11 ms·
War and subsidies have turbocharged the green transition
- whatever1 4y agoWar and subsidies have turbocharged the LNG transition. There, I fixed the title.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- uoaei 4y agoThe misdirection is so bald-faced and shameless.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoNatural gas compliments renewables until battery storage and renewables overproduction pushes out natural gas. It also produces smaller amounts of CO2 per unit of electricity produced versus coal. Recently, there was an HN thread about large amounts of UK wind curtailment. The largest battery storage system in Europe just went live to provide grid services that’ll negate the need for natural gas to provide those services, while reducing wind curtailment. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34358795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34358795 https://www.energy-storage.news/europes-largest-transmission-connected-bess-begins-world-first-reactive-power-services-contract/ https://www.energy-storage.news/europes-largest-transmission...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 4y agoThat looks .. disappointingly small? 100MW for one hour, made up of what looks like 24 containers in a yard? I guess there's a very long way to go.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoIn Germany, the main function of LNG long term will be to smooth the transition of households from burning gas for heating to using heat pumps. As LNG is expensive, people who can will switch sooner than later. Also, rolling out heat pumps is going to take a long time and some people will be dependent on gas for as long as that is going to take. A secondary role for LNG is to power gas peaker plants when renewables fall short. Mainly this can be done with existing gas plants. There's very little need for building more of those. Also, coal plants remain popular for this. Before the war the plan was replacing coal with gas plants. With current gas prices, that plan is out of the window and we're now looking at increased speed of the rollout of wind, solar, and batteries instead.
- voqv 4y agoGermany's steel and chemistry sector require large amounts of natural gas. In general, natural gas (currently LNG) was also to smooth a transition towards green hydrogen, the plan being to build infrastructure that can burn/store/use both, as explicitly stated by Federal ministries/agencies. > that plan is out of the window There hasn't been officially confirmed, soon there will be a report called "Power plant strategy 2026" that will give a better outlook as to what is gonna happen this decade.
- jillesvangurp 4y ago> There hasn't been officially confirmed, soon there will be a report called "Power plant strategy 2026" that will give a better outlook as to what is gonna happen this decade. It's a highly political topic. Blue hydrogen from LNG is more of a research topic / aspirational thing for the fossil fuel industry than it is an actual thing. This seems to be more of a talking point than something that is being done at scale with any decent capture of carbon. LNG in the industry is of course a thing. Heating things is done with gas and coal mostly. A lot of that will have to be transitioned away to something else. Hydrogen might be an option. But some industries might also switch to other forms of heating. E.g. there are some ways to use electricity directly for this via things like induction or plasma heating. Historically, using fossil fuels was cheap. But when you are going to use vast amounts of electricity to generate green hydrogen for industrial heating use cases, this changes. Using the electricity directly might be more efficient in some cases.
- throwaway4aday 4y ago> 100MW/107MWh Oh good, only 3,000 more of these and things should be peachy.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoIt’s a good thing then that Tesla is building 40GWh/year of storage at their new Megapack factory in Lathrop, CA, although the more utility scale storage manufacturing capacity built, the better. We’re going to need a lot as you mentioned, and they’re currently sold out for the next two and a half years. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvSmMUdC_nA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvSmMUdC_nA
- cinntaile 4y agoI think it is more accurate to include both. War and subsidies have turbocharged the LNG and green transition.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> War and subsidies have turbocharged the LNG transition The IEA projects "renewables are set to account for 90% of the increase in global generation capacity" between 2022 and 2027, "almost 30% higher than the agency’s forecast in 2021."
- HPsquared 4y agoThat's nameplate capacity; what about production?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> nameplate capacity; what about production You want actual production figures for 2027?
- HPsquared 4y agoForecasts would be nice I guess. It was more to point out that renewable generation equipment generally has quite a low utilization factor compared to the existing infrastructure, so a given increase in "capacity" does not reflect the same increase in actual production.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agofor a rough estimate, divide wind and solar by 3, nat gas by 2 and leave nuclear untouched. this suggests that the actual figure will be closer to 80%.
