12 ms·
Hackers interrupt Iran president’s TV speech on anniversary of revolution
- afarrell 4y ago> A voice shouted "Death to the Islamic Republic" This sounds like a source of fear that is likely to motivate people to seek security and stability. I imagine it would remind people of the threat they've been told their community faces from the countries which created Stuxnet, and the weapons carried by Saddam Hussein's army, and the 1953 coup against Mossadeq. I imagine it would motivate Iranian men to stand together to serve as protectors of the stability of their community and to tolerate the flaws of their leaders. I imagine it would stand in the way of freedom-loving Iranians trying to create an alternate vision of Iranian civic virtue.
- wl 4y agoIt's an idiom. https://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=31116 https://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=31116
- auganov 4y agoI'll have to agree with this comment by "Jason": Victor Mair quoting a colleague said: "In 1998 when the reformist president, Mohamad Khatami, came to power he tried to eliminate this slogan from the political scene and he suggested to replace any 'marg bar' slogan with 'zendeh baad my opponent'." Why would he try to do this if "marg bar X " neutrally means "down with X", not "death to X". Similarly: "Alireza is right to try to downplay the slogan — for two reasons: 1) This is an early revolutionary slogan that is quite exaggerated. 2) Not many Iranians actually subscribe to this view…The official government uses this slogan, but not many actually take it seriously." Again, why is your colleague /so concerned to downplay the significance of this slogan/ as "exaggerated" (whatever that means — do they mean "hyperbolic") and "not taken seriously" if it merely means "down with America?" Frankly this piece reads like pure political drivel of the type that's increasingly infecting Language Log of late, when it seems perfectly obvious that: 1) Marg bar Amrika literally means "Death to America" 2) Native Persian speakers are perfectly aware of this fact, or else why try to euphenize/euthemize the expression or downplay how "seriously" Iranians take it? Reza Mirsajadi's effort in sophistry reminds me of David Irving's attempts to prove that "ausrotten" doesn't mean "exterminate". And indeed, given what happened to the Shah, the fact that the phrase originated in the Iranian revolution is the opposite of comforting. Violent metaphors have a long provenance in all langauges, but in the age of terrorism and the twitter soundbite every English speaker has had to learn to avoid them /precisely because/ you can never know if such threatening language is sincere or not. I fail to see why Iranians should get a free pass and a translational obfuscation courtesy of Mirsajadi on such language. Can anyone trust Mirsajadi to translate honestly after this particular effort? You may as well claim "go kill yourself" is an idiom that means "I don't like you". An idiom is when it's nearly impossible to infer the actual meaning based off the literal meaning of the words. A hyperbole or a metaphor does not make an idiom. Death is invoked here exactly because of what it implies. "Death to X country" is not any less metaphorical in English. A country obviously cannot die.
- afarrell 4y agoAh, then CNN could do a better job translating. "death to" and "down with" have pretty different meanings.
- mc32 4y agoI think it’s more nuanced and can mean both, depending on what the speaker wants it to mean. Like two buddies trading insults )it could be banter or of could be a genuine insult). The tone denotes the meaning.
- unmole 4y agoDo you speak Farsi? The Hindustani variant Murdabad is never meant literally.
- selimthegrim 4y agoIt’s still considered gauche, i.e. they tell you not to sloganeer with it at Indo-Pak border
- alephnerd 4y agoIt used both literally and figuratively in Punjabi, Pahari, and Pashto as well.
- skissane 4y agoThe problem they face, is it has become a well-known tradition in American (and Western) journalism, going at least back to the hostage crisis in 1979. If they change the translation now, people will attack them as pro-Iran/pro-regime/etc. It is possibly an even bigger problem when it comes to the use of the phrase against Israel; I wouldn’t be surprised if a change of translation in that context got labelled as anti-Israel, anti-Zionist, even antisemitic. The politically safest course is just to keep on doing what you’ve always done
- rjzzleep 4y agoA lot of Iranians got really upset when the son of the Shah tried to hijack the movement to become "the representative" of the Iranian reforms.
- mighty_donkey 4y agoLet's be careful using words like 'hijack'. Reza Pahlavi (i.e. the son of the Shah) has led one of the most consistent and coherent oppositions to the Islamic Regime for the past few decades (has dedicated his life to it), and has clearly stated his only intent is to create a transition/solidarity council to enable an actual, democratic system in Iran. Over 85% of protestors are in favour of such a council, and 33% of them believe Reza Pahlavi should be the representative of such a council (which places him as the most popular representative by far). You can read more here (GAMAAN conducts the most rigorous surveys on public attitudes in Iran): https://gamaan.org/2023/02/04/protests_survey/ https://gamaan.org/2023/02/04/protests_survey/
- propagandist 4y agoLet's also be careful about sampling bias. The Shah regime is still widely despised in the country. If you're suggesting that we treat the revolutionaries as representatives of the people a la Chalabi and his motley crew in 2003, be prepared for disaster.
- mighty_donkey 4y agoReza Pahlavi =/= Shah's regime Also sorry but equating a bottom-up, grassroots revolution with the US invasion of Iraq is a gross misrepresentation of what's actually happening.
- propagandist 4y agoThere was massive grassroots opposition to Saddam too. And there is also precedent of a "grassroots" revolution back in 1953 in this very same country. Sorry that I'm taking this claim with a pinch of salt.
- actionfromafar 4y agoIran is currently in a position where nothing but violent resistance is likely to have an effect. The people in charge live safely in gated communities or abroad and have no shame, protestor deaths in the streets don't faze them even a little bit.
