13 ms·
WHO abandons plans for second phase of COVID-origins investigation
- locacorten 4y agoI'm disappointed to hear this news. Understanding the origins of Covid is one of the most important things we can do in this century.
- ethanbond 4y agoWhy is that? If it was a lab leak there will be no accountability anyway. If it wasn’t a lab leak, GoF research remains incredibly, incredibly high risk and should be banned. Seems almost definitionally not meaningful.
- workingdog 4y agoWe need to know so we can understand what we're doing that could lead to another disaster. Among the possibilities: wet markets, exploring caves, gain of function research, unclean cooking practices, or it could be just bad luck. Each of those would lead us to drastically differing ways of trying to mitigate the next virus.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoCan you explain how each scenario would "lead us to drastically differing ways of trying to mitigate the next virus."? There doesn't seem to be a practical way to control all known bat caves or unsanitary cooking practices. Controlling the illegal wildlife trade would require a huge government commitment which doesn't seem like a viable option.
- chitowneats 4y agoChina boasts about successfully reigning in things like drug trafficking/use, cryptocurrency investment, firearms ownership, liberal reforms and revolutions, etc. They can even prevent you from using basic public services if your state-assigned social credit score is too low. Are they lying about this? Exaggerating it in some major way? If not, I see no reason they can't shut down big wet markets like the one in Wuhan. I'm left to assume they know that COVID-19 did not originate in such a place. If it had, there would be an "all hands on deck" campaign by the security services to shut these markets down. It would be accompanied by a massive propaganda effort to convince average Chinese that wild and exotic meat is unsafe.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoDid you reply to the wrong comment?
- chitowneats 4y agoNo, I was casting doubt on this: "Controlling the illegal wildlife trade would require a huge government commitment which doesn't seem like a viable option." Why isn't it viable if it would prevent a pandemic? They already implement many other authoritarian policies (supposedly successfully) that are meant to curb far less dangerous outcomes.
- Supermancho 4y ago> If it had, there would be an "all hands on deck" campaign by the security services to shut these markets down. You're making a lot of rational deductions from assumptions of rational behavior without taking into consideration the backpressure (or negative consequences) that rational behavior will cause. eg If you start an exotic meat campaign, that's an implicit admission that it's a source (if not THE source) and you'll lose your position/head over suggesting it. Even if you could get some momentum, wherever you focus that campaign becomes the defacto ground zero. etc etc etc.
- chitowneats 4y ago> eg If you start an exotic meat campaign, that's an implicit admission that it's a source (if not THE source) and you'll lose your position/head over suggesting it Isn't it the official position of Xi Jinping, and the broader CCP he controls, that it was from the Wuhan wet market? I fail to understand why this is not a target for reform in China. "One bad apple", I guess. Plausible, but not believable, from my perspective.
- yunwal 4y ago> gain of function research
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThe parent comment addressed that if you read it carefully.
- haswell 4y agoThe parent comment asserted that it should be banned regardless, but arguably if such research was discovered to be the cause, it would be banned far more swiftly.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoI'm not quite sure if that was their meaning, since banning amateur GoF research in practice is impossible. Nor would any major country allow external inspectors into such highly classified areas. So there's no way of independently verifying claims of 'banning' in any case.
- ratg13 4y agoIf we know it came out of a lab, there would be a stronger call for internationalized safety precautions. As it stands now, BSL3/BSL4 are totally arbitrary depending on what country you are in.
- kevviiinn 4y ago>Each of those would lead us to drastically differing ways of trying to mitigate the next virus. Except we did already know some stuff but a bunch of people ignored it anyway, including chunks of the government. We learned from past viruses and a certain admin just decided to ditch the literal playbook
- LorenPechtel 4y agoThey *always* do. Acknowledging an outbreak means an economic hit to the area where it is. Officials *never* react in time to actually stop it because by the time it's obvious there's a problem it's already spread. How far it spreads comes down to how well it spreads and how well it resists efforts to stomp it out. SARS had low infectivity and showed symptoms before it became contagious--isolating the infected was possible. The world jumped on it and managed to fence it into extinction. (Note, however, that whatever the precursor was it wasn't ever identified.) MERS simply doesn't spread well regardless of containment. Covid-19, however, spreads mostly before symptoms show. This makes containment very hard--China was able to stop it with draconian lockdowns but even that doesn't work against the Omicron variants, it's simply not possible to isolate people well enough. (There are documented cases of it spreading through walls--the only way to be sure it doesn't spread is with a negative pressure room. It probably can't spread through a truly solid wall but most walls are not.)
