hand cash to? I am comfortable with it, since by the time those bank notes come into the bank, they do not know how many times, and between whom, they have changed hands. There is also plausible deniability: the suspect guy bringing cash into the bank with numbers I had might have gotten them from me spending them at the supermarket, or from me getting change at the restaurant, and the restaurant owner doing business with him. There are many gaps in this argument.
- catseyechandra 4y agoThis is good, but switzerland tend to spread this kind of news to build a very progressive image, things inside of switzerland is a bit different, i.e. this swiss intel/security hiccup: https://www.strauss-engineering.ch/posts/sevices.html https://www.strauss-engineering.ch/posts/sevices.html (in french).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Double_a_92 4y agoWhile I generally agree, practically it's probably not a huge difference compared to what we have now. Most people keep their money in banks, instead of cash. So if the government wants to target you they can already do it, no matter if you have a few 1000 in cash or not.
- zirgs 4y agoYup - and salaries are paid directly to bank accounts. Mortgage payments are automatically charged directly from bank accounts as well. If your government freezes your bank account - you're fucked.
- dools 4y ago> the state and the banks have the means to shut off a person's participation in society The state already has this, it's called prison.
- seydor 4y ago> making it easier for the state to monitor its citizens' actions. It also makes it easier for other people to monitor wealth being transferred, and switzerland hoards a lot of other people's wealth.
- robertlagrant 4y agoIt stores it. Why are you calling that storage hoarding?
- saberience 4y agoYep stores wealth for and makes money from dictators, war criminals, and international criminals. Of course they want to prevent a cashless society.
- favaq 4y agoThe solution to that is not taking the freedom from everybody.
- pacija 4y agoI want to prevent a cashless society as well, while not being a dictator, war criminal or international criminal.
- seydor 4y agoThen why do you want state-sanctioned cash? Use, i dont know, crypto or some other kind of non-state-sanctioned barter
- ahtihn 4y agoDo you think these dictators and criminals come to Switzerland with airplanes full of bank notes? Do you think there are vaults of physical cash? I don't get how this relates to having a cashless society.
- 4y ago
- kypro 4y agoWould it be possible to create some form of anonymous digital currency? Personally I think it would be sad purely for cultural reasons to completely move away from physical currency, but I think if there were some verifiably anonymous way to make transactions digitally I'd probably be okay with it. I'm sure there would still be some state issued physical currency which you could trade or deposit at a bank if people wanted to some for the novelty of it. For me, like most people, the primary concern is the power it gives the state. It seems clear society will continue to move away from using cash, regardless of what the state mandates. In the UK there are already plenty of retailers who won't accept cash payments. So I think whether we like it or not, we probably need to be proactive to ensure the inevitable move towards cashless is done in a way that protects our freedoms.
- eru 4y ago> Would it be possible to create some form of anonymous digital currency? Yes. Zero knowledge proofs might be some way to get there.
- kragen 4y agothat's how zcash and monero work
- coldtea 4y agoDigital is always prone to being lost/tracked/etc. You need to keep some "wallet" of credentials or something, there's always a trail, etc. For societies with no trouble, that might seem fine. In societies (which can include a huge chunk of the world) with turmoil, dictatorships or hostile governments, war, and so on, it's impossible to have the anonymity and portability of cash in digital form, while also being able to use it (a) without electricity, (b) without internet access, (c) without a trail
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kypro 4y ago
- durnygbur 4y agoDuring covid for a moment red/green status in a mobile app was determining basic civil freedoms and freedom of movement of an individual. This is the future if we go cashless. If things start going wrong, it takes few days for tyranny to creep in. Most people are ecstatic when given authority to control others and to toggle their rights.
- kuschku 4y ago"During the Zombie apocalypse, whether or not you're a zombie is determining basic civil freedoms and freedom of movement of an individual. This is the future if we go cashless" WTF? You do realize that it's not an arbitrary status in an app that mattered, but whether you're at risk of infecting hundreds, right?
- rgrieselhuber 4y ago“Zombie” - dehumanization is always a critical step in the process.
- kuschku 4y agoWe're talking about a highly contagious disease. I've lost my entire sense of smell (I used to be a quite good amateur chef before that, cooking for friends all the time, now that's gone) and I'm exhausted instantly when I do anything physical now, struggling with tasks that I used to do easily before. I'm not going to have any sympathy to people who intentionally and knowingly bring that upon others.
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoSo stay out of crowded areas. Rearranging an entire society with these sorts of measures is lunacy.