- stuaxo 4y agoHas the IEA got any better at predicting renewables than it has been over the last 20+ years when it grossly underestimated them ?
- pjc50 4y ago.. in which direction?
- biggoodwolf 4y agoHow convenient! Why stop there, might as well go to the Stone Age, if the green transition does not get us there, then global war surely will. /s
- user3939382 4y ago[flagged]
- staunton 4y agoAny opinions on the actual article?
- pydry 4y agoThat was an opinion. They're trying to sell this war on its benefits as hard as they sold the invasion of Iraq.
- staunton 4y agoIt was an opinion on the source, not on what it says. Your second comment still doesn't adress any claims of the article, it just attributes malicious intent to it without mentioning what makes you think that. The claim is that while rich countries don't really care enough about the climate to seriously pursue a "green transition", many now realized that they do care about energy self-sufficiency to accelerate it. Do you disagree? Do you think the article says something different?
- user3939382 4y agoMy opinion is that The Economist is looking for any angle to support the fleecing of the American people to the tune of $130B which we just handed over to the arms industry. The war was crafted by this industry through its puppeteering of the US government for expressly this purpose. The Economist might as well write an article about the long-term positive impact on the planet of humans being obliterated by the nuclear war them and their neocon buddies are happy to risk. 95% of the people I've discussed this war with have absolutely no clue about the politics and history behind the current conflict and are repeating headlines they got from US corporate (propaganda) media outlets.
- staunton 4y ago
- CalRobert 4y agoCan anyone taking issue with this article please address the substance of it?
- rippercushions 4y agoTo me the article is just economics 101. 1) Supply is constrained (by the war and sanctions), demand is fixed to rising, so price goes up. 2) Price goes up, so there is more demand for alternatives, including dirty ones (coal) but also green ones (solar, wind, etc). 3) Increased investment in green energy sources will make them more competitive faster than expected and thus spur the transition.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> investment in green energy sources will make them more competitive faster than expected and thus spur the transition The article is worth the read. Apparently "S&P Global, a data firm, thinks emissions from energy combustion will peak in 2027, at a level the world would still be producing in 2028 had the war not happened." This isn't theorized market activity, it's actual changes in generation capacity plans made over the last twelve months.
- kneebonian 4y agoInterestingly enough pretty much the same factors pushed the shale revolution in oil extraction.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> the same factors pushed the shale revolution in oil extraction The salient difference being the state intervention this time around. Fracking was largely private R&D.
- stonogo 4y agoThe Department of Energy literally invented modern fracking; see the Eastern Gas Shales Project, which lasted for a decade and a half. Early commercial fracking worked off of shale mapping performed at Sandia National Lab; reference here https://energy.sandia.gov/wp-content/gallery/uploads/FINAL-HydraulicFracturing-Final-wSAND1.pdf https://energy.sandia.gov/wp-content/gallery/uploads/FINAL-H... (which research continues). Finally, the government provided $10 billion in tax cuts for unconventional gas drilling over the past thirty years, so even that private R&D was subsidized.
- russianGuy83829 4y agoGreat, we don’t have to change anything then! Thanks, capitalism!
- runarberg 4y agoI don’t know if this is addressed by this article (I cant read it because paywall) but I’m gonna make a leap of assumption—because this is the economist and are likely to be guilty. I’m seeing more and more of a new kind type of climate denialism pop up lately, which I like to call climate optimism. A climate optimist is aware that the climate crisis is real, is caused by humans, and is an existential threat to humanity. However, they claim that the worst of the climate crisis has already been solved with technology and capitalism. I.e. they think that the current and developing technology solution will prevent more climate disasters and now it is just up to the free market to apply it. In other words, there is nothing more that governments must do but to stop subsidizing the fossil fuel industry (sometimes natural gas is excepted). A prime example of a climate optimist is the youtube channel Kurzgesagt. But I see this a lot from people that like to cite Our World In Data. This is climate denial because it completely ignores global trends in carbon emissions, production capabilities, infrastructure rollout in poorer economies, etc. We are still increasing our carbon emissions (albeit at a slower rate) at a time when we needed to have stopped releasing CO2 altogether. EDIT: After reading the article (as someone posted an archive) I see—to my surprise—that this article is not guilty of my accusations.