- holografix 4y ago> There are documented cases of it spreading through walls Source?
- metadat 4y agoThe claim is of the specious and super-bogus-misinformation variety. We now understand how COVID infections occur: As a function of viral load due to exposure via inhalation of exhaled droplets transmitted through air shared with someone shedding the virus. https://www.michigan.gov/coronavirus/frequently-asked-questions/all/hi/how-does-covid-19-spread https://www.michigan.gov/coronavirus/frequently-asked-questi...
- majormajor 4y agoSetting aside the "active research" one, which is rather different than the rest of your list: given the amount of things we (earth-level "we", not a specific government) know increase risk of cancer or other health issues, but that we willingly tolerate for lack of alternatives... what changes do you really think would happen around things like cave exploration, wet markets (farmers markets too, or do you mean specifically just more unusual foods?), cooking practices?
- theGnuMe 4y agoI hate to break it to you but all human activity is the problem. Viruses will jump species and eventually hit pandemic levels. Research is required to minimize their impact. The bird flu could mutate and broadly infect humans killing millions. Swine flu likewise.
- chitowneats 4y agoMost people in the 21st century want to believe we have forever conquered such things. Even after COVID-19, many believe that if we had just tried a little harder we could've turned back the tide. I hope we remember the utter failure of "Zero COVID", especially in places like China, for a very long time. Humility is a virtue.
- autoexec 4y ago> Even after COVID-19, many believe that if we had just tried a little harder we could've turned back the tide. I can't speak to china, but "Zero COVID" wasn't even attempted in the US, and I'm absolutely certain that if we'd tried harder we could prevented tens if not hundreds of thousands of deaths. Many Americans made no effort to avoid getting infected and some went out of their way to get infected or to promote the spread of the virus while others were convinced even as they gasped their last breaths that the virus was hoax or clung to treatments that were ineffective or harmful. The efforts we Americans should have made but failed to started long before the first cases were discovered as people had been warning us about the dangers of a global pandemic yet we were entirely unprepared. Our stockpiles hadn't been maintained. Our hospitals were already understaffed and under-equipt. Our population already under-educated and lacking critical thinking skills. We were not ready for a crisis. We could do better for the next pandemic (and it is coming) but I haven't seen a lot being done to prepare us and a lot of damage has already been done which will take a long time to repair. The CDC has proved themselves to be unworthy of our trust, the government has proved that it will not adequately care for the needs of its people in an emergency, and our supply chains have proven to be critically fragile. I don't give us very good odds at doing much better when the next virus enters the ring and starts taking shots. We were tested, we failed, and we're still failing.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoShort of basically stopping any contact between humans and non-humans we aren't going to stop it. Finding the exact route this one took (which is probably impossible--the local officials destroyed as much possible evidence as they could trying, as local officials tend to, to not take the economic hit) says nothing about the exact route the next one will take.
- droopyEyelids 4y agoYou've fallen for the "all or nothing" fallacy of security. In reality, securing something means taking steps to reduce the probability of the event, and reducing the impact of the event when it occurs.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoYou're treating the event as a binary--but it isn't. Zoonotic jumps happen when you have an animal virus capable of infecting humans and you have contact between humans and said animal. The thing is such contacts aren't a one-off, if the potential exists sooner or later it's pretty much bound to happen. What we should be doing is studying the viruses that appear to have the potential to be pandemics. We got lucky in this regard with Covid--we didn't actually engineer a vaccine in a year. Rather, we had been working on a SARS vaccine for many years, it had been taken as far as it could be without human trials (and since there were no cases of SARS around human trails were impossible.) The mRNA Covid vaccines are simply the old SARS vaccine with some tiny edits to the payload--what took the year was the human trials, not the creation of the vaccine. That took IIRC 2 days.