- komali2 4y agoIt sounds like you're arguing for the right to knowingly infect others with contagious disease. Sometimes things happen that cause society to need to be rearranged. In the case of COVID it really didn't require that much rearrangement - prefer outdoor activities, wear masks, stick HEPA filters in enclosed spaces, keep windows open. Contact tracing apps, maybe. We had those in Taiwan in a way that protected privacy. Predictably, people with reactionary tendencies, well, reacted, to which I say good luck in your next hurricane I guess? "Bah to this flooded city, I'm not about to let a half meter of water change how I live my life!"
- version_five 4y agoThe good news is that if there is a global push to digitalize currency, any country that doesn't, e.g. Switzerland is going to see demand for their money as a reserve currency shoot up. I don't know which country is actually closest to mandatory digital currency, say england for example- expect to see (and ideally start participating in asap) a CHF cash market
- pjc50 4y agoThe UK is a very long way from going cashless, we still have three of the four nations with independent banknotes! CHF as a banking currency has long been a safe haven. For a while they had negative interest rates in a desperate attempt to keep the value of their currency down to avoid destroying their export industries.
- phillc73 4y agoThe UK is in general making it very difficult to operate using cash. My experience last summer, as a tourist, was that certain attractions would accept card payments only. Want to go on a Thames river cruise or visit Warwick Castle? The only way to purchase tickets was via card. I also paid with a £50 for a few drinks in a bar and they did not have enough cash on hand to provide me with correct change. It was either end up out of pocket, or pay the correct amount with card. Making cash such an inconvenience means more and more people use cards (or some form of cashless payment), thus making it look like everyone wants to go cashless, which is not really the case. A similar story on a small local mini-market. I had a small number of items and ask the shop assistant to man the till for me. She told me that was not possible and I had to use the automated check-out system. However, because I was buying alcohol, she had to come over and approve the transation manually anyway! I do wonder if people working these jobs realise that automation is doing away with their livelihoods. They should be instead actively encouraging people to come to the manual till for checkout.
- pjc50 4y ago> I also paid with a £50 for a few drinks in a bar and they did not have enough cash on hand to provide me with correct change "£50 note in a bar" has been a mild horror story for as long as I can remember; bars hate accepting them. It's unlikely they didn't have enough cash to make change, unless you could see inside the till - more likely they wanted a non-confrontational way to refuse to take it, because £50 notes are the most common target for forgery, and they didn't want to give you real notes in change for a possible fake. Nobody uses £50 notes regularly, the ATMs largest option is nearly always £20.
- traspler 4y agoI'm Swiss and try to be as cashless as possible but I can absolutely understand people & businesses opposing a completely cashless future under the assumption that the current situation remains. The fees associated with the current system are exorbitant. Credit cards, as expected, have a pretty high fee of like 2.5% or more for the accepting business and the new Visa/Mastercard debit cards that they force on everyone have even more egregious fees of CHF 0.5 to 0.95 + 1.5% per transaction. Twint (our digital payment app) also has ~1.5% in fees per transaction and the business case of Twint is to farm as much payment data of the customers as possible for analysis and offers/ads. I do like the convenience of cashless but the cost in fees for businesses and the increased interest in exploiting my transaction history for an ads business sours this a bit for me.
- ignormies 4y agoOf course there are other reasons to avoid a purely cash-free society, but couldn't the Swiss government just limit the transaction rates/fees like the the EU? > caps interchange fees at 0.2% of the transaction value for consumer debit cards and at 0.3% for consumer credit cards; https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/summary/fees-for-card-based-payments.html https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/summary/fees-for-...
- mantas 4y agoThen banks just charge stupidly high card-reader and merchant account fees. It still sucks for small businesses in EU.
- mschuster91 4y agoSumup charges 39€ once per terminal, .9% for debit card transactions and 1.9% for credit card transactions. Nothing more. The times when accepting card payments was expensive have been over for years. Everyone whining about "card payments cost so much" should look what the combination of pricing caps and competition have brought up, especially with the pandemic. [1] https://help.sumup.com/de-DE/articles/4oI3qHHji2I2S9dyvRfec3-pricing-fees https://help.sumup.com/de-DE/articles/4oI3qHHji2I2S9dyvRfec3...
- febeling 4y agoI have the hope that recent revelations about censorship, and the problems with the covid vaccines on all levels have alerted people that their rights and interests are under attack globally. Good to see one of the few directly democratic countries move into that direction, with regards to possible mandatory centralized digital cash systems.