- DubiousPusher 4y agoDespite the drubbing the Economist is taking in this thread (and I'm no fan myself) this article is pretty much innocent of this accusation. The article simply points to some modeling which indicates European/American subsidies for green energy and the increased friction in the global oil/gas markets created by the war in Ukraine have accelerated energy transitions in advanced economies. It makes no conclusions about the future beyond these models and does not hand-wave away climate risk at all.
- dotnet00 4y agoI feel like it's telling that you need a break from the internet if someone being optimistic that progress is being made on addressing climate change at all is problematic to you. You point to Kurzgesagt, and while I'm not much of a fan of them, their most recent video on climate change presents a view that the situation is dire but not hopeless, which is a healthy view to present if you're aiming to convince people to care.
- rippercushions 4y agohttps://archive.is/KMsTT https://archive.is/KMsTT
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- colonCapitalDee 4y agoFor the many people who are criticizing the article for being pro-war: the article is simply claiming that the energy war between Russia and the West is increasing global prices for fossil fuels and is spurring concerns over energy security. Increased prices for fossil fuels makes green energy more cost competitive and concerns over energy security drive nations to find alternative energy sources. Increases in the cost competitiveness of green energy and the search of nations for new energy sources has increased private and public investment in green energy, speeding up the energy transition. This simple chain of cause and effect is oversimplified, which is why there's a whole article written about it. At no point does the article claim "war is good because it's spurring green energy spending", or "we should have more wars to spend more on green energy", or "war has downsides, but upsides like increased green energy spending are worth it". If you think that any statements that address the positive externalities of war simply shouldn't be uttered (because they glorify war, or encourage war, or whatever), then you're an idiot who thinks everyone else is an idiot.
- haswell 4y agoAssuming one believes your argument, a more charitable conclusion is that some people may be misguided, and a reexamination of their stance may be warranted. Calling people idiots isn’t going to change people’s minds, and people hold bad opinions about things all the time for reasons that aren’t as simplistic as “they’re an idiot”.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoI think the disparagement is warranted. Not because it will be effective. But because it helps focus attention away from unproductive comments.
- colonCapitalDee 4y agoIdiot is me being charitable. People who believe that speech should be limited specifically because that speech may engender beliefs in others that they disagree with are idiots at best, and malicious authoritarians at worst. This isn't free speech absolutism, I'm not advocating for unrestricted misinformation, propaganda, or calls to violence. I'm stating that people who believe that "wrongthink" is not permissible are idiots, and I have zero interest in trying to change their minds (at least over the internet). As an example, I've encountered feminists who think that the very real issues men struggle with in America should not be discussed because the very act of discussing those issues might make some people think "hey, in some ways men are worse off then women" and this would influence those people to not support feminism. I'm not trying to pick on feminism here, it's just an example. If these feminists thought that the issues men face aren't real, or that the issues women face are so immeasurably worse as to make men's issue immaterial, that would be one thing and I would be happy to explain to them why I think they're wrong (and listen to their rebuttals). But I have no interest in engaging with someone who thinks that rhetoric can be suppressed and ignored just because it's inconvenient for them and their cause.
- olivermarks 4y ago'Yet the reality is that the return of brown fuels is a subplot in a much grander story. By making coal, gas and oil scarcer and dearer—prices remain well above long-run averages, despite recent falls—Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has given renewable power, which is mostly generated domestically, a significant strategic and economic edge.' Classic Rothchild/Agnelli Economist - never mind the 'heat or eat' struggling humans, this is really helping the 'renewable power' industrialists...
- redeeman 4y agoyes, it really quite would be a shame if someone noticed how wars tend to always magically reinforce and favor some goals and ideals of the upper elites. Never the peasants on the floor. Im sure the western powers are extremely sad about the war, despite how it obviously amplifies a longstanding agenda. Coincidence, im sure.
- fragmede 4y agoIn the dead of winter - which means fewer daylight hours, cloud cover, and snow cover, solar's going to be pretty inefficient, and so with a huge array you'd only get a little bit of energy out. And critically you also need batteries to time shift the energy to heat during the colder night time hours. But it's a system that President Putin, or anyone else can't withhold. Relationships change. LNG from America ain't it.