- junofan 4y agoIf the investigation uncovers a covert offensive bioweapons program there would be major repercussions. Repercussions a state would do almost anything to avoid.
- encryptluks2 4y ago[dead]
- ethanbond 4y agoConcretely what are you imagining here? US/WHO/UN says "there was a covert bioweapons program" and China says "no there isn't" and then... we invade? We embargo China?
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoThe CCP would lose face, which is one of the worst fates for them. No more mandate from the heavens. Sure, they could try to deny it and claim the world is jealous of China or something like that, but that's unlikely to work for very long, especially with the rest of the planet. Losing their mandate from the heavens to rule China could very well lead to their ouster and perhaps the balkanization of China. Losing the respect of the rest of the world at a time when China wants to be the other major superpower, would be disastrous for them. In a multipolar world, the superpowers compete against each other for the loyalty of the rest of the world. Hard to do that when every single country on the planet suffered during the pandemic.
- ethanbond 4y agoLose face in the eyes of whom? Not clear to me that "this came out of our advanced bio research lab" is more damning than "this came out of our extremely unhygienic wet markets in urban centers."
- kneebonian 4y agoThese things move slowly and by little bits over time. If there were to be found a covert bio weapons program it costs China some credibility, not much but a bit and over time it just keeps happening.
- fasthands9 4y agoIf it was a lab leak it seems and the report said that then I imagine there would be a political consensus to ban GoF research. I dont disagree it should be banned either way but I think a bit naive to think it will be banned on its own.
- ethanbond 4y agoMaybe so, but it’s also naive to think we’ll ever get to certainty or near-certainty about the lab leak hypothesis without China’s participation (which, if culpable, we obviously will not get and cannot force). So the argument should take the form of, “jeez, this was awful and even if this was natural or artificial, we are purposely producing stuff like this on a daily basis in labs that regularly make mistakes.”
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoAt the very least, we can look at our own response to the pandemic, both government and societal, and agree that huge mistakes were made, and lessons need to be learned instead of taking the usual "Hey, let's just move on and forget about all the evil things we did" approach. There certainly needs to be a reckoning for the tech world that gleefully jumped on the authoritarian bandwagon and tried, somewhat successfully at times, to stifle all opposition to the botched pandemic response.
- ethanbond 4y agoSure, none of which is dependent on the origin of the virus.
- friend_and_foe 4y agoBanned by whom? You can't ban it. You can pretend to ban it, countries could get together and do something similar to nuclear nonproliferation, but as we see today that is only a stopgap, and the big countries that were already doing it will keep doing it. If it wasn't a leak, we need to understand the geopolitical dynamics that led to this, if this is the case it was on par with Hiroshima and surface nuclear weapons testing, it is as dangerous a technology as nuclear weapons.
- ethanbond 4y agoWell right it likely won't be actually banned, which pushes this further into the "not meaningful" territory. "If it wasn't a leak..." are you referring to a deliberate release scenario?
- friend_and_foe 4y agoI'm just responding to what you said, I'm assuming that's what you meant so that's what I had in mind when I wrote what I wrote, yes.
- ethanbond 4y agoThis is one of the problems with discussing the lab leak hypothesis is that it refers to two very different theories: accidental vs deliberate leak. I was primarily referring to the accidental version because deliberate is way less believable than accidental.
- baja_blast 4y agoProblem is unlike a nuke, a virus can not be controlled, and gives little bargaining power when compared to nukes. If the prestige of this research was taken away, China would stop investing in it.
- CSMastermind 4y ago> If it was a lab leak there will be no accountability anyway. There hopefully would be accountability from those in the west who did their best to crush any dissenting voices from even questioning the origins. I take no stance on this and don't consider myself informed enough to have an opinion but I will say that even asking the question two years ago made people treat you like a moon landing denier. I'd argue that response to crush the line of questioning at all is bad regardless of the true origin of the virus but if it did turn out to be a lab leak of some sort then hopefully it would spur all the academics, media pundits, and average joes who shouted down anyone asking questions to reevaluate their approach to topics like this.