- qwerty456127 4y agoCashless society is an orwellian horror. I am so endlessly sad Switzerland apparently is the only nation to value their cash.
- pif 4y agoIt's the obvious choice when a great deal of your wealth comes from helping foreigners bypass their tax laws.
- Etheryte 4y agoI'm not really sure where you're taking Switzerland being the only one from. As far as I know there's currently no country in the world that's cashless?
- jeffrallen 4y agoSwitzerland is one of few countries in the world where the citizens WILL decide if they reject a cashless society. In most other societies, it is the politicians who decide, who are by and large beholden to corporate interests. And because corporations are more or less uninterested in freedom, and love big profits, corporations are fine with a cashless society.
- wil421 4y agoI would like to read about countries where politicians implemented a cashless society and what happened.
- qwerty456127 4y agoChina? Many other are not completely there yet but move in the cashless direction steadily.
- qwerty456127 4y agoFor example China already is experimenting with digital "money" you can only spend until specific date (before it expires) so people won't have savings (needless to say they also control who pays for what and can even block you completely once you say something the state doesn't like). Israel is not a cashless society yet but already requires people to specifically declare cash savings exceeding certain (pretty humble) amounts even if they have already declared the income and paid the taxes.
- cies 4y agoOne of the most functioning democracies of scale: the Swiss. And even there I think lobby (the enemy of actual democracy) has big influence on the decision taking process; it just may not be more than 50%, that in most "so called democracies" it most certainly has. I'd say it is down to the fact that the Swiss distribute their power better (by it being a collaboration of Cantons), instead of consolidating at the "lobbyable" top.
- margorczynski 4y agoAfter what I saw happening in Canada now I keep a bunch of cash stashed away. Still I pay for everything via card/e-payment, a bad habit I would say as that makes removing cash easier for the state - most will not even notice it too much.
- oblio 4y ago> After what I saw happening in Canada now I keep a bunch of cash stashed away. What happened in Canada? Their banknotes froze due to the extreme cold?
- hinata08 4y agoAll the ATMs were jammed due to bills oozing maple syrup.
- bsjaux628 4y agoThe Stupidity Convoy, sorry I meant the Freedom Convoy. A bunch of anti vaccination/Q-anon supporters decided to block the traffic in Canada because they couldn't phantom the idea of not spreading Covid. Most of them were able to remain blocking the traffic while still buying supplies because of the donations from other idiots in Canada and the US, so they froze their accounts
- glofish 4y agowhich was an illegal thing to do fighting an illegal thing with another illegal thing is not the way to proceed if a convoy blocks the way, go disperse the convoy, they did the illegal account freezing to avoid "looking bad".
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoI honestly thought this was referring to the time that Rogers (internet provider) had a nationwide outage that lasted for days.
- zirgs 4y agoHow would that cash help you wnen your bank account is frozen? You can't receive your salary. Can't pay rent or mortgage. And that cash will run out in a month or two. What then?
- intellectronica 4y agoThis is just another case where the far right picks up dubious fights in the name of freedom in order to recruit new supporters. There is really no imminent risk of Switzerland becoming forcibly cashless or people losing their freedoms.
- sschueller 4y agoI agree that this far right group bringing up this issue is a problem as I don't agree with any of their policies. However on this issue: There is a lot of push from Visa and Mastercard to get people to go cashless. Push of ads, claims that cash is dirty etc. PostFinance for example no longer is issuing their own debit cards instead are now also part of Mastercard. We have lost all control of our purchasing data. Additionally there are now several businesses not accepting cash at all when this is forbidden by law.
- intellectronica 4y agoIt's hard for me to judge how much of a problem this is, and it's at least to some extent a matter of opinion, but even if it is a problem, the guiding principle for non-extremists is that you resolve problems at the appropriate level. An alarmist campaign and a national initiative isn't the appropriate level for this kind of problem, which can more productively be addressed through the relevant regulatory bodies, consumer groups, etc ... The only reason to start a campaign like this one is to make noise, desperately trying to recruit supporters to far right causes. It's not an honest and genuine attempt to address a real problem, even and especially if you are convinced that this is indeed a problem.
- sschueller 4y agoYes exactly, I hope this doesn't backfire because of the way it is being brought up and accelerate the death of cash.