- Zigurd 4y agoNatural gas production in the US has started declining. Even with the demand for LNG in Europe.
- magnuspaaske 4y agoThe article makes a lot of bold claims of the energy transition happening faster than otherwise and then mostly ignore all the context that kind of goes against the point. The most egregious example of this is saying coal has been in a secular decline for 8 years but somehow a 1.2% increase in coal use last year lead to a record – for most people that would suggest that coal use has plateaued and is not in fact decreasing as the article would otherwise want you to believe. Elsewhere it mentions 90% of new generating capacity will be renewable over the next years, but that also kind of ignores that there'll still be 10% not renewable capacity coming online and, oh yeah, India might also have new coal plants coming online in the years ahead. This is pretty important when considering that coal is still the most common source of electricity but also that electricity is only a part of our energy needs – switching to electrified transportation, industry and heating systems will all create more demand for electricity. Seeing as we want to phase out coal we would need renewable energy to account for more than 100% of net new production and we haven't even reached that. Even with all the speedup in the green transition happening over the past few years it still doesn't happen at close to the speed needed – in fact we're not even close to seeing the end of coal regardless of everything going on.
- Zigurd 4y agoThe fact that US natural gas production is in decline even as fracking and LNG demand are in play, one would have to admit, is remarkable.
- cosmic_gigachad 4y agoDefine “in play”. The current administration campaigned on blocking all new exploratory leases, which they’ve done (and is now in a confusing legal battle). The current administration also blocked the Keystone pipeline. So no new ventures, and no cheap transportation from our partners to our north. Seems like the North American industry is being starved.
- pfdietz 4y agoYou seem to be deliberately confusing natural gas with petroleum.
- Archelaos 4y ago"Lutzerath ... after Robert Habeck, the country’s energy minister, allowed a utility firm to mine for lignite ... In their panic to keep the lights on, policymakers across Europe and Asia are reopening coal mines ..." The first statement is not correct and the continuation is misleading. It was not an individual descision of minister Habeck (Green party) to allow the demolition of Lützerath, but of the German federal parliament with its majority of Labour (SPD), Greens and Liberals (FDP) in the context of its Coal-fired Power Generation Termination Act ("Kohleverstromungsbeendigungsgesetz"). The previous version of the law from August 2020, enacted by a colation of the Conservatives (CDU/CSU) and Labour (SPD), provided for the demolition of five more villages and some little settlements. This was later, in March 2021, altered into its present form by a so-called guiding decision of the government (a coalition of Conservatives and Liberals) of North Rhine-Westphalia, the state in which Lüzerath is located, on which the modified federal law from December 2022 was based. The Green Party of minister Harbeck was clearly the political force that had pushed hardest for a phase-out of coal as quickly and as extensively as possible. Of course, there are critics who believe that what has been achieved was not enough. Be that as it may, less would probably have been achieved without the participation of the Greens. For this reason it is dubious journalism to single him out. An it is also not only very low quality journalism, but deliberate misinformation not to mention that Lützerath represents the end of coal mining in the region and instead putting it into the context of an alleged reopening of coal mines.
- jacquesm 4y agoJust one datapoint: this war has motivated me to make at least this house as independent of external energy sources as possible within the limits of physics and my budget. Gas prices have gone up so far and so fast that freestanding houses are listed for sale all over the place here. I've installed a relatively large amount of solar (nominally a bit over 10 KW) and I'm using that to offset the gas bill as long as we have netmetering (essentially this allows us to use the grid as a battery). A relatively small air-air heatpump is providing auxiliary heat on really cold days to help limit the gas consumption. A larger one will be installed this year to help increase the self consumed portion of our generated energy so that when the netmetering days come to an end (projected: 1/1/2025) we'll still be able to use that energy efficiently and without the use of batteries. For us the subsidies never came into play (they have always been maxed out and besides the payback time is short enough that I don't think subsidies should be there at all), but the war certainly did. Finally, dropping the temperature a bit also really helped, unfortunately people have different comfort levels so this is a bit of an issue but by keeping one part of the house at a slightly higher temp everybody gets theirs and we still save a bundle.