- goodluckchuck 4y agoIf it was intentionally released by X, I think it’d be meaningful to hold X accountable.
- ethanbond 4y agoWhat does that look like, do you think? And what if we can only get to 99% certainty that it was intentional? Genuine question.
- anothernewdude 4y agoChina blocked it, it was their lab.
- ecf 4y agoChina wanting to have billions upon billions of citizens means it’s only right for them to own up to the occasions when those billions of people cause billions or trillions worth of economic damages to the entire world. Like it or not, if it’s Chinas fault then they should be forced to pay reparations. At the very least held accountable and change the circumstances that led to them breeding the virus.
- 6LLvveMx2koXfwn 4y agoGenuinely interested to know under what circumstances you envisage China being 'forced' to do anything. Held accountable means nothing here, and paying reparations is for the weak op cit History.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoWhy does it matter? We have multiple examples that virtually certainly aren't lab related. Even if this was a lab oops doesn't make the others go away. This time it just hit the jackpot on being able to spread well: spread before symptoms. We don't have enough understanding of genetics to engineer this. Covid is actually low in the lethality range for rampages from whatever is the underlying virus, it's just the others haven't spread so well. Finding that underlying virus could be useful, figuring out exactly how the zoonotic jump happened is simply an exercise in finger-pointing that will do nothing about the fact that they do happen naturally.
- foolfoolz 4y agothis is the single most disruptive event on the planet of the last 80 years. understanding how it happened can help us prevent it from recurring
- makeitdouble 4y agoSimilar widespread infection happened a few years before with SARS. Many countries even had procedures and emergency medical stock from there, and just discarded it for budget reasons from 2018. All this “prevent it from recurring” is cute but wont last long if history can tell.
- robomc 4y agoI mean you're right. It's weird that people are fixated on the specific way this outbreak occurred. Any plausible and proven way an outbreak of roughly this type could occur is equally significant, and I think is pretty well understood. If there was a strong will to reduce those risks it could happen without us knowing any specifics.
- vkou 4y agoWhy? It's not like we're going to react to the next pandemic any better.
- cosmic_gigachad 4y ago[dead]
- jacooper 4y agoWhat an expected disappointment. From how botched the first investigation was, it was clear China was never going to allow an actual investigation to happen.
- tjpnz 4y agoChina did allow an official investigation. It even included a visit to the Xi Jinping museum.
- webdoodle 4y agoEspecially since the virologists were educated in Canada, and the GoF was funded by the U.S.
- option 4y ago“ China is never goiing to allow an actual investigation to happen.” - any reasonable person should be now asking “Why?”
- bagels 4y agoMaybe you're trying to imply lab escape hypothesis, but probably any origin in China, including natural sources causes them discomfort due to the fact that the initial response was denial.
- option 4y agothe world needs to know, this is bigger than China and their “discomfort”
- autoexec 4y agoChina doesn't want anyone to start following up on that line of reasoning either. A lot of problems in China are "bigger than China". I doubt they'd want us snooping around looking into the specific sources of the air pollution they spread either (https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/03/03/518323094/rise-in-smog-in-western-u-s-is-blamed-on-asias-air-pollution https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/03/03/518323094...) China's problems involving climate change, human rights, censorship, manufacturing, product/consumer safety, and the economy all have global impacts but you can bet they don't want the rest of the world at their gates wanting to "do something" about any of it.
- GauntletWizard 4y agoChina should be the world's laughingstock, not bogeyman. They fucked up covid so bad that they are still in lockdowns. They let it happen in the first place and have done a hilariously bad job at the coverup. Pooh Bear doesn't have the mandate of his Mother, let alone Heaven.
- fwungy 4y agoChina is using covid lockdowns to manage consumer demand on their economy.
