9 ms·
Because it makes no sense to not go nuclear. For one: Japan has no natural resources. Fuel for power must be imported. Materials for solar panels (or the panel
by Dalewyn 4y ago
Because it makes no sense to not go nuclear.
For one: Japan has no natural resources. Fuel for power must be imported. Materials for solar panels (or the panels themselves) must be imported. Nuclear is by far one of the most efficient /and/ effective forms of power generation humanity currently has.
For two: Fukushima was a result of human incompetence, nothing to do with the reactor itself or nuclear technology thereof. The meltdowns at Fukushima #1 could have been completely avoided had the government of the time not been a bunch of worthless fools (hint: TEPCO wanted to scuttle the reactors before they melted down).
For third: Japan needs power /today/, not tomorrow. Even assuming a transition to non-nuclear forms of power, that will not happen overnight. Using nuclear power is a concern of practical necessity.
For fourth: Nuclear fearmongering is patently ridiculous. Nuclear power plants are not atomic bombs, for crying out loud. The same people who cry their hearts out about radiation proceed to fly on airliners and eat bananas. The answer to nuclear fearmongering is not shunning nuclear technology, it's to teach and bring more awareness about what nuclear technology is.
- wslh 4y agoGreat answer, I would add that also there could be new solutions to disposing nuclear material that adds more confidence to the full cycle.
- theshrike79 4y agoThe biggest risk in nuclear material disposal is environmental activists blocking the transports en route. The actual material itself emits less radiation than a store-bought banana when it's been properly stored.
- gggmaster 4y agoSea dumping?
- slim 4y agospace dumping ?
- glandium 4y ago> Japan needs power /today/ Not today, at least two years ago. Probably even earlier.
- whatshisface 4y agoUntil they have managed to redesign humans point two remains.
- theshrike79 4y agoThe current generation nuclear power stations need active human operation or the process will shut down automatically. Chernobyl-style ancient reactors were the complete opposite - and even it failed mostly because of shitty politics and bad leadership culture.
- unglaublich 4y agoYou can educate humans, or redesign technology to get humans out of the loop.
- nonethewiser 4y agoWho can redesign tech to get humans out of the loop? Humans who designed the original non fail-proof tech?
- zdragnar 4y agoDemanding "fail-proof" is FUD. Even a windmill can fall over and kill someone. What is good design and planning is "fail-safe" which is to say that any failure mode means the plant shuts down gracefully and with as little damage as possible. In the case of windmills, that means sticking them in fields or on open water where people aren't likely to be around. For nuclear plants, that means the whole thing is self contained and designed to stop reacting without direct human control. Every failure mode ends in the nuclear reaction ending with the radioactive materials contained.
- theshrike79 4y ago> Fukushima was a result of human incompetence Also Fukushima was hit with BOTH by a record-level quake AND a record-level tsunami. And it still didn't cause a huge death toll. If the backup generators would've been higher up, most of the whole issue would've been avoided. Now they got flooded by the tsunami and failed.
- nonethewiser 4y ago> Also Fukushima was hit with BOTH by a record-level quake AND a record-level tsunami Not a coincidence given all of Japan has tons of seismic activity
- emodendroket 4y agoIn fact there is a causal relationship there
- nonethewiser 4y ago> Fukushima was a result of human incompetence There is always a risk of that. Humans cannot garuntee humans wont fuck up.
- askvictor 4y ago> For one: Japan has no natural resources. Fuel for power must be imported. Materials for solar panels (or the panels themselves) must be imported. Nuclear is by far one of the most efficient /and/ effective forms of power generation humanity currently has. How is nuclear fuel any different in this respect? Sure it's more compact, but it has other complications regarding transport. They're still going to be reliant on other countries. Solar panels, even if imported, do not require the ongoing importation of fuel. > For third: Japan needs power /today/, not tomorrow I don't see how nuclear solves this problem. New plants have a very long lead time. I'm not trying to fearmonger, and I think that had we adopted a lot more nuclear in decades past we could be in a much better position regarding climate change now. But I'm not convinced that the arguments stack up for nuclear right now.
- JanSt 4y agoThe solar panels have to be replaced at some too, don't they? And how many of them are being made in China? Diversification will be key for the future - including nuclear, solar, wind, storage. France took 10 years to go from very little nuclear to most of the energy coming from nuclear. It can be done if activist don't stop it and put up ever higher requirements to make nuclear less attractive.