- landemva 4y agoI would have started with energy audit including blower door test and infrared pictures. Next I would have got busy sealing and insulating. New solar installs or heaters would then be considered.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 4y agoI did the IR picture thing, ran the numbers, and decided that the biggest ROI was to install panels, the house was already quite well insulated by the previous owners. But we are due for a refresh on all of the window frames + windows, those are definitely getting a bit old.
- krageon 4y agoIf you seal properly you need mechanical ventilation. I'm not saying you're implying you don't, a lot of people around me forget such things and end up with very unhealthy living environments.
- LatteLazy 4y agoIn almost the entire EU and especially here in the UK, governments have stepped in to spend huge amounts subsidising energy (including gas), SPECIFICALLY AND EXPRESSLY to that people don't use any less. As someone with decent insulation and solar panels etc, this was exactly the time those investments should have paid off and for other people to be left behind because they refused to take basic measures. Instead they've been bailed out and progress has been put off for another decade. And this sums up the whole of our green policy for the last 40years: we absolutely must do something, unless people don't want to, which they don't.
- LemmyInThePub 4y ago> in the UK, governments have stepped in to spend huge amounts subsidising energy (including gas), SPECIFICALLY AND EXPRESSLY to that people don't use any less No. The government stepped in because poor people (and many not so poor) could not afford to heat their homes over winter. It is (was) an emergency measure. The transition to green energy is well under way in the UK, regardless of temporary subsidies.
- LatteLazy 4y agoIn the UK, they capped the price of energy per kWh. So they bailed out everyone, rich, poor and middle alike. And the more energy you used, the more support you got. So richer and more wasteful households got the MOST support. Saying "but the poor" while throwing money at the rich is pretty self-contradictory IMHO. If they'd at least made cash payments, even if it was the same per household, it would at least have incentivised people not to waste energy. But no, it specifically rewarded people for increasing their consumption.
- butler14 4y agoI agree that the incentives were off on paper But is there any evidence that's been the case, that people have increased their consumption? Anecdotally, I can't think of anyone I know that hasn't actively reduced their usage
- 4y ago
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoStupid question: But were does a normal citizen buy redox flow batteries? I googled far and wide, and those are just not sold in my area to end consumers (germany). Has somebody else a website were you can order those? I can order normal battery packs just fine, but the chemical storage ones (https://redflow.com/ https://redflow.com/) are vannishing into silence here in germany, for unknown reasons.
- butler14 4y agoThese are new to me. Would you mind elaborating on why these specifically, rather than conventional LIon?
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoThey have infinite loading cycles, they are rather bulky, basically a fluid medium is charged and discharged. This allows for the storage capacity to easily scale (the generator remains, the tanks increase). In addition the storage fluid can be rather friendly substance from a environment perspective (some use drinkable salty water). And cheap. And if you have a old pool or a old oil tank in your house you are basically halfway there regarding installation. Its basically chemical storage of energy, allowing for the (re)use of preexisting installations.
- JackMcMack 4y agoI was skeptical, the site seemed to only show renders, nothing practical. It looks real though: https://simonhackett.com/2021/05/23/redflow-gen3-zbm/ https://simonhackett.com/2021/05/23/redflow-gen3-zbm/ Datasheet: https://redflow.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/RDF1199-Redflow-ZBM3-Datasheet-WEB-SML.pdf https://redflow.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/RDF1199-Redfl... Nothing on price
- pjc50 4y agoI don't think I've ever seen them aimed at the retail market? The downside of flow batteries is that they're no longer solid state - they have mechanical pumping elements that require maintenance. I've only ever heard them discussed in the context of grid or industrial sized units, where the value provided by scale is enough to make the servicing economically worthwhile. Which chemistry manages to use drinkable water for storage?
- talideon 4y agoJust kind of a pity that some of the most productive farmland in the world now resembles the surface of Mars, along with hundreds of thousands dead and millions displaced.