- mrkramer 4y agoVery responsible of them. :/
- qclibre22 4y agoMeanwhile, the U.S. House of Representatives is kicking off an investigation of covid origins: https://www.yahoo.com/news/gop-launches-probe-covid-origins-232616675.html https://www.yahoo.com/news/gop-launches-probe-covid-origins-...
- ch4s3 4y agoIf ever there were a team qualified to get to the bottom of this, it would include MTG and Matt Gaetz!
- influx 4y agoWhy do we have to rely on Republicans to investigate covid origins? Scary!
- purututu 4y agoMe as a European software engineer, understanding tech stuff well, but not American politics, what's the problem with the Republicans? Why would you prefer the other party, Democrats (right?) do the origin research instead?
- vuln 4y agoI wonder who swayed them to cancel the investigation? https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/04/world-health-organization-blame-pandemic-coronavirus/609820/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/04/world-h... https://www.cfr.org/blog/who-and-china-dereliction-duty https://www.cfr.org/blog/who-and-china-dereliction-duty https://www.politico.com/amp/news/magazine/2020/04/15/its-not-just-the-who-how-china-is-moving-on-the-whole-un-189029 https://www.politico.com/amp/news/magazine/2020/04/15/its-no... https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/04/02/china-coronavirus-who-health-soft-power/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/04/02/china-coronavirus-who-h... https://carnegieendowment.org/2020/03/23/fighting-coronavirus-pandemic-china-s-influence-at-world-health-organization-pub-81405 https://carnegieendowment.org/2020/03/23/fighting-coronaviru...
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 4y agoCovid killed more people than the Holocaust, and we're just going to sweep that under the rug so as not to create tension with a major global player. That's realpolitik for you.
- SnowHill9902 4y agoHas nothing to do.
- mandmandam 4y agoNot quite. 11 million people died in the holocaust. You're probably thinking of the 6 million Jewish people who were murdered. 5 million Roma, Jehovah's Witnesses, gay people disabled people, and others were also murdered.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kanzenryu2 4y agoThe Economist estimates about 20m dead https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-deaths-estimates https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-...
- purututu 4y agoSoftware programming rule #1: "Never fix bugs at their root cause." (joking, of course!!)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ARandomerDude 4y agoNothing to see here. Now shut up and take your highly profitable boosters.
- t0bia_s 4y agoWe will probably never know the real truth behind origin of virus. It carry burden of many deaths, fraud, money, poltics, ruined businesses and relationships... Worst part is, that it destroyed peoples trust in almost everything. Gonverments, science, dialogue, media, doctors... Good part is, that it will be harder to manipulate with masses by fear.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoThe virus didn't do that, the dishonest people involved in the response did that. They're not victims, they had choices to make and they made the ones that benefited themselves instead of the public they were entrusted to serve.
- t0bia_s 4y agoSure, but grinding for power was allways sickness of elected politicians. It just escalated into whole-socio-economical problem. Which proofs why globalisation is dangerous and decentralisation so important.
- tootie 4y agoPolitics did all that with an assist from social media. Scientists, mainstream media and reasonable politicians all handled the crisis pretty well. The speed of development and dispersal of effective vaccines was absolutely miraculous.
- t0bia_s 4y agoPolitics did what with assist of social media? I'm wonder why we cannot distribute drinking water and food like vaccines in poor countries? How do you know that vaccine was effective?
- tootie 4y agoVaccines. There are 8 or so that have been deployed. And we have absolutely tons of data on the morbidity rates of vaccinated vs unvaccinated controlled for other factors (especially age) that show they were effective. If you're really not sure then you just want to be a contrarian.
- frank_bb 4y ago[dead]
- purpleblue 4y agoThe WHO has shown itself to be completely and absolutely useless. It was wrong at the beginning and continuously was behind the curve. It was as if they wanted COVID to spread as quickly as possible. I think that it should be shut down at this point, there's nothing they can say that can ever regain their trust.
- gardenhedge 4y agoAgreed
- holografix 4y agoOnce again the world gets bullied into silence by the autocrats and “strong man” leaders. China buys too much from distinct European countries for them to coalesce as one trading partner and fight Chinese foreign trade bullying. France, Germany, Italy, etc know that if they voice concerns their exports will be subjected to “additional inspections” by the shameless CCP who acts with international impunity. They’re so shameless they’re lodging complaints about how their spy balloons have been shot down!