- afarrell 4y agoWhy would violent resistance be effective at this point? That seems likely to result in Syria or Libya at best. Speaking uncharitably (and ignoring vast theological differences…), the folks talking about violent overthrow seem pretty naive. ISIS was bad enough when they didn’t have the Zagros mountains to hide behind.
- actionfromafar 4y agoIt would be effective because the current leaders would flee the country. ISIS was created due to a power vacuum (actively, but naively) engineered by the US civil administration in Iraq. With some luck, things will turn out differently in Iran.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- icare_1er 4y agoWell done boys!
- sillystuff 4y ago> Security forces have responded with a deadly crackdown to the protests, among the strongest challenges to the Islamic Republic since the 1979 revolution ended 2,500 years of monarchy. Iran had a democratically elected government in 1953 when the US and UK overthrew their democracy, and installed the dictator/monarch, the Shaw. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/19/cia-admits-role-1953-iranian-coup https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/19/cia-admits-rol... https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/iran/2017-08-08/1953-iran-coup-new-us-documents-confirm-british-approached-us-late https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/iran/2017-08-08/1953...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- luckylion 4y agoThe monarchy hadn't stopped, and the Shah was still the monarch before, during and after Mosaddegh's time as Prime Minister. The Shah got more powers concentrated on him during the coup d'état, but you make it sound like the monarchy hadn't existed before 1953.
- 0xDEF 4y agoThat is true. And then the West pushed the Shah to losen up control and become less authoritarian which enabled the Islamic Revolution. There is a reason a lot of countries verbally lash out when the US/EU or Western NGOs accuse them of being too authoritarian. The alternative to authoritarianism is often worse. The CIA should stop meddling in other countries. But the same goes for Western governments and NGOs. The latter is often worse than the former.
- selimthegrim 4y agoThe Shah was dying of cancer, his own officials thought he was weak and vacillating
- moremetadata 4y agoIts amazing how training and data can manipulate those around you. Google I'm feeling lucky and Little Britain Computer say's no!
- brap 4y agoAs much as I want to see the Islamic Republic collapse, and as much as I do believe it will collapse in the next few years, to me this hack[1] seems state-sponsored. It looks like professionals trying to look like amateurs. Not a bad thing, though. Iranians need all the help they can get. [1] https://twitter.com/EdaalateAli1400/status/1624373234836668418 https://twitter.com/EdaalateAli1400/status/16243732348366684...
- Alir3z4 4y ago> I do believe it will collapse in the next few years Has been said for the last 44 years.
- kris_wayton 4y agoDo you mean as a sort of sponsored/approved false flag, or just that thoughts of revolution are reaching up into institutions?
- brap 4y agoI mean sponsored by a foreign nation (not as a false flag). Of course this is just my gut feeling, nothing else.
- lr4444lr 4y agoDefine "few".
- the_af 4y agoThe collapse of the Islamic Republic will likely bring much misery, upheaval and deaths. Why wish for this from the comfort of our countries? If the collapse comes with a power vacuum and the resurgence of competing fundamentalist groups, this wouldn't be helping any Iranians. Last time Western powers meddled, it resulted in the Islamic Revolution, after all.
- ep103 4y agoYou're right, if the future holds the possibility of danger, we should never try to improve anything at all. Better to always stay with the misery we already know, and never try to improve our lives. Good point. /s
- Alir3z4 4y ago[flagged]
- rfrey 4y agoI think it's unlikely Iranian women are risking arrest and execution by protesting inadequate manicures in prisons.
- 0x445442 4y agoYeah, because the US/CIA would never infiltrate countries that aren’t on board with US hegemony and start color revolutions to overthrow democratically elected leaders.
- icare_1er 4y agoYes, it's obvious that in a country where between your childhood and now, the currency has been divided by several thousands; your passport only allows you to travel to Venezuela and North Korea; you risk your life by not wearing a hijab; government jams signals so that you don't get the BBC or any western TV; women in prison are raped so that "they don't die as virgins and go to heaven"; etc, etc,etc... it's clear, in that situation, that if the people are fed up, it can only be as a result of a CIA operation !
- 0x445442 4y ago[flagged]
- propagandist 4y agoThat's purely conspiratorial and fact-free. It also has nothing to do with your charged language.
- 0x445442 4y ago[flagged]
- propagandist 4y agoAs far as strawmen go, this one is impressive.
- 0x445442 4y agoAs far as blindly following western propaganda, we’ll your handle says it all.
- stevev 4y agoIt’s hard to enforce such ideologies on women who are exposed to the freedoms of their counterparts in other countries. These morality police or institutions should have been long gone. Such strict rules would pave ways for abuse. Suppression of cultural changes are bloody and will cost a nation years of progress. They ought to embrace changes and unlock the abilities that lies in half of their population.
- _fat_santa 4y ago> They ought to embrace changes and unlock the abilities that lies in half of their population. I would say that's the problem. A bright future for Iran is a future that does not include his dictatorship. They know if they embrace change, they will be the first to be ousted.
- duxup 4y agoI wonder how hard it is. Lots of places women and men have fewer rights.
- NetOpWibby 4y agoDedSec?
- dtx1 4y agoHACK THE PLANET!
- bailoon 4y ago"Hackers". Yeah right. Do these "hackers" happen to work for the governments trying to destabilize iran by any chance?
- _lnwk 4y agoI remember hearing about similar things from my parents during communist occupation in Poland.
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]
- stefantalpalaru 4y ago[dead]