- cpursley 4y agoIf you wanna have your mind blown, start looking into who bought up a lot of that farmland (and agricultural enterprise) starting after the 2014 uh, government restructuring. Hint: it’s not the Ukrainians. And they were changing laws to allow more foreign takeover of Ukrainian agriculture by multinationals all the way up to the invasion.
- lm28469 4y agoYou mean that? : https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2022/09/13/fact-check-ukraines-president-did-not-sell-farmland-us-companies/7942775001/ https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2022/09/13/fact... Looks like the type of comment you'd find on a boomer conspiracy theorists facebook group
- cpursley 4y ago“Cargill, which owns a majority stake in a deep-sea port near Odessa” https://www.world-grain.com/articles/16539-ports-grain-facilities-shut-down-in-ukraine https://www.world-grain.com/articles/16539-ports-grain-facil... https://www.kyivpost.com/post/7480 https://www.kyivpost.com/post/7480 https://www.oaklandinstitute.org/sites/oaklandinstitute.org/files/Brief_CorporateTakeoverofUkraine_0.pdf https://www.oaklandinstitute.org/sites/oaklandinstitute.org/... https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-agriculture-farmland-economy-/31336984.html https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-agriculture-farmland-economy...
- lm28469 4y agoYou could have posted that directly instead of making very vague insinuations that no one can source by themselves unless they already know what you're talking about
- Synaesthesia 4y agoWar runs on oil. While the war continues we will be wasting a lot of petroleum powering tanks, trucks, drones and planes... All so we can kill each other. Pretty much the worst thing for the environment.
- yyyk 4y agoThe article's conclusion may be distasteful to some, but is in line with historical precedent. The 1973 Yom Kippur war and following oil embargo led to fuel economy standards, CFL research was started, search for alternate fuel sources and extraction method such as fracking... Many parallels to today, except "green" sources barely existed at the time.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 4y agoThe French 'Messmer Plan', a huge buildout of nuclear power, was a direct response to that 1973 oil crisis.
- pictureofabear 4y agoUnfortunately, conflict is an unsightly yet integral part of how humans progress. When the conflict becomes violent, the stakes become high enough to force us to do something drastic. I guess it's like that probably untrue idea of boiling a frog alive.
- cosmic_gigachad 4y agoWar progresses many industries and humanity as a whole. “War! What is it good for?” by Ian Morrison is a good read.
- mmsimanga 4y agoI don't have any reference but I expand it from any war to any crisis. Ask for a new server at work and you are ignored for years until the old server crashes and cannot be recovered. Suddenly they will be funding for new server and approvals done within the hour. It is sad humans too often need a crisis to realise what is important and focus on it. No crisis no focus everyone just pulling in different directions.
- staunton 4y agoThat makes a lot of sense though, to the point of being tautological. When something is a crisis, i.e. an urgent problem, you deal with it. If it's not urgent, it can wait. The fact that it would very often be "cheaper" or more efficient to deal with any individual problem ahead of time somewhat loses it's appeal when you consider the huge amount of potential problems that are costly to even evaluate as to the benefits of dealing with them in advance.
- andrewclunn 4y agoIncentives shape human action, but can't force us to break the laws of physics. When a certain type of person rejects emergence in economics as cruel right-wing ideology, but embrace it for promoting scientific progress, the tribal blinders become laughably clear. "The Black Plague was good because it lead to the Renaissance!" See? Anyone can retroactively find a way to justify or defend the merits of an event. It's not clever and (speaking personally) I find it to be an antihuman elitist view that can only be taken by those who see themselves as outside of or above history.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoA slight confounding factor here is that the green energy transition has been snowballing anyway. Just as the bad news about climate often uses the "faster than expected" cliche, the renewables stories are often about updates to predictions because they are higher than previously estimated. It would be easy to assign that increase to any big event that had just occurred. I do notice some changes that I attribute to the war, but it's only pushing at an open door. On a global scale how much does it compare to solar being the cheapest form of energy and other technical, industrial and political progress decades in the making? I'm not sure I see any direct link for EV success. More that all the big manufacturers (with Japan as a weird outlier) with government connections being on board at last and FUD being dispelled.