- maeil 4y ago> France, Germany, Italy, etc know that if they voice concerns their exports will be subjected to “additional inspections” by the shameless CCP who acts with international impunity. Then so be it, let those inspections come. 1930's appeasement all over again. China needs the EU as an export market just as much as the EU needs China. They're completely underestimating the strength of their own hand.
- option 4y agoWhat a shame. ATM, I can not imagine a more important question for WHO to answer. I must ask now - Do we actually need WHO now? What is its point?
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI know most of the comments here are the politics of the situation, but I just want to point out the extreme irony of this sentence from the article: > Researchers are undertaking some work to pin down a timeline of the virus’s initial spread. This includes efforts to trap bats in regions bordering China in search of viruses closely related to SARS-CoV-2; There is significant concern that the mere act of having researchers wade around in bat caves looking for coronaviruses is a bad idea. As happens frequently, Zeynep Tufekci has some of the most reasonable, logical takes on the pandemic [1]: > Many of these research practices weren’t deviations from international norms. A bat field researcher in the United States told me she now always wears a respirator in bat caves but that wasn’t standard practice before. > It isn’t a wild idea to suggest that field research risks setting off an outbreak. Dr. Linfa Wang, a Chinese-Australian virologist based in Singapore who frequently works with Dr. Shi and pioneered the hypothesis that bats were behind the 2003 SARS epidemic, told Nature there is a small chance that this pandemic was seeded by a researcher inadvertently getting infected by an unknown virus while collecting bat samples in a cave. There is also a good Twitter thread on this subject [2]. My vote is we stay the fuck out of trapping wild bats looking for viruses in the first place. 1. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/25/opinion/coronavirus-lab.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/25/opinion/coronavirus-lab.h... 2. https://twitter.com/zeynep/status/1557378231342350343 https://twitter.com/zeynep/status/1557378231342350343
- dboreham 4y agoBasis of the plot for the Alien movies.
- james_pm 4y agoBats are bad news and generally it's a very good idea to completely avoid contact with them and also with bat feces. Don't touch bats. Ever.
- chris1993 4y agoOne of the day trips on a Vietnam visit was swimming/wading deep into a bat cave. I wonder now what viruses we dodged and if they are still taking tourists in there?
- anenefan 4y agoTheir reasoning they don't have good access to China and all the data collected should be seen less as concerned interests who don't want the origins found, and more that the investigation isn't practical any more, given that no matter what they eventually found, the media pwned by various politics will still perpetrate the lab theory. I'm disappointed that they're not looking into the September 2019 detection in Italy of covid 19 (screened lung tissue samples) and the fact the closest iirc match so far to the original covid 19 is from a population of bats in Laos. It's not unreasonable to blame the emergence of the virus on the presence of an exotic animal trade which post codid 19, China has moved hard on that practise.
- lamontcg 4y ago> the September 2019 detection in Italy of covid 19 (screened lung tissue samples) That study was sheer utter fucking crap. They rolled their own antibody test, didn't do any false-positive testing, claimed to find D614G circulating then, and that it was commonly occurring in respiratory samples, during a time when Italy didn't have any excess deaths. It is literally dumb as fuck. The wastewater in early Dec seems to be good, matches the timeline of the pandemic, leading the wave of deaths by only a couple months, it only claims low levels of cryptic spread and was done by a totally separate group.
- anenefan 4y agoIs there a link to the full study and peer review? I wish I could find the original dissection and conclusions in 2020, but I don't recall the positive count being common. I don't recall where on the web I read the study in full and all I find about it on the web atm is somewhat limited. [1] [2] The findings were inconvenient to the lab theory cabal who have attempted to sweep away any noise that doesn't agree with their train of thought and attempts in the media, one being quite amateurish effort that needed delicate retraction where the noise the week before was being descriped along the lines as some time ago ... It would have been smart if WHO investigated to determine the variation in those samples to the Alpha strain which was detected in Wuhan. Clearly for a virus detected in 2019 that wasn't spreading much or rather benign, it wasn't the Alpha stain. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/health-coronavirus-italy-timing-idUSKBN27W1J2 https://www.reuters.com/article/health-coronavirus-italy-tim... [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33176598/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33176598/
- schoolornot 4y agoWhat does everyone think an appropriate punishment for China is if it comes out there was negligence in a lab?