- Dalewyn 4y ago>How is nuclear fuel any different in this respect? We're already talking about what we will do once major reserves of coal and oil run dry. It's obviously not going to happen any time soon, maybe even not this century, but I'm not aware of similar sentiments being thrown around about nuclear fuel such as uranium and plutonium. Nuclear power also does not belch out greenhouse gasses into the atmosphere unlike coal and oil. If we want power generation without greenhouse gas emissions, nuclear power is one of the answers. >I don't see how nuclear solves this problem. Keeping currently active plants active for longer means the immediate need for power is better satisfied and the need for /more/ power in the short-term is delayed. This plan also calls for new plants which will replace the generation capacity lost from outgoing plants (coal/oil or nuclear) and hopefully satisfy power demands today and tomorrow.
- emodendroket 4y ago> For two: Fukushima was a result of human incompetence, nothing to do with the reactor itself or nuclear technology thereof. The meltdowns at Fukushima #1 could have been completely avoided had the government of the time not been a bunch of worthless fools (hint: TEPCO wanted to scuttle the reactors before they melted down). Surely there is no reason to believe that couldn't happen again.
- Dalewyn 4y agoHumans being humans will always be a thing, but if we let that be the showstopper then we can't do anything period.
- emodendroket 4y agoIf nuclear power requires more vigilance or competence from the people running it to avert disaster then that's a real demerit.
- rightbyte 4y agoWhich especially makes me nervous about all these plans for small reactors. Harder to supervise for authorities and more "silos" where incompetence could emerge.
- tb_technical 4y agoBeware fear, uncertainty, and doubt. The new small reactors have safer designs and more fail-safes than the last gen reactors.
- mpweiher 4y agoIt doesn't. Fukushima clearly demonstrated this. 1. The reactor was an old design, not really considered safe 2. Known deficiencies were not fixed 3. Despite the regulations saying they needed to be fixed 4. Regulations that were also found to be insufficient So really colossal screwups piled on top of each other. And so an accident happened. Explosions happened. Without the containment of more modern plants. And yet, the actual effect was minimal. (The panic, on the other hand...)
- rich_sasha 4y agoI'd add, terrifying as Fukushima was, the actual damage seems far far smaller than the outcry. Actual death toll seems dominated by people evacuated through excess caution. See this link for example: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disaster_casualties https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_di... there is one confirmed fatality due to radiation, 2k or so due to evacuation, and an upper bound on future cancers in the 100s due to prolonged low-level radiation. The earthquake's and tsunami's death toll is 20k. So dangerous as it is to do statistics on human lives, it's a bit if a rounding error.
- mpweiher 4y ago> terrifying as Fukushima was As Fukushima was made to appear. > actual damage seems far far smaller than the outcry. Yes. > Actual death toll seems dominated by people evacuated through excess caution. Yes. Fear of nuclear is far more dangerous than nuclear. > one confirmed fatality due to radiation, I thought so, too. But apparently this was a worker at the reactor plant whose cancer death was classified as work-related, but not actually linked to the accident. > it's a bit if a rounding error. Exactly.
- adrianN 4y agoThe problem with nuclear is that it's very expensive and new nuclear plants take forever to build. Japan has lots of solar and wind power potential, but renewables are not very compatible with nuclear power for economic reasons.
- Gwypaas 4y ago> For one: Japan has no natural resources. Fuel for power must be imported. Materials for solar panels (or the panels themselves) must be imported. Nuclear is by far one of the most efficient /and/ effective forms of power generation humanity currently has. Nuclear has a much larger total material requirement than wind and about equal to solar. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S095965262202131X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S095965262... > For two: Fukushima was a result of human incompetence, nothing to do with the reactor itself or nuclear technology thereof. The meltdowns at Fukushima #1 could have been completely avoided had the government of the time not been a bunch of worthless fools (hint: TEPCO wanted to scuttle the reactors before they melted down). How do you perpetually guard against human nature? > For third: Japan needs power /today/, not tomorrow. Even assuming a transition to non-nuclear forms of power, that will not happen overnight. Using nuclear power is a concern of practical necessity. This nuclear would come online in 15-20 years, how is that today? > For fourth: Nuclear fearmongering is patently ridiculous. Nuclear power plants are not atomic bombs, for crying out loud. The same people who cry their hearts out about radiation proceed to fly on airliners and eat bananas. The answer to nuclear fearmongering is not shunning nuclear technology, it's to teach and bring more awareness about what nuclear technology is. Their risks are subsidized by the governments, and it still on top of that, require enormous subsidies. This move will essentially banish Japan to become an energy starved country in the face of massive renewable build-outs.