- gerikson 4y agoI figured FBS was far-right despite not reading German, simply from some keywords, the illustrations, and the web design. Interestingly they're presented neutrally ("a pressure group") in the linked Reuters article. It took some googling to find their webpage: fbschweiz.ch.
- therusskiy 4y agoAs a Russian last year I learned that any money in a bank are not really yours. Russian government banned withdrawing USD/EUR from ATMs while Mastercard and Visa banned using their cards. Your balanace ended up being a number in the app. Cashless - no thanks.
- durnygbur 4y agoWar costs money. Civilians will be cut off from money and pushed down by security services and "law" enforcement, rewarded with privileges and confiscated money. So obvious, such a cliché, and works flawlessly every time ad infinitum.
- kissiel 4y ago1. Not rouble. You could still withdraw RUB. 2. Invading other countries may have not-so-unforeseen-consequences. 3. War renders all kinds of money "just a number" I think.
- LatteLazy 4y agoI am sort of stuck on this. I never use cash, I hate cash. But the fact it exists does protect us from a bunch of dumb BS that I think would eventually happen otherwise (negative interest rates, compulsory spending, "haircuts"). I would have no issue with it being used to tackle tax evasion. I guess we will see...
- cosmodisk 4y agoThe last time I used cash was some dodgy kebab kiosk. I don't carry any coins or banknotes. I don't even have a wallet, just a card underneath the phone cover. However, I don't want my or any other country going full digital on it. Hell is already wallpapered with initiatives like this.
- gregnavis 4y agoI love dystopian novels and have recently finished reading Limes inferior[1] by J. Zajdel. Policies implemented in the story (written in 1982!) and their similarity to present day politics are frightening! SPOILER ALERT: I'm describing the currency system from the novel. Currencies were replaces by points stored on a device called the Key (= modern smartphone). There are red, green, and yellow points. Red points are the simplest: all people are equal, so everyone gets the same number of red points per month, doesn't matter their skills, employment status, health, etc. That monthly allowance is enough to survive. It's like basic minimum income. Green points are similar to red points, except they're paid out based on intellectual ability. A smarter person will always get more green points, irrespective of employment status. They were necessary because "all people are equal" is actually false. Yellow points are most similar to a monthly salary. You can get the only by working. The higher your position in the hierarchy, the more yellow points you get every month. Not all points are created equal, despite the official 1:1 fixed exchange rate. Quality goods are available only for yellow points, with other colors capable of buying substandard goods. That opened door to a host of black market activities for chameleons (who act as currency exchanges). A central computing system, called _Syskom_, is used to track citizens' moves. Despite claims of objectivity, it's rules are often manipulated for policy goals. A simplified example: some working people want to go up the hierarchy by faking their credentials. Criminals, called lifters, who can help them are often found in various bars. Those bars have slot machines allowing you to win hundreds of yellow points (an average salary is ~ 10 yellow pts). There's a non-zero chance that a winner, often drunk, will be approached by a lifter at a bar and hire him. What does the government to catch more lifters? Increase the likelihood of winning at a slot machine and keep track of where the prize flows. "You pay 300 yellow points and you get a lifter" as they phrase it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limes_inferior https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limes_inferior
- sschueller 4y agoIt is already illegal for businesses in Switzerland not the accept cash [1]. In fact the law specifically states that you need to accept up to CHF 100 in coins and all bills (including the CHF 1,000 bill). The issues is there is no penalty define if you don't and some businesses have decided they don't want to accept cash. This vote however wont fix this, all it does it force the SNB to continue to make cash available in the constitution when the SNB itself already clearly stated they have no interest in getting rid of cash and it is currently in the law. There was pressure from the EU for Switzerland to get rid of the CHF 1000 note but they didn't. If no one accepts cash the vote is mute. At least some should be forced such as food and clothing stores. Stores that are not 100% online. [1] https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/cc/2000/186/en#art_3 https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/cc/2000/186/en#art_3
- secretsatan 4y agoCash is definitely king here, I was absolutely astounded at the large denominations in circulation when I moved here. Back in the UK, people double check a 20 pound note, a Swiss cashier won't even blink after being handed a 1000CHF note
- russianGuy83829 4y agoThe logic behind the vote is that even while business have to accept cash, that wouldn't matter if there would be no cash physically available.
- koonsolo 4y agoIt's funny how some comments here try to reinvent cryptocurrencies.
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]
- _-david-_ 4y agoThere are a lot of people here talking about privacy and preventing the seizing of money. There is another issue though. Being able to buy things without power is also important.