- wkat4242 4y agoIncreasing measures at those labs, stopping gain of function research, much more international oversight in virus labs.
- baja_blast 4y agoOnly productive thing would be to forgive and the work to ban GOF on pathogens worldwide.
- pyuser583 4y agoThe WHO should invade Wuhan and claim it for the United Nations.
- gardenhedge 4y agoI remember when people were shunned for saying "lab leak". Now it's more than accepted
- tootie 4y agoLab leak is still not probable. There hasn't been any substantial evidence to change the likelihoods.
- guilhas 4y agoThere is no evidence because it was not investigated Opposed to the wild origin theory, after 3 year investigation there is also no evidence
- KerrAvon 4y agoIt's still an open question if you're honest. There's no hard evidence either way -- everything that people have come up with is disputed and reasonably so -- and China won't let people investigate.
- walterbell 4y agoAnnotated review of WHO draft agreements [1][2] to expand their powers over all countries globally. Note that the IHR amendments that will be voted upon in May 2023 only require the consent of 50% of countries to take effect, https://brownstone.org/articles/amendments-who-ihr-annotated-guide/ https://brownstone.org/articles/amendments-who-ihr-annotated... > The WHO proposes that the term ‘with full respect for the dignity, human rights and fundamental freedoms of persons’ be deleted from the text, replacing them with ‘equity, coherence, inclusivity,’ ... The underlying equality of individuals is removed, and rights become subject to a status determined by others based on a set of criteria that they define. This entirely upends the prior understanding of the relationship of all individuals with authority, at least in non-totalitarian states. It is a totalitarian approach to society, within which individuals may act only on the sufferance of others who wield power outside of legal sanction; specifically a feudal relationship, or one of monarch-subject without an intervening constitution. [1] 2023 draft of 2023 IHR amendments, https://apps.who.int/gb/wgihr/index.html https://apps.who.int/gb/wgihr/index.html [2] 2023 draft of 2025 treaty, https://docs.reclaimthenet.org/who-zero-draft-international-pandemic-treaty-february-2023.pdf https://docs.reclaimthenet.org/who-zero-draft-international-... The best references are the primary WHO source documents. A better source of analysis than Brownstone is needed. An older (May 2022) analysis was published by an EU law journal, https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-far-reaching-us-proposals-to-amend-the-international-health-regulations-at-the-upcoming-75th-world-health-assembly-a-call-for-attention/ https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-far-reaching-us-proposals-to-am... > ..amendments to Article 12 IHR will both considerably extend the executive powers of the WHO Director-General to declare global emergency-like situations and centralise this power further by removing the need to consult and find agreement with the respective state party ... if WHO’s powers are extended in this way, is there a need to also answer the question quis custodiet ipsos custodes (who guards the guards?), and to thus set up mechanisms ensuring that WHO complies with its obligations under the IHR and its Constitution, as well as its responsibilities for human rights deriving from customary international human rights law? HN ranking for this story, https://hnrankings.info/34795036/ https://hnrankings.info/34795036/
- ethbr0 4y agoThere is no effective pandemic response that respects individual rights, as we currently expect them. Too many people, too interconnected of a world. Better to go ahead and admit that if the shit hits the fan (SARS-CoV-2 being far from how bad a novel pathogen could get) then world organizations will need to be pretty totalitarian to effectively manage public health. If this concerns us, we should meet reality and focus on criteria and processes by which those powers will be guaranteed to be rolled back when the situation allows. The alternative to having such agreements in place is an procession of ineffectual response, fear, death, ceding power to authorities from fear, and then having no structures in place by which that power can be subsequently reclaimed.